Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Reserved on : 30.09.2026
Pronounced on : 22.10.2026
Uploaded on : 22.10.2026
SWP No. 741/2013 c/w SWP No.732/2013
SWP No. 1068/2013, SWP No. 1231/2013
SWP No. 1260/2013, SWP No. 1781/2013
SWP No. 2549/2013, SWP No. 2550/2013
SWP No. 2670/2013, SWP No. 330/2014
SWP No. 3285/2014, SWP No. 2763/2016
SWP No. 3050/2017, SWP No. 373/2018
SWP No. 392/2018, SWP No. 398/2018
CPSW No. 547/2018, SWP No. 614/2018
SWP No. 712/2018, CPSW No. 719/2018
CPSW No. 723/2018, CPSW No. 724/2018
SWP No. 805/2018, SWP No. 879/2018
SWP No. 880/2018, SWP No. 1645/2018
SWP No. 1652/2018, SWP No. 1669/2018
SWP No. 1687/2018, SWP No. 1719/2018
SWP No. 1720/2018, SWP No. 1731/2018
SWP No. 1739/2018, SWP No. 1745/2018
SWP No. 1749/2018, SWP No. 1751/2018
SWP No. 1770/2018, SWP No. 1773/2018
SWP No. 1781/2018, SWP No. 1788/2018
SWP No. 1789/2018, SWP No. 1831/2018
SWP No. 1836/2018, SWP No. 1839/2018
SWP No. 1849/2018, SWP No. 1865/2018
SWP No. 1880/2018, SWP No. 1898/2018
SWP No. 1920/2018, SWP No. 1930/2018
SWP No. 1945/2018, SWP No. 1962/2018
SWP No. 1975/2018, SWP No. 1992/2018
SWP No. 2014/2018, SWP No. 2033/2018
SWP No. 2112/2018, SWP No. 2138/2018
SWP No. 2209/2018, SWP No. 2560/2018
SWP No. 195/2019, CCP(S) No. 331/2019
CCP(S) No.627/2019,WP(C) No.1660/2019,
CCP(S) No. 96/2020,CCP(S) No. 210/2020,
CCP(S) No. 218/2021,CCP(S) No. 219/20211
CCP(S) No.220/2021,
WP(C) No. 470/ 2021,
CCP(S) No. 81/2022,
CCP(S) No. 247/2022,
WP(C) No. 927/2022,
WP(C) No. 2922/2023,
WP(C) No. 2946/2023
WP(C) No. 741/2013
a/w connected petitions
Sheraz Anjum and Ors.
Through:-
WP(C) No. 741/2013
a/w connected petitions
…. Appellant(s)/Petitioner(s)
Mr. Abhirash Sharma, Advocate
in SWP No. 741/2013.
Mr. R. K. S. Thakur, Advocate
in SWP No. 708/2010.
Mr. K. L. Pandita, Advocate
in SWP No. 732/2013, SWP No.
1260/2013, SWP No. 1781/2013, SWP
No. 373/2018, SWP No. 1669/2018,
SWP No. 1687/2018, SWP No.
1751/2018, SWP No. 1839/2018, SWP
No. 1880/2018, SWP No. 2209/2018,
SWP No. 1836/2018.
Mr. Mohsin Bhat, Advocate
in SWP No. 1068/2013, SWP No.
330/2014, CCP(S) No. 218/2021,
CCP(S) No. 219/2021, CCP(S) No.
220/2021.
Mr. Achal Sharma, Advocate
in SWP No. 2549/2013, SWP No.
1652/2018, SWP No. 1745/2018, SWP
No. 1788/2018, SWP No. 1849/2018.
Mr. Karman Singh Johal, Advocate
In SWP No. 392/2018, SWP No.
805/2018, SWP No. 879/2018.
Mr. Vivek Sharma, Advocate
In SWP No. 398/2018, SWP No.
2560/2018, WP(C) No. 2946/2023.
