Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page |1
SHAMUR Digitally signed
by
AILATPA SHAMURAILATP
AM SUSHIL
M
SHARMA
SUSHIL Date:
2022.05.11
SHARMA 11:26:32 +05'30'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No. 1150 of 2021
Shri Sh. Harimohan Sharma, aged about 59 years, S/o. (L)
Sh. Haridas
Sharma, Heirok Part-I, Heitupokpi P.O.
Wangjing & P.S. Heirok, District Thoubal, Manipur, presently
working as Principal, State Institute of Rural Development
(SIRD), Manipur.
…PETITIONER
-Versus1. The State of Manipur represented by the Addl. Chief
Secretary/Principal
Secretary/Commissioner/Secretary
(RD & PR), Government of Manipur, Office at Old
Secretariat, Babupara, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West
District, Manipur-795001.
2. The Principal Secretary/Commissioner/Secretary (DP),
Government of Manipur, Office at Old Secretariat,
Babupara, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District,
Manipur-795001.
3. The Principal Secretary/ Commissioner/ Secretary
(Finance), Government of Manipur, Office at Chief
Minister Bunglow, Babupara, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal
West District, Manipur-795001.
4. The Director (RD & PR), Government of Manipur, Office
at DC Complex, Porompat, P.O. & P.S. Porompat,
Imphal East District, Manipur-795005.
WP(C) No. 1150 of 2018
Page |2
5. The State Institute of Rural Development (SIRD),
Manipur through its Director/Member Secretary (SIRD),
Manipur, Office at DC Complex, Porompat, P.O. & P.S.
Porompat, Imphal East District, Manipur-795005.
…. OFFICIAL RESPONDENTS
6. The Director General, National Institute of Rural
Development & Panchayati Raj (NIRDPR), Government
of India, Rajendranagar, Hyderabad-500030
.... PROFORMA RESPONDENT
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M.V. MURALIDARAN
For the Petitioner
:: Mr. M. Hemchandra, Sr. Advocate
For the Respondents
:: Mr. Lenin Hijam, Advocate General,
Mr. Kh. Samarjit, ASG for R-6..
Date of Hearing and
reserving Judgment & Order ::
27.04.2022
Date of Judgment & Order
10.05.2022
::
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(CAV)
This writ petition has been filed by the petitioner to
quash the impugned order dated 13.9.2018 issued by the Under
Secretary (RD&PR), Government of Manipur and to direct the
respondents to streamline/re-fix the pay of the Principal/SIRD,
Manipur in parity with the scale of pay of Associate Professor as
prescribed by UGC i.e. PB-4: Rs.37400-67000+AGP 9000/- as
WP(C) No. 1150 of 2018
Page |3
per the recommendation of NIRD/MorD, Government of India or
in parity with the Principal (Under Graduate College) i.e. PB-4:
Rs.37400-67000+AGP 10,000 + Rs.2000/- special Allowances
as prescribed by the State Government.
2.
The case of the petitioner is that he was appointed
as Instructor (Agri) on ad-hoc basis in the Directorate of Rural
Development and Panchayat Raj, Manipur on 21.6.1984 and he
was later on appointed by promotion to the post of Principal
(MPRTI) [now State Institute of Rural Development (SIRD)] of the
RD & PR on regular basis. Since the Recruitment Rules and
Service Rules of SIRD have not been framed, the respondents
has adopted the Recruitment Rules and Service Rules of NIRD,
Government of India. However, by ignoring and overlooking the
fact that there must be an uniformity in the pay scale of the faculty
all over India and the pay scale should be equal to UGC scale
and equal to the UGC post of Associate Professor as per the
proceedings of National Colloquium of ETCs 2nd and 3rd June,
2016 of NIRDPR, MoRD, Government of India and also in total
disregards to the Rules of the SIRD, by the impugned order dated
13.09.2018, the petitioner who is holding the post of Principal
(MPRTI) was ordered for retirement from service on attaining the
age of superannuation with effect from 31.12.2018. According to
WP(C) No. 1150 of 2018
Page |4
the petitioner, the pay of the Principal/SIRD is to be streamlined
in parity with the scale of pay of Associate Professor as
prescribed by UGC or in parity with Principal (UG College) as
prescribed by the State Government, the age of superannuation
in respect of the petitioner on the capacity as Principal/SIRD
(MPRTI) ought to be fixed as 65 years.
