Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
CRL.A(J) NO.23 OF 2024
Shri Jyotish Debnath,
S/o, Late Sahadeb Debnath,
Of Village-Prafulla Deb Para, West Karamcherra,
P.S.-Manu, District-Dhalai, Tripura.
……Convict-Appellant(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura.
.......Respondent(s)
For the Appellant(s)
: Mr. Subrata Sarkar, Sr. Advocate.
Ms. Ayesha Saha Hirawat, Advocate.
Ms. V. Poddar, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. R. Datta, P.P.
Mr. R. Saha, Addl. P.P.
Date of hearing and delivery of
Judgment & Order
: 09/07/2025
Whether fit for reporting : YES.
HON’BLE JUSTICE DR.T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
J U D G M E N T & O R D E R(ORAL)
T. AMARNATH GOUD(J)
1.
This is an appeal filed under Section 375 of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, against the Judgment and Order
of conviction and sentence dated 15.02.2022, passed by the
learned Additional Sessions Judge, Dhalai Judicial District, Ambassa,
in connection with Case No. ST (Type-1) 35 of 2021, whereby the
appellant
was
convicted
and
sentenced
to
undergo
rigorous
imprisonment for life for the commission of an offence punishable
under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code.
2.
The brief facts of the case are that the accused,
Jyotish Debnath, had a long-standing land dispute with his brother
(the complainant) and his brother's wife, Shueli Debnath (the
deceased/victim). As neighbours, the accused would often threaten
them (the complainant and his wife) against trespassing on his land
or courtyard. On 09.05.2021, when the deceased went to a nearby
field to tend to her cattle, the accused lost his patience and
attacked her multiple times with a „dao‟, causing grievous injuries
which resulted in her death on the spot.
3.
Upon receiving the complaint, police registered
Manu Police Station Case No. 2021 MNU 018, dated 09.05.2021, for
the offence punishable under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code
(hereinafter referred to as 'IPC') against the accused, Jyotish
Debnath, and endorsed the case for investigation.
4.
During the investigation, the Investigating Officer
visited the place of occurrence and prepared a hand sketch map
with an index. The Investigating Officer also examined available
witnesses and recorded their statements under Section 161 Cr.P.C.,
arranged
for
statements
under
Section
164(5)
Cr.P.C.,
and
conducted
raids
to
arrest
Jyotish
Debnath,
and
eventually
apprehended him.
5.
The Court below took up the matter on 17.12.2021
and on 10.02.2022, charge was framed against the accused under
Section 302 IPC, to which he pleaded guilty. The same is produced
hereunder:“That, you on the alleged morning of 09th May,
2021 at about 033 hours at Machilicherrra committed
murder of the victim/deceased Shiuli Debnath by
attacking her on her neck and shoulder with a sharp
dao and that you thereby committed an offence
punishable under Section 302 (punishment of murder)
of the India Penal Code and without the cognizance of
this Court.
And I hereby direct that you be tried on
the said charge by this Court.
“The contents of the charges
are read over and explained
in Bengali language to the
accused person to which he
pleaded GUITY”
sd/Addl. Sessions Judge
Dhalai Judicial District:Ambasa.
6.
Thereafter, the Trial Court followed Section 229 of
Cr.P.C., and by dispensing with the Trial under Section 230 of
Cr.P.C., passed the Judgment dated 15.02.2022, convicting the
accused and sentencing him to undergo rigorous imprisonment for
life for the commission of an offence punishable under Section 302
of the Indian Penal Code.
7.
The Court below while passing the order invoking
Section 229 of Cr.P.C., has indicated that “In order to ensure that
the “discretion” mentioned in section 229 is exercised judicially and
not arbitrarily or mechinally, this Court has minutely explained to
the accused that he can be convicted for the offence of murder
under Section 302 of IPC on his plea of guilty and sentenced to life
imprisonment or the death penalty.”
8.
Not being satisfied with the said Judgment and
Order of conviction and sentence dated 15.02.2022, the convictappellant has preferred this appeal to set aside and quash the
impugned Judgment and Order of conviction.
9.
Heard Mr. S. Sarkar, learned Sr. counsel, assisted
by Ms. A.S. Hirawat, learned counsel appearing for the convictappellant, and Mr. R. Saha, learned Addl. P.P., appearing for the
State-respondent.
