Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
W.A. NO.3311 OF 2024
In the matter of an appeal under Rule 6 of Chapter-III of the Rules
of the High Court of Orissa read with Article 4 of Orissa High
Court Order, 1948 and Clause-10 of the Letters Patent of Patna
High Court from the order dated 11.11.2024 passed by learned
Single Judge in W.P.(C) No.27679 of 2024.
-------------….
Shiwangi Mahato
Appellant
-versus….
State of Odisha and others
Respondents
Advocates Appeared in this case
For Appellants
-
For Respondents -
M/s. Manoj Kumar Mohanty,
T. Pradhan, M. Mohanty, A. Mohanty
& S. Das Pattanaik, Advocates
Mr. Subha Bikash Panda,
Addl. Government Advocate
[R- 1 to 3]
M/s. Biswajeet Patnaik, G.M. Rath,
S.S. Padhy, M.A. Bohidar & P.
Mohanty, Advocates
[Intended Intervenor]
-----------
CORAM
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE DIXIT KRISHNA SHRIPAD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE CHITTARANJAN DASH
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Date of Hearing & Judgment : 28.01.2026
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------PER KRISHNA S. DIXIT,J.
This Intra-Court Appeal is directed against a learned Single Judge’s
order dated 11.11.2024, whereby Appellant’s WP(C) No. 12764 of 2024
has been dismissed. In the said Writ Petition, the Appellant had sought for
the quashment of Order No.12925 dated 05.11.2024 issued by Respondent
No.3 coupled with a direction to appoint him as the Assistant Professor
(Anaesthesiology) in MKCG Medical College, Berhampur.
2.
Learned counsel for the Appellant vehemently argues that pursuant to
the Advertisement dated 08.05.2024, his client & others faced a walk-in
interview and came to be selected. Accordingly, the selection list dated
14.05.2024 came to be published wherein the Appellant figured at serial
No.4; however, two of the selected candidates who were issued with
appointment orders, did not turn up for joining and eventually the
vacancies remained intact; a fresh advertisement was issued on 05.11.2024
instead of appointing the Appellant to one of the vacancies; therefore,
there is error apparent on the face of the record in negativing the Writ
Petition despite quashment of the fresh advertisement.
3.
Learned AGA appearing for the official Respondents resists the
Appeal making submission in justification of the impugned order of
learned Single Judge and the reasons on which it has been constructed. He
contends that the reasoning of learned Single Judge is unassailable, more
particularly because the employment in the public sector has to be
accomplished on normative basis, i.e., by way of regular recruitment, and
not by contractual engagement.
4.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and having perused the
Appeal papers, we decline indulgence in the matter on the following
grounds:
4.1. The process of rule-making is a protracted and complicated one
involving consultation with various authorities and compliance with
manifold formalities.
It cannot also be disputed that exigencies of
administration at times require immediate creation of service of posts and
any procrastination in that behalf cannot but prove detrimental to the
proper and efficient functioning of public departments, observed the Apex
Court in Bhakta Ramegowda v. State of Karnataka, (1997) 2 SCC 661. It
is now beyond any controversy that appointments may be regulated either
by Executive Instructions or Statutory Rules. Existence of statutory rules
is not a condition precedent for appointing an eligible and fit person to a
post. The Executive Power is co-extensive with the Legislative Power of
the State and under Article 162 the State could create civil posts and fill
them up according to the Executive Instructions consistent with Articles
14 & 16 of the Constitution. It is also settled law that once statutory rules
have been promulgated, the appointment has to be in accordance with such
rules.
4.2. The reason why there are safeguards in regular appointment is that
there should not be any scope for favouritism or other extraneous
consideration where persons, only on merit, are recruited through a fully
transparent procedure established by law, i.e., the rules of recruitment. If
the persons who are employed on contract basis, are given equal benefit
and status as regular employees, it would amount to giving premium and
sanction to a process which is totally arbitrary, inasmuch as there have
already been statutory rules of recruitment in the departments that have
been promulgated under Proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution of
India. It is not disputed before us that the extant rules of recruitment do not
provide for contractual engagement. We fail to understand how the State
agency could go for contractual appointment without exploring the regular
recruitment process ordained by law, as has happened in this case. It
needs no reiteration that all appointments in the Government and public
sector have to be done only by a duly constituted recruitment process,
subject to all just exceptions recognized by the recruitment rules.
