Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT RAWAL
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K. V. JAYAKUMAR
WEDNESDAY, THE 19TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 28TH PHALGUNA, 1946
OP (CAT) NO. 46 OF 2024
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 25.01.2024 IN O.A. NO.448 OF 2020 OF
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, ERNAKULAM BENCH
PETITIONER(S)/APPLICANT:
SASI K.K.,
AGED 55 YEARS
S/O. KUNJU, ASSISTANT FINANCE AND ACCOUNTS OFFICER,
CENTRAL PLANTATION CROPS RESEARCH INSTITUTE,
REGIONAL STATION, VITTAL, D.K. DIST. KARNATAKA,
NOW WORKING AT INDIAN COUNCIL OF AGRICULTURAL
RESEARCH,DCR, PUTTUR, DHARBE, DK DIST. KARNATAKA,
RESIDING AT KADUKAPARAMBIL HOUSE, ERAVAKAD,
CHITTISSERY P.O., THRISSUR DISTRICT,, PIN - 680301
BY ADVS.
S.P.ARAVINDAKSHAN PILLAY
N.SANTHA
V.VARGHESE
PETER JOSE CHRISTO
S.A.ANAND
K.N.REMYA
L.ANNAPOORNA
VISHNU V.K.
RESPONDENT(S):
THE DIRECTOR,
CENTRAL PLANTATION CROPS RESEARCH INSTITUTE, KASARAGOD,
KUDLU P.O., KASARAGOD DISTRICT, PIN - 671124
THE HEAD,
CENTRAL PLANTATION CROPS RESEARCH INSTITUTE,
-2-
OP (CAT) NO. 46 OF 2024
2025:KER:27446
REGIONAL STATION, VITTAL P.O., D.K. DIST,
KARNATAKA, PIN - 574243
ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICER,
CENTRAL PLANTATION CROPS RESEARCH INSTITUTE,
KASARAGOD, KUDLU P.O., KASARAGOD DISTRICT,
PIN - 671124
SENIOR FINANCE AND ACCOUNTS OFFICER,
CENTRAL PLANTATION CROPS RESEARCH INSTITUTE,
KASARAGOD, KUDLU P.O., KASARAGOD DISTRICT,
PIN - 671124
THE SECRETARY,
INDIAN COUNCIL OF AGRICULTURAL RESEARCH,
KRISHI BHAVAN, NEW DELHI, PIN - 110001
BY ADV.
SMT.BHADRA KUMARI K.V.
THIS
19.03.2025,
FOLLOWING:
OP
(CAT)
THE
COURT
HAVING
ON
BEEN
THE
SAME
FINALLY
DAY
HEARD47
ON
DELIVERED
THE
-3-
OP (CAT) NO. 46 OF 2024
2025:KER:27446
JUDGMENT
AMIT RAWAL , J.
The present O.P.(CAT) is directed against the
decision dated 25.01.2024 of the Central Administrative
Tribunal in O.A.No.448 of 2020, whereby the claim of the
applicant – petitioner for reimbursement of medical
treatment undertaken by his mother and unmarried
sister for a genetic disease called osteopetrosis, has been
declined.
2.
Succinctly
the
facts
in
brief
for
adjudication of the lis are enumerated hereinbelow:
Petitioner-applicant is working as an Assistant
Finance and Accounts Officer with the department of
Central Plantation Crops Research Institute, Regional
Station, Karnataka.
Despite having his wife and two
children his family consists of parents one unmarried
sister and one working sister.
The parents, unmarried
sister and children has been shown as dependents as per
the family composition Annexure A2.
All the family
OP (CAT) NO. 46 OF 2024
-42025:KER:27446
members are suffering from Pycknodisostosis, which is in
a common parlance called osteoporosis.
One out of
fifteen lakh suffers from this genetic disorder called Auto
Immune Disorder and has to be very careful in day to day
occasions
as one
fracture would lead to multiple
fractures and has to undertake medication.
