Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC-D:791
RSA No. 5271 of 2008
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA,AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 22ND DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C M JOSHI
REGULAR SECOND APPEAL NO. 5271 OF 2008 (PAR)
BETWEEN:
Digitally signed
by NANDINI R
Location:
HIGH COURT
OF
KARNATAKA
1.
SHANTINATH S/O. GIRAMALLAPPA BOLGOND,
AGED ABOUT 65 YEARS,
OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. TERDAL, TQ. JAMKHANDI,
DIST. BAGALKOT.
2.
RAJANIKANTH S/O. SHRIDHAR BOLGOND,
SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS.
2A.
ROHINI W/O RAJANIKANTH BOLGOND,
AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS,
OCC: HOUSEWIFE.
2B.
ROHIT S/O RAJANIKANTH BOLGOND,
AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS,
OCC: STUDENT.
2C.
SHRINIDHI D/O RAJANIKANTH BOLGOND,
AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS,
OCC: STUDENT.
APPELLANT NO. 2A TO 2C,
R/O KILLABAGA ONI, TERDAL
TQ: BANAHATTI-RABAKAVI,
DIST: BAGALKOT- 587 315.
3.
SULOCHANA W/O. RAVASAHEB BOLGOND,
SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS.
3A.
SHITAL D/O. RAVASAHEB BOLGOND,
AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS,
-2NC: 2026:KHC-D:791
RSA No. 5271 of 2008
HC-KAR
OCC. HOUSEWIFE.
3B.
ANIL S/O. RAVASAHEB BOLGOND,
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS,
OCC. STUDENT.
3C.
SUNIL S/O. RAVASAHEB BOLGOND,
AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS,
OCC. STUDENT.
APPELLANT NO.3A TO 3C ARE
R/O. KILLABAGA ONI, TERDAL,
TQ. BANAHATTI-RABAKAVI,
DIST. BAGALKOT-587 315.
4.
SHEETAL S/O. RAVASAHEB BOLGOND,
AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS,
OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. TERDAL, TQ. JAMKHANDI,
DIST. BAGALKOT.
5.
ANIL S/O RAVASAHEB BOLGOND,
AGED ABOUT 33 YEARS,
OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O TERDAL, TQ: JAMKHANDI,
DIST: BAGALKOT.
6.
SUNIL S/O RAVASAHEB BOLGOND,
AGED ABOUT 30 YEARS,
OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O: TERDAL, TQ: JAMKHANDI,
DIST: BAGALKOT.
...APPELLANTS
(BY SRI S.S.PATIL , ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
SMT. RAJMATI W/O BHUPAL BOLGOND,
SINCE RESPONDENT NO.1 DEAD HER
LR'S ARE ALREADY ON RECORD AS
RESPONDENT NO. 2,3 & 5.
-3NC: 2026:KHC-D:791
RSA No. 5271 of 2008
HC-KAR
2.
SANDIP S/O APPASAHEB DESAI,
AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS,
OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O POOJA PARK BUILDING NO.9,
PLOT NO.8, CHINTAMANI NAGARBEBIWADI
POONA.
3.
SACHIN S/O APPASAHEB DEASI,
AGED ABOUT 37 YEARS,
OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O POOJA PARK BUILDING NO.9,
PLOT NO.8, CHINTAMANI NAGARBEBIWADI
POONA.
4.
APPASAHEB S/O BHUSAHEB DESAI,
RESPONDENT NO.4 IS DEAD HIS LR'S ARE
ALREADY ON RECORD AS
RESPONDENT NO. 2 & 3.
5.
SUNANDA W/O BALASAHEB PATIL,
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS,
OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O JALATARANG HOUSING SOCIETY
NEMINATH NAGAR, SANGALI.
6.
SURESH S/O PARAPPA BOLGOND,
SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LR'S
6A.
PRAKASH S/O SURESH BOLGOND,
AGED ABOUT 46 YEARS,
OCC: AGRICULTURE.
6B.
PRATIBHA W/O BALASABHA AAKKIWATA,
AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS,
OCC:HOUSEWIFE.
6C.
SMITA W/O BHARATHES MAGADUM,
AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS,
OCC: HOUSEWIFE.
6D.
VRUSHABHA S/O SURESH BOLGOND,
AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS,
-4NC: 2026:KHC-D:791
RSA No. 5271 of 2008
HC-KAR
OCC: AGRICULTURE.
