Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 20TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHAMMAD NAWAZ
AND
THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.
REGULAR FIRST APPEAL NO.100158 OF 2014 (PAR)
C/W
REGULAR FIRST APPEAL NO. 100164 OF 2014
REGULAR FIRST APPEAL NO. 100167 OF 2014
IN RFA NO. 100158/2014
BETWEEN:
SAROJA
HANGARAKI
MALLIKARJUNAGOUDA S/O. SANKANAGOUDA ROTTI,
AGE: 47 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
AT: ASUTI, TQ. RON, DIST. GADAG.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. ARAVIND D. KULKARNI, ADVOCATE)
SAROJA HANGARAKI
Location: HIGHCOURT
OF KARNATAKA
DHARWAD BENCH
DHARWAD
AND:
1.
KARIYAVVA W/O. NINGAPPA HADLI,
AGE: 79 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE
R/O. ASUTI, TQ. RON, DIST. GADAG.
2.
NINGAVVA W/O. SANNA NIMBANNA GORAVAR,
AGE: 51 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE
R/O. UPPINBETAGERI, TQ. AND DIST. KOPPAL.
3.
IRAVVA W/O. MALLAPPA CHIMMANAKATTI,
AGE: 49 YEARS, OCC. HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. HALAKURKI, TQ. BADAMI, DIST.BAGALKOTE.
-2NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
4.
DYAMAPPA S/O. NINGAPPA HADLI,
AGE: 44 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. ASUTI, TQ. RON, DIST. GADAG.
5.
MALLAVVA W/O. GAVISIDDAPPA HUJRATTI,
AGE: 43 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. YAREHANCHINAL, TQ. YALBURGA,
DIST. KOPPAL.
6.
AKAKAMAHADEVI W/O. MARIYAPPA KOUAGERI,
AGE: 36 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE
R/O. KURAMUDI, TQ. RON, DIST. GADAG.
7.
DRAKSHAYANI W/O. NEELAPPA CHIMMANAKATTI,
AGE: 32 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE
R/O. HALAKURKI, TQ. BADAMI,
DIST. BAGALKOTE.
8.
SHIVAPPA S/O. NINGAPPA HADLI,
AGE: 48 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. ASUTI, TQ. RON, DIST. GADAG.
9.
CHANNAPPA S/O. NINGAPPA HADLI,
AGE: 39 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. ASUTI, TQ. RON, DIST. GADAG.
10.
RUDRAPPA IRABASAPPA @ VEERABASAPPA HADLI,
SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS ARE ALREADY ON RECORD.
11.
SMT. PARVATEVVA W/O. ADIVEPPA HADLI,
AGE: 65 YEARS, OCC. HOUSEHOLD WORK,
AT. ASUTI, TQ. RON, DIST. GADAG.
12.
YALLAPPA S/O. ADIVEPPA HADLI,
AGE: 40YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. ASUTI, TQ. RON, DIST. GADAG.
13.
HANAMAPPA S/O. ADIVEPPA HADLI,
AGE: 30 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. ASUTI, TQ. RON, DIST. GADAG.
14.
SHIVAVVA W/O. ADIVEPPA HADLI,
AGE: 55 YEARS, OCC. HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. ASUTI, TQ. RON, DIST. GADAG.
-3NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
15.
YALLAVVA W/O. HANAMAPPA GAJI,
AGE: 55 YEARS, OCC. HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. MALLAPUR, TQ. RON, DIST. GADAG.
16.
IRAVVA W/O. DEVAPPA SHIRPRI,
AGE: 30 YEARS, OCC. HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. RON , TQ. RON, DIST. GADAG.
17.
IRAPPA S/O. ADIVEPPA HADLI,
AGE: 25 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. ASUTI, TQ. RON, DIST. GADAG.
18.
SHARANAPPA S/O. ADIVEPPA HADLI,
AGE: 23 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. ASUTI, TQ. RON, DIST. GADAG.
19.
YALLAPPA S/O. RUDRAPPA,
SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS.
19A.
DEVAKKA W/O. YALLAPPA HADLI,
AGE: 58 YEARS, OCC. HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. ASUTI-582203, TQ AND DIST. GADAG.
19B.
IRAPPA S/O. YALLAPPA HADLI,
AGE: 40 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. NEAR DODDABASAVESHWARA TEMPLE,
KUMBAR ONI, ASUTI-582203,
TQ AND DIST. GADAG.
19C.
SMT. RENUKA W/O. RAMAPPA HIREHOLI,
AGE: 39 YEARS, OCC. HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. SIDDARAMESHWAR NAGAR, WARD NO.9,
ASHRAYA COLONY, MUDHOL ROAD,
YALABURGA-583236, DIST. KOPPAL.
19D. NAGAPPA S/O. YALLAPPA HADLI,
AGE: 38 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. ASUTI-582203, TQ. RON,
DIST. GADAG.
19E.
BASAVARAJ S/O. YALLAPPA HADLI,
AGE: 34 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. ASUTI-582203, TQ. AND DIST. GADAG.
-4NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
19F.
DEVAPPA S/O. YALLAPPA HADLI,
AGE: 34 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. ASUTI-582203, TQ. AND DIST. GADAG.
20.
YALLAPPA S/O. ADIVEPPA HADLI,
AGE: 40 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. ASUTI, TQ. RON, DIST. GADAG.
21.
HANAMAPPA S/O. ADIVEPPA HADLI,
AGE: 30 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. ASUTI, TQ. RON, DIST. GADAG.
22.
SMT. PARAVATEVVA W/O. ADIVEPPA HADLI,
AGE: 65 YEARS, OCC. HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. ASUTI, TQ. RON, DIST. GADAG.
23.
SMT. BHIMAVVA W/O. RUDRAVVA HADLI,
AGE: MAJOR, OCC. HOUSEHOLD WORK AND
AGRICULTURE, R/O. ASUTI, TQ. RON,
DIST. GADAG.
24.
VEERABASAPPA S/O. NINGAPPA HADLI,
AGE: MAJOR,
OCC. HOUSEHOLD WORK AND AGRICULTURE,
R/O. ASUTI, TQ. RON, DIST. GADAG.
25.
MALLAPPA S/O. KALASAPPA ITTAPPANNAVAR,
AGE: 45 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. Y.S. HADAGALI, TQ. RON, DIST. GADAG.
26.
HANAMANTAPPA S/O. MALLAPPA ITTAPPANAVAR,
AGE: 14 YEARS, R/O. Y.S. HADAGALI,
TQ. RON, DIST. GADAG.
27.
MAHESH S/O. MALLAPPA ITTAPPANAVAR,
AGE: 12 YEARS, R/O. Y.S. HADAGALI,
TQ. RON, DIST. GADAG.
28.
SAVITA D/O. MALLAPPA ITTAPPANAVAR,
AGE: 10 YEARS, R/O. Y.S. HADAGALI,
TQ. RON, DIST. GADAG.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. S.S. BHAWAKHAN, ADVOCATE AND
SRI. S. BADAWADAGI, ADVOCATE FOR R1 TO R7, R9 AND R18;
SRI. K. L. PATIL, ADVOCATE FOR R19 (A TO F);
-5NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
LRS OF R8 (A TO C), R10 TO R17, R20 TO R21 AND R24, R25,
R26, R27-NOTICE SERVED;
R22, R23 (A TO D) HELD SUFFICIENT)
THIS RFA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 96 OF CPC, PRAYING TO
ALLOW THE APPEAL AND TO SET ASIDE THE JUDGMENT AND
DECREE OF O.S.NO.17/2012 PASSED BY SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE AND
JMFC., RON, ON 26TH JUNE 2014 AND THE SUIT BE DISMISSED AND
ETC.
IN RFA NO. 100164/2014
BETWEEN:
1.
YALLAPPA S/O. ADIVEPPA HADLI,
AGE: 42 YEARS, OCC. AGRICUITURE,
2.
HANAMAPPA
S/O. ADVIEPPA HADLI,
AGE: 32 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
3.
SMT. PARAVATHAWWA
W/O. ADVIEPPA HADLI,
AGE: 67 YEARS,
OCC. HOUSE HOLD AND AGRICULTURE,
ALL ARE RESIDENTS OF ASUTI,
TQ.RON, DIST. GADAG- 582101,
ALL ARE NOW RESIDING OF GAWARWAD,
TQ. GADAG, DIST. GADAG- 582101.
...APPELLANTS
(BY SRI. K.L. PATIL, ADVOCATE)
AND:
NINGAPPA S/O. IRABASAPPA HADLI,
SINCE DEACESED BY HIS LRS,
1.
SMT. KARIYAVVA W/O. NINGAPPA HADLI,
AGE: 81 YEARS, OCC. HOUSE HOLD,
R/O. ASUTI, TQ. RON, DIST. GADAG.
2.
SMT. NINGAVVA W/O. SANNANIMBANNA GORAVAR,
AGE: 53 YEARS, OCC. HOUSE HOLD,
R/O. UPPIN BETAGERI,
-6NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
TQ. AND DIST. KOPPAL.
3.