3.
The first respondent filed affidavit-in-opposition
stating that the petitioner was appointed as Instructor (Agri) on
ad-hoc basis in the Directorate of Rural Development and
Panchayat Raj for a period of six months with effect from the date
of joining his duty or till the post is filled up on regular basis
whichever is earlier. He was regularized as Instructor (Agri) in the
scale of pay of Rs.720-30-1020-EB04501470/-per month. It is
stated that the Directorate has forwarded an application
submitted by the petitioner to the Secretary (RD & PR) for refixation of the pay scale of Principal in the pay scale of Associate
Professor prescribed by UGC i.e. PB-4: Rs.37400-67000+AGP
Rs.9000/-
as
per
the
recommendation
of
NIRD/MoRD,
Government of India or a Principal (UG College) of the State
Government
Rs.
PB-4:
Rs.37400-67000+AGP
Rs.10000+Rs.2000 Special Allowance prescribed by the State
Government on 27.1.2017. The Deputy Secretary (RD & PR)
WP(C) No. 1150 of 2018
Page |5
requested the Director (RD&PR) to submit a comment along with
justification for re-fixation of pay scale of Principal (MPRTI) on
4.5.2017. On 18.11.2017, the Directorate has addressed a letter
to the Principal Secretary (RD & PR) protecting the pay of the
Principal/SIRD.
4.
It is stated in the affidavit-in-opposition that the
promotion avenue of Principal/SIRD is to be from (i) Graduate
Instructor (Panchayat); (ii) Instructor (Agri) and (iii) Instructor
(Sociology) with five years regular service in their respective
grade and their pay is Rs.5200-20200+GP2800 in the
recruitment rule. The petitioner was promoted to the post of
Principal (MPRTI) vide order dated 23.8.1994 in the RD & PR
Department on regular basis in the scale of Rs.9300-34800+GP
4300/- on 21.4.2015. In the recruitment rule, it is mentioned that
the post of Principal has to be promoted from (i) Graduate
Instructor (Panchayat); (ii) Instructor (Agri) and (iii) Instructor
(Sociology) with five years regular service in their respective
grade. The then Principal/SIRD K.S.Lungrei retired on 30.4.2014
on attaining the age of superannuation i.e. 60 years.
5.
It is also stated in the affidavit-in-opposition that the
RD & PR Department, the post of BDO (Jr), Assistant Director
(Panchayat), Project Officer (MC) and Principal (SIRD) are the
WP(C) No. 1150 of 2018
Page |6
feeder post of MCS (JR) and they are same scale and to be
promoted to the next higher post to MCS-II. The age of retirement
of Polytechnic teachers is 62 years and the Government College
teachers is also 62 years. By the Office Memorandum dated
28.2.2013, the retirement of the Government College teachers
extended from 62 years to 65 years. As of now the age of
retirement of Principal and faculty members of SIRD is 60 years.
Since the petitioner cannot be considered as per rules and
standing orders, the first respondent prayed for dismissal of the
writ petition.
6.
The fifth respondent/SIRD filed counter stating that
the petitioner was appointed on promotion to the post of
Principal, Manipur Panchayat Raj Training Institute (MPRTI) now
amended as SIRD in the RD & PR Department on regular basis
in the scale of pay of Rs.9300-34800+GP4300/- on 21.4.2015.
The salary of Principal, MPRTI/SIRD is drawn from the
Directorate of RD & PR, Manipur (Panchayat Wing) and not from
the Directorate of SIRD. It is stated that the post of Principal,
MPRTI/SIRD is a cadre post of Junior Manipur Civil Service. The
higher post for promotion from the post of Principal, MPRTI/SIRD
is the post of MCS-II, which is organised service regulated under
WP(C) No. 1150 of 2018
Page |7
the Department of P&AR under the provisions of MCS Rules,
1965.
7.
