Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:MHC:910
A.S. NO.715 OF 2019
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
JUDGMENT RESERVED ON : 22 / 08 / 2025
JUDGMENT PRONOUNCED ON : 05 / 03 / 2026
CORAM :
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE R.SAKTHIVEL
APPEAL SUIT NO.715 OF 2019
Sebastian
...
Appellant / Defendant
...
Respondent / Plaintiff
Vs.
Kattari @ Selvaraj
PRAYER: First Appeal filed under Section 96 read with Order XLI Rule
1 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 praying to set aside the Judgment
and Decree dated January 3, 2017 passed in O.S. No.11 of 2014 by the
Principal District Court, Thiruvarur.
For Appellant
For Respondent
:
:
Mr.M.Thamizhavel
Mr.K.Mahalingam
JUDGMENT
Feeling aggrieved by the Judgment and Decree dated January
3, 2017 passed in O.S. No.11 of 2014 by 'the Principal District Court,
Thiruvarur' ['Trial Court' for brevity], the defendant therein has filed this
Appeal Suit under Section 96 read with Order XLI Rule 1 of 'the Code of
Civil Procedure, 1908' ['CPC' for short].
1/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. NO.715 OF 2019
2. For the sake of convenience, hereinafter, the parties will be
referred to as per their array in the Original Suit.
PLAINTIFF'S CASE
3. The Suit Properties belong to the defendant. He had
purchased the Suit Properties on different dates from different owners
through Registered Sale Deeds in Documents Nos.342 of 2007, 345 of
2007, 430 of 2007, 547 of 2007 and 3461 of 2007. The defendant offered
to sell the Suit Properties to the plaintiff. On December 20, 2010, the sale
price was fixed as Rs.13,00,000/-(Rupees Thirteen Lakhs only) and on the
same day the defendant had received Rs.4,00,000/- (Rupees Four Lacs
only) from the plaintiff as advance and executed an un-registered Sale
Agreement. As per the terms of Sale Agreement, the plaintiff has to pay
Rs.3,00,000/- (Rupees Three Lakhs only) on or before April 30, 2011 to
the defendant and further, the plaintiff shall pay the balance sale price of
Rs.6,00,000/- on or before April 30, 2012. The plaintiff was always ready
and willing to pay the balance sale price and perform his part of contract.
Several times, the plaintiff called upon the defendant to execute Sale
Deed. But the defendant failed to do so. Time was not the essence of the
2/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. NO.715 OF 2019
contract. From the date of Sale Agreement, the plaintiff has been in
possession and enjoyment of the Suit Properties.
3.1. Further case of the plaintiff is that, while the matter stood
thus, the defendant has filed a Suit in O.S. No.85 of 2012 on the file of
Principal District Munsif, Thiruvarur, seeking permanent injunction
against the plaintiff in respect of the Suit Properties and the same is
pending till now. Therefore, the plaintiff has no other option except to file
the present Suit seeking the relief of specific performance in favour of the
plaintiff.
DEFENDANT'S CASE
4. The defendant filed written statement denying the
allegations made by the plaintiff in the plaint. The defendant admitted the
execution of Suit Sale Agreement as well as the receipt Rs.4,00,000/- as
advance on the date of agreement. His case is that the plaintiff was not
ready and willing to perform his part of the contract and also did not make
the agreed payments on time as per the agreement. Hence, the plaintiff is
not entitled for the relief of Specific Performance. The plaintiff has not
deposited the balance amount of Rs.6,00,000/- in the present Suit as well
as in the previous Suit in O.S. No.85 of 2012 filed by the defendant
3/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. NO.715 OF 2019
against the plaintiff for permanent injunction. Further, the Suit is clearly
barred by limitation. The Suit is liable to be dismissed. However, on moral
grounds, the defendant is ready to return Rs.7,00,000/- received from the
plaintiff. Stating so, the defendant prayed to dismiss the Suit.
TRIAL COURT
5. Based on the above pleadings, the Trial Court framed the
following issues:
'1.
