Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:21062
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE C.PRATHEEP KUMAR
FRIDAY, THE 28TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025/9TH PHALGUNA, 1946
MACA NO. 845 OF 2016
AGAINST
THE
ORDER/JUDGMENT
DATED
30.10.2015
IN
OPMV
NO.207 OF 2012 OF MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL, PERUMBAVOOR.
APPELLANT:
SHAIJU,
S/O.GEORGE, ARACKAPARAMBIL HOUSE,
CHRANDRAPURA, MANJAPPRA P.O., KALADY,
PIN - 683 581.
BY ADVS.
P.M.ARUN DAS
josephgopuran
RESPONDENTS:
JOYMON,
S/O.LOLAPPAN, MADAVANA HOUSE,
WEST COLONY, MALAYATTOOR P.O.,
KALADY - 683 587.
CHOLAMANDALAM MS GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY LTD.
2ND FLOOR, DARE HOUSE, NSC BOSE ROAD,
CHENNAI - 600 001.
BY ADVS.
SRI.P.JACOB MATHEW
SRI.MATHEWS JACOB SR.
M.A.C.A.No.845 of 2016
2025:KER:21062
-2THIS
MOTOR
ACCIDENT
CLAIMS
APPEAL
HAVING
BEEN
FINALLY
HEARD ON 28.02.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE
FOLLOWING:
M.A.C.A.No.845 of 2016
2025:KER:21062
-3-
JUDGMENT
Dated this the 28th day of February, 2025
The petitioner in O.P.(M.V.) No.207/2012 on the file of the
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Perumbavoor is the appellant
herein. (For the purpose of convenience, the parties are hereafter
referred to as per their rank before the Tribunal).
2.
The petitioner filed the above O.P. under Section
166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, claiming compensation for the
injuries sustained in a motor vehicle accident that occurred on
01.12.2011 According to the petitioner, on 01.12.2011 at about 6.15
a.m., while he was riding a motorcycle along the AngamalyManjappra road a Swaraj Mazda Tipper Lorry bearing Reg. No. KL5/L-1449 driven by the 2nd respondent in a rash and negligent
manner hit on the motorcycle.
As a result of the accident, the
petitioner sustained serious injuries.
3.
The 1st respondent is the owner, the 2nd respondent
is the driver and 3rd respondent is the insurer of the offending
vehicle. According to the petitioner, the accident occurred due to
the negligence of the driver of the offending vehicle. The quantum of
compensation claimed in the O.P. is Rs.41,85,000/- limited to
Rs.15,00,000/-.
M.A.C.A.No.845 of 2016
2025:KER:21062
-4-
4.
The insurance company filed a written statement,
admitting the accident as well as policy, but disputing the
negligence on the part of the driver of the offending vehicle.
5.
The evidence in the case consists of the oral
testimony of PW1 and documentary evidence Exts.A1 to A18 series,
Ext.C1 and C2. No evidence was adduced by the respondents.
6.
After evaluating the evidence on record, the
Tribunal found negligence on the part of the driver of the offending
vehicle, awarded a total compensation of Rs.5,30,216/- and directed
the insurer to pay the same.
7.
Aggrieved
by
the
quantum
of
compensation
awarded by the Tribunal, the petitioner preferred this appeal.
8.
Now the point that arises for consideration is the
following:
Whether the quantum of compensation awarded
by the Tribunal is just and reasonable?
9.
Heard
Sri.A.N.Santhosh,
the
learned
Counsel
appearing for the petitioner/appellant, and Sri.P.Jacob Mathew, the
learned Standing Counsel for the 3rd respondent.
10.
The Point: In this case the accident as well as valid
insurance policy of the offending vehicle are admitted. One of the
M.A.C.A.No.845 of 2016
2025:KER:21062
-5-
contentions raised by the learned counsel for the petitioner is
regarding the income of the petitioner as fixed by the Tribunal.
According to him, the petitioner was working as welder, earning
Rs.15,000/- per month, but the Tribunal fixed his monthly income at
Rs.7,000/-.
11.
As per the dictum laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the decision in Ramachandrappa v. Manager,
Royal Sundaram Alliance Insurance Co. Ltd. [2011 (13) SCC
236], the notional income of a coolie, in the year 2011 will come to
Rs.8,000/-. The petitioner has produced Ext.A18 salary certificate
issued by PW1. According to PW1, he had contract work in Kochin
Shipyard and that the petitioner was working under him and
Ext.A18 is the salary certificate issued by him to the petitioner.
