Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Form No.J(2)
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Civil Appellate Jurisdiction
Appellate Side
Present : The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya
&
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Supratim Bhattacharya
W.P.L.R.T. 218 of 2025
Sekh Abdul Selim and Anr.
Vs.
The State of West Bengal and Ors.
For the petitioners
:
Mr. M. A. Samad,
Mr. Taher Ahamad,
Ms. Priyanka Sharma, Advs.
For the respondents
:
Sk. Md. Galib, Ld. Snr. Govt. Adv.
Heard on
:
February 9, 2026.
Judgment on
:
February 9, 2026.
Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya , J.:
1. Affidavit of service filed today be kept on record.
2.
The present challenge has been preferred against an order
dated November 14, 2025, whereby the West Bengal Land
Reforms and Tenancy Tribunal dismissed MA 1066 of 2025,
which was an application made by the writ petitioners for
review of the earlier order dated July 11, 2025 passed by the
Tribunal.
3.
The brief background of the case is that the vendor of the
present petitioners had taken out an application, upon
acquiring the subject property in the year 2008, for mutation in
the name of the said vendor. Such mutation was granted.
Subsequently, a sanction plan was also obtained by the said
vendor from the appropriate authority for raising a construction
on the subject plots.
4.
Thereafter, when an application for rectification of the
recording of the subject plot as “doba” was made by the said
vendor of the present writ petitioners, the D.L. & L.R.O.
concerned permitted the vendor to apply for conversion, upon
which a conversion application was made before the
concerned B.L. & L.R.O., giving rise to Conversion Cases No.
1040 and 1041 of 2021.
5.
However, the matter went up to the Tribunal and by a
judgment dated September 9, 2024 passed in OA 1637 of
2023 (LRTT), the Tribunal, while observing that Rule 166 of
the West Bengal Land and Land Reforms Manual, 1991 was
not applicable, gave liberty to the vendor of the writ petitioners,
nonetheless, to file “appropriate applications before Competent
Authority in accordance with law”.
6.
In the meantime, the present writ petitioners had purchased
the property and applied before the concerned District Land
and Land Reforms Officer for regularization of change of
character and/or conversion or alteration in the mode of use of
the plot of land for the purpose of the residential house erected
thereon. The said application was forwarded by the D.L.&
L.R.O. to the concerned B.L.& L.R.O. vide memo no. 9297
dated December 18, 2024.
7.
Subsequently, the B.L. & L.R.O. having sat tight over the
matter, the present writ petitioners took out OA No. 1278 of
2025 before the West Bengal Land Reforms and Tenancy
Tribunal, which was dismissed by an order dated July 11, 2025
on the ground that post-facto regularization of conversion of a
waterbody is not permissible under Section 4C (6) of the West
Bengal Land Reforms Act, 1955. However, the Tribunal also
gave the writ petitioners liberty to file an “appropriate
application before the appropriate authority”.
8.
The writ petitioners took out a review application of the said
order before the Tribunal, which was dismissed by the
impugned judgment dated November 14, 2025.
9.
Being thus aggrieved, the writ petitioners have preferred the
present challenge.
10. Learned counsel for the writ petitioners argues that the land
was all along recorded as a “doba” which, according to the writ
petitioners, is not a water body. Subsequently, without any
rhyme or reason, in the LR Records of Rights, the said subject
plot was referred to as a “pukur” which is a water body. It is
argued that such amendment in the Records of Rights
regarding the nature of the subject plot was unlawful.
11. Secondly,
it is argued that while granting mutation and
sanction plan, the appropriate authority clearly proceeded on
the premise that the land was not a water body. Hence, it is
argued that the Tribunal proceeded on a patently erroneous
premise in observing that there could not be any post-facto
conversion of a water body.
12. Thirdly,
it is contended that the Tribunal itself, on several
occasions, gave liberty to the writ petitioners, and before that
to the writ petitioners’ vendor, to approach the appropriate
authority with a proper application. Thus, it was recognized by
the Tribunal itself that there is an appropriate forum where the
application
for
post-facto
regularization
and/or
original
conversion application could be filed.
13. This
facet of the matter was overlooked by the learned
Tribunal while passing the impugned order.
14. Learned
counsel next argues that Rule 166 of the 1991
Manual is squarely applicable to the present case as well.
15. The learned Senior Government Advocate, appearing for the
State, contends that the initial order of the Tribunal dated
September 9, 2024, whereby OA 1637 of 2023 (LRTT) filed by
the writ petitioners was dismissed on the specific recording
that Rule 166 of the 1991 Manual is not applicable, was never
challenged before any higher forum. Thus, the said order has
attained finality and, accordingly, the subsequent original
application was also not maintainable on the self-same
ground.
16. That
apart, it is argued by the learned Senior Government
Advocate that the present case is squarely covered by the bar
contemplated in Section 4C (6) of the 1955 Act and as such,
post-facto conversion cannot be permitted in respect of a
water body. It is further argued that be it a “doba” or a “pukur”,
the character of the land as a water body cannot be disputed.
17. Upon a careful consideration of the submissions of the parties,
we find several facets involved in the matter. The first question
which arises for consideration is whether the writ petitioners
are debarred by operation of the principle of res judicata from
raising the self-same issue of applicability of Rule 166 of the
1991 Manual after such contention having been turned down
by the judgment dated September 9, 2024 passed in OA 1637
of 2023 (LRTT).
