The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
4. Having regard to the above, this application stand allowed on the same finding what has been given by this Court in W.P.(S) No.5455 of 2023 and other analogous cases, whereby, the impugned orders were quashed and set aside and the respondents were directed to give increment to the respective 2026:JHHC:25870 petitioners.
5. Accordingly, only note part of letter dated 13.06.2022 (Annexure-6) is hereby quashed and set aside and the respondents are directed to give all consequential benefits to the petitioners within a period of 12 weeks from the date of receipt of copy of this order.
6. Consequently, the instant writ application stands allowed. Pending I.A., if any, also stands closed. (Deepak Roshan, J.)
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:25870
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
W.P. (S) No. 7561 of 2023
---------
1. Satishwar Prasad Sinha, aged about 66 years, Son of Late
Kameshwar Prasad Sinha, Resident of Power House Chowk,
Barganda, P.O., Giridih, P.S. Giridih, Dist.- Giridih /
Jharkhand.
2. Om Prakash Gupta, aged about 73 years, Son of Late Jago Saw,
Resident of A-2, Madhuri Enclave, Harihar Singh Road,
Morabadi, P.O. Ranchi University, P.S. Bariatu, Dist. Ranchi./
Jharkhand.
3. Samir Sarkar, aged about 65 years, Son of Late Ratan Sarkar,
Resident of 58, Barganda Near Power House, P.O., Giridih, P.S.
Giridih, Dist.- Giridih / Jharkhand.
4. Ravi Krishna, aged about 69 years Son of Late Mithilesh Kumar,
Resident of Barganda, P.O., Giridih, P.S. Giridih, Dist. Giridih /
Jharkhand.
5. Saraswati Chaudhury, aged about 68 years, Daughter of Late
Jamini Ranjan Chaudhury, Resident of Power House Chowk,
Barganda, P.O., Giridih, P.S. Giridih, Dist.- Giridih
....Petitioner(s)
Versus
1) State of Jharkhand.
2) Secretary, Department of Higher, Technical Education,
Government of Jharkhand, at Nepal House, P.O.- Doranda and
P.S. Doranda, District-Ranchi,Jharkhand.
3) The Vice Chancellor, Vinoba Bhave University, P.O. Hazaribagh,
P.S. Hazaribagh, Dist. Hazaribagh, Jharkhand.
4) The Registrar, Vinoba Bhave University, P.O. Hazaribagh, P.S.
Hazaribagh, Dist. Hazaribagh, Jharkhand.
....Respondent(s)
---------
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE DEEPAK ROSHAN
---------
For the Petitioner(s) : Mr. Saurav Arun, Advocate
For the Respondent(s) : Mrs. Sunita Kumari, AC to SC-II
Mr. Amaresh Kumar, Adv.
---------
06/Dated: 20.08.2026
1.
The instant writ application has been preferred by the
petitioner praying therein for the following relief:a) for issuance of a writ(s)/order (s)/direction (s) or a
writ in the nature of mandamus commanding upon the
respondents to pay the merger scale with increments in
the pay scale of 3700-5700/- which replacement scale
is Rs. 12000-18300/- wherein basic pay will come to
2026:JHHC:25870
Rs.14,940/- but the respondents behind the back of the
petitioners, without giving any show cause, without
giving any opportunity of hearing, 2 increments already
given to the petitioners has been curtailed and thus
fixed the basic pay of the petitioners as Rs.12000/- in
spite of the fact that the Respondent university has
rightly fixed the pay scale of the petitioners and
recommended to the State for its approval which is
binding in nature, but the State does not have the power
under the University Law to curtail the increments
already given by way of executive order when the
Statute has never been amended under which the
petitioners have got 2 increments;
b) For, issuance of a writ(s)/order (s)/direction (s) or a
writ in the nature of mandamus directing upon the
respondents not to recover or deduct the scale of the
petitioners on account of 2 increments given on account
of PhD as well as increment on account of completion of
5 years service as Reader in terms of the Statute and
Circular issued time and again;
c) For issuance of a writ(s)/order (s)/direction (s) or a
writ in the nature of mandamus commanding upon the
respondents to show cause as to under what authority
they have curtailed the amount of increment on account
of completion of 5 years of service as Reader as the
petitioners are entitled for a basic scale of Rs.14,940/d) For, issuance of a writ(s)/order (s)/direction (s) or a
writ in the nature of certiorari for quashing the letter
dated 13.06.2022 (Annexure-6) by which the pay scale
of the petitioners has been fixed to the extent in which it
has been stated that the increments will be given to the
lecturer (Associate Professor) only that part because of
that 2 increments already availed way back has been
curtailed and pay scale of the petitioners has wrongly
2026:JHHC:25870
been
fixed
at
Rs.3625
w.e.f.
1.1.1996
which
replacement comes as Rs. 12000/- which does not
include PhD increments nor in includes increments on
account of completion of 5 years as Reader which comes
to the pay scale of Rs.14,940/- and curtailment has
been done without any reason by Executive order which
the State does not have power under the University Law
e) For issuance of a writ(s)/order (s)/direction (s) or a
writ in the nature of mandamus commanding upon the
respondents to pay all the arrears and family pension
due to the petitioner immediately and forthwith;
2.
