Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SHAMURAILATPAM SUSHIL
SHARMA
SUSHIL SHARMA
Date: 2023.08.31 13:46:03 +05'30'
Page |1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No. 566 of 2023
Shri Shamurailatpam Devadutta Sharma, aged about
30 years, S/o Shri Sh. Indrajit Sharma, resident of
Thoubal Khekman Wangma Taba Makha Leikai, P.O.
& P.S. & District Thoubal, Manipur.
… PETITIONER
-VERSUS1.
The State of Manipur through the Chief Secretarycum-Commissioner/Secretary
(Department
of
Personnel & Administrative Reforms), Govt. of
Manipur, Manipur Secretariat South Block, Imphal
West, Manipur – 795001.
2.
The Department of Higher and Technical Education,
through
the Principal Secretary/
Commissioner/
Secretary (Higher & Technical Education) Govt. of
Manipur, Manipur Secretariat, Imphal West, Manipur795001.
3.
The Department of Education (S) through the Principal
Secretary/ Commissioner/ Secretary Education (S),
Govt. of Manipur, Manipur Secretariat South Block,
Imphal West, Manipur – 795001.
4.
The Department of Law and Legislative Affairs,
through
the Principal Secretary/
Commissioner/
Secretary, Govt. of Manipur, Manipur Secretariat,
Imphal West, Manipur – 795001.
… RESPONDENTS
WP(C) No. 566 of 2023
Page |2
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE M.V. MURALIDARAN
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For the Petitioner
::
Mr. S. Athoi, Adv.
For the Respondents
::
Mr. M. Devananda, Addl. AG
Date of Hearing and
reserving Judgment & Order ::
14.08.2023
Date of Judgment & Order
30.08.2023
::
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(CAV)
(M.V. Muralidaran, ACJ)
Heard Mr. Sh. Athoi, learned counsel for the
petitioner and perused the records.
2.
This writ petition has been filed by the petitioner for
issuance of a quo-warranto by declaring the impugned
notification dated 1.3.2023 as ultra vires.
3.
Mr. Sh. Athoi, the learned counsel for the petitioner
submitted that the impugned notification was issued with an
ulterior motive and mala fide intention to defeat the very purpose
of W.P.(C) No.783 of 2022 for the reasons that the private
respondent No.5 therein has to discharge his duties as Chairman
of the Board of Secondary Education, Manipur till he attain the
age of 65 years, which is in total violation of the provisions of the
Manipur Elementary and Secondary Education Act, 1972 as well
as the Rules framed thereunder. In fact, the fifth respondent is
WP(C) No. 566 of 2023
Page |3
not eligible for serving as Chairman, Board of Secondary
Education on attaining the age of 60 years. Therefore, the motive
for issuance of the impugned notification is vague and also bad
in law.
4.
The learned counsel further submitted that the
Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions,
Department of Personnel and Training, issued an Office
Memorandum dated 30.5.1998 in respect of the age of retirement
of Autonomous Bodies/Organisations. In the said Memorandum,
it was specifically provided that there shall be a complete ban for
grant of extension in service beyond the age of superannuation
except in case of medical and scientific specialist, who can be
granted extension on a case to case basis up to the age of 62
years and the orders relating to increase in age of retirement
shall not be applicable to the persons on extension in service.
5.
The learned counsel added that the authorities of
the University Grants Commission have revised the age of
superannuation of the Colleges and Universities up to the age of
65 years. The enhancement of the said age of superannuation
is applicable to the employees serving in teaching faculties and
the same cannot be applied to an employee of the teaching
faculties who has been on deputation to the post other than
WP(C) No. 566 of 2023
Page |4
teaching faculties in view of the letter dated 23.3.2007 of the
Ministry of Human Resource Development, Department of
Higher Education to the Secretary, UGC.
The impugned
notification is also in total violation of the conditions provided by
the Ministry of Human Resource Development.
6.
The learned counsel submitted that the third
respondent has right to amend the Rules, however, such
amendment has to be made in the interest of general public and
the same has to be made in consultation with the Department of
P&AR as well as the Department of Law and Legislative Affairs,
Government of Manipur. However, in the case on hand, there is
no picture for consulting the said Departments and the said
amendment of Rules under the Manipur Elementary and
Secondary Education Act, 1972 was made by the Commissioner
(Edn-S) at his own accord so as to protect a particular person.
The motive of the third respondent is against the principles of
natural justice and the constitutional mandate for which, the
impugned notification is not sustainable in the eye of law.
7.
According to the learned counsel, the post of
Chairman of the Board of Secondary Education, Manipur, is an
administrative post. It is impermissible for extension of the year
of a deputationist to an Office/Board/Council beyond the age of
WP(C) No. 566 of 2023
Page |5
60 years, by an employee whose substantive post is teaching
profession. In case, such an employee who is under deputation
to a Board/Council/Public Sector Undertaking is desired to serve
beyond the age of 60 years, he/she has to be repatriated to
his/her parent Department. Otherwise, he/she has to retire from
service on attaining the age of superannuation i.e. 60 years. In
view of the above, there is no room for existence of the impugned
notification.
