Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:53652
wp15285.26 Judgment .odt
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
WRIT PETITION NO. 15285 OF 2026
Shashikumar s/o Shamrao Chaudhari,
Age; 85 years, Occ; Legal Practitioner,
R/o; ‘Shamendra’, Plot No. 468,
Near Kailas Apartment, N-3, CIDCO,
Aurangabad, Tq. & Dist. Aurangabad.
...PETITIONER
(Orig. Respondent/Objector)
VERSUS
Pravin s/o Digambar Manohar,
Age; 61 years, Occ; Business,
R/o; Govind Bhavan, Gore Peth,
Nagpur, Tq. & Dist. Nagpur.
...RESPONDENT.
(Orig. Applicant/Reporting Trustee)
………………
Advocate for the Petitioner : Mr. Vivek J. Dhage
Advocate for Respondent : Mr. R.F. Totla and Mr. V.S. Kabra i/b Shripad
S. Kulkarni
……………...
CORAM : MANJUSHA DESHPANDE, J.
Reserved on
: 27.10.2026
Pronounced on : 30.10.2026
JUDGMENT : -
1.
Rule. Rule returnable forthwith, with the consent of the
parties. Heard finally at the admission stage.
2.
wp15285.26 Judgment .odt
The petitioner is raising challenge to the order dated
21.09.2026,
passed
below
Exhibit–10,
by
the
Deputy
Charity
Commissioner, Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar, in Inquiry No. 1074 of 2024.
3.
The learned Advocate Mr. Dhage, appearing for the petitioner
submits that, the respondent - Pravin s/o Digambar Manohar has filed a
change report, bearing Inquiry No. 1074 of 2024, under Section 22 of the
Maharashtra Public Trust Act, 1950, showing that the election to the
Managing Committee of Madhyawarti Marathwada Mahila Shikshan
Samiti, Aurangabad (hereinafter referred as ‘said Samiti’ for the sake of
brevity), has taken place and a new Managing Committee has been
elected for the period 2024 to 2029. The petitioner has filed objection to
the said Inquiry Report and during the pendency of that Inquiry, the
petitioner has also filed an application below Exhibit-10, for framing of
the preliminary issue, in respect to the maintainability of the Inquiry No.
1074 of 2024.
4.
According to the petitioner, no such election as claimed in
the change report has taken place on 01.09.2024. No resolution in the
meeting of the existing Managing Committee was passed for conducting
the election. According to him, in view of the judgment and order passed
by the Charity Commissioner in Inquiry No. J-1/19/2018 passed in
Judgment dated 12.07.2024, the respondent has no locus to file the
change
report.
The
Deputy
Charity
Commissioner,
has
made
wp15285.26 Judgment .odt
observations in the order dated 12.07.2024 that, the President of the
Trust does not have any right to call the meeting. Since there is no proof
of conducting the meeting for election, the change report bearing Inquiry
No.
of
itself
would
not
be
maintainable.
On
the
aforementioned background, the petitioner has filed the application for
framing a preliminary issue, regarding the maintainability of Inquiry No.
1074 of 2024. It is submitted that the Deputy Charity Commissioner,
Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar has not taken into consideration the
previous judgment and rejected the application for framing preliminary
issue by observing that in a proceeding under Section 22 the Act of
1950, preliminary issue cannot be framed.
5.
The learned Advocate for the petitioner further submits that,
the order passed by the Deputy Charity Commissioner, Chhatrapati
Sambhajinagar is an erroneous order, in view of catena of judgments,
which lay down that, if a issue regarding maintainability is raised by any
of the party, it has to be decided at an earlier stage, before proceeding
further with the decision on merits of the matter.
In support of his
submission he has relied on the decision of this Court in Balaji Son Of
Bhikaji Kapale And Anr. vs Punjaji Son Of Balaji Tayade And Ors. 2002(1) BOM. CR 155, wherein this Court has held that,
“The provisions of Rule 7 of the Trust Rules and Section
17 of the Small Cause Court’s Act the order IX Rule 13 of
the Code of Civil Procedure will be applicable for
proceedings under Section 22 and 17-A and 72 of the
wp15285.26 Judgment .odt
Bombay Public Trust Act and Rules.”
6.
Thus, according to him, the observations made by the
learned Deputy Charity Commissioner, while rejecting the application for
deciding the preliminary issue, are contrary to the settled principle of
law as laid down by this Court.
7.
He further reinforces his submission, by relying on the
decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of RBANMS
Educational Institution v. B. Gunashekar and Another (Civil Appeal No.
5200 of 2025, decided on 16 April 2025), wherein, the Hon’ble Supreme
Court has held that
“A pure question of law that can be decided at the early
stage of the litigation ought to be decided at the earliest
stage.”
