Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
08.01.2026
Court. No. 25
D.Hira
WPA 29996 of 2025
Shree Jagdamba Coke Industries
Private Limited & Anr.
Vs.
Union of India & Ors.
Mr.Saptangsu Basu, Sr. Adv.,
Mr. Amritam Mondal,
Mr. Supravat Banerjee,
Mr. Jyotirmoy Jha.
…for the Petitioners.
Mr. Souvik Nandy, Sr. Adv.,
Ms. Supriya Dubey.
… for the respondent Nos. 2 to 4
Mr. Amal Kumar Datta,
Mr. Ram Chandra Agarwal.
… for the Union of India
1. The
petitioners
have
filed
the
present
writ
application challenging the tender notice issued by
the Steel Authority of India for supply of coke
breeze of 92,500 metric tons for six months at their
plants at IISCO Steel Plant, Rourkela Steel Plant
and Durgapur Steel Plant.
2. Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that as
per Clause 5 (2) (b) of the eligibility criteria of the
said tender, the bidders should have supplied
minimum 24,500 metric tons coke breeze by rail to
any
Central
or
State
Government
organizations/PSU/Public Limited Company over a
period of any consecutive twelve months during the
last five financial years and current financial year
ending last day of the month prior to the month in
which this tender is issued.
3. Mr. Saptangsu Basu, learned senior advocate
appearing for the petitioners submits that the
condition imposed by the Steel Authority of India
for supply of coke breeze by rail is arbitrary in
nature and is only to favour a particular entity and
no
other
bidders
in
the
entire
market
can
participate in the said tender.
4. This application was moved before the Vacation
Bench on 31st December, 2025 and this Court has
passed an interim order restraining the respondent
authorities for taking any decision for inviting
tender till 8th January, 2026 and the Steel
Authority of India is directed to file a report on the
date fixed.
5. Today when the matter is called on, learned
counsel appearing for the Steel Authority of India
has filed a report after serving a copy to the learned
counsel for the petitioners.
6. Learned counsel for the respondents has raised the
issue
of
maintainability
of
the
present
writ
application, on the ground that this Court is not
having jurisdiction to entertain the writ application
as the Steel Authority of India has published the
tender from Rourkela Steel Plant and the tender is
to be concluded at Rourkela Steel Plant itself.
Thus, this Court is not having jurisdiction.
7. The second point raised by the respondents is that
the Court does not have the expertise to examine
the terms and conditions of the tender document
and cannot interfere with the tender process.
8. Learned counsel appearing for the respondents in
support of his submissions has relied upon the
judgment in the case of Oil And Natural Gas
Commission Vs. Utpal Kumar Basu & Ors.
reported in (1994) 4 Supreme Court Cases 711
and submits that in the said case also the Hon’ble
Supreme Court has held that the tender was
submitted and scrutinized at New Delhi and the
execution of the contract works to be carried out at
Hazira
in
advertisement
Gujarat
was
and
made
merely
at
because
Calcutta
and
representation was made from Calcutta would not
constitute cause of action.
9.
Learned counsel for the respondents have further
relied upon the judgment in the case of Kusum
Ingots & Alloys Ltd. Vs. Union of India & Anr.
reported in (2004) 6 Supreme Court Cases 254
and submits that in the said case also the Hon’ble
Supreme Court has considered the case of Oil and
Natural Gas Commission (supra) and held that in
order to confer jurisdiction on a High Court to
entertain a writ petition it must disclose that the
integral facts pleaded in support of the cause of
action do constitute a cause so as to empower the
Court to decide the dispute and the entire or a part
of it arose within its jurisdiction.
10. He submits that in the present case no cause of
action arose within the jurisdiction of this Court
and all cause of action is in Rourkela.
11.
He further relied upon the judgment in the case of
Jagdish Mandal vs. State of Orissa & Ors.
reported in (2007) 14 Supreme Court Cases 517
and submits that the Hon’ble Supreme Court has
categorically held that when the power of judicial
review is invoked in the matter relating to the
tenders or award of contracts certain special
features should be borne in the mind. But in the
present case, there is no such special feature is
brought to the notice of this Court by the
petitioner, so that this Court can entertain the writ
petition filed by the petitioner.
12. Learned
upon
counsel for the respondents have relied
the
judgment
in
the
case
of
Afcons
Infrastructure Limited Vs. Nagpur Metro Rail
Corporation Limited & Anr. reported in (2016)
16 Supreme Court Cases 818 and submits that a
mere
disagreement
with
the
decision
making
process or the decision of the administrative
authority is no reason for a constitutional Court to
interfere with the matter.
13. He further relied upon the judgment in the case of
N.G. Projects Limited Vs. Vinod Kumar Jain &
Ors. reported in (2022) 6 Supreme Court Cases
127 and submits that the tender condition is
primarily upon the authority inviting the bids.
Such authority is aware of the expectations from
the tenderers while evaluating the consequences of
non-performance.