SMT. IRAVVA W/O. MALLAPPA CHIMMANAKATTI,
AGE: 51 YEARS, OCC. HOUSE HOLD,
R/O.HALAKURI,
TQ . BADAMI, DIST. BAGALKOTE.
4.
DYAMAPPA S/O. NINGAPPA HADLI,
AGE: 47 YEARS, OCC.AGRICULTURE,
R/O.ASUTI, TQ. RON -582209,
DIST. GADAG.
5.
MALLAVVA W/O. GAVISIDDAPPA HUJRATTI,
AGE: 45 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. YAREHANCHINAL, TQ. YALBURGA,
DIST. KOPPAL.
6.
AKKAMAHADEVI W/O. MARIYAPPA KOUJAGERI,
AGE: 38 YEARS, OCC.AGRICULTURE,
R/O. KARUMADI, TQ. RON,
DIST. GADAG.
7.
DRAKSHAYANI W/O. NEELAPPA CHIMMANAKATTI,
AGE: 34 YEARS, OCC.AGRICULTURE,
R/O. HALAKURKI, TQ. BADAMI,
DIST. BAGALKOTE.
8.
SHIVAPPA S/O. NINGAPPA HADLI,
AGE: 50 YEARS, OCC.AGRICULTURE,
R/O. ASUTI, TQ . RON-582209,
DIST. GADAG.
9.
CHANNAPPA S/O. NINGAPPA HADLI,
AGE: 42 YEARS, OCC.AGRICULTURE,
R/O. ASUTI, TQ. RON-582209,
DIST. GADAG.
RUDRAPPA S/O. IRBSAPPA @ VEERABASAPPA HADLI,
SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS.
ADIVEPPA RUDRAPPA HADLI,
SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS,
10.
SHIVAVVA W/O. HANUMAPPA GAJI,
AGE: 42 YEARS, OCC. HOUSEHOLD,
-7NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
R/O. ASUTI, TQ. RON-582209,
DIST. GADAG.
11.
YALLAVVA W/O. HANUMAPPA GANJI,
AGE: 42 YEARS, OCC. HOUSEHOLD,
R/O. ASUTI, TQ. RON-582209,
DIST. GADAG.
12.
SMT. IRAVVA W/O. DEVAPPA SHIPRI,
AGE: 32 YEARS, OCC. HOUSEHOLD,
R/O. ASUTI, TQ. RON-582209,
DIST. GADAG.
13.
IRAPPA S/O. ADIVEPPA HADLI,
AGE: 27 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. ASUTI, TQ. RON-582209,
DIST. GADAG.
14.
SHARANAPPA S/O. ADIVEPPA HADLI,
AGE: 25 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. ASUTI, TQ. RON-582209,
DIST. GADAG.
15.
YALLAPPA RADRAPPA HADLI,
SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS.
15A.
SMT. DEVAKKA W/O. YALLAPPA HADLI,
AGE: 60 YEARS, OCC. HOUSEHOLD,
R/O. ASUTI, DIST. GADAG-582203.
15B.
IRAPPA S/O. YALLAPPA HADLI,
AGE: 40 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. KUMBAR ONI,
NEAR DODDABASAVESHWARA TEMPLE,
R/O. ASUTI, DIST. GADAG-582203.
15C.
RENUKA W/O. RAMAPPA HIREHOLI,
AGE: 38 YEARS, OCC. HOUSEWIFE,
R/O. MUDHOL ROAD, SIDDARAMESHWAR NAGAR,
WARD NO.9, ASHRAYA COLONY,
TQ. YELBURGA, DIST. KOPPAL.
15D. NAGAPPA S/O. YALLAPPA HADLI,
AGE: 36 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. ASUTI, DIST. GADAG-582203.
-8NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
15E.
BASAVARAJ S/O. YALLAPPA HADLI,
AGE: 34 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. ASUTI, DIST. GADAG-582203.
15F.
DEVAPPA S/O. YALLAPPA HADLI,
AGE: 34 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. ASUTI, DIST. GADAG-582203.
16.
SMT. BHEEMAVVA W/O. RUDRAPPA HADLI,
AGE: 77 YEARS, OCC. HOUSEHOLD,
R/O. ASUTI, TQ. RON-582209, DIST. GADAG.
17.
VEERABHASAPPA S/O. NINGAPPA HADLI,
SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS.
17A.
SMT. YALLAVVA @ SHANTAVVA
W/O. VEERABASAPPA HADLI,
AGE: 50 YEARS, OCC. HOUSEHOLD,
17B.
IRAPPA S/O. VEERABASAPPA HADLI,
AGE: 28 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
17C.
GEETA D/O. VEERABASAPPA HADLI,
AGE: 25 YEARS, OCC. HOUSEWIFE,
17D. YALLAPPA S/O. VEERABASAPPA HADLI,
AGE: 22 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
ALL ARE R/O. ASUTI, DIST. GADAG-582203.
18.
MALLAPPA S/O. KALASAPPA ITTAPPANAVAR,
AGE: 47 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O.Y S HADAGALI, TQ. RON-582209,
DIST. GADAG.
19.
HANAMANTAPPA S/O. MALLAPPA ITTAPPANAVAR,
AGE: 16 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O.Y S HADAGALI, TQ. RON-582209,
DIST. GADAG.
20.
MAHESH S/O. MALLAPPA ITTAPPANAVAR,
AGE: 14 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O.Y S HADAGALI, TQ. RON-582209,
-9NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
DIST. GADAG.
21.
SAVITA D/O. MALLAPPA ITTAPPANAVAR
AGE: 12 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O.Y S HADAGALI, TQ. RON-582209,
DIST. GADAG.
(SINCE RESPONDENTS NO. 19 TO 21 ARE MINORS
REP. BY THEIR FATHER AS MINOR GUARDIAN RESPONDENT
NO.18)
22.
MALLIKARJUNAGOUDA S/O. SANKANAGOUDA ROTTI,
AGE: 47 YEARS, OCC. HOUSEHOLD,
R/O.ASUTI, TQ. RON-582209,
DIST. GADAG.
...RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. S.S. BHAWAKHAN, ADVOCATE AND
SRI. SHIVAKUMAR S. BADAWADAGI, ADVOCATE FOR R1 TO R7, R9;
R8 (B), R10 TO R14, R16, R17(B), R18 TO R22 -NOTICE SERVED;
SRI. AKSHAY A. VASTRAD, ADVOCATE FOR R15(A TO F);
SRI. AVINASH BANAKAR, ADVOCATE FOR R17(A);
R8 (A,C) R17(C TO D), R23 (A TO D)-HELD SUFFICIENT)
THIS RFA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 96 OF CPC, PRAYING TO
CALL FOR THE RECORDS IN O.S.NO.17/2012 ON THE FILE OF SENIOR
CIVIL JUDGE, RON AND TO SET ASIDE THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE
DATED 26.06.2014 MADE IN O.S.NO.17/2012 ON THE FILE OF SENIOR
CIVIL JUDGE, RON AND DISMISS THE SUIT O.S.NO.17/2012 ON THE
FILE OF SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE, RON AND ETC.
IN RFA NO. 100167/2014
BETWEEN:
1.
SHIVAVVA W/O. ADIVEPPA HADLI,
AGE: 57 YEARS, OCC. HOUSEHOLD,
R/O. ASUTI, TQ. RON-582 209,
DIST. GADAG.
2.
YALLAVVA @ DEVAKKA W/O. HANAMAPPA GAJI,
AGE: 57 YEARS, OCC. HOUSEHOLD,
R/O. MALLAPUR, TQ.RON-582209,
DIST. GADAG.
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
3.
IRAVVA W/O. DEVAPPA SHIPRI,
AGE: 32 YEARS, OCC. HOUSEHOLD,
R/O. RON, TQ.RON-582209,
DIST. GADAG.
4.
IRAPPA S/O. ADIVEPPA HADLI,
AGE: 27 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. ASUTI, TQ.RON-582209,
DIST. GADAG.
5.
SHARANAPPA S/O. ADIVEPPA HADLI,
AGE: 25 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. ASUTI, TQ.RON-582209,
DIST. GADAG.
...APPELLANTS
(BY SRI. SAURABH A. SONDUR, ADVOCATE)
AND:
NINGAPPA S/O. IRABASAPPA @ VEERABASAPPA HADALI,
SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS.,
1.
KARIYAVVA W/O. NINGAPPA HADLI,
AGE: 81 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O.ASUTI, TQ. RON-582209,
DIST. GADAG.
2.
NINGAVVA W/O. SANNA NIMBANNA GORAVAR,
AGE: 53 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O.UPPIN BETAGERI,
TQ. AND DIST. KOPPAL-583231.
3.
IRAVVA W/O. MALLAPPA CHIMMANAKATTI,
AGE: 51 YEARS, OCC.HOUSEHOLD,
R/O.HALAKURKI, TQ.BADAMI-587201,
DIST. BAGALKOTE.
4.
DYAMAPPA S/O. NINGAPPA HADLI,
AGE: 46 YEARS, OCC.AGRICULTURE,
R/O.ASUTI, TQ. RON - 582 209,
DIST. GADAG.