8.
Similarly, he has also relied on the decision of this Court in
Adesh Shivaji Narke v. Shree Dnyaneshwar Maharaj Sansthan and Ors.,
reported in 2025 DGLS (Bom) 1200.
9.
According to the learned Advocate for the petitioner, the
maintainability of proceeding is a pure question of law, therefore, it
requires to be decided at the preliminary stage, when such objection is
raised without waiting for the stage, where the other issues involving the
merits of the matter, are likely to be decided. He therefore, submitted
wp15285.26 Judgment .odt
that the order passed below Exhibit-10 rejecting the application of the
petitioner is required to be set aside.
10.
Per Contra, Mr. R.F. Totla, learned Advocate for the
respondent submitted that the subject matter of the pending proceeding
is an inquiry under Section 22 of the Maharashtra Public Trust Act.
Section 22, itself contains the mechanism in reporting an inquiry into
the change, in the entries of the registered Public Trust.
The Deputy
Charity Commissioner is empowered to verify the correctness of such
entries, to ascertain as to whether such change has occurred. Section
22 nowhere provides that the Charity Commissioner must frame the
preliminary issue regarding the maintainability and decide it first.
According to him, the present application is not maintainable since it is
against the provisions of Section 22 of the Maharashtra Public Trust Act.
Mr. Totla, further places reliance on the order passed by this Court in
Shashikumar Shamrao Chaudhari Vs.Vijaykumar Savlaram Shashtri
and Ors, (Writ Petition No. 7079 of 2019) decided on June 17, 2019, in
respect of the same trust as in the present Writ Petition.
The
aforementioned decision was relied in support of his submission based
on
merits
of
the
inquiry,
pending
before
the
Deputy
Charity
Commissioner. He further submitted that since there is no provision of
framing preliminary issue under the Maharashtra Public Trust Act, the
Deputy Charity Commissioner has rightly passed an order rejecting the
application filed by the petitioner.
11.
wp15285.26 Judgment .odt
Heard the rival submissions, and perused the documents
along with case laws cited by the respective parties.
12.
The inquiry No. 1074 of 2024 is pending before the Deputy
Charity Commissioner, Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar. A detailed objection
to the change report has been filed by the petitioner raising doubt about
the maintainability of the inquiry itself.
During the pendency of the
inquiry, an application has been filed by the petitioner for framing of
preliminary issue about the maintainability of the change report and an
inquiry initiated pursuant to such change report. It is the submission of
the learned Advocate for the petitioner that, if the inquiry itself is not
maintainable, it is not necessary to carry out the exercise of conducting
inquiry, hence if the preliminary issue about the maintainability is
framed, the inquiry itself can be disposed of without going through the
procedural rigors of Section
13.
Section 22 of the Act is reproduced herein below for
convenience :
“22. Change.––
(1)
Where any change occurs in any of the entries
recorded in the register kept under section 17, the trustee
shall, within 90 days from the date of the occurrence of
such change, or where any change is desired in such
entries in the interest of the administration of such public
trust, report such change or proposed change to the
wp15285.26 Judgment .odt
Deputy or Assistant Charity Commissioner in charge of
the Public Trusts Registration Office where the register is
kept. Such report shall be made in the prescribed form.
(1A)
Where the change to be reported under sub-section
(1) relates to any immovable property, the trustee shall,
along with the report, furnish a memorandum in the
prescribed form containing the particulars (including the
name and description of the public trust) relating to any
change in the immovable property of such public trust, for
forwarding it to the Sub-Registrar referred to in subsection (7) of section 18. Such memorandum shall be
signed and verified in the prescribed manner by the
trustee or his agent specially authorised by him in this
behalf.
(2)
For the purpose of verifying the correctness of the
entries in the register kept under section 17 or
ascertaining whether any change has occurred in any of
the particulars recorded in the register, the Deputy or
Assistant Charity Commissioner may hold an inquiry in
the prescribed manner.
(3)……………..
(3A)……………
(4) ………….”
14.