14. He
submits
that
in
the
present
case,
the
authorities is of the view that the Coke Breeze
should be supplied by the tenderer in a safe
condition and the Rail Rack protect material
quality better than road transport in India.
15.
Accordingly, the authorities have imposed the
condition for supply of the coke breeze by rail.
16. He submits that the petitioners have not made out
any case of arbitrary on behalf of the respondents
and have also not made out any case for interfering
in the tender process.
Accordingly, he prays for
dismissal of the writ petition.
17.
Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioners in reply has relied upon the judgment in
the case of Meerut Development Authority Vs.
Association of Management Studies & Anr.
reported in (2009) 6 Supreme Court Cases 171
and submits that the tender is an offer.
It is
something which invites and is communicated to
notify acceptance.
Broadly stated it must be
unconditional, it must be in the proper form, the
person by whom tender is made, must be able to
and willing to perform his obligations.
18. He submits that by incorporating the condition for
supply of coke breeze by rail, the respondent
authorities intending to issue the tender work only
for their favourite bidder knowing that in India only
two firms are supplying coke breeze by rails, that
is, one M/s. Mahalaxmi Wellman Fuel and M/s.
Vimla Fuel and Metals Private Limited but at
present M/s. Vimla Fuel and Metals Private
Limited has already been suspended.
Only to
favour M/s. Mahalaxmi Wellman Fuel and to oust
all other parties have incorporated the condition for
supply by Rail Rack.
19.
Heard the leaned counsel for the respective
parties and perused the materials on record.
20. The eligibility criteria of the tender documents at
Clause 5 reads as follows:
5. Eligibility Criteria:1)
Documentary evidence in support of their
eligibility to be attached along with the technocommercial bid, failing which the offer is liable
to be rejected.
2) Eligibility Criteria In order to be eligible to
participate in this tender, the bidder must
fulfill the followinga) The tenderer should be manufacturers of
coke or coke Breeze.
In support of being a
manufacturer of coke / coke breeze, tenderer
must submit the documentary evidence i.e.,
manufacturing
license
issued
by
Govt.
authority/certificate issued by Pollution control
board/DIC/SSi/NSIC Certificate etc. The above
certificate(s)
must
be
submitted
duly
self
certified by authorized person of the company.
The
documentary
evidence
indicating
the
bidder as manufacturer of Coke or Coke Breeze
must be valid as on opening of Bid and it is the
responsibility of
validity
of
the bidder to ensure the
the
manufacturing
certificate
throughout the contract period.
b) For ISP & RSP market: Bidder should have
supplied minimum 24500MT of coke breeze by
Rail
to
any
Central/State
govt.
Organization/PSU/Public limited company over
a period of any consecutive 12 months during
the
last
five
financial
years
and
current
financial year ending last day of the month
prior to the month in which this Tender is
issued.
For DSP market:
Bidder should have supplied
minimum 15750MT of coke breeze by Rail to
any
Central/State
govt.
Organization/PSU/Public limited company over
a period of any consecutive 12 months during
the
last
five
financial
years
and
current
financial year ending last day of the month
prior to the month in which this Tender is
issued.
The Tenderer shall submit self attested copies
of the Purchase Order(s) and a consolidated
statement
duly
certified
by
Chartered
Accountant with valid UDIN & registration no.,
mentioning
Purchase
order
no.
&
date,
Customer name & city, dispatch details (RR no.
RR date and RR quantity) and total supplied
Quantity
in
support
of
their
meeting
the
eligibility criteria.
3)
SAIL reserves the right to call for original
documents for verification at any time during
tendering, evaluation and/or the execution of
the
contract.
In
case
of
any
documents/information submitted by bidder(s)
found
to
be
false
misrepresentation of
and
containing
any
having any fraudulent
declaration in it, then in such eventually, legal
action
(including
cancellation
of
contract,
banning of business dealing, damages criminal
proceeding etc.) as deemed fit may be initiated
by SAIL against the bidder.
4) Only manufacturer of coke or coke breeze is
allowed to participate. Offer of traders/dealers
will not be considered for this tender.
5)
In case any specific adverse report is
received against a tenderer, as an information
or upon enquiry made by SAIL, in respect of
capabilities and performance of the tenderer,
after receipt of tender (even after opening of
price bid), the quotation/tender submitted by
such tenderer is liable to be rejected.”
21. As per the Clause 5 (2) (b), the bidders should have
supplied the minimum 24,500 metric tons of coke
breeze by rail for ISP and RSP market and
minimum 15750 MT for DSP market. Admittedly,
the petitioners are not supplying the coke by rail.
