The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
18. The objection concerning territorial jurisdiction does not furnish a ground for quashing. In Rupali Devi v. State of Uttar Pradesh, (2019) 5 SCC 384, the Supreme Court held that, depending upon the facts, the courts at the place where a wife takes shelter after leaving or being driven from the matrimonial home because of cruelty may also have jurisdiction. The informant states that the alleged harassment compelled her to take shelter with her parents at Rajur. The proceedings cannot, therefore, be quashed merely because the acts narrated occurred in Mumbai. Equally, the interval before registration of the FIR does not establish that the complaint is false or an afterthought, particularly in the context of the attempts at reconciliation and the reference during hearing to an earlier NC. It is unnecessary to determine the contents of that NC for deciding this application.
19. On consideration of the FIR and the charge-sheet material together, the allegations against the applicants remain substantially collective and do not furnish a sufficiently particular basis for their prosecution for the offences alleged. This finding does not rest on a determination that the informant's account is untrue or that her grievances against her husband are unfounded. It concerns the insufficiency of the allegations against these applicants even when the prosecution case is accepted. In these -13APPLN-4891-2025 circumstances, compelling them to undergo a criminal trial would amount to an abuse of the process of the Court. The application therefore deserves to be allowed. Hence, the following order : (a) Criminal Application No. 4891 of 2025 is allowed. (b) C.R. No. 288 of 2024 registered with Rajur Police Station, Taluka Akole, District Ahmednagar, for the offences punishable under Sections 498-A, 323, 504 and 506 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code, the charge-sheet arising therefrom and the consequential proceedings bearing Regular Criminal Case No. 70 of 2025 pending before the Judicial Magistrate First Class, Rajur, are quashed and set aside insofar as applicant No. 1, Mrs. Shahenaz Mohd. Farooque Shaikh; applicant No. 2, Mr. Shafique Abbas Shaikh; and applicant No. 3, Farah Shahbaz Qureshi alias Farah alias Heena Qureshi, are concerned. (c) The proceedi…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:48861-DB
-1APPLN-4891-2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
CRIMINAL APPLICATION NO. 4891 OF 2025
1.
Mrs. Shahenaz Mohd. Farooque Shaikh
Age : 51 Years, Occ : Housewife
R/At Hakarshee Amarashi Chawl,
No. 319, Bazar Road, Near Jain Mandir,
Bandra (West), Mumbai – 400050.
.. (Mother-in-Law)
2.
Mr. Shafique Abbas Shaikh
.. (Parental Uncle)
Age : 72 Years, Occ : Retired,
B-903, Chohan Classic CHS. Ltd.,
Captain Samant Road, Near Agarwal Estate,
Jogeshwari (W), Mumbai – 102.
3.
Farah Shahbaz Qureshi @ Farah
@ Heena Qureshi
Age : 35 Years, Occ: Housewife,
Flat No. 405, 4th Floor, Syba Building,
B-Wing, Station Road, Bandra (W),
Mumbai – 400050.
.. (Sister-in-Law)
... Applicants
Versus
1.
The State of Maharashtra
2.
The Senior Inspector of Police
Rajur Police Station, Ahmednagar,
in C.R. 288/2024.
3.
Mrs. Kashmira Farhan Shaikh
Age: 25 Years, Occ: Housewife,
Residing at Sarvodaya Galli, Rajur,
Taluka-Akole, Dist: Ahmednagar.
.. (Wife)
... Respondents
……
Mr. Amol A. Pawar, Advocate for Applicants.
Mr. D. J. Patil, APP for Respondent Nos.1 and 2- State.
Mr. Anand V. Indrale Patil, Advocate for Respondent No.3
(Appointed Through Legal Aid).
……
-2APPLN-4891-2025
CORAM : HITEN S. VENEGAVKAR, J.
DATED : 09th OCTOBER, 2026
JUDGMENT :
1.
By this application under Section 528 of the Bharatiya
Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, the applicants seek quashing of
C.R. No. 288 of 2024 registered with Rajur Police Station, Taluka
Akole, District Ahmednagar, for the offences punishable under
Sections 498-A, 323, 504 and 506 read with Section 34 of the
Indian Penal Code, together with the charge-sheet and the
consequential proceedings bearing Regular Criminal Case No.70 of
2025 pending before the Judicial Magistrate First Class, Rajur.
