Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
W.P.(C) No.362 of 2024
Shri Bimal Bhattacharjee
son of late Chitta Ranjan Bhattacharjee, R/OBama Kutir, Krishnanagar, TG Road, opposite
to Ramnagar Road No.3, P.O. Agartala, P.S.
West
Agartala,
DistrictWest
Tripura,
PIN-799001
……… Petitioner(s)
–Versus–
1.
The Tripura State Legal Services Authority,
represented by its Member Secretary, having
office at Old District & Sessions Judge Court
Complex, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala,
District-West Tripura, PIN-799001
2.
The Member Secretary,
Tripura State Legal Services Authority,
represented by its Member Secretary,
having office at Old District & Sessions
Judge Court Complex, P.O. Agartala, P.S.
West Agartala, District-West Tripura, PIN799001
3.
The Deputy Secretary,
Tripura
State
Legal Services
Authority,
represented by its Member Secretary, having
office at Old District & Sessions Judge Court
Complex, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala,
District-West Tripura, PIN-799001
4.
The District Secretary,
District Legal Services Authority, represented
by its Member Secretary, having office at Old
District & Sessions Judge Court Complex, P.O.
Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District-West
Tripura, PIN-799001
…….. Respondent(s)
For the Petitioner (s)
:
Mr. A. Bhowmik, Adv.
Ms. I. Chakma, Adv.
For the Respondent (s)
:
Mr. R.G. Chakraborty, Adv.
Date of hearing and delivery :
of Judgment & Order
Whether fit for reporting
:
16.07.2025
YES
NO
√
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. A. Bhowmik, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner and Mr. R.G. Chakraborty, learned counsel appearing for
the respondents.
[2]
It appears from the pleadings of the parties that both the
present petitioner and one Smt. Rama Chakraborty (not a party in
the proceeding) were initially engaged as Legal Services Worker
Grade-II (LDC) vide order of engagement issued to both of them
separately
on
03.05.2002.
So
far
the
order
of
engagement
[Annexure-1 to the writ petition] of present petitioner, as extracted
hereunder, is concerned, same contains the following terms and
conditions:
On the basis of the interview held at Agartala, your
name has been included in the panel of Legal Services
Workers Gr.II (LDC) to work under the State Legal
Services Authority/Permanent Lok Adalat at Agartala
(which is a statutory body) as and when called for on
no work no pay basis. Your daily remuneration will be
Rs.140/- per day subject to a maximum of Rs.3,000/per month. Your services will be necessary in
connection with various legal services programmes.
Your services will not be required when there will be no
programme or fund from the National Legal Services
Authority, State Government or other is not available or
your performance is not found satisfactory.
If you are willing to work, you are requested to report
to the office of the State Legal Services Authority,
located at Ramnagar Road No.4, Agartala (First Floor of
the Residence of Shri Sekhar Datta, Advocate)
immediately for duty.
[3]
Thereafter, both of them continued to work as Legal
Services Worker Grade-II (LDC) and thereafter, their services were
upgraded as Legal Services Workers Grade-I vide office order dated
15.05.2008 [Annexure-R/3 to the counter affidavit] and vide offer of
appointment dated 18.06.2013 [Annexure-2 to the writ petition]
they were appointed in the temporary post of UDC, Group-C in the
pay scale under the revised Pay Band (PB)-2 of Rs.5310-24000/with G.P. Rs.2100/- with other admissible allowances. Finally, both
of them were promoted to the post of Head Clerk by a common
office order issued by the Tripura State Legal Services Authority [for
short, TSLSA] on 29.02.2016 [Annexure-3 to the writ petition].
According to their respective service books, the date of birth of Smt.
Rama Chakraborty is 07.06.1963 and the date of birth of the
petitioner is 03.01.1964. In view of above, Rama Chakraborty went
on superannuation prior to the present petitioner on 30.06.2023 and
the petitioner went on superannuation on 31.01.2024.
