Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SHAMURAILATPAM SUSHIL
SHARMA
SHARMA
Date: 2023.06.22 13:37:04 +05'30'
Page |1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
MC (WP(C)) No.119 of 2023
Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023
The Shija Academy of Health Services, of Health Village,
Langol through its Director, P.O. & P.S. Lamphel, Imphal
West District, Manipur -795004.
-Applicant/Respondent No. 4.
-Versus1. Sh. Tomba Sharma, aged about 62 years, S/o.
(L) Sh. Dhojo Sharma of Kakwa Naorem Leikai, P.O. &
P.S. Singjamei, Imphal West District, Manipur -795008.
2. M. Zamchinthang, aged about 62 years, S/o.
(Late) Paukhokam of Paite Colony Laimanai Langol,
P.O. & P.S. Lamphel, Imphal West District, Manipur
- 795008.
3.
Khundongbam Bimol Singh, aged about 57
years, S/o. (Late) Kh. Nongyai Singh of Heirok Part —
IT Bazar, Laikol Leirak, Thoubal P.O. & P.S. Thoubal,
Thoubal District, Manipur- 795138.
4. Huidrom Singhajit Singh, aged about 47 years, S/o.
H. Ibosana Singh of Langmeidong Bazar, P.O. &
P.S. Waikhong, Kakching District, Manipur- 795103.
5. Yumnam (Ongbi) Anita Leima, aged about 51 years,
W/o. Y. Senior Singh of Kwakeithel Akham Leikai, P.O.
Imphal & P.S. Singjamei, Imphal West District, Manipur
-795008.
MC (WP(C)) No. 119 of 2023 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023)
Page |2
6. Loitongbam (O) Shanti Devi aged about 42 years,
W/o. L. Nilakanta Singh of Kwakeithel Konjeng Leikai,
P.O. Imphal& P.S. Singjamei, Imphal West District,
Manipur-795008.
7. Khomdram Shanti Devi, aged about 64 years, W/o.
R.K. Somorjit Singh of Keishamthong Elangbam Leikai,
P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur 795001.
8. Masida Begum, aged about 43 years, W/o. Tamijur
Shah of Hatta Golapati, P.O, & P.S. Porompat, Imphal
East District, Manipur- 795005.
9. Khundrakpam (Ongbi) Meena Devi, aged about 41
years, W/o. Kh. Anupam of Yaiskul Jamasthan, P.O. &
P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur -795001.
10. Association of Parents of 1st Batch State Quota
MBBS Students in SAHS (2021-2022), through its
President Shri. Sh. Tomba Sharma.
-Respondents/Petitioners.
11. The State of Manipur represented by the Addl. Chief
Secretary, Health & Family Welfare Department,
Government of Manipur, New Secretariat Block, P.O. &
P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur – 795001.
MC (WP(C)) No. 119 of 2023 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023)
Page |3
12. The Deputy Secretary, Health & Family Welfare
Department, Government of Manipur, New Secretariat
Block, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District,
Manipur -795001.
13. The State Fee Regularity Committee, through its
Chairman, the Addl. Chief Secretary, Health & Family
Welfare Department, Government of Manipur, New
Secretariat Block, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West
District, Manipur -795001.
14. The National Medical Commission, through its
Secretary, Pocket 14, Phase I, Dwarka, Sector 8, New
Delhi- 110077.
- Respondents.
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE M.V. MURALIDARAN
For the Applicants
::
Mr. I. Lalitkumar, Sr. Adv
Mr. I. Denning, Adv.
For the Respondents
No. 1 to 10
::
Mr. N. Ibotombi, Sr. Adv.
For the Respondents
No. 11 to 13
::
Mrs. Ch. Sundari,GA
For the Respondents
No. 14
::
Mr. BR Sharma, Sr.PCCG
Date of Hearing and
reserving Judgment & Order ::
12.06.2023
Date of Judgment & Order ::
21.06.2023
MC (WP(C)) No. 119 of 2023 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023)
Page |4
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(CAV)
Heard Mr. I. Lalitkumar, learned senior counsel
for the applicant; Mr. N. Ibotombi, learned senior counsel for
the respondents 1 to 10; Mrs. Ch. Sundari Devi, learned
Government Advocate for the respondents 11 to 13 and Mr.BR
Sharma, learned Sr. PCCG for respondent No.14.
2.
This miscellaneous case has been filed by the
applicant, who is the fourth respondent in the writ petition,
under Article 226(3) of the Constitution of India to vacate the
interim order dated 2.3.2013 passed in the writ petition.
3.
For proper adjudication, the interim order dated
2.3.2023 is extracted hereunder:
“[1] Heard Mr. N.Ibotombi, learned senior
counsel for the petitioner and Mrs. Ch.
Sundari, learned GA for the respondents
No.1, 2 and 3 and Mr. BR Sharma, learned
Sr. PCCG for the respondent No.5.
[2] Learned counsels for the respondents
seeks time for filing counter affidavit.
[3] Therefore, post the matters on 11.4.2023.
MC (WP(C)) No. 119 of 2023 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023)
Page |5
[4] Till such time, there shall be an order of
interim stay
staying
the
Notice
dated
06.02.2022 (Annexure-A/7).
[5] Petitioner is directed to take steps to the
respondent No.4 returnable by 11.04.2023.”
4.