According to PW1, the petitioner was getting a salary of Rs. 15,000/per month. However, the tribunal has not accepted the evidence of
PW1 and fixed the notional income at Rs. 7,000/-.
12.
During the pendency of the appeal, the petitioner
produced Annexure A2 certificate issued from Technical Education
Society of Vidya stating that the petitioner obtained TIG/ARC
Welding certificate course in March 2007 in Second Class.
Annexure A3 is the Access Card for contractor’s workmen engaged
M.A.C.A.No.845 of 2016
2025:KER:21062
-6-
in Kochin Shipyard Ltd., in the name of the petitioner.
From
Annexure A2 and A3, it is revealed that the petitioner is a
technically qualified welder since 2007. Annexure A1 is the copy of
the National Trade Certificate in the name of the petitioner, showing
that he has completed the course of training at Balanagar Technical
Institute ITC, Mookkannur in the trade Welder (Gas and Electric) in
July 1999. Therefore from the evidence of PW1 and from Annexure
A1 to A3, it is proved that the petitioner was working as welder
under PW1 in Kochin Shipyard. In the above circumstance, I do not
find any grounds to disbelieve the testimony of PW1 that the
petitioner was getting a monthly income of Rs. 15,000/-. As such the
notional monthly income of the petitioner is fixed at Rs. 15,000/-.
13.
In the accident the petitioner sustained Type IIIB
open fracture both bone right leg, lacerated wound right knee and
fracture Ppx ring finger right hand. The petitioner was treated as in
patient for a total period of 70 days in six sessions. The details of
the treatment undergone by the petitioner is described in the
paragraph 15 of the award as follows:
“Ext.A14 also shows that the petitioner was admitted in the
hospital on 1.12.2011 and was discharged on 23.12.2011. Ext.A15
photographs show external ring fixator to the right leg of the
M.A.C.A.No.845 of 2016
2025:KER:21062
-7-
petitioner. Ext. A16 contains four discharge summaries, the first one
for the period from 1.12.2011 to 23.12.2011. which shows that the
petitioner had sustained Type IIIB open fracture both bones right
leg, comminuted with bone loss, lacerated wound right knee,
fracture PPX ring finger right hand. Wound debridement and
external fixator application to right tibia was done. The petitioner
was readmitted in the hospital on 3.1.2012 with bone defect right
leg M/3rd and bifocal ilizarov osteosynthesis right leg was done, and
was discharged on 23.1.2012. As per the third discharge summary
the petitioner was readmitted for the period from 23.7.2012 to
28.7.2012 for revision lizarov bone grafting/ The petitioner was
admitted in the hospital on 1.4.2013 for removal of Ilizarov ring
fixator and was discharged on 8.4.2013”.
14.
As
per
Exhibit.C2
disability
certificate
the
petitioner suffered 14% permanent physical disability. It was issued
by the medical board. The Tribunal, has accepted the permanent
physical disability of the petitioner as such and hence, I do not find
any grounds to disbelieve the same. Therefore, the
permanent
physical disability of the petitioner is accepted as 14%, as fixed by
the Tribunal.
15.
On the date of accident, the petitioner was aged 31
M.A.C.A.No.845 of 2016
2025:KER:21062
-8-
years. Therefore, 40% of the monthly income is to be added towards
future prospects, as held in the decision in National Insurance Co.
Ltd v. Pranay Sethi [(2017) 16 SCC 680] and the multiplier to be
applied is 16, as held in Sarla Verma v. Delhi Transport
Corporation, [(2009) 6 SCC 121]. In the above circumstances, the
loss of disability will come to Rs.5,64,480/16.
From the evidence it is revealed that though the
accident was occurred on 01.12.2011. The petitioner was treated as
inpatient for a total period of 70 days, in six sessions and in the
meantime bifocal ilizarov osteosyntheses right leg was done on
05.01.2012.
Thereafter on July 2012 revision of Ilizarov bone
grafting was made and in April 2013 he was again admitted for
removal of Ilizarov ring fixator.
He was discharged from the
hospital finally on 08.04.2013.
The petitioner continued his
treatment even thereafter and during the pendency of this appeal he
has produced additional medical bills worth Rs. 1,09,671/-. In the
above circumstance, towards loss of earning, the petitioner is
entitled to get the notional income at least for a period of 16
months, till April 2013, which will come to Rs. 2,40,000/- (15,000 x
16).
17.
Towards bystander expense the petitioner was
M.A.C.A.No.845 of 2016
2025:KER:21062
-9-
awarded Rs. 13,500 @ 250 per 57 days.