Applicant No.1 is the mother-in-law of respondent No.3, applicant
No.2 is an elderly relative of the husband's family and applicant
No.3 is the married sister-in-law. The husband is not an applicant
before this Court. The relief sought must, therefore, be examined
only in respect of these three applicants.
2.
Respondent No.3 states that she married Farhan Mohd.
Farooque Shaikh on 2nd March, 2020 according to Muslim rites and
thereafter went to reside at the matrimonial home at Bandra,
Mumbai. She states that she was treated properly for about three
months, after which her husband demanded Rs.5,00,000/- from
her parental family for starting a business. When she expressed
-3APPLN-4891-2025
her father's inability to provide that amount, her husband allegedly
assaulted her and told her that she was no longer wanted. She
further states that during her pregnancy, disputes arose
concerning expenditure on medical treatment and that her
husband and members of his family taunted her for not bringing
anything from her parental home and for not knowing how to
conduct herself or perform household work.
3.
Respondent No.3 states that the family members also
spoke of getting her husband married again so that another
marriage would bring money into the family. According to her, the
physical and mental harassment compelled her to return to her
parental home at Rajur in 2022. Relatives from both sides
subsequently intervened and brought about a reconciliation. She
accordingly returned to Mumbai on 17 th February, 2024 and
remained there until 17th April, 2024. She states that the demand
for money and the ill-treatment continued during this period, that
she was deprived of food and that her husband threatened to kill
her if she returned. In particular, she attributes the assault and
expulsion on 16th April, 2024 to her husband. She then contacted
her parents, who came to Mumbai and took her to Rajur.
4.
The FIR was registered on 2nd August, 2024. During
-4APPLN-4891-2025
investigation, the statements of the informant's father, mother and
another relative were recorded. The papers also contain the report
of
the
Bharosa
Cell
concerning
unsuccessful
efforts
at
reconciliation and documents relating to the police visit to Mumbai
and service of notices for attendance. The police ultimately
submitted a charge-sheet against the husband and the present
applicants, and the criminal case referred to above came to be
instituted.
5.
Learned Advocate for the applicants submits that the
allegations of demand for money, assault and threats are
principally directed against the husband and that the applicants
have been included by making common allegations against the
family. He submits that applicant No.2, aged about 72 years,
resides at Jogeshwari and that applicant No.3 is married and
resides at her own matrimonial home. Neither of them, according
to him, has been assigned any specific act constituting the offences
alleged. As regards applicant No. 1, he accepts that she resided in
the matrimonial home with the informant but submits that
residence in the same house cannot, by itself, justify her
prosecution in the absence of sufficiently particular allegations
against her.
-5APPLN-4891-2025
6.
Learned Advocate for the applicants further submits
that the statements collected during investigation do not cure the
absence of particulars concerning the applicants' individual
involvement. The application also questions registration of the
offence at Rajur when the alleged incidents occurred in Mumbai
and relies upon the interval between the informant leaving the
matrimonial home and registration of the FIR. In the course of
hearing, reference was made to an earlier NC at Mumbai in
connection with the events of April 2024. Counsel also responded
to the query concerning attendance pursuant to the police notice
by stating that the necessary compliance had been furnished.
7.
The respondent's case, as disclosed by the prosecution
papers, is that the demand for Rs.5,00,000/- was accompanied by
harassment in the matrimonial home and that members of the
family participated in that harassment. The statements of the
informant's parents repeat the allegations of taunts during her
pregnancy, collective assault and continued ill-treatment after
reconciliation. The police summary further states that, on the
advice of accused No.3, Shafique Abbas Shaikh, the husband,
mother-in-law and sister-in-law deprived the informant of food and
expelled her. This material requires consideration along with the
FIR. It would not be correct to proceed on the footing that the
-6APPLN-4891-2025
witnesses say nothing against the applicants or that the chargesheet contains no allegation concerning them.
8.
