Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:MLHC:31
Serial No. 07
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
Crl.Rev.P. No.15 of 2023
Date of Order: 03.02.2026
Shri. Shngain Lamare, 39 years
Son of Late Brin Chyrmang,
Resident of Umkyrpong Village,
East Jaintia Hills District,
Khliehriat, Meghalaya.
…..Petitioner
-VERSUSThe State of Meghalaya,
Represented by its Public Prosecutor
…..Respondent
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice B. Bhattacharjee, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
: Mr. P. Bora, Sr.Adv with
Ms. K. Decruse, Adv
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. K.P. Bhattacharjee, GA
JUDGMENT (Oral)
1.
Heard Mr. P. Bora, learned Senior counsel assisted by Ms. K.
Decruse, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner and Mr. K.P.
Bhattacharjee, learned GA appearing for the State-respondent.
2.
This revision petition has been preferred by the petitioner against
the impugned order dated 20.06.2023 passed in Misc.Case No.60 of 2022
arising out of Sessions Case No.2 of 2015 u/s 302/34 IPC, whereby the
prayer of the petitioner for recalling the prosecution witnesses PW-1,
2026:MLHC:31
PW-2, PW-3 and PW-5 was rejected with a cost of Rs.10,000/-.
3.
The petitioner, who is an accused in Sessions Case No.2 of 2015,
filed an application before the Trial Court u/s 311 CrPC on 12.09.2022
registered as Misc.Case No.60 of 2022 seeking recalling of the
prosecution witnesses namely, Smti. Ribhamiki Salahe (PW-1), Smti.
Kylluidki Salahe (PW-2), Shri. Suk Lyngdoh (PW-3) and Shri. Praiwess
Salahe (PW-5) for cross-examination. The prosecution filed a show
cause/objection to the said application. The application was heard on
07.03.2023 and the learned Sessions Judge by order dated 20.06.2023
rejected the prayer by holding that the petitioner had chosen to repeatedly
exert his right which amounted to abuse of the process of the Court.
Being aggrieved, the petitioner has preferred this revision petition before
this Court.
4.
The learned Senior counsel appearing for the petitioner, in his
submission elaborated the fact of the case that pursuant to the lodging of
the FIR dated 26.05.2014, the petitioner had surrendered before the
ADM, Khliehriat Court on 26.06.2014. On 24.09.2014, the petitioner
completed 90 days of detention but, still continued to remain in custody.
The charge-sheet in the case was submitted on 10.11.2024. PW-1 was
examined and discharged on 10.09.2015, PW-2 and PW-3 were examined
and discharged on 14.09.2015 and PW-5 was examined and discharged
28.09.2015. Thereafter, the petitioner’s statement u/s 313 CrPC was
recorded on 29.08.2016. On 21.04.2020, the petitioner was granted bail
by the High Court and on 24.04.2020 he was released from judicial
custody. The learned Senior counsel submits that the petitioner has taken
a plea of alibi in his defense and for that purpose recalling of PW-1, PW2, PW-3 and PW-5 is absolutely necessary. He submits that the petitioner
is ready to bear the cost of recalling and re-examination of the said
witnesses. He also submits that the defense intends to put only few
2026:MLHC:31
questions to the said witnesses on their recall which is not likely to cause
any harassment and inconvenience and will also not result in any delay of
the proceedings. By placing reliance on the case of Varsha Garg v. State
of Madhya Pradesh & ors, (2023) 19 SCC 646, the learned Senior
counsel submits that the prayer of the petitioner for recalling the
witnesses should not be refused as the right of the accused to a fair trial is
constitutionally protected under Article 21 of the Constitution of India. It
is therefore, prayed that the impugned order dated 20.06.2023 be set aside
and quashed and necessary directions may be passed allowing recalling of
the witnesses.
5.
The learned GA, on the other hand, opposes the contentions raised
on behalf of the petitioner and submits that there is nothing wrong in the
order passed by the learned Sessions Judge rejecting the prayer for
recalling as the application filed by the petitioner was nothing but an
abuse of process of law. He submits that, on an earlier occasion also, the
petitioner had filed an application for recalling some of the prosecution
witnesses including PW-1 and PW-2, which was rejected by order dated
23.01.2020. The petitioner did not challenge the said order dated
23.01.2020, instead filed a fresh application in total abuse of process of
law. He submits that recalling of the witnesses, at this stage, is totally
unjustified and would not serve any purpose as the witnesses sought to be
recalled were examined and discharged long back in the year 2015 and
the petitioner’s statement u/s 313 CrPC was recorded as far back as on
29.08.2016. He further submits that the defense witnesses adduced by the
petitioner was closed on 21.12.2021 and hence, the prayer for recalling of
the prosecution witnesses is aimed at stalling the proceedings. The
learned GA has also taken this Court to the details of the facts recorded
by the Sessions Judge in justifying his order and submits that in the
backdrop of the said facts, it is clear that filing of the application for
2026:MLHC:31
recalling is not aimed at serving justice. He, therefore, submits that there
is no merit in the present case and the revision petition is liable to be
dismissed.
