The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. 903-FA-3112-2013.odt Although the Civil Surgeon who issued the disability certificate is not examined, the appellant had examined treating doctor to prove the nature of the injuries suffered during the accident. The nature of the injuries is not seriously in dispute. The appellant was 73 years of age on the date of which he was injured in road accident. He is an agriculturist. He has suffered three major fracture injuries. The leg in which injuries are suffered is shortened in length. He was hospitalized for treatment for a period of around two months. Having regard to the nature of the injuries, as well as the occupation and the age of the appellant, it must be held that he suffered 100% loss of earning capacity. The learned Tribunal has erred in restricting the amount of compensation on account of loss of earning capacity to the tune of Rs.45,000/11. The learned Tribunal has rightly considered the notional income of the appellant, who was an agriculturist, as Rs.3,000/- per month. Having regard to the age of the appellant, a multiplier of 5 would be the appropriate multiplier. In view of the aforesaid, the compensation payable to the appellant is determined at Rs.1,80,000/- (Rs.36,000/- x 5 = Rs.1,80,000/-) as against Rs.45,000/- awarded by the learned Tribunal. Having regard to the nature of injuries suffered, in the considered opinion of this Court, the learned Tribunal sho…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:41363
903-FA-3112-2013.odt
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
903 FIRST APPEAL NO. 3112 OF 2013
Shrawan Bhagwan Sonawane
1.
2.
VERSUS
Mukesh Atmaram Jadhav
Age Major, Occ. Transport,
R/o Kusumbe, Tal. & Dist. Dhule
The National Insurance Co. Ltd.,
The Branch Manager,
Maharana Pratap Chowk, Dhule.
… Appellant
(Org. Claimant)
… Respondents
…..
Mr. S. S. Patil, Advocate for the Appellant.
Mr. S. R. Bobade, Advocate for Respondent No.2.
…..
CORAM
: ROHIT W. JOSHI, J.
DATE
: 04 SEPTEMBER 2026
JUDGMENT:
1.
The present appeal is filed under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles
Act, 1988 by the Original Claim petitioner in Motor Accident Claim
Petition No.284 of 2004, which came to be decided by the learned
Member, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Dhule, vide judgment and
order dated 25 August 2014 in order to seek enhancement of the
compensation awarded by the learned Tribunal. The learned Tribunal has
awarded compensation of Rs.1,73,800/- to the appellant, Rs.45,000/towards disability suffered, Rs.1,01,800/- towards reimbursement of
Kiran Kawre
903-FA-3112-2013.odt
medical expenses, Rs.12,990/- towards purchase of medicine and medical
expenses, Rs.5,000/- towards pain and suffering, Rs.6,000/- towards loss
of income during the period of hospitalization and Rs.3,000/- towards
special diet.
2.
The appellant met with a road accident on 27/9/2002 at about
6.30 p.m. while he was riding a motorcycle as a pillion rider, which was
hit by the offending vehicle owned by respondent No.1. The offending
vehicle was insured with the respondent No.2 at the relevant time. The
appellant is an agriculturist. On account of the injuries suffered, he
sustained fractures on the lumber joint, legs and right ankle. The
appellant was discharged from the hospital on 18/11/2002.
3.
He preferred a claim petition under Section 166 of the Motor
Vehicles Act, which came to be registered as Motor Accident Claim
Petition No.284 of 2003. The respondent – insurance company filed its
written statement opposing the claim and disputing all the facts stated in
the claim petition. Based on the rival pleadings, issues were framed by
the learned Tribunal. The appellant examined himself, Dr. Gautam Shah
and Dr. Nikhil Shah, and also examined two pharmasists, namely, Mr.
Imran Ansari and Mr. Dinesh Shah, in support of his case. The appellant
deposed that on account of the injuries suffered in the accident, his right
leg was shortened and that he was not fit to perform his work. He also
Kiran Kawre
903-FA-3112-2013.odt
stated that he has lost vision in his left eye. Dr. Gautam Shah, who had
performed the surgery on the appellant, stated in his deposition that the
appellant had recovered from ailment after the treatment. The disability
certificate issued by the Civil Surgeon shows 50% disability. Dr. Nikhil
Shah has deposed on the facts pertaining to admission of the appellant in
the hospital on the date of accident.
4.
On appreciation of the evidence, the learned Tribunal has held that
the appellant was an agriculturist and having regard to the nature of
work to be performed by a farmer, it cannot be said that he had suffered
total loss of earning capacity. The learned Tribunal opined that since
there was no evidence on record to ascertain the income of the appellant,
a notional income of Rs. 3,000/- could be taken into consideration for
computing the compensation. It was held that the appellant was 73 years
of age as on the date of the accident. Accordingly, the learned Tribunal
has awarded fixed compensation of Rs.45,000/- on account of disability
suffered by the appellant. In addition, compensation was awarded
towards medical expenses, medical expenditure, medicines, pain and
suffering, hospitalization.
5.