8.
The learned counsel then submitted that the
impugned notification has no role to play in respect of the
employees of the Department of Higher and Technical Education
who is/are under deputation to other departments/offices
including the Board of Secondary Education as the service
condition of the employees of the Department of Education (U),
Government of Manipur, who are on deputation etc. to other
departments are governed by the terms and conditions of the
order dated 29.10.2014 issued by the Commissioner, Higher and
Technical Education.
9.
The learned counsel further submitted that the
Commissioner (Edn-S) has no power to appoint the present
Chairman of the Board of Secondary Education, Manipur, to his
present post as the said person is a regular employee of the
WP(C) No. 566 of 2023
Page |6
Department of Higher and Technical Education, Government of
Manipur. Therefore, the Commissioner (Edn-S) has no power for
issuance of the order of appointment. Thus, a prayer has been
made to set aside the impugned notification dated 1.3.2023.
10.
We have considered the submissions.
11.
The grievance of the petitioner is that he has filed
W.P.(C) No.783 of 2022 challenging the order dated 11.11.2021
issued by the Joint Secretary, Education (S), whereby a person
whose substantive post is Associate Professor in Electronics and
posted at the DM College of Science was allowed to discharge
his duties as Chairman of the Board of Secondary Education,
Manipur on deputation for a period of three years in total violation
of the provisions of the Manipur Secondary Education Act, 1972
as well as the Rules framed thereunder and the amendments
made vide order dated 27.1.2000 and also the Corrigendum
dated 1.9.2022. During the pendency of the said writ petition, the
Commissioner, Education (S) issued the impugned notification
thereby amending the Rule which was framed under the Manipur
Secondary Education Act by revising the upper age limit for
deputation from 60 years to 65 years and also by making
eligibility for deputation by an Associate Professor of a
WP(C) No. 566 of 2023
Page |7
Government College in addition to the eligibility as provided
earlier.
12.
The impugned notification dated 1.3.2023 reads
thus:
“No.DAB-1/8/2022-EDN(S)-EDN(S): Under
the powers conferred by the Section 12(2) of
the Manipur Elementary and Secondary
Education Act, 1972 as amended from time
to time, the Governor of Manipur is pleased
to amend Rule 5 and Rule 6(a) of the
“Recruitment and Conditions of the services
of the Chairman of the Board of Secondary
Education, Manipur Rule, 1979” as follows:I. Amendment of Rule 5 of the Recruitment
and conditions of Service of the Chairman of
the BoSEM Rules, 1979, by inserting the
following after the last line,
‘In case of appointment by deputation,
deputation will be allowed till the age of 65
years or upto the date of retirement
whichever is earlier, subject to the term of
deputation as notified vide Order No.3/19/79SE(S) dated 27/01/2000.
II. Amendment of Rule 6(a) of Mode of
Recruitment and Conditions of Service of the
Chairman of the BoSEM Rules, 1979 as
under:
WP(C) No. 566 of 2023
Page |8
‘6.
Mode
of
recruitment:
Method
of
appointment may be either by promotion or
deputation.
(a) Deputation: The Director of Education
(Schools) or a Professor of a Government
College or an Associate Professor of a
Government
College
with
years
experience in the Grade as the Chairman of
the Board’.”
13.
According to the petitioner, there is no provision
under Section 12(2) of the Act for amendment of Rules framed
thereunder. Despite that, the amendment was purportedly made
which is ultra vires.
14.
The prayer in the writ petition is for issuance of quo-
warranto and/or any other appropriate writ/order/direction by
declaring the impugned notification dated 01.03.2023 as ultravires, as the same is violative of the constitutional mandate.
15.
The very framing of the prayer in the writ petition is
not legally sustainable. The petitioner seeks issuance of a quowarranto to declare the impugned notification as ultra-vires.
Such a prayer was made by the petitioner without impleading the
person against whom quo-warranto is prayed .
WP(C) No. 566 of 2023
Page |9
16.
The maxim “quo waranto” means “by what
authority” and this writ is issued to prevent a ‘usurper’ from
wrongfully occupying a substantive public office, enjoying certain
privileges and franchise from that public office, when he does not
have the authority to do so. The person being appointed to the
public office must show by what authority he occupies it, in order
to consider it to be a valid appointment.
17.
The following conditions are required to be
considered by the Court to issue a writ of quo-warranto:
1. There is no bar or restriction on who can
apply. Any person can apply as long as their
fundamental or any other legal right is being
breached. In cases where there is no breach
of right, a question of public interest must
arise with respect to the application.
2. The application made by the applicant
should be bona fide.
3. The application should not be made for the
sake of certain hidden political struggle or
undercurrent. The applicant should act in
public interest, and not expect any benefit or
unethical
gain
through
making
the
application.
18.