It is
contended that the father is a pensioner from the Kerala
State
Government
Service
with
pension
about
Rs.18,180/- (Rupees Eighteen thousand one hundred and
eighty only), whereas the claim for reimbursement of
Rs.3,78,800/- towards the treatment expenses of his
mother for the period 26.11.2018 to 25.01.2019 and of
his unmarried sister from 30.04.2018 to 24.08.2018 has
been rejected vide the impugned order Ext.A6.
It is
further contended that prior to the passing of the
impugned order the department was reimbursing the
medical expenses for treatment of the mother and the
unmarried sister. Even the father, the pensioner, is also
suffering and has not claimed the Central Government
-5-
OP (CAT) NO. 46 OF 2024
2025:KER:27446
Health (CGH) Scheme showing all the family members as
dependents.
2.
Respondents contested the matter and
submitted that though as per the Central Services
(Medical Attendance) Rules, 1944, parents including
adoptive parents, step-mother, sisters, widowed sisters,
divorced/abandoned
or
separated
sisters,
widowed
daughters, divorced/ abandoned/separated daughters,
minor brothers, permanently disabled brother, children
and step children are fall within the definition of family
in Rule 2 of the Appendix XIII, but in the absence of any
direct materials that both mother and unmarried sister
are dependents particularly the other sister who is
working, the medical reimbursement was rejected.
3.
Learned
tribunal
on
noticing
the
contention in paragraph Nos.12, 13 and 14 rejected the
claim.
4.
Mr.S.P.Aravindakshan
Pillay,
learned
counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner submitted
OP (CAT) NO. 46 OF 2024
-62025:KER:27446
that the order of the tribunal is totally opaque and
repugnant
for
the
reason
that
no
plausible
and
reasonable explanation has come forth in denying the
medical reimbursement by taking into consideration the
definition of family in Rule 2 of Appendix XIII of the
Central Services (Medical Attendance) Rules, 1944. One
of the reasoning for rejecting the claim is that the
applicant is not the only child of the parents, but has a
sister who is employed as a teacher and another brother
who is suffering from osteopetrosis. Non availability of
the means to take care of the family is wholly justified for
the reason that the unmarried sister is also suffering
from the same decease and is able to recoup her medical
expenses by claiming the medical reimbursement for
herself. Father is only getting a pension of Rs.18,180/plus Dearness Allowances and cannot take care of the
other dependents from the members like the mother and
the unmarried sister as he himself is a sufferer of the
genetic decease. It is not the case that the petitioner at
OP (CAT) NO. 46 OF 2024
-72025:KER:27446
any point of time after the retirement of his father had
ever submitted a claim for his treatment.
The upper
financial limit of Rs.9,000/- (Rupees Nine thousand only)
in Annexure R1 can be only applied with regard to the
medical claim for reimbursement raised by the pensioner
himself.
K.V.,
5.
On the other hand, Smt.Bhadra Kumari
learned
counsel
appearing
on
behalf
of
the
respondents countered the aforementioned arguments by
submitting that the reasoning assigned by the tribunal is
perfectly legal and justified and do not require any
different opinion qua entertaining the present O.P.
Petitioner had claimed the medical expenses in respect
of his mother and unmarried sister on a number of times
amounting to lakhs of rupees, as he himself was the
authority to pre-audit all the bills pertaining to the
regional station even though the expenditure had been
sanctioned by the competent authority.
Petitioner’s
mother and unmarried sister are not depended upon the
OP (CAT) NO. 46 OF 2024
-82025:KER:27446
petitioner but on his father, who was not depended on,
and also drawing a pension of Rs.18,180/- (Rupees
Eighteen thousand one hundred and eighty only) plus
Dearness Allowances. Government of India has issued a
direction for determining the dependency kept out for
reimbursement as Annexure R1, which categorically
states that the income limit for the purpose of providing
the CGHS coverage to the family members of the CGHS
covered under the Central Government employees to
Rs.9,000/- (Rupees Nine thousand only) plus the amount
of the dearness relief on the basic pension of Rs.9,000/(Rupees Nine thousand only) as on the date of the
consideration.
6.
