Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED : 04.07.2019
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
RFA No.07 of 2016
:
Appellant
Shiva Kumar Nepal
versus
:
Respondent
Shankar Roy
Appeal under Order XLI Rules 1 and
2 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. N. Rai, Senior Advocate with Ms. Malati Sharma, Advocate
for the Appellant.
Mr. A. Moulik, Senior Advocate with Mrs. K. D. Bhutia and Mr.
Ranjit Prasad, Advocates for the Respondent.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
Dissatisfied with the
Judgment of
the
learned
District Judge, South Sikkim, at Namchi, in Eviction Suit No.02
of
2014,
decreeing
the
Suit
of
the
Respondent/Plaintiff
(hereinafter, Respondent) and dismissing the Counter-Claim of
the Appellant/Defendant (hereinafter, Appellant), the Appellant
seeks redressal before this Court.
2.
A brief factual narrative is essential for clarity in the
matter. The Respondent‟s case is that he was a tenant in the
ground and first floor of a building initially owned by one
Purnima Shreshta, at a monthly rent of Rs.3,500/- (Rupees
three thousand and five hundred) only, used for his residence
RFA No.07 of 2016
Shiva Kumar Nepal
vs. Shankar Roy
and business respectively. The property was purchased by the
Appellant in the year 2011. From January, 2012 he demanded
an
enhanced
monthly
rent
of
Rs.8,000/-
(Rupees
eight
thousand) only, which the Respondent refused to pay, while the
Appellant declined to accept the original rent of Rs.3,500/(Rupees three thousand and five hundred) only, the intention
allegedly being to declare the Respondent a defaulter and
thereby evict him. Consequently the Respondent was compelled
to send the rent by Money Order from January, 2012. The
Appellant also employed some musclemen to intimidate the
Respondent in order to expedite his eviction from the suit
premises. On 12-01-2014, the Appellant coerced him in the
presence of witnesses into affixing his signature on Exhibit „A,‟
an Undertaking to vacate the suit premises. Pursuant thereto
the Respondent issued a Legal Notice, Exhibit 2A, to the
Appellant
denying
execution
of
such
Agreement.
The
Respondent then approached the learned Trial Court under
Notification No.6326—600-H&W—B of the Health and Works
Department, Government of Sikkim, dated 14-04-1949 (for
short “Notification of 1949”), seeking a declaration that he is
entitled
to
enjoy
his
rented
premises
free
from
undue
harassment and interference from the Appellant, his agents or
servants till such time that he is evicted by due course of law.
He also sought prohibitory injunction on the same grounds, till
final disposal of the Suit.
RFA No.07 of 2016
Shiva Kumar Nepal
3.
vs. Shankar Roy
Denying and disputing the allegations, the Appellant
in his Written Statement-cum-Counter Claim averred that he
required the suit premises bona fide, for the purposes of
opening a beauty parlour for his wife, a trained beautician and a
fast food eatery for his unemployed brothers. The building also
required overhauling for proper residential and commercial use,
the premises having been damaged by the Respondent, though
subsequently this ground was abandoned. Despite the original
owner‟s assurance that the Respondent would vacate the suit
premises within two months of registration of the building in the
Appellant‟s name, another five months time was sought from
January, 2012. Later, he agreed to vacate within a period of two
months, but ceased paying rent from the same month, viz.
January, 2012. On enquiry by the Appellant in the month of
May, 2012, the Respondent informed him that the rent was
being sent by Money Order, while enquiry from the Postal
Authorities negatived such remittance, thereby rendering the
Respondent a defaulter. The Appellant enumerated the following
prayers in his Counter-Claim;
„a. A decree for declaration that the defendant is the owner
and the plaintiff is the tenant of the suit premises.
b. A decree for eviction of the plaintiff from the suit
premises on the ground of default on payment of house
rent to the defendant for more than the statutory period
for payment of monthly house rent, for the ground of
bona fide requirement of the defendant, his wife,
brothers and mother of the defendant of the suit
premises and thorough overhauling of the suit premises
for the purpose of remodeling or Modifying the suit
RFA No.07 of 2016
Shiva Kumar Nepal
vs. Shankar Roy
premises for running the beauty parlour and a fast food
joint.
