Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Reserved on: 27.10.2025
Pronounced on: 27.01.2026
Uploaded on:
12.02.2026
Whether the operative part or full
judgment is pronounced: FULL
OWP No. 1208/2012
c/w
OWP No. 1212/2012
CPOWP No. 124/2015
CPOWP No. 227/2018
Vidyawati and others
…..Petitioners
Through: Mr. P. N. Raina, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. J. A. Hamal, Advocate
Vs
Financial Commissioner (Revenue) and others
.….Respondents
Through: Ms. Nazia Fazal, Advocate vice
Mrs. Monika Kohli, Sr. AAG
Mr. Vinod Wali, Advocate
Coram :
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAHUL BHARTI, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
OWP No. 1208/2012
01.
Editing of facts by litigants effects the edict of
litigation best defines the present case in which both sides
have come charging each other not speaking true and
correct facts despite both fully knowing true and correct
facts alike while one party assailing and other availing the
verdict in question.
OWP No. 1208/2012
c/w
OWP No. 1212/2012
CPOWP No. 124/2015
CPOWP No. 227/2018
02.
The petitioners No. 1 to 4 and the respondents No. 3
& 4 come from a same clan. The kinship of the petitioners
No. 1 to 4 and the respondents No. 3 to 4 needs to set out
before coming to deal with the cause and core of the dispute
which has led to the institution of more than decade long
pending present writ petition.
03.
The common ancestor of the petitioners No. 1 to 4
and the respondents No. 3 to 4 is one Sh. Nand. The
pedigree of said Sh. Nand bearing mention of the petitioner
No. 1 to 4 as well as the respondents No. 3 to 4 is given as
under:-
Nand
2 sons
Tota
Pyara
1 son
3 sons
Himmat
Balia
Haldar Joo
Lakshman
5 sons
Niranjan
Nath
Nana
Joo
Bishamber
Nath
1 son
1 daughter
Kailash
Bonamati
Prithvi Nath
Nath Ji alias
Dwarika Nath
(Petitioner No.1)
2 sons
Maharaj Krishan
Sharma
(Respondent No. 3)
Subash Krishan
Sharma
(Respondent No. 4)
OWP No. 1208/2012
c/w
OWP No. 1212/2012
CPOWP No. 124/2015
CPOWP No. 227/2018
Adopted
Son
Widow
Dalip Kumar
(Petitioner No. 2)
Soomawati
(Petitioner No. 4)
Son
Bharat Bhushan
(Petitioner No. 3)
04.
The petitioner No. 1 – Nath Ji alias Dwarika Nath is
one of said five sons of Haldar Joo.
05.
The petitioner No. 2 - Soomawati and the petitioner
No.3 – Bharat Bhushan are widow and son of Prithvi Nath
who was also one of said five sons of Haldar Joo.
06.
Petitioner No. 4 – Dalip Kumar is actually said to be
natural son of said Prithvi Nath but taken in adoption by his
brother Bishamber Nath, third son of Haldar Joo.
07.
The respondent No. 3 – Maharaj Krishan Sharma
and the respondent No. 4 - Subash Krishan Sharma are
sons of Niranjan Nath, fourth son of Haldar Joo.
08.
In so far as Haldar Joo’s fifth son late Nana Joo is
concerned, he in turn is said to have four sons, namely,
Soom Nath, Mohan Lal, Makhan Lal and Sundri Lal who do
not figure as party in the present petition.
09.
Facts permitting, if a safe inference is to be drawn
from the state of pleadings obtaining on record, then all
afore-named five sons of Haldar Joo in one way or other had
succeeded to the ancestral property in the sense that Haldar
Joo’s two brothers Balia (Balaha) and Lakshman had died
issueless whereas his cousin Himmat’s son Kalish is alleged
to have adopted Niranjan Nath, one of five sons of Haldar
Joo.
OWP No. 1208/2012
c/w
OWP No. 1212/2012
CPOWP No. 124/2015
CPOWP No. 227/2018
10.
The respondent No. 3 – Maharaj Krishan Sharma
and the respondent No. 4 - Subash Krishan Sharma, thus,
relate themselves to said Kalish as well, in terms of
inheritance.
11.
It is a claim on the record of this case from the end
of the petitioners that long back in the month of March,
1961 there was a family settlement amongst five brothers
namely, Niranjan Nath, Nana Joo, Bishamber Nath, Prithvi
Nath Ji alias Dwarika Nath- the petitioner No. 1 when the
entire property relatable as ancestral property drawn from
great grandfather – Nand had come to be apportioned in five
equal shares and, accordingly, all five shareholders came to
be in settled possession thereof.
12.
It is also an accepted position of fact, which may
admit of no denial or dispute even from the end of the
petitioners or for that matter from
the end of
the
respondents
from
legal
No.
&
or
even
the
heirs/representatives of Nana Joo, that at no point of time
there was any dispute whatsoever obtaining amongst the
descendants of Nand which first includes his two sons,
namely, Tota and Pyara, then their next off-springs,
namely, Balia, Haldar, Lakshman and Himmat followed by
their next generation comprised of five sons of Haldar and
Kalish sole son of Himmat with respect to the estate which
had devolved upon them comprising in particular of the
agricultural land all situated in Village Kherman Ganesh
Raina (Wanpoh), Tehsil Kulgam, District Anantnag.
OWP No. 1208/2012
c/w
OWP No. 1212/2012
CPOWP No. 124/2015
CPOWP No. 227/2018
13.
Khewat Nos. 6, 14, 22, 34 & 35 are relatable to the
clan of common ancestor Nand.