10.
Mr. Sarkar, learned Senior Counsel appearing for
the appellant, submits that the present appeal challenges the
legality of the sentence. He contends that if Sections 229, 230 and
375 of Cr.P.C., are read together, it is clear that when an accused
pleads guilty, the judge shall record the plea and may, in his
discretion, convict him thereon. Therefore, the discretion lies with
the Judge to convict based on the plea or to proceed with trial.
Recording the plea is mandatory, but conviction is not mandatory.
The learned Senior Counsel further argues that the accused stated
in his plea that he “murdered” the victim. However, “murder” is a
legal term, and in law, it comprises Sections 299 and 300 of the
IPC and the same creates ambiguity. The Court simply asked
whether he committed murder, and he responded affirmatively.
The legal aspect of the matter has not been made clear to the
accused including the fact that he has an option not to plead guilty
or the fact that after a trial he might be even acquitted. Moreover,
no inquiry was conducted into the mental health of the accused.
The record shows that the accused-appellant had been suffering
from a mental disorder, but this was not considered at all. As per
the order dated 29.06.2021, the accused was directed to be shifted
from Longtrai Valley Sub-Jail to KST Bisalghar for better treatment
as advised by the M.O. of Longtrai Valley Hospital. On 08.07.2021,
a medical report from KST Bisalghar stated that the accused was
suffering from psychosis, a mental depressive disorder and referred
to the definition of „Psychosis‟ under Medical Jurisprudence and
relied on the Judgment of the Hon‟ble Kerala High Court passed in
Raseen Babu K.M. Vs. The state of Kerala bearing No. Crl. Rev.
Pet No.227 of 2021 and also relied on Judgment of Hon‟ble High
Court of Gauhati reported in 2005 0 Supreme(Gau) 793 titled as
State of Mizoram Vs. Ramengmawia.
11.
On the other hand, Mr. R. Saha, learned Addl. P.P.,
submits that since the accused pleaded guilty, a trial was not
necessary. At the time of the trial, the accused-appellant was
assisted by a legal aid counsel. Therefore, in the presence of his
Advocate, he pleaded guilty. The Trial Court also repeatedly
enquired whether he maintained his plea of guilt, to which he
confirmed affirmatively. These were also explicitly explained to him
in the Bengali language. When an impugned Judgment of conviction
is passed under Section 229 of the Cr.P.C., the Court must record
the plea and may, at its discretion, convict the accused. Learned
Addl. P.P. points out that in the order dated 10.02.2022, when the
charge was framed, it is stated that “the contents of the charges
were read over and explained to the accused in Bengali language,
to which he pleaded guilty.” Thereafter, in the order dated
14.02.2022, he was again asked about the sentence and the
consequences of pleading guilty. He reiterated that he was guilty
and had committed the offence. Based on that, the impugned
Judgment of conviction was passed under Section 229 Cr.P.C.
Learned Addl. P.P., also referred to Section 375 of Cr.P.C., wherein
he argued that if an accused person has pleaded guilty and has
been convicted, on such plea, there shall be no appeal.
11.1.
Further learned Addl. P.P. stated that the
accused was duly assisted by a legal professional but he never took
any plea before the trial Court claiming mental illness such as
„psychosis‟. There is no record that this concern was ever brought
to the notice of the trial judge. He further refers to Para-7 of the
impugned judgment, wherein it is stated that the Court had
minutely explained to the accused that he could be convicted for
the offence of murder under Section 302 of IPC based on his plea
of guilt.
11.2
Accordingly, the learned Addl. P.P. urges this
Hon‟ble Court to consider the above submission and dismiss the
appeal as not maintainable.
12.
Heard the parties and perused the materials on
record.
13.
Before we delve into the reasoning of the case, let
us re-produce Sections 229, 230 and 375 of Cr.P.C., and Sections
299 and 300 of IPC:-
“
229. Conviction on plea of guilty.- If the accused
pleads guilty, the Judge shall record the plea and may, in
his discretion, convict him thereon.
230. Date for prosecution evidence.- if the
accused refuses to plead, or does not plead, or claims to
be tried or is not convicted under section 229, the Judge
shall fix a date for the examination of witnesses, and
may, on the application of the prosecution, issue any
process for compelling the attendance of any witness or
the production of any document or other thing.