The jurisdiction under Section 528 of BNSS is to be
exercised with care. At this stage, the Court does not decide
whether the informant or her witnesses should be believed, nor
does it weigh their statements against the applicants' defence. The
allegations and the material collected during investigation must be
considered on their own terms. The question is whether, even on
that basis, they disclose a prima facie case against the persons who
seek quashing. Completion of investigation does not preclude the
exercise of inherent jurisdiction, but it requires the Court to
consider the charge-sheet material as well as the FIR.
9.
In Kahkashan Kausar alias Sonam v. State of Bihar,
(2022) 6 SCC 599, the Supreme Court held that general and
omnibus allegations against the husband's relatives, without a
specific and distinct role indicating their involvement, do not
warrant their prosecution. The decision does not confer immunity
upon relatives of a husband. It requires the Court to distinguish
allegations disclosing their participation from a general accusation
which includes them merely as members of the family.
-7APPLN-4891-2025
10.
The same approach was reiterated in Sanjay D. Jain
and Others v. State of Maharashtra and Others , 2025 SCC OnLine
SC 2090, decided on 26th September, 2025. The Supreme Court
examined both the FIR and the final report and quashed the
proceedings against the father-in-law, mother-in-law and sister-inlaw where the allegations did not disclose the necessary
ingredients against them. The proceedings against the husband
were expressly left to be decided on their own merits. These
decisions require scrutiny of the actual allegations against each
applicant. They do not permit rejection of a complaint merely
because it arises from a matrimonial dispute.
11.
Turning to the present record, the informant's account
identifies her husband as the person who required money for a
business, repeatedly assaulted her when it was not provided,
threatened her and assaulted and expelled her on 16 th April, 2024.
When the account refers to the applicants, it largely shifts to
expressions concerning the family members together. Their names
occur in connection with the pregnancy-related taunts and in the
concluding collective allegations, but the narration does not
identify what each applicant did in the alleged course of coercion.
The difficulty is not merely that a date or time has been omitted.
An FIR need not be an exhaustive account of every incident. The
-8APPLN-4891-2025
difficulty is that neither the FIR nor the statements recorded
thereafter sufficiently distinguish the applicants' participation in
the conduct alleged against the husband.
12.
Applicant No.1's case requires consideration because
she lived in the matrimonial home. Separate residence is not
available as a circumstance in her favour. Equally, sharing the
matrimonial home does not make her answerable for every act of
the husband. The allegations concerning expenditure during
pregnancy, dissatisfaction with what the informant brought from
her parents and the proposal of another marriage are serious
matters and have been considered. They are, however, attributed
to the husband and several relatives together, without a distinct
incident identifying applicant No.1's conduct in making or
enforcing the demand. After the informant returned in February
2024, the account again refers generally to the conduct of her
husband and the family. The specific assault and expulsion of 16 th
April, 2024 is narrated against the husband. On a reading of the
material, the common allegations have not acquired sufficient
particulars against applicant No.1 merely because she resided in
the same house.
13.
As regards applicant No.2, the charge-sheet summary
refers to the others acting on his advice. Such an allegation cannot
-9APPLN-4891-2025
be disregarded merely because he is elderly or resides at
Jogeshwari. A person residing elsewhere may participate in
cruelty by directing or encouraging it. The question is whether the
material supplies the factual basis for that alleged participation.
Here,
the
summary
does
not
identify
any
occasion
or
communication in which he gave the alleged advice. The
informant's account and the statements of her relatives do not
describe a conversation or other act supplying particulars to that
conclusion. Beyond naming him among those who allegedly
taunted the informant during her pregnancy, the material
continues to refer collectively to the family. The assertion of advice
in the police summary thus does not cure the absence of a
sufficiently particular account of his involvement.
14.
Applicant No.3 is a married sister-in-law whose
separate matrimonial residence is stated in the application. Her
separate residence would not justify quashing if the prosecution
material disclosed her participation in an offence. However, the
statements do not identify a visit, a communication or an incident
in which she individually demanded money, assaulted the
informant or enforced the alleged demand. She is included with the
other relatives in the account of taunts during pregnancy and in
the collective allegations of harassment. Investigation has not
-10APPLN-4891-2025
supplied a distinct factual account connecting her with the
subsequent deprivation of food or expulsion. Her prosecution
would therefore rest upon the same general allegations which the
Supreme Court has held insufficient to compel a relative to face
trial.
15.