Mr. Mazher Ali Khan, Advocate
In SWP No. 1731/2018
Mr. N. D. Qazi, Advocate with
Mr. Amir Ajaz, Advocate
In SWP No. 1645/2018, SWP No.
1719/2018, SWP No. 1749/2018, SWP
No. 1770/2018, SWP No. 1945/2018,
SWP No. 2112/2018, CCP(S) No.
627/2019, WP(C) No. 2922/2023
Mr. Anil Kumar Verma, Advocate
In SWP No. 1669/2018
Mr. Rahul Raina, Advocate vice
Mr. S. S. Ahmed, Advocate
SWP No. 1920/2018.
Mr. Sunil Sethi, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Nahiem Sheikh, Advocate
In SWP No. 1669/2018.
Mr. Sheikh Anwar, Advocate vice
Mr. F. S. Butt, Advocate.
Mr. Sheraz Anjum, Advocate vice
Mr. Mazher Ali Khan, Advocate.
Mr. Mohd. Israr, Advocate.
Mr. A. K. Sharma, Advocate.
Mr. Gagan Kohli, Advocate.
Mr. Imran Ahmed Rather, Advocate.
Mr. Amullaya Gupta, Advocate vice
Mr. Ashish Sharma, Advocate.
V/s
…..Respondent(s)
State of J&K & Ors.
Through:-
Mr. Raman Sharma, Sr. Advocate with
Ms. Saliqa Sheikh, Advocate &
Mr. Kartikay Sharma, Advocate.
Ms. Rozina Afzal, Advocate.
CORAM:HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY DHAR, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1. The afore-titled writ petitions, except SWP Nos. 2138/2018
and 195/2019, involving common questions of fact and law,
are proposed to be taken up together for decision. The writ
petitioners, except those in the aforesaid two writ petitions,
have
been
engaged
as
Gram
Rozgar
Sevaks
(GRS)/Supporting Staff under the MGNREGA Scheme on
different dates. The petitioners in SWP Nos. 2138/2018 and
195/2019 have been engaged as supporting staff under the
same scheme on outsourcing basis. These two cases will be
taken up separately for determination.
2. In as many as 37 writ petitions out of the afore-titled writ
petitions, challenge has been thrown to Govt. Order No. 203
WP(C) No. 741/2013
a/w connected petitions
RD & PR of 2018 dated 09.08.2018, issued by the Secretary
to the Government, Department of Rural Development and
Panchayati Raj, whereby all engagements made under the
MGNREGA
Scheme
in
contravention
of
the
rules/guidelines/norms in vogue and without following due
procedure have been directed to be discontinued with
immediate effect. The Deputy Commissioners have been
asked to submit an action taken report in terms of the said
Government order. In the remaining writ petitions, the writ
petitioners have challenged fresh advertisement notices
issued for engagement of GRS/Supporting Staff and they
have also sought their continuance as GRS/Supporting Staff.
The writ petitioners have further sought regularization of
their services and a direction that their services should not be
discontinued.
3. It is the contention of the writ petitioners that they have been
working as GRS/Supporting Staff under the MGNREGA
Scheme for the past several decades and they have been
performing their duties to the entire satisfaction of the
respondent-department, and by now, most of them have
become overage. It is being contended that prior to the
issuance of Circular No. RD-NREGA of 2010 dated
WP(C) No. 741/2013
a/w connected petitions
14.12.2010, whereby guidelines regarding the procedure for
selection of Supporting Staff under the MGNREGA Scheme
were issued by the respondents, there were no guidelines in
vogue. Therefore, even if the engagements of some of the
writ petitioners may not be in accordance with the procedure
prescribed under the circular dated 14.12.2010 (supra), still
then, such engagements cannot be termed de hors the
procedure.