It is stated that as per the records maintained by the
Directorate of RD & PR, K.S.Lungrei, former Principal,
MPRTI/SIRD was also appointed on promotion to the post of
MCS-II and retired on 30.4.2014 on attaining the age of
superannuation i.e. 60 years. The educational qualification of the
petitioner is B.Sc. (Agri) Hons. However, in the recruitment rules,
for the post of Principal of Government Colleges (Professor’s
Grade), it is mentioned that the essential qualification for direct
recruitment for the post of Principal in Government Colleges are
(i) Master’s Degree with at least 55% of the marks or its
equivalent grade of recognized University; (ii) Ph.D. Degree or
equivalent qualification; (iii) total experience of 15 years of
teaching/research in University/College and other institution of
higher education.
8.
Assailing the impugned order dated 13.9.2018, Mr.
Hemchandra, the learned senior counsel for the petitioner
submitted that in total disregards to the Rules of SIRD, Manipur,
the under Secretary of RD & PR, Government of Manipur,
ordered retirement of the petitioner, who is holding the post of
Principal, MPRTI of the Directorate of RD & PR, from the
WP(C) No. 1150 of 2018
Page |8
Government service on attaining the age of superannuation with
effect from 31.12.2018 and further ordered that the service of the
petitioner stands terminated with effect from 31.12.2018, which
is highly improper, arbitrary and purely non application of mind
and also bad in law.
9.
The learned senior counsel further submitted that
the Recruitment Rules and Service Rules of the SIRD has not
been framed so far and the respondent State adopted the
Recruitment Rules and Service Rules of NIRD, Government of
India as enshrined under Chapter-VI of the Rules of the SIRD.
As such, the age of superannuation in respect of the petitioner,
on the capacity as Principal/SIRD/MPRTI ought to be 65 years of
age as prescribed by the UGC or the State Government.
10.
Drawing the attention of the Court to various Office
Memorandums and notifications of the Under Secretary (DP),
Government of Manipur and Department of P&AR and also
AICTE, the learned counsel submitted that the age of retirement
in case of a State Government employee is raised from 59 to 60
years and in the case of teachers of State Government and
teachers of State Government Polytechnic, the retirement age
was raised from 60 to 62 years on superannuation and also in
the case of retirement of teachers of the State Government
WP(C) No. 1150 of 2018
Page |9
Colleges, the age for retirement was raised from 62 to 65 years
on superannuation. He would submit that the petitioner who is
now working as Principal, MPRTI is not only doing the
administrative work but also involve class room teaching
activities and therefore he is entitled to be superannuated at the
age of 65 years and hence, the impugned order is highly illegal
and the same is liable to be set aside.
11.
Per contra, Mr. Lenin Hijam, the learned Advocate
General submitted that while the petitioner was in service, he has
submitted an application for re-fixation of pay scale of Principal
in the pay scale of Associate Professor prescribed by the UGC
as per the recommendation of NIRD/MoRD, Government of India
or as a Principal (Under Graduate College of State Government)
as prescribed by the State Government and the Director
addressed a letter dated 18.11.2017 in this regard to the Principal
Secretary, P&AR protecting the pay of the Principal, SIRD.
12.
The learned Advocate General further submitted
that in the Department, the promotion avenue of Principal, SIRD
is to be promoted from (1) Graduate Instructor (Panchayat); (2)
Instructor (Agri); (3) Instructor (Sociology) with five years regular
service in their respective grade and their pay is Rs.520020200+GO 2800 in the recruitment rules. The petitioner was
WP(C) No. 1150 of 2018
P a g e | 10
promoted to the post of Principal, MPRTI in RD & PR Department
on regular basis in the scale of pay of Rs.9300-34800+GP 4300/.
He would submit that the then Principal, SIRD retired on
30.4.2014 on attaining the age of 60 years on superannuation
and the petitioner is the successor. Since as of now the age of
retirement of Principal and faculty members of SIRD, Manipur is
60 years, the claim of the petitioner has no basis and therefore,
the same is liable to be rejected.
13.
