Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
Crl.Rev.P. No.24 of 2023
1. Shri Amit Kumar Roy,
S/o Sri Amal Krishna Roy,
Resident of Routhkhala,
P.O & P.S- Bishalgarh, District- Sepahijala Tripura.
… Petitioner
Versus
1. Smt. Lipika Banik Roy,
W/o Shri Amit Kumar Roy,
D/o Sri Jatish Chandra Banik,
Resident of Bridya Nagar,
P.O & P.S- Ranirbazar, District- West Tripura,
2. Miss Abantika Roy,
D/o Sri Amit Kumar Roy,
Resident of Bridya Nagar,
P.O & P.S- Ranirbazar, District- West Tripura,
(Minor daughter to be represented by her mother i.e.
Respondent No.1)
3. The State of Tripura,
Represented by the Secretary, Home Department,
Government of Tripura.
…Respondents
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Kundan Pandey, Adv,
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. S. Ghosh, Addl. P.P.,
Mr. D.P. Ghosh, Adv.
Date of Hearing
:
15.03.2024
Date of delivery of
Judgment and Order :
21.03.2024
Whether fit for
Reporting
YES
:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
This criminal revision is filed under Section 397 of
Cr.P.C. for setting aside the judgment and order dated
11.07.2022 passed by Learned Additional Judge, Family
Court, Agartala, West Tripura in case No.Crl.Misc.462 of
2019. By the said order Learned Additional Family Judge,
Agartala
has
directed
the
petitioner-husband
to
pay
Rs.3,000/- per month to the respondent No.1 i.e. wife and
Rs. 5,500/- to the respondent No.2 i.e. the minor daughter
in total Rs.8,500/- from the month of July 2022 onwards.
02.
Heard Mr. Kundan Pandey, Learned Counsel for
the petitioner-husband. Also heard the submission of Mr. D.
Ghosh, Learned Counsel for the private respondents No.1
and 2 and Mr. S. Ghosh, Learned Additional P.P. for the
State. Before entering into the merit, let us discuss the
subject matter of the dispute amongst the parties. The
respondent No.1, i.e. wife, Smt. Lipika Banik(Roy) filed one
case on behalf of herself and for the minor daughter
Abantika Roy against her husband Sri. Amit Kumar Roy
under Section 125 Cr.P.C. seeking maintenance at the rate
of Rs.20,000/- per month.
03.
The gist of the petition filed by the respondent-
wife in short, is that, her marriage was solemnized with the
present petitioner-husband on 24.11.2005 as per Hindu
Marriage Rites and Customs in presence of relatives and
well-wishers of both the sides and after the marriage she
went to her matrimonial home at RouthKhala, Bishalgarh and
started resuming conjugal life with her husband. After that
they resumed conjugal life for certain period peacefully,
thereafter, the wife-respondent observed that her husband
started misbehaving with her on petty matters, even, one
day, she was severely assaulted on the issue of attending
marriage ceremony of one of her relatives. After that, the
matter was mitigated by the intervention of her parents-inlaw but after coming back from the marriage, the husbandpetitioner herein misbehaved with her with filthy languages
and again assaulted her. Thus, she could realize that her
husband was a man of short temperament. After one year of
their marriage, the O.P. wife became pregnant and during
that period, the husband-petitioner did not take any care of
her for her medical checkup and medication. It was further
asserted that during the period of her pregnancy, her
husband also assaulted her, in case of her inability to
perform household works. One day, during the advanced
stage of her pregnancy, again she was severely assaulted by
the petitioner-husband and for that the neighbouring persons
had to intervene to mitigate the dispute. On 05.10.2007 she
delivered one girl child and after that she went to her
father’s house and stayed therein for two months. That time
also her husband abused her over telephone stating that she
was avoiding to perform household works. During that
period, her husband never enquired about her, nor came to
his in-laws house to see her and the minor baby. After that,
she
returned
back
to
her
matrimonial
home,
when
thereafter, so many incidents took place on different dates
and the petitioner-husband dragged her from his residence
for which the wife-respondent was compelled to come back
to the residence of her father and stayed therein for eight
months. But the petitioner-husband that time also did not
take any care for his wife and after that in the month of
August 2008, the family members of both the parties held a
meeting when the petitioner-husband assured that he will
not cause any cruelty upon his wife and then she came back
to her matrimonial home again. Few days were elapsed
peacefully and again the petitioner husband started causing
mental cruelty upon the wife-respondent, not only that the
mother-in-law of the wife-respondent used to instigate her
son for causing cruelty upon the wife-respondent.
