Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
MACA No.1290 of 2025
CNR No. ODHC010884542025
.....
Alugulu Raj Kumari Dora &
Appellants
Ors.
Represented by Adv. Soubhagya Kumar
Dash
The Divisional Manager,
Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd.,
Ganjam & Anr.
-versus.....
Respondents
Represented by Adv. Prasanta Kumar
Mahali (for R-1)
CORAM:
THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ADITYA KUMAR
MOHAPATRA
ORDER
13.08.2026
Order No.
02.
1.
This matter is taken up through Hybrid Mode.
2.
Learned counsel appearing for the claimant-Appellants, at
the outset, files a memo indicating therein that the Appellant No.2,
namely, Alugulu Pantulu @ Patulu Dora has died on 29.12.2025.
The memo further reveals that the legal heirs of the deceasedAppellant No.2 are already on record.
3.
The memo is accepted and taken on record. Accordingly, the
name of Appellant No.2 be deleted from the appeal record.
4.
Heard learned counsel appearing for the claimant-Appellants
as well as the learned counsel appearing for the Respondent No.1Page 1 of 7.
Insurance Company. Perused the appeal memo as well as the
impugned judgment dated 25.09.2025 passed in MAC No.67 of
2023 by the learned Additional District Judge-cum-8th MACT,
Aska, Ganjam.
5.
The factual background of the claimant-Appellants’ case, in
short, is that on 26.06.2023, around 6 AM, while the deceased was
returning to his village, on the State Highway, by riding his
motorcycle bearing Registration No.OD-07-AL-7118, he met with
an accident near Reliance Tower at village Borda. The offending
vehicle, a bus, was coming from the opposite direction and was
being driven in a rash and negligent manner by the driver of the
vehicle. As a result of the accident, the deceased succumbed to the
injuries at CHC, Badagada where he was shifted to for his
treatment. A police case was initiated with the registration of
Badagada P.S Case No.299 dated 26.06.2023 under Sections
279/304-A of IPC. In the said police case, the driver of the
offending vehicle was charge-sheeted.
6.
The claimant-Appellants, who are the family members of the
deceased, approached the Tribunal by filing the abovenoted MAC
No.67 of 2023 claiming a compensation of Rs.40,00,000/- for the
death of the deceased in the road accident. In the claim application,
the claimants have stated that the deceased was working as a Senior
Electrician in D.D Builders Ltd., Bhubaneswar and he was getting
salary of Rs.26,800/- per month. The pleadings further reveal that
the offending vehicle was plying with valid documents including a
valid insurance.
7.
Despite valid service of notice on the owner of the vehicle,
the Respondent No.1-Owner did not appear before the learned
Page 2 of 7.
Tribunal. As a result, he was set ex-parte vide order dated
22.01.2025. The learned Tribunal after recording evidence from the
side of the claimants as well as the insurance company awarded a
total compensation of Rs.15,12,040/- along with interest @ 6% per
annum from the date of filing of the claim application. Being
aggrieved
by
the
aforesaid
judgment
awarding
a
lower
compensation, the claimants have approached this Court with a
prayer for enhancement of the awarded amount.
8.
Learned counsel appearing for the claimants-Appellants, at
the outset, contended that the quantum of compensation has been
assessed by taking into consideration the monthly income of the
deceased to be Rs.10,350/-, result in the computation of a lower
compensation amount, which has seriously caused prejudiced to the
claimants. He further contended that the income of the deceased has
not been properly assessed and that the impugned award has caused
injustice to the family of the deceased, who are the claimantsAppellants before this Court.
9.
While assailing the quantum of compensation fixed by the
learned Tribunal, learned counsel for the claimants-Appellants
submitted before this Court that the deceased was working as a
Senior Electrician with a construction company. It was further
submitted that the deceased was getting a salary of Rs.26,800/- per
month. However, such income of the deceased, as has been pleaded
in the claim application, has been disbelieved by the learned
Tribunal while assessing the income of the deceased to fix the total
quantum of compensation. He further contended that the learned
Tribunal has committed an illegality by assessing the income of the
deceased notionally by taking into consideration the total income of
Page 3 of 7.
the deceased to be Rs.10,350/- that is @ Rs.345/- per day and, as
such, the Tribunal has arrived at an erroneous conclusion that the
annual income of the deceased was Rs.1,24,000/-. With regard to
the application of the 16 multiplier in terms of the judgment of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Smt. Sarla Verma & Ors. vs.
Delhi Transport Corporation & Anr., reported in (2009) 43 OCR
(SC) 349. Learned counsels appearing for both sides have no
objection to the same.
10.