c. A decree for recovery of Rs.1,15,500/- being the arrear
rent along with the interest at the rate of 10% per
annum of the suit premises from the month of January,
2012 to the month of June 2014.
d. A decree for Rs.6,750/- for court fees paid by the
defendant for his Counter-Claim.
e. Permanent injunction.
f. Ad interim and temporary injunction, if prayed for.
g. Receivership of the suit premises, if prayed for.
h. Cost of litigation.
i. Any other relief or reliefs as this Hon‟ble Court may
deem fit and proper.‟
„
4.
The Respondent, while countering the averments of
the Appellant stated that the Appellant‟s claim of bona fide
requirement was fallacious as the Appellant is already in
possession of three storeys in the five storeyed building.
The
Respondent in fact had been assured by the original owner that
despite the sale he would not be required to vacate the suit
premises. That, his eviction would have a cascading effect on
his employees who would consequently be unemployed, thereby
affecting their families. Besides, the brothers of the Appellant
being independent had their own sources of income and the
grounds forwarded for eviction were a ploy to hire out the
premises to Companies at enhanced monthly rents. That, rents
for the months of December, 2013 to May, 2014, were collected
by the Appellant from the Post Office, therefore, the question of
RFA No.07 of 2016
Shiva Kumar Nepal
vs. Shankar Roy
the Respondent defaulting in payment of rent does not arise.
Hence, the Counter-Claim be dismissed with costs.
5.
The learned Trial Court on the basis of the pleadings
of the parties settled the following Issues for adjudication;
1. Whether the suit is maintainable?
2. Whether the Defendant has been harassing the Plaintiff
in order to illegally evict him from the suit premises?
3. Whether the Defendant stopped accepting the monthly
rent with effect from January, 2012, owing to which the
Plaintiff was constrained to send the monthly rent
through Money Order which too was refused by the
Defendant?
4. Whether on 12-01-2014 the Plaintiff was compelled to
sign
on
the
concerned
document(s)/undertaking(s)
pertaining to the suit premises/demised premises?
5. Whether
the
Defendant
unilaterally
enhanced
the
monthly rent of the suit premises from Rs.3,500/- to
Rs.8,000/-?
6. Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to the reliefs as prayed
for by him?
6.
Separate Issues were framed on the Counter-Claim
as follows;
1. Whether
the
Counter-Claim
of
the
Defendant
is
maintainable?
2. Whether the Defendant requires the suit premises for
his/his family‟s bona fide use?
3. Whether the suit premises need thorough overhauling?
4. Whether the Plaintiff has willfully defaulted in payment of
the monthly rent from January, 2012?
5. Whether the Plaintiff is liable to be evicted on any of the
above grounds?
RFA No.07 of 2016
Shiva Kumar Nepal
vs. Shankar Roy
6. Whether the Defendant is entitled to the reliefs as prayed
for by him in his Counter-Claim including arrears of rent?
7.
The learned Trial Court took up Issue No.3 of the
main Suit and Issue No.4 of the Counter-Claim and on
consideration of the evidence and documents furnished before
it, reached the finding that there is always a presumption under
the law that any Registered Post sent to the correct address of
the addressee has duly reached him and it was for the Appellant
to rebut the said presumption, which he failed to do. That, there
was no reason for the Plaintiff to have sent the monthly rent by
Money Order had the Appellant been willing to accept the same
and it was this refusal that constrained the Respondent to send
it through Money Orders. The Issues were decided accordingly.
