Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:23716
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SATHISH NINAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN
THURSDAY, THE 20TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 29TH PHALGUNA, 1946
MAT.APPEAL NO. 1097 OF 2014
AGAINST THE DECREE AND JUDGMENT DATED 29.10.2014 IN
OP
NO.1099 OF 2013 OF FAMILY COURT, MAVELIKKARA (TRANSFERRED
FROM THE FAMILY COURT, ALAPPUZHA AS O.P.NO.151/2012)
APPELLANT/PETITIONER:
SEENA V
W/O. THE LATE PREMKUMAR, KAVILETHU HOUSE, VENMONEY
EAST MURI, VENMONEY VILLAGE, VENMONEY P.O.,
689509, CHENGANNUR TALUK, ALAPPUZHA DISTRICT,
PRESENTLY RESIDING AT INDHU BHAVANAM, PALLICKAL
EAST MURI, THEKKEKARA P.O., 690107, MAVELIKARA
TALUK.
BY ADVS.
SRI.MOHAN JACOB GEORGE
SMT.NIGI GEORGE
SMT.P.V.PARVATHY P-41
SMT.REENA THOMAS
2025:KER:23716
Mat.Appeal No.1097 of 2014
-: 2 :-
RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS 2 TO 5:
ROHINI
AGED 58 YEARS
W/O. N.RAVEENDRAN, KAVILETHU HOUSE, VENMONEY
EAST MURI, VENMONEY VILLAGE, VENMONEY P.O.,
689509, CHENGANNUR TALUK, ALAPPUZHA DISTRICT.
RANI
AGED 35 YEARS
W/O.BIJU, MANI BHAVAN, KARAZHMA MURI,
CHENNITHALA VILLAGE, CHERUKOLE, MAVELIKARA690104.
BIJU
AGED 38 YEARS
S/O. VISWANATHAN, MANI BHAVAN, KARAZHMA MURI,
CHENNITHALA VILLAGE, CHERUKOLE, MAVELIKARA690104.
RAJI
AGED 35 YEARS
W/O. MADHU, KAVILETHU HOUSE, VENMONEY EAST
MURI, VENMONEY VILLAGE, VENMONEY P.O.,
689509,CHENGANNUR TALUK, ALAPPUZHA DISTRICT.
BY ADVS.
SRI.S.ARAVIND
SRI.K.JANARDHANA SHENOY
SRI.R.ROHITH
SRI.K.SASIKUMAR
THIS MATRIMONIAL APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR HEARING ON
20.03.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE
FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:23716
SATHISH NINAN & SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN, JJ.
= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
Mat.Appeal No.1097 of 2014
= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
Dated this the 20th day of March, 2025
JUDGMENT
Sathish Ninan, J.
The original petition filed by the wife before the
Family Court, seeking a declaration that Ext.A5=Ext.B2
Cancellation Deed, cancelling Ext.A4=Ext.B1 Settlement
Deed, is null and void, for declaration of her half
right
over
the
property,
and
for
recovery
of
gold
ornaments, money and movables, was decreed in part.
Challenging that part of the decree which refused the
reliefs sought, she is in appeal.
2.
Premkumar
The marriage of the petitioner-wife with late
was
on
11.05.2010.
Premkumar
died
on
03.10.2011. The respondents in the original petition,
2025:KER:23716
Mat.Appeal No.1097 of 2014
-: 2 :-
who are the respondents in this appeal, are the in-laws
of the petitioner-wife.
3.
According
to
the
petitioner,
after
her
marriage with Premkumar, there was “Adukalakanal”, a
customary function, on 13.05.2010. On that date, the 1 st
respondent(father-in-law) was entrusted with an amount
of
Rs.5,00,000/-
11.06.2010,
a
towards
further
petitioner's
amount
of
share.
On
Rs.3,00,000/-
was
entrusted with the husband towards her share. At the
time of marriage, the petitioner had 20 sovereigns of
gold ornaments; out of the same, 2.5 sovereigns are with
her. The remaining gold ornaments and the money were
misappropriated by the respondents. There is a further
claim for the value of movables allegedly entrusted at
the time of marriage.
4.
the
On 20.09.2011, respondents 1 and 2, namely,
father-in-law
and
the
mother-in-law
of
the
2025:KER:23716
Mat.Appeal No.1097 of 2014
-: 3 :-
petitioner, executed Ext.A4=Ext.B1 Settlement Deed in
favour of their son, Premkumar. On 03.10.2011, Premkumar
committed suicide. On 10.10.2011, respondents 1 and 2
executed
Ext.A5=Ext.B2
Cancellation
Deed,
cancelling
Ext.A4=Ext.B1 Settlement Deed. The petitioner seeks a
declaration that the Cancellation Deed is null and void
and a declaration of her half-right over the property.
