The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
15. Accordingly this petition is allowed and the impugned order dated 5:58:20 PM
4. 12.2023 passed by the learned Principal District Judge, Indore is hereby set aside by allowing the petitioner's petition under Section 24 of CPC and it is directed that the Civil Suit Case No. RCS 71-A/2003 (Erachshaw & others Vs. Union of India) is transferred from the Court of 1st Civil Judge, Senior Division, Dr. Ambedkar Nagar (Mhow), District Indore to 1st Civil Judge, Senior Division, Indore for proper adjudication in accordance with law.
16. With the aforesaid direction, this miscellaneous petition is disposed of.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE ANIL VERMA
ON THE 24th OF JANUARY, 2024
MISC. PETITION No. 7396 of 2023
BETWEEN:SHAILENDRA SINHAL S/O MOHANLAL SINHAL, AGED
ABOUT 60 YEARS, OCCUPATION: BUSINESS R/O 208
SANGHI STREET, MHOW, DISTT. INDORE (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SENIOR ADVOCATE SHRI A.S. GARG WITH SHRI MOHAN SHARMA ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
UNION OF INDIA THROUGH MILITARY STATE
OFFICE, IN FRONT OF GURUDWARA, MHOW
CIRCLE, MHOW DISTT. INDORE (MADHYA
PRADESH)
2.
STATE
OF M.P.
THROUGH
COLLECTOR
COLLECTORATE OFFICE, MOTI TABELA, INDORE
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(SHRI HIMANSHU JOSHI - DEPUTY SOLICITOR GENERAL FOR
RESPONDENT NO.1)
(SHRI AMIT RAWAL - GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT
NO.2/STATE)
This petition coming on for admission this day, th e court passed the
following:
With the consent of both the parties, matter is heard finally.
ORDER
1. Petitioner has preferred this miscellaneous petition under Article 227 of
the Constitution of India being aggrieved by the impugned order dated
4.12.2023 passed in MJC No.814/2023 by the Principal District Judge, Indore,
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-Jan-24
5:58:20 PM
whereby the petitioner's application under Section 24 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908 (in short "CPC") has been dismissed.
2. Brief facts of the case are that the petitioner/plaintiff has filed a civil
suit for seeking decree for declaration of title and permanent injunction in
respect of the suit property - Bungalow No.74, Mall Road, Mhow, District
Indore against the respondents/defendants, which is still pending. Petitioner
preferred an application under Section 24 of the CPC before the Principal
District Judge, Indore for transfer of the case from the Court of Shri Ajay Singh
Yadav, 1st Civil Judge, Senior Division, Dr. Ambedkar Nagar, Indore to any
other competent court situated at District Court, Indore. After hearing both the
parties, the court below has dismissed the petitioner's application by observing
that the allegations of impartiality and fairness of the judge is not made out and
on the basis of mere presumption and apprehension, no case is made out for
transfer to another court. Being aggrieved by the said order, petitioner has
preferred this petition.
3. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the impugned order
passed by the learned Principal District Judge is completely illegal, perverse and
improper and against the settled principle of law. He has failed to consider that
the concerned Presiding Judge has already adjudicated exactly the same issues
negatively, which will certainly affect the result of the present litigation adversely
and the petitioner may not get justice from the concerned court. When the same
issues has already been decided and an opinion has been formed by the
Presiding Officer, the trial court cannot do justice with the present case. Trial
court has rejected the petitioner's application under Order 11 Rule 12 of CPC,
which has been set aside by the Hon'ble High Court. Defendants are trying to
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-Jan-24
5:58:20 PM
make every effort to influence the trial at Mhow. Hence, he prays that the
aforesaid case which is pending before the 1st Civil Judge, Senior Division, Dr.
Ambedkar Nagar, Indore be transferred to any other competent civil court
situated at District Court, Indore.
4. Learned counsel for the respondent No.1 opposed the prayer by
submitting that the impugned order passed by the learned Principal District
Judge, Indore is just and proper and not deserve for any interference. So many
cases against the Union of India are pending before the various courts at Dr.
Ambedkar Nagar, Mhow, which cannot be transferred to another court only on
the basis of mere presumption and apprehension.
5. Learned counsel for the respondent No.2/State submits that the
respondent No.2 is a formal party and the court may pass any appropriate order
as it deem fit.
6. Learned counsel for both the parties heard at length and perused the
record.
7. Section 24 of the CPC provides as under:"24. General power of transfer and withdrawal—(1) On the
application of any of the parties and after notice to the parties and after hearing
such of them as desired to be heard, or of its own motion, without such notice,
the High Court or the District Court may, at any stage—
(a) transfer any suit, appeal or other proceeding pending before it for trial
or disposal to any Court subordinate to it and competent to try or dispose of
the same, or
(b) withdraw any suit, appeal or other proceeding pending in any Court
subordinate to it, and—
(i) try or dispose of the same; or
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-Jan-24
5:58:20 PM
(ii) transfer the same for trial or disposal to any Court subordinate to it
and competent to try or dispose of the same; or
(iii) re-transfer the same for trial or disposal to the Court from which it
was withdrawn.