375. No appeal in certain cases when accused
pleads guilty.- Notwithstanding anything contained in
section 374, where an accused person has pleaded guilty
and has been convicted on such plea, there shall be no
appeal.
1. if the conviction is by a High Court; or
2. if the conviction is by a Court of Session, Metropolitan
Magistrate or Magistrate of the first or second class,
except as to the extent or legality of the sentence.
“299. Culpable homicide.—
Whoever causes death by doing an act with the
intention of causing death, or with the intention of
causing such bodily injury as is likely to cause death, or
with the knowledge that he is likely by such act to cause
death, commits the offence of culpable homicide.”
300. Murder.—
Except in the cases hereinafter excepted, culpable
homicide is murder, if the act by which the death is
caused is done with the intention of causing death, or
(Secondly)— If it is done with the intention of causing such
bodily injury as the offender knows to be likely to cause
the death of the person to whom the harm is caused, or
(Thirdly)— If it is done with the intention of causing bodily
injury to any person and the bodily injury intended to be
inflicted is sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to
cause death, or
(Fourthly)— If the person committing the act knows that it
is so imminently dangerous that it must, in all
probability, cause death or such bodily injury as is likely
to cause death, and commits such act without any
excuse for incurring the risk of causing death or such
injury as aforesaid.”
14.
The process adopted by the learned Trial Court
suffers from grave procedural lapses, particularly concerning the
mental fitness of the accused at the time of recording his plea.
The medical records in the lower Court file, the Doctor reports
dated
08.07.2021,
03.08.2021,
21.07.2021,
30.08.2021,
12.09.2021, 06.10.2021 and ors., clearly indicate that even prior
to the framing of charge on 10.02.2022, the accused-appellant
had been diagnosed with „psychosis‟, a serious mental condition
which impairs judgment, comprehension, and decision-making
ability. The medical report say that he is not fit for trial,
yet,
there is no evidence that the Trial Court ever recorded any finding
of satisfaction as to whether the accused was mentally fit to enter
a plea of guilty, nor was there any judicial discussion of the
medical opinion available on record. This omission vitiates the
voluntariness and reliability of the plea.
15.
Furthermore, Section 229 of Cr.P.C states
that, while the recording of a plea is mandatory, conviction is not
automatic. It is at the discretion of the Judge, who must exercise
such discretion judiciously, especially in offences carrying the
maximum punishment of life imprisonment or death under Section
302 IPC. In such serious charges, the judicial duty is heightened.
The accused mere admission of guilt, especially by stating “I have
murdered,” cannot be construed as a legal acknowledgment of all
ingredients constituting murder under Sections 299 or 300 IPC,
unless it is clear that the accused fully understood the legal
implications of the term. In common language, "murder" simply
means "killing someone." But legally, the Court must ascertain
whether the killing amounts to murder under Sections 299 or 300
of IPC. That legal distinction was not explained to the accused. It
was the duty of the Court to examine the legal nature of the act,
not merely rely on the accused‟s understanding of the word
“murder”, because the punishment differs and needs to examine as
to which provision needs to be applied for punishment.
16.
The language used, the lack of clarity on the
gradation between culpable homicide and murder, and the absence
of explanation of possible acquittal or lesser conviction if trial
proceeds, further highlight that the accused was not made aware of
the complete legal landscape. The legal aid counsel‟s mere
presence does not fulfill the constitutional guarantee of effective
assistance of counsel, especially when the accused is mentally
vulnerable and the stakes involve capital punishment.
17.
The absence of any satisfaction recorded regarding
the mental health of the accused prior to framing the charge, and
the failure to explain the gravity of punishment under Section 302
IPC, render the prior proceedings defective.
18.
According
to
Dr.
K.S.
Narayan
Reddy‟s
Medical Jurisprudence and Toxicology, „psychosis‟ is characterized
by a withdrawal from reality and living in a world of fantasy, with
progressive loss of contact with reality. Similarly, as per Dr. Gupta
& Agarwal‟s Medical Jurisprudence and Toxicology, „psychosis‟ is
“an extreme mental disturbance involving distorted perceptions and
irrational behavior.” Therefore, when it is already on record that
the accused is suffering from severe mental illness, the Court ought
to have conducted a proper inquiry as to whether the accused is fit
to
give
his
plea.