4. It is the further contention of the writ petitioners that it is not
legally permissible for the respondents to disengage the writ
petitioners, who are working on contractual basis, and
replace them with a similar arrangement. Thus, the fresh
advertisement
notices
issued
by
the
respondents
in
connection with engagement of GRS/Supporting Staff under
the MGNREGA Scheme on contractual basis are liable to be
quashed. It is also the contention of the writ petitioners that
the respondents cannot disengage their services on the basis
of an omnibus order issued in the form of the impugned
Government Order dated 09.08.2018, without following the
principles of natural justice and without giving the writ
petitioners an opportunity to show before the respondents
that their engagements are not de-hors the procedure. It has
WP(C) No. 741/2013
a/w connected petitions
been contended that even the orders of disengagement issued
pursuant to Government Order dated 09.08.2018 are not
sustainable in law, as no opportunity of hearing has been
given to the writ petitioners.
5. Another contention that has been raised by some of the writ
petitioners is that merely because some of them were
engaged on the recommendations of the Minister, MLAs or
any other authority does not make their engagements de hors
the procedure. It has been contended that, at the relevant time
when these engagements were made, the proper procedure
for selection was followed by the respondents and merely
because some authority had made recommendations in their
favour, their engagement is not rendered illegal.
6. The stand of the official respondents in all these writ
petitions is that the engagements of the petitioners as
GRS/Supporting Staff under the MGNREGA Scheme are
patently illegal, as no transparent procedure was followed
while making their engagements. Therefore, they have no
right to continue in service. It has been contended that, in the
cases of some of the writ petitioners, the orders of
engagement issued in their favour, which have been placed
on record, clearly reflect that they have been engaged on the
WP(C) No. 741/2013
a/w connected petitions
basis of the recommendations of one authority or the other
without following any procedure for their engagement. It has
been contended that even prior to the issuance of the
guidelines for engagement of GRS/Supporting Staff under
the MGNREGA Scheme, in terms of Circular dated
14.12.2010 (supra), the engagements of Supporting Staff
under the said scheme had to be made through a transparent
system, which, in the instant cases, has not been followed,
thereby rendering the engagements of the petitioners illegal.
According
to
the
engagement/appointment
official
made
respondents,
de-hors
the
any
prescribed
procedure or without following any transparent process is
void ab initio and, therefore, the writ petitioners are not even
entitled to right of hearing before their services are
discontinued.
7. I have heard learned counsel appearing for the parties and I
have gone through the pleadings and the record.
8. From the rival contentions of the parties, broadly the
following issues arise for determination by this Court:(i)
Whether prior to the issuance of guidelines by the
Government in terms of Circular No. 15-RD-NREGA
of 2010 dated 14.12.2010, it was open to the official
WP(C) No. 741/2013
a/w connected petitions
respondents
to
make
engagements
of
GRS/Supporting Staff under the MGNREGA Scheme
without following due procedure?
(ii)
Whether it is legally permissible for the official
respondents to replace the existing contractual
engagees with another set of contractual engagees in
the facts and circumstances of the present case?
(iii)
Whether impugned Govt. Order No. 203 RD&PR of
2018 dated 09.08.2018 is sustainable in law?
(iv)
Whether it is legally permissible for the official
respondents to disengage the services of the writ
petitioners and, if so, what procedure is required to
be followed while taking such action?
Issue No.(i): Whether prior to issuance of guidelines by the
Government in terms of circular No. 15 RD-NREGA of 2010
dated 14.12.2010 it was open to the official respondents to
make engagement of GRS/Supporting Staff under the
MGNREGA Scheme without following due procedure.
9. As has already been noted, the procedure and guidelines for
engagement of GRS/Supporting Staff under the MGNREGA
Scheme were prescribed for the first time vide Circular dated
14.12.2010 (supra). The scheme in the erstwhile State of
J&K was implemented in the year 2007. Admittedly, from
the year 2007 up to the year 2010, no guidelines were
WP(C) No. 741/2013
a/w connected petitions
prescribed regarding the procedure for engagement of
GRS/Supporting Staff under the MGNREGA Scheme. It is
the contention of the writ petitioners that, in the absence of
any guidelines, it was open to the official respondents to
choose
any
suitable
candidate
for
engagement
as
GRS/Supporting Staff under the MGNREGA Scheme. The
contention of the official respondents, on the other hand, is
that even in the absence of any prescribed procedure, they
were under an obligation to adopt a transparent procedure for
engaging the staff.