Issue No.4 of the main Suit was taken up next and it was
concluded that the Respondent had been pressurized to sign on
Exhibit „A‟. While deciding Issue No.2 of the Counter-Claim the
learned Trial Court concluded that the plea of requirement of the
suit premises by the Appellant‟s wife, brothers and mother was
made
only
to
evict
the
Respondent
without
bona
fide
requirement. In Issue No.3 of the Counter-Claim it was
observed that the claims regarding the suit premises/building
requiring thorough overhauling were rightly abandoned by the
Appellant as he was unable to prove the same. Issue No.5 of
the main Suit however came to be decided in favour of the
Appellant with the observation that the Respondent had
miserably failed to prove unilateral enhancement of rent by the
Appellant. In Issue No.2 of the main Suit the learned Trial Court
RFA No.07 of 2016
Shiva Kumar Nepal
vs. Shankar Roy
concluded that the Respondent had proved harassment caused
to him on account of the Appellant's refusal to accept the
monthly rent and by pressuring him to sign Exhibit „A‟. Issues
No.1 and 6 of the main Suit were decided in favour of the
Respondent. Issues No.1, 5 and 6 of the Counter-Claim of the
Appellant were found to be not maintainable on the Appellant‟s
failure to establish bona fide use or default in payment of
monthly rent. In the end result, the Suit of the Respondent
stood decreed while the Counter-Claim of the Appellant was
dismissed.
8.
Before this Court, on the ground of bona fide
requirement of the suit premises by the Appellant, learned
Senior Counsel for the Appellant contended that the family of the
Appellant also comprises of his unemployed brothers and ailing
mother who is in constant need of medical attention. That, the
income of the Appellant does not suffice for the upkeep of his
entire family and hence the requirement of employment for his
brothers by way of opening business in the suit premises in
order to augment the family income. On this count, reliance was
placed
on
Joginder
Pal
v.
Naval
Dwarkaprasad v. Niranjan and Another2.
Kishore
Behal1
and
Admittedly, the Appellant
and his brothers own landed property in the village with their
respective shares demarcated which remain registered in their
late father‟s name besides no income is generated therein. That,
although the second, third and fourth floor of the building are
2002 (5) SCC 397
(2003) 4 SCC 549
RFA No.07 of 2016
Shiva Kumar Nepal
vs. Shankar Roy
being used by the Appellant, it is inadequate for the purposes of
beauty parlour and fast food eatery, hence the requirement of
the two other floors. That the Appellant's brother DW3 Hari Lall
Sharma bolstered the evidence of the Appellant by stating that
although he had not submitted either an Unemployment Card
issued to him or Income Certificate before the Court, his elder
brother requires the suit premises for the purposes as stated by
him. Strength was garnered from the ratio in Malpe Vishwanath
Acharya and Others v. State of Maharashtra and Another 3 and Adil
Jamshed Frenchman v. Sardar Dastur Schools Trust and Others4.
It
was vehemently denied that Exhibit A was signed by the
Respondent under coercion in the presence of witnesses, and to
the contrary was done voluntarily with the assurance of vacating
the suit premises and handing over vacant possession to the
Appellant in the month of June, 2014. In this context reliance
was placed on Cauvery Coffee Traders, Mangalore v. Hornor
Resources (International) Company Limited5.
That, it is now settled
law that it is not necessary to establish that a person is trained
or has Licence to take up a profession in the premises, all that is
to be established is the bona fide requirement and not mere
whim or desire of the landlord.
9.
On the aspect pertaining to default in payment of
rent by the Respondent, it was contended by the Appellant that
the learned trial Court erroneously decided Issue No. 3 of the
(1998) 2 SCC 1
(2005) 2 SCC 476
(2011) 10 SCC 420
RFA No.07 of 2016
Shiva Kumar Nepal
vs. Shankar Roy
main suit and Issue No. 4 of the Counter-Claim assuming that
the rent was sent by Money Order to the correct address,
however Exhibit 3 reveals an incorrect and incomplete address.
The Postman who allegedly delivered the money was not
examined as a witness neither is there any evidence to establish
refusal by the Appellant. Exhibit 3 is therefore proof of the fact
of default in payment of rent for the months of January 2012 to
November, 2013 which remained unreceived due to incorrect
address. Rents for the months of December, 2013 to June, 2015
was sent in the Appellant‟s Jorethang address and duly received
by him. It was also argued that the finding of the learned trial
Court that the Appellant had been coerced to sign on Exhibit A is
an incorrect presumption arrived at sans proof. Besides, despite
the Respondent‟s undertaking to furnish his wife and daughter as
witnesses, he failed to comply, thereby, leading to adverse
inference against him. On this count reliance was placed on Om
Prakash
and
Another
v.