Whether the plaintiff is entitled to the relief of Specific
Performance against the defendant?
2.
Whether the Suit is barred by limitation?
3.
To what other relief?'
6. At trial, on the side of the plaintiff, plaintiff was examined
as P.W.1 and one Balasubramanian was examined as P.W.2 and Ex-A.1 to
Ex-A.4 were marked. On the side of the defendant, defendant was
examined as D.W.1 and Ex-B.1 to Ex-B.6 were marked.
7. After full-fledged trial, the Trial Court concluded that the
plaintiff was always ready and willing perform his part of the Sale
Agreement. But the defendant refused to come forward to execute the
Sale Agreement. The plaintiff proved that he paid a sum of Rs.7,00,000/4/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. NO.715 OF 2019
to the defendant and deposited the balance sale consideration of
Rs.6,00,000/- into Court pending Suit. Upon arriving at these findings, the
Trial Court decreed the Suit by granting the relief of Specific
Performance, as sought for in the plaint by the plaintiff.
8. Feeling aggrieved, the defendant has preferred this First
Appeal under Section 96 read with Order XLI Rule 1 of the CPC.
ARGUMENTS
9. Mr.M.Thamizhavel, learned Counsel appearing for the
Appellant/Defendant would submit that the Trial Court failed to consider
the fact that the Plaintiff was not ready and willing to perform his part of
the contract within the stipulated time as per the terms of the contract. The
Plaintiff ought to have paid Rs.3,00,000/- on or before April 30, 2011 and
the remaining part of the balance sale consideration i.e., Rs.6,00,000/ought to have been paid on or before April 30, 2012. But the Plaintiff
remitted a sum of Rs.2,95,000/- (Rupees two lakhs and ninety five
thousand only) only on February 25, 2012, beyond the stipulated period.
Further, the balance sale consideration of Rs.6,00,000/- (Rupees six lakhs
only) was not paid before April 30, 2012 which clearly establishes that the
Plaintiff was not ready and willing to perform his part of the contract.
5/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. NO.715 OF 2019
The Trial Court failed to consider the aforesaid facts in consonance with
law. Accordingly, he would pray to allow the Appeal Suit and set aside
the Decree and Judgment of the Trial Court. He would rely upon the
following Judgments in support of his contentions: (i) Gana. Kannappan
-vs- G.Mohanlal Patel reported in 2025 (3) CTC 306; (ii) Krishnamoorthy
-vs- Nagammal reported in 2019 (3) CTC 215.
10. Per
contra,
Mr.K.Mahalingam,
learned
Counsel
appearing for the Respondent/Plaintiff drew attention of this Court to ExA.2 - Kist Receipts and Ex-A.3 - Adangal Extract issued by the Village
Administrative Officer on April 18, 2013 and submitted that the Plaintiff
is in possession and enjoyment of the Suit Properties since 2010, even
prior to Ex-A.1 - Suit Sale Agreement. Further, time is not the essence of
Ex-A.1 - Suit Sale Agreement.
The Plaintiff remitted Rs.2,95,000/-
(Rupees two lakhs and ninety five thousand only) on February 25, 2012
and handed over a sum of Rs.5,000/- (Rupees five thousand only) directly
to the Defendant.
The Defendant without any objection or demur,
received the said amount. Thereafter, the Plaintiff was ready and willing
to perform his part of the contract by tendering the balance sale
consideration of Rs.6,00,000/- to the Defendant. But the Defendant for
6/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. NO.715 OF 2019
reasons best known to him, refused to come forward to execute the Sale
Deed. The Plaintiff is an illiterate agriculturist, and he depends only on
agricultural income. In these circumstances, the Trial Court rightly
appreciated the facts and circumstances and granted relief of specific
performance. There is no warrant to interfere with it. Accordingly, he
prayed to dismiss the Appeal Suit.
POINTS FOR CONSIDERATION
11. Heard the rival submissions. Perused the evidence
available on record. The points that arise for consideration in this Appeal
Suit are:
(i)
Whether the Plaintiff was ready and willing to perform his part
of the contract?
