Judgments
LegalFirms.in Judgments · legalfirms.in/judgments/satheesan-t-vs-pothuvarath-vijayan-20240719/ · Printed 21 Nov 2026
Civil

Satheesan. T vs Pothuvarath Vijayan

Add to a compilation

Keep judgments in folders, mark the paragraphs you rely on, and print a compilation with an index. It comes with the Research and Advocate Pro judgment plans and with a campus licence. Sign in · See the plans

Court
Kerala High Court
Date
19 July 2024
Case No.
RSA 372/2024
Result
Dismissed
Bench
Honourable Mr. Justice M.a.abdul Hakhim
Cite this judgment
Citation
Link for your website or blog
Cite the court's own record or the law report in court filings.

The court's order

The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.

10. In Appellate the Court first round of litigation, remanded the matter to prove the the execution of Ext.A1 will, taking note of Sec.90 of the Indian Evidence Act. The defendants did not challenge the said remand order. I am of the view that said exercise was not necessary since execution of Will is admitted by defendants and they also obtained the property on the strength of the said Will.

11. In the decision in Sharada’s case (supra) this Court found that propounder has to discharge his burden when the Will is not specifically denied or No.372 of 2024 - 13 - expressly admitted. The said decision is not applicable in the case on hand as the defendants had specifically admitted the execution of Ext.A1 Will. Under the illegality in circumstances, the impugned I do judgments. not find None of any the questions of law framed in the Memorandum of Appeal arise in the matter and accordingly the Regular Second Appeal is dismissed. Sd/-

Filed under

Indian Evidence Act, 1872 Section 90, Indian Evidence Act, 1872

The law this judgment cites

Opens the section on Law Maker (lawmaker.in), our sister site for law students.