Mishri
Lal6.
To buttress his other
submissions, reliance was placed on Ragavendra Kumar v. Firm
Prem Machinery & Co.7, Bhupinder Singh Bawa v. Asha Devi8, Kailash
Chand and Another v. Dharam Dass9, Siddalingamma and Another v.
Mamtha Shenoy10, Smt. Jahejo Devi and Others v. Moharam Ali 11 and
Pratap Rai Tanwani and Another v. Uttam Chand and Another 12.
(2017) 5 SCC 451
(2000) 1 SCC 679
(2016) 10 SCC 209
(2005) 5 SCC 375
(2001) 8 SCC 561
AIR 1988 SC 411
(2004) 8 SCC 490
RFA No.07 of 2016
Shiva Kumar Nepal
10.
vs. Shankar Roy
Rebutting the arguments of the Appellant, learned
Senior Counsel for the Respondent urged that the Appellant‟s
averments are false as the negotiations for purchase of the
building took place around the year 2010-2011 while the
Appellant married only in the year 2014. In this circumstance,
the probability of the Appellant having informed the original
owner of his intention to buy her property for his wife‟s beauty
parlour is nil.
That, in fact, Exhibit A was the outcome of
coercion on the Respondent by the Appellant, in the presence of
witnesses who were in the Appellant‟s house at that time. The
Appellant also does not possess any Licence to run any business
for his brothers while the Licence for his wife was obtained much
later, hence the Appellant has not approached the Court with
clean hands.
It was next contended that no proof whatsoever
was furnished to establish that the brothers were dependent on
the Appellant or that he requires the suit premises to start a
business venture for them. On this count, reliance was placed on
Deena Nath v. Pooran Lal13.
Denying that the Appellant‟s aged
mother would form a part of his family, attention was drawn to
the definition of “family” as detailed in the Sikkim Allotment of
House Sites and Construction of Building (Regulation and
Control) Act, 1985 (for short „Act of 1985‟) which describes
“family” as father, mother, their minor children and major
children living jointly with the parents.
It was urged that the
definition excludes mother or brothers whose needs cannot be
taken
into
(2001) 5 SCC 705
consideration
for
the
purposes
of
bona
fide
RFA No.07 of 2016
Shiva Kumar Nepal
vs. Shankar Roy
requirement. To fortify this submission, reliance was placed on
the ratiocination of State of Gujarat through Chief Secretary and
Others v. Savitri Devi14 wherein the Hon‟ble Supreme Court held
that the mother has not been included as a member of the
family to the claim in Family Pension from the Government. The
evidence
furnished
by
the
Appellant
would
lead
to
the
unequivocal conclusion that it is a mere desire of the Appellant
to be in possession of the other floors of the building although
law mandates the “genuine need” of the landlord to be proved.
Reliance was placed on Vengdasalam Pillai v. Union Territory of
Pondicherry15.
11.
While resisting the arguments of the Appellant on
the ground of default of payment of rent learned Senior Counsel
for the Respondent advanced the argument that the address of
the Appellant at Rhenock had been correctly detailed in the
Money Orders remitting rent to the Appellant. That, there was
only one “Professor S.K. Nepal” in Rhenock at the relevant time.
The denial of acceptance of rent by the Appellant after
enhancement led to remittance thereof by Money Order.
The
declaratory suit was a result of the coercion on the Respondent
to sign on Exhibit A and refusal to receive the rents remitted by
Money Orders. That, the finding of the learned trial Court that
there was no unilateral enhancement of rent of the suit premises
while deciding Issue No.5 of the main suit is erroneous and
hence requires rectification. That in view of the aforementioned
(1996) 1 SCC 558
AIR 1985 SC 571
RFA No.07 of 2016
Shiva Kumar Nepal
vs. Shankar Roy
grounds, the Appeal be dismissed.