(ii) Whether the Suit is barred by limitation as contended by the
Defendant?
(iii) Whether the Plaintiff is in possession and enjoyment of the suit
properties and if so, whether he is entitled to protect the same ?
(iv) Whether the Decree and Judgment of the Trial Court has to be
interfered with?
7/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. NO.715 OF 2019
DISCUSSION AND DECISION
Point No.(i):
12. The Defendant is the owner of the Suit Properties. The
Plaintiff and the Defendant entered into Ex-A.1 - Sale Agreement on
December 20, 2010. The execution and contents of the Sale Agreement is
not disputed by both parties. As per the Sale Agreement, the total sale
price was agreed at Rs.13,00,000/- (Rupees thirteen lakhs only) and the
Plaintiff paid a sum of Rs.4,00,000/- (Rupees four lakhs only) as advance
on the date of the agreement itself. As per the terms of the agreement, the
Plaintiff shall pay a sum of Rs.3,00,000/- on or before April 30, 2011 and
the remaining part of the balance sale consideration i.e., Rs.6,00,000/shall be paid on or before April 30, 2012. A bare reading of Ex-A.1 - Suit
Sale Agreement would show that the parties further agreed that if the
Plaintiff failed to remit the amount within the stipulated period, the
agreement shall stand cancelled. Relevant extract reads thus:
,uz;lhtJ egUf;F
brhe;jkhd moapy; fz;l eO;ir epyj;ij
2tJ egh; 1tJ egUf;F 13/00/000/-+. (gjp\d;W
‘.
.
.
v';fspy;
yl;rk; kl;Lk;). (10 Vf;fh; 30 kh) Rj;j fpuak;
ngrpf; bfhLg;gjha; ngrp xg;g[f; bfhz;L
mjw;F ml;thd;!; +.4/00/000/- (ehd;F yl;rk;
8/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. NO.715 OF 2019
kl;Lk;)
1tJ
eghplkpUe;J
2tJ
egUf;F ,d;iwa njjpapy; buhf;fk; brYj;jp
nkw;go ml;thd;!; bjhifia 2tJ egUk;
1tJ eghplkpUe;J buhf;fk; bgw;Wf;bfhz;lJ
ehns ,d;W Kjy; tUk; Vg;uy; 30Mk;
njjpf;Fs; 5 Vf;fUf;F fpuaj;ij 2tJ eghplk;
1tJ egh; +.3/00/000/- (\d;W yl;rk; +gha;
kl;Lk;) bfhLj;J tplntz;Lk;. nkYk; kPjp
bjhif ,uz;lhtJ jtizahf Vg;uy; 30/
2012f;F kPjp bjhifia +.6/00/000/- MW
yl;rj;ij 1tJ egh; 2tJ eghplk; KG
bjhifiaa[k; brYj;jp 1tJ egUf;F gj;jpu
gjpt[ bra;J bfhs;s ntz;Lk;. ,e;j
xg;ge;jg;go
Fwpg;gpl;l
njjpapy;
gzk;
brYj;jtpy;iy vd;why; ,e;j xg;ge;jk;
fhyhtjpahfptpLk;. nkYk; ,e;j epge;jidapy;
,Ue;J ,uz;L egh;fSk; jtwpa egh; jtwhj
egh; nfhWk; e#;lj;jpw;Fk; gupfhu';fSf;Fk;
fl;Lg;gl
ntz;oaJ
vd;Wk;
v';fs;
ghpg{uz rk;kjkha; vGjpf;bfhz;l fpua
xg;ge;j Mtzk;.‘
13. As per the terms of Ex-A.1, the plaintiff ought to have
remitted Rs.3,00,000/- on or before April 30, 2011. Admittedly, in this
case, the Plaintiff remitted a sum of Rs.2,95,000/- (Rupees two lakhs and
9/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. NO.715 OF 2019
ninety five thousand only) to the defendant's bank account, however only
on February 25, 2012 i.e., beyond the stipulated period that too without
any prior notice to the defendant about the deposit. According to the
Plaintiff, after the said remittance, he paid a sum of Rs.5,000/- (Rupees
five thousand only) directly to the Defendant and the Defendant received
the said amount without any demur or objection. The Defendant denied
the said fact. Admittedly, the Plaintiff did not pay Rs.6,00,000/- on or
before April 30, 2012 as agreed in Ex-A.1. The said amount was deposited
in the Suit only on October 21, 2016, during the pendency of the Suit.