The respondents 1 to 10/writ petitioners have
filed the writ petition with the following prayers:
(i)
to admit this writ petition;
(ii)
to issue a rule nisi;
(iii)
to issue a writ in the nature of Certiorari
for quashing the Fees Structures for
Undergoing MBBS Course for the year
2021-2022 fixed by the Shija Academy of
Health Sciences, Langol as the same is
against the Office Memorandum dated
03/02/2022
issued
by
the
National
Medical Commission and also the letter
dated 20/10/2022 issued by the Deputy
Secretary (Health & Family Welfare),
Government of Manipur.
(iv)
to issue a writ in the nature of Certiorari
for quashing the notice dated 06/02/2022
issued by the Respondent No.4 Academy
as the same was issue din complete
violation of the Office Memorandum
dated 03/02/2022 issued by the National
Medical Commission and also the letter
dated 20/10/2022 issued by the Deputy
MC (WP(C)) No. 119 of 2023 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023)
Page |6
Secretary (Health & Family Welfare),
Government of Manipur.
(v)
to issue a writ in the nature of Mandamus
directing the Respondents to fix the Fee
Structure for Undergoing MBBS Course
in Shija Academy of Health Sciences,
Langol for the Academic Session 20212022 at par with the Fee Structures of
MBBS Course at Shija Academy of
Health
Sciences,
Langol
for
the
Academic Session 2022-2023 and Office
Memorandum dated 03/02/2022 issued
by the National Medical Commission of
India and also the letter dated 20/10/2022
issued by the Deputy Secretary (Health &
Family Welfare), Government of Manipur.
(vi)
in the interim, to pass an order either for
staying the Notice dated 06/02/2022
(Annexure-A/7) or to allow the students of
2021-2022 batch to pay their tuition fees
at par with the tuition fees of the students
of 2022-2023 batch till the disposal of the
case.”
5.
The impugned notice dated 06.02.2022 issued
by the applicant college reads thus:
“NOTICE
6th February, 2022
No.SAHS/Acad-001/23-90:
It
is
hereby
informed to all the MBBS students of Shija
MC (WP(C)) No. 119 of 2023 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023)
Page |7
Academy of Health Sciences, Langol, Imphal
(2021-22 batches) to clear 2nd Year’s tuition,
hostel and mess fees (for 1st semester) on or
before 15th March, 2023.
Available Mode of Payment:
1. NEFT/RTGS
2. Cheque
3. Demand Draft
4. Bank Deposit
Bank Details:
A/C No.120000537573
A/C Name – SHIJA ACADEMY OF HEALTH
SCIENCES
IFSC – CNRB0003955
CANARA
BANK,
IMPHAL
BRANCH,
THANGAL BAZAR
N.B. Any other mode of payment other than
above mentioned will summarily be rejected.
(Dr. M.Amuba Singh)
DIRECTOR
Shija Academy of Health
Sciences,
Langol, Imphal-795004”
6.
Aggrieved by the interim order dated 2.3.2023
passed by this Court staying the notice dated 6.2.2022, the
applicant College has filed the present miscellaneous case to
vacate the said interim order contending that without giving an
MC (WP(C)) No. 119 of 2023 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023)
Page |8
opportunity of being heard, the interim order was passed on
2.3.2023 against the applicant ex parte and the same needs
to be re-considered and re-examined by this Court to protect
the rule of law so as to enable to survive and maintain the
newly established medical college for the best interest of all
concerned.
7.
Mr. I. Lalitkuma, the learned senior counsel for
the applicant submitted that the applicant college is the first
home grown private medical college in the North Eastern India
at Manipur in the year 2021 with the permission and approval
of the concerned authorities of the State of Manipur.
Accordingly, the first session for the first batch of 150 students
started from 14.2.2022 and the State Fee Fixation Committee,
Manipur, allotted 63 seats for the State Government quota and
fixed the annual tuition fee at Rs.8 lakh for the academic
session 2021-2022, for which the authorities of the State
Government had issued an order relating to seat sharing
percentage and the fee structure for the academic year 20212022. The learned senior counsel would submit that such fee
structure fixed by the Government of Manipur was accepted
by all concerned, including the respondents 1 to 10 without
any complaint and dispute for first batch was almost
MC (WP(C)) No. 119 of 2023 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023)
Page |9
completed and the first batch is now undergoing the second
year MBBS course.
8.
The learned senior counsel further submitted that
running a newly established private medical college would be
largely dependent upon the fees of the students for quality
education and infrastructure and the college management is
still trying to cater to the needs of the MBBS students in the
college wherever it is necessary as per the norms and
guidelines of the Medical Council of India, which is now
substituted by the National Medical Commission, 2019 with
the approval of the State Government as well as the other
authority applicable in this regard. The applicant college is
continuing with its available minimum infrastructure after the
issuance of the Government letter dated 13.12.2021.
Exercising power under Section 10(1)(i) of the
National
Commission Act, 2019, an Office Memorandum dated
3.2.2022 was issued by the National Medical Commission,
which resulted in issuing the letter dated 20.10.2022 by the
Deputy Director (Health and Family Welfare), Government of
Manipur, to the Director of Health Services, Manipur, without
superseding the fee structures fixed vide Government letter
dated 13.12.2021.
MC (WP(C)) No. 119 of 2023 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023)
P a g e | 10
9.
The learned senior counsel next submitted that
the applicant college is the first private unaided medical
college having very highly reputed hospital in the North East
Region of India and since the college management requires
financial
support
from
the
Government
as
their
nominees/students have taken 63/64 seats of each alternate
years, the Chairman/Managing Director of the college has
submitted a representation dated 17.1.2022 to the Additional
Chief Secretary, Health and Family Welfare, Government of
Manipur requesting to provide necessary financial support and
despite receipt of the said representation, the same has not
been considered till date. Thus, the learned senior counsel
submitted that the ex parte interim order passed by this Court
is causing hardship to the applicant college and, therefore, the
same is liable to be vacated.