14.
In January, 2007, the respondents No. 3 & 4, by
virtue of a registered General Power of Attorney dated
25.01.2007, had come to constitute one Mst. Shahzada
Akhter W/o Mushtaq Ahmed Yatoo R/o Veesu, Tehsil
Dooru, District Anantnag as their lawful attorney with
respect to land comprised in khasra Nos. 211 (10 kanals 6
marlas), 205 (4 kanals 1 marla) & shamilat land measuring
1 kanal, aggregating to 15.7 kanals, thereby vesting said
attorney holder with possession of the aforesaid land with all
enabling powers to construct, sell, transfer, mortgage,
relinquish, gift etc.
15.
The aforesaid fact is a testament to the fact that
there was no dispute whatsoever relating to inheritance of
the estate in an apportioned status otherwise there could
not have been individual reference of khasra numbers with
measure of land as well to be mentioned in said General
Power of Attorney being so given.
16.
So much so, four sons as being legal heir of late
Nana Joo, who was one of sons of Haldar Joo, had similarly
executed a registered General Power of Attorney dated
25.01.2007 in favour of very said person – Mst. Shahzada
Akhter. In terms of this registered General Power of
Attorney, Soom Nath, Mohan Lal, Makhan Lal and Sundri
Lal authorized Mst. Shahzada Akhter with respect to land
OWP No. 1208/2012
c/w
OWP No. 1212/2012
CPOWP No. 124/2015
CPOWP No. 227/2018
comprised in khasra Nos. 205 (6 kanal 1 marla), 205 (1
kanal 10 marlas), 211 (10 marlas), 205 (12 marlas)
aggregating 8 kanals 13 marlas with identical power as
given by the respondents No. 3 & 4 in favour of said attorney
Mst. Shahzada Akhter.
17.
The petitioner No. 2 – Soomawati, the petitioner No.
3 – Bharat Bhushan and the petitioner No. 3 – Dalip Kumar
at their joint end, by virtue of a registered General Power of
Attorney dated 13.02.2007, constituted one Mst. Mugli W/o
Haji Gulam Mohd Rather as their joint attorney with respect
to land comprised in khasra Nos. 205-B (3 kanal 16 marlas),
205-C (9 kanal 17 marlas), 205-D (14 marlas) aggregating
14 kanals 7 marlas thereby constituting said attorney Mst.
Mugli to be in settled possession of the land forming subject
matter of the General Power of Attorney with all enabling
power and authority.
18.
The petitioner No. 1 – Nath Ji alias Dwarika Nath, at
his end, by virtue of a registered General Power of Attorney
dated 13.02.2007, also constituted same very Mst. Mugli as
his attorney with respect to land comprised in khasra No.
180 (7.9 kanal) along with Shamilat land.
19.
In the backdrop of all aforesaid obtaining General
Power of Attorneys, very first litigation which sprouted
involving the petitioner No. 1 and the respondents No. 3 & 4
is related to execution of one of two General Power of
Attorneys dated 13.02.2007 by the petitioner No. 1 – Nath
OWP No. 1208/2012
c/w
OWP No. 1212/2012
CPOWP No. 124/2015
CPOWP No. 227/2018
Ji alias Dwarika Nath in favour Mst. Mugli which came to be
questioned by the respondents No. 3 & 4 co-joined by Soom
Nath, Mohan Lal, Makhan Lal and Sundri Lal being four
sons of Nana Joo in a civil suit filed on 23.10.2008 before
the court of learned Sub Registrar (Munsiff), Jammu.
20.
In this civil suit, six plaintiffs, including the
respondents No. 3 & 4 herein, came forward with averments
that they are owners in possession of land measuring 7
kanals 9 marlas comprised in khasra No. 180 with which
the petitioner No.1 herein-Nath Ji alias Dwarika Nath,
figuring as the defendant No. 1 in the suit, had no concern
or right whatsoever. It came to be further averred that the
petitioner No. 1 – Nath Ji alias Dwarika Nath is the adopted
son of Bishamber Nath whereas in the impugned General
Power of Attorney dated 13.02.2007 he has falsely referred
to his father name as Haldar Joo.
21.
In response to the said civil suit, the petitioner No. 1
- Nath Ji alias Dwarika Nath had submitted his written
statement in January, 2009 stating therein that it is he who
is in possession of the land forming subject matter of the
impugned General Power of Attorney being within his
exclusive share in terms of the private partition having
taken place amongst the shareholders way back forty years
ago.
22.
The petitioner No. 1 - Nath Ji alias Dwarika Nath in
his written statement came to highlight that the respondents
OWP No. 1208/2012
c/w
OWP No. 1212/2012
CPOWP No. 124/2015
CPOWP No. 227/2018
No. 3 & 4 have also executed the General Power of Attorney
in favour of Mst. Shahzada Akhter and so is the case with
the plaintiffs No. 2 to 4, and the four sons of Nana Joo who
also had executed General Power of Attorney in favour of
Mst. Shahzada Akhter.
23.
It came to be stated in his written statement by the
petitioner No. 1 that the General Power of Attorney executed
by the petitioners No. 2 to 4 has not been questioned by the
respondents No. 3 & 4 and their co-plaintiffs in the said
suit.
24.
The petitioner No. 1 - Nath Ji alias Dwarika Nath in
his written statement came to dispel question mark with
respect to his parentage saying that he was son of Haldar
Joo and not the adopted son of his uncle Bishamber Nath
who, in fact, had adopted the petitioner No.4 – Dalip Kumar
who in turn succeeded Bishamber Nath as his sole legal
heir.
