Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE M.A.ABDUL HAKHIM
FRIDAY, THE 19TH DAY OF JULY 2024 / 28TH ASHADHA, 1946
RSA NO. 372 OF 2024
AGAINST THE ORDER/JUDGMENT DATED 31.01.2024 IN AS NO.31 OF 2021 OF
ASSISTANT SESSIONS COURT/ADDITIONAL SUB COURT, THALASSERY ARISING
OUT OF THE ORDER/JUDGMENT DATED 12.01.2021 IN OS NO.259 OF 2013 OF
PRINCIPAL MUNSIFF COURT, KANNUR
APPELLANT/S:
SATHEESAN. T,
AGED 62 YEARS
S/O LATE YESHODA, VISMAYAM, CHEMBILODE P.O. MOWECHERY,
KANNUR (LEGAL HEIR OF DECEASED YESHODA. T. D1/R1 IN
AS), PIN - 670613
VASANTHA.T,
AGED 68 YEARS
D/O LATE YESHODA ARADHANA, NARIKKODE PANAYATAM
PARAMBA.P.O , KANNUR (LEGAL HEIR OF DECEASED YESHODA.
T. D1/R1 IN AS), PIN - 670611
RAMANI. P.V,
AGED 65 YEARS
D/O LATE YESHODA MURALI KRIPA KIZHUTHALLI, NEAR POLICE
QUARTERS P.O. CHOVVA, KANNUR (LEGAL HEIR OF DECEASED
YESHODA. T. D1/R1 IN AS),
PIN - 670611
JYOTHI DASAN. T
AGED 49 YEARS
D/O LATE YESHODA, JYOTHI NIVAS, KANAYANORE P.O.
MOWANCHERY, KANNUR (LEGAL HEIR OF DECEASED YESHODA. T.
D1/R1 IN AS), PIN - 670613
THANDARATH NALINI
AGED 82 YEARS
D/O.DEVAKI, RESIDING AT THANDARATH HOUSE, CHEMBILODE
AMSOM, MOWANCHERI DESOM, P.O.MOWANCHERI, KANNUR,
PIN - 670613
THANDARATH LAKSHMANAN
AGED 72 YEARS
S/O.DEVAKI, RESIDING AT PATTAYACHALIL HOUSE, CHEMBILODE
AMSOM, MOWANCHERI DESOM P.O.MOWANCHERI, KANNUR,
PIN – 670613
THANDARATH REMESAN
AGED 60 YEARS
S/O.DEVAKI, RESIDING AT PATTAYACHALIL HOUSE, CHEMBILODE
AMSOM, MOWANCHERI DESOM, P.O.MOWANCHERI, KANNUR,
PIN – 670613
R.S.A
No.372 of 2024
- 2 -
C.SANTHA
AGED 74 YEARS
W/O.SREEDHARAN, RESIDING AT PATTAYACHALIL HOUSE,
MUNDERI AMSOM, EACHUR DESOM, P.O. EACHUR, KANNUR,
PIN - 670591
REENA C,
AGED 49 YEARS
D/O.SREEDHARAN, RESIDING AT PATTAYACHALIL HOUSE,
MUNDERI AMSOM, EACHUR DESOM, P.O. EACHUR, KANNUR,
PIN - 670591
C.RIJESH
AGED 47 YEARS
S/O.SREEDHARAN, RESIDING AT PATTAYACHALIL HOUSE,
MUNDERI AMSOM, EACHUR DESOM, P.O. EACHUR, KANNUR,
PIN - 670591
C.REJULA
AGED 45 YEARS
D/O.SREEDHARAN, RESIDING AT PATTAYACHALIL HOUSE,
MUNDERI AMSOM, EACHUR DESOM, P.O. EACHUR, KANNUR,
PIN - 670591
THEKKEYIL SUJITHA
AGED 62 YEARS
W/O.GANGADHARAN RESIDING AT THAKKEYIL HOUSE, ELAYAVOOR
AMSOM, KEEZHUTHALLI DESOM, THAZHE CHOVVA, KANNUR
DISTRICT, PIN - 670018
BALAKANDI SUMA
AGED 52 YEARS
W/O.VIJAYAN, RESIDING AT BALAKANDI HOUSE, CHEMBILODE
AMSOM, PANAYATHAMPARAMBA DESOM P.O.PANAYATHAMPARAMBA,
KANNUR DISTRICT, PIN - 670595
BALAKANDI SAYOOJ,
AGED 29 YEARS
S/O.VIJAYAN, RESIDING AT BALAKANDI HOUSE, CHEMBILODE
AMSOM, PANAYATHAMPARAMBA DESOM P.O.PANAYATHAMPARAMBA,
KANNUR DISTRICT, PIN - 670595
BALAKANDI SNEHA
AGED 28 YEARS
D/O.VIJAYAN, RESIDING AT BALAKANDI HOUSE,CHEMBILODE
AMSOM, PANAYATHAMPARAMBA DESOM P.O.PANAYATHAMPARAMBA,
KANNUR DISTRICT, PIN – 670595
MAHIJA E,
AGED 61 YEARS
RESIDING AT THEJUS, KOTTANCHICHERI, P.O. KANHIORDE
KUDIKKIMOTTA, KANNUR, PIN – 670592
R.S.A
No.372 of 2024
- 3 -
BHAVIA E,
AGED 33 YEARS
D/O.BHARATHAN, RESIDING THEJUS, KOTTANCHICHERI, P.O.
