Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
OSA No. 78 of 2019
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
Reserved on : 25-06-2026
Pronounced on : 28.07.2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE P. VELMURUGAN
AND
THE HON'BLE MRS.JUSTICE K. GOVINDARAJAN THILAKAVADI
OSA Nos. 78 and 80 of 2019
and
CMP NO. 7430 Of 2019
O.S.A. No.78 of 2019
Shanmugavelli
W/o. A. Ashokan,
No.6 Parthasarathy Street,
Saligramam, Chennai 600 093
..Appellant
Vs
1.R. Panchavarnam
W/o. Late A. Raja,
No.62/13, Vijayaraghavapuram 3rd Street,
Saligramam, Chennai.
2.Minor R. Priyadharshini
D/o. Late A. Raja,
Minor Rep By Mother And Natural Guardian
R. Panchavarnam,
..Respondents
OSA No. 80 of 2019
1.R.Shanmugavalli
No.6 Parthasarathy Street, Saligramam, Chennai.
2.Minor R.Sabarish
3.Minor R.Harish
Minor 2 And 3 Rep By their Mother And Natural
Guardian R.Shanmugavalli,
..Appellants
Vs
__________
Page1 of 14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No. 78 of 2019
Minor R.Priyadharshini
Rep By Mother Natural Guardian,
Smt R.Panchavarnam
No.62/13, Vijayaraghavapuram 3rd Street,
Saligramam, Chennai 600 093
..Respondent
Common Prayer: Original Side Appeals are filed under Order XXXVI of Rule
1 of Original Side Rules Read with Clause 15 of the Letters Patent praying to
set aside the order dated 11-08-2017 passed in OP Nos.637 of 2008 and 432 of
2009 on the file of this Court.
For Appellant(s):
Mr. S.C. Sezhiyan
for Mr. K. Subash in both appeals
For Respondent(s):
Ms. M.Meenatchi For R1 and R2 in OSA
No.78/2019 and
for Sole Respondent in OSA No. 80/2019
Common Judgment
(Judgment of the Court was delivered by K.Govindarajan Thilakavadi J.)
A common judgment of this Court, disposing of two petitions is in
challenge before us.
2. The petition in O.P. No.637/2008 was filed under Section 372 and 276
of the Indian Succession Act and Order XXV Rule 6 of the Original Side Rules,
by one Panjavarnam and Minor Priyadarshini, claiming themselves to be the
widow and the daughter of Late Raja. The said Raja died on 04.02.2007 while
in service at Government Royapettah Hospital, Chennai.
__________
Page2 of 14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No. 78 of 2019
3. The petition in O.P. No.432/2009 was filed by one Shanmugavalli
along with minor Sons, namely, Sabarish and Harish, claiming themselves to be
the widow and children of late Raja.
These two petitions came to be filed for
obtaining Succession Certificate with respect to the claim for the death benefits
and pensionary benefits of deceased Raja.
4. Therefore, both Panchavarnam and Shanmugavalli are claiming to be
the legally wedded wife of Raja. As stated above, both the succession cases
came to be consolidated and tried together. Both oral and documentary evidence
was led by both the parties. The petitioner in O.P. No.637/2008 namely
Panchavarnam has stated that, she had married Raja as per the Hindu Religious
Rights and Customs on 28.08.1998 and the 2nd petitioner was born to them.
Their marriage Invitation is marked as Ex.P1.
She had further stated that
Shanmugavalli had made rival claim for the death benefits of deceased Raja,
who is actually the wife of Ashokan, brother of deceased Raja. She had also
produced
Ex.P4 dated 11.11.1984, the marriage receipt issued by Meenakshi
Sundareswarar temple, reflecting the marriage between Ashokan and
Shanmugavalli, petitioner in O.P. No.432/2009, claiming that she is the wife of
Ashokan, and the minor petitioners 2 and 3 in O.P. No.432 of 2009 are the
children born to the said Ashokan and Shanmugavalli and they are not the
children born to Late. Raja and Shanmugavalli.