10.
The argument advanced by the writ petitioners in the
above context is absolutely fallacious. Merely because no
procedure was prescribed for engagement of GRS/Supporting
Staff under the MGNREGA Scheme prior to the year 2010, it
was not open to the authorities to adopt the policy of pick and
choose and confer the benefit of engagement on any person
of their choice. The Supreme Court has, way back in the year
1979, in the case of Ramana Dayaram Shetty Vs.
International Airport Authority of India and others,
(1979) 3 SC 489, made it clear that every action of the
executive government must be informed by reason and
should be free from arbitrariness. It has been held that the
WP(C) No. 741/2013
a/w connected petitions
very essence of the rule of law is to curb arbitrariness in the
exercise of power. It would be apt to quote the following
observations of the Supreme Court made in the said
judgment:“….It must, therefore, be taken to be the law that where
the Government is dealing with the public, whether by
way of giving jobs or entering into contracts or issuing
quotas or licences or granting other forms of largess,
the Government cannot act arbitrarily at its sweet will
and, like a private individual, deal with any person it
pleases, but its action must be in conformity with
standard or norms which is not arbitrary, irrational or
irrelevant. The power or discretion of the Government
in the matter of grant of largess including award of
jobs, contracts, quotas, licences etc., must be confined
and structured by rational, relevant and nondiscriminatory standard or norm and if the Government
departs from standard or norm in any particular case
or cases, the action of the Government would be liable
to be struck down, unless it can be shown by the
Government that the departure was not arbitrary, but
was based on some valid principle which in itself was
not irrational, unreasonable or discriminatory.”
11.
Again, the Supreme Court, in the case of State of
Orissa and another Vs. Mamata Mohanty, (2011) 3 SCC
436, while holding that no person, even on a temporary basis,
can be appointed without inviting applications from all
eligible candidates, observed as under:“19. Therefore, it is a settled legal proposition that no
person can be appointed even on a temporary or
ad hoc basis without inviting applications from all
eligible candidates. If any appointment is made by
merely inviting names from the employment
WP(C) No. 741/2013
a/w connected petitions
exchange or putting a note on the noticeboard,
etc. that will not meet the requirement of Articles
14 and 16 of the Constitution. Such a course
violates the mandates of Articles 14 and 16 of the
Constitution of India as it deprives the candidates
who are eligible for the post, from being
considered. A person employed in violation of
these provisions is not entitled to any relief
including salary. For a valid and legal
appointment mandatory compliance with the said
constitutional requirement is to be fulfilled. The
equality clause enshrined in Article 16 requires
that every such appointment be made by an open
advertisement as to enable all eligible persons to
compete on merit.”
12.
From the foregoing analysis of the legal position, it
becomes clear that even for temporary or contractual
appointments to be made by the Government or its
authorities, it is incumbent upon them to invite applications
from eligible candidates and adopt a transparent method.
Thus, even in the absence of any prescribed procedure prior
to the issuance of Circular dated 14.12.2010 (supra), it was
obligatory upon the official respondents to adopt some sort of
transparent procedure before making engagements of
GRS/Supporting Staff under the MGNREGA Scheme. They
could not do so on a pick-and-choose basis, as the same
would be violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution
of India and, hence, non-est in the eyes of law.
13.
Issue No.(i) is answered in the aforesaid terms.
WP(C) No. 741/2013
a/w connected petitions
Issue No.(ii): Whether it is legally permissible for the official
respondents to replace the existing contractual engagees with
another set of contractual engagees in the facts and
circumstances of the present case?
14.