6E.
AJITH S/O SURESH BOLGOND,
AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS,
OCC: AGRICULTURE.
RESPONDENT NO.6A TO 6E ARE
R/O KILLABAGA ONI, TERDAL,
TQ: BANAHATTI-RABAKAVI,
DIST.: BAGALKOT-587 315.
7.
MALLINATH S/O PARAPPA BOLGOND,
AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS,
OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O TERDAL, TQ: JAMKHANDI,
DIST.: BAGALKOT.
8.
PADMAVATHI W/O TAVANAPPA KOKATANUR,
AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS,
OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O TERDAL, TQ: JAMKHANDI,
DIST.: BAGALKOT.
9.
MAHAVEER S/O TAVANAPPA KOKATANUR,
AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS,
OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O TERDAL, TQ: JAMKHANDI,
DIST.: BAGALKOT.
10.
SANMANTI W/O DEVAGOUDA CHOUGALE,
AGED ABOUT 33 YEARS,
OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O SAVALAGI, TQ: JAMKHANDI,
DIST.:BAGALKOT.
11.
TANGEWWA D/O TAVANAPPA KOKATANUR,
W/O SANJAY HARAVI,
AGED ABOUT 28 YEARS,
OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O NEAR YALLAMMA TEMPLE, TERDAL,
TQ: JAMKHANDI, DIST: BAGALKOT.
12.
AJIT S/O TAVANAPPA KOKATNUR,
-5NC: 2026:KHC-D:791
RSA No. 5271 of 2008
HC-KAR
AGED ABOUT 22 YEARS,
OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O TERDAL, TQ: JAMKHANDI,
DIST.:BAGALKOT.
13.
TANGEWWA W/O BHARAMAPA KHEMALAPURE,
AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS,
OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O TERDAL, TQ: JAMKHANDI,
DIST.: BAGALKOT.
14.
SARASWATI W/O GUNDAPPA KHEMALAPURE,
SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LR'S.
14A. SHALINI W/O ASHOK HULLE
AGED ABOUT 73 YEARS,
OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK.
14B. SHANTINATHA S/O GUNDAPPA KHEMALAPURE,
AGED ABOUT 70 YEARS,
OCC: AGRICULTURE.
14C. SUKUMAR W/O GUNDAPPA KHEMALAPURE,
AGED ABOUT 68 YEARS,
OCC: AGRICULTURE.
RESPONDENT NO. 14A TO 14C ARE
R/O BELLADA BAGEWADI,
TQ: HUKKERI, DIST.: BELAGAVI-591 309.
15.
BALAWWA @ VIJAYA W/O VASANTRAO PATIL,
AGED ABOUT 67 YEARS,
OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O JAYASINGAPUR, TQ: SHIROL,
DIST: KOLHAPUR, DIST.: MAHARASHTRA.
16.
SRI MAHAVEER S/O CHANDAPPA NANDREKAR,
AGED ABOUT 28 YEARS,
R/O MAHESHWADAGI, TQ; ATHANI,
DIST.: BELGAUM.
17.
SIDDAPPA S/O PARAPPA ULGOND,
AGED ABOUT 25 YEARS,
-6NC: 2026:KHC-D:791
RSA No. 5271 of 2008
HC-KAR
R/O TERDAL, TQ: BANAHATTI-RABAKAVI,
DIST: BELGAUM.
18.
SRI RAMESH S/O PADMANNA HIPPARAGI,
AGED ABOUT 24 YEARS,
R/O MAHESHWADAGI, TQ: ATHANI,
DIST.: BELGAUM.
19.