__________
Page3 of 14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No. 78 of 2019
5. On the side of Shanmugavalli, copies of family Ration Card, Voter ID
card were marked as Ex.R2 and R3 to establish the fact that the said Raja was
living along with Shanmugavalli at No.6, Parthasarathy Street, Saligramam,
Chennai 93.
Shanmugavalli deposed that her marriage with Ashokan was
dissolved as per customary practice in the presence of village elders under
Ex.R4 and duly signed by her and Ashokan. Further She had examined R.W.2
and R.W.3 respectively. R.W.2 Krishnan claimed to be the president of
Alagarsamypuram, Arunthadiyar, Hindu, Sakliyar, Uravinmurai Munnetra
Sangam. Through him Ex.R21 was marked, which is a letter by Kathiriyammal
dated 01.02.1995, seeking to settle the difference of opinion between her
daughter Shanmugavalli and son-in-law Ashokan.
R.W.2 deposed that the
marriage between Shanmugavalli and Ashokan was dissolved by them vide
Ex.R4 Divorce deed.
Further, for the said reason, one Perumal was also
examined as R.W.3 on the side of Shanmugavalli, claiming to be Head of the
Village Committee.
Further, the marriage agreement entered into between
Shanmugavalli and Late Raja is marked as Ex.R5 and the Birth certificates and
school certificates of Harish and Sabarish, the 2nd and 3rd petitioners in O.P.
No.432/2009, are marked as Ex.R7 to Ex.R10. Ex.R13 is the burial ground
report of death and Ex.R14 is the death certificate of Raja. Ex.R21 is the letter
from Kathiriyammal, mother of Shanmugavalli.Ex.R22 is the letter of
Mariyappan and Ex. R23 is the document relating to divorce. Shanmugavalli
__________
Page4 of 14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No. 78 of 2019
marked the above documents to establish that she is the wife of Late Raja and
petitioners 2 and 3 are born to them.
6. However, the learned Single Judge disbelieved the above documents
marked on the side of Shanmugavvali and allowed the petition filed by
Panchavarnam in O.P. No.637 of 2008 and consequently dismissed the petition
filed by Shanmugavalli in O.P. No.432 of 2009 against which, the said
Shanmugavalli has preferred the present appeals.
7. Mr. S.C. Sezhiyan, The learned counsel appearing for the appellant
Shanmugavalli strenuously argued that the learned Single Judge could not have
granted the claim of Panchavarnam. He pointed out that, in grant of certificate
in favour of Panchavarnam, the claim of Shanmugavalli and her two sons was
altogether ignored, despite the fact that the name of Panchavarnam and her
daughter was not reflected in the Service Register of Raja who died on
04.02.2007 and the said Raja had only nominated Shanmugavalli to receive the
retirement benefits. He would further submit that, even children born through
second marriage are entitled for the estate of the deceased, which is a settled
law. His further contention is that, Exs. R1 to R21 would clearly establish that
deceased Raja was living only with Shanmugavalli till his death. However, the
learned Single Judge failed to appreciate the above documents in a proper
perspective manner. Further, the ex-husband Ashokan authored Ex.R4 which is
__________
Page5 of 14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No. 78 of 2019
nothing but an agreement entered into between Ashokan and Shanmugavalli,
dissolving their marriage. Hence, he would submit that the relationship between
Shanmugavalli and Ashokan came to an end through E.R4 as per their
customary practice and Ex.R5 is the marriage agreement entered into between
Shanmugavalli and Raja.
Further, Ex.R8 to R10 are Government Records in
which the deceased Raja had signed as the father of the minor children. Hence
he would submit that the learned Single Judge, without appreciating the above
documents, dismissed the petition filed by Shanmugavalli, warrants interference
by this Court.