The learned Additional Solicitor General submitted
that the petitioner was appointed on promotion to the post of
Principal, MPRTI, now amended as SIRD in the RD & PR
Department on regular basis in the scale of pay of Rs.930034800+GP 4300/-. He would submit that the salary of Principal,
MPRTI/SIRD is drawn from the Directorate of RD & PR and not
from the Directorate of SIRD and that the post of Principal,
MPRTI/SIRD is a cadre post of Junior Manipur Civil Service. The
higher post for promotion from the post of Principal, MPRTI/SIRD
is the post of MCS-IT which is an organised service regulated
under the Department of P&AR under the provisions of MCS
Rules, 1965. He would also submit that the former Principal was
also appointed on promotion to the post of MCS-II and retired on
WP(C) No. 1150 of 2018
P a g e | 11
30.4.2014 on attaining the age of superannuation i.e. 60 years
and therefore, there is no illegality in the impugned order.
14.
This Court considered the submissions raised by
learned counsel for the parties and also perused the materials
available on record.
15.
The grievance of the petitioner is that he was not
only doing administrative work, but was also involved in class
room teaching activities while he was working as Principal,
MPRTI and, therefore, he is entitled to superannuation at the age
of 65 years. In support, the petitioner has mainly relied upon the
Office Memorandum dated 28.2.2013, wherein the age of
retirement of teachers of the State Government Colleges in
Manipur
was
raised
from
years
to
years
on
superannuation.
16.
The learned senior counsel for the petitioner
submitted that in the said Office Memorandum dated 28.2.2013,
it has been stated that after careful consideration of all relevant
UGC guidelines regarding the service conditions of Teachers of
Government Colleges and also with the approval of the State
Cabinet in its sitting held on 28.02.2013, it has been decided by
the State Government that the age of retirement of the teachers
WP(C) No. 1150 of 2018
P a g e | 12
who are involved in class-room teaching in respect of all the State
Government Colleges in Manipur on superannuation shall be 65
years with immediate effect. He would submit that in the case of
the petitioner, he is not only doing administrative work but also
involved class room teaching activities.
17.
The petitioner was initially appointed as Instructor
(Agri) on ad-hoc basis in the Directorate of RD & PR, Manipur for
a period of six months with effect from the date of joining his duty
or till the post is filled up on regular basis, whichever is earlier
and thereafter he was regularized as Instructor (Agri) in the scale
of pay of Rs.720-30-1020-EB-45-1470/-.
18.
It appears that by the order dated 24.12.2016, 68
contract employees (Faculty & Staff) of SIRD, RGPSA/BRGF
and e-Panchayat have been regularised and absorbed in the
Department of RD & PR, Manipur against the post created. In the
said order, it has been stated that all posts created, if any, at the
time of initial engagement of these 68 contract employees would
stand abolished. It has also been mentioned that all 68 contract
employees shall be utilised at SIRD, Porompat till further orders.
According to the fifth respondent, there is no single contract and
regular employee in the SIRD, Manipur.
WP(C) No. 1150 of 2018
P a g e | 13
19.
The petitioner who was working as Instructor (Agri)
was appointed on promotion to the post of Principal, MPRTI now
amended as SIRD in the Rural Development and Panchayat Raj
Department on regular basis in the time scale of pay of Rs.930034800+GP Rs.4300/- vide order dated 21.4.2015.
20.
At this juncture, by placing reliance upon the
decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Motor General
Traders and another v. State of Andhra Pradesh, (1984) 1
SCC 222, the learned senior counsel for the petitioner submitted
that equals have to be treated equally and unequals ought not to
be treated equally.
21.
In Motor General Traders, supra, the Hon’ble Apex
Court held:
“10. The petitioners principally rely upon Article 14
of the Constitution in support of their case. The
equality clause contained in that Article requires
that all persons subjected to any legislation should
be treated alike under like circumstances and
conditions. Equals have to be treated equally and
unequals ought not to be treated equally. While that
Article forbids class legislation, it does not forbid
classification for purposes of implementing the right
of equality guaranteed by it. ....”
WP(C) No. 1150 of 2018
P a g e | 14
22.
It is apposite to mention that the petitioner is a
simple B.Sc. (Agri) Honours and in the relevant Recruitment
Rules for the post of Principal of Government Colleges i.e.