The learned advocate for the appellant argued that the correct age
of appellant was 62 years, as is recorded in the treatment papers. He
contended that age of 73 years was wrongly recorded in the medical
Kiran Kawre
903-FA-3112-2013.odt
paper of the year 2004, when the appellant had visited the doctor for
follow-up treatment. The learned advocate also contended that the
learned Tribunal has erred in awarding compensation of Rs.45,000/-,
which was inadequate. Apart from this, it is contended that appropriate
enhancement ought to be granted to the appellant under the head of pain
and suffering.
6.
Per contra, the learned advocate for the respondent – Insurance
Company contended that since the Civil Surgeon who has issued the
disability certificate was not examined, the disability certificate could not
be relied upon. The learned advocate contended that there was no
evidence on record to arrive at conclusion regarding the permanent
disability suffered by the appellant. It is further contended that the
documents placed on record by the appellant himself indicated that the
correct age of appellant was 73 years as on the date of accident. The
learned advocate therefore submits that the appeal deserves to be
dismissed.
7.
Upon hearing the rival submissions, the following points arises for
consideration in the present appeal (i) Has the learned Tribunal correctly
assessed the amount of compensation payable to the appellant by treating
his age as 73 years and his loss of earning capacity by 50%?
8.
The appellant has stated in his examination-in-chief that his age
Kiran Kawre
903-FA-3112-2013.odt
was 64 years as on the date of recording of deposition. The deposition
was recorded in the year 2011. The examination-in-chief is not on
affidavit but recorded by the learned Tribunal. The initial medical
documents dated 27/9/2002 and the discharge card dated 18/11/2002
records the age of the appellant as 62 years. Thereafter, the appellant had
met the doctor for follow-up treatment on 28/09/2004, wherein his age
was recorded as 73 years. Apart from this, no evidence was produced on
record to prove the age of the appellant. It appears from the crossexamination that the age of the appellant was challenged during the
course of cross-examination. The appellant was therefore aware that his
age was seriously disputed and that it was necessary for him to produce
evidence on record to prove his age. Despite being put to notice during
cross-examination that his age was seriously disputed, the appellant did
not produce any evidence on record.
9.
Although the initial medical papers of the year 2002 indicate the
age of the appellant as 62 years, the said documents cannot be treated as
documents of proof of date of birth or age. The burden of proving his age
was on the appellant. Since the appellant failed to bring appropriate
material on record in order to prove his age, this Court does not intend to
interfere with the finding recorded by the learned Tribunal treating the
age of the appellant as 73 years. It would be appropriate to take the age
of the appellant as 73 years.
Kiran Kawre
10.
903-FA-3112-2013.odt
Although the Civil Surgeon who issued the disability certificate is
not examined, the appellant had examined treating doctor to prove the
nature of the injuries suffered during the accident. The nature of the
injuries is not seriously in dispute. The appellant was 73 years of age on
the date of which he was injured in road accident. He is an agriculturist.
He has suffered three major fracture injuries. The leg in which injuries
are suffered is shortened in length. He was hospitalized for treatment for
a period of around two months. Having regard to the nature of the
injuries, as well as the occupation and the age of the appellant, it must be
held that he suffered 100% loss of earning capacity. The learned Tribunal
has erred in restricting the amount of compensation on account of loss of
earning capacity to the tune of Rs.45,000/11.
The learned Tribunal has rightly considered the notional income of
the appellant, who was an agriculturist, as Rs.3,000/- per month. Having
regard to the age of the appellant, a multiplier of 5 would be the
appropriate multiplier. In view of the aforesaid, the compensation
payable to the appellant is determined at Rs.1,80,000/- (Rs.36,000/- x 5
= Rs.1,80,000/-) as against Rs.45,000/- awarded by the learned
Tribunal. Having regard to the nature of injuries suffered, in the
considered opinion of this Court, the learned Tribunal should have
awarded Rs.20,000/- towards pain and suffering, as against Rs.5,000/awarded by the Court. The amount of compensation towards pain and
Kiran Kawre
903-FA-3112-2013.odt
suffering is enhanced by Rs.14,000/-. In addition to this, an additional
amount of Rs.15,000/- is awarded towards
future treatment, having
regard to the nature of the injuries suffered. Compensation awarded
against other heads is proper. Accordingly, the total amount of
compensation awarded by the learned Tribunal is enhanced by an
amount of Rs.65,000/-. In the result, the appeal is partly allowed in the
following terms:
(i)
The judgment and award dated 17/10/2011 passed by the learned
Member, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Dhule, in Motor Accident Claim
Petition No.284 of 2003 is modified by enhancing the amount of
compensation awarded by a sum of Rs.1,65,000/-, over and above
compensation of Rs.1,73,800/- awarded by the learned Tribunal.
(ii)
The respondent Nos.1 and 2 will be jointly and severally liable to
pay additional compensation of Rs.1,65,000/-, as determined by this
Court, along with interest at the rate of 6% per annum from the date of
filing of the Claim Petition i.e., 28/4/2003, till realization.
(iii)
Parties to bear own cost in appeal.
[ ROHIT W. JOSHI, J. ]
Kiran Kawre
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review