Since he was treated a
inpatient for a total period of 70 days he is entitled to get an amount
of Rs.17,500/- (250 x 70).
18.
Towards
the
head
‘pain
and
sufferings’,
the
Tribunal has awarded Rs.40,000/-. Towards 'loss of amenities of life'
Rs.25,000/- was awarded and towards 'extra nourishment' Rs.2,000/was awarded. According to the learned counsel for the petitioner,
the compensation awarded on those heads are on the lower side.
19.
The petitioner sustained very serious injuries in the
accident and was treated as inpatient for 70 days. Because of the
injuries sustained, the percentage of disability suffered and the
length of treatment undergone by the petitioner, I hold that the
compensation awarded by the Tribunal on the
heads ‘pain and
sufferings’, 'loss of amenities of life' and 'extra nourishment' are on
the lower side and hence they are enhanced to as Rs. 2,00,000/- ,
2,00,000 and 20,000/- respectively.
20.
As early as on 21.01.2024, the petitioner has
produced additional bills 52 in numbers for a total sum of Rs.
1,09,671/- as Annexures A7 to A58. Though, sufficient opportunity
was given, no objection was raised against these bills. In the above
circumstances, I do not find any grounds to disbelieve the additional
M.A.C.A.No.845 of 2016
2025:KER:21062
-10-
bills worth Rs. 1,09,671/- produced by the petitioner and as such
towards additional medical expense a sum of Rs. 1,09,671/- is
allowed. Even at this stage the learned standing counsel for the 2 nd
respondent sought for more time for getting approval from the
company. Since, more than 14 months elapsed after the production
of these bills, I am not inclined to grant more time for the approval
of the company.
21.
No change is required, in the amounts awarded on
other heads, as the compensation awarded on those heads appears
to be just and reasonable.
22.
Therefore, the petitioners/appellants are entitled to
get a total compensation of Rs.15,43,207/-, as modified and
recalculated above and given in the table below, for easy reference:
Sl.
No
.
Head of Claim
Amount awarded
by Tribunal (in
Rs.)
Amount
Awarded in
Appeal (in Rs.)
1 Loss of earning
70,000/-
2,40,000/-
2 Transport to hospital
5,000/-
5,000/-
3 Extra nourishment
2,000/-
20,000/-
4 Payment of bystander
13,500/-
17,500/-
5 Damage to clothes
1,000/-
1,000/-
6 Medical expenses
1,85,556/-
2,95,227/(1,85,556/- +
1,09,671)
7 Pain and sufferings
40,000/-
2,00,000/-
M.A.C.A.No.845 of 2016
2025:KER:21062
-11-
8 Loss of amenities etc.
25,000/-
2,00,000/-
9 Permanent disability
1,88,160/-
5,64,480/-
5,30,216/-
15,43,207/-
Total
Enhanced Rs.10,12,991/23.
In the result, this Appeal is allowed in part, and
Respondent No.3 is directed to deposit a total sum of Rs.15,43,207/(Rupees fifteen lakhs forty three thousand two hundred and seven
only), less the amount already deposited, if any, along with interest
@
9%
per
annum,
deposit/realisation,
from
the
date
of
the
petition
till
within a period of two months from today.
(Enhanced compensation will carry interest @8%)
24.
On depositing the aforesaid amount, the Tribunal
shall disburse the entire amount to the petitioner, excluding court
fee payable, if any, without delay, as per rules.