SRI JAKKAPPA S/O DHAREPPA HIPPARAGI,
AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS,
R/O MAHESHWADAGI, TQ: ATHANI,
DIST.: BELGAUM.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI SHIVARAJ P MUDHOL, ADVOCATE FOR R5,
SRI VIJAYKUMAR B HORATTI, ADVOCATE FOR R7;
NOTICE TO R8, R9, R11 & R12 - HELD SUFFICIENT;
R2,R3, R10, R13, R15 - SERVED;
SRI GIRISH S HIREMATH, ADVOCATE FOR R16 - R19;
NOTICE TO R14(A) TO R14(C) - HELD SUFFICIENT;
R6(A) TO R6(D)- HELD SUFFICIENT;
R6(E) - SERVED)
THIS RSA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 100 OF CPC,
AGAINST THE JUDGEMENT AND DECREE DATED 14.08.2008
PASSED IN R.A.NO.83/2003 ON THE FILE OF THE FAST TRACK
COURT, JAMAKHANDI, DISMISSING THE APPEAL, FILED
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 31.03.2003
PASSED IN O.S NO.91/1996 ON THE FILE OF THE CIVIL JUDGE
(JR.DN), BANAHATTI, DISMISSING THE SUIT FILED FOR
PARTITION, SEPARATE POSSESSION AND INJUNCTION.
THIS RSA HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED ON
04.12.2025, COMING ON FOR PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGMENT
THIS DAY AT BENGALURU BENCH, COURT DELIVERED THE
FOLLOWING:
-7NC: 2026:KHC-D:791
RSA No. 5271 of 2008
HC-KAR
CAV JUDGMENT
(PER: THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C M JOSHI)
Being aggrieved by the dismissal of OS No. 91/1996
by the learned Civil Judge, (Jr.Dn), Banahatti, dated
31.03.2003 and the dismissal of RA No. 83/2003 by learned
Presiding
Officer,
Fast
Track
Court,
Jamkandy,
dated
14.08.2008, the plaintiffs are before this Court in this
second appeal.
2.
The factual matrix that is necessary for the
purpose of this appeal may be summarized as below:
(a)
One Payappa was a propositus and he was
survived by his two sons Irappa and Ningappa. The
branches of Ningappa and Irappa was continued by
their sons Girmallappa and Parappa respectively. The
branch of Girmallappa was survived by Ravsaheb,
Shridhar and Shantinath. Ravsaheb is survived by
plaintiff Nos. 4 to 7 and Shridhar is survived by
plaintiff Nos. 2 and 3 and Shantinath is the plaintiff
No. 1. The branch of Parappa was survived by one
Bhupal,
Suresh
and
Mallinath.
Bhupal
died
and
-8NC: 2026:KHC-D:791
RSA No. 5271 of 2008
HC-KAR
defendant Nos.1 to 3 are survived by him. Suresh and
Mallinath are
defendant Nos. 4 and 5. For better
understanding the genealogy is depicted as below:
Payaappa- Propositus
Ravasaheb
Dead
Ningappa Dead
Girmallappa
Parappa Dead
Wife is also dead
Shridhar
Dead
Smt. Sulochana
Deft-1
Sheetal
Plff.5
Irappa Dead
Anil
Plff.6
Smt. Gangavva
Plff.No.2
Shantina
Plff.No.1
Bhupal
Dead
Rajanikant
Plff No.3
Sunil
Plff.7
Suresh Mallinath
Deft-4 Deft-5
Smt.Rajamati
Smt. Shalini
Deft-2
Smt. Sunanada
Deft.3
(b) The suit schedule property is land bearing RS No.
41/3 measuring 16 acres 04 guntas situated at Terdal
Village, Jamkhandi Taluk.
(c) The suit land was the ancestral joint family
property of plaintiff Nos.1 to 7 and defendant Nos.1
-9NC: 2026:KHC-D:791
RSA No. 5271 of 2008
HC-KAR
to 5 and they have half share in it. It was contended
that however in the record of rights the name of
defendant Nos. 1 to 3 has been entered as kabjadars
and the said entry is without knowledge and consent
of the plaintiffs.
(d) The plaintiffs called upon defendant Nos.1 to 5 to
award a division by meets and bounds in the suit land
and the lawful demand of the plaintiffs for partition
was postponed by defendant Nos.1 to 5 under false
excuses. They started attempting to transfer the
schedule
property under colourable documents in
favour of defendant No. 6, who is a stranger.
Therefore, there was a cause of action for filing the
suit and as such, they instituted the suit for partition
of their half share in the schedule property. (It is
pertinent to note that the plaint do not elaborate on
the manner of acquisition of the schedule property by
the family of the plaintiffs and defendants and in what
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC-D:791
RSA No. 5271 of 2008
HC-KAR
manner it is an ancestral joint family property of the
family).