Further, as per Section 16 (c) of the Specific Relief Act, 1963, dehors a
plea from the defence, the Plaintiff has to plead and prove that he was
ready and willing to perform his part of the contract during the stipulated
period [See J.P. Builders -vs- A.Ramadass reported in (2011) 1 SCC 429]
and even thereafter, but the Plaintiff failed to prove the same. The Plaintiff
did not give any explanation for the delayed payments. The Plaintiff did
not prove that he had a sum of Rs.6,00,000/- (Rupees six lakhs only) in
his hand or in his bank account. There is no evidence available on record
to show that the Plaintiff had Rs.6,00,000/- (Rupees six lakhs only) in his
hand to pay the sale consideration. Further, the Plaintiff presented the
plaint in the present Suit on March 06, 2014 i.e., after two years. No
10/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. NO.715 OF 2019
explanation was given for filing the Suit after a period of two years. The
Plaintiff did not issue any legal notice during the period of the agreement
to the Defendant expressing his readiness and willingness to perform his
part of the contract. No pre-suit notice was issued expressing his readiness
and willingness to perform his part of contract. Moreover, the balance sale
consideration was not deposited before the Court at the time of filing the
Suit; the same was deposited only on October 21, 2016 during the
pendency of the Suit. The cumulative facts and circumstances would
make it clear that the Plaintiff was not ready and willing to perform his
part of the contract. Point No.(i) is answered accordingly.
Point No.(ii):
14. As per the terms of Ex-A.1 - Suit Sale Agreement dated
December 20, 2010, the Plaintiff ought to have made a payment of
Rs.3,00,000/- on or before April 30, 2011 and further, if the plaintiff fails
to perform his part of the contract, Ex-A.1 shall stand cancelled. The Suit
was filed on March 06, 2014 and taken on file on April 30, 2014, within
three years from the stipulated date for the first payment of Rs.3,00,000/viz., April 30, 2011, which was not met by the plaintiff. Hence, the Suit
has been filed well within the limitation period. Therefore, the defence
11/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. NO.715 OF 2019
that the Suit is barred by limitation under Article 54 of the Limitation Act,
1963 does not hold water. Point No.(ii) is answered accordingly.
Point No.(iii):
15. It is stated by the Plaintiff side that the Plaintiff has been
in possession and enjoyment of the suit properties. Ex-A.2 - Kist Receipts
relied on by the Plaintiff side contains four receipts relating to the Fasli
Years 1414, 1417, 1421 and 1422. They range from March 12, 2010 to
January 17, 2013. They stand in the Defendant's name, but the payment
have been made by the Plaintiff. Mere payment of Kist amount by the
Plaintiff that too in the name of Defendant, cannot be taken as conclusive
proof of possession. The Plaintiff side would further rely on Ex-A.3 Adangal extracts issued by Village Administrative Officer on April 18,
2013. It is an inadmissible document as the author of the document was
not examined and it does not mention any Fasli Years. Even in Ex-A.3, the
Defendant has been mentioned as the owner and the one in possession.
Contrary to the contents in the prescribed columns of Adangal Register,
the Village Administrative Officer has made an endorsement in Ex-A.3 to
the effect that the Plaintiff has been cultivating the suit properties. The
Village Administrative Officer has no power or authority to make an
12/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. NO.715 OF 2019
endorsement contrary to the entries in the prescribed columns, that too
without any enquiry after notice. Moreover, the Village Administrative
Officer has no authority to issue Adangal Extract. Certified Copies applied
as per Board Standing Orders are alone admissible. If any document is
issued against the Board Standing Order, is inadmissible [See Bhinka -vsCharan Singh, reported in AIR 1959 SC 960]. Hence, Ex-A.3 is also not
admissible in evidence. In other words, the endorsement which is made in
Ex-A.3 can be construed as a statement of the Village Administrative
Officer. The said statement which is a statement of a living person, cannot
be marked without examining the maker of the statement viz., Village
Administrative Officer. For this reason also, Ex-A.3 is inadmissible.