25.
All the aforesaid four registered General Power of
Attorneys are relatable to khasra numbers situated in village
Kherman
Ganesh
Raina
(Wanpoh),
Tehsil
&
District
Anantnag.
26.
As mentioned in the respective Attorneys, the
execution and registration of the aforesaid registered
General Power of Attorneys were made when the executants
OWP No. 1208/2012
c/w
OWP No. 1212/2012
CPOWP No. 124/2015
CPOWP No. 227/2018
were in state of migration having migrated out from
Anantnag (Kashmir) to Jammu.
27.
It is then in the year 2010 that so called dispute
came to be set into scene when the respondents No. 3 & 4
approached the respondent No.2 – District Magistrate,
Anantnag by invoking the provisions of Jammu & Kashmir
Migrant Immovable Property (Preservation, Protection
and Restraint on Distress Sales) Act, 1997 (in short
“Migrant
Immovable
Property
Act,
1997”)
with an
application addressed against the petitioners.
28.
Taking cognizance of said application in which the
petitioners herein were named as non-applicants, the
respondent No. 2 – District Magistrate, Anantnag had put
the petitioners herein on notice by reference to the fact that
the respondents No. 3 & 4 have complained against the
petitioners that there is an unauthorized execution of
attorney by them by reference to estate comprised in khewat
Nos. 35, 22, 14 & 6 of village Kherman Ganesh Raina
(Wanpoh).
29.
Before making the aforesaid application to the
respondent No. 2 – District Magistrate, Anantnag, the
respondents No. 3 & 4 had first in July, 2009 already
approached Tehsildar, Anantnag with an application stating
therein that they be given their purported share of
possession of land with respect to Khewat Nos. 34 & 35.
OWP No. 1208/2012
c/w
OWP No. 1212/2012
CPOWP No. 124/2015
CPOWP No. 227/2018
30.
During pendency of their original application so
made by the respondents No. 3 & 4 against the petitioners
before the respondent No. 2 – District Magistrate, Anantnag
complaining against unauthorized execution of Attorneys,
the respondents No. 3 & 4 had made second application
again to the respondent No. 2 – District Magistrate,
Anantnag for seeking restraint upon the petitioners not to
transfer or alienate or provide any attorney to anybody with
respect to the land comprised under khewat No. 35, 22, 14,
34 & 6 alleging that the petitioners have already transferred
the landed estate purportedly in excess of their share.
31.
In
response
to
this
second
application,
the
respondent No. 2 – District Magistrate, Anantnag, by virtue
of
an
Order
No.DCA/Mig/Camp(692)948/010
dated
03.01.2011, had directed maintaining of status quo with
respect to aforesaid khewat numbers’ related land.
32.
While the respondent No 2 – District Magistrate,
Anantnag was seized of the application so made by the
respondents
No.
&
with
respect
to
so
called
unauthorized execution of attorneys by the petitioners
relatable to khewat Nos. 35, 22, 14 & 6, an application
under section 5 of the Migrant Immovable Property Act,
1997 came to be made by the respondents No. 3 & 4
complaining therein that that one Gh. Mohammad Rather,
Nazir Ahmad Khan, Mohammad Ramzan Bhat & Ab.
Rehman Bhat are in unauthorized occupation of the
OWP No. 1208/2012
c/w
OWP No. 1212/2012
CPOWP No. 124/2015
CPOWP No. 227/2018
property share of the respondents No. 3 & 4 from where they
need to be evicted.
33.
The petitioners, on their part, in response to the
application so made under section 5 of the Migrant
Immovable Property Act, 1997 by the respondents No. 3 & 4
seeking
eviction of
unauthorized
occupants
from
the
purported migrant property, came up with the reply stating
therein that the application so made is not maintainable
because of inconsistent pleas made therein, all being
baseless and false.
34.
It came to be disclosed by the petitioners before the
respondent No. 2 – District Magistrate, Anantnag that there
is a civil suit in the court of Sub Registrar, Jammu preferred
by the respondents No. 3 & 4 challenging therein the locusstandi of the petitioners in executing the General Power of
Attorneys in view of which the respondent No. 2 – District
Magistrate, Anantnag himself had pended the proceedings
on the pretext that since the matter is pending in the civil
court so the outcome of the matter from the civil court is to
be awaited and, as such, the application preferred by the
respondents No. 3 & 4 invoking section 5 of the Migrant
Immovable Property Act, 1997 seeking eviction of the so
named unauthorized occupants was not maintainable.
35.
In their reply, the petitioners came to narrate that
how the respondents No. 3 & 4’s father Niranjan Nath was
related as brother to Nana, Bishamber Nath, Prithvi Nath
OWP No. 1208/2012
c/w
OWP No. 1212/2012
CPOWP No. 124/2015
CPOWP No. 227/2018
and the petitioner No. 1-Nath Ji all being sons of Haldar
Joo and how the respondents No. 3 & 4’s father Niranjan
was purportely related as adoptive son of Kailash S/o
Himmat, the cousin of Haldar Joo.
36.
By virtue of an order No. DCA/Mig/Camp(692)
010/1166 dated 11.10.2011, later on corrected to be
19.12.2011
by
virtue
of
DCA/Mig/Camp(692)010/1176
a
dated
corrigendum
21.12.2011,
No.
the
respondent No. 2 – District Magistrate, Anantnag came to
dispose of said application of the respondents No. 3 & 4
made under section 5 of the Migrant Immovable Property
Act, 1997 with the following directions:“Hence till the issue is settled in Civil Court, it will be in the
interest of the parties that re-course is taken to Section 5 of the
Jammu & Kashmir Migrant Immoveable Property (Preservation,
Protection and Restrain on Distress Sales) Act, 1997. It is thus
ordered that Tehsildar Anantnag shall take possession of the
whole migrant property and manage the property as is
envisaged under the Jammu & Kashmir Migrant Immoveable
Property (Preservation, Protection and Restrain on Distress
Sales) Act, 1997. Stay order if any is vacated and file consigned
to records.”