There can be no quarrel with the proposition of law
that one set of contractual engagees cannot be replaced with
another set of contractual engagees. The law in this regard
has been laid down by the Supreme Court in the case of
Rattan Lal and others Vs. State of Haryana and others,
(1985) 4 SCC 43. It has been held in the said case that the
policy of ad hocism for a fairly long period breaches Articles
14 and 16 of the Constitution of India and that one set of adhoc employees cannot be replaced by another set of similar
employees. This principle of law has been consistently
followed by the Supreme Court from time to time.
15.
The question, however, that arises for determination in
these writ petitions is whether, even in a case where the
initial contractual engagements are de hors any transparent
procedure, the same can be continued by applying the
aforesaid principles of law. It is settled law that an
engagement/appointment made in violation of the principles
enshrined under Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution is void
ab initio, meaning thereby that such engagements are non-est
WP(C) No. 741/2013
a/w connected petitions
in the eyes of law. Therefore, in a case where contractual
engagements have been made de-hors any transparent
procedure or contrary to prescribed procedure, the said
engagements cannot be continued by applying the principle
that one contractual engagee cannot be replaced by another
contractual engagee. Applying this principle in cases of
illegal and backdoor appointments would amount to
perpetuating illegality, which is impermissible in law. Thus,
if it is found that the engagements of the writ petitioners were
contrary to the procedure prescribed under Circular dated
14.12.2010 (supra) or de-hors any procedure consistent with
Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India, they cannot
take shelter under the principle that one contractual engagee
cannot be replaced by another contractual engagee.
16.
Learned counsel appearing for the writ petitioners have,
by placing reliance upon the judgment of this Court in the
case of Yasir Arafat and others Vs. State of J&K and
others, [WP No. 2672/2012, decided on 14.12.2017],
contended that, in similar set of facts, this Court had come to
the rescue of the petitioners therein and quashed their
disengagement by holding that one temporary employee
cannot be substituted by another temporary employee.
WP(C) No. 741/2013
a/w connected petitions
17.
A careful perusal of the judgment passed by a
Coordinate Bench of this Court in Yasir Arafat and others
(supra) would reveal that the Court has not considered the
issue as to what would be the legal position if the initial
engagement of a contractual appointee, whose engagement is
sought to be replaced, is de hors the procedure recognized
under Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. The
said issue was not adverted to by the learned Single Judge
while passing the judgment dated 14.12.2017 in the aforesaid
case.
18.
The basic principle that one set of temporary engagees
cannot be substituted by another set of temporary engagees,
as laid down by the Supreme Court in the case of Rattan
Lal’s (supra), is dependent upon the condition that the initial
engagement must have been made after following the proper
procedure. A backdoor engagement cannot be perpetuated by
prohibiting the State authorities from advertising the posts in
accordance with the prescribed procedure.
19.
Issue No.(ii) is answered accordingly.
Issue No.(iii): Whether the impugned Govt. order No. 203
RD &PR of 2018 dated 09.08.2018 is sustainable in law?
20.
As already stated, a number of writ petitions have been
filed by the writ petitioners challenging the impugned order
WP(C) No. 741/2013
a/w connected petitions
dated 09.08.2018 (supra), whereby a general direction has
been issued for the disengagement of those contractual
engagees
whose
engagements
have
been
made
in
contravention of the rules/norms/guidelines and without
following due procedure of law. Even prior to the issuance of
impugned order dated 09.08.2018, a communication was
addressed by the Under Secretary to the Government, Rural
Development Department, on 23.04.2013 to the Director,
Rural Development Department, for holding an inquiry into
the illegal engagements and stopping the salaries of illegal
appointees. The said communication is also the subject
matter of challenge in a couple of writ petitions.
21.
The first question that falls for determination is whether
an order in the nature of order dated 09.08.2018 (supra) or in
the nature of communication dated 23.04.2013(supra) could
have been issued by the respondents. The objection raised by
the writ petitioners to the issuance of the impugned order and
the communication is that omnibus orders/directions could
not have been issued.
22.