10.
Per contra, Mr. N. Ibotombi, the learned senior
counsel appearing for the respondents 1 to 10/writ petitioners
submitted that the fee structure fixed by the State Government
for the academic year 2021-2022 in respect of the State
Government quota was on the basis of the proposal made by
the applicant college.
He would submit that on the
recommendation of the State Fee Regulatory Committee and
MC (WP(C)) No. 119 of 2023 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023)
P a g e | 11
in compliance with the Office Memorandum dated 3.2.2022,
the State Government had fixed Rs.45,700/- as fee of the
State Government quota for admission to the applicant college
for the academic session 2022-2023 subject to the outcome of
the writ petition now pending before the Hon’ble Apex Court.
11.
The learned senior counsel for the respondents
1 to 10 urged that in the case of the students who were
admitted in the State Government quota for the academic
session 2021-2022, the authority can fix the fee structure at
par with the fee structure of the students of 2022-2023 subject
to the outcome of the writ petition pending before the Hon’ble
Apex Court. According to the learned senior counsel, the fee
structure for Government nominated students in the private
medical college in other States are lower than the fee fixed by
the applicant college. In fact, for admission to the AIIMS, a
sum of Rs.5,856/- has been fixed as fee and for the admission
to Armed Force Medical College, Pune, the fee fixed is about
Rs.30,000/-.
12.
The learned senior counsel further submitted that
the fee structure for students under the Government quota for
academic session 2021-2022 in respect of the applicant
college was fixed as tuition fee at Rs.8 lakh per year excluding
MC (WP(C)) No. 119 of 2023 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023)
P a g e | 12
one-time admission fee at Rs.75,000/- and caution deposit at
Rs.25,000/- and at Rs.4 lakh payable per semester from third
semester onwards upto the completion of the course. The
applicant college has not taken into account the Office
Memorandum dated 3.2.2022 issued by the National Medical
Commission and also the letter dated 20.10.2022 issued by
the Deputy Secretary (Health & Family Welfare), Government
of Manipur. Arguing so, the learned senior counsel for the
respondents 1 to 10 prays for dismissal of the miscellaneous
case with a direction on the applicant college to collect the fee
from the students of the year 2021-2022 batch at par with the
fees paid by the students of 2022-2023 batch.
13.
This Court also heard the submissions of the
learned Government Advocate and the panel counsel for the
National Medical Commission.
14.
Considered the rival submissions and also
perused the materials available on record.
15.
It is not in dispute that the applicant college was
established in the year 2021 with the approval of the
competent authorities of the State and Central Governments
and the first session for the first batch of 150 students was
started from 14.2.2022. The State Fee Fixation Committee,
MC (WP(C)) No. 119 of 2023 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023)
P a g e | 13
Manipur, allotted 63 seats for the State Government quota
fixing the annual tuition fee at Rs.8 lakh for the academic
session 2021-2022. In this regard, the Deputy Secretary of the
Health and Family Welfare, Government of Manipur,
addressed a letter to the Director of Health Services and the
applicant college qua seat sharing and the fee structure for the
academic year 2021-2022.
16.
For
proper
adjudication,
the
letter
13.12.2021 is quoted hereunder for ready reference:
“MED-506/31/2021-HS-HEALTH
GOVERNMENT OF MANIPUR
SECRETARIAT : HEALTH DEPARTMENT
Imphal, the 13th of December, 2021
1.Director of Health Services, Manipur.
2.Chairman
&
Managing
Director,
Shija
Hospitals and Research Institute, Langol.
Subject: Seat sharing percentage for MBBS
seats – Regarding.
Sir,
In
inviting
a
reference
to
letter
no.SAHS/006/2021, dated 04.12.2021 and in
partial modification of this Government letter of
even number dated 30/11/2021 on the above
MC (WP(C)) No. 119 of 2023 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023)
dated
P a g e | 14
subject, I am directed to convey approval of the
Government of the following in respect of Shija
Academy of Health Sciences:
1. Seat Sharing Arrangement:
Sharing of MBBS seats between the State
Government and the Management shall be 50%
of the total number of seats available after
deducting 15% NRI Quota. Thus, the seat
sharing for the Academic year 2021-22 shall be
as under:
Sl. No. Category
Share
(%)
Number of Seats
State
Government
quota
Managem 43
ent quota
NRI
quota
Total
Further, number
of
seats
between
State
Government Quota and Management Quota
shall be alternately 63 and 64 seats for each
Academic year.
2. Fee Structure: The fee structure for various
categories of seats proposed by Shija Academy
of Health Sciences are approved as under:
Sl.
No.
Category
Tuition fee
(Annual)
State
Government
quota
Rs.8,00,000
Admission
fee
(one
time)
Rs.75,000
Caution fee
(one time)
Rs.25,000
MC (WP(C)) No. 119 of 2023 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023)
Full Course
Fee for NRI
-
P a g e | 15
Management
quota
NRI quota
Rs.19,00,000
Rs.75,000
Rs.25,000
$ 2,00,000
(for
full
course)
3. Reservation Policy:
Reservation policy notified by the State
Government shall be adopted for seats
available under State Government quota.
However, Management of Shija Academy of
Health Sciences shall adopt the guidelines of
NMC/MCI or any other applicable guidelines
for the reservation of seats falling under the
category of Management Quota and NRI
Quota.
Yours faithfully,
(Dr.Yumnam Suraj Singh)
Deputy Director (Health &
FW)
Government of Manipur”
17.