Professor’s
Grade,
the
essential
qualification
for
direct
recruitment for the post of Principal are (a) Master’s Degree with
at least 55% of the marks or its equivalent grade of recognised
University; (b) Ph. D. Degree or equivalent qualification and (c)
total
experience
of
years
of
teaching/research
in
University/Colleges and other institutions of higher education. As
stated supra, the petitioner was promoted to the post of Principal
from the feeder category of Instructor (Agri) and therefore, he
cannot be equated as Principal of Government Colleges. Nothing
has been brought on record to show that the Principal serving in
SIRD, Manipur is equivalent to the Principal of Government
Colleges. Moreover, the salary of Principal, MPRTI/SIRD is
drawn from the Directorate of RD & PR, Manipur (Panchayat
Wing) and not from the Directorate of SIRD.
23.
It also appears from the pleadings that the post of
Principal, MPRTI/SIRD is a cadre post of Junior Manipur Civil
Service and the higher post for promotion from the post of
Principal, MPRTI/SIRD is the post of MCS-II which is an
organised service regulated under the Department of Personnel
WP(C) No. 1150 of 2018
P a g e | 15
and Administrative Reforms, Government of Manipur under the
provisions of Manipur Civil Service Rules, 1965. It is pertinent to
point out that the former Principal of MPRTI/SIRD K.S.Lungrei
was also appointed on promotion to the post of MCS-II and
retired on 30.4.2014 on attaining the age of superannuation i.e.
years.
Therefore,
the
petitioner
cannot
claim
his
contended
that
the
superannuation at the age of 65 years.
24.
Though
the
petitioner
Recruitment Rules and Service Rules of the SIRD, Manipur has
not been framed so far and the respondent State is adopting the
Recruitment Rules and Service Rules of the NIRD, Government
of India under Chapter- VI of the Rules of the SIRD and as such
the age of superannuation in respect of the petitioner on the
capacity as Principal, MPRTI/SIRD ought to be 65 years of age
as prescribed by UGC or State Government, in view of the finding
arrived at by this Court that the Principal from the feeder category
of Instructor (Agri) cannot be equated as Principal of Government
Colleges, the petitioner is estopped from comparing the
Recruitment Rules and Service Rules of the NIRD, Government
of India.
25.
On a perusal of the notification dated 23.8.1994, it
is clear that the Directorate of P&AR (Personnel Division) has
WP(C) No. 1150 of 2018
P a g e | 16
regulated the method of recruitment to the post of Principal,
MPRTI in the Panchayat Department as shown in the MPSC
Form-8. Since the recruitment rule prescribes that the post of
Principal has to be promoted from (i) Graduate Instructor
(Panchayat); (ii) Instructor (Agri) and (iii) Instructor (Sociology)
with 5 years regular service in their grade, the petitioner cannot
compare the other categories to contend that the retirement age
has been raised from 60 to 62 years and 62 to 65 years
respectively. In view of the above, this Court finds no infirmity in
the impugned order dated 13.9.2018 ordering the retirement of
the petitioner from Government service on attaining the age of
superannuation with effect from 31.12.2018. Further, as of now
the age of retirement of Principal and faculty members of SIRD,
Manipur is 60 years.
26.
Since the prayer of the petitioner to raise the age of
superannuation of the Principal from 60 to 65 years has no basis
and the same cannot be granted, the question of consideration
of the next prayer of the petitioner to direct the respondents to
streamline/re-fix the pay of Principal, SIRD, Manipur in parity with
the scale of pay of Associate Professor as prescribed by the UGC
does not arise. That apart, in support of the said claim, nothing
has been produced by the petitioner. The only document relied
WP(C) No. 1150 of 2018
P a g e | 17
upon by the petitioner is the representation dated 23.1.2017
wherein the petitioner sought re-fixation of pay scale of the
Principal, SIRD/SIPARD/MPRTI in the scale of Associate
Professor prescribed by UGC. Since the petitioner was issued
with the order impugned ordering to retire from Government
service on attaining the age of superannuation with effect from
31.12.2018 A.N., the consideration of the aforesaid prayer for refixation of the pay of the Principal does not arise. There is no
merit in the writ petition and therefore, the same is liable to be
dismissed.
27.
In the result, the writ petition is dismissed. No costs.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
Sushil
WP(C) No. 1150 of 2018
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review