KANHIORDE KUDIKKIMOTTA, KANNUR, PIN - 670592
KAVIA E,
AGED 29 YEARS
D/O.BHARATHAN, RESIDING THEJUS, KOTTANCHICHERI, P.O.
KANHIORDE KUDIKKIMOTTA, KANNUR, PIN - 670592
BY ADVS.
ABDUL RAOOF PALLIPATH
E.MOHAMMED SHAFI
KRISHNAPRIYA R.
SITHARA RAHEEM V.K.
RESPONDENT/S:
POTHUVARATH VIJAYAN
AGED 66 YEARS
S/O. JANAKI, RESIDING AT POTHUVARATH HOUSE, MUNDERI
AMSOM, EACHUR DESOM, P.O. EACHUR KANNUR DISTRICT,
PIN - 670591
POTHUVARATH RADHA
AGED 75 YEARS
D/O. JANAKI, RESIDING AT POTHUVARATH HOUSE, MUNDERI
AMSOM, PURAVOOR, P.O. KANHIRODE KANNUR DISTRICT,
PIN - 670591
POTHUVARATH SASIDHARAN
AGED 69 YEARS
S/O. JANAKI, RESIDING AT POTHUVARATH HOUSE, MUNDERI
AMSOM, EACHUR DESOM, P.O. EACHUR KANNUR DISTRICT,
PIN - 670591
POTHUVARATH BALAN @ BABU
AGED 58 YEARS
S/O. JANAKI, RESIDING AT POTHUVARATH HOUSE, MUNDERI
AMSOM, EACHUR DESOM, P.O. EACHUR KANNUR DISTRICT,,
PIN - 670591
POTHUVARATH VASUMATHI
AGED 71 YEARS
D/O. NARAYANAN, RESIDING AT GOKULAM, MUZHAPILANGAD
AMSOM, DESOM, P.O. MUZHAPILANGAD, KANNUR DISTRICT,
PIN - 670662
POTHUVARATH REMA,
AGED 68 YEARS
D/O. NARAYANAN, RESIDING AT SWAPNA NIVAS, MUZHAPILANGAD
AMSOM, DESOM, P.O. MUZHAPILANGAD, KANNUR DISTRICT,
PIN - 670662
MITHUN GANGADHARAN
R.S.A
No.372 of 2024
- 4 -
AGED 33 YEARS
S/O. GANGADHARAN, RESIDING AT THEKEYIL HOUSE ELAYAVOOR
AMSOM, KIZHUTHALLI DESOM, P.O. THAZHE CHOVVA KANNUR
DISTRICT, PIN - 670018
JITHIN GANGADHARAN
AGED 29 YEARS
S/O. GANGADHARAN, RESIDING AT THEKEYIL HOUSE ELAYAVOOR
AMSOM, KIZHUTHALLI DESOM, P.O. THAZHE CHOVVA KANNUR
DISTRICT, PIN - 670018
SEETHA. C,
W/O LATE P. RAJAN PODUVARATH HOUSE, KOTTANICHERI NEAR
KOTTANICHERI ANGAN VADI P.O.EACHUR- KANNUR,
PIN - 670591
SHAMNA. P
D/O LATE P. RAJAN PODUVARATH HOUSE, KOTTANICHERI NEAR
KOTTANICHERI ANGAN VADI P.O.EACHUR- KANNUR,
PIN - 670591
SHAJU. P,
S/O LATE P.RAJAN PODUVARATH HOUSE, KOTTANICHERI NEAR
KOTTANICHERI ANGAN VADI P.O.EACHUR- KANNUR, PIN 670591
SHERIL CHAKKARAYAN,
S/O LATE P.RAJAN PODUVARATH HOUSE, KOTTANICHERI NEAR
KOTTANICHERI ANGAN VADI P.O.EACHUR- KANNUR,
PIN - 670591
THIS REGULAR SECOND
ADMISSION ON 19.07.2024,
DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
APPEAL HAVING COME UP
THE COURT ON THE SAME
FOR
DAY
R.S.A
No.372 of 2024
- 5 -
J U D G M E N T
The Defendants 1 to 3, 5 to 10, 13, 14, 15 and
the legal heirs of the deceased 4th defendant are the
appellants in this Regular Second Appeal. The parties
are
referred
according
to
their
status
before
the
Trial Court.
