Judgments
LegalFirms.in Judgments · legalfirms.in/judgments/shailendra-chowdhary-vs-smt-jolly-choudhary-20260313/ · Printed 20 Nov 2026
Civil

Shailendra Chowdhary vs Smt. Jolly Choudhary

Add to a compilation

Keep judgments in folders, mark the paragraphs you rely on, and print a compilation with an index. It comes with the Research and Advocate Pro judgment plans and with a campus licence. Sign in · See the plans

Court
Patna High Court
Date
13 March 2026
Case No.
C.R. 193/2024
Result
Dismissed
Bench
Ramesh Chand Malviya
Cite this judgment
Citation
Link for your website or blog
Cite the court's own record or the law report in court filings.

The court's order

The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.

21. Accordingly, the present Civil Revision No. 193 of 2024 stands dismissed.

22. There shall be no order as to costs.

Filed under

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Order VII Rule 11, Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 115, Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Rejection of plaint (Order VII Rule 11 CPC)

The sections, explained

The law this judgment cites

Opens the section on Law Maker (lawmaker.in), our sister site for law students.

Full Judgment Text

Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs, CC BY 4.0). The court's own copy is the authoritative text.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA CIVIL REVISION No.193 of 2024 In CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS JURISDICTION No.740 of 2024 ====================================================== Shailendra Chowdhary, male, aged about-49 years, S/o Late Dr. Kiran Shankar Pd. Chowdhary, Resident of Mohalla - Gopaljee Lane Saraiyaganj, P.O. and P.S. - Town, District - Muzaffarpur. 1. 2. ... ... Petitioner/s Versus Smt. Jolly Choudhary W/o Sri Ravi Ranjan Jaiswal, D/o Late Dr. Kiran Shankar Pd. Choudhary, Resident of Mohalla - Ghora Sahan, P.O. and P.S. Ghora Sahan, District - East Champaran, presently residing at M/s Laziz Restraunt, Yogendra Mukherjee Road, Saraiyaganj, P.O. and P.S. - Town, District- Muzaffarpur. Smt. Rashmi Jaiswal W/o Sanjay Jaiswal, D/o Late Dr. Kiran Shankar Pd. Choudhary, Resident of Mohalla - Henari, Bazar, in town of Motihari, P.O. and P.S. - Motihari, District- East Champaran. ... ... Respondent/s ====================================================== Appearance : For the Petitioner/s : For the Respondent/s : Mr. Ramesh Kumar Agrawal, Advocate Mr. R.K.Agrawal, Advocate Mr. Sanjeev Kumar, Advocate Mr. Shashi Shekhar Dwidedi, Sr. Advocate Mr. Manish Jha, Advocate Mr. Pratyush Pratap Singh, Advocate Mr. Ashutosh Kr. Pandey, Advocate ====================================================== CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE RAMESH CHAND MALVIYA CAV ORDER 13-03-2026 Heard the learned counsel for the petitioner as well as learned counsel for the respondents. 2. This Civil Revision application has been filed under Section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter referred to as ‘CPC’) against the order dated 04.04.2024 passed in the partition Suit No. 356 of 2013, by the learned Court of Sub-Judge II, Muzaffarpur (hereinafter referred to as ‘Trial Court’) whereby and whereunder the learned Trial Court has Patna High Court C.R. No.193 of 2024(6) dt.13-03-2026 2/19 dismissed the application dated 13.01.2017 filed by the petitioner/defendant no.2 for dismissal of the partition suit under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC, on the ground of nonmaintainability as it involve mixed question of law and fact. 3. The facts of the case, in brief, are that the Opposite Party No.1 (plaintiff) instituted Partition Suit No. 356 of 2013 seeking a preliminary decree for partition with respect to the properties described in Schedule I and Schedule II of the plaint claiming 1/4th share therein. In the said suit, the plaintiff also prayed for a declaration that the compromise petition filed in earlier Partition Suit No. 435 of 2002 and Partition Suit No. 273 of 2006, which culminated in an award before the Lok Adalat, was fraudulent, illegal and obtained by playing fraud upon the plaintiff. The petitioner (defendant no.2) and other defendants appeared in the suit and filed their joint written statement raising several objections with respect to the maintainability of the suit, including that the suit was barred by the principles of res judicata, barred under Order XXIII Rule 3A of the CPC and that the suit had been undervalued and requisite ad-valorem court fee had not been paid. Thereafter, the petitioner (defendant no.2) filed an application dated 13.01.2017 before the learned Trial Court praying for dismissal of the suit or rejection of the plaint, Patna High Court C.R. No.193 of 