Full Judgment Text

Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs, CC BY 4.0). The court's own copy is the authoritative text.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM PRESENT THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE M.A.ABDUL HAKHIM FRIDAY, THE 19TH DAY OF JULY 2024 / 28TH ASHADHA, 1946 RSA NO. 372 OF 2024 AGAINST THE ORDER/JUDGMENT DATED 31.01.2024 IN AS NO.31 OF 2021 OF ASSISTANT SESSIONS COURT/ADDITIONAL SUB COURT, THALASSERY ARISING OUT OF THE ORDER/JUDGMENT DATED 12.01.2021 IN OS NO.259 OF 2013 OF PRINCIPAL MUNSIFF COURT, KANNUR APPELLANT/S: SATHEESAN. T, AGED 62 YEARS S/O LATE YESHODA, VISMAYAM, CHEMBILODE P.O. MOWECHERY, KANNUR (LEGAL HEIR OF DECEASED YESHODA. T. D1/R1 IN AS), PIN - 670613 VASANTHA.T, AGED 68 YEARS D/O LATE YESHODA ARADHANA, NARIKKODE PANAYATAM PARAMBA.P.O , KANNUR (LEGAL HEIR OF DECEASED YESHODA. T. D1/R1 IN AS), PIN - 670611 RAMANI. P.V, AGED 65 YEARS D/O LATE YESHODA MURALI KRIPA KIZHUTHALLI, NEAR POLICE QUARTERS P.O. CHOVVA, KANNUR (LEGAL HEIR OF DECEASED YESHODA. T. D1/R1 IN AS), PIN - 670611 JYOTHI DASAN. T AGED 49 YEARS D/O LATE YESHODA, JYOTHI NIVAS, KANAYANORE P.O. MOWANCHERY, KANNUR (LEGAL HEIR OF DECEASED YESHODA. T. D1/R1 IN AS), PIN - 670613 THANDARATH NALINI AGED 82 YEARS D/O.DEVAKI, RESIDING AT THANDARATH HOUSE, CHEMBILODE AMSOM, MOWANCHERI DESOM, P.O.MOWANCHERI, KANNUR, PIN - 670613 THANDARATH LAKSHMANAN AGED 72 YEARS S/O.DEVAKI, RESIDING AT PATTAYACHALIL HOUSE, CHEMBILODE AMSOM, MOWANCHERI DESOM P.O.MOWANCHERI, KANNUR, PIN – 670613 THANDARATH REMESAN AGED 60 YEARS S/O.DEVAKI, RESIDING AT PATTAYACHALIL HOUSE, CHEMBILODE AMSOM, MOWANCHERI DESOM, P.O.MOWANCHERI, KANNUR, PIN – 670613 R.S.A No.372 of 2024 - 2 - C.SANTHA AGED 74 YEARS W/O.SREEDHARAN, RESIDING AT PATTAYACHALIL HOUSE, MUNDERI AMSOM, EACHUR DESOM, P.O. EACHUR, KANNUR, PIN - 670591 REENA C, AGED 49 YEARS D/O.SREEDHARAN, RESIDING AT PATTAYACHALIL HOUSE, MUNDERI AMSOM, EACHUR DESOM, P.O. EACHUR, KANNUR, PIN - 670591 C.RIJESH AGED 47 YEARS S/O.SREEDHARAN, RESIDING AT PATTAYACHALIL HOUSE, MUNDERI AMSOM, EACHUR DESOM, P.O. EACHUR, KANNUR, PIN - 670591 C.REJULA AGED 45 YEARS D/O.SREEDHARAN, RESIDING AT PATTAYACHALIL HOUSE, MUNDERI AMSOM, EACHUR DESOM, P.O. EACHUR, KANNUR, PIN - 670591 THEKKEYIL SUJITHA AGED 62 YEARS W/O.GANGADHARAN RESIDING AT THAKKEYIL HOUSE, ELAYAVOOR AMSOM, KEEZHUTHALLI DESOM, THAZHE CHOVVA, KANNUR DISTRICT, PIN - 670018 BALAKANDI SUMA AGED 52 YEARS W/O.VIJAYAN, RESIDING AT BALAKANDI HOUSE, CHEMBILODE AMSOM, PANAYATHAMPARAMBA DESOM P.O.PANAYATHAMPARAMBA, KANNUR DISTRICT, PIN - 670595 BALAKANDI SAYOOJ, AGED 29 YEARS S/O.VIJAYAN, RESIDING AT BALAKANDI HOUSE, CHEMBILODE AMSOM, PANAYATHAMPARAMBA DESOM P.O.PANAYATHAMPARAMBA, KANNUR DISTRICT, PIN - 670595 BALAKANDI SNEHA AGED 28 YEARS D/O.VIJAYAN, RESIDING AT BALAKANDI HOUSE,CHEMBILODE AMSOM, PANAYATHAMPARAMBA DESOM P.O.PANAYATHAMPARAMBA, KANNUR DISTRICT, PIN – 670595 MAHIJA E, AGED 61 YEARS RESIDING AT THEJUS, KOTTANCHICHERI, P.O. KANHIORDE KUDIKKIMOTTA, KANNUR, PIN – 670592 R.S.A No.372 of 2024 - 3 - BHAVIA E, AGED 33 YEARS D/O.BHARATHAN, RESIDING THEJUS, KOTTANCHICHERI, P.O. KANHIORDE KUDIKKIMOTTA, KANNUR, PIN - 670592 KAVIA E, AGED 29 YEARS D/O.BHARATHAN, RESIDING THEJUS, KOTTANCHICHERI, P.O. KANHIORDE KUDIKKIMOTTA, KANNUR, PIN - 670592 BY ADVS. ABDUL RAOOF PALLIPATH E.MOHAMMED SHAFI KRISHNAPRIYA R. SITHARA RAHEEM V.K. RESPONDENT/S: POTHUVARATH VIJAYAN AGED 66 YEARS S/O. JANAKI, RESIDING AT POTHUVARATH HOUSE, MUNDERI AMSOM, EACHUR DESOM, P.O. EACHUR KANNUR DISTRICT, PIN - 670591 POTHUVARATH RADHA AGED 75 YEARS D/O. JANAKI, RESIDING AT POTHUVARATH HOUSE, MUNDERI AMSOM, PURAVOOR, P.O. KANHIRODE KANNUR DISTRICT, PIN - 670591 POTHUVARATH SASIDHARAN AGED 