Keep judgments in folders, mark the paragraphs you rely on, and print a compilation with an index. It comes with the Research and Advocate Pro judgment plans and with a campus licence. Sign in · See the plans
Penal Code, 1860 – s.394 – Conviction under, when not justified – High Court affirmed the appellant’s conviction and sentence u/s.394 passed by the Trial Court – Interference with: Held: Conviction of the appellant u/s.394 is not sustainable – s.394 applies where the offender, in committing or attempting to commit robbery, voluntarily causes hurt – The robbery or attempted robbery is not at all a peripheral circumstance and is rather an essential component of the offense – In the present case, such allegation of robbery rests entirely upon the assertion of the complainant that the appellant snatched her mangalsutra and dorle from her neck – There was no recovery of the alleged jewellery and nothing incriminating was seized from the appellant’s possession either – There was no purchase receipt or any other material establishing the identity or value of the articles, as admitted by the complainant herself in cross-examination – Though the High Court relied on the observation in the spot panchanama that wooden tulsi beads and black beads were found scattered on the porch, these beads were never connected through evidence to the mangalsutra, and only pieces of rope were exhibited and their seizure from the spot proved through PW-3, one of two panch witnesses, before the Trial Court – Therefore, the conviction u/s.394 cannot be sustained – Further, the complainant’s account is that the appellant had threatened her with a knife, and during a brief ensuing scuffle, slashed her left palm with it – Though, this is partly corroborated by the medical evidence showing presence of injury (iv), however, PW-5-Doctor only opined that it was caused by a sharp, hard object, and no such weapon was ever recovered from the appellant or linked to injury – Moreover, the wound itself, measuring 7×½×½ cm, is relatively shallow in nature – Therefore, this is not a fit case attracting offence u/s.326 of the IPC – However, from the evidence on record, the assertion of the complainant that the appellant struck her in her mouth and caused her left upper incisor tooth to fall out is sufficiently proved through witness testimony and medical evidence – The same falls squarely within the definition of ‘grievous hurt’ given in s.320, IPC viz. fracture or dislocation of a bone or tooth – Conviction of the appellant altered to one u/s.325, IPC – Appellant is convicted for the offence punishable u/s.325, IPC – On facts, the sentence of rigorous imprisonment for seven years with a fine of ₹1,000 is reduced to the period already undergone by him with fine – Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – s.222. [Paras 9, 11, 12, 15] Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – s.222 – Principle of Cognate Offences:
Held: Under s.222, a person charged with an offence consisting of several particulars may be convicted where the proved facts constitute a minor offence, notwithstanding that the minor offence was not separately charged – The principle of cognate offences, enables Courts to convict and sentence offenders for a ‘minor’ or less grave offence whose essentials are satisfied by the evidence on record, even when the original charge was framed for the ‘major’ offence – Complainant’s account that the appellant had threatened her with a knife, and during a brief ensuing scuffle, slashed her left palm with it – Though this is partly corroborated by the medical evidence showing presence of injury (iv), however, PW-5-Doctor only opined that it was caused by a sharp, hard object, and no such weapon was ever recovered from the appellant or linked to injury (iv) – Moreover, the wound itself, measuring 7×½×½ cm, is relatively shallow in nature – Therefore, this is not a fit case attracting offence u/s.326, IPC – However, from the evidence on record, the assertion of the complainant that the appellant struck her in her mouth and caused her left upper incisor tooth to fall out is sufficiently proved through witness testimony and medical evidence – The same falls squarely within the definition of ‘grievous hurt’ given in s.320, IPC viz. fracture or dislocation of a bone or tooth – Conviction of the appellant altered to one u/s.325, IPC. [Paras 10-12]
Evidence – Lack of Test Identification Parade, when not fatal – Plea of the appellant that his identity was not established, as the incident occurred at night, the faces of the assailants were admittedly covered, no Test Identification Parade was conducted, the appellant was shown to the witnesses by the police after his arrest, and the complainant’s husband as well as her daughter stated in cross-examination that the assailants were not previously known to them:
Held: Courts below have already comprehensively considered these circumstances and were quite justified in treating the identification of the appellant as satisfactorily proven – FIR was lodged at 1:50 a.m., within four hours of the incident, though it occurred late at night – The complainant (PW-1) categorically identified the appellant, stated his name and place of residence, the nature and manner of their prior acquaintance – She reiterated this in her examination-in-chief and cross-examination – Her daughter (PW-2) and her husband (PW-6), the injured eyewitnesses, corroborated her identification – Her husband also stated that the appellant used to visit their village to meet his relatives – Moreover, the act that the complainant attributed to the appellant was that he sat close to her on the cot and threatened and assaulted her – The entire incident is said to have lasted about an hour, and multiple witnesses have stated that the bulb of the porch was switched on at the time – Therefore, the High Court rightly found that the complainant could not be disbelieved on the point of the appellant’s identification – In these circumstances, the lack of a Test Identification Parade cannot be fatal either. [Paras 6, 7]
As published in the Supreme Court Reports, Supreme Court of India. Headnotes prepared by: Divya Pandey. Text from the Indian Supreme Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs), CC BY 4.0.
As listed in the Supreme Court Reports. Linked where the judgment is on LegalFirms.in.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong? Request a review