5.
The
trial
court
granted
a
decree
for
Rs.3,00,000/- paid on 11.06.2010 and for an amount of
Rs.45,000/- towards the value of movables. The other
claims were disallowed against which this appeal by the
petitioner-wife.
6.
We have heard Shri.Mohan Jacob George, the
learned counsel for the appellant and Shri.K. Sasikumar,
the learned counsel for the respondents.
7.
The points that arise for determination are;
i)
Does the evidence on record prove the entrustment of
2025:KER:23716
Mat.Appeal No.1097 of 2014
-: 4 :-
Rs.5,00,000/- on 13.05.2010, to the respondents, as claimed by the
petitioner?
ii)
Was the Family Court right in having rejected the claim for
gold ornaments, holding that there is lack of evidence to prove the
entrustment of the gold ornaments with the respondent?
iii)
Is the finding of the Family Court that the petitioner has
failed to prove the acceptance of Ext.A4=Ext.B1 Settlement Deed
sustainable on the evidence?
iv)
Does the decree and judgment of the Family Court warrant
interference?
8.
The
marriage
of
the
petitioner
with
late
Premkumar, was solemnised on 11.05.2010. At the time of
marriage, Premkumar was employed abroad at Abu Dhabi,
UAE. It is the claim of the petitioner that, after the
marriage,
on
13.05.2010,
function,
the
1st
during
respondent
the
was
'Adukkalakanal'
entrusted
with
Rs.5,00,000/- towards the petitioner's share. The Family
Court has rejected the claim for lack of evidence. PW4
is the petitioner's uncle. He has deposed that he had
handed
over
the
amount
to
the
1 st
respondent.
To
2025:KER:23716
Mat.Appeal No.1097 of 2014
-: 5 :-
substantiate the payment of such amount, the petitioner
relies on Exts.A16 and A20 documents. They relate to the
redemption
of
various
respondent
after
gold
13.05.2010.
ornaments
by
According
the
1 st
to
the
petitioner, utilising Rs.5,00,000/-, which was gifted to
her on 13.05.2010, the gold ornaments of Premkumar's
sisters, which were under pledge, were redeemed under
Exts.A16 to A21. A perusal of the receipts indicates
that the accounts were closed on various dates. Exts.
A16 and A20 alone were closed on 14.06.2010. The other
accounts were closed much later. The total amount for
Exts.A16 and A20 is only Rs.85,000/-. The mere fact that
the pledge under Exts.A16 to A21 were redeemed after the
date of the alleged entrustment of Rs.5,00,000/- is not
sufficient to establish that the said amount was indeed
entrusted, as claimed by the petitioner. This is all the
more so since, even according to the petitioner, an
2025:KER:23716
Mat.Appeal No.1097 of 2014
-: 6 :-
amount of Rs.3,00,000/- was entrusted as her share to
her husband on 11.06.2010. As held by the Family Court
there
is
no
evidence
to
find
that
an
amount
of
Rs.5,00,000/- was entrusted to the 1 st respondent on
13.05.2010. The said claim was rightly declined by the
Family Court.
9.
Coming
to
the
claim
for
gold
ornaments,
according to the petitioner, at the time of marriage she
had 20 sovereigns of gold ornaments, out of which she
has only 2.5 sovereigns with her. The remaining is
claimed to have been misappropriated by the respondents.
The ornaments were sold and utilised for the renovation
of the residential house and also to redeem the pledges
of gold ornaments, is the case. The fact that at the
time of marriage, the petitioner had 20 sovereigns of
gold ornaments with her, is evidenced by the entry in
Ext.A6
marriage
register
maintained
by
SNDP.
The
2025:KER:23716
Mat.Appeal No.1097 of 2014
-: 7 :-
register was proved through the Secretary of SNDP, who
was examined as PW2. Therefore, the fact that at the
time of marriage, the petitioner had 20 sovereigns of
gold ornaments, has been proved.