We have heard learned counsel for the
parties and appraised the paper book and of the view
that there is force on merit in the submissions.
7.
Annexure R1 reads as under:
“OFFICER MEMORANDUM
Sub:
Revision of income limit for dependency
for the purpose of providing Central
-9-
OP (CAT) NO. 46 OF 2024
2025:KER:27446
Government. Health Scheme (CGHS)
coverage to family members of the CGHS
covered employees subsequent to
implementation of recommendation of
the seventh Central pay commissionregarding.
The undersigned is directed to say that
subsequent
to
the
implementation
of
the
recommendations of the 6th CPC, the income
limit
for
dependency
for
the
purpose
of
extending CGHS coverage to "family" members
of
the CGHS covered Central Government
employees
was
enhanced
to
Rs.
3500/-per
month plus the amount of dearriess rellef on the
basic pension of Rs. 3500/- as on the date of
consideration.
2.
With
the
recommendations
Implementation
of
the
7th
of
the
Central
pay
commission, the issue of revision of income limit
for dependency for the purpose of providing
CGHS coverage to family members of the CGHS
covered Central Government employees and
pensioner
CGHS
beneficiaries
was
under
consideration keeping in view the amount of
minimum pension/family pension fixed by the 7 th
central pay commission
3. On the basis of the recommendations
of the 7th CPC, the Department of Pension and
Pensioners' Welfare under Para 5.2 of their OM
-10-
OP (CAT) NO. 46 OF 2024
2025:KER:27446
No. 38/37/2016-P&PW (A)(I) dated 4/8/2016,
has fixed the amount of minimum pension as Rs.
9,000/-per month and under para 7.1 of this OM
the amount of family pension has been fixed as
30% of the basic pay in revised pay structure
and shall be subject to a minimum of Rs. 9,000/per month and maximum of 30% of the highest
pay in the Government. Vide Para 7.3 of the
aforesaid O.M it has been mentioned that there
will be no other change in the provisions
regulating family pension.
4. It has been decided, in consultation
with the Department of Expenditure, to revise
the income limit for the purpose of providing.
CGHS coverage to the family members of the
CGHS, covered Central Government employees
to Rs. 9,000/- plus the amount of dearness relief
on basic pension of Rs. 9,000/- as on the date of
consideration".
5. As such, all the orders related to the
CGHS Rules stand amended to the extent that
the income limit for Rs.3500/- per month from
all sources Including pension/and family pension
stands amended to an income of Rs.9000/- plus
amount of the dearness relief om the basic
pension
of
Rs.9000/-
as
on
the
date
of
consideration. The amount of dearness relief as
indicated in the income limit stands for the
-11-
OP (CAT) NO. 46 OF 2024
2025:KER:27446
amount
of
dearness
pensioner/family
relief
pensioner
on
drawn
by
a
the
date
of
consideration and not the amount of dearness
relief due on the date of consideration.”
8.
This applies to the employees who have
undertaken the CGH Scheme. Concededly the father of
the petitioner was not a Central Government employee
but a State Government, therefore the limit of Rs.9,000/would not be applicable. It would be axiomatic to extract
the definition of family in Rule 2 of Appendix XIII of
Rules of 1944. The same reads as under:
“APPENDIX XIII
CONCESSIONS FOR FAMILIES OF
CENTRAL GOVERNMENT SERVANTS
1. Families of Central Government servants are
entitled to n. attendance and/or treatment, as
defined in the CS (MA) Rules, 1944 and the
orders issued thereunder, on the scale and
conditions
himself,
allowed
subject
to
to
Government
such
servant
exceptions
or
restrictions specified herein or in the said rules.
Note 1: The provisions of this Appendix apply
-12-
OP (CAT) NO. 46 OF 2024
2025:KER:27446
mutatis
mutandis
to
female
Government servants also.
Note 2: The Authorised Medical Attendant of
the family of a Government servant is
the same as the Authorised Medical
Attendant of the Government servant.
