Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
--1--
IN THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT I N D O R E
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE HIRDESH
ON THE 8th OF JANUARY, 2024
SECOND APPEAL No. 194 of 2023
BETWEEN:SHANTILAL S/O RADHAKISH JANI, AGED ABOUT 75 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: AGRICULTURE DUDHIYA TEHSIL AND DISTRICT
INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....APPELLANT
(SHRI AMIT AGRAWAL, LEARNED SENIOR COUNSEL WITH SHRI
RISHIRAJ TRIVEDI, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE APPELLANT)
AND
1. SMT. SUNDARBAI W/O LATE GENDALAL JANI, AGED ABOUT 73
YEARS, OCCUPATION: HOUSEWIFE DUDHIYA TEHSIL AND DISTRICT
INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
2. SMT. VIDHYABAI W/O SHRI RADHESHYAM JAT, AGED ABOUT 48
YEARS, OCCUPATION: HOUSEWIFE VILLAGE BAGANKHEDA,
TEHSIL KANNOD (MADHYA PRADESH)
3. COLLECTOR THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH INDORE (MADHYA
PRADESH)
4. SMT. CHANDABAI W/O RAMBHAROSE JAT, AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: HOUSEWIFE GAOLGAON, TEHSIL SIVNI MALVA,
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(SHRI RAHUL KUMAR LAAD, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE
RESPONDENTS)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This appeal coming on for admission this day, the court
passed the following:
JUDGMENT
This second appeal has been filed by the appellant being aggrieved
--2--
by the judgment and decree dated 16.12.2022 passed in Civil Regular
Appeal No.114/2019 passed by 4th District Judge, Indore whereby the first
appellate court has upheld the judgment and decree passed by 9 th Civil
Judge, Class-I, Indore in RCS No.499A/2014.
2.
The brief facts of the case are that the respondents / plaintiffs filed a
Civil Suit before the learned Trial Court for declaration, partition,
possession, mesne profit, injunction in respect of agricultural land bearing
survey No.193/2 admeasuring 0.777 hectare situated at Village Malikhedi,
Tehsil and District Indore (herein after referred to as “Suit Properties”)
against the defendants/appellant. The respondents/plaintiffs averred that
the suit properties remained joint property of the husband of respondent
No.1-Late Gendalal and the appellant who are real brothers. It has also
been pleaded that due to the ill health of the husband of the respondent
No.1, the appellant looked after the agricultural work relating to suit
property and after the death of the husband of respondent No.1, the
appellant / plaintiff continued to look after the suit property but after some
time the appellant denied sharing the profit arising out of the produce from
the suit property. The respondent No.1 enquired as to her status in the land
records from where she gathered a knowledge that after the death of the
husband of respondent No.l, the plaintiff appellant secured mutation in his
name solely in respect of the suit property. The respondent No.1 claims
half share in the suit property and prayed for partition, possession and
mesne profit.
3.
The defendant No.1/appellant in his written statements admitted the
relationship of the parties however refuted the plaint averments and prayed
for the dismissal of the same. It was pleaded that Late Gendalal was in
need of money for his treatment and therefore he sold one half share of the
Suit property to the appellant in 1990 and since then the appellant enjoyed
--3--
the exclusive possession of the suit property in the capacity of owner. The
mutation order in his favour was passed in the year 1991 and the plaintiffs
were aware of the same and the husband of respondent No.1 tendered his
consent for the mutation.
4.
Learned counsel for the appellant submits that learned courts below
have committed error of law by not appreciating the evidence on record.
Learned courts below have committed error of law while drawing
unwarranted inferences and in passing judgment and decree based on
surmises and conjectures without appreciating the evidence and hence, the
findings arrived at by the courts below suffers from perversity. He further
submits that the courts below have miserably failed to appreciate that the
respondents/plaintiffs have remained failed to demolish the factum of
consented mutation in the name of the appellant in respect of the suit
property. He further stated that this suit was time barred because Article 99
of Limitation Act, 1963 gives one year time to set aside a sale by a civil or
revenue court or a sale for arrears of Government revenue or for any
demand recoverable as such arrears. Learned counsel for the appellant
placed reliance upon the judgments delivered in the cases of Ravinder
kaur Grewal and others Vs. Manjit Kaur and others, AIR 2019 SC
3827; Vidya Devi alias Vidya Vati (Dead) by LRs Vs. Prem Prakash
and others, 1995 (4) SCC, 496; Govindammal Vs. R.Preumal Chettiar
and others, 2006 (11) SCC, 600; Kashiram Gopal Garj Vs. Nathu Hira
and another, 1980 MPLJ 670 (FB) and Saranpal Kaur Anand Vs.
Praduman Singh Chandhok and others, 2022 (8) SCC, 401.