From the above said letter, it is clear that the fee
structure for various categories of seats proposed by the
applicant college was approved by the Deputy Director (Health
and Family Welfare), Government of Manipur, as also the seat
sharing for the academic year 2021-2022. Accepting such fee
structure, the students allotted for the State Government
quota, including the sons/daughters of the respondents 1 to
10/writ petitioners, who are the then first batch, have paid the
fee without any objection and/or protest.
MC (WP(C)) No. 119 of 2023 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023)
P a g e | 16
18.
It appears that the National Medical Commission
had issued guidelines through the Office Memorandum dated
3.2.2022 of the Secretary, National Medical Commission,
wherein, it has been, inter alia, stated as under:
“4. It is also anticipated that in newly
established medical colleges the overheads
like interest, depreciation and salary would
be very high in comparison to old established
medical colleges.
There may be a case
where no audited balance sheet would be
available with the college (being its first year).
In such a case, the determination of fee for a
newly established college should be made on
an ad-hoc basis, based on the fee structure
of the most recently established medical
college in the State, whose audited balance
sheets were available. ……
6. The fees can be fixed for a block of three
years or on a year-to-year basis. The fee
fixed for a student joining a college in a
particular year should remain the same for
the entire duration of his study in the college,
subject to inflation adjustment, as considered
appropriate by the State Fee Regulatory
Authority, which could for example be at the
rate of 5% or on the basis of Consumer Price
Index (CPI), on a whichever is higher basis.
MC (WP(C)) No. 119 of 2023 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023)
P a g e | 17
8. … However, if a hospital is running at a
loss in the initial days of a newly established
college, it may need to be supported for a few
years so that it can turn the corner. If the
hospital shuts down suddenly for lack of
funds, the future of the already enrolled
students may be jeopardised. This cannot,
however, be a blank cheque to burden the
students of a college indefinitely. Thus, a
time limit of say 5-7 years could be put for
absorbing, the losses of a hospital by the
students by way of increased fees. In the
alternative, if the State Fee Regulatory
Authority judges that a hospital cannot be run
on a self/sustaining basis for a much longer
term, especially if it is located in a poor and
backward part of the State, up to 20% of the
costs of the hospital could be added to the
operating costs of the medical college for a
limited number of years. In earlier case, the
State Regulatory Authorities would need to
satisfy themselves fully from the segmented
accounts submitted by an institution and the
final decision should be left to them.
9. Salaries of the teaching, staff and other
non-teaching staff should be taken into
account for the purpose of determination of
fees for medical education. …”
MC (WP(C)) No. 119 of 2023 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023)
P a g e | 18
12. Interest cost on the loan(s) taken for
meeting the capital expenditure in respect of
a medical college could be taken into account
only if the loans are taken from scheduled
commercial
banks
and
not
promoters or private parties.
from
the
Similarly,
interest costs of a loan taken from a
scheduled bank for meeting the working
capital requirements may also be taken into
account for the purpose of computation of
fees.
13. In order to consider interest cost for fee
fixation, only a loan which is directly
attributable to a medical college and/or the
hospital, should be taken into consideration
which calculating fees. …..
21. Hostel, mess, transport, library, and
examination fees etc., could be arrived at
broadly based on the actual expenses
incurred for providing these services and the
number of students availing these facilities.
Expenses which are common and not directly
identifiable
should
be
apportioned
on
equitable basis to different activities for
arriving at the cost of providing different
facilities.
Utilising the hostel, mess and
transport facilities by students is entirely
optional and students who do not utilise
MC (WP(C)) No. 119 of 2023 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023)
P a g e | 19
these facilities are not to be charged for
them.
25. The State FRC may required the private
medical
colleges
and
deemed
to
be
Universities to publish on their website a
prospectus containing the annual audited
accounts along with the schedules forming
part of the accounts, details in respect of
names of the teaching, faculty (full time, part
time, guest faculty etc. as well as their
qualifications) and other details relating to the
hospital, hostel, mess, transpor6t and library
expenses.”
19.
Assailing Section 10(1)(i) of the National Medical
Commission Act, 2019 and the Office Memorandum dated
3.2.2022, a batch of writ petitions were filed before the Madras
High Court in W.P.No.10088 of 2022 etc. By a common order
dated 9.9.2022, a Division Bench of the Madras High Court
held as under:
“48. Learned Additional Solicitor General
submitted that the purpose of bringing
Section 10(1)(i) of the Act of 2019 is to
regulate the fee of 50% of the seats of the
management quota, as otherwise the fee of
the first 50% of seats is to be at par with the
fee of the students in the government
MC (WP(C)) No. 119 of 2023 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023)
P a g e | 20
medical colleges.
The
fees would
be
regulated in the same manner as was
obtaining before bringing the Act of 2019 and
thereby it was submitted that the Office
Memorandum is basically to regulate the fee
of 50% of the management quota seats.
49. We do not find a clarification of that
nature in the Office Memorandum and
otherwise it rigidly talks about the fee for first
50% of seats at par with the fee in the
government medical colleges. A perusal of
the fee structure of different States given in
the report of the Expert Committee would
show
a
meagre
fee
charged
in
the
government medical colleges for the reason
that it is subsidized by the government out of
the money of the tax payer. The government
is not subsidizing it for the private medical
colleges and by virtue of it, if the Office
Memorandum would operate, the 50% of the
students would pay fee at par with the fee in
the government medical colleges, which
even as per the report of the Expert
Committee would be one-sixth or one-tenth
of the fee charged from the students taking
admission against the management quota
seats. The result of the aforesaid would be
nothing but cross-subsidizing of the fee by
one set of students for another set, which
MC (WP(C)) No. 119 of 2023 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023)
P a g e | 21
was the position obtaining after the case of
Unni Krishnan J.P. and others, supra. The
Apex Court in the subsequent judgments in
the cases of T.M.A.Pai Foundation and
others, Islamic Academy of Education and
another, and P.A.Inamdar, supra, did not
approve
the
aforesaid.