2024(6) dt.13-03-2026 3/19 inter alia, on the grounds that the suit properties were the exclusive properties of the petitioner (defendant no.2) and not liable for partition, the suit was barred by res judicata in view of the earlier compromise before the Lok Adalat, the suit was barred under Order XXIII Rule 3A of the CPC, and that the plaintiff had failed to pay proper ad-valorem court fee despite seeking declaration and consequential relief. The said application was contested by the plaintiff and was ultimately disposed of by the learned Trial Court vide order dated 04.04.2024 holding that the question of maintainability of the suit involves mixed questions of law and fact and therefore cannot be decided as a preliminary issue. 4. It is the case of the petitioner/defendants that the properties sought to be partitioned were the exclusive properties of petitioner (defendant no.2) and not liable for partition. They denied the allegations of fraud and breach of trust, stating that Opposite Party No.1 was educated and mature and that the Lok Adalat compromise was executed with free consent of all parties. It was also stated that Partition Suit No. 559 of 2009 filed earlier by Opposite Party No.1 with regard to the same property was dismissed on 30.07.2013 as it is barred by res judicata in view of the compromise in Partition Suit No. 273 of Patna High Court C.R. No.193 of 2024(6) dt.13-03-2026 4/19 2006. The claim of the plaintiff that he came to know about the compromise only in 2011 was denied, asserting that she had been aware of the proceedings and had obtained a certified copy of the compromise deed. It was further stated that one property in Schedule I was taken on lease by the plaintiff’s husband from petitioner (defendant no.2). 5. The petitioner further sought declarations that the Lok Adalat award cannot be challenged in the partition suit by seeking declaration of nullity on the ground of fraud. It is well established fact that the issues of maintainability including res judicata, court fee and bar under Order XXIII Rule 3A of the CPC are pure questions of law and liable to be decided as preliminary issues. Consequently, dismissal of Partition Suit No. 356 of 2013 is barred and not maintainable as prayed, along with any other appropriate relief. The substantial questions which has arisen includes the maintainability of the suit, liability for ad-valorem court fee, applicability of res judicata and statutory bar, whether such issues must be decided as preliminary issues, and the petitioner’s entitlement to relief. 6. Considering the materials available on record and in view of the facts and circumstances of the case, learned Trial Court rejected the application dated 13.01.2017 as not Patna High Court C.R. No.193 of 2024(6) dt.13-03-2026 5/19 maintainable vide impugned order dated 04.04.2024 holding that Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC is applicable only in a case where there is involvement of pure question of law but in this case it is mixed with question relating to the fact and it needs trial on that question. The Court determined that the issue of maintainability in this specific case is a mixed question of law and facts. As the issue involves complex disputes over property acquisition and allegations of fraud, they cannot be decided as a preliminary issue and require the appreciation of evidence. The Court ruled that the issue of maintainability will be decided alongwith all other issues which need to be framed later in the suit. 7. Aggrieved by the impugned order dated 04.04.2024 passed in the partition Suit No. 356 of 2013, by the learned Court of Sub-Judge II, Muzaffarpur, whereby the application dated 13.01.2017 under Order VII Rule 11 of CPC was dismissed, the petitioner has preferred this Civil Revision application before this Court, assailing the legality, propriety and correctness of the said order on the ground that the learned Trial Court has failed to properly appreciate the mandatory provisions of law and has exercised jurisdiction with material irregularity. Patna High Court C.R. No.193 of 2024(6) dt.13-03-2026 6/19 8. Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the learned Trial Court has committed a manifest error of law in rejecting the petitioner’s application dated 13.01.2017 by mechanically observing that the issue of maintainability of the suit is a mixed question of law and fact. It is submitted that the petitioner had specifically raised several legal objections going to the root of the maintainability of the suit, such as bar of the suit by the principle of res judicata, bar under Order XXIII Rule 3A of the CPC, and the issue of improper valuation and nonpayment of requisite ad-valorem court fee. Learned counsel further submitted that each of these objections required independent consideration by the learned Trial Court and could not have been deferred to be decided along with the final adjudication of the suit. 8.i. Learned counsel for petitioner further submitted that the present suit itself is barred by the principle of res judicata in view of the earlier compromise entered into between the parties before the Lok Adalat in the previous partition proceedings. It is also submitted that once the dispute between the parties had already been settled by way of a compromise resulting in an award before the Lok Adalat, the same attains the status of a decree of a Civil Court and cannot be re-agitated in a Patna High Court C.R. No.193 of 2024(6) dt.13-03-2026 7/19 subsequent suit. Learned counsel for the petitioner further submitted that the Opposite Party No.1 (plaintiff) had earlier also instituted a partition suit in respect of the same properties which was dismissed by the competent court on the ground of res judicata, and therefore, the present suit is clearly barred by law. 8.ii. Learned counsel for the petitioner further submitted that the Opposite Party No.1 (plaintiff) has sought a declaration that the compromise arrived at the earlier partition suits was fraudulent and illegal and has also prayed for consequential relief of partition. It is submitted that in such circumstances, the plaintiff was legally bound to pay advalorem court fee on the value of the relief claimed. He further submitted the suit has been deliberately undervalued and the requisite court fee has not been paid despite the objection having been raised by the defendants in the written statement as well as in the application dated 13.01.2017. It is submitted that under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC, the court is duty-bound to examine the question of valuation and sufficiency of court fee at the threshold on the basis of the averments made in the plaint. 8.iii. Lastly, learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that in view of the clear statutory bar contained in Patna High Court C.R. No.193 of 2024(6) dt.13-03-2026 8/19 Order XXIII Rule 3A of the CPC, no separate suit lies for setting aside a compromise decree on the ground that the compromise was not lawful. It is submitted that the plaintiff has sought to indirectly challenge the Lok Adalat award, by way of the present partition suit which is impermissible in law. Learned counsel therefore submitted that the learned Trial Court ought to have decided these issues as preliminary issues, as they are purely based on questions of law going to the root of the jurisdiction and maintainability of the suit. On these grounds, learned counsel prayed that the impugned order dated 04.04.2024 be set aside. 9. Per contra, learned counsel appearing on behalf of Opposite Party No.1 has supported the impugned order and submitted that the present revision petition is wholly misconceived and liable to be dismissed. It is submitted that Opposite Party No.1 instituted Partition Suit No. 356 of 2013 seeking a preliminary decree for partition of the properties described in Schedule I and II of the plaint to the extent of her 1/4th share and also for declaration that the compromise petitions filed in Partition Suit No. 435 of 2002 and Partition Suit No. 273 of 2006 were fraudulent and obtained by playing fraud upon her. Learned counsel submitted that the properties in question Patna High Court C.R. No.193 of 2024(6) dt.13-03-2026 9/19 originally belonged to Subhadra Devi, who had acquired right, title and possession over Schedule II property after purchasing the same in the year 1987 from Ganga Prasad Choudhary. It is also submitted that after her death on 15.12.2006, the property devolved upon her husband namely Dr. Kiran Shankar Prasad Choudhary, her son namely Shailendra Choudhary (petitioner) and her two daughters, namely Jolly Chowdhry (Opposite Party No.1 herein) and Rashmi Jaiswal, who succeeded to the said property in equal shares. 9.i. Learned counsel for the Opposite Party No.1 further submitted that the petitioner, in connivance with his father, fraudulently obtained compromise decrees in earlier partition proceedings by misusing blank papers bearing the signatures of the answering Opposite Party No.1 and her sister, which were taken by their father on the pretext of being required for litigation with tenants. He submitted that the answering Opposite Party No.1 had complete faith in her father and used to sign documents placed before her without knowledge of their contents. It is further submitted that taking advantage of such trust, the petitioner and his father utilized those signed papers as compromise petitions and affidavits in Partition Suit No. 435 of 2002 and Partition Suit No. 273 of 2006. It is submitted that the Patna High Court C.R. No.193 of 2024(6) dt.13-03-2026 10/19 answering Opposite Party No.1 came to know about the said fraud only on 15.06.2011, upon receiving a communication from the Assistant Electrical Engineer, Muzaffarpur, thereafter she obtained certified copies of the pleadings and orders passed in the said proceedings. 