10. According to the petitioner, the respondents
had
pledged,
sold,
and
misappropriated
her
gold
ornaments. In the objections filed by the respondents,
the
contention
is
that
the
petitioner
herself
had
pledged and redeemed her ornaments. The learned counsel
for the appellant would submit that the 2 nd respondent,
as RW1, has admitted that the 1 st respondent had pledged
the gold ornaments of the petitioner but had claimed
that it was for and on behalf of the petitioner. The
relevant deposition reads thus;
"ഹർജ കകയ ട
സ ർണ ഭരണങള ൽ 3 സ ർണ വളകൾ 1 ആ
എത ർ കക ടവൺമണ Service Coperative Bank Ltd. ൽ പണയ
ടവച ട ട!ന .
ആയത ന$ട% Receipt
ന$ട% certified
copy
ആണ$.
20/05/2010 ട& Exbt.A17 document എന 26/05/11 ട& Exbt. A18 document
എന
പ%യ ന .
രസ'ത$ ഇത ണ$.
ടമർഷ പ$ ഉളത ടക !$ സ'ന
2025:KER:23716
Mat.Appeal No.1097 of 2014
-: 8 :-
തടനയ ണ$ എത ർ കകടയട- !$ പണയ ടവപ ചത$ . സ'ന തടന
അത$ ത ര ച$ എ - കയ ട/യ1 .”
Evidently, what RW1 has referred to is only 3 bangles.
PW1 deposed that after the death of her husband, she has
redeemed
sovereigns
of
gold
ornaments
from
a
financier. The deposition reads thus,
“Q. chief സത2വ ങ$മ3&ത ൽ വ വര - ന സ ർണ ഭരണങൾ പണയ
വചതല6? A. ഭർത വ
ഏത$
ഭർത വ ന$ട% അചന
സ പനത & ണ$
പണയ
ക3
വചത$?A.
പണയ വച . Q.
എവ ട യ ടണന$
എന -% യ 6. Q. അത ടക !$ പണയ ടവചത ന$ട% ലരഖകൾ ഒന
ഹ ജര - ൻ സ ധ - ല6?A. ഇ6.Q. പണയ ടവച ഏടതങ & ഉര പ
ന ങൾ ത ര ടകടയ ത ട ല! ?A. ല?പ ക മ % ന$ട% മരണ ല@ഷ
അലന ഷ ച$
പവൻ എ ത ട !$.Q.
ആറ ടവള മ ൽ ഫDന ൻസ ലയഴF,$
എവ ട
ടവൺമണ
ന ന യ ര ന ?A.
പവൻ ത ര ടക
എ ത.Q. ബ - എവ ട യ ടണന$ അലന ഷ ലച ?A. ഇ6. ത ര- .
അവ ട 2 പവൻ മ ?തലമ ഉള3.”
If RW1 had pledged her ornaments, the same could be
redeemed only by him and not by the petitioner. It
indicates
that
the
petitioner
had
also
pledged
her
ornaments. Further, after 13.05.2010, there had been
only two pledges under Ext.A17 and A18 and they were
only very small quantities and amounts. Hence, merely
2025:KER:23716
Mat.Appeal No.1097 of 2014
-: 9 :-
referring to RW1’s deposition as above, it could not be
found that the ornaments of the petitioner were pledged
by the 1st respondent. Therefore, we agree with the
Family Court in having negatived the claim.
11. Now, we proceed to deal with Ext.A4=Ext.B1
Settlement Deed and its cancellation under Ext.A5=Ext.B2
Cancellation Deed. The Settlement Deed was executed by
respondents 1 and 2 in favour of their son, Premkumar on
20.09.2011. Premkumar committed suicide on 03.10.2011.
Respondents 1 and 2 executed the Cancellation Deed on
10.10.2011.
According
to
the
petitioner,
the
cancellation of the settlement, which had already taken
effect,
is
null
and
void;
hence,
at
the
time
of
Premkumar's death, the property belonged to him. As a
legal heir, the petitioner is entitled to half share
over the same.
12. The
Family
Court
held
that
the
petitioner
2025:KER:23716
Mat.Appeal No.1097 of 2014
-: 10 :-
failed to prove that the gift was accepted by Premkumar
during his life time. The document was executed on
20.09.2011, and Premkumar died on 03.10.2011. In terms
of Section 122 of the Transfer of Property Act, a gift
needs to be accepted by the donee during his life time.
If the donee dies before acceptance, the gift is void.
There being no evidence to prove the acceptance of the
gift by Premkumar, the gift is void and could have been
validly revoked by the donor. Hence, the Cancellation
Deed is valid, held by the Family Court.
13.
