The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
14. A perusal of the orders does not reflect that the Petitioner was guilty of adopting any delaying tactics. In fact, this was neither the contention of the learned Counsel for the Respondent nor the opinion of the learned District Judge. Time should not be granted as a matter of routine and merely for the asking. However, when the learned District Judge has considered those grounds and thought it fit to grant extension of time again and again the same cannot be said to be gross negligence while considering the application for condonation of delay filed subsequently. While considering the application it was necessary for the learned District Judge to have taken into account the fact, as reflected in the various orders, that the Court had considered each of the said grounds for extension on each separate occasion and granted the same. If sufficient cause is shown or is reflected in the records of the case a more liberal approach must be adopted to ensure that a party in the adversarial system of justice dispensation is not denied the opportunity of participating in it. This Court is therefore, unable to agree with the conclusion that there has been an inordinate delay and the reasons are unacceptable. delay cannot be attributable to The the Petitioner alone. Sufficient cause for condoning the delay was also reflected in the orders passed by the learned District Judge. The learned S…
15. In view of the aforesaid, the Civil Revision Petition No. 02 of 2019 is allowed. The impugned order dated 22.08.2018 is set aside. The learned District Judge shall accept the Senior Branch Manager, Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. v. Managing Director Sikkim Power Development Co. Ltd. (SPDCL) C.R.P. No. 02 of 2019 written statement filed on 15.06.2018 and proceed with the case in accordance with the law.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Senior Branch Manager,
Oriental Insurance Company Ltd.
v.
Managing Director Sikkim Power Development Co.
Ltd. (SPDCL)
C.R.P. No. 02 of 2019
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM: GANGTOK
(Civil Revisional Jurisdiction)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH: THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, JUDGE
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
C.R.P. No. 02 of 2019
Senior Branch Manager,
Oriental Insurance Company Ltd.,
M.G. Marg, Gangtok, East Sikkim.
… Petitioner
Versus
Managing Director,
Sikkim Power Development Co. Ltd. (SPDCL),
Near STNM Hospital, National Highway,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
…. Respondent
-------------------------------------------------------------------------Application under Section 115 read with Section 151 of
the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 and Article 227
of the Constitution of India.
Appearance:
Mr. Manish Kumar Jain, Advocate for the Petitioner.
Mr. Sudhir Prasad, Advocate for the Respondent.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------J U D G M E N T (O R A L)
(25.07.2019)
Bhaskar Raj Pradhan, J
1.
This is a Civil Revision Petition filed by the Petitioner
(defendant
in
the
suit)
challenging
an
order
dated
22.08.2018 (impugned order) passed by the learned District
Judge, Special Division-II at Gangtok (learned District
Judge) in Money Suit No. 30 of 2017 (the suit) by which the
Senior Branch Manager,
Oriental Insurance Company Ltd.
v.
Managing Director Sikkim Power Development Co.
Ltd. (SPDCL)
C.R.P. No. 02 of 2019
application under Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963 (the
application) filed by the Petitioner seeking condonation of the
delay in filing written statement was rejected.
2.
The learned District Judge was of the view that the
delay was inordinate and the explanation unacceptable. In
the learned District Judge’s opinion apart from gross
negligence and laxity there is nothing to suggest that the
Petitioner could not file the written statement in spite of its
best efforts.
3.
Order VIII Rule 1 of the CPC is the relevant provision
and reads as under:
“ORDER VIII
1. Written statement.- The defendant shall, within
thirty days from the date of service of summons on
him, present a written statement of his defence:
Provided that where the defendant fails to file the
written statement within the said period of thirty
days, he shall be allowed to file the same on such
other day, as may be specified by the Court, for
reasons to be recorded in writing, but which shall not
be later than ninety days from the date of service of
summons.”
4.
The
defendant
is
required
to
present
a
written
statement of his defence within a period of 30 days from the
service of summons on him. Where the defendants fails to
Senior Branch Manager,
Oriental Insurance Company Ltd.
v.
Managing Director Sikkim Power Development Co.