So far as the jurisdiction and authority of the
respondents to issue impugned order dated 09.08.2018
(supra) or to issue communication dated 23.04.2013 (supra)
WP(C) No. 741/2013
a/w connected petitions
is concerned, the same cannot be questioned. By virtue of the
impugned order and the communication (supra), the
authorities of the official respondents are only seeking to
tackle the problem of backdoor appointments. A person who
has been appointed/engaged de-hors the prescribed procedure
or in violation of any transparent procedure cannot claim a
vested right to continue in service. As already discussed
hereinbefore, an engagement made de-hors the rules or
contrary to a transparent procedure is non-est in the eyes of
law. Such an engagee does not have any right to continue in
service. Therefore, neither the intention nor the jurisdiction
of the respondents to issue impugned order dated 09.08.2018
or impugned communication dated 23.04.2013 can be
questioned.
23.
However, the issue that arises for determination is
whether, on the basis of these general directions, the services
of the writ petitioners could have been discontinued and their
salaries stopped. In this regard, the writ petitioners have
contended that their services could not have been
discontinued, nor their salaries could have been withheld,
without following the principles of natural justice and
WP(C) No. 741/2013
a/w connected petitions
without holding an inquiry into the nature of their
engagements.
24.
Per contra, learned AAG has argued that, because the
engagements of the petitioners were made in violation of the
procedure prescribed under Circular dated 14.12.2010 or
contrary to any transparent procedure, their engagements are
void ab initio. Therefore, no notice is required to be issued to
the petitioners. It is being contended that no inquiry is
required to be held before disengaging services of backdoor
engagees. To support this contention, learned AAG has
placed reliance upon judgment of a Coordinate Bench of this
Court in the case of Shameem Ahmad Shah and others Vs.
State of J&K and others, [SWP No. 667/2017, decided on
09.05.2024].
25.
There can be no quarrel with the legal proposition that
an engagement/appointment made without following the
mandate of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India is
illegal and non est in the eyes of law and, therefore, the
beneficiaries of such appointment/engagement are not
entitled
to
an
opportunity
of
hearing
before
their
disengagement. However, the question that arises for
determination is whether, in the present petitions, there is any
WP(C) No. 741/2013
a/w connected petitions
admission on the part of any of the writ petitioners that their
engagements are illegal or backdoor. If there is an admission
on the part of the writ petitioners, or some of them, on this
aspect of the matter, then certainly they are not entitled to
right of hearing before their disengagement.
26.
Learned AAG has referred to the engagement orders
issued in favour of some of the writ petitioners, which they
have placed on record along with their writ petitions, wherein
it has been mentioned that their engagements have been made
on
the
recommendations
of
Ministers/MLAs/high
government functionaries. On this basis, it is being contended
that, at least in their cases, there is no requirement to hold
any inquiry or to give them an opportunity of hearing.
27.
In the above context, if we have a look at the pleadings
and the engagement orders of the writ petitioners, it is
revealed that even though, in some cases, the engagement
orders
do
refer
to
recommendations
made
by
Ministers/MLAs/high Government functionaries, yet the writ
petitioners have specifically pleaded that they had applied
pursuant to an advertisement notice issued by the engaging
authorities.
Therefore,
merely
because
some
Ministers/MLAs/ Government functionaries may have made
WP(C) No. 741/2013
a/w connected petitions
recommendations in their favour, their engagements do not
become illegal if they had been engaged after inviting
applications from eligible candidates. There are also
pleadings of the writ petitioners in some cases wherein they
have specifically pleaded that a selection committee was
constituted and their engagements were made on the basis of
proper selection even though the guidelines issued vide
Circular dated 14.12.2010 were not in place.
28.
In the aforesaid circumstances, the issue as to whether
or not the engagements of the writ petitioners are illegal, or
in contravention of the rules/norms/guidelines, becomes a
matter that requires to be examined in individual cases. The
respondents, therefore, are not legally justified in dispensing
with the services of the petitioners on the basis of the general
Government Order dated 09.08.2018, nor they are justified in
withholding their salaries on the basis of the general
communication dated 23.04.2013. Each case has to be
examined and analyzed by the respondents before taking a
decision with regard to the withholding of salary or
disengagement of the writ petitioners. They cannot be
disengaged, nor their salaries can be withheld, by way of a
WP(C) No. 741/2013
a/w connected petitions
general order on the ground that their engagements are in
contravention of the rules/norms/guidelines.