In
the
recent
judgment in the case of Modern Dental
College and Research Centre and others,
supra,
while
Commission
the
is
National
allowed
to
Medical
bring
the
regulation, it was not to cross-subsidize the
fee of one set of students by another.
50. In view of the above, there is a need for
the National Medical Commission to give a
re-look to the Office Memorandum under
challenge, when it would be operating not in
one State, but in all the States of the country
having different seat matrix arrangement as
well as fee structure for government quota
and management quota seats. The aforesaid
has been elaborately referred by the Expert
Committee in its report. In few States, the
management quota seats are limited to 15%
and the government quota seats are at 85%
and
in
variation,
in
few
States,
the
government quota seats were 30% and the
remaining were management quota seats,
apart from NRI quota, etc. The intention
MC (WP(C)) No. 119 of 2023 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023)
P a g e | 22
behind bringing Section 10(1)(i) of the Act of
2019 is to determine the fee of the
management quota seats, which was earlier
determined by the Committee headed by the
Retired High Court Judge.
51. In view of the foregoing discussion, we
find reason to direct the National Medical
Commission
to
re-visit
the
Office
Memorandum dated 3.2.2022 in the light of
the observations made by us and if the
intention of the Parliament was to make
provision for determining the fee structure for
all the seats in the medical colleges, then to
amend Section 10(1)(i) of the Act of 2019
appropriately. However, the provision now
operating and held to be constitutionally valid
allows the National Medical Commission to
regulate fee of 50% of seats and if such
regulation of fee is permitted in regard to the
management quota seats, then the Office
Memorandum under challenge can operate,
but the question would be for determination
of fee for the remaining 50% seats to be at
par with the fee in the government medical
colleges. To avoid confusion of any nature, it
would be appropriate for the respondents to
take a decision on it at the earliest so that a
proper fee structure is determined for the
MC (WP(C)) No. 119 of 2023 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023)
P a g e | 23
students, which may not result in cross
subsidization of fees.
52. The aforesaid is required even for the
reason that if there would be a huge
difference of the fee structure between two
sets of students, then it may even result in
sacrificing the merit of the candidates in view
of the fact that after filling of first 50% of seats
of government quota at par with the fee of the
government medical colleges, the remaining
would be offered to the next meritorious
candidate
and
if the
next
meritorious
candidate is not in a position to bear the
burden of high fee, he/she would be unable
to take admission in the medical college and
then the seat would go to the next meritorious
candidate, who may be below the caliber of
the candidate who could not afford to pay
high fee. This would ultimately result in
sacrificing the merit and the worst scenario
would be when no candidate down in the
merit list is ready to take the burden of paying
high fee and the seat remains vacant, which
would be a loss to the institution and the
nation.
53. The aforesaid aspects have not been
taken into consideration by the Expert
Committee while making recommendation,
though it has undertaken extensive work not
MC (WP(C)) No. 119 of 2023 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023)
P a g e | 24
only for collection of data from different
States, but even considering the suggestions
and objections from the medical colleges.
The
Expert
Committee
recommendation,
while
however,
making
could
not
visualize that if there would be huge different
in the fee structure between two sets of
students, it may result in sacrificing the merit.
54. In the result, the writ petitions are
disposed of with the direction that in the light
of the observations and finding recorded in
the preceding paragraphs, the National
Medical Commission should at the earliest
come out with a fresh Office Memorandum
after
giving
a
re-look
to
the
Office
Memorandum under challenge. Till the
exercise aforesaid is undertaken, the fee
structure may be governed by the present
system.”
20.
The provision of Section 10(1)(i) of the National
Commission Act and the Office Memorandum dated 3.2.2022
were also assailed before the Kerala High Court in W.P.(C)
No.24112 of 2022 etc. batch and, by the order dated
19.8.2022, the learned Single Judge of the Kerala High Court
held as under:
MC (WP(C)) No. 119 of 2023 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023)
P a g e | 25
“30. As I have already said above, the sole
quandary in the "OM", as far as Kerala is
concerned, is with respect to the fixing of fees
in 50% seats in the Private Medical Colleges
and Deemed Universities, to be "on par" with
that fixed by the Government for the seats in
the Government Medical Colleges. If the
"OM" is directed to be enforced in such
manner, it will indubitably lead to a piquant
predicament where the fees for the balance
50% seats in the said colleges will have to be
escalated
because,
otherwise,
the
institutions cannot sustain, especially since,
even as on today, the AFRC is fixing the
minimum requisite fee for all students taking
into account infrastructural investments,
future prospects and such other criteria as
are statutorily mandated, but ensuring that
there is absolutely no leeway for profiteering
in any manner.
31. Ironically, viewed from the correct
perspective, the implementation of the afore
mandate of the "OM" would be highly
iniquitous in Kerala, because it expects the
benefits of subsidisation to flow to the
students
in
the
"Government
quota",
presumably under the often presumed
impression that such students are more
meritorious; but on our State there is no such
MC (WP(C)) No. 119 of 2023 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023)
P a g e | 26
quota and every student allotted to a Private
Institution or Deemed University is "on par"
with those allotted to the Government
Colleges and all such allotments are made by
the Commissioner of Entrance Examinations
alone. Hence it would also be an impossibility
in our state to enforce the "OM" to the
aforementioned extent since all students in
the Colleges and Deemed Universities are
identically placed, it being even if possible being arbitrary and discriminatory.