5.
MALLAVVA W/O. GAVISIDDAPPA HUJRATTI,
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
AGE: 45 YEARS, OCC.AGRICULTURE,
R/O. YAREHANCHINAL,
TQ. YELBURGA-583236,
DIST. KOPPAL.
6.
AKKAMAHADEVI W/O. MARIYAPPA KOUAGERI,
AGE: 38 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. KARAMUDI, TQ. RON-582209,
DIST. GADAG.
7.
DRAKSHAYANI W/O. NELAPPA CHIMMJANAKATTI,
AGE: 34 YEARS, OCC.AGRICULTURE,
R/O. HALAKURKI,
TQ. BADAMI-587201,
DIST. BAGALKOTE.
8.
SHIVAPPA S/O. NINGAPPA HADLI,
SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS.
8A.
SMT. RENAVVA W/O. SHIVAPPA HADLI,
AGE: 45 YEARS, OCC. HOUSEHOLD,
8B.
ARUN S/O. SHIVAPPA HADLI,
AGE: 21 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
8C.
BASAV S/O. SHIVAPPA HADLI,
AGE: 19 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
ALL ARE R/O. ASUTI, TQ. RON-582209,
DIST. GADAG.
9.
CHANNAPPA S/O. NINGAPPA HADLI,
AGE: 41 YEARS, OCC.AGRICULTURE,
R/O. ASUTI, TQ. RON-582209,
DIST. GADAG.
ADIVEPPA S/O. RUDRAPPA HADLI,
SINCE DECEASED BY HIS L.R.S.,
10.
PARVATEVVA W/O. ADIVEPPA HADLI,
AGE: 67 YEARS, OCC. HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. ASUTI, TQ. RON-582209,
DIST. GADAG.
11.
YALLAPPA S/O. ADIVEPPA HADLI,
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
AGE: 42 YEARS, OCC.AGRICULTURE,
R/O. ASUTI, TQ. RON-582209,
DIST. GADAG.
12.
HANAMAPPA S/O. ADIVEPPA HADLI,
AGE: 32 YEARS, OCC.AGRICULTURE,
R/O. ASUTI, TQ. RON-582209,
DIST. GADAG.
13.
YALLAPPA S/O. RUDRAPPA HADLI,
SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS
13A.
SMT. DEVAKKA W/O. YALLAPPA HADLI,
AGE: 60 YEARS, OCC. HOUSEHOLD,
R/O. ASUTI, DIST. GADAG-582203.
13B.
IRAPPA S/O. YALLAPPA HADLI,
AGE: 40 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. KUMBAR ONI,
NEAR DODDABASAVESHWARA TEMPLE,
R/O. ASUTI, DIST. GADAG-582203.
13C.
RENUKA W/O. RAMAPPA HIREHOLI,
AGE: 38 YEARS, OCC. HOUSEWIFE,
R/O. MUDHOL ROAD, SIDDARAMESHWAR NAGAR,
WARD NO.9, ASHRAYA COLONY,
TQ. YELBURGA, DIST. KOPPAL.
13D. NAGAPPA S/O. YALLAPPA HADLI,
AGE: 36 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. ASUTI, DIST. GADAG-582203.
13E.
BASAVARAJ S/O. YALLAPPA HADLI,
AGE: 34 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. ASUTI, DIST. GADAG-582203.
13F.
DEVAPPA S/O. YALLAPPA HADLI,
AGE: 34 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. ASUTI, DIST. GADAG-582203.
14.
YALLAPPA S/O. ADIVEPPA HADLI,
AGE: 42 YEARS, OCC.AGRICULTURE,
R/O. ASUTI, TQ. RON-582209,
DIST. GADAG.
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
15.
HANAMAPPA S/O. ADIVEPPA HADLI,
AGE: 32 YEARS, OCC.AGRICULTURE,
R/O. ASUTI, TQ. RON-582209,
DIST. GADAG.
16.
PARVATEVVA W/O. ADIVEPPA HADLI,
AGE: 67 YEARS, OCC.HOUSEHOLD,
R/O. ASUTI, TQ. RON-582209,
DIST. GADAG.
17.
BHIMAVVA W/O. RUDRAVVA HADALI,
AGE: 42 YEARS, OCC.AGRICULTURE,
R/O. ASUTI, TQ. RON-582209,
DIST. GADAG.
18.
VEERABASAPPA S/O. NINGAPPA HADDLI,
SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS.
18A.
SMT. YALLAVVA @ SHANTAVVA
W/O. VEERABASAPPA HADLI,
AGE: 50 YEARS, OCC. HOUSEHOLD,
18B.
IRAPPA S/O. VEERABASAPPA HADLI,
AGE: 28 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
18C.
GEETA D/O. VEERABASAPPA HADLI,
AGE: 25 YEARS, OCC. HOUSEWIFE,
18D. YALLAPPA S/O. VEERABASAPPA HADLI,
AGE: 22 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
ALL ARE R/O. ASUTI, DIST. GADAG-582203.
19.
MALLAPPA S/O. KALASAPPA ITTAPPANAVAR,
AGE: 47 YEARS, OCC.AGRICULTURE,
R/O. Y.S.HADAGALI, TQ. RON-582209,
DIST. GADAG.
20.
HANUMANTAPPA S/O. MALLAPPA ITTAPPANAVAR,
AGE: 16 YEARS,
MINOR GUARDIAN BY HIS NATURAL MINOR GUARDIAN
I.E., HIS FATHER
MALLAPPA S/O. KALASAPPA ITTAPPANAVAR.
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
21.
MAHESH S/O. MALLAPPA ITTAPPANAVAR,
AGE: 14 YEARS,
MINOR GUARDIAN BY HIS NATURAL MINOR GUARDIAN
I.E., HIS FATHER
MALLAPPA S/O. KALASAPPA ITTAPPANAVAR.
22.
SAVITA D/O. MALLAPPA ITTAPPANAVAR,
AGE: 12 YEARS,
MINOR GUARDIAN BY HIS NATURAL MINOR GUARDIAN
I.E., HIS FATHER
MALLAPPA S/O. KALASAPPA ITTAPPANAVAR.
23.
MALLIKARJUNAGOUDA
S/O. SANKANAGOUDA ROTTI,
AGE: 47 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE, R/O. ASUTI,
TQ. RON-582 209,
DIST. GADAG.
...RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. S.S. BHAWAKHAN, ADVOCATE AND
SRI. SHIVAKUMAR S. BADAWADAGI, ADVOCATE FOR R1 TO R7, R9, R13;
R8 (A,B), R10 TO R12, R14, R15, R16, R17(B), R18 TO R22 NOTICE SERVED;
SRI. AKSHAY A. VASTRAD, ADVOCATE FOR R15(A TO F);
SRI. AVINASH BANAKAR, ADVOCATE FOR R17(A);
R8 (A,C) R17(C TO D), R23 (A TO D)-HELD SUFFICIENT)
THIS RFA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 96 OF CPC, PRAYING TO CALL
FOR RECORDS AND TO SET ASIDE THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE
DATED 26.06.2014 PASSED BY THE LEARNED SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE
AND JMFC RON, IN O.S.NO.17/2012 AND DISMISS THE SUIT OF THE
PLAINTIFFS, IN THE INTEREST OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY.
THESE APPEALS, COMING ON FOR FINAL HEARING, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHAMMAD NAWAZ
AND
HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER: HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.)
RFA
No.100158/2014
is
filed
by
defendant
No.13/purchaser of one of the suit schedule properties
during pendency of the suit; RFA No.100164/2014 is filed by
defendant Nos.4 to 6 and RFA No.100167/2014 is filed by
the legal representatives of defendant No.2. All these
Regular First Appeals are filed challenging the judgment and
decree
dated
26.06.2014
passed
in
O.S.No.17/2012
(O.S.No.44/1999) on the file of Senior Civil Judge and JMFC,
Ron.
2.
O.S.No.44/1999
was
earlier
filed
before
the
Additional Senior Civil Judge, Gadag by Ningappa Hadli
against his brother Rudrappa Hadli and others, praying for
partition and separate possession of his half share in suit
schedule properties by metes and bounds. Initially, the said
suit was decreed on 20.11.2003. Against such judgment and
decree,
two
Regular
First
Appeals
were
filed
in
RFA.Nos.259/2007 and 904/2007 and both of them were
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
clubbed together and they were partly allowed by setting
aside the judgment and decree dated 20.11.2003 passed in
O.S.No.44/1999 and remanded the matter for fresh disposal.
After such remand, in view of establishment of the Senior
Civil Judge Court at Ron, this suit was transferred to the
Senior Civil Judge, Ron, and renumbered as O.S.No.17/2012.
3.
During pendency of the suit, the original plaintiff
and defendant Nos.1 and 2 died and their respective legal
representatives are brought on record.