3. On service of summons, defendant No. 1 filed his
written statement resisting the claim of the plaintiffs. He
denied that the suit property is a joint family property and
that plaintiffs have got any semblance of right, title or
interest in the same. He also denied the joint possession of
the plaintiffs over the suit schedule property. He further
contended that there is severance of the joint family
nucleus long back between the branch of Girmallappa and
Parappa and the father of the plaintiffs Girmallappa had
filed Form No.7 with respect to the suit schedule property
claiming occupancy rights admitting the ownership of
Bhupal and the said application came to be rejected.
Therefore, the branch of Girmallappa, now represented by
the plaintiffs, cannot claim any ownership right, title or
interest and as such they are estopped from claiming the
same. Inter-alia, he also contended that the suit suffers
from non-joinder of necessary parties.
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC-D:791
RSA No. 5271 of 2008
HC-KAR
4.
Defendant Nos.2 and 3 had adopted the written
statement of defendant No. 1 by a memo.
5.
Defendant
Nos.4
and
filed
statement contending that the suit schedule
their
written
property is
joint family property of defendant Nos. 1 to 5 but not of the
plaintiffs. They contended that the plaintiffs were never in
joint possession of the suit schedule property along with
defendant Nos.1 to 5 and in that regard, they supported the
contention of defendant Nos. 1 to 3
and ultimately, they
sought for dismissal of the suit.
6.
On the basis of the above pleadings, the
following issues and additional issues were framed by the
trial Court.
ISSUES
1. Whether
plaintiffs
prove
that
the
plaintiffs
and
defendant Nos. 1 to 5 are in lawful possession of the
suit property?
2. Whether plaintiffs prove that the suit property are joint
and ancestral properties of plaintiffs and defendant
Nos. 1 to 5?
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:791
RSA No. 5271 of 2008
HC-KAR
3. Whether the suit is bad for non-joinder of necessary
parties?
4. Whether plaintiffs are stopped from claiming any fights
in the suit properties?
5. Whether the relationship of plaintiffs and defendant
Nos. 1 to 5 several long back?
6. Whether
plaintiffs
are
entitled
for
permanent
injunction?
7. Whether plaintiffs are entitled for partition and separate
possession as prayed for?
8. What order or decree?
ADDITIONAL ISSUES
1. Whether the suit is not maintainable?
2. Whether the genealogy is incorrect and incomplete?
3. Whether the defendants Nos. 1 to 3 prove that the sit
land is self acquired property of husband of defendant
No.1 and father of defendants Nos. 2 and 3?
4. Whether the valuation made by the plaintiff is not
proper and correct, fee paid on the plaint is not
correct?
5. Whether the defendant Nos. 4 and 5 are entitled for
compensatory costs of Rs.3,000/-?
7.
Plaintiff No.1 was examined as PW1 and one
witness was examined as PW2. Exhibits P1 to P9 were
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC-D:791
RSA No. 5271 of 2008
HC-KAR
marked on their behalf. Defendant Nos.1 to 3 have not
adduced any evidence in their favour, despite sufficient
opportunities. However, defendant Nos.4 and 5 examined
defendant No. 5 as DW1, but no documents were marked
on their behalf.
8.
During pendency of the suit, defendant No. 6
died and his LRs were brought on the record.
9.
After hearing the arguments by both the sides,
the trial Court dismissed the suit by holding Issue Nos. 1 to
3, 6, 7 and Additional issue Nos.1 to 5 in the negative and
issue Nos. 4 and 5 in the affirmative. In effect, it held that
the joint family status had severed much prior to the
purchase of the suit sale property by Bhupal in the year
1949 and as such the suit schedule survey number cannot
be subject matter of partition.
10.
Being aggrieved,
First Appellate Court in
the plaintiffs approached the
RA No. 83/2003. On hearing the
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC-D:791
RSA No. 5271 of 2008
HC-KAR
arguments by both the sides, the First Appellate Court
formed the following points for consideration:
1.
Whether the plaintiffs prove that the suit
property was purchased in the name of Bhupal out of
the joint family nucleus?
2.
Whether the plaintiffs further prove that the
suit property was continued to be joint family
property consisting of the plaintiffs and defendants?
3.
Whether the impugned judgment and decree
under challenge call for interference by this court?
4.
What order?
11.
During the pendency of the Regular appeal,
defendant No.2 had died and her LRs were brought on
record. The First Appellate Court answered the points 1 to
3 in the negative and dismissed the appeal and confirmed
the judgment of the trial Court.