18. However, from a perusal of the said judgment, we find that
although the original application of the writ petitioners was
dismissed, liberty was given to the writ petitioners to file
appropriate applications before the competent authority in
accordance with law.
19. The observation, regarding Rule 166 not being applicable, was
rendered only on the premise that there is nothing appearing
from the records to show that the conversion regarding the
subject plots was made prior to March 24, 1986.
20. As such, it was observed on such footing that there could not
have been any applicability of Rule 166 of the 1991 Manual.
21. However,
the said observation, on a pure question of law,
cannot be said to be binding on the writ petitioners, inasmuch
as, by the observations of the Tribunal, it had only adverted to
one of the facets of Rule 166, as covered by Clause (i) of Rule
166. However, the four criteria stipulated in Clause (ii) of Rule
166 were not dealt with nor adverted to or adjudicated upon by
the said judgment. Thus, the applicability of Clause (ii) of Rule
166 was not covered by the said judgment and the said
judgment does not operate as a res judicata with regard to the
said aspect of the matter.
22. From the factual position as presented before us, we find that
pursuant to the liberty granted by the learned Tribunal at the
first instance, the writ petitioners have taken out an application
for regularization of change of character, conversion or
alternation in the mode of use of the plot of land, thereby
keeping the window open for the concerned authority i.e. the
B.L. & L.R.O. to consider all three aspects of the matter
alternatively.
23. There
may be several scenarios applicable to the present
case.
24. Clause (ii) of Rule 166 of the 1991 Manual contemplates that if
the change in the use of land (a) has occurred in the usual
course of nature, or (b) has occurred at a time when such
change was not unlawful (prior to March 24, 1986), or (c) has
occurred due to development activities of the Government or
of a local body in the surrounding area, or (d) due to
urbanization in the surrounding area, the applicant should be
informed that the change is being noted in the Record-ofRights, and the said record should be corrected accordingly in
due course.
25. Furthermore, (ii) provides that if there was a reasonable cause
made behind the change that occurred, the Collector may
consider on the merits of the fact if post-facto permission
should be granted.
26. Clause (ii) is directly relatable to Clause (i) of Rule 166, which
contemplates the aforesaid consideration being in the context
of disposal of a petition for conversion.
27. Thus, in view of the pendency of the conversion application
before the B.L. & L.R.O. at present at the behest of the writ
petitioners, it is the incumbent duty of the B.L. & L.R.O. to
consider as to whether any of the situations as covered by
Clauses (a) to (d) of Rule 166 (ii) are applicable in the facts
and circumstances of the present case. For example, no
material is before us to indicate as to whether the change in
the use of the land occurred in the usual course of nature or
due to urbanization in the surrounding area. Hence, it was
premature for the learned Tribunal to close the rights of the
writ petitioners, by observing that under Section 4C (6) of the
1955 Act, there was an absolute prohibition on the
regularization of the land which is classified as a water body.
28. Although we
do not subscribe to the submission of learned
counsel for the writ petitioners that a “doba” is not a water
body, fact remains that Section 4C (6) of the 1955 Act is
circumscribed by Rule 166 of the 1991 Manual. Hence, since
the 1991 Manual is a reflection of a policy of the State
Government, the Government itself is bound by the same.
29. Accordingly,
we find that the observations made by the
Tribunal in the impugned judgment, and the judgment of which
review was sought before the Tribunal, cannot debar the writ
petitioners
to
pursue
their
application
for
post-facto
conversion / regularization before the concerned B.L. & L.R.O.
and if so pursued, the said authority is duty-bound to
undertake an enquiry as to whether the matter falls within any
of the provisions as contemplated in Rule 166 (ii), sub-clauses
(a) to (d) of the 1991 Manual.
30. Hence,
WPLRT 218 of 2025 is partially allowed, thereby
modifying the impugned judgment dated November 14, 2025
to the effect that nothing in the said judgment or the judgment
of the Tribunal dated July 11, 2025 passed in OA No. 1278 of
2025 and/or the judgment dated September 9, 2024 passed in
OA No. 1637 of 2023 (LRTT) shall preclude the writ petitioners
from proceeding with their application for regularization of
change of character, conversion or alteration in the mode of
user of the subject plot of land dated November 4, 2024, as
annexed at Page 83 of the present writ petition, before the
concerned B.L.& L.R.O. The concerned B.L. & L.R.O. shall,
upon being communicated the present order, undertake an
independent enquiry as envisaged under Rule 166 of the 1991
Manual, without being influenced by any of the observations
made by the Tribunal, by giving special weight to the
consideration as to whether any of the conditions as
mentioned in Clauses (a) to (d) of Rule 166 (ii) of the West
Bengal Land and Land Reforms Manual, 1991 are applicable
to the present case. In the event it is found that any of such
criteria are satisfied, the Collector/ B.L. & L.R.O. may consider
on the merits of the case if post-facto permission should be
granted.
31. It
is expected that the entire exercise, as per the above
direction, shall be concluded as expeditiously as possible,
preferably within four months from the date of communication
of this order to the concerned B.L. & L.R.O.
32. The parties as well as all concerned shall act on the written
communication of the learned advocates for the parties,
coupled with a server copy of this order, for the purpose of
compliance, without insisting upon prior production of a
certified copy of this order.
33.
There will be no order as to costs.
34. Certified
copies, if applied, for be granted urgently to the
parties.
I agree.
(Supratim Bhattacharya, J.)
AD -4
Ct No.16
09.02.2026
(SSS)
(Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review