29.
Learned AAG, while relying upon the judgment of the
Supreme Court in the case of State of West Bengal and
others Vs. Baishakhi Bhattacharya (Chatterjee) and
others, 2025 SCC Online SC 2330 has contended that, in
the said case, the Supreme Court upheld the cancellation of
the entire selection process relating to teachers and other staff
initiated by the West Bengal Central School Service
Commission. It has been contended that, in the said
judgment, even the direction regarding refund of salary by
tainted candidates was upheld, as their appointments were
found to be the result of fraud.
30.
The principle of law laid down by the Supreme Court in
the aforesaid judgment, being a binding precedent, has to be
followed in all cases. However, if we have a look at the
judgment passed by the Supreme Court in the said case, the
directions issued therein were issued on the basis of the
findings of the inquiry committee and the investigation
conducted by the CBI. It was only on the strength of these
findings that the Supreme Court upheld the directions of the
High Court to the aforesaid extent.
WP(C) No. 741/2013
a/w connected petitions
31.
In the present case, it is not even the contention of the
official respondents that they have held any inquiry into the
nature of engagement of the writ petitioners. No report of any
enquiry relating to nature of engagement of the writ
petitioners has been placed on record, nor there is any such
report available in the record produced by the official
respondents. In fact, the official respondents have not
undertaken any exercise to ascertain the actual nature of the
engagements of the writ petitioners. Without undertaking an
exercise to ascertain the nature of the engagements of the
writ petitioners in which they are required to be associated,
their services cannot be dispensed with by way of a general
Government Order. The official respondents were obliged
either to hold an in-house inquiry into the nature of the
engagements of the writ petitioners after allowing them to
present their version before the enquiry committee or to issue
individual notices to the writ petitioners, calling upon them to
show cause as to why their engagements should not be
terminated on the ground that the same are illegal. It is true
that an illegally appointed employee is not entitled to the
benefit of the principles of natural justice; however, to arrive
at the conclusion that a particular engagement is illegal either
WP(C) No. 741/2013
a/w connected petitions
an enquiry has to be held or an opportunity of hearing has to
be given to the concerned engagee, unless the illegality of the
appointment is an admitted fact.
32.
The writ petitioners have contended that their
engagements cannot be terminated without holding a regular
departmental inquiry. Reliance in this regard has been placed
upon the judgment of a Coordinate Bench of this Court in the
case titled Feroz Ahmed Sheikh and others Vs. UT of J&K
and
another,
[WP(C)
No.
2260/2022,
decided
on
16.12.2023].
33.
So far as the status of a contractual appointee is
concerned, it cannot be equated with that of an employee
holding a civil post. A contractual engagee is not entitled to
the protection available to a regularly appointed employee as
Article 311 of the Constitution of India is not applicable to a
contractual appointee. The service conditions of a contractual
appointee are governed by the contract of appointment and
not by the Civil Services Regulations or the relevant
provisions of the Constitution. Before disengaging a
contractual appointee, he can, at best, claim adherence to the
principles of natural justice or to a fair procedure. A
WP(C) No. 741/2013
a/w connected petitions
contractual engagee cannot insist upon a regular departmental
inquiry before his services are disengaged.
34.
In any case, we are dealing with a situation where the
official respondents claim that the very engagements of the
writ petitioners are illegal and backdoor, being de-hors the
rules or contrary to fair procedure. If the contention of the
official respondents is found to be correct, the engagements
of writ petitioners cannot be protected. However, before
disengaging them in view of the dispute raised by the writ
petitioners on the factual aspects of the case, either an inhouse inquiry has to be conducted by the official respondents
to ascertain the nature of the engagements of the petitioners,
in which they are permitted to participate or individual
notices have to be issued to the writ petitioners calling upon
them to present the material in support of their contentions.
