Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
In the High Court at Calcutta
Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction
Appellate Side
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya
And
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Supratim Bhattacharya
WPLRT No. 126 of 2023
Saregama India Limited
Vs.
State of West Bengal and others
For the petitioner
:
Mr. Saktinath Mukherjee, Sr. Adv.,
Mr. Arindam Banerjee, Sr. Adv.,
Mr. Pranit Bag,
Mr. Pourush Bandyopadhyay,
Mr. Victor Chatterjee
Heard and reserved on
:
20.01.2026
Judgment on
:
03.02.2026
Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya, J.:1.
The starting point of the present narrative is an application by the writ
petitioner
Saregama
India
Limited (previously,
the
Gramophone
Company Limited) under Section 4C of the West Bengal Land Reforms
Act, 1955 (hereinafter referred to as “the 1955 Act”) for conversion of
the subject plot for the purpose of residential and commercial user.
The said application gave rise to Miscellaneous Case No.01 of 2020
before the First Authority, that is the Additional District Magistrate and
District Land and Land Reforms Officer (DL & LRO), North 24 Parganas
at Barasat, who, vide Order No.4 dated October 14, 2020, disallowed
the said application for conversion on the ground that the writ
petitioner is a lessee of the plot-in-question within the contemplation of
Section 4B of the 1955 Act and is not entitled to seek such conversion,
which right is available only to raiyats.
2.
The brief backdrop of the case is that a total property comprised of 16.9
acres of land with structure, partially used as factory/workshop of the
petitioner-company, was owned by the petitioner at the time when the
West Bengal Estates Acquisition Act, 1953 (for short, “the 1953 Act”)
came into operation. The said property comprised of two portions, one
on each side of the Jessore Road near Kolkata – one measuring about
1.96 acres and the other about 14.33 acres.
3.
Vide Order No.1536-L.Ref./5M-2/96 dated September 20, 1999 issued
by the Land Reforms Department, Government of West Bengal, the
State of West Bengal allowed the petitioner-company to retain the total
area of 16.29 acres for factory purpose, subject to the condition that an
area of 1.96 acres, as mentioned above, which was not used for the
purpose of running a factory, should be brought to use for the said
purpose within two years from the issuance of the order. In case of the
failure on the part of the petitioner-company to do so, the order of
retention was to be reviewed under the proviso to Section 6(3) of the
1953 Act for resumption.
4.
Subsequently, upon the failure of the petitioner to use the said strip of
1.96 acres of land for factory purpose, the same was resumed by the
State of West Bengal. Being aggrieved by the resumption/vesting, the
petitioner-company filed OA No.299 of 2005, which was dismissed by
the Land Reforms and Tenancy Tribunal vide its judgment dated
February 18, 2013, holding that the resumption of land of 1.96 acres
was valid.
5.
The petitioner-company moved this Court against the same, giving rise
to WPLRT No.67 of 2013, which was allowed by this Court vide order
dated January 17, 2014.
6.
However, the said 1.96 acres of land is not the subject-matter of the
present dispute. The genesis of the present cause of action arose with
an application being filed by the petitioner-company on April 30, 2019
for conversion of the nature and character of the plot of land comprised
of 14.33 acres in total under Section 4C of the 1955 Act.
7.
Since the said application was kept pending for a considerable period,
the petitioner moved OA No.2202 of 2019 (LRTT), which was dispose of
on July 13, 2020 by the Fourth Bench of the West Bengal Land
Reforms and Tenancy Tribunal with a direction upon the DL & LRO to
dispose of the said application within a period of three months from the
date of communication of the order.
8.
Accordingly, the DL & LRO passed an order dated October 14, 2020
rejecting the application for conversion. The said order was challenged
under Section 54 of the 1955 Act before the Commissioner, Presidency
Division, who, vide order dated March 28, 2022, affirmed the rejection
of the conversion application on different grounds than that attributed
by the DL & LRO. Whereas the DL & LRO had held that the petitioner-
company was a lessee by operation of Section 4B of the 1955 Act, since
the land was retained under Section 6(3), read with Section 6(1)(g) of
the 1953 Act, the Commissioner was of the view that the assertion
made by the writ petitioner regarding the factory being operational at
present brought about a new dimension to the conversion application
and observed that there are a number of standard procedures which
need to be followed under various labour laws in case of closure of the
factory and consequent rehabilitation of the workers. It was observed
that closure of such a big factory has numerous socio-economic
consequences which need to be addressed by appropriate authorities
before any conversion.