8. On the other hand, Ms.M.Meenatchi, the learned counsel for the
respondents would submit that the marriage between Panchavarnam and Raja is
established through Ex.P1 marriage invitation and that the marriage between
them was arranged by elders solemnised at Sarveswarar Temple. Her further
contention is that the evidence of Ashokan, who was examined as P.W.2, would
clearly establish that he is the husband of Shanmugavalli and the marriage
between them was never dissolved and that the petitioners Sabarish and Harish
were only born to him through his wife Shanmugavalli. She further submitted
that the evidences of P.W.3 and P.W.4, who are the sisters of deceased Raja
would clearly establish that the said Panchvarnam alone is the wife of deceased
Raja and the said Shanmugavalli never married Raja at any point of time. The
learned counsel
__________
Page6 of 14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
would further contend that a customary divorce must be
OSA No. 78 of 2019
specifically pleaded and established by the person propounding such custom
and the law of land is that the marriage has to be solemnised and it has to be
dissolved only by a court of law and that in the present case the marriage
between Ashokan and Shanmugavalli admittedly was not dissolved by any court
of law. She would further contend that customary divorce should not be taken as
one of the grounds to grant divorce and the party pleading the form of
customary divorce should raise this issue before the competent court to prove
the source. The learned counsel supported the judgment of the Single Judge and
contented that Panchavarnam and her daughter Priyadarshini being the legal
heirs of deceased Raja are alone entitled for the grant of succession certificate as
ordered by the learned Single Judge.
Consequently, the contention of
Shanmugavalli was rightly rejected by the learned Single Judge, warrants any
interference.
9. Heard on both sides. Records perused.
10. The petitions in O.P. Nos. 637/2008 and 432/2009 concerns the grant
of succession certificate in respect of death benefits and pensionary benefits of
deceased Raja.
10.1. The 1st petitioner in O.P. No.637/2008 namely Panchavarnam is the
legally wedded wife of deceased Raja and the 2 nd petitioner Priyadarshini in the
__________
Page7 of 14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No. 78 of 2019
said petition is the daughter of deceased Raja and Panchavarnam. Her marriage
with Raja is admitted and has not been shown to have been dissolved by any
decree of a competent Court. She claims the succession certificate on that basis.
10.2. The 1st petitioner in O.P. No.432/2009, namely Shanmugavalli
asserts that she lived with Raja as his wife for several years and petitioners 2
and 3 are the children born to them. To establish her status, she has produced a
document described as a customary divorce deed executed between herself and
her erstwhile husband before panchayatdars. There can be no dispute that the
said Shanmugavalli had never pleaded divorce through a competent court much
less a customary divorce,
and the existence of any custom recognizing
dissolution of marriage by such a panchayat divorce. She relies on documentary
evidences to show that her first marriage was dissolved and that she married the
deceased Raja and had long cohabitation with him and the birth certificates and
school records relating to the two children for establishing that they were born
to deceased Raja.
10.3. Now the question arises whether Shanmugavalli has established that
her earlier marriage stood validly dissolved under law. Though she has relied
upon
Ex.R4 divorce deed duly signed by herself and Ashokan and Ex.R5
photocopy of the marriage registration deed dated 27.08.1998 between her and
deceased Raja, it is well settled that a customary divorce must be specifically
__________
Page8 of 14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No. 78 of 2019
pleaded and established by the person propounding such custom and the law of
the land is that marriage has to be solemnised and it has to be dissolved only by
a Court of law. Admittedly, the marriage between Ashokan and Shanmugavalli
was not dissolved by any Court of law. The party pleading the form of
customary divorce should raise this issue before the competent court to prove
the source. Under the Hindu Marriage Act, the Hindu marriage can be dissolved
only by a decree of divorce passed by a competent Court, unless a valid custom
having the force of law permitting customary divorce is specifically pleaded and
strictly proved.
10.4. In the present case, the said Shanmugavalli has neither pleaded the
existence of such a custom nor led evidence establishing that the community to
which she belongs recognises dissolution of marriage through panchayat. Mere
production of a divorce deed signed before panchayatdars is insufficient to
establish a valid dissolution of marriage. In the absence of pleading and proof of
custom, such a document has no legal sanctity. In such circumstances, her
earlier marriage cannot be held to have been validly dissolved. Further, it
should not be understood by the above discussion that we made, in any way,
deciding the status of Shanmugavalli finally. She may still prosecute her own
remedies for establishing her own status independently of these proceedings.