32. I am certain that the "NMC" never
intended that their "OM" should be used to
either cross-subsidise education -- which is
expressly
proscribed
by
the
Hon'ble
Supreme Court; or to burden one section of
students at the cost of the other, though they
are all similarly, if not identically, situated and
placed in Kerala, after the year 2017, when
the "Kerala Medical Education Act" came into
being.
In the afore circumstances,
(a)
W.P.(C).No.5851
of
and
W.P.(C).No.24112 of 2022 are ordered,
directing the AFRC to implicitly abide by all
the "guidelines" postulated by the NMC in
their Office Memorandum dated 03.02.2022,
while fixing the fees for all seats in all Private
MC (WP(C)) No. 119 of 2023 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023)
P a g e | 27
Medical
Colleges
and
Deemed-to-be
Universities in Kerala except the stipulation
therein for fixing the fee of 50% of the seats
in the Private Medical Colleges or Deemed
Universities on par with the seats in the
Government Medical Colleges.
(b) Consequential to the declarations above,
which I reiteratingly clarify are in the context
of the State of Kerala alone, W.P(C).No.5503
of 2022 will also stand ordered, but to the
afore extent.
(c) It is reiteratingly clarified that this Court
has not struck down Section 10(1)(i) of the
"NMC Act"; and therefore, that all contentions
with respect to the same are left open to be
impelled by any person or entity, including
the petitioners herein, if it becomes so
warranted in future.”
21.
It appears that challenging the order of the
Division Bench of the Madras High Court in W.P.No.10088 of
2022 etc. batch, the National Medical Commission has filed
SLP (C) Nos.21002-21009 of 2022 before the Apex Court and
the same are pending. From the website, it is seen that the
said SLPs are likely to be listed on 04.07.2023.
It also
appears that several cases of similar nature were considered
MC (WP(C)) No. 119 of 2023 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023)
P a g e | 28
by different High Courts in the country. Since the matter is
under consideration of the Apex Court, this Court has not
make any observation and consider the scope of Section
10(1)(i) of the National Medical Commission Act, 2019 and the
Office Memorandum dated 3.2.2022.
22.
Coming to the applicant college, it started
functioning from 14.2.2022 and the Deputy Secretary
conveyed the approval of seat sharing and fee structure in
respect of the applicant college and, accordingly, they have
admitted the students i.e. 63 seats allotted for State
Government quota by collecting Rs.8 lakh for the academic
session 2021, which was admittedly approved by the
Government of Manipur. Therefore, this Court is of the prima
facie view that no fault can be attributed against the applicant
college for collecting the fee of Rs.8 lakh in respect of State
Government quota for the academic year 2021-2022.
23.
The argument of learned senior counsel for the
applicant that the starting and running a newly established
private medical college would be largely dependent upon the
fees of the students for providing quality education and
infrastructure, and it is the duty of the college management to
cater to the needs of MBBS students studying in the college,
MC (WP(C)) No. 119 of 2023 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023)
P a g e | 29
which are provided by the applicant college without any
complaint.
It is also the argument of the learned senior
counsel for the applicant that it is not the case of the writ
petitioners that there is lack of proper teaching and
infrastructure facilities in the applicant college.
24.
It is to be pointed out that securing good marks
by the students who are pursuing their MBBS course is not
only appreciable for the students and such efforts are the
credit of the teaching staff both for theory and practical, for
which the college management requires to maintain best
teachers as well as necessary infrastructure facilities. When
there is no complaint from any corner with regard to imparting
education and infrastructure facilities available in the applicant
college, it is to be presumed that the applicant college is
having all facilities, including the teaching and non-teaching
staff and the students of the applicant college are pursuing
their MBBS courses without any complaint. Thus, it is clear
that based on the letter of the Government of Manipur dated
13.12.2021, the applicant college is running with its available
infrastructure facilities.
25.
It is apposite to mention that the 63 seats meant
for Government quota students were fully aware of the fee
MC (WP(C)) No. 119 of 2023 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023)
P a g e | 30
structure of MBBS course at the applicant college for the batch
of 2021-2022 even before counselling and admission. Those
students who were in the merit list but could not afford the fees
of the applicant college withdrew themselves at the time of
counselling. Thus, the students were fully aware of the fees
for the session 2021-2022 and admitted themselves on their
own volition with full consent without raising any nature of
objection.
26.
The case of the writ petitioners is that the fee
structure fixed by the State Government for admission of
students in the State Government quota in the applicant
college for the academic session 2022-2023, which was
issued in consonance with the Office Memorandum dated
3.2.2022, should be made applicable to the students who were
admitted in the applicant college under the State Government
quota for the academic session 2021-2022. In support, the
writ petitioners have relied upon the letter of the Deputy
Secretary (Health and Family Welfare), Government of
Manipur dated 20.10.2022.
27.
For proper appreciation, the letter of the Deputy
Secretary (Health and Family Welfare), Government of
Manipur, dated is quoted hereunder for ready reference:
MC (WP(C)) No. 119 of 2023 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023)
P a g e | 31
MED-506/31/2021-HS-HEALTH
GOVERNMENT OF MANIPUR
SECRETARIAT : HEALTH DEPARTMENT
Imphal, the 20th October, 2022
To
Director of Health Services, Manipur.
Subject: Fee structure of MNNS course at
SAHS, Langol for the academic session
2022-23 – reg.