Upon reading Section 22 of the Maharashtra Public Trust
Act, Section 22 (2) provides that for the purpose of verifying the
correctness of the entries in the register kept under Section 17, for
ascertaining as to whether any change occurred in any of the particulars
recorded
in
the
register,
the
Deputy
or
the
Assistant
Commissioner may hold an inquiry in the prescribed manner.
objections
are
received
to
the
proposed
change,
an
Charity
If any
inquiry
is
contemplated within three months from filing of such objection. After
initiating of such inquiry, the findings are required to be recorded by the
wp15285.26 Judgment .odt
Deputy Charity Commissioner. The proceedings are required to be
completed within a period of one year from initiating such inquiry. Thus,
upon going through Section 22, it no where contemplates of framing of
any preliminary issue. Section 22 merely provides about the procedure
to be followed while making any inquiry about the change
that has
occurred in the trust. Section 73 of the Maharashtra Trust Act provides
for the powers of the Civil Court to be exercised by the Officers while
holding inquiries under the Act. The powers of the Officers are limited
only to the extent of proof of facts by affidavits, summoning and
enforcing the attendance of any person, examining him on oath, ordering
discovery and inspection, compelling the production of documents and
issuing of commissions etc. Section 73 of the Maharashtra Public Trust
Act is reproduced here in under, which reads thus :
“73. Officers holding inquiries to have powers of civil court.––
In holding inquiries under this Act, the officer holding the same
shall have the same powers as are vested in courts in respect of the
following matters under the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 in trying a suit
—
(a)proof of facts by affidavits,
(b)summoning and enforcing the attendance of any person and
examining him on oath,
(c)ordering discovery and
production of documents,
inspection,
and
compelling
the
(d)issuing of commissions.”
On perusal of Section 73 of the Maharashtra Public Trust Act, it is
evident that when the Officer under the Act is holding an inquiry, as in
wp15285.26 Judgment .odt
the present case, the powers of Civil Court, are vested in officer only to
the extent as provided under Clause (a to d) read with the Proviso and
except for the purpose mentioned in Clauses (a to d), no other powers are
vested in the Deputy Charity Commissioner, in the matters of inquiry.
Assuming that, the Deputy Charity Commissioner is governed by the
provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. Section 9 (A) of the Code
of Civil Procedure, 1908. an enabling provision which permitted framing
preliminary issue was introduced way of State Amendment in 1977,
which has now been deleted w.e.g. 27.06.2018. Thus, neither under the
Maharashtra Public Trust Act, nor under the Code of Civil Procedure,
1908, there is any enabling provision, which would permit framing
preliminary issue in case of an inquiry under Section 22 of the
Maharashtra Public Trust Act.
15.
One more aspect that needs to be considered is that, in the
impugned order itself it is observed by the Deputy Charity Commissioner
that, the petitioner has previously also filed an application for framing
preliminary issue, in Inquiry No. 19 of 2018, which was rejected by the
Deputy Charity Commissioner and the challenge to the said order was
raised in the Writ Petition No. 7079 of 2019, which had been turned
down by this Court.
Although, the petitioner has relied on certain
decisions of this Court, as well as the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court. The decisions relied by the petitioner would not be applicable to
the facts of the present case. Although the petitioner has relied on the
wp15285.26 Judgment .odt
decision in Balaji Son Of Bhikaji Kapale And Anr. (supra) which lay down
that the provisions of Rule 7 of the Trust Rules, Section 17 of the Small
Cause Court and the Section 9 (a) of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908,
will be applicable, in case of the proceedings under the Maharashtra
Public Trust Act. It is worthwhile to note that the subject matter of the
aforementioned cited judgments was regarding the application for setting
aside the Ex-parte order.
16.
In the present case, the question is whether it is necessary
to frame the preliminary issue about the maintainability of inquiry under
Section 22 of the Act. Thus, the aforementioned decision would not be
applicable in the present case. Similarly in the reported decision in case
of, RBANMS Educational Institution (supra), the issue before the Hon’ble
Supreme Court was rejection of plaint and non disclosure of cause of
action, wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that the question of
law can be decided at the early stage of litigation. The observations of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court are in reference to the subject matter of
challenge i.e. rejection of plaint, will not be applicable in the present
case. It is held that the pure question of law, can be decided at the early
stage of the litigation. Considering the above observations in the context
of the present case, the subject matter of the inquiry is about the change
in the trust which requires an inquiry to be conducted and based on
such inquiry an order is required to be passed in such proceedings, such
proceedings cannot be dismissed by framing a preliminary issue only
wp15285.26 Judgment .odt
and upon necessary inquiry is conducted by the Deputy Charity
Commissioner, the change report can be allowed or reject.
17.
If at all the petitioner desires that, the issue raised by him
should be decided before dealing with the merits of case under Section
22 of the Maharashtra Public Trust Act, the said issue can be framed as
first issue, to be decided prior to any other issues. The petitioner is at
liberty to make such request to the Deputy Charity Commissioner.
Thus, I am of the view that there is no error committed by the learned
Deputy Charity Commissioner, while passing the impugned order. Hence
the order does not deserve any interference.
18.
As such, the Writ Petition is dismissed being devoid of any
merit.
19.
Rule is discharged.
( MANJUSHA DESHPANDE, J. )
Mahajansb/
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review