69 YEARS S/O. JANAKI, RESIDING AT POTHUVARATH HOUSE, MUNDERI AMSOM, EACHUR DESOM, P.O. EACHUR KANNUR DISTRICT, PIN - 670591 POTHUVARATH BALAN @ BABU AGED 58 YEARS S/O. JANAKI, RESIDING AT POTHUVARATH HOUSE, MUNDERI AMSOM, EACHUR DESOM, P.O. EACHUR KANNUR DISTRICT,, PIN - 670591 POTHUVARATH VASUMATHI AGED 71 YEARS D/O. NARAYANAN, RESIDING AT GOKULAM, MUZHAPILANGAD AMSOM, DESOM, P.O. MUZHAPILANGAD, KANNUR DISTRICT, PIN - 670662 POTHUVARATH REMA, AGED 68 YEARS D/O. NARAYANAN, RESIDING AT SWAPNA NIVAS, MUZHAPILANGAD AMSOM, DESOM, P.O. MUZHAPILANGAD, KANNUR DISTRICT, PIN - 670662 MITHUN GANGADHARAN R.S.A No.372 of 2024 - 4 - AGED 33 YEARS S/O. GANGADHARAN, RESIDING AT THEKEYIL HOUSE ELAYAVOOR AMSOM, KIZHUTHALLI DESOM, P.O. THAZHE CHOVVA KANNUR DISTRICT, PIN - 670018 JITHIN GANGADHARAN AGED 29 YEARS S/O. GANGADHARAN, RESIDING AT THEKEYIL HOUSE ELAYAVOOR AMSOM, KIZHUTHALLI DESOM, P.O. THAZHE CHOVVA KANNUR DISTRICT, PIN - 670018 SEETHA. C, W/O LATE P. RAJAN PODUVARATH HOUSE, KOTTANICHERI NEAR KOTTANICHERI ANGAN VADI P.O.EACHUR- KANNUR, PIN - 670591 SHAMNA. P D/O LATE P. RAJAN PODUVARATH HOUSE, KOTTANICHERI NEAR KOTTANICHERI ANGAN VADI P.O.EACHUR- KANNUR, PIN - 670591 SHAJU. P, S/O LATE P.RAJAN PODUVARATH HOUSE, KOTTANICHERI NEAR KOTTANICHERI ANGAN VADI P.O.EACHUR- KANNUR, PIN 670591 SHERIL CHAKKARAYAN, S/O LATE P.RAJAN PODUVARATH HOUSE, KOTTANICHERI NEAR KOTTANICHERI ANGAN VADI P.O.EACHUR- KANNUR, PIN - 670591 THIS REGULAR SECOND ADMISSION ON 19.07.2024, DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING: APPEAL HAVING COME UP THE COURT ON THE SAME FOR DAY R.S.A No.372 of 2024 - 5 - J U D G M E N T The Defendants 1 to 3, 5 to 10, 13, 14, 15 and the legal heirs of the deceased 4th defendant are the appellants in this Regular Second Appeal. The parties are referred according to their status before the Trial Court. 2. The plaintiffs Janaki, who was the are daughter the children of one of one Pothuvarathu Kalyani who was the 3rd wife of one Punnakkal Kunhappa. The plaintiffs preferred the suit for declaration of title, recovery injunction of with possession respect to and for a perpetual the Plaint Schedule Property of 23 cents of land, on the averments that the Punnakkal 01.09.1950 Kunhappa bequeathing executed item Ext.A1 No.1 to Will dated properties therein to his children in the 1st wife by them, item No. 9 to 10 properties therein to the children to the second wife Povanath Kalyani and Item No.21 was bequeathed with 3rd wife Pothuvarath Kalyani and item No.22 was bequeathed to his grand daughter; that after R.S.A No.372 of 2024 - 6 - the death of Kunhappa, the Ext.A1 Will came into force and the respective respective plots bequeathed were that devolved Pothuvarath upon the Kalyani, who derived Item No.21 property transferred 68 cents of land to one Puthalath Raman, the husband of Pothuvarth Devaki in the year 1956 as per Ext.A3 document and the remaining extent of cents of land was in the possession of Pothuvarath Kalyani that on the death of Kalyani, the said 23 cents which is included in the Plaint Schedule was devolved upon her children Janaki and Narayanan; that after the death of Janaki, plaintiffs 1 to 5 derived right over the property and after the death of Naraynan, plaintiffs and derived right over the plaint schedule property; that the defendants are the children and legal heirs of deceased children of Pothuvarth Devaki, daughter of Kunhappa in his 1st wife who died in the year 2009; that the plaintiffs are residing far away from the plaint schedule property adjacent property; to the that the defendants plaint schedule got property; that when the plaintiffs went to the Village office to remit basic tax for during April 2010, the the plaint village schedule officer property refused to R.S.A No.372 of 2024 - 7 - receive basic tax stating that the defendants have been paying basic tax for the plaint schedule property; that ultimately the matter was considered by the Sub dated Collector, 26.03.2012 Thalassery directing and the he 1st passed order plaintiff to approach the Civil Court and accordingly, the present suit is filed. 