The respondent authorities have filed their report
by justifying why the condition for supply of coke
breeze by rail has been imposed in the tender
condition, which reads as follows:4. In compliance with the said directions, I beg
to submit this report in the form of an affidavit
and rely upon the stand of the SAIL and the
reply of the respondent Nos. 2 to 4 in the form
of this Affidavit in response to the query of the
Hon’ble
Court.
reproduced
below,
The
stand
it
has
of
the
been
SAIL
clearly
mentioned that on what basis such decision was
taken by the Tendering authorities for inviting
tender by way of transport through Rail and
excluding road transportation by inserting the
particular clause in the Tender, such as:
i) That Pilferage of material during road transit
is a significant and persistent issue in India,
with the logistics sector losing an estimated
Rs.13,000 crore annually to cargo theft and
pilferage.
ii) A full railway rake movement is generally a
more cost-effective freight solution than road
transportation methods, especially for large
volumes of goods over long distances.
iii) Rail rakes (trains) protect material quality
better than road transport in India.
iv) Trucks involve multiple loading/unloading
points
and
road
travel
vibrations,
causing
significant breakage and creating fine dust
(fines)
quality.
from
coke
breeze,
which
degrades
v) Rakes move large quantities in one go with
fewer transfers, and wagons offer a more stable
journey,
preserving
the
particle
size
distribution crucial for coke quality.
vi) Railways move massive volumes (e.g., 3,0004,000
tones
numerous
per
trucks,
rake)
much
reducing
faster
than
time
coke
the
breeze is exposed to adverse weather and
handling, ensuring it reaches the plant in better
condition.
vii)
The requirement of Coke breeze in bulk
quantities
is
essential
for
maintaining
continuous production at SAIL units. Any delay
in supply will lead to loss of production having
significant adverse monetary impact.
Hence,
prior experience in terms of proven supply
capability including the mode of transport
opted (in this case rail) is considered essential.
viii)
In case such bulk requirement of Coke
breeze is transported by road in trucks, there is
high chance of spillage even after covering of
the material being transported. Past experience
of transportation of this material through road
shows that it has led to spillage enroute to the
Plant as also inside the Plant thereby causing
pollution and safety hazard.
ix)
For aforesaid reasons, SAIL/RSP had a
reasonable basis for preferring the Suppliers
having
the
capacity
to
send
the
material
supplied through Rail Rakes over that of road
transport.
Rourkela Steel Plant, the Central
Procurement
constantly
Agency
and
in
present
successfully
case,
receiving
is
the
supply of material through Rail Rake and not
from the road transport.
We are citing an
example of previous procurement of material by
SAIL/RSP through Rail as under.”
22. This Court considers the justification provided by
the authorities.
The authorities have issued the
tender for supply of coke breeze. In Clause 6 of the
tender conditions mode of dispatch is prescribed.
In the said conditions also it is mandatory to
supply the coke breeze by rail rack. If the bidders
will supply the coke breeze by road transport also,
the coke breeze supplied by the bidder to the
actual weight and quality is to be checked by the
purchaser.
If the purchaser finds that the
materials supplied by the bidder the quality and
quantity is not complied with the terms and
conditions of the tender document, the purchaser
is at liberty to refuse to accept with the direction to
supply in terms of the tender condition.
If the
condition of mode of dispatch is taken into
consideration, the same condition can be imposed
if the coke breeze is supplied through road
transport.
23. Considering the above, this Court is not satisfied
with the justification given by the authorities for
imposing condition for supply of coke breeze by
rail.
24. This Court also finds that in paragraph 21 of the
writ application, the petitioners have made a
specific
averment
that
the
respondents
have
deliberately and intentionally to give favour to one
supplier imposed such condition.
25. In
the report submitted by the authorities it is
mentioned that two successful parties namely,
M/s. Mahalaxmi Wellman Fuel and M/s. Vimla
Fuel and Metals Private Limited are the successful
parties.
26. It is the submission made by the petitioners that
M/s. Vimla Fuel and Metals Private Limited is
closed and only M/s. Mahalaxmi Wellman Fuel is
supplying the coke by rail rack.
27. Considering
the above, this Court finds that by
incorporating the condition to supply coke breeze
by Rail refrains many firms for participating in the
tender process and the reasons assigned for
incorporation
of
the
said
condition
is
not
justifiable.
28. Accordingly,
this Court has entertained the writ
application.
29. As regards the jurisdiction of this Court, admittedly
the authorities have published the tender from
Rourkela and the tender process is to be completed
at the office of Rourkela but as per the tender
document the tenderer has to supply the coke at
IISCO Steel Plant which is situated at West Bengal
and also to Durgapur Steel Plant which is also
situated at the State of West Bengal.
30. The judgment relied by the petitioners in the case
of Kusum Ingots & Alloys Ltd. (supra) and Oil
and
Natural
Gas
Commissiion
(supra)
are
distinguishable from the facts of the present case.
In the case in hand, cause of action arose at
Rourkela as well as in the State of West Bengal,
thus this Court is also having jurisdiction to
entertain the writ application.
31. Considering the above, the respondent authorities
are directed to proceed with the tender process
without imposing the condition for supply of the
coke breeze by rail only.
32. Accordingly, WPA No. 29996 of 2025 is disposed of.
33. Urgent
Photostat certified copy of this order, if
applied for, be supplied to the parties upon
compliance with all the necessary formalities.
(Krishna Rao, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review