This
essential
procedural
safeguard
was
overlooked. The mental health condition was known to the Court
prior to the framing of charge, yet it was not considered while
accepting the plea of guilt. Thus, the procedure outlined in Sections
229 and 230 Cr.P.C. was not followed, rendering the entire process
vitiated.
19.
The Hon‟ble High Court of Kerala in Raseen Babu
K.M. Vs. The state of Kerala(supra), states thus:Para-11. The relevant provisions and the
precedents discussed above mandate compliance of the
following requirements before acting upon the pleading of
guilt by an accused;
(i) The Magistrate should frame the charge, specifying the
offences alleged against the accused;
(ii)The charge should be read over and explained to the
accused;
(iii)The accused should be asked whether he pleads guilty of
the offence/s with which he is charged;
(iv) The accused should plead guilty after understanding the
seriousness of the Crl.R.P.Nos.227 and 228 of 2021
allegations and the implications of pleading guilty. The plea
should be voluntary and expressed in clear and unambiguous
terms.
(v) The Magistrate should record the accused's plea of guilty
in the words of the accused, to the extent possible.
(vi) The Magistrate, after considering all relevant factors
should exercise his discretion and decide whether to accept
the plea of guilty or not
(vii) If the plea is accepted, the accused can be convicted
and suitable punishment imposed. “
20.
The Hon‟ble High Court of Gauhati in State of
Mizoram Vs. Ramengmawia states thus:“Para-8. What also needs to be borne in mind is
that ordinarily, for a common man, killing of a person is
murder; whereas in law, murder is an offence strenuously
defined under Section 300 read with Section 299 IPC. A
killing, in only specified circumstances, can amount to
murder. For a layman, therefore, to plead guilty to the
charge of murder does not necessarily mean that his plea of
guilt is to the charge of murder, for, his plea of guilt may,
unknowingly and in reality, be to his act of killing, which, in
law, may or may not amount to murder. To put it differently,
the plea of guilt of an accused may, thus, be a plea to the
accusation of killing, which may or may not, eventually,
amount to murder, for, to a common man, there is no
difference between the act of killing and murder. Therefore,
to decide the nature of the offence, the Court should have
before it the details of the occurrence, the motive and the
circumstances under which the act was done and for this
purpose, it is not only desirable, but essential that the entire
evidence be placed before the Court unless the
circumstances of the case and the plea of guilt of the
accused indicate otherwise enabling the Court to dispense
with the requirement of obtaining evidence before it and to
act entirely on the plea of guilt of the accused.”
21.
Article 21 of the Constitution of India states that:“21. Protection of life and personal liberty
No person shall be deprived of his life or personal
liberty except according to procedure established
by law.”
22.
It is needless to observe that the Constitution has
protected by way of its fundamental right, the life and liberty of a
citizen. Moreover, in the discussion, the Court below has not given
any reasoning dealing with mental ability and health. Condition of
the accused-convict and also no reasoning is given how the Court
has clarified and explained about the consequences of pleading
guilty or not guilty and his right to be tried and chances of acquittal
or lesser punishment before taking a decision under Section 229 of
Cr.P.C.
23.
Though the Section 229 of Cr.P.C., do not explain
in detail, but the duty is cast upon the Court in all fairness to follow
certain hidden procedure by way of its discretion. The word
discretion is not an empty formality to be exhausted but in its
wisdom is a complete hidden and underlying procedure to be
adopted to unearth the truth to meets the ends of justice.
24.
In light of the above discussion this Court feels
that an opportunity of trial could have been given to the accused.
The impugned Judgment is liable to be set aside and accordingly,
the same is set aside and the matter is remanded back to the Trial
Court to adjudicate the same as per procedure by conducting Trial.
The Court shall, before proceeding further, ensure that the accused
is mentally fit to stand trial.
25.
With the above observation and direction, this
present appeal stands disposed of.
26.
As
a
sequel,
stay
if
any
vacated.
Pending
application(s), if any also stands closed.
B. PALIT, J
SABYASAC
HI GHOSH
suhanjit
SABYASACHI
GHOSH
Date: 2025.07.15
10:17:26 +05'30'
DR. T. AMARNATH GOUD, J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review