4.3. A cryptic advertisement for contractual appointment followed by a
half-hearted walk-in interview conducted by persons not answering the
description of selection committee under the extant rules, would not give a
legally enforceable right to appointment to anyone, be it contractual or
otherwise. We are coming across a plethora of such cases wherein the
dispute relates to contractual recruitment, in the face of regular recruitment
rules. We harshly deprecate the practice of contractual appointments in
public employment, that are undertaken by the ‘authorities that be’
flouting the normative recruitment process. Posts are created in several
departments/establishments as a matter of State policy; the appointment to
these posts cannot be made except by the known modes. Public
advertisement is the first step; then comes the written examination;
thereafter, the interview. Doing away any of these fundamentals, would
mar the end product, namely, the appointment itself. A walk-in interview
in any circumstance cannot be the sole criteria for adjudging eligibility,
qualification, competition and suitability of the candidates. In Lila Dhar
v. State of Rajasthan, AIR 1981 SC 1777 it is observed as under:
“What is the ideal mode of selection to a public service, by written
examination, by oral test (viva voce), or by a combination of both ?...
the written examination assesses the man’s intellect and the interview
tests the man himself and ‘the twain shall meet’ for a proper
selection…”
4.4. State and its instrumentalities under Article 12 of the Constitution,
being Model Employers, vide Bhupendra Nath Hazarika v. State of
Assam, AIR 2013 SC 234, have to undertake recruitment process only in
accordance with the extant Rules of Recruitment, that intend to achieve
transparency, fairness & objectivity. That is defeated if walk-in interview
is adopted as the mode of selection. Walk-in interview gives scope for the
allegation that things have been accomplished in shrouded mystery and
that shakes confidence of the public in the recruitment process. It is said,
sunlight is a true detergent. When the world is moving towards
transparency, things that are done in a non-transparent way, become
vulnerable for challenge. In the case of walk-in interview, who
interviewed whom and how would remain enigmatic. However, such a
mode may be adopted if the rules permit, is also true. In the case at hand,
no such rule is cited before us. It is relevant to reproduce what the Apex
Court observed in Praveen Singh v. State of Punjab, (2000) 8 SCC 633:
“…..Does it say that an interview should be the only method of
assessment of the merits of the candidates? The answer obviously
cannot be in the affirmative. The vice of manipulation, we are afraid
cannot be ruled out. Though interview undoubtedly is a significant
factor in the matter of appointments, it plays a strategic role but it also
allows creeping in of a lacuna rendering the appointments illegitimate.
Obviously it is an important factor but ought not to be the sole guiding
factor since reliance thereon only may lead to a ‘sabotage of the purity
of the proceedings’….”
4.5 The impugned order of the learned Single Judge inarticulately
reflects what has been discussed hereinabove and therefore, the same
cannot be faltered. It gives the scope for the State to undertake the regular
recruitment process on a war footing. Merely because the advertisement
for contractual employment has been quashed, that would not give an
indefeasible right of appointment to a candidate who has been selected in a
mode unknown to regular recruitment rules. We hasten to add that there is
scope for improvement even in heaven, said Oscar Wilde (1854-1900).
That applies to the realm of judgments too.
4.6. There is one more significant aspect that cannot go uncommented
upon: Vacancies in the sanctioned posts in the Government & in public
sector do periodically arise & accumulate because of death, decease,
retirement, removal, resignation or otherwise. It is a continuous process.
However, we often come across poignant situation wherein no regular and
periodic recruitment process is undertaken. That would obviously result
into a chunk of eligible & qualified candidates who belong to reserved &
unreserved categories, is rendered age barred. Such unfortunate candidates
will have a lot of heart burn and that would not augur well to any system.
Thousands of vacancies in this State continue for an unreasonably long
period. PILs are also pending in this regard. Huge vacancy positions create
difficulties to the governance, needs no research for vouching. This can be
avoided if recruitment is undertaken in the public employment, with fair
degree of regularity. Otherwise, the eligible & aspiring candidates would
become age barred. The employment under a State entity is a public asset
and every citizen has a right to apply for it, vide The Municipal Council
v. K. Jayaram, 2026 LiveLaw (SC) 38. It is high time that the Government
and other concerned agencies to look into the matter and swing into swift
action.
In the above circumstances, this Appeal fails, of course, with the
observations hereinabove made.
Registry to send a copy of this judgment by speed post to:
(i)
The Chief Secretary,
Government of Odisha,
Bhubaneswar.
(ii) The Secretary,
Odisha Public Service Commission,
Cuttack
Web copy of the judgment to be acted upon by all concerned.
(Dixit Krishna Shripad)
Judge
(Chittaranjan Dash)
Judge
Orissa High Court, Cuttack
The 28th day of January, 2026 /Madhusmita
Digitally Signed
Signed by: MADHUSMITA MALLICK
Designation: Jr. Stenographer
Reason: Authentication
Location: HIGH COURT OF ORISSA, CUTTACK
Date: 29-Jan-2026 16:55:37
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review