4.
and
The case of plaintiff in brief is that the plaintiff
defendant
No.1
are
brothers
and
sons
of
one
Veerabasappa Hadli. The plaintiff contended that the suit
schedule properties are joint family properties of plaintiffs
and defendant Nos.1 to 5 & 8, defendants No.6 & 7 are not
entitled to any legal share, as they are female members of
the joint family. The defendants No.2 & 3 are sons of
defendant No.1. Defendants No.4 & 5 are sons of defendant
No.2; defendant No.6 is the wife of defendant No.2;
- 17 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
defendant No.7 is the wife of defendant No.1 and defendant
No.8 is the son of plaintiff.
5.
The contention of the plaintiff is that suit schedule
properties are jointly owned and possessed by plaintiff and
defendants No.1 to 5 & 8. The joint family had sufficient
nucleus, from the income and savings of the said nucleus,
and also from the joint labour of male members of the joint
family, some of the properties were acquired by the joint
family and thus, they are also joint family properties.
Defendant No.1 is the manager of the joint family. He
specifically contended that there is no partition in respect of
the suit schedule properties between plaintiff and defendant
No.1 at any point of time and there is no partition amongst
parties to the suit. Plaintiff further contended that some suit
properties are standing in the name of some of defendants.
The mutations are affected illegally without the consent of
original plaintiff and behind his back. Those entries will not
convey absolute ownership to respective parties. Defendants
No.6 & 7 are not the owners in possession of the properties
standing in their names. The mutations came into existence
- 18 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
only to escape from the clutches of provisions of ceiling limits
described by the Karnataka Land Reforms Act, 1961. Plaintiff
and defendants did not live together jointly and hence
plaintiff demanded his half share in the suit schedule
properties, but defendant No.1 denied it in the second week
of March-1999 and hence the suit was filed for appropriate
reliefs.
6.
Within a span of short period of filing of the suit,
defendant No.1 died before he filing written statement.
7.
Defendant No.2 appeared through his counsel and
filed his written statement, wherein he admitted the plaint
averments and contented that there is no partition between
the parties and he also admitted the relationship between
parties. He further stated that he has no objection to decree
the suit.
8.
The written statement of defendant No.2 is
adopted by defendant No.8, who is none other than the son
of plaintiff.
- 19 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
9.
Defendant No.3 has filed his written statement,
which is adopted by defendants No.4 to 7.
10.
In the written statement, defendant No.3 has
admitted the relationship between parties, but taken specific
contention that only Sl.Nos.1 to 3 of suit schedule properties
were the joint family properties of plaintiff and defendant
No.1. Other items of suit schedule properties are selfacquired properties of deceased defendant No.1 and he got
entered the names of defendants No.2 to 8 to some of those
properties. Item No.8 of suit schedule property is the selfacquired property of deceased defendant No.1 and he got
entered the same into the name of defendant No.4. The
movable properties alleged in the plaint are not in existence.
The properties standing in the name of defendants No.6 and
7 are their absolute properties and mutation is properly
entered in respect of those properties. Item Nos.1 to 3 of
suit schedule properties were fallen to the share of plaintiff in
the family partition that had taken place 40-50 years prior to
filing of the suit and since then there is no joint family in
existence between plaintiff and defendants. Item Nos.4 to 20
- 20 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
of Schedule I-A and Sl.Nos.1 to 8 of Schedule I-B are
purchased by defendant No.1 during his lifetime from his
own funds that too after the partition that had taken place in
between him and plaintiff and got entered those properties in
the names of other defendants respectively and handed over
the actual possession to respective defendants. Defendant
No.1 was not the manager of joint family of plaintiff and
other defendants. He was the manager of joint family of only
first defendant and his children and his family. The question
of ceiling limits does not arise because the suit properties are
standing in the names of different defendants since from
beginning. There is no cause of action to file the suit as there
was earlier partition between parties. Hence, prayed for
dismissal of suit with costs.
11.
During pendency of the suit, defendant No.2 died
and his some legal representatives i.e., defendants No.4 to 7
were already on record and his other legal representatives
were brought on record as defendants No.2(a to h). After
bringing them on record, defendant No.2(h) has filed written
- 21 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
statement,
which
is
adopted
by
the
other
legal
representatives of defendant No.2.
12.
In his written statement, defendant No.2(h) has
taken specific contention that suit is not maintainable in law.
He has taken contention that there was partition as per
M.E.No.2632 and rectified partition dated 03.05.1960. Thus,
the partition has taken place in the year 1959-60 itself. In
that partition, Sy.No.259 measuring 13 acres 6 guntas and
house property No.370 were fallen to the share of defendant
No.1 and thereafter, partition took place between defendant
No.1 and his son-Adiveppa (defendant No.2) through his first
wife
on
15.05.1966
and
in
the
said
partition,
R.Sy.No.258/1+2 measuring 8 acres 24 guntas was fallen to
the share of defendant No.1-Rudrappa and Re-Sy.No.258/2
measuring 6 acres,
R.Sy.No.257 measuring 13 acres 6
guntas, R.Sy.No.497 measuring 6 acres 12 guntas were
fallen to the share of defendant No.2. Thereafter, during
lifetime of Adiveppa, there was partition that had taken place
between defendant No.2, his wife, sons and daughters on
02.11.2002. He has also mentioned that which properties
- 22 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
were fallen to their respective shares under the said
partition.
13.
Defendant No.2(h) has taken further contention
that the suit is clearly barred by limitation from 23.06.1959
onwards and thus if any rights were there to the plaintiff, it
was extinguished. He has taken further contention that
defendant No.2 was illiterate and taking undue advantage of
his illiteracy by exercising threat, coercion and undue
advantage of illiteracy of defendant No.2, the plaintiff got
filed false written statement and affidavit of deceased
defendant No.2 behind the back and without the knowledge
and consent of defendants No.2(d) to 2(h). Plaintiffs have
not challenged the mutation entries from 1959-60 onwards.
Thus, there is presumption under Section 133 of Karnataka
Land Revenue Act, 1961 that the entries in RTC's are
presumed to be true, unless they are rebutted. Hence,
prayed for dismissal of suit with costs.
14.
During the pendency of the suit, one of the
properties was sold to defendant No.13, who is impleaded
- 23 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
later and he has filed his written statement, wherein he has
taken contention that is taken by defendants No.3 to 7 and
legal representatives of defendant No.2 and further stated
that he is a bonafide purchaser without notice for a sum of
₹.1,54,000/- and thus the transaction binds other parties to
the suit. He purchased the property from defendant No.7
under registered sale deed dated 17.10.2006 and prayed for
dismissal of suit with compensatory costs of ₹.5,000/-.
15.
Defendants
No.9
to
are
the
legal
representatives of Ratnavva, who is the daughter of plaintiff.
During pendency of the suit, plaintiff died and his legal
representatives were brought on record as plaintiffs No.1(a)
to 1(i). During the pendency of these appeals, one of the
sons
of
plaintiff-Irabasappa
died
and
his
legal
representatives were brought on record as respondents
No.23(a) to (d).
16.
Another son of plaintiff-Shivappa also died during
the pendency of the appeal and his legal representatives
were brought on record as respondent No.8(a) to (c).
- 24 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
17.
Based on these pleadings, the Trial Court has
framed the following issues. As discussed above, after
passing the decree, which was challenged by some of the
defendants and after such remand, the Trial Court has
framed one additional issue. Subsequent to filing of written
statement by other defendants, several other additional
issues were framed. The issues and additional issues are as
under:
“ISSUES
1. Whether the plaintiff proves that, suit properties are
the joint family properties of himself and defendants
No.1 to 5 and 8?
2. Whether the plaintiff proves that he is in joint
possession and enjoyment of the suit properties along
with defendants No.1 to 5 and 8?
3. Whether the plaintiff proves that, he is entitled to half
share in all the suit properties?
4. Whether the plaintiff proves that movables mentioned
in plaint para 1(C) are also available for partition?
5. Whether the defendant Nos.3 to 7 prove that all the
landed properties except the properties mentioned at
sl.no.1 to 3 in para 1 (A) of the plaint are the separate
properties of now deceased defendant No.1 and these
- 25 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
properties have been acquired by deceased defendant
No.1 out of his own funds?
6. Whether the defendants No.3 to 7 further prove that
all the house properties mentioned in para 1(B) of the
plaint are also the self acquired properties of deceased
defendant No.1?
7. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to any share? If so,
what is the extent of his share?
8. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to preliminary decree
as prayed for?
9. What order or decree?
ADDL.ISSUE Dated: 11.10.2013
1. Whether the defendants prove that, there was a
partition taken place in the family in the year 1959?
ADDL.ISSUE Dated: 19.10.2013
2. Whether the defendant No.13 proves that, he is the
bonafide
a
purchaser
of
the
property
bearing
R.S.No.258/1+2B from the instant defendant No.7
for a valuable consideration amount of Rs.1,54,000/and accordingly, he has become the absolute owner
in possession of the same?
ADDL.ISSUE Dated: 02.01.2014
3. Whether the defendant No.2(h) proves that, himself &
D2(d) to (f) are the absolute owners in lawful possession
- 26 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
of the suit properties(lands) item Nos.4 to 7 since from
the date of partition heitherto?