Sir,
In
inviting
a
reference
No.104/CMC/DHS/2021
(Pt
to
letter
I)
dated
17/10/2022 on the above subject, I am
directed
to
convey
approval
of
the
Government of the following in respect of
Shija Academy of Health Sciences for the
year 2022-23:
Seat Sharing Arrangement:
Sl No.
Category
State
Government
Quota
Management
Quota
NRI
Quota
Total
Numbers
of seats
MC (WP(C)) No. 119 of 2023 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023)
P a g e | 32
Fee Structure: The fee structure for various
categories of seats proposed by Shija
Academy of Health Sciences are approved
as under:
Sl. Category
No.
Management
Quota
NRI Quota
Tuition fee
Rs.19,00,000
Admission
fee
Rs.75,000
Caution
money
Rs.25,000
$ 2,00,000 (one time)
Fee structure of State Government Quota:
Sl
No.
Particular
Amount
Admission Fee
Tuition Fee
Library Fee
Laboratory Fee
Blazer Fee
Health Care
Hostel Fee
Games Fee
College Cultural
Fee
Magazine Fee
University
Enrolment Fee
University
Games fee
University
Cultural Fee
Hostel Caution
money
(Refundable)
Laboratory
Caution money
(Refundable)
Mess
Caution
money
Security Deposit
(Refundable)
Rs.4,000/Rs.6,000/Rs.1,000/Rs.2,000/Rs.5,500/Rs.2,000/Rs.7,000/Rs.2,000/Rs.1,500/Rs.1,000/Rs.100/Rs.200/Rs.100/Rs.1,000/-
Rs.1,000/-
Rs.2,000/Rs.1,000/-
MC (WP(C)) No. 119 of 2023 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023)
Total
Rs.20,00,000
P a g e | 33
Total
College
Examination Fee
House T-Shirt
Apron (2)
Annual Meet
Union Fees
Rs.3,000/Rs.2,000/Rs.3,000/Rs.300/Rs.45,200
The fee structure for State Government
quota seats, Management quota seats and
NRI quota seats shall be subject to the
outcome of the petition filed before the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India.
Reservation Policy:
Reservation policy notify by the State
Government shall be adopted for seats
available under State Government quota,
However, Management of Shija Academy of
Health Sciences shall adopt the guidelines of
NMC/MCI or any other applicable guidelines
for the reservation of seats falling under the
category of Management Quota and NRI.
Yours faithfully,
(Dr.Yumnam Suraj Singh)
Deputy Director (Health & FW)
Government of Manipur”
28.
The aforesaid letter clearly indicates that the fee
structure in respect of State Government quota seats,
Management quota seats and NRI quota seats shall be
subject to the outcome of the petition pending before the
Hon’ble Apex Court.
The fee structure shown in the
MC (WP(C)) No. 119 of 2023 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023)
P a g e | 34
Government letter dated 13.12.2021 has not been superseded
in the letter dated 20.10.2022 and the fee structure in the letter
dated 13.12.2021 is still in force. Therefore, the presumption
is, the students of the first batch MBBS are bound by the fee
prescribed in the Government letter dated 13.12.2021.
Moreover, in the opening portion of letter dated 20.10.2022, it
has been stated that “I am directed to convey approval of the
Government of the following in respect of Shija Academy of
Health Sciences for the year 2022-23”, which means that the
fee structure of State Government quota is applicable for
admission of students of Government quota for the year 20222023 and, prima facie, the writ petitioners cannot claim the
benefit under the letter dated 20.10.2022, as the earlier
Government letter dated 13.12.2021 has not been superseded
in the subsequent letter dated 20.10.2022.
29.
The argument of learned senior counsel for the
applicant is that no State in the country follows the National
Medical Commission’s memorandum on fee structure 2022
except in Manipur like the second batch of the applicant
college i.e. 2022-2023 session.
The fee structure of the
second batch is financially incompatible for the newly
established unaided private medical college like the applicant
MC (WP(C)) No. 119 of 2023 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023)
P a g e | 35
and will lead to compromising the infrastructure and quality
medical education. He would submit that the Government
medical institutes like JNIMS, Churachandpur Medical College
and RIMS, Imphal are fully funded by the Government.
However, the applicant college could not get any NRI quota
admissions from both the batches and the fees from the
management quota students could not support the students in
the Government quota seats. According to the learned senior
counsel, the applicant college has to incur the annual
expenditure of Rs.18,18,858/- per student and, therefore, the
cost is justified as the applicant college is a newly established
one. The aforesaid argument of the learned senior counsel in
respect of the expenditure cannot now be gone into in the
present proceedings, as it would involve a detailed enquiry.
30.
It is to be noted that in the present prevailing
nature of the fee structure applicable to the applicant college
in respect of students admitted on Government quota for the
year 2021-2022, the prescribed fee structure fixed in the letter
dated 13.12.2021 is applicable. That apart, the fees for the
first batch MBBS 2021-2022 was already fixed by the State
Fee Fixation Committee on 13.12.2021 prior to the issuance
of the National Medical Commission’s Office Memorandum
MC (WP(C)) No. 119 of 2023 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023)
P a g e | 36
dated 3.2.2022. Nothing has been produced to show that fees
once fixed by the State Fee Fixation Committee cannot be
changed for the entire course as explained in the Office
Memorandum dated 3.2.2022. Since the applicant college is
an unaided private new medical college operating in the North
East Region and while attempting to build up young medical
students to become a good deserving medical doctors which
is now just budding to take the health care and to protect the
valuable human lives and there are many requirements in the
new establishment likely to face financial difficulties and the
fact remains that the Government letter dated 13.12.2021
under which the applicant college was permitted to collect
Rs.8 lakh for Government quota has not been superseded till
date, in the interest of justice and welfare of the students and
in order to avoid the financial burden, the students admitted
under Government quota for the year 2021-2022, the fee
structure may be governed as per the Government letter dated
13.2.2021, subject to the outcome in the proceedings pending
before the Apex Court.