Being aggrieved, the
plaintiffs are before this Court in second appeal.
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC-D:791
RSA No. 5271 of 2008
HC-KAR
12.
This Court, while admitting the appeal, has
framed the following substantial questions of law on
28.01.2014:
1.
Whether
both
the
Courts
below
have
concurrently erred in coming to the conclusion that
the suit schedule property would be the self acquired
property of Bhupal inspite of negative finding on
issue No.1?
2.
Whether the Courts below have committed an
error in noticing that this property continued to be
joint family property inspite of an application filed in
Form No.7?
13.
During
pendency of the present appeal, the
appellant Nos. 2, 3 and respondent Nos.1,4,6 and 14 died
and their legal heirs are brought on record.
14.
The arguments by both the sides were heard.
15.
The learned counsel appearing for the appellant
would submit that the burden of proving that any property
is a self-acquired property is on the person who alleges the
property to be self-acquired and in the absence of any
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC-D:791
RSA No. 5271 of 2008
HC-KAR
evidence, the presumption becomes perfect and it has to be
held in favour of the plaintiffs. It is submitted that the
Courts below have failed to consider that Bhupal, being a
person
aged 25 years in the year 1948 would not have
acquired Rs.3,000/- at that time by his self earning to
purchase the suit schedule
property. There is nothing on
record to show that Bhupal had any independent income
and
therefore,
the
suit
property
would
become
his
independent and self acquired property. The Courts below
have failed to appreciate this aspect and as such, the
findings of the trial Court as well as the First Appellate Court
are perverse. It is pointed out that the registered Partition
Deed at Exhibit P1 speaks that the suit schedule property
would be subjected to partition after disposal of the
proceedings before the Courts and authorities and the
observation of the Courts below that there is no evidence to
prove that suit property is not subjected to partition is
perverse. It is pointed out that the family partition had
taken place in the year 1956 and if any property is
- 17 NC: 2026:KHC-D:791
RSA No. 5271 of 2008
HC-KAR
purchased before the date of partition, it has to be
presumed to be the joint family property and the burden is
upon the party who contends that it is such self acquired
property. Therefore, he submits that the Courts below have
erred in fastening the entire burden upon the plaintiffs in
the absence of any material on behalf of the defendants to
prove that it was the self-acquired property of Bhupal. He
also pointed out that the Land Tribunal had given a
categorical finding that the suit property is the joint family
property and Girmallappa cannot claim tenancy against his
own brother as it is the joint family property wherein he has
an interest in the form of owner. It is further pointed out
that the said finding of the Tribunal binds everyone
including that of the defendants representing the branch of
Parappa and therefore, the impugned judgment is not
proper and correct. In other words, the learned counsel for
the appellants
places reliance on four documents i. e.,
Exhibit P1, P4, P7, P8 and P9 and made his submissions.
- 18 NC: 2026:KHC-D:791
RSA No. 5271 of 2008
HC-KAR
16.
Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the
respondents contends that the trial Court as well as the
First Appellate Court have considered the burden of proof in
the
proper
perspective
and
there
is
no
need
for
interference. He submitted that the plaint is bereft of any
pleadings to contend that the schedule
property was
acquired out of the joint family funds. It is pointed out that
Exhibit P1 being a registered document of Partition do not
mention anything about the suit property bearing No. 41/3
of Terdala Village. It is pointed out that Exhibits P6 and P7
which is an unregistered plain paper document has not been
proved by the plaintiffs. If at all the suit property is slated
to
be
partitioned
subsequently
after
the
litigation
is
complete, that mention should have found place in Exhibit
P1 and therefore, Exhibit P6 and P7 cannot be of any
relevance. He contends that a mutation entry in the form of
Exhibit P3 cannot be of any relevance in the matter. He also
points
out
that
Exhibit
P4,
the
loan
application
of
Girmallappa and Parappa, to Sangli Bank for an overdraft
- 19 NC: 2026:KHC-D:791
RSA No. 5271 of 2008
HC-KAR
facility of Rs.1,000/- would indicate that the property was
purchased out of the loan granted by Sangli Bank. But this
document do not show that it was used for purchase of the
suit schedule property. He also points out that the order of
the Land Tribunal shows that the suit schedule property was
admittedly in the name of Bhupal and the Tribunal by
observing
that
they
are
the
cousins,
the
claim
of
Girmallappa against Bhupal that he was the tenant under
Bhupal cannot be accepted and as such the order of the
Land Tribunal is not of any assistance to the contention of
the plaintiffs.