Note 3: The family of a Government servant is
entitled to receive medical attendance
and treatment at the hospital at which
the Government servant himself is
entitled. A list of hospitals recognised
for the purpose of medical attendance
and treatment of Central Government
servants and members of their families
is given in Appendix I.
DEFINITION OF FAMILY
2. General Conditions
The term 'family' for the purpose of the Central
Services (Medical Attendance) Rules, 1944,
shall mean a Government servant's wife or
husband, as the case may be, parents including
adoptive parents, step-mother, sisters, widowed
sisters,
divorced/abandoned
or
separated
sisters,
widowed
daughters,
divorced/
abandoned/separated
brothers,
permanently
daughters,
minor
disabled
brother,
children and step children wholly dependent
OP (CAT) NO. 46 OF 2024
-132025:KER:27446
upon the Government servant.
Note 1: A member of the family is treated as
dependant only if his/her income from
all sources including pension/family
pension and pension equivalent of
gratuity does not exceed Rs. 3,500
p.m. plus dearness relief drawn on
basic pension of Rs. 3500 as on the
date of consideration. The condition of
dependency both in the case of
husband or the wife of the Government
servant has been dispensed with.”
9.
On perusal of the definition of family, it is
evident that the sister and the mother falls in the
category of dependents. It is a matter of record that all
the family members consisting of petitioner and his
brother and two unmarried sisters including the mother
and the father are suffering from the same very disease
which is a genetic disorder, a kind of an auto immune
disorder, for which, treatment is required for prevention
of further deterioration.
During the course of the
hearing, Mr.S.P.Aravindakshan Pillay submitted that the
OP (CAT) NO. 46 OF 2024
-142025:KER:27446
earlier
reimbursement
bills,
no
doubt,
have
been
sanctioned by the competent authority and this fact was
examined by the learned tribunal after verifying the files
summoned for that purpose.
It is not the case of
misusing the power, as petitioner has not faced any
departmental enquiry or other modes of recovery.
10.
The reasoning of the tribunal in our
considered view is not justified for the reason that the
other unmarried sister, who is also suffering from the
very same disease is bearing her own medical treatment
and therefore, she cannot through the income derived as
a salary offset the medical reimbursement expenses viza-viz the mother and other sister.
For the reason aforementioned, we set aside the
judgment of the Central Administrative Tribunal on the
ground that both unmarried sister and the mother falls in
the definition of the ‘family’ being dependents and
petitioner is entitled to medical reimbursement for their
treatment.
Impugned order Annexure A6 is hereby
OP (CAT) NO. 46 OF 2024
-152025:KER:27446
quashed.
O.P.(CAT) is allowed.
Respondents are
directed to pay the medical expenses within a period of
one month from the date of receipt of the certified copy
of the judgment.
Sd/-
AMIT RAWAL
JUDGE
Sd/K. V. JAYAKUMAR
JUDGE
VV
OP (CAT) NO. 46 OF 2024
-162025:KER:27446
APPENDIX OF OP (CAT) 46/2024
PETITIONER ANNEXURES
ANNEXURE A6
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER IN F
NO.21(1)5(RS&RC)/2019-BILLS ISSUED BY
THE RESPONDENT NO.3, DATED 28.07.2020.
ANNEXURE A1
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER OF APPOINTMENT
GIVEN TO THE APPLICANT BY RESPONDENT
NO.1 DATED 01.06.2010.
ANNEXURE A2
TRUE COPY OF THE DECLARATION GIVEN TO
THE RESPONDENT NO.1 BY THE APPLICANT
DATED 27.04.2019.
ANNEXURE A3
TRUE COPY OF THE DISABILITY
CERTIFICATE ISSUED BY THE MEDICAL
BOARD OF GOVERNMENT MEDICAL COLLEGE,
THRISSUR TO THE APPLICANT’S SISTER
SUJATHA K.K., DATED 07.04.2015.