4. Whether the defendant No.2(h) proves that suit of the
plaintiff is barred by time since 23.06.1959?”
18.
On behalf of plaintiff one of the sons of plaintiff
was earlier examined as power of attorney holder of original
plaintiff and after the death of original plaintiff, same witness
is examined once again; got marked Exs.P.1 to P.36 and
closed their side before the Trial Court. On behalf of
defendants, earlier defendant No.2 was examined as D.W.1
and four other witnesses are examined as D.W.2 to D.W.5
and got marked Exs.D1 to D.74 and closed their side. The
defendants got summoned original revenue records from
Tahasildar Office, who was examined as C.W.1, got marked
Exs.C.1 to C.12 through him.
19.
After
recording
evidence
of
both
sides
and
hearing arguments of both sides, learned Trial Judge has
decreed the suit and granted half share in all the suit
schedule properties by metes and bounds to the legal
representatives of plaintiff including defendant No.8 on the
- 27 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
ground that the defendants failed to prove the Mutation
Entry Nos.2632 and 2778 and thus defendants failed to
establish the partition between the plaintiff and defendant
No.1.
20.
Aggrieved by the said judgment and decree,
these three appeals are filed as stated above.
21.
Heard arguments of Sri Aravind D Kulkarni, Sri
K.L. Patil and Sri Saurabh A Sondur, learned counsels for
appellants in all the three appeals and Sri S.S.Bhawakhan
and Sri Shivakumar S Badawadagi, learned counsels for
respondents/legal representatives of plaintiff.
22.
Learned counsel for appellants-defendants No.4
to 6, Sri K.L.Patil would submit that there were three sons to
original propositus. They are Irappa Hadli, Rudrappa Hadli
(defendant No.1) and Ningapa Hadli (plaintiff). It is an
admitted fact that this Irappa Hadli was given in adoption
and at the time of adoption, he was having a son.
23.
It is the specific argument of the learned counsel
for appellants that when this Irappa had gone in adoption to
- 28 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
another family, he was having a son called Kuberappa and
thus
Irappa
has
affected
partition
amongst
plaintiff,
defendant No.1 and his son-Kuberappa, which is entered in
the revenue records as per order dated 23.06.1959 in
M.E.No.2632 and at that time, there was partition of the
original
properties
Sy.No.172/2B,
available
Sy.No.259,
in
the
joint
family
i.e.,
Sy.No.163
and
Sy.No.196/1,
totally measuring approximately about 30 acres. Afterwards,
there was some understanding between the parties and they
have entered into another Apsat Vatani partition as per
Ex.C.4 on 30.05.1960 and in that partition, Sy.No.172/2
measuring 6 acres 38 guntas , Sy.No.163 measuring 5 acres
32 guntas + 5 guntas Kharab land and Sy.No.196/1
measuring 5 acres 1 guntas + 8 guntas Kharab land, totally
18 acres 6 guntas were fallen to the share of original
plaintiff-Ningappa and Sy.No.259 measuring 13 acres 6
guntas was fallen to the share of defendant No.1-Rudrappa
and it is stated that both agreed to give ₹.1,000/- each i.e.,
total ₹.2,000/- to Kuberappa and Kuberappa accepted the
- 29 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
cash in lieu of his share in the joint family properties and
thus this Mutation Entry No.2778 was affected as per Ex.C.4.
24.
Learned counsel for the appellants would further
submit that based on Ex.C.4, revenue entries were mutated
into respective names of plaintiff and defendant No.1 during
1960 itself. Subsequently, from 1966 onwards defendant
No.1 started purchasing several properties i.e., other items
of suit properties in his name, in the name of defendant No.2
and also in the name of defendants No.3 to 7 and this
purchase is only after the partition between plaintiff and
defendant No.1. Hence, plaintiff will not get any share in the
remaining suit schedule properties.
25.
The learned counsel for appellant further submits
that Kuberappa, the son of Irappa born before adoption is
not made as party to the suit. Hence, the suit is not
maintainable for non-joinder of necessary parties.
26.
submit
Learned counsel for the appellants would further
that
after
this
partition
in
the
year
subsequently, there was partition amongst defendants No.1
- 30 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
and 2 in the year 1966 itself and then, in the year 1979
there was one more partition between defendant No.2, his
wife, sons and daughters and thus, there is no existence of
joint family as on the date of filing of the suit between
plaintiff and defendants and thus plaintiff is not entitled for
any share in the remaining properties, but plaintiff was the
absolute owner of Item Nos.1 to 3 of suit schedule properties
by virtue of partition that had taken place during 1959-60.
27.
Learned counsel for the appellants would further
submit that because this partition has taken place during
1959-60 and the suit is filed in the year 1999 i.e., after lapse
of about 40 years and thus defendants could not produce the
witnesses, who have witnessed this partition. He would
further submit that the learned Trial Judge has misread the
provisions of law and proposition of law improperly and held
that the defendants failed to establish those facts. The
original records were summoned from Tahasildar’s Office,
which establish this partition that had taken place in the year
1959 and also in the year 1960 and even subsequent
partition between defendants No.1 and 2. These facts were
- 31 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
not appreciated by the learned Trial Judge properly and
hence prayed for allowing the appeal of defendants No.4 to
6.
28.
Learned
counsel
for
appellants
in
RFA
No.100167/2014 Sri Saurabh A Sondur, who is appearing for
LRs. of defendant No.2 would adopt the arguments of
learned counsel for appellants in RFA No.100164/2014.
29.
Learned counsel for appellant-defendant No.13 in
RFA No.100158/2014 Sri Aravind D Kulkarni adopts the
aforesaid arguments and further submit that he is bonafide
purchaser of one of the suit schedule properties for value
and hence if the suit is to be decreed, then the property
purchased by him shall be allotted to the share of defendant
No.7 so as to validate his sale deed.
30.
Sri
Learned counsel for respondents-LRs. of plaintiff
S.S.Bhawakhan
would
submit
that
in
the
written
statement itself there is categorical admission by defendant
No.2 that there is no partition amongst plaintiff and
defendants. The admitted facts need not be proved. He
- 32 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
would further submit that the total extent of suit schedule
properties is more than 100 acres. In the alleged partition,
only 18 acres 6 guntas was given to the share of plaintiffNingappa and hence apparently there is inequitable partition
between plaintiff and defendants and hence even if it is
stated that there was partition in the year 1959-60 that was
not an equitable partition and that was not acted upon. In
this regard, he would rely upon the judgment of Hon’ble
Apex Court in the case of Kale and others V/s Deputy
Director of Consolidation and others1.
31.
Learned counsel for respondents/LRs. of plaintiff
would further submit that even for the sake of arguments, if
it is accepted that the partition has taken place between
parties in the year 1959-60, then also it is not a partition,
but it is only the release deed executed by Kuberappa in
favour of other parties and thus it is compulsory registerable
document and there is no registration of such document.
Furthermore, as per Ex.C.7, there was partition deed, which
is not at all produced in the case to believe the contention of
(1976) 3 SCC 119
- 33 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
defendants
that
partition
had
taken
place.
Hence,
considering these aspects, rightly, the Trial Court has
decreed the suit and it requires no interference.
32.
Learned counsel for respondents/plaintiffs would
further submit that merely because one of the parties is not
impleaded as party in the suit, the suit shall not be
dismissed, but even in the final decree proceedings, the
Court can add necessary parties to the suit. In this regard,
he relied upon the judgment of Division Bench of this Court
in the case of Subbanna vs. Kamaiah reported in ILR
1988 KAR 786.
“(B) CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE, 1908 (Central Act
No.5 of 1908) - Order 1 Rule 9 Proviso Notwithstanding proviso Order 1 Rule 10(2)
empowers Court to add necessary party.
HELD:
Rule 9 of Order 1 of C.P.C., specifically provides
that no suit shall be defeated by reason of the misjoinder or non-joinder of parties and the Court may in
every suit deal with the matter in controversy so far as
regards the rights and interests of the parties actually
before it. A proviso has been added by Central Act 104
of 1976 to the effect that "nothing in this rule shall
apply to non-joinder of a necessary party." But sub-rule
(2) of Rule 10 of Order 1 C.P.C., empowers the Court to
direct the plaintiff to add a person to the suit who ought
to have joined whether as plaintiff or defendant whose
presence before the Court is necessary in order to
- 34 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
enable the Court effectually and completely adjudicate
upon and settle all the questions involved in the suit.
(Para-10.6)”
33.
Learned counsel for respondent would further
submit that except the agricultural income, defendant No.1
had no other source of income to purchase other suit
schedule properties and thus, the joint family income was
the nucleus to purchase them and hence, the plaintiff is
entitle for half share in all the suit schedule properties by
metes and bonds.
34.
Thus, prayed for dismissal of all the three
appeals.
… …… … ……
35.
Having heard the arguments of both sides, upon
verifying the appeal papers and records of Trial Court, the
points that would arise for consideration are:
1. Whether the appellants/LRs. of defendant No.2 and
defendants No.4 to 7 would establish the earlier
partition that had taken place between plaintiff and
defendant No.1 in the year 1959-60?