17.
Lastly, he submits that the trial Court as well as
the First Appellate Court have rightly held that bereft of any
pleadings, the proof alone cannot be of any value and as
such have correctly held that the plaintiffs have failed to
prove that the suit schedule property was the joint family
property.
- 20 NC: 2026:KHC-D:791
RSA No. 5271 of 2008
HC-KAR
18.
When we examine the above contentions raised
by the appellants and respondents with reference to the
substantial questions of law, it is pertinent to note that
concurrent finding of fact by both the Courts cannot be
interfered unless it is apparently perverse and arbitrary.
19.
The crux of the matter appears to be whether the
evidence without pleading should have been considered by
the Courts below? It is in the light of this, the substantial
questions have to be answered by this Court.
Re. substantial questions of law 1 and2 :
20.
Issue No.1 appears to be incorrectly framed. It
may be noted that the lawful possession of the plaintiffs and
defendant Nos.1 to 5 is not a relevant point which was to be
considered by the trial Court. The lawful possession of the
defendant Nos. 1 to 5 over the suit schedule property was
not a disputed aspect in a suit for partition. The defendants
never agreed that the plaintiffs were in lawful possession of
the suit schedule property. The question of possession over
- 21 NC: 2026:KHC-D:791
RSA No. 5271 of 2008
HC-KAR
the property was not a subject matter of the suit.
Therefore, Issue No. 1 has to be read that the trial Court
had perceived the ownership rights of the plaintiffs and
defendant Nos. 1 to 5 over the suit schedule property.
21.
A perusal of the plaint shows that the plaintiffs
simply state that the suit schedule property bearing Survey
No. 41/3 measuring 16 acres is the ancestral joint family
property. The plaintiff did not elaborate as to how the suit
property became the ancestral joint family property. It is
pertinent to note that there is lot of difference between the
ancestral property and the joint family property. It has to
be construed by this Court that the plaintiffs were referring
to the suit schedule property to be the joint family property
acquired by Bhupal during the jointness of the family.
Except this averment, there is nothing in the pleadings of
the plaintiffs.
22.
The evidence is led by the plaintiffs, contending
that the suit property was purchased by the members of the
- 22 NC: 2026:KHC-D:791
RSA No. 5271 of 2008
HC-KAR
joint family of Parappa and Girmallappa in the name of
Bhupal
son
of
Parappa.
The
partition
was
effected
somewhere in the year 1957 as per Exhibit P1 and prior to
it in the year 1955 there was another document in the form
of Exhibit P6, the translated copy of which is at Exhibit P7.
Both these documents show that there was an earlier
partition and it is only reduced in the form of writing in the
year 1955 and 1957. Obviously, Exhibit P1 is a certified
copy of a registered document. The Exhibit P1 nowhere
mention that Survey No. 41/3 is the subject matter of some
litigation and it has to be partitioned at a subsequent date.
It does not refer to the suit property at all. This document is
dated 25.07.1957 and is executed between Parappa and
Girmallappa. As per this document, a mutation entry was
effected as per Exhibit P3.
23.
The Exhibit P6 is in Marathi
and this document
shows that the suit Survey No. 41/3 was purchased in the
name of Bhupal and Bhupal had undertaken that he is only
in possession of half of the two lands which were purchased
- 23 NC: 2026:KHC-D:791
RSA No. 5271 of 2008
HC-KAR
and the
Girmallappa had half share in it and it would be
partitioned after the litigations in respect of the properties
are cleared. Obviously, this is not a document which was
registered. It is relevant to note that the contents of Exhibit
P6 that the suit property and another property were to be
partitioned later
do not find place in the subsequent
document which is produced at Exhibit P1 in the year 1957.
It is curious to note that if at all Exhibit P1 represented a
partial partition, definitely, it would have mentioned that
Survey No. 41/3 has to be partitioned at a later point of
time. But nowhere such an averment is found in Exhibit P1.
24.
Tribunal.