The statements of the informant's father and mother
have also been considered. They repeat the account of the demand,
the taunts, the informant's return to Rajur and the attempt at
reconciliation. It is neither necessary nor permissible to reject
those statements because the witnesses are her parents or because
parts of their account were communicated to them by her. Even if
their
statements
are
accepted,
however,
they
repeat
the
accusations against the family collectively without supplying the
missing particulars concerning each applicant. The other relative's
statement similarly recounts what was conveyed to him about the
matrimonial dispute. The conclusion reached here rests upon the
content of these statements, and not upon any assessment of the
witnesses' credibility.
16.
Section
498-A
covers
both
the
wilful
conduct
contemplated by clause (a) of its Explanation and harassment
connected with an unlawful demand contemplated by clause (b).
Harassment for failure to meet an unlawful demand may itself
-11APPLN-4891-2025
attract the provision. The allegation that Rs.5,00,000/- was
required for starting a business cannot therefore be dismissed
merely because of the purpose for which the money was sought.
What is missing in the present case is a sufficiently particular
factual account connecting each applicant with the alleged coercive
harassment. The gravity of the conduct attributed to the husband
cannot supply that deficiency against the applicants.
17.
The remaining offences require the same examination.
The specific account of assault on 16 th April, 2024 and the threat to
kill is directed against the husband. The general references to
assault and abuse by family members do not disclose a sufficiently
distinct incident against any of these applicants so as to sustain
their prosecution under Sections 323 or 504 of IPC. Nor does the
material identify a threat by an applicant, made with the intention
of causing alarm or compelling the informant to act or refrain from
acting, which would sustain the charge under Section 506. Section
34 does not require a separate overt act by every accused in every
case, but there must be facts indicating participation in
furtherance of a common intention. The collective description of
the family, without such factual particulars, cannot by itself supply
that connection.
-12APPLN-4891-2025
18.
The objection concerning territorial jurisdiction does
not furnish a ground for quashing. In Rupali Devi v. State of Uttar
Pradesh, (2019) 5 SCC 384, the Supreme Court held that,
depending upon the facts, the courts at the place where a wife
takes shelter after leaving or being driven from the matrimonial
home because of cruelty may also have jurisdiction. The informant
states that the alleged harassment compelled her to take shelter
with her parents at Rajur. The proceedings cannot, therefore, be
quashed merely because the acts narrated occurred in Mumbai.
Equally, the interval before registration of the FIR does not
establish that the complaint is false or an afterthought,
particularly in the context of the attempts at reconciliation and the
reference during hearing to an earlier NC. It is unnecessary to
determine the contents of that NC for deciding this application.
19.
On consideration of the FIR and the charge-sheet
material together, the allegations against the applicants remain
substantially collective and do not furnish a sufficiently particular
basis for their prosecution for the offences alleged. This finding
does not rest on a determination that the informant's account is
untrue or that her grievances against her husband are unfounded.
It concerns the insufficiency of the allegations against these
applicants even when the prosecution case is accepted. In these
-13APPLN-4891-2025
circumstances, compelling them to undergo a criminal trial would
amount to an abuse of the process of the Court. The application
therefore deserves to be allowed. Hence, the following order :
ORDER
(a)
Criminal Application No. 4891 of 2025 is allowed.
(b)
C.R. No. 288 of 2024 registered with Rajur Police
Station, Taluka Akole, District Ahmednagar, for the offences
punishable under Sections 498-A, 323, 504 and 506 read with
Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code, the charge-sheet arising
therefrom and the consequential proceedings bearing Regular
Criminal Case No. 70 of 2025 pending before the Judicial
Magistrate First Class, Rajur, are quashed and set aside
insofar as applicant No. 1, Mrs. Shahenaz Mohd. Farooque
Shaikh; applicant No. 2, Mr. Shafique Abbas Shaikh; and
applicant No. 3, Farah Shahbaz Qureshi alias Farah alias
Heena Qureshi, are concerned.
(c)
The proceedings against the husband shall continue and
shall be decided independently on their own merits.
(d)
The observations in this judgment are confined to the
present applicants and shall not influence adjudication of the
case against husband.
(e)
Tandale
There shall be no order as to costs.
(HITEN S. VENEGAVKAR)
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review