In the year 2010, the marriage of the younger
sister of the respondent-wife was fixed, for which her
parents came to her matrimonial home for invitation. That
time the petitioner-husband assaulted them saying that they
had made false statement at the time of meeting and that he
will never attend the marriage ceremony and also will not
allow the wife-respondent to attend the marriage. But as the
wife-respondent went to attend the marriage, that time the
petitioner-husband abused her over telephone by filthy
languages. On 04.12.2010, the petitioner-husband came to
her father’s house under influence of alcohol and started
assaulting her physically in presence of everybody and
damaged her mobile phone. And Since then, the wiferespondent has been staying in the residence of her father.
Later on, she became ill when her father-in-law along with
others came to see her and requested her to return back to
her to matrimonial home. The petitioner-husband also came
and requested her to resume conjugal life and after that
considering the future of the minor daughter and with a hope
for living peaceful conjugal life, again she went to her
matrimonial home but thereafter, also the same episode
continued and after that on 06.10.2018 at about 4 a.m the
petitioner-husband woke up suddenly from his sleep and
severely
assaulted
the
wife-respondent
physically
and
dragged her out of his house. It was stated that the
petitioner-husband
also
threatened
to
kill
the
wife-
respondent after knowing the fact that she was trying to
inform the matter to her brother. In such a situation, finding
no other alternative, the wife-respondent stated to have
taken shelter at her father’s house on 11.12.2018 along with
her minor daughter. On 06.01.2019, the petitioner-husband
came to the father’s house of the wife-respondent and tried
to assault her but she was saved by the intervention of her
parents and local people.
04.
It
was
further
asserted
that
the
petitioner-
husband being the 2nd party is a school teacher and he is
earning more than Rs.50,000/- per month. Hence, the wiferespondent
as
petitioner
filed
the
application
seeking
maintenance. The petitioner-husband as O.P., 2nd party
contested the proceeding before the Learned Family Judge,
denying all the assertions and stated that he was on fixed
pay employee with monthly salary of Rs.20,267/- per month
and countering all the allegations of the wife-respondent, he
finally prayed for dismissal of the proceeding.
05.
To substantiate the case, the wife-respondent
adduced two witnesses and the petitioner-husband also
adduced two witnesses and finally, after taking evidence and
also on hearing arguments, Learned Additional Judge, Family
Court, Agartala passed the order on 11.07.2022. The
operative portion of the order runs as follows:
“In the result, I am satisfied that the
1st party has proved her Case much to
the extent required by law. The relief
awarded to the 1st party and
directions to the 2nd party are as
follows:a) The 2nd party is accordingly,
directed to hand over the 1st party an
amount of Rs.3,000/- (Rupees three
thousand
only)
for
herself
and
Rs.5,500/- (Rupees five thousand and
five hundred Only) for their minor
daughter, every month starting from
the month of July 2022 to be paid by
the 7th day of August 2022 and every
consecutive months thereafter.
b) The 2nd party is directed to send
the total amount of Rs.8,5000/-(sic. it
should be 8,500/-) every month, as
directed above, by way of Money
Order or in any other due process,
convenient to both, in the following
address:
Address of the 1st party:
Smt. Lipika Banik (Roy), W/O Sri. Amit
Kumar Roy,
D/O. Sri. Jatish Ch. Banik, Presently
residing at
Village- Briddha Nagar, PO & PS- Ranir
Bazar,
West Tripura- 799130,
Or
Deposit the same in her Bank account,
if the details are forwarded to him.
c) The above total amount of
Rs.8,500/- is fixed considering the
basic requirements of the 1st party
and her minor son, which is sufficient
at present compared to the present
status and income of the 2nd party.
d) Any Order of interim maintenance,
if existing, shall stand vacated with
immediate effect.