37.
In his said order dated 11.10.2011, later on re-
dated
19.12.2011,
the
respondent
No.
–
District
Magistrate, Anantnag came to refer that there is 32.19
kanals of land relatable to khewat No. 35 in which the
respondents No. 3 & 4 hold share of 19.15 kanals and that
the General Power of Attorneys executed by the petitioners
are in excess of the share and that the land in question is in
OWP No. 1208/2012
c/w
OWP No. 1212/2012
CPOWP No. 124/2015
CPOWP No. 227/2018
occupation of the attorney holders of the petitioners. It is
only this extent of property which came to bear mention and
identification in the entire order dated 11.10.2011, later on
re-dated 19.12.2011, by the respondent No. 2 – District
Magistrate, Anantnag.
38.
Aggrieved
of
the
respondent
No.2
–
District
Magistrate, Anantnag’s said order dated 11.10.2011, later
on re-dated 19.12.2011, an appeal under section 7 of the
Migrant Immovable Property Act, 1997 came to be preferred
by the petitioners before the Financial Commissioner
(Revenue), J&K on 03.01.2012 who, by virtue of his order
No. 669-70/FC/AP dated 09.01.2012, is said to have stayed
the operation of the impugned order of the respondent No. 2
– District Magistrate, Anantnag.
39.
The petitioner No. 1-Nath Ji alias Dwarika Nath
joined by the petitioner No. 3 – Bharat Bhushan by virtue of
an application dated 11.06.2012 filed before the Deputy
Commissioner, Anantnag had solicited the release of their
residential building in view of the stay of the respondent No.
–
District
Magistrate,
Anantnag’s
order
dated
No.
DCA/Mig/Camp(692)010/1166 dated 19.12.2011.
40.
In their said application, it came to be referred by
the petitioners No. 1 & 3 that one Nazir Ahmad Khan S/o
Gh. Hassan Khan had intruded in occupation of the major
portion of the house by having broken the locks of two
rooms and this intrusion by Nazir Ahmad Khan was despite
OWP No. 1208/2012
c/w
OWP No. 1212/2012
CPOWP No. 124/2015
CPOWP No. 227/2018
the order of the respondent No. 2 – District Magistrate,
Anantnag upon Tehsildar, Anantnag to take the property
under possession.
41.
In response to said application of the petitioners No.
1 & 3, the respondent No. 2 – District Magistrate, Anantnag
had directed the Tehsildar concerned to proceed on spot
personally and take immediate appropriate action as per law
which resulted in action taken on spot by breaking open the
lock of said Nazir Ahmad Khan.
42.
The Financial Commissioner (Revenue), J&K, by
virtue of his final order dated 25.07.2012, came to dispose
of the appeal of the petitioners in the manner and effect
which is reproduced as under:“ORDER
The instant appeal has been filed against the order of
District Magistrate Anantnag wherein he has ordered that till
the dispute between the parties is settled in the Civil Court,
Tehsildar Anantnag shall take possession of the Migrant
property in dispute under the provisions of section 5 of the
Jammu & Kashmir Migrant Immovable Property (Preservation,
Protection and Restraint on Distress Sales) Act, 1997.
The order of the District Magistrate is only an interim
order and does not confer any right to any part in any manner
whatsoever. The order is operative till only the dispute is
settled between the parties in the Civil Court and it in
consonance with the
J&K
Migrant Immovable
Property
(Preservation, Protection and Restraint on Distress Sales) Act,
1997.
In view of the above the appeal is dismissed and
interim
directions issued vide
No. 660-68/FC-AP dated
09.01.2012 stands vacated.
OWP No. 1208/2012
c/w
OWP No. 1212/2012
CPOWP No. 124/2015
CPOWP No. 227/2018
File
shall
be
consigned
to
records
after
due
completion.”
43.
It is by reference to aforesaid two adjudications so
made under the Migrant Immovable Property Act, 1997 that
the present writ petition OWP No. 1208/2012 came to be
preferred by the four petitioners, led by the petitioner No. 1 –
Nath Ji alias Dwarika Nath, who at the relevant point of time
was the only surviving son of Haldar Joo with rest of his
four brothers being no more whereas the petitioners No. 2 &
3 are successors-in-interest of late Prithvi Nath, the
petitioner No. 4 being successors-in-interest of Bishamber
Nath and the respondents No. 3 & 4 being sons of Niranjan
Nath. Four sons of Nana Joo being not party to the dispute
and, thus, not figuring in the present writ petition.
44.
By virtue of an order dated 29.08.2012, this Court
came to direct status-quo on spot to be maintained, further
supplemented by a direction given in an order dated
15.07.2013 directing the parties to adhere to the interim
order dated 29.08.2012 and the official respondents
directed to ensure that the order is complied in letter and
spirit.
45.
During the pendency of present writ petition, the
petitioner No. 1 – Nath Ji alias Dwarika Nath came to expire
on 22.11.2020 with his legal representatives, namely,
Vidyawati (wife), Ashok Kumar Pandita (son), Jyoti
Pandita (daughter) & Seema Pandita (daughter) coming on
record in terms of an order dated 06.04.2022.