It was also held that the very purpose of
retention of the land to run a factory would be defeated by the
conversion and accordingly, the appeal of the petitioner was dismissed.
9.
Being thus aggrieved, the petitioner moved the Tribunal, upon which,
by the impugned judgment dated January 3, 2023, the First Bench of
the said Tribunal dismissed the challenge of the writ petitioner bearing
OA No.1635 of 2015 (LRTT), against which the present challenge has
been preferred.
10. Learned senior counsel appearing for the petitioner argues that
although an order was passed, purportedly permitting the petitioner to
retain the land, being required for factory purpose under Section 6(3) of
the 1953 Act, such permission/order was a surplusage since, in any
event, the petitioner was entitled to retain the subject-land of 14.33
acres, along with structure, both under Section 6(1)(b) and Section
6(1)(c) of the said Act, since it fell under the ceiling limit for the purpose
of such retention, which was 15 acres.
11. Under Clause (b) of Section 6(1), an intermediary would be entitled to
retain, from the dated of vesting, the total land comprised in or
appertaining to buildings and structures.
Thus, the portion of the
property where the structure stands, in any event, comes within the
purview of the said clause.
12. Also, as per Clause (c) of Section 6(1), non-agricultural land in khas
possession of the intermediary, not exceeding 15 acres in area, comes
within the purview of land which the intermediary is entitled to retain
automatically.
13. Since the total extent of the subject-property is 14.33 acres, which is
below the ceiling limit of 15 acres as per Clause (c) of Section 6(1) in
any event, the petitioner was entitled to retain the land, with or without
any further permission.
14. As such, with the coming into force of the 1953 Act, the status of the
writ petitioner became that of a raiyat under the State.
15. Hence, it is argued that the premise on which the Tribunal as well as
the fora below proceeded, that the petitioner was a lessee in respect of
the property, is bad in law.
16. Learned senior counsel places reliance on the provisions of Section
4B(2) of the 1955 Act and submits that the same is not attracted in the
present case, since the retention was automatic, under Clauses (b) and
(c) of sub-section (1) of Section 6 of the said Act and the order under
Section 6(1)(g), read with Section 6 (3) of the Act was a mere
surplusage.
17. As per Section 4C of the said Act, a “raiyat” holding any land may apply
to the Collector for change of area or character of such land or for
conversion of the same for any purpose other than the purpose for
which it was settled or was being previously used or for alteration in
the mode of use of such land.
18. It is argued that after the coming into force of the 1955 Act, the Act
took over insofar as the lands covered by the same are concerned.
19. Thus, although initially the land-in-question was used as a factory and
a superfluous order under Section 6(3) was passed, upon the land
being retained within the contemplation of Section 6(1), clauses (b) and
(c) of the 1953 Act, the petitioner-company automatically continued as
a raiyat. Hence, the petitioner comes within the purview of Section 4C
of the 1955 Act for the purpose of enabling the petitioner to apply for
conversion as a raiyat.
The previous user of land cannot be a
deterrent, it is contended, for seeking conversion since the petitioner is
now governed by the 1955 Act, which specifically permits a raiyat to
apply for conversion of the character of the land.
20. Learned senior counsel argues that in the event Section 6(1), Clauses
(a) to (e) of the 1953 Act apply, the retention is automatic, irrespective
of the applicability of Section 6(3) over and above the same.