At the outset, learned counsel for the petitioners
submits that the issue of increment involved in this writ
application has been set at rest by this Court in the case of W.P.(S)
No.5455 of 2023 with analogous cases, wherein this Court has
held as under:
“6.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and after going
through the documents annexed with the respective affidavits especially
Annexure-5,6,11&15 in W.P.S No.5455/23, W.P.S No.5789/23, W.P.S
No.7396/23, it appears that after the appeal preferred by the State was
allowed and two scale of Reader was set aside; thereafter, the respondents
came with provisional pay fixation of teachers in several colleges in which at
the bottom it has been indicated as “Note-PhD increments will be applicable
only for Lecturer/Assistant Professor” which has directly affected the pay
scale of these petitioners who are readers. It has been stated that PhD
increment is admissible to the Lecturer only.
In this regard it is necessary to indicate that Section 2(V) defines
Teacher as Principal, University Professor, College Professor, Reader,
Lecturer, Demonstrator, and other person imparting instruction in
Department, College or Institute maintained by the State. It further
transpires from the Statute No.1 which is the general condition of the
service, wherein Section 22(1) stipulates that the increment can be withheld
as measures of punishment; otherwise entitles as a matter of course. At this
stage it is also pertinent to mention that no notice was ever served to the
respective petitioners before taking the decision.
7.
It has been admitted by both the parties that statute no.22, 4th
UGC pay scale has been adopted by State by virtue of appendix-1 Clause
(11). Further 5th UGC scale has been adopted by the State and Clause 6
speaks about incentive for PhD/M. Phil qualification. Therefore, when
Section 2(V) of the University Act itself says that Teacher means Reader also
then simply by an executive order Section 2(V) of the University Act cannot
be amended. In this regard it would be profitable to refer the judgment in the
case of K. Kuppusamy & Anr. Vs. State of T. N. and others reported in
(1998) 8 Supreme Court Cases 469 wherein it has been held by Hon’ble
Apex Court that Rule framed cannot be overridden by executive orders or
executive practice. For brevity para-3 of the said judgment is quoted
hereinbelow: 3. The short point on which these appeals must succeed is that the
2026:JHHC:25870
Tribunal fell into an error in taking the view that since the
Government had indicated its intention to amend the relevant rules,
its action in proceeding on the assumption of such amendment
could not be said to be irrational or arbitrary and, therefore, the
consequential orders passed have to be upheld. We are afraid this
line of approach cannot be countenanced. The relevant rules, it is
admitted, were framed under the proviso to Article 309 of the
Constitution. They are statutory rules. Statutory rules cannot be
overridden by executive orders or executive practice. Merely
because the Government had taken a decision to amend the rules
does not mean that the rule stood obliterated. Till the rule is
amended, the rule applies. Even today the amendment has not
been effected. As and when it is effected ordinarily it would be
prospective in nature unless expressly or by necessary implication
found to be retrospective. The Tribunal was, therefore, wrong in
ignoring the rule.
8.
The law is now no more res-integra that administrative
instructions/circular/orders cannot override statutory rules. The note part in
Annexure-5 & 6 referred to hereinabove indicates that PhD increment is
admissible to Lecturer only which is against Section 2(V) of the University
Act and as stated hereinabove the statute cannot amend by an executive
order and accordingly Section 2(V) of the University Act cannot be amended
by executive Act, even the increment payable to employees under the
provisions of article 22 of the Statutes, framed under the provision of the
University Act and approved by the Chancellor, and according to the said
Article, increment is payable to the University servant as a matter of course,
unless it is withheld by the authority empowered to appoint him, as a
measure of punishment, on this ground also order impugned is bad in law.
9.
Having regard to the aforesaid discussions, the note part indicated
in Annexure-5 & 6 of W.P.(S) No.5455 of 2023, W.P.(S) No.5789 of 2023,
W.P.(S) No.7396 of 2023 and also Annexure-11& 15 in respective
Interlocutory Application wherein it has been stated that PhD increment is
admissible to the Lecturer only, is hereby, quashed and set aside.”
3.
It has been informed by learned counsel for the
petitioners and also not disputed by learned counsel for the
respondents that the issue involved in this writ application is
same and similar and further the State has challenged the said
order before the Division Bench of this Court, however, the same
was dismissed on the ground of limitation, but the fact remains
that thereafter, they have not filed any further application as per
their information.
4.
Having regard to the above, this application stand
allowed on the same finding what has been given by this Court in
W.P.(S) No.5455 of 2023 and other analogous cases, whereby,
the impugned orders were quashed and set aside and the
respondents were directed to give increment to the respective
2026:JHHC:25870
petitioners.
5.
Accordingly, only note part of letter dated 13.06.2022
(Annexure-6)
is
hereby
quashed
and
set
aside
and
the
respondents are directed to give all consequential benefits to the
petitioners within a period of 12 weeks from the date of receipt of
copy of this order.
6.
Consequently, the instant writ application stands
allowed. Pending I.A., if any, also stands closed.
(Deepak Roshan, J.)
AUGUST 20, 2026
fahim/uploaded
01/09/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review