[4]
At the time of retirement, said Smti Rama Chakraborty
did not complete her 10 years of service for which she was not
entitled to receive the pension. The resolution of the TSLSA dated
16.12.2022 [Annexure-6 to the writ petition] shows that to enable
Rama Chakraborty to get the pension on completion of 10 years of
service, the authority considered her prayer favourably to add half of
the period of her past service rendered as contractual (no work no
pay) LSG, Grade II (LDC) with her services rendered as regular
employee, based on a memorandum of the State Government dated
07.10.2005 [Annexure-10 to the writ petition]. Relatively, it also
requires reference here that prior to that resolution, said Rama
Chakraborty submitted one representation before the TSLSA on
18.12.2020 [Annexure-R/13 to the counter affidavit] for counting
half of her past service as Legal Services Worker as Grade-I &
Grade-II both before her absorption in the regular service, to enable
her to get the pension benefit on completion of 10 years of
continuous service and the matter was referred to the Finance
Department through the Law Department, Government of Tripura
and in turn, the Finance Department on consideration of the same
informed vide letter dated 24.05.2022 [Annexure-R/15 to the
counter affidavit] that the case of Rama Chakraborty did not come
under the purview of the extant rule of the State Government and
therefore, the matter could be settled at the own level of TSLSA and
thereafter, the matter was placed before the TSLSA and in it’s 41st
Meeting, the above said resolution was taken to extend the benefit
of such counting half of the period of her past service.
[5]
After the petitioner went on retirement, he also filed a
similar representation to TSLSA for counting the period of half of his
past service as Legal Services Worker Grade-I & Grade-II and
accordingly, the said matter was also taken up by the TSLSA in their
42nd Meeting on 11.01.2024 [Annexure-12 to the writ petition] and
the authority rejected his claim on the ground that the petitioner
was already eligible for getting pension and therefore, such benefit
was not being provided to him. The relevant agenda No.2 and
resolution thereof in this regard, are also extracted hereunder:
Agenda No.2- Discussion & decision on allowing
pensionary benefits to Sri Bimal Bhattacharjee, Head
Clerk (now posted in the office of DLSA, West Tripura)
going to retire on 03.01.2024, counting half of his
services rendered as contractual (no work-no pay)
LSW, Gr.II (LDC) & LSW, Gr-I(UDC) for his pension
benefits etc.
Resolution: Members of the Authority present in the
meeting thoroughly discussed and resolved that Sri
Bimal Bhattacharjee, Head Clerk (now posted in the
office of DLSA, West Tripura is already eligible for
getting pension. So, the prayer of Sri Bhattacharjee for
counting half of his services rendered as LSW, Gr.II &
LSW, Gr-I(no work-no pay) for his pension benefits etc.
has not been considered. The matter stands rejected.
[6]
Being aggrieved by the said decision, the present writ
petition has been filed by the petitioner.
[7]
Mr. Bhowmik, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner
strenuously argues that both said Rama Chakraborty and the
petitioner are similarly situated persons and both of them were
engaged initially as Legal Services Worker Grade-II on the same
date and then were promoted as UDC also on the same date and
thereafter, as Head Clerk also on the same date. Therefore, there
was no reason to deny the benefit to him which was already
provided to said Rama Chakraborty. According to Mr. Bhowmik,
learned counsel, in-equal treatment has been done thereby between
the equals violating Article 14 of the Constitution. Mr. Bhowmik,
learned counsel also submits that the petitioner was engaged as full
time worker as Legal Services Worker as Grade-II and as per Rule
14 of the Tripura State Legal Services Authority (Conditions of
Service and the Salary and Allowances of the Officers and other
Employees) Rules, 2012 (for short the Rules of 2012), the officers
and other employees of State Legal Services Authority are entitled to
all such facilities, allowances and benefits as are notified by the
State Government from time to time and also the scale of pay at par
with the State Government employees holding equivalent posts and
their age of retirement, pension, Death-Cum-Retirement Gratuity,
pay and allowances, leave etc. are also governed by State
Government rules. For further reference, the said Rule 14 is
excerpted below:
(i) The officers and other employees shall be entitled to
draw pay and allowances in the scale of pay at par with
the State Government employees holding equivalent
posts;
(ii) In all matters like age of retirement, pension,
Death-Cum-Retirement Gratuity, pay and allowances,
leave, other benefits and entitlements the officers and
other employees shall be governed by the State
Government rules as are applicable to persons holding
equivalent posts:
(iii) The officers and other employees shall be entitled
to such other facilities, allowances and benefits as may
be notified by the State Government from time to time.