OWP No. 1208/2012
c/w
OWP No. 1212/2012
CPOWP No. 124/2015
CPOWP No. 227/2018
46.
In the writ petition, the petitioners have come
seeking quashment of the final order dated 25.07.2012
passed by the respondent No. 1-Financial Commissioner
(Revenue), J&K in dismissing the appeal of the petitioners
preferred against said original order dated 11.10.2011, later
on re-dated 19.12.2011, of the respondent No. 2 – District
Magistrate, Anantnag, and also of the quashment of the
original
order
dated
11.10.2011,
later
on
re-dated
19.12.2011, of the respondent No. 2 – District Magistrate,
Anantnag,
by
terming
both
as
arbitrary,
illegal
and
unconstitutional apart from being dehors the Migrant
Immovable Property Act, 1997.
47.
In the writ petition from the end of the petitioners, it
has come to be averred that Niranjan Nath, the father of the
respondents No. 3 & 4, was real brother of the petitioner No.
1 – Nath Ji alias Dwarika Nath, Prithvi Nath, Bishamber
Nath and Nana Joo, all being sons of Haldar Joo.
48.
Reference is made in the writ petition to father
Haldar Joo’s cousin Himmat without anything further stated
about him in terms of his son Kalish by whose reference the
respondents No. 3 & 4 claim their father Niranjan Nath to be
adopted son.
49.
It has come to be averred in the writ petition that
entire estate, without dilating further as to whether the said
estate comprised only of inheritance of Haldar Joo or of his
two brothers – Balia and Lakshman and his cousin Himmat,
OWP No. 1208/2012
c/w
OWP No. 1212/2012
CPOWP No. 124/2015
CPOWP No. 227/2018
by way of family settlement comprised of five shares, has
taken place by virtue of a writing on 12.03.1961 as referred
in the writ petition along with the documents annexed to
stress upon the point that there was no scope for any tussle
of succession amongst the shareholders i.e., the petitioner
No. 1 and his four brothers and their respective successorsin-interest.
50.
From the end of the petitioners, it has been stated in
the writ petition that the Clan’s original residential house in
village stood long apportioned into two with half share going
to Niranjan Nath, the father of the respondents No. 3 & 4
and other half going to Nana Joo, the father of Soom Nath,
Mohan Lal, Makhan Lal and Sundri Lal.
51.
By reference to three other brothers, namely,
Bishamber Nath, Prithvi Nath and the petitioner No. 1 –
Nath Ji alias Dwarika Nath, construction of a residential
house by converting existing granary site has been claimed
to highlight the separation of habitation having taken place
amongst the brothers. It has further been stated in the writ
petition that the respondents No. 3 & 4’s father Niranjan
Nath had, in addition, constructed a separate residential
house in the village somewhere in the year 1980 and so is
the case with other brother Nana Joo.
52.
The other three brothers led by the petitioner No. 1 –
Nath Ji alias Dwarika Nath are said to have constructed a
new house in the year 1972 in order to accommodate their
OWP No. 1208/2012
c/w
OWP No. 1212/2012
CPOWP No. 124/2015
CPOWP No. 227/2018
respective families about which the documentary permission
is said to have been availed in the name of Prithvi Nath
alone, whereas the insurance of said house property being
done in the name of the petitioner No. 1 – Nath Ji alias
Dwarika Nath and Prithvi Nath.
53.
The residential house constructed by conversion of a
granary is said to have been given to the petitioner No. 4 –
Dalip Kumar whereas the residential house constructed in
year 1972 is said to have been retained by the petitioner
No. 1 along with Prithvi Nath upon whose death his share
came to be in use and occupation of the petitioners No. 2 &
3 along with the petitioner No. 1 – Nath Ji alias Dwarika
Nath in his own share and to this effect document dated
09.05.1986 executed between the petitioner No. 1, Prithvi
Nath and the petitioner No. 4 – Dalip Kumar stands referred
in the writ petition besides being annexed with the writ
petition.
54.
The petitioners have stated as to how even after
migration from Kashmir in the year 1990, there was no
dispute of any kind whatsoever amongst the sons of Haldar
Joo.
55.
Prithvi Nath is said to have expired in the year 2004
whereas Niranjan Nath is said to have expired in the year
2006.
OWP No. 1208/2012
c/w
OWP No. 1212/2012
CPOWP No. 124/2015
CPOWP No. 227/2018
56.
As per the narrative set out in the writ petition, it is
only after the death of Niranjan Nath, the father of the
respondents No. 3 & 4 that said two respondents had
indulged in parting with their share of property by execution
of documents which included General Power of Attorney
executed on 25.01.2007 about which a reference has been
made herein earlier.
57.
On the same basis of claim, the petitioners are said
to have executed the requisite documents in parting with
their share of property by executing registered General
Power of Attorneys.
58.
The petitioners come forth in making mention that
the respondents No. 3 & 4 had made an application to
Tehsildar,
Anantnag in
2009 pleading contrary facts
meaning to unsettle a long settled property position by
asking for share of land falling in khewat Nos. 34 & 35 by
manipulating reports from the revenue field agency contrary
to the particular recorded position.
59.
Speaking
from
their
property
perspective,
the
petitioners have stated that their residential houses had
been trespassed against which they had filed applications in
the year 2005 followed by an application in June, 2012.
60.
The petitioners also refer to the fact of pending civil
suit having been preferred by sons of Nana Joo joined by the
OWP No. 1208/2012
c/w
OWP No. 1212/2012
CPOWP No. 124/2015
CPOWP No. 227/2018
respondents No. 3 & 4 before the court of learned Sub
Registrar (Munsiff), Jammu.
