The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
15. In the said allegation, the name of petitioner no.3, did not find place. It is to be mentioned that, petitioner no. 3, was only alleged to have entered into a agreement with the husband of the informant with regard to tenancy agreement. There are otherwise no allegations against the petitioner no.3. Further in the charge-sheet, laid in pursuance of the said case had not mentioned any allegations to have been established against the petitioner no.3. As such, the FIR registered as Khatkhati P. S. Case No. 220/2021, the Chargesheet being, Charge-sheet No. 8/2022, dated. 30.01.2022, as well as the cognizance order dated 25.05.2022, are quashed with regard to the petitioner no. 3.
16. However, in case of petitioner nos. 1 & 2, there are allegations that both of them had abused and forced her to vacate the place. Although the same allegations of cheating was there in the earlier FIR but in the subsequent FIR, more graver allegations were leveled & as such, the offence of 420 of IPC is attracted. As far as allegation under Section 294 of the IPC is concerned, it is not clear from the FIR, as to whether, the vulgar words were stated inside the house or at a place, which is considered as a public place as per various Supreme Court’s judgments. Further, as far as offence under Section 509 of the IPC is concerned, it is seen that allegations were made only against petitioner no. 1, and there is no allegation against petitioner no. 2. As such, the Page No.# 9/9 cognizance taken by the Court of Judicial Magistrate First Class, Bokajan, Karbi Anglong for offence under Section 509 IPC against Petitioner no. 2; is set aside and quashed.
17. In view of the findings and conclusions mentioned hereinabove, this petition is as such, partly allowed and disposed of. Comparing Assistant
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/9
GAHC010181212022
2026:GAU-AS:14287
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : Crl.Pet./920/2022
SELIM UDDIN CHOUDHURY AND 2 ORS.
S/O LATE BASIR ALI
R/O LAHORIJAN,
NEAR KARBI ANGLONG TAX GATE, P.S. KHATKHATI, DIST KARBI
ANGLONG, ASSAM
2: MRS. RUKIA BEGUM
W/O MD. SELIM UDDIN CHOUDHURY
R/O LAHORIJAN
NEAR KARBI ANGLONG TAX GATE
P.S. KHATKHATI
DIST. KARBI ANGLONG
ASSAM
3: MISS. AYESHA BEGUM CHOUDHURY
D/O MD. SELIM UDDIN CHOUDHURY
R/O LAHORIJAN
NEAR KARBI ANGLONG TAX GATE
P.S. KHATKHATI
DIST. KARBI ANGLONG
ASSA
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND ANR.
REP. BY THE PP, ASSAM
2:SMTI. JORINA BEGUM
W/O MD. ABDUL KALAM
R/O LAHARIJAN NEAR KARBI ANGLONG TOOL TAX GATE
P.S. KHATKHATI
DIST. KARBI ANGLONG
Page No.# 2/9
ASSA
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR. P K MUNIR, MR. A GAYAN
Advocate for the Respondent : PP, ASSAM, MR. S ROY,M. HOSSAIN,MR. M H LASKAR
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE SHAMIMA JAHAN
ORDER
Date : 25.09.2026
Heard Mr. P. K. Munir, learned counsel for the petitioner and Mr. B. Sarma,
learned APP for the State.
2.
By this application filed under section 482 of this CrPC, read with article
226 of the Constitution of India, petitioners have prayed for setting aside and
quashing of the P.R.C Case No. 117 of 2022, corresponding to G.R. Case No.
595/2021. The petitioner has also prayed for setting aside and quashing of the
order of cognizance dated 25-05-2022, passed in the said PRC case as well as
the subsequent orders.
3.
