Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
"
"
#
#
$
!!
%!
(
!
!
Digitally signed
by SACHIN
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
"
!
#
!
!
#
&
'
-2-
$$
%
&
'
( )
)
!
!
*
#
)
!
#
+ ,,
)
!
%
&
'
$
,)
$
$
*
$
#"
! !#
*
$
$
$
*
"! !
$
$
$*
-3-
$
*
$
-
*
*
-
*
*
./0
#
&
-
*
.445.6
72650
; #"
! !# <1.665/=2/= ./ ;>05> 0.:50
4.3350 :15>52/ 89 :15
.6.8@>.=2
0575/0./:
2?26
*'
:15
002:2;/.6
46.2/:2773
5/2;>
2/
"! !
2?26 *@0=5
2/ :5>A3 ;7 B12<1 ./ .4462<.:2;/ 72650 89
; ! @/05>
>05>
@65
;7 :15
;05 ;7
>;<50@>5 B.3 .66;B50 ./0 :15 46.2/: B.3 >5C5<:50 .3
2: 020 /;: 023<6;35 ./9 <.@35 ;7 .<:2;/
!
15 4.>:253 31.66 15/<57;>:1 85 >575>>50 :; .3
:159 B5>5 .>>.950 857;>5 :15
B5>5
:15
46.2/:2773
>2.6
./0
:15
0575/0./:3 857;>5 :15 >2.6
;@>:
;@>:
15 .44566./:3
>534;/05/:3
B5>5
:15
-4-
#&2'
15 3@2: 2/
; #"
! !# B.3 72650 89 :15
46.2/:2773 7;> 4.>:2:2;/ ./0 354.>.:5 4;335332;/ ;7 :152>
31.>5 2/ :15 3@2: 3<150@65 4>;45>:253
2/ :15 46.2/: :1.: 46.2/:277
;
15 46.2/:2773 465.050
23 :15 B275 ./0 46.2/:277
;3 ! ./0 # .>5 :15 <1260>5/ ;7 0575/0./:
;
0575/0./:
;3 ! ./0 # .>5 :15 8>;:15> ./0 323:5> ;7
0575/0./:
;
&22'
15 46.2/:2773 <6.2A50 :1.: :15 3@2: 4>;45>:253
3:;;0 2/ :15 /.A5 ;7
;7 46.2/:277
;
A:
.3@/01.>. :15 A;:15>+2/+6.B
/ :15 3.A5 ?52/ :159 <6.2A50 :1.: :15
3@2: 4>;45>:253 B5>5 ./<53:>.6 4>;45>:253 :1.: 3:;;0 2/ :15
/.A5 ;7 :15 3.20
A:
.3@/01.>.
159 7@>:15> <6.2A50
:1.: :15 D1.:. 5E:>.<:3 ;7 :15 3@2: 4>;45>:253 7;> :15 95.>
!
+!
! .63; 2/02<.:50 :1.: :15 3@2: 4>;45>:253 3:;;0 2/
:15 /.A5 ;7 :15 A;:15>+2/+6.B ;7 46.2/:277
&222'
46.2/:2773
7@>:15>
;
465.050
:1.:
A:
.3@/01.>. 1.0 5E5<@:50 . =27: 0550 ;/ !
,!
" 2/
-5-
>5345<: ;7 3@2: :5A
;
2/ 7.?;@> ;7 0575/0./:
;3 ! ./0
#
&2?'
2D5B235 2: B.3 <6.2A50 :1.:
1.0 5E5<@:50 . >565.35 0550 0.:50 !
;7 3@2: 2:5A
A:
.3@/01.>.
! !
2/ >5345<:
; ! 2/ 7.?;@> ;7 0575/0./:
;!
46.2/:2773 <6.2A50 :1.: :123 B.3 0;/5 89 0575/0./:
;3 !
./0 # :; 05/9 :152> 65=2:2A.:5 31.>5 2/ :15 3@2: 4>;45>:253
;/35F@5/:69 :159 3;@=1: 7;> . 05<>55 ;7 4.>:2:2;/ ./0
354.>.:5 4;335332;/ ;7 :152> ;/5+:12>0 31.>5 5.<1 2/ :15
;/5+:12>0 31.>5 ;7 0575/0./:
;
2/ :15 3@2: 4>;45>:253
./0 :; 05<6.>5 :1.: :15 >565.35 0550 ./0 :15 =27: 0550
>575>>50 .8;?5 .>5 /;: 82/02/= @4;/ :15A ./0 :; >53:>.2/
0575/0./:
;3 ! ./0 # 7>;A <>5.:2/= ./9 <1.>=5 ;?5> :15
3@2: 4>;45>:253
575/0./:
;!
72650
.