61.
The
petitioners
have
averred
that
from
onwards they have been frequently visiting their native
village Wanpoh residing in their respective residential
houses during summer.
62.
In
the
aforesaid
backdrop,
the
impugned
proceedings along with the impugned order before and by
the respondent No. 2 – District Magistrate, Anantnag has
been assailed on the grounds as set out in para 16 (a) to (c).
63.
In the grounds of challenge, the petitioners have
referred that there were no facts and circumstances which
warranted indulgence of the respondent No. 2 – District
Magistrate, Anantnag, as solicited by the respondents No. 3
& 4, who upon being apprised by the petitioners about true
state of facts and circumstances ought to have withdrawn
the indulgence by referring the parties to the civil suit in
which lis was already pending.
64.
The petitioners have highlighted that once the
respondents No. 3 & 4 themselves have sold their share of
agriculture land, said fact meant that there was no dispute
with respect to share holding.
65.
The manner in which the date of impugned order
originally given on
11.10.2011,
later on
re-dated as
19.12.2011 by the respondent No. 2 – District Magistrate,
OWP No. 1208/2012
c/w
OWP No. 1212/2012
CPOWP No. 124/2015
CPOWP No. 227/2018
Anantnag has also been highlighted to show that the
proceedings were conducted by the respondent No. 2 –
District Magistrate, Anantnag in a very shaded manner.
66.
The respondents No. 3 & 4 came forward with a
reply filed on 01.10.2012 to the writ petition in which the
two respondents came to stress upon the fact that their
father-Niranjan Nath was given in adoption to Kalish and,
accordingly,
their
father-Niranjan
Nath
had
acquired
inheritance of said Kalish by way of mutation attested which
property further passed unto them from their fatherNiranjan Nath.
67.
The respondents No. 3 & 4 have come attacking the
petitioner No.1- Nath Ji alias Dawarika Nath that his
parentage is not relatable to Haldar Joo as he was adopted
by Bishamber Nath, the brother of Haldar Joo and to this
effect the school record, service documents, state subject
certificate of the petitioner No. 1 are being referred to.
68.
With respect to the petitioner No. 4 – Dalip Kumar,
the respondents No. 3 & 4 refer him to be son of Prithvi
Nath and not the adopted son of Bishamber Nath.
69.
The underlying aim and objective of the writ petition
filed by the petitioners is said to be questioning the
mutation of inheritance attested by reference to Kalish in
favour of Niranjan Nath and then unto the respondents No.
3 & 4.
OWP No. 1208/2012
c/w
OWP No. 1212/2012
CPOWP No. 124/2015
CPOWP No. 227/2018
70.
The respondents No. 3 & 4 in their reply mention
that total ancestral property was divided in two equal shares
of which one share was inherited by grand-parents of the
answering respondents No. 3 & 4 and one share by legal
heirs of Haldar Joo and Balia (Balaha). The respondents No.
3 & 4 further claim one share out of the land inherited by
Balia (Balaha) and Haldar Joo as sons of Tota on the basis
of purported claim that they i.e., the respondents No. 3 & 4
are the registered tenants/cultivators. The respondents No.
3 & 4 further refer that some other land was personally
acquired by their ancestors about which mutation has been
attested and the same cannot be called in question.
71.
The respondents No. 3 & 4 refer that the writ
petition filed by the petitioners entail disputed questions of
fact for which writ jurisdiction is not a proper forum and for
that civil court should have been approached.
72.
The writ petition is challenged to be highly time
barred filed after so many decades for laying claim over
ancestral property beyond the shares as disclosed in the
mutation/s that too without challenging the mutation/s.
The respondents No. 3 & 4 in their reply have referred to
mutation Nos. 27 & 98 related to inheritance of and from
Kalish which mutations are said to have been questioned.
73.
The petitioner No. 1-Nath Ji alias Dawarika Nath
has been attacked personally by the respondents No. 3 & 4
reference to the fact that he has retired as a Deputy
OWP No. 1208/2012
c/w
OWP No. 1212/2012
CPOWP No. 124/2015
CPOWP No. 227/2018
Director, Animal Husbandry and by exploit of his said govt.
position
is
bent
upon
to
manipulate
the
facts
and
circumstances by claiming the property of Haldar Joo.
74.
The respondents No. 3 & 4, in their long drawn reply
to the writ petition, have come up with the repetition of
emphasis that they are short of their share whereas the
petitioners are bent upon to alienate the property held in
excess of their share and on that basis are meaning to
defend the indulgence of the respondent No. 2 – District
Magistrate,
Anantnag
under
the
Migrant
Immovable
Property Act, 1997.
75.
This Court has opened this judgment with an
educated observation that both sides have resorted to
editing of facts at every level and which is confirmed from
the very fact that the respondents No. 3 & 4 allege and
assert that the petitioner No. 1-Nath Ji alias Dwarka Nath
was not son of Haldar Joo but was an adopted son of
Bishamber Nath. In this regard, the respondents No. 3 & 4
refer to the alleged school and service related documents of
the petitioner No. 1. This fact has not been adverted to by
the petitioners in particular the petitioner No.1-Nath Ji alias
Dawarika Nath in their entire writ petition.
76.
This Court is not meaning to hold the fact that the
petitioner No. 1- Nath Ji alias Dawarika Nath could not
claim himself to be the natural son of Haldar Joo and
equally not related to Bishamber Nath in terms of parentage
OWP No. 1208/2012
c/w
OWP No. 1212/2012
CPOWP No. 124/2015
CPOWP No. 227/2018
by any formal adoption so as to link him in terms of his
parental lineage to Bishamber Nath instead of Haldar Joo
but
nevertheless,
there
should
have
been
a
candid
statement of fact in the writ petition upfront to said effect
instead of withholding the said aspect.