Exhibit P8 happens to be the order of the Land
It
was
between
one
Channayya,
Gadigaya,
Magaya, Chanabasaya and the Girmallappa against the LRS
of Bhupal. It is worth to note that the Land Tribunal upholds
the contention of Channayya, Gadigaiya, Magaiya and
Channabasaya, but rejects the claim of Girmallappa on the
ground that Girmallappa happens to be the member of the
family of the Bhupal and therefore, occupancy rights as a
- 24 NC: 2026:KHC-D:791
RSA No. 5271 of 2008
HC-KAR
tenant cannot be given. It may be noted that Exhibit P8
simply mentions that the applicant Girmallappa is the uncle
of Bhupal and therefore, he cannot claim the tenancy. It is
worth to note that this Order of the Land Tribunal nowhere
mention anything about the Partition Deed at Exhibit P1 or
the document allegedly executed by Bhupal as per Exhibit
P6. Therefore, the order of the Land Tribunal cannot be
construed to be sacrosanct
in respect of its holding that
Girmallappa is part of the joint family and as such he would
also have ownership rights in it.
25. The Trial Court in para 15, 16 and 17, considers
these
aspects
elaborately.
It
also
observes
that
the
evidence let in by the plaintiffs is bereft of any pleadings so
far as it relates to the partial partition as mentioned in
Exhibit P1 and the consent of Bhupal to partition the suit
property subsequently as per Exhibit P6. These aspects are
nowhere to be found in the pleadings of the plaintiffs.
- 25 NC: 2026:KHC-D:791
RSA No. 5271 of 2008
HC-KAR
26.
So far as the loan from the Sangli bank (Exhibit
P4) is concerned, it holds that there is no pleading to the
effect that the loan was raised for the purpose of purchase
of the suit property. In para 16, the trial Court holds as
below:
16. xxxx The document as per Ex.P.4 on its careful
reading goes to show that Parappa Giramallappa and
Bhupal have availed cash credit facility of Rs.1000/which was to be in force inbetween 30.09.1949 till end
of year i.e. 31.12.1949. The suit property is purchased
in the name of deceased Bhupal as per Ex.P.2 on
19.4.1949 for Rs.3,000/-. Therefore it is evident that the
cash credit facility availed by them is not for the purpose
of purchasing the suit property, since suit property was
already purchased on 19.4.1949 much prior to the
availment of cash credit facility as per Ex.P.4. The loan
availed is also Rs.1000/- whereas the sale consideration
under Ex.P.2 is Rs.3000/- there is no any pleading or
reasonable explanation coming from the plaintiffs to
prove that during the subsistence of joint family status
between Parappa and Giramappa the suit property was
purchased in the name of deceased Bhupal. xxxx
- 26 NC: 2026:KHC-D:791
RSA No. 5271 of 2008
HC-KAR
27.
Further, the trial Court also observed that there
is no material to show that there was any litigation in
respect of the suit property which would have substantiated
the contents of Exhibit P6, (translated copy P7), which
would have given credence to it.
28.
The
First
Appellate
Court
in
the
impugned
judgment, has discussed all these aspects in length. In para
15 of the impugned judgment it observes as below:
"15. xxxxx The suit property though purchased in the
year 1949 in the name of Bhupal it was not subjected
to partition during the year 1957. There is no recital
that the suit property was kept in joint possession of
the family of plaintiffs and defendants as such it is not
included in Ex.P.1. There is no whishper in Ex.P.1
partition deed in respect of the suit property. The first
paragraph
of
Ex.P.1
indicates
that
parappa
and
Giramallappa had partitioned the joint family properties
long back under Apasat-Watani and the said terms of
partition are incorporated in Ex.P.1. PW.1 during the
course of evidence stated that his father Giramallappa
and Parappa
father of Bhupal were partitioned the
family properties excluding the suit property - during
- 27 NC: 2026:KHC-D:791
RSA No. 5271 of 2008
HC-KAR
the year 1955. PW.1 in cross-examination admitted
that he has not produced any documents to show that
Giramallappa and Parappa had partitioned the family
properties in the year 1955. On the contrary DW.1
deposed
that
Giriamallappa
and
parappa
had
partitioned the family properties during the year 1945
and thereafter in the year 1949 the suit property was
purchased in the name of Bhupal out of self-earnings
of the branch of Parappa. In fact the suit property had
purchased out of the joint family funds that would have
mentioned in Ex.P.1. partition deed".