The writ of quo-warranto can be issued under the
following cases:
WP(C) No. 566 of 2023
P a g e | 10
“1. When a public office (created by law or
the Constitution) is occupied by a private
person, who does not actually have the
authority to do so.
2. The public office must be substantive in
character. The duties connected to the office
must also be public in nature.
3. The usurper, whose authority is being
challenged, must be holding his position at
the time the challenge is made.
4. Even if a person was qualified at one point
of time, the writ of quo warranto can be
issued
against
him
if
he
loses
his
qualifications.”
19.
The case of the petitioner is that the Commissioner
has no power to appoint the present Chairman of the Board of
Secondary Education, Manipur, as the Chairman is a regular
employee of the Department of Higher and Technical Education.
20.
In paragraph 17 of the writ petition, the petitioner
averred that the Commissioner has no power for issuance of the
order of appointment dated 11.12.2021 and, therefore, the said
appointment order is null and void in the eye of law. Apart from
this, the term ‘deputation’ is a tripartite agreement i.e. lending
department,
borrowing
department
and
the
employee
concerned. In the instant case, there is no picture for having
WP(C) No. 566 of 2023
P a g e | 11
such an agreement for which the said appointment order has also
no role to play.
21.
Though the petitioner contended that the impugned
notification was issued for the benefit of a particular person
according to the choice, no proof has been produced to establish
the same. When the petitioner is levelling serious allegations
against the respondent authorities attacking the impugned
notification, it is his bounden duty to prove that the impugned
notification was issued only to support a particular candidate and
not in public interest.
22.
Admittedly, the office of the Chairman of the Board
of Secondary Education, against whom writ of quo-warranto is
sought has not been made as party. When the petitioner is
questioning a particular person eligibility to hold the post, it is the
duty of the petitioner to array the said person as respondent, as
any order passed without hearing the particular party is nullity.
23.
When the petitioner seeks quo-warranto, it is his
bounden duty to show how his fundamental and other legal rights
are breached by issuance of the impugned notification.
As
admitted by the petitioner, he is an unemployed person and is
not connected with the Departments concerned.
WP(C) No. 566 of 2023
P a g e | 12
24.
It is pertinent to note that a person cannot apply for
quo-warranto when he does not have even the remotest
connection to the appointment of the public office which is being
challenged. Even if the locus standi is relaxed, there must be
certain connection between the petitioner and the appointment to
the public office.
In the case on hand, nothing has been
produced by the petitioner to connect him with the appointment
order, impugned notification and the Department.
25.
Coming to the impugned notification, the petitioner
is challenging the impugned notification dated 1.3.2023 on the
ground that the impugned notification has no role to play in
respect of the employees of the Department of Higher and
Technical Education, Government Manipur who are under
deputation to other departments, including the Board of
Secondary Education, as the service condition of employees of
the Department of Education (U), Government of Manipur, who
are on deputation etc. to other departments are governed by the
terms and conditions of the order dated 29.10.2014 issued by the
Commissioner, Higher & Technical Education.
26.
The challenge made to the impugned notification is
not well founded and the petitioner is not an aggrieved person to
challenge the impugned notification.
WP(C) No. 566 of 2023
P a g e | 13
27.
Article 226 of the Constitution of India empowers
the High Court to issue to any person or authority including the
Government within its territorial jurisdiction, directions, orders or
writs in the nature of mandamus, certiorari, prohibition or quowarranto for the enforcement of fundamental rights or for the
enforcement of the legal rights and for any other purpose. The
founding fathers of our Constitution have couched the Article in
comprehensive phraseology to enable the High Court to remedy
injustice wherever it is found, but it is equally true that a person
invoking the extraordinary jurisdiction of this Court should be an
aggrieved person.
If he does not fulfill the character of an
aggrieved person and is a stranger, the Court will, in its
discretion, deny him the extraordinary remedy.
28.
It is the plea of the petitioner that in order to give
benefit to the present Chairman, Board of Secondary Education,
the impugned notification was issued. When such being the plea,
the present Chairman of the Board of Secondary Education has
to be made as party. However, the petitioner has failed to array
the Chairman, Board of Secondary Education as party
respondent in the writ petition.
29.
Though the petitioner contended that there is no
power for amendment of the provision of the Rules framed under
WP(C) No. 566 of 2023
P a g e | 14
the Act, nothing has been produced by the petitioner. On the
other hand and as stated supra, in the impugned notification itself
it has been stated that under the power conferred under Section
12(2), the Governor is pleased to amend Rules 5 and 6(a) of the
Recruitment and Conditions of the services of the Chairman of
the Board of Secondary Education, Manipur Rule, 1979.
Admittedly, no aggrieved person in the Department has
challenged the impugned notification.
30.
We are of the view that the impugned notification
has been issued considering all the relevant provisions of the Act.
No valid grounds have been made to interfere with the same.
Thus, writ petition fails.
31.
The writ petition is dismissed at the admission stage
itself. No costs.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
Sushil
WP(C) No. 566 of 2023
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review