6.
Heard submissions advanced on behalf of the rival parties and
also perused the materials on record. As the question of recalling of
witness in exercise of power u/s 311 CrPC primarily vests on the
discretion of the Trial Court, it is imperative for this Court to first take
into consideration the details of the reasoning recorded in the impugned
order dated 20.06.2023 by the learned Sessions Judge while rejecting the
prayer for recalling made by the petitioner.
7.
The facts recorded by the learned Sessions Judge, which are not
sought to be disputed by the petitioner before this Court, reveals that 24
prosecution witnesses were examined during the course of the trial and
the statement of the petitioner u/s 313 CrPC was recorded on 29.08.2016.
The petitioner, thereafter, was given an opportunity to adduce defence
witness. On the failure of the petitioner to bring any defence witness, the
opportunity was closed vide order dated 18.09.2017 and the matter was
posted for final argument. On 26.07.2019, the petitioner filed
Crl.Misc.Application No.9 of 2019 before the trial Court seeking
recalling of PW-1, Pw-2, PW-16, PW-20 and PW-22 and on the same
date
filed
another
Crl.Misc.Application
No.8/2019
praying
for
summoning additional defense witnesses, without disclosing the fact that
the opportunity was closed by order dated 18.09.2017. The application
for summoning additional defense witnesses was allowed, however, the
application seeking recalling of PW-1, Pw-2, PW-16, PW-20 and PW-22
was rejected by the trial Court by common order dated 23.01.2020. The
order of rejection attained finality as the same was not challenged before
any higher forum.
8.
It transpires from the record that PW-1 was examined and
2026:MLHC:31
discharged on 10.09.2015, PW-2 and PW-3 were examined and
discharged on 14.09.2015 and PW-5 was examined and discharged
28.09.2015. There is nothing on record to justify as to why it took 7
(seven) years for the petitioner for filing Misc.Case No.60 of 2022
seeking recalling of the said witnesses. Moreover, the order dated
20.06.2023 reveals that Misc.Case No.60 of 2022 was preferred on the
same ground basing on which Crl.Misc.Application No.9 of 2019 was
filed. The petitioner has failed to assign any fresh or new ground for
filing the successive application. It is also not the case of the petitioner
that he was not provided effective legal assistance during the course of
the trial. In fact, it appears that he was represented by a counsel of his
choice and the counsel who filed the Crl.Misc.Application No.9 of 2019
has also filed the Misc.Case No.60 of 2022. The prayer of the petitioner,
as such, appears to be frivolous and vexatious.
9.
The plea of alibi taken at the trial by an accused essentially
requires to be proved by adducing defence witness. However, there is no
law which debars an accused from establishing his plea of alibi from the
evidence of prosecution witness; but after entering defense, if the accused
fails to establish his plea, he cannot, as a matter of right, revert to the
prosecution witness seeking re-examination. The record reveals that the
petitioner, in the instant case, was given an opportunity to establish his
defense and 2 defence witnesses were examined on 06.02.2020 and
04.08.2020. Further, there is no cogent explanation by the petitioner for
the delay in filing the fresh application seeking recall of witnesses,
particularly, after significant progress of the trial. In the above situation, it
is clear that the subsequent application for the same witnesses without
fresh ground after prior rejection is also not aimed at advancing the cause
of justice.
10.
The learned Sessions Judge, while passing the order dated
2026:MLHC:31
20.06.2023 has taken into consideration the proposition of law laid down
by the Apex Court in Varsha Garg (supra) and UT of Dadra and Haveli
& ors v. Fatih Sinh and Mohon Singh Chauhan (2006) 7 SCC 529. The
learned Senior counsel in his argument has not pointed out any illegality
or infirmity in the recording of the fact and the reasoning of the learned
Sessions Judge. Although, reliance was placed on the decision of Varsha
Garg (supra) on behalf of the petitioner before this Court, nothing was
pointed out to project that the impugned order was passed in utter
disregard of the proposition of law laid down therein.
11.
In view of the discussion made above, the petitioner has failed to
make out a case for interference by this Court in exercise of its revisional
jurisdiction. The petition, as such, is devoid of merit and accordingly
stands dismissed.
Judge
Meghalaya
03.02.2026
“Shrity,PS”
CH MOMIN
Date: 2026.02.03 19:13:04 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review