A copy of this judgment be furnished
to both the parties free of cost for
information and compliance.
With the above observation and
directions, the instant Case is hereby
allowed and disposed of on contest.”
06.
It is to be noted here that to determine the case,
Learned Family Judge formulated three (3) points for
decision of the proceeding which are as follows:
“i) Whether the 1st party was tortured
by her husband and in-laws or that
she was compelled to take shelter at
her father’s house along with her
minor child?
ii) Whether the 2nd party neglects to
maintain his wife and daughter, inspite of having sufficient means?
iii) Whether the 1st party and her
daughter
are
entitled
to
get
maintenance
as
claimed
and
if
allowed,
what
should
be
the
quantum?”
07.
At the time of hearing, Learned Counsel for the
petitioner fairly submitted that there is no dispute on record
in respect of the fact of marriage of the petitioner-husband
with the O.P. wife. Learned Counsel for the petitioner further
submitted that petitioner-husband has got no objection to
comply with the order of the Learned Family judge, in
respect of paying maintenance allowance to the minor
daughter but in respect of the respondent-wife, Learned
Counsel submitted that before the Learned Family Judge the
wife-respondent suppressed the fact that she was highly
qualified and serving in Education Department as a guest
lecturer but in course of evidence, she specifically stated that
she does not have any income of her own. Learned Counsel
for the petitioner also drawn the attention of the Court to
draw inference on Exhibit-A, relied upon by the petitionerhusband. Learned Counsel also submitted that there is no
cause of action to file the petition by the wife-respondent
because the wife-respondent by adducing oral/documentary
evidence on record has failed to prove that she was
subjected to cruelty by the petitioner-husband and she was
refused/neglected to provide maintenance by the petitionerhusband. Learned Counsel further submitted that as the
respondent-wife is earning money so, as per law, she is not
entitled to get any maintenance and prayed for setting aside
the order of the Learned Additional Judge, in respect of
awarding maintenance in favour of the respondent-wife.
08.
On the other hand, Learned Counsel for the wife-
respondent submitted that Learned Court below rightly
awarded maintenance in favour of the wife-respondent
because according to Learned Counsel, the wife-respondent
was subjected to cruelty by the petitioner-husband at her
matrimonial home and even he failed to provide maintenance
to
the
wife-respondent
and
drove
her
out
from
her
matrimonial home. He further submitted that as alleged by
Learned Counsel for the petitioner, the case was filed in the
year 2019 but she got employment, as alleged, in the year
2021 but during that period, no maintenance allowance was
provided by the petitioner-husband to the wife-respondent.
Furthermore,
just
to
avoid
the
liability
to
provide
maintenance, the petitioner-husband has filed a case of RCR
and further submitted that inspite of allowing order, the
present petitioner is not paying any maintenance to the wiferespondent and asked for dismissal of the revision petition.
09.
Here in the case at hand, there is no dispute on
record in respect of the marriage of the petitioner-husband
with the wife-respondent and also the birth of the minor
daughter. The only contention raised by the petitionerhusband is that since the wife-respondent is earning some
money, which she has suppressed in her application and also
during evidence and the Learned Court below ignoring the
legal position has allowed her petition. So, Learned Counsel
for the petitioner urged for modification of the order to that
extent. To determine the case, both the parties have
adduced evidences:
“A. Witnesses of the 1st Party:
PW-1 Smt. Lipika Banik (Roy) &
PW-2 Sri. Jatish Ch. Banik.
B. Documents of the 1st Party: Nil.
C. Witnesses of the 2nd Party:
OPW1- Sri. Amit Kr. Roy &
OPW-2 Sri. Mihir Debnath.