29.
Further in para 18, it observes as below:
"The Land Tribunal, Jamakhandi after making detail
enquiry rejected the application filed by Giramallappa
father of plaintiff No.1 an defendant Nos. 4 and 5 in
respect of the suit property. The father of plaintiff No.1
filed Form No. VII stating that Bhupal husband of
defendant No.1 was owner of the suit property. The
said Form No.VII filed on 28.06.1976 PW.1 during the
course of cross-examination on page No.7 admitted
that his father had filed Form No. VII for grant of
occupancy rights in respect of the suit property PW.1
explained that his father filed form No. VII during the
year 1976 to retain the suit property for their family
PW.1 on page No.7 further admitted that his father
filed Form No.VII claiming that he is tenant of the suit
- 28 NC: 2026:KHC-D:791
RSA No. 5271 of 2008
HC-KAR
property admitting that Bhupal was its owner PW.1
further admitted that Form No. VII filed by his father is
dismissed in the year 1992 and he gave evidence
before the Land Tribunal Jamakhandi in respect of the
suit property. The admission of plaintiff Nol1 indicates
that his father while filing form No. VII before the Land
Tribunal Jamakhandi admitted that Bhupal husband of
defendant No.1 was owner of the suit property."
30.
Finally in the concluding part, the First Appellate
Court observes as below:
"The above discussion shows that the plaintiffs failed to
prove that the suit property had purchased prior to
severance
of
joint
family
status
in
between
Giramallappa and parappa and it was purchased out of
joint family funds. secondly, they failed to prove that
the suit property was not subjected to partition in the
year 1956. Lastly, the plaintiffs failed to establish that
the
suit
property
was
continued
to
be
in
joint
possession and enjoyment of them and defendants."
31.
Thus, it is evident that both the Courts below
have considered that the primary burden of proving the fact
that the suit schedule property is the joint family property
and it was acquired out of the joint family nucleus is on the
- 29 NC: 2026:KHC-D:791
RSA No. 5271 of 2008
HC-KAR
plaintiffs. Obviously, there was a partition prior to 1957 as
per Exhibit P1 and Exhibit P6, an undertaking or a consent
for a deferred partition by Bhupal was not proved as
required under law. If at all there was an Exhibit P6, the
contents of which should have found place in Exhibit P1.
Therefore, when there is no pleading on the part of the
plaintiffs to establish as to how Bhupal had purchased the
property and how there was tenancy which was created in
favour of Girimallappa which showed that it was a joint
family property and as such, the Land Tribunal had
dismissed the application filed by Girmallappa, it is not in
the mouth of the plaintiffs to say that the suit property
continued to be the joint family property. Though there is a
presumption that a family is joint unless it is shown to be
severed, such presumption is not available in respect of the
nature of the property.
32.
In the case on hand, evidently there was a
partition much prior to 1955 as may be seen from Exhibit
P1. Moreover, Bhupal happens to be the brother's son of
- 30 NC: 2026:KHC-D:791
RSA No. 5271 of 2008
HC-KAR
Girmallappa. It is not known how and why the property was
purchased in the name of Bhupal. There is no explanation
as to how and why the property was purchased in the name
of Bhupal. On the other hand, the documents of partition at
Exhibit P1 and Exhibit P7 show that there was a partition
much earlier. Curiously, Exhibit P1 does not mention
anything about the suit property. The pleading is also silent
on that aspect. The explanation by the plaintiffs that suit
schedule property was to be partitioned later emanates only
from the Exhibit P6 and nothing else. Exhibit P6 do not find
any mention in the pleading and it has not been proved by
the plaintiffs. Therefore, this Court finds that the concurrent
findings cannot be held to be erroneous either on the
ground of negative finding on Issue No. 1 or an application
filed by Girmallappa to the Land Tribunal in Form No. 7
having been dismissed by it as per Exhibit P8. Therefore,
the substantial questions of law deserve to be answered in
the negative and accordingly, they are answered in the
- 31 NC: 2026:KHC-D:791
RSA No. 5271 of 2008
HC-KAR
negative. Consequently, the appeal fails and hence, the
following:
ORDER
The appeal is dismissed.
Costs made easy.
Sd/(C M JOSHI)
JUDGE
tsn*
List No.: 19 Sl No.: 5
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review