- 35 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
2. Whether
the
learned
Trial
Judge
has
not
appreciated the aforesaid fact in proper manner
and judgment and decree passed by the learned
Trial Judge is erroneous?
3. Whether interference of this Court on the above
said judgment and decree is required?
4. What order or decree?
36.
Findings
on
the
above
points
are
in
AFFIRMATIVE for the following reasons:
37.
fact.
The relationship between parties is an admitted
According to the admitted G-Tree furnished in this
case, one Irabasappa Hadli was the original propositus
having three sons and a daughter. They are Iramma, Irappa,
Rudrappa (defendant No.1) and Ningappa (plaintiff). The
said
Iramma
died,
leaving
behind
a
daughter
called
Parvatevva and a son called Rayappa Kambli. They are not
made as parties in this case.
- 36 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
38.
It is an admitted fact that the first son Irappa was
given in adoption to another family and before he was given
in adoption, he was having a son called Kuberappa.
39.
It is the contention of defendants that at the time
of Irappa going in adoption to another family, a partition had
taken place between plaintiff, defendant No.1 and son of
Irappa-Kuberappa in the year 1959.
40.
To substantiate this contention, defendants have
produced Ex.D-50 as per M.E.No.2632. At that time, three
properties were given to plaintiff, two properties were given
to defendant No.1 and cash of ₹2,000/- in lieu of his share
was
given
corrections
to
Kuberappa.
required
in
However,
said
there
M.E.No.2632.
were
some
Hence,
on
31.05.1960, as per M.E.No.2778 and Ex.C-4, a fresh mutual
partition (Apsat Vatni) had taken place. Under said partition,
Sy.No.172/2 measuring 6 acres 38 guntas, Sy.No.163
measuring 5 acres 37 guntas including 5 guntas kharab land
and Sy.No.196/1 measuring 5 acres 9 guntas were fallen to
the share of plaintiff-Ningappa i.e., totally 18 acres 6 guntas.
- 37 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
In the said partition, Sy.No.259 measuring 13 acres 6 guntas
was fallen to the share of defendant No.1 and both plaintiff
and defendant No.1 have given ₹1,000/- each to Kuberappa,
the son of Irappa before adoption. In view of his share in
joint family properties, as he was willing to purchase the
properties in the place where his adoptive father is going.
41.
Based on this partition, as per M.E.No.2778, all
revenue entries were mutated into respective needs of
plaintiff and defendant No.1. In this regard, the RTCs
produced by plaintiff as per Exs.P-2 and 3. Another RTC is in
respect of Sy.No.172/3 and not in Sy.No.172/2. This suit is
filed in respect of Sy.No.172/3 and not in respect of
Sy.No.172/2. Even these Exs.P-2 to 4 establish that as per
M.E.No.2778, these properties are mutated into the name of
plaintiff. These documents further establish that the plaintiff
has taken some agricultural loans from the Agricultural CoOperative Society by mortgaging these properties and said
mortgages are reflected with M.E.Nos.5899, 6997, 5685,
5899, 6899, 5728 and 5908. Thus, all the above three
properties are standing in the name of plaintiff as on the
- 38 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
date of filing of the suit based on M.E.No.2778 as per
inheritance. However, another Sy.No.259 was renumbered
as Sy.Nos.259/1, 259/2 because there is further partition in
the family of defendant No.1. The plaintiff and defendants
have not produced the RTCs. earlier to partition amongst
defendant No.1 and his family and hence, this M.E.No.2778
is not shown in respect of Sy.No.259.
42.
It is the further contention of defendants that in
the family of defendant No.1, there was one more partition
that had taken place in the year 1966. In this regard, they
rely upon Ex.D.3. According to it, there was partition
between defendant Nos.1 & 2. Defendant No.2 is the son of
defendant No.1 through his first wife-Yallavva. There was
partition between defendant Nos.1 & 2 and accordingly on
15.05.1966, in that partition, Sy.No.258/1+2, 497 and
268/1 were partitioned between them. In that partition,
258/1+2 measuring 8 acres 24 guntas and Sy.No.268/1
measuring 7 acres 39 guntas totally 16 acres 23 guntas were
fallen
to
Sy.No.259
the
share
measuring
of
defendant
acres
No.1-Rudrappa
guntas,
and
Sy.No.497
- 39 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
measuring 6 acres 12 guntas i.e. 19 acres 18 guntas were
fallen to the share of defendant No.2. Based on Ex.D.3,
revenue entries were mutated.
43.
Afterwards, once again there was partition in the
family of defendant No.1 and his second wife-Bhimavva and
children
of
second
wife.
As
per
Ex.D-34
based
on
M.E.No.5646, there was partition between the second wife of
Rudrappa (Bhimavva) and her son Yallappa (defendant No.3)
and in that partition, Sy.No.258/1+2/B, measuring 8 acres
24 guntas, was fallen to the share of Bhimavva and
Sy.No.229/4A,
measuring
acres
268/1+2A+2B,
measuring
acres
guntas
guntas
and
and
268/2B/2, measuring 5 acres totally more than 22 acres and
17 guntas were fallen to the share of defendant No.3 and
only 8 acres 24 guntas was fallen to the share of defendant
No.7. Ex.D-35 is M.E.No.6816 dated 26.08.1995. According
to it, some of the properties were standing in the name of
defendant No.4, who was minor represented by his minor
guardian-Rudrappa (defendant No.1) and defendant No.1
has given application and accordingly the four properties
- 40 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
bearing Sy.No.220/2A, 258/H2, 259/2 and 497 properties
shall continue in the name of defendant No.1 and after his
death, they shall be mutated equally in to the name of his
grandchildren-Yallappa and Hanumappa (defendant No.4 &
5). Exs.D-34 and 37 are one and the same documents.
44.
It is the specific contention of plaintiff that several
other properties were purchased in the names of members of
joint family only from the joint family income and nucleus
and hence, plaintiff is entitled for share in all those
properties. Ex.D.31 is the mutation register extract bearing
M.E.No.4244. It reveals that, five properties were purchased
by defendant No.1 i.e., R.Sy.Nos.258/1, 258/2, 497, 268/1,
268/2 for a sum of ₹4,500/- under registered sale deed
dated 21.12.1964 and based on that registered document,
these five properties were mutated into the name of
defendant No.1 as per M.E.No.4244 dated 24.01.1965.
45.
During 1975, defendant No.1 has purchased an
open site bearing V.P.C.No.821. Ex.D.44 is the original
registered sale deed dated 02.01.1975 in respect of this
- 41 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
property, V.P.C.No.821. One more property is purchased in
the
name
of
defendant
No.3
i.e.,
open
site
bearing
V.P.C.No.822 on 27.04.1976 and said sale deed is produced,
but not marked separately. It is purchased in the name of
minor grandson-Yallappa (defendant No.4) by defendant
No.1. Another site bearing V.P.C.No.108 is purchased in the
names of Ramappa and Yallappa, the sons of defendant
No.2, as per registered sale deed dated 03.12.1987 as per
Ex.D-48. Another property was purchased i.e., resurvey
No.77/5 measuring 3 acres 21 guntas under registered sale
deed dated 29.04.1982 as per Ex.D-49 in the name of minor
son-Yallappa
Adiveppa
Hadli
(defendant
No.4).
Under
registered sale deed dated 24.11.1983, one more property is
purchased in the name of defendant No.3, bearing resurvey
No.60 measuring 6 acres by defendant No.1 as minor
guardian.
46.
All the above sale deeds reveal that defendant
No.1 has purchased the above said properties in the name of
his minor grandchildren.
- 42 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
47.
As stated above, all the above said sale deeds
came into existence from 1966 till 1987.
48.
If defendants establish the earlier partition of
1959-60, then these properties were purchased by defendant
No.1 after separation and in those circumstances, plaintiff or
his legal representatives will not get any right over those
properties. If defendants failed to establish the earlier
partition of 1959-60, then plaintiffs will get share on those
properties.
49.
Hence, it is very crucial to verify about existence
or non-existence of earlier partition.
50.
In this regard the defendants have produced M.E.
No.2632 of 1959 and M.E.No.2778 as per Ex.D-1. As the
legal representatives of plaintiff disputed the mutations, to
establish those documents, the defendants have summoned
the original records from Tahasildar and he has given
evidence as C.W-1 and produced several documents as per
Exs.C-1
to
C.12(a).
Under
Ex.C-1-M.E.No.2632,
on
23.06.1959, there was partition and some properties were
- 43 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
allotted to the share of plaintiff and defendant No.1. Ex.D.50
and Ex.C-4 are one and the same documents. Later under
Ex.C.4-M.E.No.2778, there was alteration (zÀÄgÀ¹Ü) in the
properties allotted to each sharer.
51.
As discussed above, these documents reveal that
there was partition between plaintiff, defendant No.1 and son
of Irappa-Kuberappa and in that partition, Kuberappa has
taken cash in lieu of his share and remaining properties were
mutated separately in the names of plaintiff and defendant
No.1.