Law
is
well
settled
that,
with
regard
to
acceptance of gift, very little evidence is sufficient,
since a man would only be too eager and willing to
promote his own interests. Even mere knowledge of the
gift would be sufficient to constitute acceptance of the
gift [See: Narayani Bhanumathi & Anr. v. Karthyayani Lelitha Bhai (1973 KLJ
354), K. Balakrishnan v. K. Kamalam And Others (2004 (1) SCC 581), Asokan v.
2025:KER:23716
Mat.Appeal No.1097 of 2014
-: 11 :-
Lakshmikutty and Ors (2007 (13) SCC 210), Bini Anilkumar v. Bhaskaran (2009 (3)
KLT 753), Parameswaran & Ors. v. Lekshaman & Ors. ( 2013 (1) KLT 487), Sulekha
Devi v. Ajith Kumar (2015 SCC OnLine Ker 27053), K. Cherunni v. K. Nalini (2017
SCC OnLine Ker 32010)]. The original of the Settlement Deed
is marked as Ext.B1. A perusal of the same shows that
the stamp paper for the same was purchased by Premkumar.
It
is
not
(petitioner),
disputed
and
that
respondents
Premkumar,
and
2,
his
wife
were
living
together in the same house. Ext.A15 is the final report
with regard to the suicide of Premkumar. It is recorded
therein that there were some disputes in the family
leading to the execution of the Settlement Deed. In the
circumstances, there is no point in contending that
Premkumar was unaware of the gift or that the gift was
not accepted by him. The circumstances as above are
sufficient enough to find that the gift was accepted by
Premkumar. We are unable to agree with the finding of
2025:KER:23716
Mat.Appeal No.1097 of 2014
-: 12 :-
the Family Court to the contrary.
14. Before this Court, the only argument of the
respondents with regard to Ext.A4=Ext.B1 is that no
right in praesenti has been created thereunder. The property
was to vest with the donee only after the death of the
executants (respondents 1 and 2). No right in praesenti
having been created in the document, it is within the
right of the executants to cancel the same, it is
argued. The learned counsel relied on the judgment of
the Apex Court in Kokilambal v. Raman [2005 (11) SCC 234] to
contend that a Settlement Deed with a clause reserving
she right to enjoy the property during the lifetime of
the executant does not create a right in praesenti.
15. On a reading of the Settlement Deed, we are
unable to accept the argument. The recitals in the
document in unambiguous terms affirm transfer of title
and possession of the property under the document, from
2025:KER:23716
Mat.Appeal No.1097 of 2014
-: 13 :-
the date of execution of the document. All that has been
reserved in favour of the executants is the right to
reside in the building and to take income from the
property during their lifetime. Therefore, there is no
merit in the contention that under the document there
has been no transfer of right in praesenti. The judgment in
Kokilambal (supra) was on the recitals in the document in
that case wherein there was no vesting of rights in
praesenti. Therein the Apex Court referred to its earlier
judgment in Namburi Basava Subrahmanyam v. Alapati Hymavathi and others,
[1996 (9) SCC 388] which acknowledged creation of a right in
prasenti when life interest was reserved. It is held,
“It is settled law that the executant while divesting herself of the title to the
property could create a life estate for her enjoyment and the property would
devolve on the settlee with absolute rights on the settlor’s demise”.
The document was held to be a settlement deed and not a
Will.
2025:KER:23716
Mat.Appeal No.1097 of 2014
-: 14 :-
16. In the present case, there has been creation of
rights in praesenti under Ext. A4=B1 Settlement Deed. The
contention to the contrary is only to be repelled and we
do so. Ext.A4=B1 Settlement Deed having been accepted by
Premkumar during his lifetime, it could not have been
cancelled under Ext.A5=Ext.B2. Such Cancellation Deed
cannot affect the title of the donee over the property
and is of no consequence.
17. The title having vested with Premkumar under
the Settlement Deed, on his death, the petitioner-wife
inherits
one-half
share
as
a
legal
heir.
The
petitioner's claim is for such share, which is liable to
be granted. The findings of the Family Court with regard
to the settlement deed and its cancellation are hereby
set aside.
Resultantly, the appeal is allowed in part. The
decree and judgment of the Family Court, insofar as it
2025:KER:23716
Mat.Appeal No.1097 of 2014
-: 15 :-
relates
to
Ext.A4=Ext.B1
Settlement
Deed
and
its
cancellation, are set aside. The petitioner’s title and
possession
over
one-half
of
the
petition
schedule
property is declared. In all other respects, the decree
and judgment of the Family Court will stand affirmed.
Sd/SATHISH NINAN
JUDGE
Sd/SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN
JUDGE
yd
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review