(2) Where any suit or proceeding has been transferred or withdrawn
under sub-section (1), the Court which [is thereafter to try or dispose of such
suit or proceeding] may, subject to any special directions in the case of an
order of transfer, either retry it or proceed from the point at which it was
transferred or withdrawn.
[(3) For the purposes of this section,—
(a) Courts of Additional and Assistant Judges shall be deemed to be
subordinate to the District Court;
(b) “proceeding” includes a proceeding for the execution of a decree or
order.]
(4) The Court trying any suit transferred or withdrawn under this section
from a Court of Small Causes shall, for the purposes of such suit, be deemed
to be a Court of Small Causes.
[(5) A suit or proceeding may be transferred under this section from a
Court which has no jurisdiction to try it.]"
8. It is trite law that Section 24 of CPC empowers the High Court or
District Court to transfer inter alia any suit, appeal or any other proceedings
pending before it or in any court subordinate to it, to any other court for trial
and disposal. The said provision confers comprehensive power on the court to
transfer suits, appeals or other proceedings at any stage either on an application
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-Jan-24
5:58:20 PM
by any party or suo motu. Although the discretionary power of transfer of
cases cannot be imprisoned within a straitjacket of any cast-iron formula
unanimously applicable to all situations, it cannot be gainsaid that the power to
transfer a case must be exercised with due care, caution and circumspection. It
is the basic principle of law that the justice must not only be done but must also
be seen to be done.
9. The Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Maneka Sanjoy Gandhi Vs.
Rani Jethmalani reported in (1979) 4 SCC 167 has held that:"Assurance of a fair trial is the first imperative of the dispensation of
justice and the central criterion for the court to consider when a motion for
transfer is made is not the hypersensitivity or relative convenience of a
party or easy availability of legal services or like mini grievances.
Something more substantial, more compelling, more imperiling, from the
point of view of public justice and its attendant environment, is
necessitious if the Court is to exercise its power of transfer. This is the
cardinal principle although the circumstances may be myriad and vary
from case to case."
10. The purpose of section 24 of CPC is merely to confer on the court a
discretionary power. A court acting under Section 24 of CPC may or may not
in its judicial discretion transfer a particular case. Section 24 does not prescribe
any ground for ordering the transfer of a case. Transfer has to be made in the
interest of justice.
11. In the instant case main objection of the learned senior counsel for the
petitioner is that the judge of the concerned trial court has expressed his opinion
on the point of law or fact previously in a case which will adversely affect the
result of the present litigation and he also expressed apprehension that the
petitioner will not get justice from the concerned court because the Presiding
Officer in flagrant violation of the order passed by this Court in MA
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-Jan-24
5:58:20 PM
No.1458/2009 is conducting the trial in utmost haste and is in process to
dismiss the civil suit.
12. In is noteworthy that the trial Court has dismissed the petitioner's
application under Order 11 Rule 12 of CPC and this Court vide order dated
18.1.2024 passed in MP No.7426/2023 has set aside the said order and trial
Court is directed to issue direction to the respondents to produce the
concerned document before the Court or to make discovery on oath regarding
the aforesaid document.
13. In the aforesaid circumstances, petitioner has made several allegation
against in respect of impartiality and fairness of the Presiding Officer.
Therefore, for the purpose of assurance of a fair trial for dispensation of justice,
there is no harm to transfer the particular case to another court and it would not
cause any prejudice to the petitioner or any other party. Reading sections 24
and 25 of the Code together and keeping in view various judicial
pronouncements, certain propositions as to what may constitute a ground for
transfer have been laid down, they are issues raised by the parties; reasonable
apprehension in the mind of the litigant that he might not get justice in the court
in which the suit is pending; important questions of law involved, therefore, the
interest of justice would be served from transfer of case to any other court.
Learned Principal District Judge, Indore has not considered the grounds raised
by the petitioner in true perspective.
14. In view of the aforesaid, this Court feels that the petitioner/plaintiff is
not likely to have a fair trial in the court from which he seeks to transfer a case.
Therefore, in the above circumstances, I deem it proper to transfer this case to
any other competent court.
15. Accordingly this petition is allowed and the impugned order dated
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-Jan-24
5:58:20 PM
4.12.2023 passed by the learned Principal District Judge, Indore is hereby set
aside by allowing the petitioner's petition under Section 24 of CPC and it is
directed that the Civil Suit Case No. RCS 71-A/2003 (Erachshaw & others Vs.
Union of India) is transferred from the Court of 1st Civil Judge, Senior
Division, Dr. Ambedkar Nagar (Mhow), District Indore to 1st Civil Judge,
Senior Division, Indore for proper adjudication in accordance with law.
16. With the aforesaid direction, this miscellaneous petition is disposed
of.
17. Let a copy of this order be sent to both the concerning courts below
and the learned Principal District Judge, Indore for necessary action.
C.C. as per rules.
(ANIL VERMA)
JUDGE
trilok
Signed by: TRILOK SINGH
SAVNER
Signing time: 25-Jan-24
5:58:20 PM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review