Ltd. (SPDCL)
C.R.P. No. 02 of 2019
file the written statement within the said period of 30 days,
he shall be allowed to file the same on such other day, as
may be specified by the Court, for reasons to be recorded in
writing, but which shall not be later than 90 days from the
date of service of summons.
5.
The provision quoted above has been examined by the
Supreme Court in its various judgments and is no longer res
integra. The learned Counsel for the Petitioner relied upon in
re: Kailash v. Nanhku & Ors.1; Salem Advocate Bar
Association, T.N. v. Union of India2 and Zolba v. Keshao &
Ors.3. The learned District Judge has also referred to the
judgment of the Supreme Court in re: Kailash (supra).
6.
The ratio of the above judgments is that the provision is
procedural and directory. It would be open to the Court to
permit the defendant to file his written statement beyond the
prescribed period of 30 days and 90 days if exceptional
circumstances have been made out.
7.
In fact Mr. Sudhir Prasad, learned Counsel for the
Respondent (Plaintiff in the suit) was also of the view that
written statement can be accepted by the Court beyond the
time permitted only in exceptional circumstances. It was his
case that such of the facts placed before the learned District
1 (2005) 4 SCC 480
2 (2005) 6 SCC 344
3 (2008) 11 SCC 769
Senior Branch Manager,
Oriental Insurance Company Ltd.
v.
Managing Director Sikkim Power Development Co.
Ltd. (SPDCL)
C.R.P. No. 02 of 2019
Judge could not be considered as exceptional. The learned
Counsel for the Respondent also submitted that the
Petitioner had failed to explain the delay day to day.
8.
Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963 has conferred the
power to condone delay in order that the Courts could do
substantial justice. The expression “sufficient cause” is
sufficiently elastic. The Supreme Court has been adopting a
justifiable liberal approach while examining cases for
condonation of delay. The doctrine of seeking day to day
explanation of the delay must be applied in a pragmatic
manner and the Court should not have a pedantic approach.
Substantial
justice
must
be
preferred
to
technical
considerations. The Court must avoid any presumption that
the delay is deliberate and the negligence culpable. A justice
oriented approach would be the right approach in examining
whether or not to condone delay.
9.
In an adversarial system, no party should ordinarily be
denied the opportunity of participating in the process of
justice dispensation. Therefore, it has also been held in re:
Zolba (supra) that unless compelled by express and specific
language of the statute, the provisions of Order VIII Rule 1
CPC should not be construed in a manner, which would lead
the Court helpless to meet extraordinarily situation in the
ends of justice.
Senior Branch Manager,
Oriental Insurance Company Ltd.
v.
Managing Director Sikkim Power Development Co.
Ltd. (SPDCL)
C.R.P. No. 02 of 2019
10. Having examined the law it would be necessary to
consider the facts relevant for the disposal of the present
petition. These facts are not in dispute.
11. On 27.10.2017 the Petitioner was served the summons
from the Court. 30 days for filing the written statement would
thus end on 26.11.2017. If the proviso to Order VIII Rule 1 of
the CPC was to be applied the 90 days period would expire on
25.01.2018. Admittedly, no application for extension of time
was filed by the Petitioner on or before the expiry of the 30
days period i.e. 26.11.2017. Nevertheless, the record of the
orders passed by the learned District Judge reflects that on
30.10.2017 time was granted to the Petitioner to file written
statement
on
or
before
13.11.2017.
The
order
dated
13.11.2017 reflects that the Advocate for the Petitioner
sought time for filing written statement till 18.11.2017 on the
ground that the conducting Counsel was mourning the death
of a close relative. The ground was considered and time was
granted till 18.11.2017 by the learned District Judge. On
28.11.2017 the Petitioner was represented by a proxy
advocate who pleaded that the advocate for the Petitioner had
to suddenly go out of station to attend important matters and
sought further time to file the written statement. This ground
was also considered and time granted till 18.12.2017. The
order dated 18.12.2017 reflects that the advocate for the
Senior Branch Manager,
Oriental Insurance Company Ltd.
v.
Managing Director Sikkim Power Development Co.