9.ii. Learned counsel for the Opposite parties has also drawn attention of this Court to the peculiar circumstances surrounding the award allegedly passed by the mobile Lok Adalat in Partition Suit No. 273 of 2006. It is submitted that although the compromise petition was filed on 02.11.2006 and affidavits in support thereof were filed on 28.12.2006, the award is shown to have been prepared on 15.12.2006, i.e., the very date on which the mother of the parties, Subhadra Devi, expired. It is further submitted that the said award was thus passed against a dead person and therefore,it is null and void in the eyes of law. In this regard, learned counsel has placed reliance upon the decisions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Rajendra Prasad & Anr. v. Khirodhar Mahto & Ors., reported in 1994 Supp (3) SCC 314; Amba Bai & Ors. v. Gopal & Ors., reported in (2001) 5 SCC 570; and Vikram Bhalchandra Ghongade v. State of Maharashtra & Ors., reported in 2025 SCC OnLine SC 2360, wherein it has been held that any decree or order Patna High Court C.R. No.193 of 2024(6) dt.13-03-2026 11/19 passed against a dead person is a nullity and non est in the eye of law. 9.iii. Learned counsel for the Opposite Party No.1 submitted that the petitioner has been attempting to change the nature of the suit property by alienating substantial portions thereof during the pendency of the dispute and therefore appropriate protection is necessary to safeguard the rights of the parties. Learned counsel has also placed reliance upon the decision of a Division Bench of this Court in Meena Choudhary & Anr. v. Dr. Dilip Choudhary & Ors. (C.W.J.C. No. 14426 of 2009) vide order dated 06.11.2009, wherein it has been held that where an award of Lok Adalat is alleged to have been obtained by fraud, the aggrieved party is not remediless and may approach the competent Civil Court for appropriate relief. On these premises, it is submitted that the Partition Suit No. 356 of 2013 filed by Opposite Party No.1 is perfectly maintainable and the order dated 04.04.2024 passed by the learned Trial Court does not suffer from any illegality warranting interference in revisional jurisdiction, and therefore the present revision petition deserves to be dismissed. 10. Having considered the rival submissions advanced on behalf of the parties and have perused the materials available Patna High Court C.R. No.193 of 2024(6) dt.13-03-2026 12/19 on record, including the impugned order and the order sheets of the learned Trial Court, the point that arises for determination in the present revision is “whether the learned Trial Court erred in law in rejecting the application under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC seeking rejection of the plaint?” 11. Before adverting to the rival contentions on merits, it would be apposite to notice the scope of interference in exercise of revisional jurisdiction under Section 115 of the CPC. This Court does not sit as a court of appeal over the order of the subordinate Court; interference is warranted only where the learned Trial Court has exercised a jurisdiction not vested in it by law, or has failed to exercise jurisdiction so vested, or has acted in the exercise of its jurisdiction illegally or with material irregularity. Thus, unless the finding recorded by the learned Trial Court is shown to suffer from a patent error of law or jurisdictional infirmity, this Court would be slow to substitute its own view merely because another view is possible. 12. The contours of revisional jurisdiction under Section 115 of the CPC have been authoritatively delineated by the Hon’ble Apex Court in Shiv Shakti Coop. Housing Society v. Swaraj Developers and Ors., reported in (2003) 6 SCC 659, wherein, it has been held that the revisional power is Patna High Court C.R. No.193 of 2024(6) dt.13-03-2026 13/19 supervisory in nature and cannot be equated with appellate jurisdiction; interference is permissible only where the subordinate Court has acted without jurisdiction or with material irregularity in the exercise of such jurisdiction. Similarly, in Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd. v. Dilbahar Singh, reported in (2014) 9 SCC 78, the Hon’ble Apex Court reiterated that re-appreciation of facts or substitution of a possible view is impermissible in revision unless the impugned order suffers from patent illegality or perversity. 