B>2::5/
3:.:5A5/:
05/92/= :15 .335>:2;/3 A.05 2/ :15 46.2/: ./0 <6.2A50 :1.:
:15 3@2: 4>;45>:253 B5>5 :15 3567+.<F@232:2;/ ;7 123 A;:15>
A:
.3@/01.>.
5 <;/:5/050 :1.: 123 A;:15> B.3 .
-6-
:5.<15> 2/ .
;?5>/A5/:
2=1
<1;;6 ./0 :1.: 315 1.0
.<F@2>50 :15 3@2: 4>;45>:253 ;@: ;7 15> ;B/ 5.>/2/=3
<;/:5/050 :1.: 123 A;:15> B.3 850>2005/ ./0 :1.: 15
345/: 1@=5 3@A3 ;7 A;/59 7;> 15> :>5.:A5/:
:1.: 46.2/:277
;
1.0 72650 . <>2A2/.6 <.35 .=.2/3:
.3@/01.>. 15> 1@38./0 .3 B566 .3 0575/0./:
!
5 <6.2A50
<1.>=5 3155: B.3 72650 2/
3.A5 B.3 <6;350 ;/
! ! !!
; #,)) !
;3
A:
./0
) ./0 :15
5 <;/:5/050 :1.:
A:
.3@/01.>. 1.0 5E5<@:50 . =27: 0550 ./0 :15 >565.350
0@>2/=
15> 6275:2A5
;/
15>
;B/
?;62:2;/
./0
:15>57;>5 :15 46.2/:2773 .>5 /;: 5/:2:650 :; ./9 31.>5 2/ :15
3@2: 4>;45>:253
575/0./:
@/05>
>05>
@65
; ! :15>5.7:5> 72650 ./ .4462<.:2;/
;7 :15
:; >5C5<: :15 46.2/: ;/
:15 =>;@/0 :1.: 2: 020 /;: 023<6;35 ./9 <.@35 ;7 .<:2;/
3.20 .4462<.:2;/ B.3 <;/:53:50 89 :15 46.2/:2773
>2.6
;@>: .7:5> <;/3205>2/= :15 .335>:2;/3 A.05 2/ :15 46.2/:
<.A5 :; :15 <;/<6@32;/ :1.: :15 46.2/:2773 :15A356?53
.0A2::50 :1.: :15 3@2: 4>;45>:253 3:;;0 2/ :15 /.A5 ;7
-7-
A:
.3@/01.>. ./0 :1.: 315 1.0 5E5<@:50 . =27: 0550 2/
7.?;@> ;7 0575/0./:
;3 ! ./0 # ./0 . >565.35 0550 2/
7.?;@> ;7 0575/0./:
;!
15>57;>5 :15
>2.6
;@>: 1560
:1.: :15 46.2/:2773 020 /;: 1.?5 ./9 <.@35 ;7 .<:2;/ :; 7265
7;> 4.>:2:2;/ ./0 354.>.:5 4;335332;/ ;7 :152> 31.>53 ./0
<;/35F@5/:69
.66;B50 :15 .4462<.:2;/ ./0 >5C5<:50 :15
46.2/: @/05>
>05>
@65
&.' ;7 :15
52/=
.==>25?50 89 :15 3.20 ;>05> :15 46.2/:2773 .>5 857;>5 :123
;@>:
)
15 65.>/50 <;@/356 7;> :15 46.2/:2773 <;/:5/050
:1.: :15 3@2: 4>;45>:253 B5>5 ./<53:>.6 4>;45>:253 :1.:
3:;;0 2/ :15 /.A5 ;7
;7 46.2/:277
;
A:
.3@/01.>. :15 A;:15>+2/+6.B
5 :15>57;>5 <;/:5/050 :1.: :123 B.3 .
F@53:2;/ ;7 7.<: B12<1 1.0 :; 85 :>250 89 :15
>2.6
;@>:
./0 <;@60 /;: 1.?5 855/ 02385625?50 8.350 ;/ :15
.335>:2;/3 A.05 89 0575/0./:
:1.: :15
46.2/:
>2.6
;!
5 :15>57;>5 <;/:5/03
;@>: <;AA2::50 ./ 5>>;> 2/ >5C5<:2/= :15
5 7@>:15> <;/:5/050 :1.: :15
>2.6
;@>: <;@60 /;:
1.?5 5/:5>:.2/50 ./9 3:.:5A5/:3 A.05 89 :15 0575/0./:
-8-
; ! 2/ :15 B>2::5/ 3:.:5A5/: B1265 <;/3205>2/= ./
.4462<.:2;/ @/05>
>05>
@65
;7 :15
/
3@44;>: ;7 :123 <;/:5/:2;/ 15 >56250 @4;/ :15 7;66;B2/=
C@0=A5/:3
2'
!"