Learned Senior Counsel
placed reliance on Commissioner of Income Tax, Bombay and Others
v. Podar Cement Pvt. Ltd. and Others16, Vengdasalam Pillai v. Union
Territory
of
Pondicherry17,
State
of
Gujarat
v.
Savitri
Devi 18,
Haricharan Singh v. Shivrani and Others 19 and Deena Nath v. Pooran
Lal20 to fortify this submission.
12.
The rival contentions advanced by both learned
Counsel have been afforded due consideration as also the
evidence and documents on record and the citations made at
the Bar. The impugned judgment has been perused.
13.
The only point that requires consideration by this
Court is:
Whether the Appellant requires the suit premises for his
bona fide use and whether there was default in payment
of rent by the Respondent?
14.
It is relevant in the first instance to consider what
the Notification of 1949 deals with. In this context it is essential
to extract the Notification hereinbelow for convenience;
”GOVERNMENT OF SIKKIM
Health and Works Department
Notification No.6326—600-H&W—B.
Under powers conferred in para 2 of Notification
No.1366-G, dated the 28th July 1947, the following Rules
have been framed to regulate letting and sub-letting of
premises controlling rents thereof and unreasonable eviction
of tenants as the scarcity of housing accommodation still
exists in Sikkim.
(1997) 5 SCC 482
AIR 1985 SC 571
(1996) 1 SCC 558
(1981) 2 SCC 535
(2001) 5 SCC 705
RFA No.07 of 2016
Shiva Kumar Nepal
vs. Shankar Roy
I The landlords can charge rent for premises either for
residential or business purposes on the basis of the rents
prevailing in locality in year 1939, plus an increase upto 50
per cent so long as the scarcity of housing accommodation
lasts.
2. The landlords cannot eject the tenants so long as the
scarcity of housing accommodation lasts, but when the
whole or part of the premises are required for their personal
occupation or for thorough overhauling the premises or on
failure by the tenants to pay rent for four months the
landlords may be permitted to evict the tenant on due
application to the Chief Court.
3- Any tenant may apply to this Department for fixing
his rent. On receipt of such application the Department will
enquire about the rent prevailing in the locality in 1939, and
fix rent as per Rule (I) above.
4- Any person acting in contravention of this Notification
will be liable to prosecution under para. 4. of notification
No.I366-066-G, dated the 28th July, 1947.
5. The tenant means those person in actual occupation.
Landlord means owners of the premises.
These rules will come into force with immediate effect.
By order of his Highness the Maharaja of Sikkim.
R.B. Singh
Gangtok,
Secretary,
Health and Works Department;
The 14th, April, 1949.
Government of Sikkim.”
This
Notification
mandates
that
the
tenants
cannot
be
unreasonably evicted from their tenanted premises so long as
the
scarcity
of
housing
accommodation
exists
in
Sikkim.
Paragraph 2 of the Notification would be relevant for the present
purposes as it gives the landlords grounds to eject the tenants
which inter alia includes requirement of the landlord of the whole
or part of the premises for his personal occupation, or for
thorough overhauling, or on failure by the tenants to pay rent for
four months. Pausing here it may relevantly be noted that this
RFA No.07 of 2016
Shiva Kumar Nepal
vs. Shankar Roy
Paragraph does not specify that non-payment of rent should be
continuously for four months. That having been said, we may
now first examine the requirement for bona fide use of the
Appellant.
15.
It is the specific case of the Appellant that his
brothers are dependent on him which is supported by the
evidence of his brother DW3 Hari Lall Sharma and the wife of the
Appellant, DW4 Beena Sharma.
She has also reiterated the
stand of the Appellant that he is the only member of the joint
family to have a Government job and the rest of his brothers
also require some work for their livelihood in view of which the
Appellant has decided to open a business for them in the suit
premises.