Ltd. (SPDCL)
C.R.P. No. 02 of 2019
Petitioner was not present and notice was issued to the
Petitioner returnable on 13.02.2018. On 13.02.2018 the
advocates for the parties sought adjournment as the matter
was likely to be amicably settled. Accordingly time was
granted till 28.02.2018. On 28.02.2018 the advocate for the
Petitioner expressed her intention to retire from the case.
However, since the Petitioner was absent the retirement was
not considered on the date and the Petitioner was directed to
appear on 09.03.2018. On 09.03.2018 the advocate for the
Petitioner submitted that she had informed the Petitioner
about her intention to retire but no intimation has been
received from the Petitioner. The learned District Judge
considered and issued notice to the Petitioner returnable on
15.03.2018. On 15.03.2018 as notice to the Petitioner had
not returned, on the request of the advocate for the
Respondent, a fresh notice was issued. On 04.04.2018
another advocate filed his vakalatnama and prayed for a short
date to take appropriate steps in the matter which was
considered and granted till 11.04.2018. On 11.04.2018 the
advocate for the Petitioner sought for further time to take
steps as he was out of station and necessary instructions
from the Petitioner could not be obtained. The same was
considered by the learned District Judge and time was
granted till 17.04.2018. On 17.04.2018 an application for
Senior Branch Manager,
Oriental Insurance Company Ltd.
v.
Managing Director Sikkim Power Development Co.
Ltd. (SPDCL)
C.R.P. No. 02 of 2019
adjournment was filed by the advocate for the Petitioner on
the ground that the Branch Manager was out of station and
hence he could not take instructions for taking steps. This
was also considered and allowed by the learned District Judge
but as a final opportunity. The matter was posted to
03.05.2018 for taking steps. On 03.05.2018 the advocate for
the Petitioner sought for further time on the same ground
that the Branch Manager has been out of station since the
month before. The learned District Judge imposed cost but
considered the oral prayer and granted time till 19.05.2018.
On 19.05.2018 the advocates for the Petitioner expressed
their desire to retire from the case due to personal reasons.
The reasons were considered and the advocates were allowed
to withdraw their vakalatnama. The advocates for the
Petitioner undertook to inform the Petitioner about the next
date of hearing which was posted on 05.06.2018. On
05.06.2018 yet another advocate appeared on behalf of the
Petitioner and undertook to file his vakalatnama on the next
date. The advocate for the Petitioner sought a weeks’ time to
file application seeking leave to file the written statement. The
matter was posted to 15.06.2018 after the learned District
Judge considered and allowed the Petitioner’s prayer for
further time. On 15.06.2018 the advocate for the Petitioner
filed the application for condonation of delay and prayed that
Senior Branch Manager,
Oriental Insurance Company Ltd.
v.
Managing Director Sikkim Power Development Co.
Ltd. (SPDCL)
C.R.P. No. 02 of 2019
the written statement as well as counter claim may be placed
on record. The Respondent sought time to file objection to the
application
and
the
matter
was
therefore
posted
to
05.07.2018. On 05.07.2018 an adjournment was sought for
by the Respondent as the reply could not be filed. This was
considered and allowed and the matter posted to 21.07.2018.
On 21.07.2018 the Petitioner once again sought time on the
personal ground of the Respondent’s advocate which was
considered and time allowed till 09.08.2018. On 09.08.2018
the application for condonation of delay was heard at length
and matter posted for orders on 22.08.2018 on which date
the impugned order rejecting the application for condonation
of delay was passed by the learned District Judge.
12.
The orders reflect that on every occasion time was
sought on various grounds, considered and granted by the
learned District Judge. It also reveals that during this period
several advocates came on record on behalf of the Petitioner
and retired with the leave of the Court.
13. Some of these facts have been narrated in the
application. In any case these facts are clearly reflected in
the orders passed by the learned District Judge from time to
time. The same have been placed on record in the present
proceedings with the leave of the Court. The Petitioner has
also pleaded in the application that they had entrusted the
Senior Branch Manager,
Oriental Insurance Company Ltd.
v.
Managing Director Sikkim Power Development Co.
Ltd. (SPDCL)
C.R.P. No. 02 of 2019
matter for defending its case to various advocates but due to
communication gap and lack of instructions the Petitioner
was not able to file the written statement. A perusal of the
said orders reflect that each of the advocates save the last
retired from the case before getting a firm grip of the case.