The only dispute that survives for determination in the
present appeal is with regard to the fixation of the monthly as well
as annual income of the deceased. Learned counsel for the
claimants-Appellants contended that although it was pleaded and
proved that the monthly income of the deceased was Rs.26,800/which he was getting as salary from the company where he was
employed, the learned Tribunal has disbelieved the same and taken
a lower income on notional basis by calculating the income of the
deceased @ Rs.345/- per day as a labour.
11.
Learned counsel appearing for the Respondents-Insurance
Company, on the other hand, supported such finding of the learned
Tribunal with regard to the income of the deceased and the method
adopted by the learned Tribunal to arrive at the monthly as well as
the annual income of the deceased. In such view of the matter,
learned counsel for the Respondent No.1-Insurance Company
contended that the impugned award does not call for any
interference by this Court in the present appeal. Accordingly, it was
prayed that the appeal, being devoid of merit, is liable to be
dismissed.
12.
Having regard to the submissions made by learned counsels
Page 4 of 7.
appearing for both sides, on a careful examination of their
submissions as well as on a close scrutiny of the impugned award
as well as the materials on record, this Court found that the only
issue that falls for determination in the present appeal is with regard
to the fixation of the income of the deceased and the consequential
award of the compensation. The claim application it has been
pleaded that the deceased was getting a salary of Rs.26,800/- per
month. The same was disputed by the Insurance Company. Taking
into consideration the aforesaid dispute, the learned Tribunal
adopted the notional method of fixation of the income and,
accordingly, calculated the monthly income of the deceased by
taking into consideration the daily wages as is prescribed by the
government notification @ Rs.345/- per day at the relevant point of
time. Accordingly, the learned Tribunal has arrived at a conclusion
that the monthly income of the deceased of Rs.10,350/- per month
and Rs.1,24,200/- per annum.
13.
This Court, on a careful analysis of the factual background of
the present case as well as the materials on record, found that the
deceased was an Electrician, who was engaged by a construction
company. Therefore, it cannot be disputed that the deceased had
acquired some skill in the electrical field. Such finding of this Court
is confirmed by the fact that he was hired by a construction
company for the purpose of electricity. Thus, there is no doubt that
the deceased is entitled to a much higher daily wage that the rate at
which it had been calculated by the learned Tribunal on a notional
basis. Viewing the matter from the aforesaid angle, this Court is of
the considered opinion that the learned Tribunal has committed an
error by notionally fixing the income of the deceased @
Page 5 of 7.
Rs.10,350/- per month. Taking into consideration the fact that at the
relevant point of time, the daily wage for the skilled category of
labourer was Rs.423/- per day. Accordingly, the monthly income of
the deceased is re-fixed @ Rs.12,690/-. Accordingly, the annual
income of the deceased is hereby re-fixed @ Rs.1,52,280/-. By
applying the multiplier ‘16’ to the annual income of the deceased
which has been re-fixed @ Rs.1,52,280/-, the total compensation
amount comes to Rs.24,36,480/-. Since the deceased was a
bachelor, after deducting 50% from his total income, the net total
income of the deceased per annum would come to Rs.12,18,240/-.
With the aforesaid amount, the loss of future prospect @ 40% is to
be added. Accordingly, the total figure comes to Rs.17,05,536/-. To
the aforesaid amount, the general damage to be added @
Rs.70,000/-. Hence, the total amount would be Rs.17,75,536/-.
Therefore, the Respondent No.1-Insurance Company is liable to
pay a total compensation of Rs.17,75,536/-.
14.
It is stated by learned counsel for the Respondent No.1-
Insurance Company that a total sum of Rs.16,84,040/-, including
the interest, has been paid, out of which the total awarded amount is
Rs.15,12,040/-. In view of the above it is clear that the interest
element has already been taken care of and the same has already
been paid to the claimants. Therefore, out of the total amount of
Rs.17,75,536/-, a total amount of Rs.15,12,040/- is to be deducted
and the balance amount comes to Rs.2,63,496/-, which may be
rounded off to Rs.3,00,000/-. Accordingly, it is ordered that the
Respondent No.1-Insurance Company shall pay a
further
consolidated sum of Rs.3,00,000/- to the Appellant No.1 within a
period of eight weeks. Since the interest amount has already been
Page 6 of 7.
paid, the same is hereby waived.
15.
With the aforesaid modification, the Appeal stands disposed
of.
( A.K. Mohapatra )
Judge
Anil
Digitally Signed
Signed by: ANIL KUMAR SAHOO
Reason: Authentication
Location: High Court of Orissa
Date: 17-Aug-2026 19:21:56
Page 7 of 7.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review