Although it was argued by the Respondent that no
Unemployment Card of the brothers or Licence to establish
business was put forth by the Appellant, this is of no assistance
to the Respondent‟s case. In Sait Nagjee Purushotham & Co. Ltd.
vs. Vimalabai Prabhulal and Others21 the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court
held as follows;
“… It is always the prerogative of the landlord that if he
requires the premises in question for his bona fide use for
expansion of business this is no ground to say that the
landlords are already having their business at Chennai and
Hyderabad therefore, it is not genuine need. …”
It was also held therein that the tenant cannot dictate terms to
the landlord about how he should utilize his own premises. It is
the prerogative of the landlord to decide what he seeks to do
with his property and how best to utilize it. That apart, it is also
(2005) 8 SCC 252
RFA No.07 of 2016
Shiva Kumar Nepal
vs. Shankar Roy
now settled law that a person does not require experience in
business, all that the Appellant is required to establish before the
Court is his bona fide requirement. Admittedly the Appellant and
his brothers own landed property, duly partitioned, but no
income is generated from the said property and they require to
set up business in town.
16.
In Siddalingamma and Another (supra), the Appellant
who was the landlady of the premises sought eviction of the
Respondent under Section 21(1)(h) of the Karnataka Rent
Control Act, 1961. She was residing at the relevant time in her
village home and the requirements as set out in the suit was
that her husband was suffering from asthma and respiratory
problems for which he required medical treatment and was
required to be taken to Bangalore from the village which was
situated at some distance. On the demise of her spouse during
the pendency of the matter, an amendment was inserted to the
effect that the suit properties were required by her on account of
her own ill-health.
The learned trial Court held that the suit
premises was required for the use of the Appellant No. 1 and her
family members in view of her ill-health and for the requirement
of the children in her family such as better schooling and
educational facilities. The Hon‟ble High Court in revision held that
the husband of the Appellant No. 1 for whose sickness the
shifting was required had since passed away and the cause had
ceased to exist and thereby dismissed the Eviction Petition. The
Hon‟ble Supreme Court supporting the judgment of the learned
trial Court held that the Hon‟ble High Court ought to have
RFA No.07 of 2016
Shiva Kumar Nepal
vs. Shankar Roy
adopted a realistic and objective approach rather than being
skeptical about the landlady's mannerism when the need of the
landlady as borne out from the amended pleadings was bona
fide and not arbitrary, whimsical or fanciful and thus upheld the
well reasoned findings of the learned trial Court. These principles
hold in good stead in the matter at hand as well.
17.
In Smt. Jahejo Devi and Others (supra) the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court would opine that which shop is suited best to the
interest of the Respondent is a prerogative of the landlord and
the tenant cannot question his choice, therefore even if some
houses are vacant and the family of the Respondent (landlord)
has become large and the members have become major then
the requirement of the suit house is bona fide and reasonable.
In Joginder Pal (supra) the Hon‟ble Supreme Court interpreted
the meaning of the words “for his own use” as occurring in
Section 13(3)(a)(ii) of the East Punjab Urban Rent Restriction
Act, 1949 and observed that the words must receive a wide,
liberal and useful meaning rather than a strict or narrow
construction.
It was further held that the expression that the
landlord requires for “his own use,” is not confined in its
meaning to the actual physical user by the landlord personally
but includes the normal “emanations” of the landlord.