ANNEXURE A4
TRUE COPY OF THE DISABILITY
CERTIFICATE ISSUED TO THE APPLICANT BY
THE MEDICAL BOARD OF GOVERNMENT
MEDICAL COLLEGE, THRISSUR, DATED
07.04.2015
ANNEXURE A5
TRUE COPY OF THE CERTIFICATE ISSUED BY
DR.SURENDRA U. KAMATH, CONSULTANT
ORTHOPAEDIC, K.M.C. HOSPITAL,
MANGALORE TO THE APPLICANT, DATED
08.06.2019.
ANNEXURE A7
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER OF THIS HON’BLE
TRIBUNAL IN O.A.(EKM) NO.512/2017
DATED 31.10.2017.
ANNEXURE A8
TRUE COPY OF THE OFFICE MEMORANDUM
DATED 31.05.2007 ISSUED BY MINISTRY OF
HEALTH AND FAMILY WELFARE, GOVERNMENT
OF INDIA.
OP (CAT) NO. 46 OF 2024
-172025:KER:27446
ANNEXURE A9
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER OF THIS HON’BLE
TRIBUNAL IN O.A.NO.469/2014 DATED
16.10.2015.
ANNEXURE A10
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT OF THE
HON’BLE HIGH COURT OF DELHI IN
L.P.A.NO. 764/2017 DATED 01.12.2017.
ANNEXURE R1
TRUE COPY OF THE OM NO.S-11012/2/2016CGHS-P) DATED 08.11.2016.
EXHIBIT -P1
TRUE COPY OF THE O.A.NO.180/00448/2020
BEFORE THE CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE
TRIBUNAL, ERNAKULAM BENCH.
EXHIBIT P2
TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY STATEMENT IN
EXT.P1 FILED BY THE RESPONDENTS.
EXHIBIT P3
TRUE COPY OF THE REJOINDER FILED BY
THE PETITIONER TO EXT.P2.
EXHIBIT P4
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED
25.01.2024 IN O.A.NO.180/00448/2020 OF
THE CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
ERNAKULAM BENCH.
EXHIBIT P5
TRUE COPY OF THE MEDICAL CERTIFICATE
DATED 21.02.2024 ISSUED BY DR.POULOSE
GEORGE, M.D., CONSULTANT PHYSICIAN,
THRISSUR DISTRICT CO-OPERATIVE
HOSPITAL.
EXHIBIT P6
TRUE COPY OF THE DISCHARGE SUMMARY IN
RESPECT OF THE PETITIONER’S FATHER,
ISSUED ON 20.11.2009 BY DR.DEVAPRASAD
S. & DR.DAWN ANTONY, CONSULTANT, NEURO
SURGEONS, ASWINI HOSPITAL PVT. LTD.,
THRISSUR.
EXHIBIT P7
TRUE COPY OF THE CASH SALES BILL DATED
13.02.2024 ISSUED BY ROUND SOUTH
SEVANA MEDICINES, THRISSUR, TO THE
PETITIONER’S FATHER.
OP (CAT) NO. 46 OF 2024
-182025:KER:27446
EXHIBIT P8
TRUE COPY OF THE OF CASH SALES BILL
DATED 15.11.2023 ISSUED BY ROUND SOUTH
SEVANA MEDICINES, THRISSUR, TO THE
PETITIONER’S FATHER.
EXHIBIT P9
TRUE COPY OF THE CASH SALES BILL DATED
04.01.2024 ISSUED BY ROUND SOUTH
SEVANA MEDICINES, THRISSUR, TO THE
PETITIONER’S FATHER.
EXHIBIT P10
TRUE COPY OF THE FRONT PAGE OF THE
RATION CARD IS ISSUED IN FAVOUR OF THE
PETITIONER’S UNMARRIED SISTER
SMT.SUJATHA K.K.
EXHIBIT P11
TRUE COPY OF THE DISCHARGE SUMMARY
DATED 15.06.2023 IN RESPECT OF
SMT.SUJATHA K.K., ISSUED BY KMC
HOSPITAL, MANGALURU.
EXHIBIT P12
TRUE COPY OF THE FINAL BILL DATED
15.06.2023 ISSUED BY KMC HOSPITAL,
MANGALURU.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review