Sd/C. PRATHEEP KUMAR,
JUDGE
ADS
M.A.C.A.No.845 of 2016
2025:KER:21062
-12APPENDIX OF MACA 845/2016
PETITIONER ANNEXURES
Annexure A1
3. THE TRUE COPY OF THE NATIONAL TRADE
CERTIFICATE ISSUED TO THE APPELLANT
QUALIFYING HIM TO BE A WELDER (GAS AND
ELECTRIC) DATED 26.08.2002
Annexure A2
THE TRUE COPY OF THE CERTIFICATE ISSUED TO
THE APPELLANT BY THE TECHNICAL EDUCATION
SOCIETY OF INDIAQUALIFYING HIM TO BE A
TIG/ ARC WELDER DATED 30.04.2007
Annexure A3
THE ORIGINAL ACCESS CARD ISSUED TO THE
APPELLANT BY THE COCHIN SHIPYARD
Annexure A4
THE TRUE COPY OF THE DISCHARGE SUMMARY
ISSUED FROM WEST FORT HITECH HOSPITAL
DATED 10.10.2016
Annexure A5
THE TRUE COPY OF THE DISCHARGE SUMMARY
ISSUED FROM ASWINI HOSPITAL LTD. DATED
01.02.2017
Annexure A6
THE TRUE COPY OF THE TREATMENT CERTIFICATE
ISSUED BY SUN MEDICAL RESEARCH CENTRE
DATED 03.06.2017
Annexure A7
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILL NO. 14243 DATED
27.09.2016
Annexure A8
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILL NO. 34962 DATED
29.09.2016
Annexure A9
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILL NO. 7904 DATED
29.09.2016
Annexure A10
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILL NO.13220 DATED
29.09.2016
Annexure A11
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILL NO. 34842 DATED
29.09.2016
M.A.C.A.No.845 of 2016
2025:KER:21062
-13Annexure A12
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILL NO. 34990 WITH
DATED 29.09.2016
Annexure A13
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILL NO.8126 WITH
DATED 04.10.2016
Annexure A14
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILL NO. 36018 DATED
04.10.2016
Annexure A15
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILL NO. 36607 DATED
07.10.2016
Annexure A16
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILL NO. 8272 DATED
07.10.2016
Annexure A17
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILL NO. S 35205
DATED 18.10.2016
Annexure A18
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILL NO. 16056 WITH
DATED 18.10.2016
Annexure A19
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILL WITH NO. 8749
DATED 18.10.2016
Annexure A20
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILL WITH NO. 38739
DATED 18.10.2016
Annexure A21
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILL WITH NO. 38740
THE DATED 18.10.2016
Annexure A22
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILL WITH NO.71956
THE DATED 28.10.2016
Annexure A23
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILL NO. 17385 DATED
03.11.2016
Annexure A24
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILL WITH NO. 9419
DATED 03.11.2016
Annexure A25
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILL NO. 41723 DATED
03.11.2016
Annexure A26
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILL NO.16239 DATED
03.11.2016
M.A.C.A.No.845 of 2016
2025:KER:21062
-14-
Annexure A27
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILL NO.9925 DATED
14.11.2016
Annexure A28
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILLS NO. 43644 DATED
14.11.2016
Annexure A29
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILL NO.79408 DATED
14.11.2016
Annexure A30
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILLNO.83073 DATED
22.11.2016
Annexure A31
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILLNO.19361 DATED
30.11.2016
Annexure A32
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILL NO. 10592 DATED
30.11.2016
Annexure A33
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILL NO.22498 DATED
07.01.2017
Annexure A34
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILL NO.096557 DATED
30.01.2017
Annexure A35
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILLNO.064003 DATED
30.01.2017
Annexure A36
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILL NO.021326 DATED
30.01.2017
Annexure A37
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILL NO.016424 DATED
30.01.2017
Annexure A38
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILLNO.064107DATED
31.01.2017
Annexure A39
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILL NO.144866 DATED
31.01.2017
Annexure A40
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILL NO. 144927 DATED
31.01.2017
Annexure A41
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILL NO.13497 DATED
M.A.C.A.No.845 of 2016
2025:KER:21062
-1501.02.2017
Annexure A42
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILLNO.021256 DATED
01.02.2017
Annexure A43
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILLNO.145641 DATED
01.02.2017
Annexure A44
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILL NO.019952 DATED
06.02.2017
Annexure A45
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILLNO.147919 DATED
06.02.2017
Annexure A46
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILL NO. 022605 DATED
16.02.2017
Annexure A47
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILLNO.152870 DATED
16.02.2017
Annexure A48
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILLNO.144898 DATED
31.01.2017
Annexure A49
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILL NO.126159 DATED
21.02.2017
Annexure A50
THE ORIGINAL MEDICALNO.155183 DATED
21.02.2017
Annexure A51
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILL NO. 020919 DATED
21.02.2017
Annexure A52
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILLNO.103671 DATED
21.02.2017
Annexure A53
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILLNO.115530 DATED
30.03.2017
Annexure A54
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILLNO.OP/25716 DATED
03.06.2017
Annexure A55
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILLNO. OP/25700
DATED 03.06.2017
M.A.C.A.No.845 of 2016
2025:KER:21062
-16Annexure A56
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILLNO.30935 DATED
03.06.2017
Annexure A57
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILL NO.OP/25896
DATED 03.06.2017
Annexure A58
THE ORIGINAL MEDICAL BILL NO. 2690 DATED
15.06.2017
STATEMENT OF BILLS
STATEMENT OF BILLS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review