This
would depend on a variety of factors such as interrelationship
and interdependence, economic or otherwise between the
landlord and such person in the background of social, socioreligious and local customs and obligations of the society or
region to which they belong. It was also inter alia held that his
RFA No.07 of 2016
Shiva Kumar Nepal
vs. Shankar Roy
own use would also depend on the nature and degree of
relationship or the dependence between the landlord and the
person who actually uses the premises, the circumstances in
which the claim arises and is put forward and the intrinsic
tenability of the claim. Although this ratio was also relied on by
both parties, I am of the considered opinion that it is of no
assistance to the Respondent‟s case since the Hon‟ble Supreme
Court was of the firm opinion that the expression “for his own
use” arising in the aforementioned statute cannot be narrowly
construed. This Court is indeed conscious that the law under
consideration is the Notification of 1949 but the principles
enunciated by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court supra apply with equal
measure in the instant matter. Besides, “family” as defined in
the Act of 1985 supra is for the purposes of allotment of house
sites inasmuch as if one family is allotted a site by the
Government it is expected that the entire family will be
accommodated in the building and allotment will not be given
individually to each member. This definition cannot be foisted in
the instant matter as it was coined for the specific purposes of
the Act of 1985 and is relevant thereto and not otherwise. In
Malpe
Vishwanath
Acharya
and
Others
(supra)
the
Hon‟ble
Supreme Court while emphasizing the need of social legislations
like Rent Control Act striking a balance between rival interests so
as to be just, held that, the law ought not to be unjust to one
and give a disproportionate benefit or protection to another
section of the society. That while the shortage of accommodation
makes it necessary to protect tenants it is coupled with an
RFA No.07 of 2016
Shiva Kumar Nepal
vs. Shankar Roy
obligation to ensure that the tenants are not conferred with a
benefit disproportionately larger than the one needed. That,
socially progressive legislation must have a holistic perception
and not a short-sighted parochial approach. The power to
legislate socially progressive legislations is coupled with a
responsibility to avoid arbitrariness and unreasonability. A
legislation impregnated with tendency to give undue preference
to one section, at the cost of constraints by placing shackles on
the other section, not only entails miscarriage of justice but may
also result in constitutional invalidity. The Hon'ble Supreme
Court in Adil Jamshed Frenchman (supra) held that the concept of
bona fide need or genuine requirement needs a practical
approach instructed by the realities of life and it is to be
assessed whether in the given facts proved by the material on
record whether the need to occupy the premises can be said to
be natural, real, sincere and honest. The requirement should be
so as to convince the Court that it is not a mere fanciful or
whimsical desire.
In Ragavendra Kumar (supra) the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court was considering eviction based on bona fide
requirement of the landlord for starting business.
It was held
inter alia that it is a settled position of law that the landlord is
the best judge of his requirement for residential or business
purpose and he has complete freedom in the matter and this
could not be faulted. The decision in State of Gujarat through Chief
Secretary and Others (supra) relied on by the Respondent which
disentitles the mother from the pension is with the reasoning
that when the widow of the deceased survives him then she
RFA No.07 of 2016
Shiva Kumar Nepal
vs. Shankar Roy
would be entitled to the pension and the upkeep of the family
which would be done from the said amount received. Reliance on
this ratio is misplaced as here the property is purchased by the
Appellant, it is for him to decide what best use he wants to put
it to. That apart it is the duty of a son or daughter to look after
their mother for which purpose we may also draw on the
provisions of the Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior
Citizens Act, 2007 which mandates as follows;
“4. Maintenance of parents and senior citizens.-(1)…
(2) The obligation of the children or relative as the case
may be, to maintain a senior citizen extends to the needs of
such citizen so that senior citizen may lead a normal life.
(3) The obligation of the children to maintain his or her
parent extends to the needs of such parent either father or
mother or both, as the case may be, so that such parent
may lead a normal life.
………………”
Cross-examination did not decimate the requirement of the
premises of the Appellant‟s mother on medical grounds.
18.
The allegation that there was coercion on the
Respondent to sign on Exhibit A cuts no ice since the witnesses
who were examined before the learned trial Court being DW2
Hari Bhakta Sharma on a suggestion put to him has denied that
the Respondent did not voluntarily desire to vacate the suit
premises or that the Respondent was not ready to sign on
Exhibit A. DW5 Jagat Sharma also deposed that the Respondent
came to the house of the Appellant where the Appellant informed
them that the premises were required by him. The Respondent
thereupon stated that he would vacate the rented premises in
RFA No.07 of 2016
Shiva Kumar Nepal
vs. Shankar Roy
six months' time. He denied that he was deposing in favour of
the Appellant being of the same caste.
assembled
persons
and
the
He denied that the
Appellant
pressurized
the
Respondent to affix his signature on the Akarnama or that the
contents thereof were not read over to the Respondent. If this
be the circumstance, then, as correctly pointed out by learned
Senior Counsel for the Appellant, the Respondent cannot be
heard to approbate and reprobate, such conduct is not worthy of
approval. Hence on the allegations of coercion by the Appellant
on the Respondent to sign on Exhibit A, I have to differ with the
findings of the learned trial Court. Besides, Exhibit „A‟ has no
tangible effect on the merits of the matter in view of the law
points involved and is only a peripheral matter with no bearing
on the outcome.