[8]
not
Mr. Bhowmik, learned counsel further contends that for
giving
similar
benefit
to
the
present
petitioner,
like
Smt. Chakraborty, he is now getting less amount of pension than
Smt. Chakraborty despite the fact that he served the Institution for
longer period than Smt. Chakraborty. Mr. Bhowmik, learned counsel,
therefore, prays that similar benefit may be extended to the
petitioner like Smt. Chakraborty.
[9]
Mr. R.G. Chakraborty, learned counsel, on the other
hand, referring to said two resolutions of TSLSA as indicated above,
submits that the reason for extending the benefit of counting of half
of the period of past service of Smt. Chakraborty as contractual
employee was only to enable her to get the pension, otherwise she
would be deprived of the same. Mr. Chakraborty, learned counsel
submits that as the Finance Department already left the matter for
decision of the TSLSA without giving any decision on that issue, the
TSLSA on their wisdom and giving due consideration to the attending
facts, decided to extend such benefit to said Smt. Chakraborty on
sympathetic ground, but in case of the present petitioner, already he
had completed his regular service for above 10 years and became
entitled to get pension and therefore, he was not entitled to get such
sympathetic consideration. Mr. Chakraborty, learned counsel also
submits that when in respect of Smt. Chakraborty, the Finance
Department left the matter for decision of TSLSA without giving any
decision on merit, the identical matter relating to the present
petitioner was not further referred to the Finance Department.
[10]
This Court has given due consideration to the submissions
of the learned counsel of both the sides and has also considered the
relevant materials placed by the parties through their pleadings and
documents.
It appears that the benefit of counting of half of the
period of past service of Smt. Rama Chakraborty as contractual
employee was allowed by the TSLSA relying on the memorandum
dated 07.10.2005 [Annexure-10 to the writ petition] which provides
that the half of the period of service of permanent labourers with
regular service in continuation without any break will be counted for
the purpose of pension and other pensionary benefits only in the
event of their absorption in regular Government service. It appears
that the said memorandum is concerned with the permanent
labourers. However, later on another memorandum was also issued
by the State Government on 25.02.2010 [Annexure-11 to the writ
petition] which deals with the counting of such half of the period of
past service of employees like DRWs/ contingent workers/Monthly
rated workers/ casual workers etc. who were paid from ‘wages’ on
full time basis, and it was decided by the State Government that the
benefit of counting of half of the period of continuous service
rendered by them as DRWs/Contingent Workers/Monthly Rated
Workers/Casual Workers working on full time basis would be counted
towards pension following their regularisation with the approval of
Finance Department. It was also clarified that the benefit provided
under this circular would not have any relevance in declaration of
employees
as
quasi
permanent/permanent/counting
of
seniority/counting of period for the purpose of determining eligibility
for extending the benefit of CAS/ACP. The relevant portion of the
said
memorandum
is
also
extracted
hereinbelow
for
better
appreciation:
(1) References have been received from different
Departments seeking clarification about continuation of
applicability of memo No.8(3)-FIN(G)/78 dated 16.08.1978
and memo even number dated 19.07.1982 regarding counting
of half of the period continuous service rendered by
Contingent Workers/Copyist/Typist/ Extra Moharars etc. who
were paid from ‘wages’ on full time basis, towards pension
and in respect of DRWs/Contingent Workers/Monthly Rated
Workers/ Casual Workers working on full time basis and
subsequently regularized as per Government decision.