31.
In order to produce good medical students and
further to undergo research in the field of medical sciences, it
is the expectation of all concerned to grow the applicant
MC (WP(C)) No. 119 of 2023 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023)
P a g e | 37
college, which is an unaided medical college more and more
to fulfil the object and reasons of the establishment of such
institute in the State of Manipur as well as in the North East
Region of India.
32.
The interim prayer made in the writ petition
staying the operation of the notice dated 6.2.2022 and allowing
the students of 2021-2022 batch to pay their tuition fees at par
with the tuition fees of the students of 2022-2023 batch is a
debatable question, which cannot now be gone into. Since the
issue is in seizin of the Hon’ble Apex Court, this Court is of the
prima facie view that the respondents 1 to 10/writ petitioners
cannot seek the aid of the letter dated 20.10.2022 and argue
that pursuant to the order dated 15.11.2021, the State
Government constituted a State Fee Regulatory Committee
for fixation of fee for MBBS course in the applicant college and
the State Government, by a letter dated 20.10.2022, has
conveyed approval of the Government for the fee structure of
State Government quota for admission to the applicant college
for the academic session 2022-2023 at Rs.45,700/- only and
the same should be applicable to the batch of medical students
who were admitted for Government quota for the year 20212022. It is also the arguments of the senior counsel for the writ
MC (WP(C)) No. 119 of 2023 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023)
P a g e | 38
petitioners that there is a huge disparity in the fee structure for
the students under the Government quota for the academic
session 2021-2022 and 2022-23 in the applicant college and
similarly situated persons has to be treated similarly.
33.
As stated supra, when the tuition fee fixed by the
Government vide letter dated 20.10.2022 at the rate of
Rs.45,700/- is meant for the academic year 2022-2023, the
writ petitioners cannot seek to implement the said letter dated
20.10.2022 retrospectively for the Government nominated
students of the academic session 2021-2022. That apart, for
the second batch MBBS 2022-2023, the fees fixed by the Fee
Fixation Committee vide order dated 20.10.2022 is not yet
settled, as the same is subject to the outcome of the petition
pending before the Apex Court.
34.
Though the State Fee Regulatory Committee had
been constituted under the order dated 15.11.2021, the
Government
after
considering
the
matter
in
proper
perspective, issued letter dated 13.12.2021 allowing the
applicant college to collect fee for State Government quota at
Rs.8 lakh for the students admitted in the year 2021-2022. As
stated supra, now the 2021-2022 batch have completed their
first year and for collection of second year fee, the applicant
MC (WP(C)) No. 119 of 2023 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023)
P a g e | 39
college had issued the notice dated 6.2.2022 calling upon the
students of 2021-22 batch to pay the second year’s tuition,
hostel and mess fees on or before 15th March, 2023. Issuance
of such notice cannot be faulted by the students of 2021-2022
batch, as the timely payment of fees is required for
infrastructure development of the applicant college, a newly
established unaided private medical college so as to run the
college smoothly and effectively. The learned senior counsel
for the applicant argued that the fee structure of the second
batch is financially incompatible for the applicant college which
is a newly established unaided private medical college.
35.
This Court while issuing notice to the applicant
college, stayed the notice dated 6.2.2022 and after notice and
entering appearance, the applicant prima facie established
that if payments of tuition, hostel and mess fees are stayed,
the management has to face financial difficulty in running the
college.
36.
Considering the fact that the fee structure for the
academic year 2021-2022 fixed by the Government of Manipur
was accepted by all concerned without any complaint and the
first batch have completed their first year course and the
continuation of the interim order dated 2.3.2023 passed in the
MC (WP(C)) No. 119 of 2023 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023)
P a g e | 40
writ petition in respect of the notice dated 6.2.2022 would
definitely cause financial problem and also untold hardship to
the applicant college for its smooth functioning and
administration, this Court is of the view that there is bona fide
in the contentions made by the applicant college. It is not the
case of the writ petitioners that the applicant college
management has discontinued the training/academic courses
and closed down the hostel and mess facility for fee default.
Taking into consideration the future of all the students, the
applicant college is continuing its training/academic courses
including the Government nominees.
37.
Since the National Medical Commission has not
prescribed the fee in respect of the applicant college and the
power of the National Medical Commission qua 50% of seats
in private medical college is under challenge before the
Hon’ble Apex Court and the fee structure shown in the
Government letter dated 13.12.2021 in respect of the applicant
college for State Government quota for the year 2021-2022
has not yet been superseded and still in force and the fee
structure shown in the letter dated 20.10.2022 is meant for the
academic session 2022-2023, this Court is of the prima facie
MC (WP(C)) No. 119 of 2023 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023)
P a g e | 41
view that the interim order dated 2.3.2023 passed in the writ
petition deserves to be re-considered in the interest of justice.
38.
For all the reasons stated above, the interim
order dated 2.3.2023 granted by this Court in W.P.(C) No.158
of 2023, which was extended from time to time, stands vacated
and M.C. (WP) No.119 of 2023 in W.P.(C) No.158 of 2023 is
allowed.
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
Sushil
MC (WP(C)) No. 119 of 2023 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 158 of 2023)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review