&
'(
22'
*
#
%$
$
) 15
65.>/50
3@8A2::50 :1.: :15
%
)
, - %
"
$
>2.6
$
<;@/356
7;>
+
)
0575/0./:
;!
;@>: 5/:5>:.2/50 :15 .4462<.:2;/
./0 1.3 <;/3205>50 ;/69 :15 .?5>A5/:3 A.05 2/ :15 46.2/:
./0 <.A5 :; :15 <;/<6@32;/ :1.: :15 46.2/:2773 1.?5 /;:
A.05 ;@: ./9 <.@35 ;7 .<:2;/
:15
15 2/?2:50 :15 .::5/:2;/ ;7
;@>: :; :15 .?5>A5/:3 A.05 2/ :15 46.2/: ./0
<;/:5/050 :1.: :15 46.2/:2773 <.:5=;>2<.669 05<6.>50 2/ :15
46.2/: :1.: :15 3@2: 4>;45>:253 3:;;0 2/ :15 /.A5 ;7
A:
.3@/0.>.
:15 A;:15>+2/+6.B ;7 46.2/:277
;
<;/:5/050 :1.: :15 46.2/:2773 .63; .0A2::50 :1.:
A:
-9-
.3@/01.>. 0@>2/= 15> 6275:2A5 1.0 5E5<@:50 . >565.35
0550 >565.32/= 15> 2/:5>53: 2/ >5345<: ;7 3@2: :5A
; ! 2/
7.?;@> ;7 0575/0./:
; ! ./0 1.0 5E5<@:50 . =27: 0550 2/
>5345<: ;7 3@2: :5A
;
#
2/ 7.?;@> ;7 0575/0./:
; ! ./0
15 :15>57;>5 <;/:5/03 :1.: :15 3@2: 4>;45>:253 852/=
:15 3567+.<F@2>50 4>;45>:253 ;7
A:
.3@/01.>. B5>5 15>
.83;6@:5 4>;45>:253 ./0 :1.: 89 ?2>:@5 ;7
2/0@
@<<5332;/
5<:2;/
;7 :15
<: 315 B.3 :15 7@66 ./0 .83;6@:5 ;B/5>
;7 :15 3@2: 4>;45>:253
15 <;/:5/03 :1.:
A:
.3@/01.>.
1.?2/= <;/?5950 :15 3@2: 4>;45>:253 :; :15 0575/0./:3 :15
46.2/:2773 1.0 /; <.@35 ;7 .<:2;/ :; 7265 . 3@2: 7;> 4.>:2:2;/
./0 354.>.:5 4;335332;/
>2.6
15 :15>57;>5 <;/:5/03 :1.: :15
;@>: .7:5> <;/3205>2/= :1535 .335>:2;/3 A.05 2/ :15
46.2/: 1.3 <;A5 :; :15 <;/<6@32;/ :1.: :15 46.2/:2773 1.?5
/;: A.05 ;@: ./9 <.@35 ;7 .<:2;/ :; 7265 7;> 4.>:2:2;/ ./0
:15>57;>5
/; 2/:5>75>5/<5 23 B.>>./:50 B2:1 :15 ;>05>
4.3350 89 :15 >2.6
;@>:
5 1.?5 <;/3205>50 :15 3@8A2332;/3 ;7 :15
65.>/50 <;@/356 7;> :15 46.2/:2773 ./0 :15 65.>/50 <;@/356
- 10 -
7;> 0575/0./:
;!
5 1.?5 .63; 45>@350 :15 2A4@=/50
;>05> .3 B566 .3 :15 >5<;>03 ;7 :15 >2.6
,
;@>:
15 ;/69 4;2/: :1.: .>2353 7;> ;@> <;/3205>.:2;/
23 GB15:15> :15
>05>
>2.6
@65
;@>: 1.0 5E5><2350 2:3 4;B5> @/05>
;7 :15
;/69 ;/ :15 8.323 ;7 :15
.335>:2;/3 A.05 2/ :15 46.2/: ;> B15:15> 2: 6;;D50 2/:; :15
.335>:2;/3
A.05
0575/0./:
;!
2/
:15
B>2::5/
>2.6
;@>: 31;B3
3:.:5A5/:HI
15 46.2/: 72650 857;>5 :15
:1.:
:15
46.2/:2773
<.:5=;>2<.669
4>;45>:253 3:;;0 2/ :15 /.A5 ;7
A;:15> ;7 0575/0./:
;3
3:.:50
:1.:
:15
3@2:
A:
.3@/01.>.
:15
! ./0 #
15 46.2/:2773 .63;
3:.:50 :1.: :15 >5<;>03 A.2/:.2/50 89 :15
7;> :15 95.> !