3. The defendants 1 to 10 and 13 to 15 filed Written Statement denying the plaint averments that Pothuvarath Kalyani was the 3rd wife of Punnakkal Kunjappa; and that Pothuvarath Kalyani sold 68 cents of land after the property devolved upon her as per Will executed by Kunhappa in favour of Puthalath Raman and admitting execution and registration of Ext.A1 Will by Kunhappa with respect to the said properties. The said defendants further contended that even though item No.21 was set apart to Pothuvarath Kalyani as per Ext.A1 Will, the executor of the Will transferred this property during the lifetime itself to Puthalath Raman, the predecessor of defendants, and hence the said property was not available when the Will came into force. They raised an alternate contention that R.S.A No.372 of 2024 - 8 - the right of the plaintiffs over the plaint schedule property had lost by the adverse possession and limitation. 4. The Trial Court dismissed the suit initially as per judgment dated 25.02.2021, finding that the plaintiff failed to prove execution of Ext.A1 Will (which is the certified copy of the Will) by producing the original of the Will before the Court and examining the attesting witness. The Trial Court found that the defendants failed to prove that the right of plaintiff over the plaint schedule property was lost by adverse possession and limitation. The plaintiffs filed A.S.No. 36/2015 before the First Appellate Court and the First Appellate Court by judgment dated 20.05.2019 confirmed the finding of the Trial Court on issue No.2 with regard to adverse possession and limitation and remanded the matter back to the Trial Court to give reasonable opportunity to the plaintiff to produce the original of Ext.A1 Will or to take steps to establish the ground necessary to adduce the secondary evidence of the Will and to prove the same, holding that, if the plaintiffs succeed to prove the R.S.A No.372 of 2024 - 9 - circumstance to enable them to adduce secondary evidence to mark Ext.A1 evidence, the Trial Court can presume due execution of the original of Ext.A1 Will under Sec.90 of the Indian Evidence Act. 5. Thereafter, the plaintiff amended the plaint, incorporating Paragraph No.16(a) that the plaintiffs are not in possession of original Will which is marked as Ext.A1; that to their knowledge, the original of Ext.A1 Will has gone into the hands of the children of Devaki who are the defendants 1 to 5. Thereafter, PW1 was further examined in support of the plaint allegation. 6. By the impugned judgment passed by the Trial Court, the Trial Court found available materials are sufficient to draw a presumption that the original of Ext.A1 Will is duly executed by Punnakkal Kunhappa and duly attested by the attesting witnesses and it came into force after the death of Kunhappa that the plaintiffs got title over the plaint schedule property as the remaining portion of the plot after transfer of 68 cents of land as per Ext.A3 in favour of Raman, the predecessor of the defendants. Accordingly allowed the R.S.A No.372 of 2024 - 10 - suit granting possession prohibitory from declaration the title, defendants injunction plaintiffs. The of as recovery and sought of consequential for by the Defendants 1 to 3, 5 to 10, 13, 14, 15 and the legal heirs of the deceased 4 th defendant filed A.S.No. 31/2021 and the same was dismissed by the First Appellate 31.01.2024, confirming Court the by judgment judgment dated and decree the passed by the Trial Court. 