__________
Page9 of 14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No. 78 of 2019
10.5. However, the evidence establishes that she cohabitated with Raja
for a considerable period until his death and that two children, namely Harish
and Sabarish were born during such cohabitation. The documents produced
regarding the children have not been effectively rebutted. The paternity of the
children stands satisfactorily established.
10.6. The law distinguishes the status of the woman from the status of
children. Even where the marriage is void, children born from such relationship
are entitled to the protection available under Section 16 of the Hindu Marriage
Act, and cannot be treated as illegitimate merely because the marriage of their
parents is void. They are entitled to succeed to the property of there parents in
accordance with law.
10.7. The proceedings for grant of succession certificate under the Indian
Succession Act, are summary in nature. The Court is only required to ascertain
whether the persons are having the prima facie best entitlements to collect the
debts and securities of the deceased. Though the law is clear that a nominee can
claim the death benefits arising out of the employment can always file an
application under Section 372 of the Indian Succession Act, as there is nothing
in that Section to prevent such a nominee from claiming the certificate on the
basis of nomination. Though Shanmugavalli would claim that she had been
nominated in the Service Register of deceased Raja, there is nothing on record
__________
Page10 of 14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No. 78 of 2019
to show that she was nominated by late Raja.
10.8. However, Shanmugavalli not only claimed herself a nominee but
also mother of two children of late Raja who are also the legal heirs of late Raja.
Accordingly, while Shanmugavalli cannot be granted a succession certificate in
her personal capacity as widow of the deceased, the two children, being the
children of Raja, are entitled for succession certificate.
The Hon'ble Supreme
Court in a reported decision in Rameswari Devi vs. State of Bihar (2000) 2
SCC 431 has held that even if a Government Servant has contracted a second
marriage during the subsistence of the first marriage, children born out of such
second marriage would still be legitimate though the second marriage itself
would be void. The Apex Court, therefore, went on to hold that such children
would be entitled to pension but not the second wife.
10.9. Therefore, in our opinion, the learned Single judge was not justified
in granting the claim of Panchavarnam to the exclusion of deceased Raja's
legitimate legal heirs.
10.10. Therefore, even if Panchavarnam is declared the legally wedded
wife and is granted the succession certificate, the rights of children who
establish that they are the biological children of Raja cannot be extinguished by
such proceedings. While family pension is generally payable only to the legally
__________
Page11 of 14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No. 78 of 2019
recognised spouse and eligible dependants under the applicable service rules,
terminal benefits forming part of the deceased's estate may be distributable
among all legal heirs including children who are entitled to inherit under law.
10.11. Hence, we are inclined to pass the following orders:
The succession certificate shall be issued jointly :
(a) To the petitioners in O.P. No. 637 of 2008 , namely Panchavarnam
and Priyadarshini (since attained majority) and
(b) to the petitioners 2 and 3 (since attained majority)
in
O.P.No.432/2009.
10.12. It is made clear that this judgment is confined to the grant of
succession certificate and shall not prejudice or extinguish any independent
right that may accrue to the said children in accordance with law.
This
approach is consistent with the settled principle that a succession certificate
does not adjudicate questions of heirship conclusively and does not bar
subsequent civil proceedings regarding entitlement to the estate. The amounts
shall be distributed in accordance with the personal law governing succession.
__________
Page12 of 14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No. 78 of 2019
11. In the result, both the Original Side Appeals are allowed. No costs.
Consequently connected miscellaneous petition is closed.
(P.V.,J.)
(K.G.T.,J.)
28-07-2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
BGA
To
The Sub Assistant Registrar
Original Side, High Court, Madras
__________
Page13 of 14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
OSA No. 78 of 2019
P.VELMURUGAN J.
AND
K.GOVINDARAJAN THILAKAVADI J.
BGA
Pre delivery Common Judgment in
OSA Nos. 78 and 80 of 2019
and
CMP No. 7430 of 2019
28-07-2026
__________
Page14 of 14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review