13. At this stage, it is apposite to reproduce the principles governing rejection of a plaint under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC which have been explained in the case of Dahiben v. Arvindbhai Kalyanji Bhanusali (Gajra) and Ors., reported in (2020) 7 SCC 366 wherein the Hon’ble Apex Court has settled the principles and made the following observations: “12.6. At this stage, the pleas taken by the defendant in the written statement and application for rejection of the plaint on the merits, would be irrelevant, and cannot be adverted to, or taken into consideration. “12.7. The test for exercising the power under Order VII Rule 11 is that if the averments made in the plaint are taken entirety, in conjunction with the documents relied upon, would the same result in a decree being passed”. “23.2. The remedy under Order 7 Rule 11 is an independent and special remedy, wherein the court is empowered to Patna High Court C.R. No.193 of 2024(6) dt.13-03-2026 14/19 summarily dismiss a suit at the threshold, without proceeding to record evidence, and conducting a trial, on the basis of the evidence adduced, if it is satisfied that the action should be terminated on any of the grounds contained in this provision. 23.5. The power conferred on the court to terminate a civil action is, however, a drastic one, and the conditions enumerated in Order 7 Rule 11 are required to be strictly adhered to. 23.9. In exercise of power under this provision, the court would determine if the assertions made in the plaint are contrary to statutory law, or judicial dicta, for deciding whether a case for rejecting the plaint at the threshold is made out. 23.10. At this stage, the pleas taken by the defendant in the written statement and application for rejection of the plaint on the merits, would be irrelevant, and cannot be adverted to, or taken into consideration. [Sopan Sukhdeo Sable v. Charity Commr., (2004) 3 SCC 137] 23.12. In Hardesh Ores (P) Ltd. v. Hede & Co. [Hardesh Ores (P) Ltd. v. Hede & Co., (2007) 5 SCC 614] the Court further held that it is not permissible to cull out a sentence or a passage, and to read it in isolation. It is the substance, and not merely the form, which has to be looked into. The plaint has to be construed as it stands, without addition or subtraction of words. If the allegations in the plaint prima facie show a cause of action, the court cannot embark upon an enquiry whether the allegations are true in fact. D. Ramachandran v. R.V. Janakiraman [D. Ramachandran v. R.V. Janakiraman, (1999) 3 SCC 267; See also Vijay Pratap Singh v. Dukh Haran Nath Singh, AIR 1962 SC 941]. 23.13. If on a meaningful reading of the plaint, it is found that the suit is manifestly Patna High Court C.R. No.193 of 2024(6) dt.13-03-2026 15/19 vexatious and without any merit, and does not disclose a right to sue, the court would be justified in exercising the power under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC. 23.15. The provision of Order 7 Rule 11 is mandatory in nature. It states that the plaint “shall” be rejected if any of the grounds specified in clauses (a) to (e) are made out. If the court finds that the plaint does not disclose a cause of action, or that the suit is barred by any law, the court has no option, but to reject the plaint.” 14. Upon meticulous examination of the facts and circumstances of the case, this Court is of the view that the learned Trial Court has rightly observed, the objections raised by the petitioner with regard to the maintainability of the suit, particularly on the grounds of res judicata, bar under Order XXIII Rule 3A of the CPC and valuation of the suit, involve questions which cannot be decided merely on the basis of pleadings and require proper adjudication upon appreciation of evidences during the stage of the trial. 15. The Hon’ble Apex Court in Srihari Hanumandas Totala v. Hemant Vithal Kamat & Ors., reported in (2021) 9 SCC 99 held that the adjudication of the plea of res judicata is beyond the scope of Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC, relevant para is as under: “25.4. Since an adjudication of the plea of res judicata requires consideration of the Patna High Court C.R. No.193 of 2024(6) dt.13-03-2026 16/19 pleadings, issues and decision in the “previous suit”, such a plea will be beyond the scope of Order 7 Rule 11(d), where only the statements in the plaint will have to be perused.” 16. Moreover, the issue of res judicata cannot be decided merely on assertions made in the application seeking rejection of plaint. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Keshav Sood v. Kirti Pradeep Sood, reported in 2023 SCC OnLine SC 2459 took a strong view against the plea of res judicata being raised in applications seeking rejection of plaint and held as under: “5. As far as scope of Rule 11 of Order VII of CPC is concerned, the law is well settled. The Court can look into only the averments made in the plaint and at the highest, documents produced along with the plaint. The defence of a defendant and documents relied upon by him cannot be looked into while deciding such application. 6. Hence, in our view, the issue of res judicata could not have been decided on an application under Rule 11 of Order VII of CPC. The reason is that the adjudication on the issue involves consideration of the pleadings in the earlier suit, the judgment of the Trial Court and the judgment of the Appellate Courts. Therefore, we make it clear that neither the learned Single Judge nor the Division Bench at this stage could have decided the plea of res judicata raised by the appellant on merits.” 17. It is well settled law that while considering the prayer for rejection of plaint under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC, the Court is required to confine itself to the averments Patna High Court C.R. No.193 of 2024(6) dt.13-03-2026 17/19 made in the plaint and the documents relied upon therein. The defence taken by the defendants in the written statement or the materials relied upon by them, cannot be looked into at that stage. In the present case, the plea of res judicata raised by the petitioner necessarily requires examination of the earlier proceedings, the nature and scope of the compromise before the Lok Adalat, and the surrounding circumstances in which the previous proceedings were concluded, which are matters that cannot be determined without leading evidence. 18. This Court is of the opinion that the question whether the present partition suit is barred by the principles of res judicata or by Order XXIII Rule 3A of the CPC cannot be conclusively determined at the threshold merely on the basis of pleadings. Such issues involve a mixed question of law and fact and require consideration of the earlier proceedings and the evidence that may be brought on record by the parties. Therefore, the learned Trial Court was justified in holding that the issue of maintainability should be decided along with other issues after appreciation of evidence. 19. Upon overall consideration of the pleadings of the parties and the grounds urged in the application under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC, this Court finds that the controversy raised Patna High Court C.R. No.193 of 2024(6) dt.13-03-2026 18/19 by the petitioner involves disputed questions relating to existence of prior partition, identity of subject matter in the earlier Title Suit No. 06 of 1999, alleged absence of cause of action, and non-joinder of necessary parties in a suit for partition. In view thereof, determination of these issues would necessarily require examination of pleadings of both suits, scrutiny of documents, and appreciation of evidence with respect to unity of title and possession, nature of the property, and entitlement of the parties. Such matters cannot be conclusively adjudicated merely on a reading of the plaint and undoubtedly constitute mixed questions of law and fact. The scope of Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC being limited and summary in nature, the learned Trial Court has rightly refrained from embarking upon a detailed inquiry at the threshold stage. 20. As settled above that in revisional jurisdiction, interference is warranted only when the Subordinate Court has exercised the jurisdiction not vested in it, failed to exercise jurisdiction so vested, or acted with material irregularity. The impugned order, though concise, reflects consideration of the relevant aspects and does not suffer from jurisdictional error or perversity so as to warrant interference under Section 115 of the CPC. Since the plaint, on its face, discloses triable issues Patna High Court C.R. No.193 of 2024(6) dt.13-03-2026 19/19 requiring adjudication after full-fledged trial and evaluation of evidences, this Court is of the considered view that no such ground is made out to invoke the revisional power of this Court. 21. Accordingly, the present Civil Revision No. 193 of 2024 stands dismissed. 22. There shall be no order as to costs. 23. Let the copy of this order be transmitted to the Court concerned forthwith for its compliance. (Ramesh Chand Malviya, J) Harshita/U

This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.

Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong? Request a review

All Patna HC judgments →

Civil Litigation advocates near the Patna High Court

Dealing with a similar matter? Send a free enquiry to advocates who handle it. Fees are agreed with the advocate directly.

All Civil Litigation advocates in India