The case of the petitioner is that, an FIR was lodged on 24-07-2021 by
one Jarina Bengum before the Officer-in-Charge of Khatkhati Police Station
stating inter alia that, the petitioners had cheated her, first by offering her to
help in releasing her husband who was in Diphu jail and secondly, by taking her
signatures on many blank papers including Non-Judicial paper and also by
taking cash to an amount of Rs. 10,000/- (Rupees Ten Thousand) with the
Page No.# 3/9
promise that they will get her husband released from jail. It is also stated in the
said FIR, that the petitioner no.1 had threatened her to leave the place
considering her as a tenant. She further stated that, the petitioner no. 1, is not
her landlord and that she is a tenant of one Shri Tahjul Islam and the tenancy
agreement has been entered into with said Tahjul Islam by her husband.
4.
She also stated that she was surprised when she got a legal notice on 23-
07-2021 through the advocate of petitioner no.1, directing her to vacate his
house. She stated that, many documents were taken from her on the pretext of
getting her husband out of jail and she suspects that one of such documents
was used and a fraud agreement was made between petitioner no. 3 and her
husband.
5.
On receipt of the FIR, the police registered the case as Khatkhati PS Case
No. 134/2029, under section 120(B) as well as 420 of IPC.
6.
On completion of the investigation, the police, upon finding no evidence to
connect the accused person with the offence, had submitted a final report on
31-08-2021, vide Final Report No. 48/2021. In the said final report, it was
stipulated that the Investigating Officer tried to get witnesses against the
accused, but no witnesses and no evidence was found.
7.
It was stipulated further that a verbal argument might have taken place
Page No.# 4/9
between the petitioners
and the informant, which is not known by any
person and as such, final report was submitted.
8.
The Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that, pursuant to the
submission of the final report, the concerned court had given notice to the
informant but the informant had not filed any protest petition and that, she did
not appear before the court and the court had accepted the final report, vide
order dated 15-10-2022. Thereafter, the learned counsel
for the petitioner
submits that after the final report was submitted and before the final report was
accepted by the court, the informant had filed another FIR before the
Superintendent of Police, Diphu, Karbi Anglong, stating the same facts, that she
had stated in the first FIR along with certain additional facts to the effect that,
on 20-10-2021, some workers had come to her house to repair certain things
and that the petitioner no.1 and his wife had threatened the said workers to
leave the place immediately. It was also alleged in the FIR that petitioner no.1,
had threatened her in various ways to withdraw the complaint or else he will
trap her in some false case. It was also stated that petitioner no.1, used to
come to her room and abuse her with vulgar words in front of her children and
in absence of her husband.
9.
On receipt of the said FIR, the police registered the case as Khatkhati PS
Page No.# 5/9
Case No. 220/2021 under section 420, 294 as well as 509 of IPC. On completion
of the investigation, the police submitted charge-sheet in connection with
the said case on 31-20-2022, vide Charge-sheet No. 8/2022. In the said Chargesheet, it was stipulated that a prima facie case is established against the
petitioners, who are three in numbers and the said Charge-sheet was
submitted. Thereafter, the Charge-sheet was submitted before the SDJM
Bokajan Karbi Anglong, who had transferred the case to the Judicial Magistrate
First Class, Bokajan Karbi Anglong, and the court of JMFC, Bokajan Karbi
Anglong first class, vide order dated 25-05-2022, took cognizance of the offence
under Sections 420, 294 as well as 509 of IPC against the petitioners.
10.
The learned counsel for the petitioner had further placed the order sheets,
which reflects that on 02.05.2026, the present case was taken up for charge
framing but the Court fixed the next hearing date as 02.06.2026, and the matter
rested at that and a further date was fixed on 02.11.2026.
11.
The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that, as far as offence
under Section 420 IPC is concerned, same allegations were written in the
previous FIR, dated 24.07.2021, which resulted in Final Report as stated above.