7. Heard the counsel for the appellant Sri Abdul Raoof Pallipath. 8. The Counsel for the appellant submitted that the execution of Will is not properly proved after remand of the matter by the First Appellate Court when a specific direction was made for the same. According to him, Sec.90 of the Indian Evidence Act is not available to prove a Will. He cited in a decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court dated 14/03/2023 in Civil Appeal No. 7775/2021 in which it is held that Wills cannot be proved only on the basis of their age - presumption under Sec.90 as to the regularity of documents more than 30 years of age is inapplicable when it comes to R.S.A No.372 of 2024 - 11 - proof of wills, which have to be proved in terms of Sec.63(c) with of the Succession Act 1925 and Sec.68 of the Evidence Act 1972. He also cited Division Bench decision of this Court in Sarada [2017(2) KLT 372] and contended execution of Will is not V. that Radhamani in even if the denied or specifically expressly admitted, the Propounder has to discharge his burden with respect to execution of Will by calling at least one of the attesting witnesses. 9. I find from the impugned judgments that the contesting defendants did not dispute execution of Ext.A1 Will, which is of the year 1950. The plaintiff has produced certified copy of the said will as Ext.A1. With respect to the contents of Will also, the contesting defendants cannot have any objection. They also claim 68 cents of property, which is the part of the property derived by Pothuvarath Kalyani, through their predecessor Puthalath Raman who got the property from Pothuvarath Kalyani. Since defendants also derived property on the basis of Ext.A1 Will, through the predecessor the plaintiff, the defendants could not make any challenge against Ext.A1 Will. The R.S.A No.372 of 2024 - 12 - contention of the contesting defendants was that the testator had transferred by the property covered under Item 21 bequeathed to Pothuvarath Kalyani even before his death and as on the date when the will came into force, Item No.21 property was not available. Here also, Puthalath Raman, the predecessor of defendants obtained 68 cents of land from the very same Item No.21 from Pothuvarth Kalyani as per Ext.A3. That apart, the defendants did not produce any document to prove that the testator parted with the said property before his death. 10. In Appellate the Court first round of litigation, remanded the matter to prove the the execution of Ext.A1 will, taking note of Sec.90 of the Indian Evidence Act. The defendants did not challenge the said remand order. I am of the view that said exercise was not necessary since execution of Will is admitted by defendants and they also obtained the property on the strength of the said Will. 11. In the decision in Sharada’s case (supra) this Court found that propounder has to discharge his burden when the Will is not specifically denied or R.S.A No.372 of 2024 - 13 - expressly admitted. The said decision is not applicable in the case on hand as the defendants had specifically admitted the execution of Ext.A1 Will. Under the illegality in circumstances, the impugned I do judgments. not find None of any the questions of law framed in the Memorandum of Appeal arise in the matter and accordingly the Regular Second Appeal is dismissed. Sd/- M.A.ABDUL HAKHIM JUDGE SM

This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.

Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong? Request a review

All Kerala HC judgments →