Keep judgments in folders, mark the paragraphs you rely on, and print a compilation with an index. It comes with the Research and Advocate Pro judgment plans and with a campus licence. Sign in · See the plans
Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 (POCSO Act) – s.6 – Conviction under, when not justified – Appellant was accused of the offence punishable u/s.6 for allegedly subjecting the specially abled minor victim to sexual assault – Convicted and sentenced by trial Court – Appeal thereaginst rejected by High Court – Interference with: Held: Prosecution failed to establish the guilt of the appellant beyond reasonable doubt – Evidence brought on record falls woefully short of the standard required for sustaining the conviction of the accused appellant – Cumulative effect of unnatural conduct of victim’s mother (PW-1) coupled with the significant delay in lodging the FIR; failure of the victim (PW-4) and her cousin (PW-2) to identify the appellant before the Court; contradictory versions regarding the relationship of the accused-appellant with the victim’s family; non-examination of the school teacher (Ms. ‘P’-a material witness) and; the defence evidence indicating that the appellant had gone to another village in connection with a property transaction, creates serious doubt on the genuineness and credibility of the prosecution allegations – It is wholly unsafe to sustain the conviction of the appellant – Courts below clearly fell in error in relying upon the wavering testimony of the informant (PW-1), her niece (PW-2) and the victim-child witness (PW-4) to convict the appellant and in affirming his conviction in appeal – Findings recorded by the Courts below are unsustainable in law, set aside – Judgment of conviction and order of sentence passed by the trial court and impugned judgment of the High Court, set aside – Appellant acquitted by giving him the benefit of doubt. [Paras 61-64]
Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 (POCSO Act) – Testimony of the victim, when cannot be relied upon: Held: The victim was a mentally challenged girl and as such, a certain degree of latitude would have to be given while appreciating her evidence – However, even after giving due deference to her weak mental disposition, there was a complete failure of the victim to identify the accused-appellant before the Court – Admittedly, the prosecution could not present any scientific corroboration for the incident as the FIR itself was lodged after 10 days of the incident – Therefore, it would be unsafe to rely upon the testimony of the victim to sustain the conviction of the accused – On a thorough analysis of the evidence, the conduct of PW-1 is found to be very unnatural – She had been told by her own niece (PW-2) that her daughter i.e., the victim herein who was mentally impaired, had been subjected to rape – However, the mother, i.e., PW-1 did not give much credence to this complaint of PW-2 – The concern of a mother on receiving such complaint would be expected to be heightened as the child was suffering from mental deficiency – This disability factor of the child would definitely have made the mother more wary and a serious complaint of sexual assault on the child would not have been brushed aside so casually only because the child did not confirm that she had been subjected to any such assault – If at all there had been any iota of truth in the theory that PW-2 had informed PW-1 about the incident, then, she being the mother of the child, would be expected to at least check her physical condition and to be specific, the genital area – Hence, on a perusal of the evidence of the informant (PW-1), grave discrepancies are apparent regarding the source of information of the alleged occurrence received by the informant; the hesitation shown by the informant in taking any action despite the fact that her own niece had informed her about the incident; the refusal of the victim to divulge about the sexual assault despite persistent questioning and the omission to mention this fact in the FIR – These are material aspects carrying significance affecting the credibility of the prosecution case. [Paras 32, 33, 48] FIR – Not an encyclopaedia however, where a circumstance subsequently relied upon constitutes a material incriminating fact forming the very foundation of the prosecution case, its omission from the earliest version assumes considerable significance:
Held: A material improvement made during the course of trial, particularly on a circumstance sought to connect the accused with the alleged occurrence, necessarily calls for closer judicial scrutiny – If such omission remains unexplained, the subsequent version may lose much of its evidentiary fervour – Prosecution placed strong reliance upon the circumstance that PW-1 had allegedly seen the accused-appellant in the garden adjoining her house immediately before leaving for Sutanga – Significantly, this material allegation finds no mention whatsoever in the FIR (Exh. 2), despite the fact that the FIR was lodged after a delay of 10 days – Equally significant is the omission to mention in the FIR that PW-2 had allegedly informed PW-1 about the incident on the very next day of the alleged occurrence – Had these facts actually transpired in the manner sought to be projected during trial, there was no reason why they would not have found place in the FIR – These omissions assume considerable significance and the subsequent improvements made by the first informant (PW-1) during the course of evidence render her testimony highly doubtful and unsafe to rely upon. [Paras 51, 54] Evidence Act, 1872 – s.106 – Plea that the accused-appellant was last seen by the informant (PW-1) in the garden adjoining her house and, therefore, the burden shifted upon him u/s.106: Held: Said contention is absolutely farfetched and unconvincing – The theory of last seen seems to be a material improvement from the version as set out in the highly belated FIR (Exh. 2), wherein no such allegation is levelled – Even according to the version of PW-1 in her sworn testimony, she merely saw the accused plucking mulberry leaves in the garden before she left for Sutanga – She nowhere stated that the victim was present with the accused or that both of them were seen together at any point of time – Thus, the testimony of PW-1 does not establish the circumstance of the accused and the victim having been last seen together and hence there is no question of shifting the burden of proof on the accused by virtue of s.106 – Further, if the informant (PW-1) had in fact seen the accused-appellant in the vicinity of her house on the relevant day and, on the very next morning, her niece (PW-2) had informed her about the incident, it is difficult to comprehend why she would hesitate in approaching the police immediately – The conduct of the informant in not taking any prompt action and not even physically checking her own daughter for signs of sexual assault despite allegedly receiving such information from her own niece, is a circumstance which creates a serious doubt on the truthfulness of the prosecution story. [Paras 49, 50]
Evidence – Withholding of a material witness – Effect: Held: Prosecution withheld a material witness, namely, Ms. ‘P’, the school teacher, whose disclosure admittedly prompted PW-1 to lodge the FIR – No explanation was offered by the prosecution for her non-examination as a witness – The omission to examine such an important witness assumes considerable significance in the facts of the present case – What exactly was the disclosure made by the child to her teacher would definitely be a material fact and the withholding thereof effects the veracity of the prosecution case – Though the prosecution is not obliged to examine each and every witness cited during investigation, it is unquestionably under a duty to examine those witnesses whose evidence goes to the root of the matter and is essential to elicit the truth – Where a material witness, capable of throwing light on the genesis of the occurrence is withheld without any plausible explanation, the Court would be justified in drawing adverse inference against the prosecution, particularly when such witness occupies a pivotal position in the chain of events – Ms. ‘P’, the school teacher, was undeniably a material witness – In the specific facts of the present case, this omission assumes considerable significance and an adverse inference is drawn against the prosecution. [Paras 56, 57, 59]
Evidence – Testimony of Medical Jurists, when cannot be relied upon:
Held: Testimony of the Medical Jurist (PW-3) remained untested by cross-examination, as no effective opportunity to cross examine the witness was given to the accused whose defence counsel was absent on that day – Though, the partial deposition of PW-3 indicates that the victim had sustained injuries on her genital region suggestive of sexual assault but the fact remains that the testimony of the witness remained untested in crossexamination, not on account of any waiver by the accused, but because the defence counsel was unavailable on the date when the witness entered the witness-box – Another medical officer examined by the prosecution was PW-8 – During the course of recording the evidence of the said witness, the trial court did not even offer the opportunity of cross-examination to the defence counsel – Hence, the testimony of both medical jurists cannot be read in evidence as the defence was not given an effective opportunity of cross-examining both the witnesses (PW-3 & PW-8). [Paras 41, 42]
As published in the Supreme Court Reports, Supreme Court of India. Headnotes prepared by: Divya Pandey. Text from the Indian Supreme Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs), CC BY 4.0.
As listed in the Supreme Court Reports. Linked where the judgment is on LegalFirms.in.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong? Request a review