35.
The issue is answered accordingly.
36.
In writ petitions bearing SWP Nos. 2138/2018 and
195/2019, the writ petitioners have been engaged by the
official respondents on outsourcing basis. This is clear from
the engagement orders issued in favour of the writ
petitioners, copies whereof, have been placed on record.
Since the writ petitioners have not been appointed pursuant to
WP(C) No. 741/2013
a/w connected petitions
any contract between them and the official respondents, as
their engagement has been made through a contractor, who
has not even been made party to the writ petitions, they
cannot claim any relief against the official respondents. There
is no privity of contract between the writ petitioners and the
official respondents. Thus, the writ petitioners have neither
locus standi to challenge the Government Order dated
09.08.2018 nor they can challenge the action of the official
respondents in putting the posts of GRS/Supporting Staff to
fresh advertisement. Both these writ petitions are, therefore,
liable to be dismissed.
37.
In view of the foregoing discussion, the following
directions are issued:(1)
Writ petitions bearing SWP No. 2138/2018 and SWP
No.195/2019 are dismissed.
(2)
Rest of the writ petitions are disposed of by holding as
under:(i)
Prior to the issuance of circular dated 14.12.2010,
the official respondents were obliged to follow a
fair and transparent procedure for engagement of
GRS/Supporting staff under MGNREGA Scheme;
(ii)
The legality and validity of the impugned
Government Order No. 203 RD & PR of 2018
WP(C) No. 741/2013
a/w connected petitions
dated
09.08.2018
and
the
impugned
communication dated 23.04.2013 is upheld.
(iii)
Before taking any action against the writ
petitioners on the basis of impugned Government
Order No. 203 RD & PR of 2018 dated
09.08.2018 and impugned communication dated
23.04.2013, the official respondents shall either
hold an in-house inquiry to determine the nature
of engagement of the writ petitioners, in which the
writ petitioners shall be permitted to make
representations and produce documents in support
of their claims, or, in the alternative, issue
individual notices to the writ petitioners calling
upon them to show cause as to why their
engagements should not be terminated on the
ground of illegality.
(iv)
In the case of those writ petitioners whose initial
engagements are found to have been made in
accordance with a fair procedure or the prescribed
norms, they shall be allowed to continue in
service, and their legitimately earned salaries shall
also be released in their favour. Besides this, any
fresh advertisement notice issued for filling up the
posts held by such writ petitioners shall stand
quashed.
(v)
In the cases of those writ petitioners whose
engagements are found to be illegal or de hors the
prescribed norms or fair procedure, the official
respondents shall be at liberty to disengage them
from service, and such writ petitioners shall not be
WP(C) No. 741/2013
a/w connected petitions
entitled to any wages. However, any wages
already paid to such petitioners pursuant to the
directions of this Court shall not be recovered by
the official respondents.
38.
The petitions stand disposed of along with connected
CM(s), if any.
CPSW No. 547/2018, CPSW No. 719/2018
CPSW No. 723/2018, CPSW No. 724/2018
CCP(S) No. 331/2019,CCP(S) No.627/2019,
CCP(S) No. 96/2020,CCP(S) No. 210/2020,
CCP(S) No. 218/2021, CCP(S) No. 219/2021
CCP(S) No.220/2021, CCP(S) No. 81/2022,
CCP(S) No. 247/2022.
39.
Since the main writ petitions stand disposed of, as such,
the contempt petitions arising out of the interim orders passed
in the said writ petitions do not survive and are accordingly
closed.
40.
The contempt petitions stand disposed of.
(Sanjay Dhar)
Judge
Jammu
22.10.2026
Madan Verma-Secy
Whether order is speaking?
Whether order is reportable?
WP(C) No. 741/2013
a/w connected petitions
MADAN LAL VERMA
2026.10.22 16:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Yes
Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review