2.
The
plaintiffs
Janaki,
who
was
the
are
daughter
the
children
of
one
of
one
Pothuvarathu
Kalyani who was the 3rd wife of one Punnakkal Kunhappa.
The plaintiffs preferred the suit for declaration of
title,
recovery
injunction
of
with
possession
respect
to
and
for
a
perpetual
the
Plaint
Schedule
Property of 23 cents of land, on the averments that
the
Punnakkal
01.09.1950
Kunhappa
bequeathing
executed
item
Ext.A1
No.1
to
Will
dated
properties
therein to his children in the 1st wife by them, item
No. 9 to 10 properties therein to the children to the
second
wife
Povanath
Kalyani
and
Item
No.21
was
bequeathed with 3rd wife Pothuvarath Kalyani and item
No.22 was bequeathed to his grand daughter; that after
R.S.A
No.372 of 2024
- 6 -
the death of Kunhappa, the Ext.A1 Will came into force
and
the
respective
respective
plots
bequeathed
were
that
devolved
Pothuvarath
upon
the
Kalyani,
who
derived Item No.21 property transferred 68 cents of
land to one Puthalath Raman, the husband of Pothuvarth
Devaki in the year 1956 as per Ext.A3 document and the
remaining
extent
of
cents
of
land
was
in
the
possession of Pothuvarath Kalyani that on the death of
Kalyani, the said 23 cents which is included in the
Plaint Schedule was devolved upon her children Janaki
and
Narayanan;
that
after
the
death
of
Janaki,
plaintiffs 1 to 5 derived right over the property and
after
the
death
of
Naraynan,
plaintiffs
and
derived right over the plaint schedule property; that
the defendants are the children and legal heirs of
deceased children of Pothuvarth Devaki, daughter of
Kunhappa in his 1st wife who died in the year 2009;
that the plaintiffs are residing far away from the
plaint
schedule
property
adjacent
property;
to
the
that
the
defendants
plaint
schedule
got
property;
that when the plaintiffs went to the Village office to
remit
basic
tax
for
during
April
2010,
the
the
plaint
village
schedule
officer
property
refused
to
R.S.A
No.372 of 2024
- 7 -
receive basic tax stating that the defendants have
been
paying
basic
tax
for
the
plaint
schedule
property; that ultimately the matter was considered by
the
Sub
dated
Collector,
26.03.2012
Thalassery
directing
and
the
he
1st
passed
order
plaintiff
to
approach the Civil Court and accordingly, the present
suit is filed.
3.
The defendants 1 to 10 and 13 to 15 filed
Written Statement denying the plaint averments that
Pothuvarath Kalyani
was the 3rd wife of
Punnakkal
Kunjappa; and that Pothuvarath Kalyani sold 68 cents
of land
after the property devolved upon her as per
Will executed by Kunhappa in favour of Puthalath Raman
and
admitting
execution
and
registration
of
Ext.A1
Will by Kunhappa with respect to the said properties.
The said defendants further contended that even though
item No.21 was set apart to Pothuvarath Kalyani as per
Ext.A1 Will, the executor of the Will transferred this
property
during
the
lifetime
itself
to
Puthalath
Raman, the predecessor of defendants, and hence the
said property was not available when the Will came
into force. They raised an alternate contention that
R.S.A
No.372 of 2024
- 8 -
the right of the plaintiffs over the plaint schedule
property
had
lost
by
the
adverse
possession
and
limitation.
4.
The Trial Court dismissed the suit initially
as per judgment dated 25.02.2021, finding that the
plaintiff failed to prove execution of Ext.A1 Will
(which is the certified copy of the Will) by producing
the
original
of
the
Will
before
the
Court
and
examining the attesting witness. The Trial Court found
that the defendants failed to prove that the right of
plaintiff over the plaint schedule property was lost
by adverse possession and limitation. The plaintiffs
filed A.S.No. 36/2015 before the First Appellate Court
and
the
First
Appellate
Court
by
judgment
dated
20.05.2019 confirmed the finding of the Trial Court on
issue
No.2
with
regard
to
adverse
possession
and
limitation and remanded the matter back to the Trial
Court to give reasonable opportunity to the plaintiff
to produce the original of Ext.A1 Will or to take
steps to establish the ground necessary to adduce the
secondary evidence of the Will and to prove the same,
holding that, if the
plaintiffs succeed to prove the
R.S.A
No.372 of 2024
- 9 -
circumstance
to
enable
them
to
adduce
secondary
evidence to mark Ext.A1 evidence, the Trial Court can
presume due execution of the original of Ext.A1 Will
under Sec.90 of the Indian Evidence Act.
5.
