Keep judgments in folders, mark the paragraphs you rely on, and print a compilation with an index. It comes with the Research and Advocate Pro judgment plans and with a campus licence. Sign in · See the plans
Abuse of process of law – Appellant lodged complaint against the respondent alleging commission of offences u/s.16(2)(b) r/w ss.132(1)(b), 132(1)(c) and 132(1)(f) of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017, punishable u/s.135 thereof – Successive bail applications filed by the respondent before the trial court as well as the Additional City Civil and Sessions Judge were rejected – Eventually, bail granted by Single Judge – Challenge to:
Held: Respondent not only abused the process of law, he suppressed material facts from the High Court – There is clear lack of uberimma fides, the foundation for invoking the equitable and discretionary jurisdiction for grant of bail – Respondent had filed the criminal petition before the High Court seeking bail on 9th December, 2025 – On 10th December, 2025, he filed a similar application seeking bail before the Sessions Court which came to be rejected at a point of time when the criminal petition before the High Court was pending – Undeterred, on 22nd December, 2025, the respondent challenged the legality of his arrest by filing the writ petition – Not only did he seek quashing of the complaint filed before the trial court, he also sought ad-interim stay of further proceedings and release from custody stating that the remedy of applying for bail u/s.483, BNSS is not efficacious – Admittedly, a prayer for interim/ad-interim release was made on 22nd December, 2025 in the writ petition before the High Court, which was refused – Later in the day, a memo seeking listing of the criminal petition was filed – This was allowed and the petition was directed to be listed on 26th December, 2025 – Refusal of the prayer for ad-interim release was not disclosed to the Single Judge who, having heard the parties and regard being had to the nature of the case, proceeded to grant the respondent bail – Thus, respondent simultaneously pursued proceedings seeking bail/release before the Sessions Court as well as in his writ petition before the High Court while the criminal petition seeking bail before the High Court was pending consideration – Rejection of the prayer for bail (fourth in the series) by the Sessions Court as well as refusal by the writ court to order release from custody were particularly not brought to the notice of the High Court – Respondent engaged in forum shopping – Appellant, however, failed to place relevant materials on record by not filing its objections; may be, the time was too short – Also, in view of the winter vacation that followed and without having notice of the memo moved by the respondent for urgent listing of his criminal petition on 26th December, 2025, neither the appellant nor the counsel who appeared on 26th December, 2025 on its behalf could bring all facts to the attention of the Single Judge – Of utmost importance is that the respondent too did not – He indulged in suppressio veri and suggestio falsi – Respondent’s conduct in pursuing such parallel remedies, while keeping all judicial authorities in the dark, severely deprecated – It may be a right of the accused to challenge his arrest or to approach a court seeking bail; however, such conduct of pursuing remedies parallelly, particularly without adequate disclosure, clearly amounts to abuse of the process of law – The criminal petition before the Single Judge was listed, upon a memo having been moved by the counsel for the respondent, post 22nd December, 2025, during the winter vacation of the High Court – Ideally, in view of the earlier direction, the criminal petition should have been listed upon reopening of the High Court after the winter vacation particularly when such petition had not been made returnable on a specific date falling during such vacation or the Single Judge had not directed its listing before the Vacation Bench – To have obtained listing of a petition, without adequate notice to the appellant, was clearly an attempt to steal a march by even misleading the Court – The part of the impugned order whereby the criminal petition stood disposed of, set aside with the result that the same shall revive on the file of the High Court; and instead of the bail granted by the Single Judge, the respondent shall continue to remain on interim bail on earlier terms and conditions – Interim bail granted to the respondent shall be operative till such time further orders are passed by the Single Judge on the criminal petition [Paras 21, 22, 25-27, 30]
Directions by Supreme Court – Urgent listing of matters (petition, application or appeal) before a Bench of a High Court when the court is on vacation:
Held: In cases of the present nature, where a Bench of a High Court directs listing of a petition “two weeks hence” and the day following expiry of the period of “two weeks”, in terms of such direction, happens to fall in the midst of a vacation, the period of two weeks should ordinarily be computed by the registry of each such court excluding the period during which the court is on vacation – However, if the petition is made returnable on a specific date by the Bench which falls during the vacation or the Bench directs listing before the Vacation Bench, such petition should ideally be accordingly listed, subject to the relevant rules framed by the High Courts. [Para 34]
As published in the Supreme Court Reports, Supreme Court of India. Headnotes prepared by: Divya Pandey. Text from the Indian Supreme Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs), CC BY 4.0.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong? Request a review