77.
On the other hand, the respondents No. 3 & 4 are
equally found playing smart and shrewd with facts in not
disclosing as to whether their father –Niranjan Nath was
natural son of Haldar Joo or not and further whether their
father- Niranjan Nath’s adoption by Kalish was on the basis
of any formal adoption deed or in the same manner as the
petitioner No. 1 is alleged to have been adopted by
Bishamber Nath.
78.
The respondents No. 3 & 4 are attempting to screen
away the fact that if their father-Niranjan Nath is to be
related to his adoptive father – Kalish, then how come in
their reply they are making a very double faced averment
that their father Niranjan Nath was also entitled to
succession from his natural father side without disclosing
said father’s name for sake of identify. Obviously, said
natural father of Niranjan Nath is none other than Haldar
Joo.
79.
The respondents No. 3 & 4, being co-plaintiffs with
four sons of Nana Joo, are coming forward with a claim to
oust the petitioner No. 1-Nath Ji alias Dawarika Nath from
succession by reference to Haldar Joo and assailing the
OWP No. 1208/2012
c/w
OWP No. 1212/2012
CPOWP No. 124/2015
CPOWP No. 227/2018
execution of General Power of Attorney by him but for the
reasons best known to the respondents No. 3 & 4 and their
co-plaintiffs, the suit has been restricted only for the
declaration to assail the General Power of Attorney dated
13.02.2007 executed by the petitioner No. 1-Nath Ji alias
Dawarika Nath without seeking any further declaration
about the status of the estate related to them.
80.
The respondents No. 3 & 4 in their reply to the writ
petition have come forward stating that their fatherNiranjan Nath was personally cultivating the ancestral
property of his original father as a tenant under the
Agrarian Reforms Act, 1976 but without bothering to
disclose the name of said original father, but simultaneously
claiming right of succession under him.
81.
The respondents No. 3 & 4 have not come forward
giving any whisper of detail as to how much ancestral
property was divided so to say in two equal shares and
whether any effect was given in the revenue record to said
alleged partition.
82.
When this Court bears in perspective the aforesaid
backdrop of blurred facts and circumstances, this Court
bears and suffers no iota of doubt that the act on the part of
the respondents No. 3 & 4 in invoking and exploiting the
proceedings under the Migrant Immovable Property Act,
1997 was a sham pretext under the garb of which what
actually was meant to be intended and attained was the reOWP No. 1208/2012
c/w
OWP No. 1212/2012
CPOWP No. 124/2015
CPOWP No. 227/2018
alignment and re-defining of the shares in terms of
succession to the estate relatable to Halder Joo and
Himmat.
83.
This position gets confirmed from the very notice
which was put to the petitioners from the end of the
respondent No. 2 – District Magistrate, Anantnag for seeking
their appearance before him in which notice it was being
recited that the respondents No. 3 & 4 have complained
about unauthorized execution of General Power of Attorney
by reference to khewat Nos. 35, 22, 14 & 6 with an intent to
transfer or alienate the same through attorney holders.
84.
This nature of dispute per se did not qualify to be
cognizable by the respondent No. 2 – District Magistrate,
Anantnag under the Migrant Immovable Property Act, 1997.
85.
In a judgment titled “Pushkar Nath Koul Vs State
of J&K and others” 2008 JKJ(3) 325, this Court has
already held that the property dispute amongst the cosharers who are Kashmiri migrants is not meant to be dealt
with under the Migrant Immovable Property Act, 1997.
86.
It is only by introduction of an application filed on
18.03.2011 by purported reference to section 5 of the
Migrant Immovable Property Act, 1997 by reference to
unauthorized occupants, namely, Gh. Mohammad Rather,
Nazir Ahmad Khan, Mohammad Ramzan Bhat & Ab.
Rehman Bhat that the respondents No. 3 & 4 were able to
OWP No. 1208/2012
c/w
OWP No. 1212/2012
CPOWP No. 124/2015
CPOWP No. 227/2018
engage the respondent No. 2 –District Magistrate, Anantnag
on the basis whereof impugned order came to be passed.
87.
The respondent No. 2– District Magistrate, Anantnag
in his said order dated 11.10.2011, later on re-dated
19.12.2011, does not identify as to how land comprised in
khewat No. 35 could become the matter of his statutory
attention and indulgence. In the entire order, the names of
the persons who were alleged to be unauthorized occupants
have missed mention by the respondent No. 2 – District
Magistrate, Anantnag and reason for the said miss is that
the respondent No. 2 – District Magistrate, Anantnag
perhaps was well aware of all along that from the end of the
petitioners as well as from the end of the respondents No. 3
& 4, their respective attorneys were at play in attending to
the respective properties with respect to which they had
come to be constituted as attorneys.
88.
Thus, serious legal lacuna which came to attend the
application of mind on the part of the respondent No. 2 –
District Magistrate, Anantnag in making his impugned order
dated 11.10.2011, later on re-dated 19.12.2011, is that
what was originally complained before him was left undealt
by him and by a blanket order the property left undefined in
the order was directed to be taken over in possession by
Tehsildar, Anantnag. In fact, Tehsildar, Anantnag came to
be directed to take possession of whole migrant property and
manage the property without disclosing as to what is the
OWP No. 1208/2012
c/w
OWP No. 1212/2012
CPOWP No. 124/2015
CPOWP No. 227/2018
identification and extent of whole migrant property which is
to be so taken in possession by Tehsildar, Anantnag.