Thereafter, the plaintiff amended the plaint,
incorporating Paragraph No.16(a) that the plaintiffs
are not in possession of original Will which is marked
as Ext.A1; that to their knowledge, the original of
Ext.A1 Will has gone into the hands of the children of
Devaki who are the defendants 1 to 5. Thereafter, PW1
was
further
examined
in
support
of
the
plaint
allegation.
6.
By the impugned judgment passed by the Trial
Court, the Trial Court found available materials are
sufficient to draw a presumption that the original of
Ext.A1 Will is duly executed by Punnakkal Kunhappa and
duly attested by the attesting witnesses and it came
into
force
after
the
death
of
Kunhappa
that
the
plaintiffs got title over the plaint schedule property
as the remaining portion of the plot after transfer of
68 cents of land as per Ext.A3 in favour of Raman, the
predecessor of the defendants. Accordingly allowed the
R.S.A
No.372 of 2024
- 10 -
suit
granting
possession
prohibitory
from
declaration
the
title,
defendants
injunction
plaintiffs. The
of
as
recovery
and
sought
of
consequential
for
by
the
Defendants 1 to 3, 5 to 10, 13, 14,
15 and the legal heirs of the deceased 4 th defendant
filed A.S.No. 31/2021 and the same was dismissed by
the
First
Appellate
31.01.2024,
confirming
Court
the
by
judgment
judgment
dated
and
decree
the
passed by the Trial Court.
7.
Heard the counsel for the appellant Sri Abdul
Raoof Pallipath.
8.
The Counsel for the appellant submitted that
the execution of Will is not properly proved after
remand of the matter by the First Appellate Court when
a specific direction was made for the same. According
to
him,
Sec.90
of
the
Indian
Evidence
Act
is
not
available to prove a Will. He cited in a decision of
Hon’ble Supreme Court dated 14/03/2023 in Civil Appeal
No. 7775/2021 in which it is held that Wills cannot be
proved only on the basis of their age - presumption
under Sec.90 as to the regularity of documents more
than 30 years of age is inapplicable when it comes to
R.S.A
No.372 of 2024
- 11 -
proof of wills, which have to be proved in terms of
Sec.63(c) with of the Succession
Act 1925 and Sec.68
of the Evidence Act 1972. He also cited Division Bench
decision
of
this
Court
in
Sarada
[2017(2)
KLT
372]
and
contended
execution
of
Will
is
not
V.
that
Radhamani
in
even
if
the
denied
or
specifically
expressly admitted, the Propounder has to discharge
his
burden
with
respect
to
execution
of
Will
by
calling at least one of the attesting witnesses.
9.
I find from the impugned judgments that the
contesting
defendants
did
not
dispute
execution
of
Ext.A1 Will, which is of the year 1950. The plaintiff
has
produced
certified
copy
of
the
said
will
as
Ext.A1. With respect to the contents of Will also, the
contesting defendants cannot have any objection. They
also claim 68 cents of property, which is the part of
the property derived by Pothuvarath Kalyani, through
their predecessor Puthalath Raman who got the property
from
Pothuvarath
Kalyani.
Since
defendants
also
derived property on the basis of Ext.A1 Will, through
the predecessor the plaintiff, the defendants could
not
make
any
challenge
against
Ext.A1
Will.
The
R.S.A
No.372 of 2024
- 12 -
contention of the contesting defendants was that the
testator had transferred by the property covered under
Item 21 bequeathed to Pothuvarath Kalyani even before
his death and as on the date when the will came into
force, Item No.21 property was not available. Here
also, Puthalath Raman, the predecessor of defendants
obtained 68 cents of land from the very same Item
No.21
from
Pothuvarth
Kalyani
as
per
Ext.A3.
That
apart, the defendants did not produce any document to
prove that the testator parted with the said property
before his death.
10. In
Appellate
the
Court
first
round
of
litigation,
remanded
the
matter
to
prove
the
the
execution of Ext.A1 will, taking note of Sec.90 of the
Indian Evidence Act. The defendants did not challenge
the said remand order. I am of the view that said
exercise was not necessary since execution of Will is
admitted
by
defendants
and
they
also
obtained
the
property on the strength of the said Will.
11. In
the
decision
in
Sharada’s
case
(supra)
this Court found that propounder has to discharge his
burden when the Will is not specifically denied or
R.S.A
No.372 of 2024
- 13 -
expressly
admitted.
The
said
decision
is
not
applicable in the case on hand as the defendants had
specifically admitted the execution of Ext.A1 Will.
Under
the
illegality
in
circumstances,
the
impugned
I
do
judgments.
not
find
None
of
any
the
questions of law framed in the Memorandum of Appeal
arise in the matter and accordingly the Regular Second
Appeal is dismissed.
Sd/-
M.A.ABDUL HAKHIM
JUDGE
SM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review