The records also reveal that time was sought for filing
written statement more on the personal grounds of the
learned advocates for the Petitioner. In the confusion of the
advocate seeking time to take necessary steps and in not
being able to do so due to their personal reasons time which
started running did not stop and in the process there has
been an admitted delay of 138 days. The learned District
Judge has calculated the period between 27.10.2017 and
15.06.2018 i.e. the day the Petitioner filed the written
statement and subtracted 90 days there from to arrive at the
figure of 138 days delay. The learned District Judge has not
considered the fact that time for filing written statement had
been extended by the Court after considering the grounds on
several dates till 05.06.2018. Thereafter the learned District
Judge had granted time to the Petitioner to file application
for condonation of delay on 15.06.2018. Pursuant thereto
time was granted to the Respondent to file objections till
09.08.2018.
Senior Branch Manager,
Oriental Insurance Company Ltd.
v.
Managing Director Sikkim Power Development Co.
Ltd. (SPDCL)
C.R.P. No. 02 of 2019
14. A perusal of the orders does not reflect that the
Petitioner was guilty of adopting any delaying tactics. In fact,
this was neither the contention of the learned Counsel for
the Respondent nor the opinion of the learned District
Judge. Time should not be granted as a matter of routine
and merely for the asking. However, when the learned
District Judge has considered those grounds and thought it
fit to grant extension of time again and again the same
cannot be said to be gross negligence while considering the
application for condonation of delay filed subsequently.
While considering the application it was necessary for the
learned District Judge to have taken into account the fact,
as reflected in the various orders, that the Court had
considered each of the said grounds for extension on each
separate occasion and granted the same. If sufficient cause
is shown or is reflected in the records of the case a more
liberal approach must be adopted to ensure that a party in
the adversarial system of justice dispensation is not denied
the opportunity of participating in it. This Court is therefore,
unable to agree with the conclusion that there has been an
inordinate delay and the reasons are unacceptable.
delay cannot be attributable
to
The
the Petitioner alone.
Sufficient cause for condoning the delay was also reflected in
the orders passed by the learned District Judge. The learned
Senior Branch Manager,
Oriental Insurance Company Ltd.
v.
Managing Director Sikkim Power Development Co.
Ltd. (SPDCL)
C.R.P. No. 02 of 2019
District has rightly held that the object behind Order VIII
Rule 1 CPC is to curb the mischief of unscrupulous
defendants adopting dilatory tactics, delaying the disposal of
the case much to the chagrin of the Plaintiffs. However, the
record
of
the
unscrupulous
present
dilatory
case
does
not
reflect
tactics
being
adopted
by
such
the
Petitioner. Rightly again the learned District Judge has not
come to a finding that the Petitioner was unscrupulous in its
approach and was adopting dilatory tactics.
retirement
of
advocates
during
the
The frequent
period
when
the
Petitioner was required to file the written statement and the
grant of several extensions beyond the statutory period by
the learned District Judge would make it an exceptional case
in favour of the Petitioner while considering the application.
This Court is satisfied that the reasons pleaded in the
application and also reflected in the various orders passed
by the learned District Judge from time to time in support of
the prayer for extension of time were sufficient. It would also
be in the interest of justice and fairness that the suit is
decided on the merits of the case by permitting the written
statement filed by the Petitioner.
15. In view of the aforesaid, the Civil Revision Petition No.
02 of 2019 is allowed. The impugned order dated 22.08.2018
is set aside. The learned District Judge shall accept the
Senior Branch Manager,
Oriental Insurance Company Ltd.
v.
Managing Director Sikkim Power Development Co.
Ltd. (SPDCL)
C.R.P. No. 02 of 2019
written statement filed on 15.06.2018 and proceed with the
case in accordance with the law.
16. A copy of the judgement shall be forwarded to the Court
of the learned District Judge, Special Division-II at Gangtok
forthwith.
(Bhaskar Raj Pradhan)
Judge
25.07.2019
to/
Approved for reporting: yes.
Internet: yes.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review