52.
Ex.C.2
is
the
application
defendant No.1 and Kuberappa.
given
by
plaintiff,
In this document, it is
stated that all the above three had mutually partitioned the
properties and they have attached partition deed to the said
application and accordingly, they requested to mutate their
respective names into the respective properties.
the
partition
deed
attached
to
this
Ex.C.2,
However,
is
not
forthcoming. In this regard, C.W.1, in his cross-examination
has deposed that, document annexed to Ex.C.2 is not
- 44 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
available in their office. He further deposed that there is an
endorsement in Ex.C.2 dated 05.09.1960 stating that the
RTC, partition deed and also the Mutation Register Extracts
were sent to Tahsildar office, Ron.
53.
C.W.1 has further deposed that even though the
properties which are partitioned under Ex.C.2 were not
mentioned in that document, it is available in Ex.C.1.
However, Ex.C1 is bearing M.E.No.2632 dated 23.06.1959
and this is in respect of earlier partition. Under Ex.C.4, the
parties have rectified the partition and details of said
partition is shown in Ex.C4.
54.
As discussed earlier, under this document, three
properties measuring more than 18 acres was given to the
plaintiff and only one property measuring 13 acres 6 guntas
was given to defendant No.1 and Kuberappa has received
cash from both plaintiff and defendant No.1.
55.
In
this
respondents/legal
vehemently
regard,
learned
representatives
submits
that
the
suit
of
counsel
plaintiff
schedule
for
would
properties
- 45 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
measure more than 100 acres, but only, 18 acres 06 guntas
was given to the share of plaintiff and hence, even if it is
held that there was a partition, the same is unequal and
hence, cannot be held as proper partition.
56.
In
this
regard,
learned
counsel
for
the
respondents/legal representatives of plaintiff rely upon the
judgment of Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Kale and
others
V/s
Deputy
Director of
Consolidation and
others2, wherein at paragraph Nos.9 & 10, held as follows:
“9. Before dealing with the respective contentions put
forward by the parties, we would like to discuss in
general the effect and value of family arrangements
entered into between the parties with a view to resolving
disputes once for all. By virtue of a family settlement or
arrangement members of a family descending from a
common ancestor or a near relation seek to sink their
differences and disputes, settle and resolve their
conflicting claims or disputed titles once for all in order
to buy peace of mind and bring about complete harmony
and goodwill in the family. The family arrangements are
governed by a special equity peculiar to themselves and
would be enforced if honestly made. In this connection,
Kerr in his valuable treatise Kerr on Fraud at p. 364
makes the following pertinent observations regarding the
nature of the family arrangement which may be
extracted thus:
(1976) 3 SCC 119
- 46 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
“The principles which apply to the case of ordinary
compromise between strangers do not equally apply to
the case of compromises in the nature of family
arrangements. Family arrangements are governed by a
special equity peculiar to themselves, and will be
enforced if honestly made, although they have not been
meant as a compromise, but have proceeded from an
error of all parties, originating in mistake or ignorance of
fact as to what their rights actually are, or of the points
on which their rights actually depend.”
The object of the arrangement is to protect the family
from long-drawn litigation or perpetual strifes which mar
the unity and solidarity of the family and create hatred
and bad blood between the various members of the
family. Today when we are striving to build up an
egalitarian society and are trying for a complete
reconstruction of the society, to maintain .and uphold
the unity and homogeneity of the family which ultimately
results in the unification of the society and, therefore, of
the entire country, is the prime need of the hour. A
family arrangement by which the property is equitably
divided between the various contenders so as to achieve
an equal distribution of wealth instead of concentrating
the same in the hands of a few is undoubtedly a
milestone in the administration of social justice. That is
why the term “family” has to be understood in a wider
sense so as to include within its fold not only close
relations or legal heirs but even those persons who may
have some sort of antecedent title, a semblance of a
claim or even if they have a spes successionis so that
future disputes are sealed for ever and the family instead
of fighting claims inter se and wasting time, money and
energy on such fruitless or futile litigation is able to
devote its attention to more constructive work in the
larger interest of the country. The courts have,
therefore, leaned in favour of upholding a family
arrangement instead of disturbing the same on technical
or trivial grounds. Where the courts find that the family
arrangement suffers from a legal lacuna or a formal
- 47 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
defect the rule of estoppel is pressed into service and is
applied to shut out plea of the person who being a party
to family arrangement seeks to unsettle a settled dispute
and claims to revoke the family arrangement under
which he has himself enjoyed some material benefits.
The law in England on this point is almost the same.
In Halsbury's Laws of England, Vol. 17, Third Edition, at
pp. 215-216, the following apt observations regarding
the essentials of the family settlement and the principles
governing the existence of the same are made:
“A family arrangement is an agreement between
members of the same family, intended to be generally
and reasonably for the benefit of the family either by
compromising doubtful or disputed rights or by
preserving the family property or the peace and security
of the family by avoiding litigation or by saving its
honour.
The agreement may be implied from a long course of
dealing, but it is more usual to embody or to effectuate
the agreement in a deed to which the term “family
arrangement” is applied.
Family arrangements are governed by principles
which are not applicable to dealings between strangers.
The court, when deciding the rights of parties under
family arrangements or claims to upset such
arrangements, considers what in the broadest view of
the matter is most for the interest of families, and has
regard to considerations which, in dealing with
transactions between persons not members of the same
family, would not be taken into account. Matters which
would be fatal to the validity of similar transactions
between strangers are not objections to the binding
effect of family arrangements.
10. In other words to put the binding effect and the
essentials of a family settlement in a concretised form,
the matter may be reduced into the form of the following
propositions:
- 48 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
“(1) The family settlement must be a bona fide one
so as to resolve family disputes and rival claims by a fair
and equitable division or allotment of properties between
the various members of the family;
(2) The said settlement must be voluntary and should
not be induced by fraud, coercion or undue influence;
(3) The family arrangement may be even oral in
which case no registration is necessary;
(4) It is well settled that registration would be
necessary only if the terms of the family arrangement
are reduced into writing. Here also, a distinction should
be made between a document containing the terms and
recitals of a family arrangement made under the
document and a mere memorandum prepared after the
family arrangement had already been made either for
the purpose of the record or for information of the court
for making necessary mutation. In such a case the
memorandum itself does not create or extinguish any
rights in immovable properties and therefore does not
fall within the mischief of Section 17(2) of the
Registration Act and is, therefore, not compulsorily
registrable;
(5) The members who may be parties to the family
arrangement must have some antecedent title, claim or
interest even a possible claim in the property which is
acknowledged by the parties to the settlement. Even if
one of the parties to the settlement has no title but
under the arrangement the other party relinquishes all
its claims or titles in favour of such a person and
acknowledges him to be the sole owner, then the
antecedent title must be assumed and the family
arrangement will be upheld and the courts will find no
difficulty in giving assent to the same;
(6) Even if bona fide disputes, present or possible,
which may not involve legal claims are settled by a bona
fide family arrangement which is fair and equitable the
family arrangement is final and binding on the parties to
the settlement.”
- 49 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
57.
learned
The above judgment is also relied upon by the
counsel
for
the
appellants.
In
the
aforesaid
judgment, it is held that the properties shall be equitably
divided between various coparceners, so as to achieve an
equal distribution of wealth, instead of concentrating in the
hands of a few. Some guidelines that is, essentials of family
settlement are noted in the aforesaid judgment at paragraph
No.10. According to it, the family settlement must be
bonafide, and voluntary. It may be oral and if it is reduced
into writing, then, if the document containing the terms and
recitals of family arrangement, then it requires registration.
If it is only a memorandum of partition, which does not
create or extinguish any rights and thus, it does not require
registration. It is further held that the family arrangement
may be a settlement between parties. In such a settlement,
if one of the parties relinquishes his claim in favour of other
persons, even then, the family arrangement will be upheld
and the Courts.
58.
In
the
instant
case,
as
discussed
above,
Kuberappa had received ₹.2,000/-, in lieu of his share in
- 50 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
joint family properties because he was intending to purchase
the properties in the place where his father was given in
adoption and other two brothers i.e., plaintiff and defendant
No.1 have partitioned the properties. It appears that 18
acres and odd was given to the plaintiff and only 13 acres
and odd was given to defendant No.1. Hence, if there was
any unequal partition, then, it is defendant No.1 who ought
to have taken that contention. However, strangely only at
the time of arguments, learned counsel for plaintiff is taking
said contention.
59.
One of the sons of plaintiff was examined as GPA
holder of plaintiff initially and after death of plaintiff, he was
again examined. In the cross-examination, a suggestion was
put to this witness that about 50 years prior to his
deposition, there was partition between his father and
defendant No.1, which is denied by him. But he categorically
admitted that, at that time, the joint family was having only
five landed properties and a house property. He also
admitted that out of these five properties, some properties
were mutated into the name of plaintiff and some others
- 51 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
were mutated into the name of defendant No.1. There is
categorical admission that, at that time, there were only 31
acres of property available in the family.
60.