+!
31;B50 :15 /.A5 ;7
;>4;>.:2;/
! 2/ >5345<: ;7 :15 3@2: 4>;45>:253
A:
.3@/01.>. .3 :15 ;B/5> ./0
4;33533;> ;7 :15 3@2: 4>;45>:253
A:
2:9
159 .63; .0A2::50 :1.:
.3@/01.>. 1.0 5E5<@:50 . >565.35 0550 2/ >5345<:
;7 3@2:
:5A
; ! 2/ 7.?;@> ;7 0575/0./:
; ! ;/
- 11 -
!
!
! !
,!
./0 :1.: 315 1.0 5E5<@:50 . =27: 0550 0.:50
" 2/ >5345<: ;7 3@2:
./0
#
:5A
;
2/ 7.?;@> ;7
0575/0./:
;3 !
46.2/:2773
<6.2A50
0575/0./:
; ! 2/ <;66@32;/ B2:1 0575/0./:
;#
:1.:
1.0
<>5.:50 :15 =27: 0550 ./0 :15 >565.35 0550 :; @3@>4 :15
65=2:2A.:5 31.>5 ;7 :15 46.2/:2773 2/ :15 3@2: 4>;45>:253
6.2/:2773 <6.2A50 :1.: :15 1@38./0 ;7 46.2/:277
;
7.:15> ;7 46.2/:277
' .63; 1.0 .
;3 ! ./0 # &0575/0./:
31.>5 2/ :15 3@2: 4>;45>:253
.3 :; 1;B 0575/0./:
;
;B5?5> :159 020 /;: 023<6;35
1.0 . 31.>5 2/ :15 3@2:
4>;45>:253 0@>2/= :15 6275:2A5 ;7
:>2:5 :1.: @/05>
5<:2;/
;
./0 :15
;7 :15
, ) :15 4>;45>:9 ;7 . 75A.65
A:
2/0@
.3@/01.>.
: 23
@<<5332;/
<:
2/0@ B15:15> .<F@2>50
857;>5 ;> .7:5> :15 <;AA5/<5A5/: ;7 :15
<: 31.66 85 15>
.83;6@:5 4>;45>:9
>2.6
;@>: 1.3 <;/3205>50 :15 .8;?5
.?5>A5/:3 ./0 1.3 1560 :1.: :15 46.2/:2773 1.?5 .0A2::50
:1.: :15 3@2: 4>;45>:253 3:;;0 2/ :15 /.A5 ;7
A:
.3@/01.>. ./0 :15>57;>5 :15 46.2/:2773 B5>5 /;: 5/:2:650
- 12 -
:; ./9 31.>5 2/ :15 3@2: 4>;45>:253 .3
A:
1.0 .6>5.09 <;/?5950 :15A :; 0575/0./:
.3@/01.>.
;3 ! ./0 # 89
B.9 ;7 =27: 0550 ./0 >565.35 0550 >575>>50 .8;?5
>2=1:69 1560 89 :15
>2.6
;@>:
:15>5 B.3 /; <.@35 ;7
.<:2;/ 7;> :15 46.2/:2773 :; 3@5 7;> 4.>:2:2;/ 2/ >5345<: ;7 :15
4>;45>:253 :1.: 856;/=50 :;
A:
.3@/01.>. ./0 15/<5 2:
>2=1:69 5E5><2350 C@>2302<:2;/ @/05>
:15
:; >5C5<: :15 46.2/:
>05>
@65
: 020 /;:
&.' ;7
5?5/ 7;> .
A;A5/: <;/3205> :15 .335>:2;/3 A.05 89 0575/0./:
;!
2/
7;>
:15
B>2::5/
3:.:5A5/:
15>57;>5
:15
4;2/:
<;/3205>.:2;/ 7>.A50 89 @3 23 ./3B5>50 .<<;>02/=69
!
/ :1.: ?25B ;7 :15 A.::5>
B5 .>5 ;7 :15
;42/2;/ :1.: :15
>2.6
;@>: B.3 >2=1: 2/ 5E5><232/= 4;B5>
@/05>
@65
&.' ;7 :15
>05>
./0 >5C5<:2/= :15
46.2/: ;/ :15 =>;@/0 :1.: 2: 020 /;: 023<6;35 ./9 <.@35 ;7
.<:2;/
5/<5 :15 4;2/: 7;> <;/3205>.:2;/ 7>.A50 89 @3 23
./3B5>50 .<<;>02/=69 ./0 :15 .445.6 23
$
$
- 13 -
#
15>5 31.66 85 /; ;>05>3 .3 :; <;3:3
)&
%
'
)&
%
23:
;
;
!
$
'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review