D. Documents of the 2nd Party:
Exbt-A: He has submitted one memo
dt.01.10.2021 issued by the Principal,
Govt. Degree College, Khumulwng,
West Tripura regarding engagement of
the 1st party as a Guest Lecturer.”
10.
It
is
the
admitted
position
that
the
wife-
respondent filed the application granting maintenance on
26.07.2019 before the Learned Additional Family Judge,
Agartala, West Tripura and from Exhibit-A, as relied upon by
the petitioner-husband, it appears that she was engaged as a
guest lecturer vide memo dated 01.10.2021 of the Principalin-charge, Government Degree College, Khumulwng for the
year 2021-22 at the rate of Rs.400/- per class subject to
maximum limit of 180 classes and she was allotted 90
classes for the first time. The memo, as already stated was
issued on 01.10.2021. The wife-respondent appeared before
the Family Court for her evidence on 15.11.2021 when she
stated that she has got no income of her own. From the
contents of Exhibit-A, it is clear that, that was purely a
temporary engagement on the basis of which it cannot be
said that the wife-respondent had a permanent job to sustain
her livelihood.
11.
Learned Counsel for the petitioner, in course of
hearing relied upon few citations.
In Bheekha Ram vs. Goma Devi and Ors.
dated 22.01.1999, reported in (1999) SCC OnLine Raj
265, Hon’ble the Rajasthan High Court in Para No.8
observed as under:
“8. The right to be maintained by the
husband stems from performance of
marital duty. It is only when the Court
inter alia comes to the finding that the
wife claiming maintenance had been
prevented from performing the marital
duty by the husband that she could be
awarded maintenance. When it is
found that the wife declines to live
with husband without any just cause
and there is no evidence of ill-
treatment by the husband, wife is not
entitled to maintenance. In the instant
case, it is noticed that the husband
even sent a registered notice to the
wife asking her to stay with him but
she refused to accept the notice.”
12.
In Niharika Ghosh vs. Shankar Ghosh dated
12.09.2023, reported in (2023) SCC OnLine Del 5624,
Hon’ble the Delhi High Court in Para No.13 observed as
under:
“13. We find that in the present case it
is not only that the appellant is highly
qualified and has an earning capacity,
but in fact she has been earning,
though has not been inclined to
truthfully disclose her true income.
Such a person cannot be held entitled
to maintenance. Pertinently, the claim
for maintenance by the appellant
under the provisions of Protection of
Women against Domestic Violence Act
has also met the same fate and the
maintenance has been declined to her.
We, therefore, find no merit in the
Appeal which is hereby dismissed.”
13.
In Criminal Revision No.512 of 2022 dated
02.02.2024, Hon’ble the Jharkhand High Court in Para No.16
observed as under:
“16. In view of the overall evidence
adduced on behalf of both the parties,
it is found that the respondentapplicant has been residing aloof from
the husband without any reasonable
cause. Accordingly, this point of
determination is decided in favour of
the petitioner-husband and against
the
opposite
party-wife.
In
consequence thereof, in view of
Section 125(4) of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973 she is not entitled to
any amount of maintenance. Section
125(4) of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973 reads as under:
“(4) No wife
shall be
entitled
to
receive
an
[allowance
for
the
maintenance or the interim
maintenance and expenses
of proceeding, as the case
may be,] from her husband
under this section if she is
living in adultery, or if,
without
any
sufficient
reason, she refuses to live
with her husband, or if they
are living separately my
mutual consent.”
14.
In
Civil
Revision
No.
1290/99
dated
24.03.2000, reported in (2000) SCC OnLine MP 580,
Hon’ble the High Court of Madhya Pradesh in para No.7
observed as under:
“7. In view of this, the question arises,
as to in what way Section 24 of the
Act has to be interpreted. Whether a
spouse who has capacity of earning
but chooses to remain idle, should be
permitted to saddle other spouse with
his or her expenditure? Whether such
spouse should be permitted to get
pendente lite alimony at higher rate
from other spouse in such condition?