The relevant portion of evidence of P.W.1 in this
regard reads as follows:
"ªÀÄÆ® ¥ÀÄgÀĵÀ FgÀ§¸À¥Àà ºÀzÀ° FvÀ£À ªÀÄ£ÉvÀ£ÀPÀPÌÉ MlÄÖ 31 JPÀgÉ a®ègÉ UÀÄAmÉ
d«ÄãÀÄ EvÀÄÛ JA§ÄzÀÄ ¸Àj".
61.
When P.W.1 admitted that only 31 acres were
there at that time, if 18 acres and odd was given to his
father, then if properties were purchased after the partition,
plaintiff
cannot
claim
any
share
in
those
properties.
Admittedly, mutation entries were made in the name of
plaintiff and defendant No.1 separately.
62.
The contention of plaintiff that to avoid ceiling
limit of Karnataka Land Reforms Act, 1961, this mutation of
1959-60
had
taken
place.
However,
admittedly, the
question of ceiling limit came into existence in 1970s and not
during 1959-60. Hence, said contention is not tenable.
- 52 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
63.
These mutation entries were not challenged either
by plaintiff or by defendant No.1 at any point of time, till
filing of suit in the year 1999 i.e., for a period of about 39
years, both plaintiff and defendant No.1 have not challenged
the said mutation entry. Furthermore, after 1960 also, as
discussed above, several internal partitions have taken place
in the family of defendant No.1. Admittedly, defendant No.1
had two wives and from the first wife, he got a son i.e.,
defendant No.2 and from second wife, he got other sons and
daughters. There was internal partition earlier between
defendant Nos.1 and 2. Later, there was partition between
defendant No.1 and his other sons. Subsequently, there was
partition between defendant No.3 and his mother also. These
partitions have not taken place at single time. They have
taken place from 1966 to 1979 onwards. None have
challenged those entries.
64.
Initially, this PW1 was denying the partition of
1959-1960, but subsequently, he has only deposed that he
does not know about said partition and he does not know
that those properties i.e., item Nos.1 to 3 of suit schedule
- 53 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
properties were mutated into the name of plaintiff No.1.
However, he himself has produced RTCs which establish the
aforesaid facts as discussed above. He denied even the
subsequent partition amongst defendant No.1 and his family.
But, mutation entries produced by both parties establish
those partitions.
65.
Initially, plaintiffs have not impleaded their sister-
Ratnavva in the suit. Subsequently, her legal representatives
are brought on record.
66.
It is to be noted here that Kuberappa is not made
as party in the present suit. Always, there is presumption
that a Hindu family is Hindu joint family until and unless it is
rebutted. However, when defendants have produced ample
material before the Court to show the partition between
plaintiff and defendant No.1 and subsequently, in between
defendant No.1 and his other family members and mutations
were affected and RTCs also reflect those
facts, the
presumption under Section 133 of Karnataka Land Revenue
Act would arise and the entries in revenue records are
- 54 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
presumed to be true until they are rebutted. No rebuttal
evidence is produced by legal representatives of plaintiff to
rebut the said presumption.
67.
The defendants have examined one witness as
D.W.4, who is aged about 76 years at the time of filing his
affidavit evidence and he has stated in his affidavit evidence
regarding the partition that had taken place between plaintiff
and defendant No.1 in the year 1959 and 1960. He has also
stated the extent of properties fallen to respective shares of
plaintiff and defendant No.1. In this regard, in the crossexamination, he has deposed that the partition has taken
place in the year 1959, but, he does not remember the date
and moment. He has also stated who were all present at the
time of said partition.
68.
The above evidence of D.W.4 substantiates the
contention of defendants.
69.
Some of the defendants’ witnesses have admitted
that defendant No.1 was not having any other source of
income, except, the income from agriculture. Hence, learned
- 55 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
counsel for plaintiff vehemently submitted that the properties
which were acquired by defendant No.1 from 1965 to 1987
are acquired from the joint family nucleus and thus, they are
the ancestral and joint family properties of both plaintiff and
defendant No.1. However, it is to be noted here that, after
severance of status between plaintiff and defendant No.1
during 1959-60, defendant No.1 has purchased the other
properties. Hence, they are the joint family properties of
defendant No.1 and his family and plaintiff cannot claim any
share in those properties.
70.
Learned
counsel
for
respondents
vehemently
submitted his arguments that defendant No.2 in his written
statement and also in his affidavit evidence has categorically
admitted that there was no partition between plaintiff and
defendant No.1.
71.
In the affidavit evidence of defendant No.2, he
contended that there was no partition in the family and he
has
no
objection
to
decree
the
suit.
In
the
cross-
examination, he has admitted that his father has purchased
- 56 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
Sy.No.253/1A, 229/4A and till his death, they were in the
absolute possession of defendant No.1. He also admitted that
two landed properties and two open sites were purchased by
his father in his name and they are standing in his name and
he is looking after those properties. He further admitted that
defendant No.1 has purchased three landed properties, three
open sites in the name of defendant No.3 and defendant
No.3 is enjoying those properties. Likewise, he admitted that
defendant No.6 is his wife, defendant Nos.4 and 5 are his
children and they are having landed properties and house
properties at Gavarawada and they were purchased by his
father in the names of his wife and children. He also
admitted that his father has purchased a property at
Gavarawada in the name of defendant No.6. His father has
purchased
property
in
the
name
of
his
second
wife
Bhimavva(defendant No.7) and those properties are being
enjoyed by defendant Nos.6 and 7 separately. He admitted
that during his lifetime, his father has purchased several
properties.
- 57 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
72.
oral
and
On careful perusal of all the above materials, i.e.,
documentary
evidence,
they
clearly
and
categorically establish that partition had taken place in the
year 1959-60 and it was acted upon. 39 years after such
partition, the plaintiff is not permitted to challenge the same
and to file a suit for partition. However, learned Judge has
not considered these aspects and only held that the mutation
entries were not proved by defendants because the partition
deed is not produced. As discussed above, said partition
deed was sent to the office of Tahsildar at Ron and hence,
the defendants could not produce those documents.
73.
Exs.C1 to 11 are the official records maintained in
regular course by the revenue officials in their revenue
office. Furthermore, all those records are 30 years old
documents. Hence, the presumption arises that they are
maintained in a proper manner and entries in those revenue
records are genuine. If anyone disputes them, then, he has
to establish that how they are concocted records. No
material is produced by plaintiff or legal representatives of
plaintiff that those revenue records are concocted records.
- 58 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
As discussed earlier, in Kale’s case referred supra, it is held
that even if, one of the parties to the settlement has no title,
but under the arrangement, the other party relinquishes all
its
claims
or
titles in favour
of such a
person
and
acknowledges him to be the sole owner, then the antecedent
title must be assumed and the family arrangement will be
upheld.
74.
In the instant case, plaintiff and defendant No.1
were having right by birth over the ancestral properties and
one
of
the
Kuberappa
legal
representative
of
the
ancestor
i.e.,
has taken cash in lieu of his share and he
acknowledges
the
right
and
title
of the
plaintiff
and
defendant No.1. Hence, merely because cash is given to
Kuberappa in lieu of his share, it cannot be said that said
document is a release deed and it requires compulsory
registration. These aspects were not dealt by the Trial Court
properly and the oral and documentary evidence were not
properly appreciated by the Trial Court and the point of law
was misread by the Trial Court, which resulted in miscarriage
of justice in decreeing the suit of the plaintiff. Hence, the
- 59 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
said judgment and decree is erroneous and it requires
interference.
75.
The appellants/legal representatives of defendant
No.2 and defendant Nos.4 to 7 have established the earlier
partition that had taken place in the year 1959-1960 and
thus, the judgment and decree of the Trial Court needs
interference. When it is established that there was partition
between
plaintiff
and
between
defendant
defendant
No.1
and
No.1;
defendant
subsequently,
No.2;
and
subsequently, between defendant Nos.4 and 7. Defendant
No.7 was having every right to sell her property to defendant
No.13 and thus, the sale deed executed by defendant No.7 in
favour of defendant No.13 is valid and binding on other
parties to the suit. Accordingly, point Nos.1 to 3 are
answered in affirmative.
76.
In view of findings on point Nos.1 to 3, we
proceed to pass the following:
- 60 NC: 2026:KHC-D:642-DB
RFA No. 100158 of 2014
C/W RFA No. 100164 of 2014
RFA No. 100167 of 2014
HC-KAR
ORDER
i)
All
three
appeals
Nos.100158/2014,
filed
under
RFA
100164/2014
and
100167/2014 are allowed by setting aside
the
judgment
and
decree
passed
in
O.S.No.17/2012 (O.S.No.44/1999) on the
file of Senior Civil Judge and J.M.F.C., Ron.
ii)
The suit of plaintiff is dismissed.
iii) Under facts and circumstances of the case,
the parties are directed to bear their own
costs.
Sd/(MOHAMMAD NAWAZ)
JUDGE
Sd/(GEETHA K.B.)
JUDGE
RKM, SH, SSP
CT:PA LIST NO.: 1 SL NO.: 13
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review