(2) After careful consideration of the matter, the Governor
has been pleased to decide that the benefit of counting of half
of the period of continuous service rendered by the
DRWs/Contingent Workers/Monthly Rated Workers/Casual
Workers who were engaged on full time basis and paid from
‘Wages’ would be counted towards pension following their
regularization with the approval of the Finance Department.
The benefit provided under this circular will not have any
relevance
in
declaration
of
employees
as
quasi
permanent/permanent/counting of seniority/counting of
period for the purpose of determining eligibility for extending
benefit of CAS/ACP.
[11]
On
consideration
of
the
said
memorandum
under
Annexure 11, it appears that one of the basic criteria to apply the
said memorandum is that the employee concerned to avail such
benefit should be engaged on full time basis whose service was later
on regularized. In respect of the issue involved in this writ petition,
already the Finance Department left the matter for the decision of
TSLSA while dealing with the case of said Smt. Chakraborty.
[12]
The petitioner in this writ petition in paragraph No.13 has
categorically asserted that he had served on full time basis as Legal
Services Workers as Grade-II and then Grade-I and the said fact has
not been specifically denied by the respondents in their counter
affidavit. On query placed by this court on that issue asto whether
the initial engagement of the petitioner was on full time basis or not,
no specific reply has also come out from the respondents. Rather,
the respondents again referred the initial engagement of the
petitioner which is placed at Annexure-1 to the writ petition and
already extracted hereinabove. Rule 3(g) of Rules of 2012 also
envisages that existing Leal Services Workers Grade-I corresponds
to UDC and Legal Services Workers Grade-II corresponds to LDCcum-Typist respectively. The initial engagement of the petitioner
was as Legal Services Workers Grade-II (LDC). Though it was also
mentioned in the order of engagement that the daily remuneration
would be Rs.140/- per day subject to maximum of Rs.3,000/- per
month and his services would be necessary in connection with the
various legal services programmes and would not be required when
there will be no programme or fund from the National Legal Services
Authority, State Government or other is not available along with
further condition that such engagement was on no work-no pay
basis and as and when called for, but nothing could be placed or
even asserted by the respondents that the petitioner was not in full
time engagement in TSLSA. Generally, LDC level employees are
engaged or appointed on full time basis.
[13]
Considering all these aspects, it can be presumed that the
petitioner’s engagement as Legal Services Workers Grade-I & GradeII was on full time basis. The services of both said Rama
Chakraborty and the present petitioner, before their appointment as
UDC were upgraded as Legal Services Workers Grade-I vide office
order dated 15.05.2008 as indicated earlier. Both of them were
appointed in the regular cadre of UDC vide offer of appointment
dated 18.06.2013 [Annexure-2 to the writ petition]. Therefore, cases
of both of them can be considered in the light of the memorandum
dated 25.02.2010 [Annexure-11 to the writ petition]. When the
benefit of counting of half of the period of past service as contractual
employee was extended to said Smt. Chakraborty, on similar facts
situation, there is no reason to deny such benefit to the present
petitioner. The said memorandum dated 25.02.2010 or even the
memorandum dated 07.10.2005 do not differentiate amongst the
persons who have already completed pensionable period of service
and who have not completed the same. Both the petitioner and said
Smt. Rama Chakraborty having stood on similar footings, similar
treatment is required to be done to both of them.
[14]
Considering all these aspects and in view of above said
discussions, the writ petition is allowed. It is held that the petitioner
is also entitled to get the benefit of counting half of the period of
continuous past service having worked as Legal Services Workers
Grade-II and Grade-I for the purpose of pensionary benefits. The
respondents are directed to act accordingly to extend such benefit to
the petitioner by taking necessary steps within 4[four] weeks from
the date of receipt of the copy of this judgment and order.
Accordingly, the writ petition is disposed of.
Interim application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
The service books of Sri Bimal Bhattacharjee and Smt.
Rama Chakraborty be returned to Mr. R.G. Chakraborty, learned
counsel.
JUDGE
signed by SUJAY GHOSH
SUJAY GHOSH Digitally
Date: 2025.07.18 12:26:44 +05'30'
Sujay
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review