According to me, Section 24 has been
enacted for the purpose of providing a
monetary assistance to such spouse
who is incapable of supporting himself
Or herself inspite of sincere efforts
made by him or herself. A spouse who
is well qualified to get the service
immediately with less efforts is not
expected to remain idle to squeeze
out, to milk out the other spouse by
relieving him of his or her own purse
by a cut in the nature of pendente lite
alimony. The law does not expect the
increasing
number
of
such
idle
persons who by remaining in the
arena of legal battles, try to squeeze
out the adversory by implementing the
provisions of law suitable to their
purpose. In the present case Mamta
Jaiswal is a well qualified woman
possessing qualification like M.Sc. M.C.
M.Ed. Till 1994 she was serving in
Gulamnabi Azad Education College. It
impliedly
means
that
she
was
possessing sufficient experience. How
such a lady can remain without
service? It really puts a bug question
which is to be answered by Mamta
Jaiswal with sufficient congent and
believable evidence by proving that in
spite of sufficient efforts made by her,
she was not able to get service and,
therefore, she is unable to support
herself. A lady who is fighting
matrimonial petition filed for divorce,
cannot be permitted to sit idle and to
put her burden on the husband for
demanding pendente lite alimony from
him
during
pendency
of
such
matrimonial petition. Section 24 is not
meant for creating an army of such
idle persons who would be sitting idle
waiting for a 'dole' to be awarded by
her husband who has got a grievance
against her and who has gone to the
Court for seeking a relief against her.
The case may be vice versa also. If a
husband well qualified, sufficient
enough to earn, sits idle and puts his
burden on the wife and waits for a
'dole' to be awarded by remaining
entangled in litigation. That is also not
permissible. The law does not help
indolents as well idles so also does not
want an army of self-made lazy idles.
Everyone has to earn for the purpose
of maintenance of himself or herself,
atleast, has to make sincere efforts in
that direction. If this criteria is not
applied, if this attitude is not adopted,
there would be a tendency growing
amongst such litigants to prolong such
litigation
and
to
milk
out
the
adversory who happens to be a
spouse, once dear but far away after
an emerging of litigation. If such army
is permitted to remain in existence,
there would be no sincere efforts of
amicable settlements because the lazy
spouse would be very happy to fight
and frustrate the efforts of amicable
settlement because he would be
reaping the money in the nature of
pendente lite alimony, and would
prefer to be happy in remaining idle
and not bothering himself or herself
for any activity to support and
maintain himself or herself. That
cannot be treated to be aim, goal
of Section 24. It is indirectly against
healthyness of the society. It has
enacted for needy persons who in
spite of sincere efforts and sufficient
effort are unable to support and
maintain themselves and are required
to fight out the litigation jeopardising
their hard earned income by toiling/
working hours.”
15.
Referring the same, Learned Counsel for the
petitioner submitted that in view of the principles of the
aforesaid citations, the wife-respondent is not entitled to get
any maintenance. I have heard detailed submission of
Learned Counsels at length. From the evidence on record, it
appears to me that some mal-adjustment cropped up
amongst the parties for which the wife-respondent had to
take shelter at her parents’ house and since December 2018
she has been staying at her paternal house and after waiting
for some period, she has filed the case before the Family
Court on 26.07.2019. There is no evidence on record that
during that period and thereafter also the petitioner-husband
paid any maintenance to the wife-respondent and her minor
daughter.
Further,
from
the
cross-examination
of
the
petitioner-husband before the Family Court, it appears that
he filed the case of restitution of conjugal life against the
wife-respondent after receiving notice of maintenance case
from the Family Court, which was filed by the wiferespondent.
16.
Learned Judge, Family Court, after considering all
the facts and circumstances of the case determined the
amount of compensation at the rate of Rs.3,000/- per month
from the month of July 2022 in favour of the wiferespondent.