89.
The passing of impugned order dated 11.10.2011,
later on re-dated 19.12.2011 by the respondent No. 2 –
District Magistrate, Anantnag came to take place while he
acknowledged that there is a civil suit going on between the
petitioners and the respondents No. 3 & 4 before the civil
court and, therefore, that should have been enough good
reason for the respondent No. 2 – District Magistrate,
Anantnag to deny any further indulgence in the matter in
any manner and to any extent.
90.
The very essence of the Migrant Immovable Property
Act, 1997 is resting upon the doctrine of “parens patriae”
under which the State becomes the parent like guardian of
the person and properties of the subject/s who cannot take
care of his/her/their person as well as his/her/their
property for the circumstances beyond their control.
91.
The Migrant Immovable Property Act, 1997 holds its
enactment to said position of Kashmiri Pandits who suffered
exodus from Kashmir Valley leaving their home and hearth
in order to ensure their bare physical survival with their
properties,
both
moveable
and
immoveable,
rendered
vulnerable to grab and grub for protecting which the
Migrant Immovable Property Act, 1997 came in to ensure
the safety and security of the abandoned properties of
OWP No. 1208/2012
c/w
OWP No. 1212/2012
CPOWP No. 124/2015
CPOWP No. 227/2018
Kashmiri migrants to be duly taken care of by none else
than the State itself.
92.
The Migrant Immovable Property Act, 1997 is not
meant to be exploited for settling property dispute/s
amongst the co-owners/co-sharers or successors-in-interest
of Kashmiri Migrants but which exactly and actually was
intended to be done by the respondents No. 3 & 4 through
the medium of an application so made to the respondent No.
2 – District Magistrate, Anantnag.
93.
The impugned order dated 11.10.2011, later on re-
dated 19.12.2011 of the respondent No. 2 – District
Magistrate, Anantnag being legally and factually faulty
ought to have been examined under appellate jurisdiction by
the respondent No.1 – Financial Commissioner (Revenue),
J&K who instead also acted mechanically by referring to
order dated 11.10.2011, later on re-dated 19.12.2011 of the
respondent No. 2 – District Magistrate, Anantnag as an
innocuous one leaving the petitioners constrained to come
up with the present writ petition.
94.
Thus, this Court is of the view that the entire course
of proceedings initiated before the respondent No. 2 –
District Magistrate, Anantnag at the instance of the
respondents No. 3 & 4 leading to the passing of the
impugned
order
dated
11.10.2011,
later
on
re-dated
19.12.2011 by the respondent No.2 – District Magistrate,
Anantnag along with the order dated 25.07.2012 of the
OWP No. 1208/2012
c/w
OWP No. 1212/2012
CPOWP No. 124/2015
CPOWP No. 227/2018
respondent No. 1 – Financial Commissioner (Revenue), J&K
were misconceived right from the inception which warrant to
be set aside and are, accordingly, set aside leaving it free for
the petitioners as well as the respondents No. 3 & 4, and
whomsoever other legal heirs/representatives may be to
settle their property dispute/s if any existing or subsisting
by resorting to proper forum of Civil/Revenue Court, be it
under the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 or the Jammu &
Kashmir Land Revenue Act, Svt., 1996.
95.
In view of the fact this Court has come to set aside
the order dated 11.10.2011, later on re-dated 19.12.2011 of
the respondent No.2 – District Magistrate, Anantnag along
with the order dated 25.07.2012 of the respondent No. 1 –
Financial Commissioner (Revenue), J&K, any property
whatsoever which came to be taken in possession by
Tehsildar, Anantnag relatable to the petitioners as well as
the respondents No. 3 & 4 be restored back to the position
as it was obtaining before passing of the order dated
11.10.2011, later on re-dated 19.12.2011 of the respondent
No.2 – District Magistrate, Anantnag along with the order
dated 25.07.2012 of the respondent No. 1 – Financial
Commissioner (Revenue), J&K.
96.
Nothing observed herein shall be referred to be any
observation on merits and demerits of respective claims of
the petitioners’ vis-à-vis the respondents No. 3 & 4 or viceversa in the matter of inheritance/succession for which the
OWP No. 1208/2012
c/w
OWP No. 1212/2012
CPOWP No. 124/2015
CPOWP No. 227/2018
adjudication of the Civil Court/ Revenue Court is going to
determine the actual status.
97.
Disposed of.
OWP No. 1212/2012
98.
The
adjudication
of
the
writ
petition
OWP
No.1208/2012 is to govern the adjudication of this writ
petition OWP No. 1212/2012 in view of the fact that the
petitioner herein-Shambu Nath Koul is claiming under
respondent No.9-Dalip Kumar who is one of the petitioners
in OWP No.1208/2012, and is seeking the quashment of
the adjudication made by the Financial Commissioner
(Revenue), J&K read with adjudication made by the District
Magistrate, Anantnag with respect to which this Court has
returned the final verdict in OWP No.1208/2012.
CPOWP No. 124/2015 & CPOWP No. 227/2018
99.
In the light of the disposal of the aforesaid two writ
petitions, these two contempt petitions shall also stand
disposed of accordingly.
(Rahul Bharti)
Judge
Jammu
27.01.2026
Muneesh
OWP No. 1208/2012
c/w
OWP No. 1212/2012
CPOWP No. 124/2015
CPOWP No. 227/2018
Whether the judgment is speaking :
Yes
Whether the judgment is reportable :
Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review