16. Even while assuming that the Plaintiff is in possession
and enjoyment of the suit properties, the same is not lawful and cannot be
protected, as Ex-A.1 is an un-registered document. Section 53-A of the
Transfer of Property Act, 1882 has been amended by the Registration and
Other Related Laws (Amendment) Act, 2001 (Act No.48 of 2001) with
effect from September 24, 2001. In view of the amendment made in
Section 53-A, the Plaintiff cannot protect his alleged possession under the
law. It is true that, the Defendant filed a Suit in O.S. No.85 of 2012
before the District Munsif Court, Thiruvarur, seeking a permanent
13/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. NO.715 OF 2019
injunction against the Plaintiff. It appears that the said Suit was later
dismissed, on grounds not known. The Decree and Judgment of that Suit
will not have any impact in the present suit and whatever may be,
plaintiff's possession cannot be protected in view of amended Section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882. Point No.(iii) is answered
accordingly.
Point No.(iv):
17. The Defendant in his written statement in Paragraph
No.8, has clearly and categorically stated that “on the grounds of morality
this defendant is ready to pay back entire Rs.7,00,000/- seven lakhs to the
plaintiff which the defendant received from the plaintiff on two dates.
Further, in Ex-B.2 which is the plaint in the earlier Suit filed by the
Defendant, the Defendant has categorically pleaded and admitted that he
received a sum of Rs.3,00,000/- and Rs.4,00,000/-, totally Rs.7,00,000/-.
As per Section 22 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963, relief of return of
advance money cannot be granted to the Plaintiff without a specific prayer
to that effect. However, in view of the aforesaid unequivocal admissions
made by the Defendant and his willingness to return the said amount, this
Court in the interest of justice and to avoid multiplicity of proceedings, is
14/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. NO.715 OF 2019
inclined to grant a decree of return of amount of Rs.7,00,000/- to the
Plaintiff. In view the above as well as the findings under Point Nos.(I) to
(III), the Judgment and Decree passed by the Trial Court are liable to be
set aside. Point No.(iv) is answered accordingly.
18. No quarrel with the rulings relied on either side.
CONCLUSION
19. In the result, the Appeal Suit is allowed in part in the
following terms:
(i) The Decree and Judgment passed by the Trial Court are set aside
and the Plaintiff is not entitled to the relief of specific performance.
(ii) Alternatively, the Plaintiff is entitled to money decree in the
following manner:
(a)
The Defendant shall pay Rs.7,00,000/- with simple interest at
the rate of 6% per annum from the date of Suit till the date of
realisation.
(b)
A charge is created over the suit properties in favour of the
Plaintiff for due realization of the aforesaid amount. If the
15/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. NO.715 OF 2019
Defendant paid the said amount, the charge shall be raised
automatically without any reference to Court.
(c)
The Defendant shall pay the aforesaid amount within a period
of two months from the date of receipt of a copy of this
Judgment.
(d)
The Plaintiff is entitled to refund of the balance sale
consideration deposited in the Court with accrued interest, if
any.
(iii) Considering the facts and circumstances of the case, there shall be
no order as to costs.
/ 03 / 2026
Index
Speaking Order
TK/pam
: Yes
: Yes
: Yes
To
The Principal District Court
Thiruvarur.
16/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. NO.715 OF 2019
17/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. NO.715 OF 2019
R. SAKTHIVEL, J.
TK/pam
PRE-DELIVERY JUDGMENT MADE IN
APPEAL SUIT NO.715 OF 2019
05 / 03 / 2026
18/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review