5.
Heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
6.
Learned
courts
below
have
respondents/plaintiff is owner of suit land.
recorded
categorically
that
--4--
7.
Learned counsel for the appellants submits that according to Article
99 of The Limitation Act, one year limitation is granted to the party to set
aside the sale by a civil or revenue court or a sale for arrears of
Government revenue or for any demand recoverable as such arrears. But, it
is a duty of defendant to prove that husband of respondent No.1- Gendalal
gave consent for mutation before revenue court in regard to the disputed
property in favour of the appellant but, respondent has not filed any
revenue record or proceeding of the revenue court to prove that Gendalal
gave consent for mutation in regard to the disputed property so limitation
of one year is not applicable in this case.
8.
Learned counsel for the appellant submits that husband of
respondent No.1 sold the disputed property to the appellant for
consideration of Rs.31,000/- in the year 1990 and gave consent before
Tehsildar for mutation in favour of respondent in revenue record.
9.
The immovable property more than Rs.100/- may be transferred by
way of registered sale deed. Section 54 of The Transfer of Property Act,
1882 reads as under:54. “Sale” defined.—
"Sale” is a transfer of ownership in exchange for a price paid
or promised or part-paid and part-promised.
Sale how made.—Such transfer, in the case of tangible
immoveable property of the value of one hundred rupees and
upwards, or in the case of a reversion or other intangible
thing, can be made only by a registered instrument.
In the case of tangible immoveable property of a value less
than one hundred rupees, such transfer may be made either
by a registered instrument or by delivery of the property.
Delivery of tangible immoveable property takes place when
the seller places the buyer, or such person as he directs, in
possession of the property.
Contract for sale.—A contract for the sale of immoveable
--5--
property is a contract that a sale of such property shall take
place on terms settled between the parties.
It does not, of itself, create any interest in or charge on such
property.”
In the case of Suraj Lamp & Industries Pvt. Ltd. Vs. State of
Haryan, Judgment Today 2011 (12) SC 654, Apex Court has held that
transfer of immovable property by way of sale can only be by a deed of
conveyance (sale deed). In the absence of a deed of conveyance (duly
stamped and registered as required by law), no right, title or interest in an
immovable property can be transferred.
10.
So according to the provision of Section 54 of Transfer of Property
Act, 1882, no right in immovable property can be transferred orally, it
must be by way of registered sale deed with proper stamp. So by way of
oral sale, no right has been accrued in favour of appellant.
11.
Learned
counsel
for
the
appellant
further
submits
that
appellant/defendant is in continuous possession of the suit land from 1990
and courts below have wrongly held that plaintiff is co-owner of the suit
land. It is well settled that question of the possession of the suit land is
essentially one of the question of fact. Respondent No.1/plaintiff's claim
that they are co-owner of the disputed land, appellant is unable to prove
that he purchased the suit land from the husband of respondent No.1 and
husband of respondent No.1 gave consent in favour of appellant for
mutation in revenue record in regard to suit property. So it was found that
suit land was ancestral property of husband of respondent No.1 and the
appellant.
12.
In the light of the aforesaid discussion, in the considered opinion of
this Court, impugned judgments passed by courts below are well reasoned
and based on due appreciation as well as documentary evidence available
--6--
on the record, findings recorded by the courts below are concurrent finding
of facts. The appellant has failed to show as to why the finding of facts
recorded by both the courts below are legally perverse and based on no
evidence. Thus, no substantial question of law arises for consideration in
the present second appeal.
13.
Hon'ble the Apex Court in the case of Hari Narayan Bansal Vs.
Dada Dev Mandir Prabandhak Sabha (Barah Gaon) Patam, reported
in (2015) 16 SCC 540 empowers this Court to finally dispose of this
appeal without framing the substantial questions of law at the admission
stage itself. The observation made by Hon'ble Supreme Court is
reproduced htereinbelow :“In our opinion, a substantial question of law is
not required to be framed if the High Court decides to
dismiss the second appeal at an admission stage. Only
in a case where the second appeal is admitted or is
decided finally by allowing the same, a substantial
question of law is required to be framed by the High
Court. In the instant case, no substantial question of
law was involved in the second appeal and therefore,
the High Court had rightly dismissed the second appeal
at the admission stage by passing the impugned order.
We, therefore, see no reason to entertain this Petition ”.
14.
Hon'ble Supreme Court in number of cases has held that in exercise
of powers under Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure, High Court
can interfere with the findings of fact only if the same is shown to be
perverse and based on no evidence.
15.
Accordingly, present second appeal sans merit, is hereby dismissed
at the admission stage for the reasons indicated above.
(HIRDESH)
JUDGE
N.R.
KUMAR RAIPURIA
Date: 2024.01.30 13:17:37 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review