With regard to the offence under Section 294 of the IPC, the counsel submits
that, although there are allegations that petitioner no. 1 had shouted at her by
Page No.# 6/9
using vulgar words but the same was not in public place, which is the
mandatory requirements under the said section and as such, he submits that
the said offence is not attracted in the instant case. Further with regard to the
offence under Section 509 of the IPC, the learned counsel submits that, the
specific allegation is only against the petitioner no. 1, who is stated to have
threatened her in various ways to withdraw the complaint or that he will trap
her in some false case. He submits that, there is no outraging of modesty of the
informant by the petitioner nos. 2 & 3.
12.
On the other hand, the learned counsel appearing for the State, Mr. B.
Sarma, submits that, the ingredients of Sections 420, 294, 509 of IPC, are
present in the complaint lodged by the informant. He also submits that, the
cognizance of the offence taken under the said Section was based on materials
on record and as such, he submits that, there is no question of quashing of the
said case along with the cognizance order.
13.
I have heard, the learned counsels and gone through the records. It is
seen that the First FIR lodged by the informant, namely, Jarina Bengum, which
was registered under Sections 120(B)/420 of the IPC, resulted in final report
submitted by the police, vide Final Report No. 48/2021, dated 31/08/2021. In
the said final report, it was stated that, no evidence was found and although,
Page No.# 7/9
there could be some verbal argument between petitioners and the informant,
but the same was stated to have not been heard by any witness and as such,
the case was dropped against the petitioners.
14.
It is thereafter, seen that same allegations were made against the
petitioners in the second complaint lodged before the Superintendent of Police,
Diphu, Karbi Anglong, Assam, which were stated in the First FIR. The contents
which were present in both the FIRs relating to the offence of cheating under
Section 420 IPC, is not maintainable. However, the further allegations that were
made in the subsequent FIR, calls for examination. It is a settled position of law
that, a second FIR relating to the said cause of action, if discloses graver
offence can be taken into account and registered.
15.
In the instant case, it is seen that in the second FIR, it was stated that,
petitioner nos. 1 & 2, came over to the place of the informant with weapons and
forced the workers working in her house to leave the place. It was also stated
that petitioner nos. 1 & 2 had abused her verbally to vacate the place. It was
also stated that petitioner no. 1, as was referred in the complaint as “this
person” had threatened her to withdraw the complaint or otherwise he will trap
her in some false case. It is also stated that petitioner no. 1, had made her life a
hell and used to enter her room and abuse her with vulgar words.
Page No.# 8/9
15.
In the said allegation, the name of petitioner no.3, did not find place. It is
to be mentioned that, petitioner no. 3, was only alleged to have entered into a
agreement with the husband of the informant with regard to tenancy
agreement. There are otherwise no allegations against the petitioner no.3.
Further in the charge-sheet, laid in pursuance of the said case had not
mentioned any allegations to have been established against the petitioner no.3.
As such, the FIR registered as Khatkhati P. S. Case No. 220/2021, the Chargesheet being, Charge-sheet No. 8/2022, dated. 30.01.2022, as well as the
cognizance order dated 25.05.2022, are quashed with regard to the petitioner
no. 3.
16.
However, in case of petitioner nos. 1 & 2, there are allegations that both
of them had abused and forced her to vacate the place. Although the same
allegations of cheating was there in the earlier FIR but in the subsequent FIR,
more graver allegations were leveled & as such, the offence of 420 of IPC is
attracted. As far as allegation under Section 294 of the IPC is concerned, it is
not clear from the FIR, as to whether, the vulgar words were stated inside the
house or at a place, which is considered as a public place as per various
Supreme Court’s judgments. Further, as far as offence under Section 509 of the
IPC is concerned, it is seen that allegations were made only against petitioner
no. 1, and there is no allegation against petitioner no. 2. As such, the
Page No.# 9/9
cognizance taken by the Court of Judicial Magistrate First Class, Bokajan, Karbi
Anglong for offence under Section 509 IPC against Petitioner no. 2; is set aside
and quashed.
17.
In view of the findings and conclusions mentioned hereinabove, this
petition is as such, partly allowed and disposed of.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review