19.
Coming to the next point as to whether there was
default in payment of rent by the Respondent. Section 27 of the
General Clauses Act, 1897 provides as follows;
“27. Meaning of service by post.-Where any [Central
Act] or Regulation made after the commencement of this Act
authorizes or requires any document to be served by post,
where the expression "serve" or either of the expressions
"give" or "send" or any other expression is used, then, unless
a different intention appears, the service shall be deemed to
be effected by properly addressing, pre-paying and posting
by registered post, a letter containing the document, and,
unless the contrary is proved, to have been effected at the
time at which the letter would be delivered in the ordinary
course of post.”
(Emphasis supplied)
The learned trial Court observed that the address was sent
correctly and the rents consequently delivered. Having examined
RFA No.07 of 2016
Shiva Kumar Nepal
vs. Shankar Roy
the first page of Exhibit 3 which is collectively in four pages, it is
seen that the address is mentioned as “To: Prof. S,K. Nepal
(Renock).” This address is consistent for the months of January,
2012 to April 2012. There are no Acknowledgment Cards
furnished before the Court to establish as to who received it or
who refused to accept the rent. The provision of law extracted
hereinabove assumes that service is deemed to be effected inter
alia only if the address furnished is correct. In the absence of a
correct address it cannot be assumed merely because there is
only one “Professor S.K. Nepal” in Rhenock that it referred to the
Appellant and none else. This could have been a consideration
had the place of work been detailed in Exhibit 3. Nothing in this
context is revealed in Exhibit 3, hence this is an incorrect
submission, finds no credibility in the eyes of the Court and the
finding of the learned trial Court on this aspect is erroneous.
Consequently I am of the considered opinion that there was
default in payment of rent by the Respondent.
20.
Although
an
allegation
emanated
from
the
Respondent that there was a unilateral increase in the rent by
the Appellant from Rs.3,500/- (Rupees three thousand and five
hundred) only, to Rs.8,000/- (Rupees eight thousand) only, and
he refused to accept the rent, no proof whatsoever on this count
has been advanced, neither are there witnesses and nor is there
substantiation of the allegation by way of documentation.
Random statements by witnesses without proof
cannot be
considered by the Court and in fact requires to be castigated.
RFA No.07 of 2016
Shiva Kumar Nepal
21.
vs. Shankar Roy
On the basis of the discussions which have been
detailed hereinabove, I find that the Appellant has made out a
case for requirement of the suit premises for his bona fide use
which is not a mere desire nor is it whimsical or dictated by
avarice. That apart the evidence reflects default in payment of
rent by the Respondent for four months, which ground by itself
suffices to evict him from the suit premises.
22.
Consequently, the findings of the learned Trial Court
on Issues No. 1, 2, 4 and 6 of the Main Suit, Issue No.3 of Main
Suit and Issue No.4 of the Counter-Claim and Issues No.1, 2, 5
and 6 of the Counter-Claim are set aside. Issue No.3 of the
Counter-Claim was abandoned and requires no orders.
23.
The grounds raised by learned Senior Counsel for the
Respondent pertaining to the question of Rent Control Tribunal in
Sikkim does not merit a discussion herein.
24.
Appeal allowed.
25.
The Respondent shall vacate the suit premises and
hand over vacant possession to the Appellant within five months
from today.
26.
The Respondent shall pay the arrears in rent for the
months of January, 2012 to November, 2013 and from the
month of July, 2015 till the time he hands over vacant
possession of the suit premises to the Appellant.
27.
No interest is ordered on the defaulted rent amount.
28.
No order as to costs.
RFA No.07 of 2016
Shiva Kumar Nepal
29.
vs. Shankar Roy
Copy of this Judgment be sent to the Learned Trial
Court for information.
30.
Records of the Learned Trial Court be remitted
forthwith.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
04.07.2019
ml
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review