The
petitioner-husband,
in
course
of
his
examination before the Court stated that he is receiving
gross salary of Rs.34,852/- per month as on December
2021. By this time, his salary might have increased. In this
regard, there was no finding by the Learned Family Court.
17.
In Sunita Kachwaha and Others vs. Anil
Kachwaha dated 28.10.2014 reported in (2014) SCC 715,
Hon’ble the Supreme Court in para 6 and 8 observed as
under:
“6. The proceding under Section 125
CrPC is summary in nature. In a
proceeding under Section 125 CrPC, it
is not necessary for the court to
ascertain as to who was in wrong and
the minute details of the matrimonial
dispute between the husband and wife
need not be gone into. While so, the
High Court was not right in going into
the intricacies of dispute between the
appellant wife and the respondent and
observing that the appellant wife on
her own left the matrimonial house
and therefore she was not entitled to
maintenance. Such observation by the
High Court overlooks the evidence of
the appellant wife and the factual
findings, as recorded by the Family
Court.
8. The learned counsel for the
respondent
submitted
that
the
appellant wife is well-qualified, having
postgraduate degree in Geography
and working as a teacher in Jabalpur
and also working in the Health
Department.
Therefore,
she
has
income of her own and needs no
financial support from the respondent.
In our considered view, merely
because the appellant wife is a
qualified postgraduate, it would not be
sufficient to hold that she is in a
position to maintain herself. Insofar as
her employment as a teacher in
Jabalpur, nothing was placed on
record before the Family Court or in
the
High
Court
to
prove
her
employment and her earnings. In any
event, merely because the wife was
earning something, it would not be a
ground to reject her claim for
maintenance.”
From the aforesaid principle of law laid down by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, it appears that the wife
is well-qualified, having post-graduate degree and working
as a lecturer and is earning something is not a ground to
reject her claim for maintenance. Here in this case, after
going through the evidence on record of the Learned Court
below, it appears to me that the respondent-wife has been
able to prove that she has been neglected and refused to
provide
maintenance
by
the
petitioner-husband.
Furthermore, there is no any specific evidence on record as
to how much amount of money is earning by the respondentwife after attending her classes or earning any money or not.
So, in view of the principle laid down by the Hon’ble Apex
Court, it appears to me that the Learned Additional Judge,
Family Court, Agartala, reasonably and rightly awarded
maintenance in favour of the respondent-wife and their
daughter. As already stated, there is no satisfactory evidence
on record from the side of the petitioner-husband that the
respondent-wife is serving/holding any post of permanent in
nature rather, her engagement is purely temporary in nature
as surfaces from the contents of Exibit-A as relied upon by
the petitioner-husband. Furthermore, it appears that the
Learned Additional Judge, Family Court awarded lesser
amount
of
maintenance
allowance
in
favour
of
the
respondent-wife for which, she shall have the liberty to claim
for enhancement of maintenance in due course of time, if
she is so advised.
18.
But
considering
the
present
facts
and
circumstances of the case, I do not find any scope to
interfere with the order passed by Learned Additional Judge,
Family Court, Agartala dated 11.07.2022.
19.
In the result, the petition filed by the petitioner-
husband
challenging
the
judgment
and
order
dated
11.07.2022 passed by Learned Additional Judge, Family
Court, Agartala, West Tripura in case No.Crl.Misc.462 of
2019 is hereby dismissed. The petitioner-husband is hereby
asked to ensure the order dated 11.07.2022 passed by
Learned Additional Judge, Family Court in Criminal Misc.462
of 2019 in letter and spirit, so as to enable the wiferespondent and her daughter to avoid sufferings from any
vagrancy and destitution.
20.
With this observation, the revision petition is
dismissed on contest. Pending application(s), if any, also
stands disposed of.
Send down the LCR along with the copy of the
judgment.
JUDGE
SABYASACHI
BHATTACHARJEE
BHATTACHARJEE Date: 2024.03.22 18:22:15 +05'30'
Purnita
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review