21. By placing reliance on the language of Rule 4A of the West Bengal
Estates Acquisition Rules, 1954 (“the 1954 Rules”, in short), learned
senior counsel argues that sub-rule (1) thereof stipulates that every
intermediary entitled to retain possession of lands under sub-section
(1) of Section 6 of the 1953 Act, shall, if he chooses to retain any such
land, make his choice by furnishing to the Settlement Officer or to the
Revenue Officer a statement in writing in the form and within the time
stipulated therein. The proviso thereto, it is submitted, stipulates that
if the area of land held by a raiyat or an under-raiyat, who is deemed to
be an intermediary under Section 52, does not exceed the limit laid
down under Clause (c) of sub-section (1) of Section 6, he shall not be
required to exercise such choice.
22. Read in conjunction with the said Rule, learned senior counsel also
relies on sub-section (5) of Section 6 of the 1953 Act, which provides
that an intermediary is to exercise his choice for retention of land under
sub-section (1) in such time and manner as prescribed; but if no choice
is exercised, the Revenue Officer shall, after giving him an opportunity
of being heard, allow him to retain so much of the land as does not
exceed the limit specified in Clause (c), etc., of the said sub-section.
23. Thus, it is reiterated that vesting is automatic and no form is required
to be submitted for retention of land, if the land held by the raiyat is
within the permissible ceiling limit.
24. Learned senior counsel cites State of West Bengal and others v. Calcutta
Mineral Supply Company Private Limited and another, reported at (2015)
8 SCC 655, in support of the proposition that if a land is governed by
Section 6(1), Clauses (a) to (e), it could not be subjected to Section 6(3)
of the 1953 Act.
25. Learned senior counsel next cites a Division Bench judgment of this
Court in BRC Construction Company Private Limited and Another v.
State of West Bengal and Others, reported at 2015 SCC OnLine Cal
5146, where it was observed, inter alia, that as the land of the
petitioner therein was well within the ceiling limit with existing
structures, even assuming that Section 6(3) applies to the land, still the
State cannot resume the land-in-question.
26. Learned senior counsel also relies on State of West Bengal and Others v.
Ratnagiri Engineering Private Limited and Others, reported at (2009) 4
SCC 453, in support of the said arguments.
27. Lastly, learned senior counsel relies on another co-ordinate Bench
Judge of this Court in the matter of Juhi Finalease (P) Ltd. & Anr. v.
State of West Bengal & Ors., reported at 2017 SCC OnLine Cal 5043,
where BRC Construction Company Private Limited (supra)1 was relied on.
28. As recorded in our order dated January 20, 2026, since none appeared
for the State-respondents at the time of hearing, the writ petition is
being disposed of ex parte on merits.
29. The short question which falls for consideration in the present writ
petition is whether, in view of an order being passed under Section 6(3)
of the 1953 Act, the status of the petitioner-company would be that of a
BRC Construction Company Private Limited and Another v. State of West Bengal
and Others, reported at 2015 SCC OnLine Cal 5146
lessee by operation of Section 4B(2) of the 1955 Act. A consequential
issue which falls for consideration is the interplay between Sections
6(1)(b) and (c) on the one hand and 6(3), read with Section 6(1)(g), of the
1953 Act on the other.
30. In order to resolve the said issues, the language of Section 6 of the
1953 Act is required to be looked into. The said provision is set out
hereinbelow:
“6. Right of intermediary to retain certain lands.—(1) Notwithstanding anything
contained in sections 4 and 5, an intermediary shall, except in the cases mentioned in
the proviso to sub-section (2) but subject to the other provision of that sub-section, be
entitled t retain with effect from the date of vesting—
(a) land comprised in homesteads;
(b) land comprised in or appertaining to buildings and structures 1 owned by
the intermediary or by any person, not being a tenant, holding under him
by leave or license;
Explanation.-- For the purposes of this clause „tenant‟ shall not include
a thika tenant as defined in the Calcutta Thika Tenancy Act, 1949 (West
Ben. Act II of 1949);
(c) non-agricultural land in his khas possession including land held under him
by any person, not being a tenant, by leave or license, not exceeding fifteen
acres in area, and excluding any land retained under clause (a):
Provided that the total area of land retained by an intermediary under
clauses (a) and (c) shall not exceed twenty acres, as may be chosen by him:
Provided further that if the land retained by an intermediary under
clause (c) or any part thereof is not utilised for a period of five consecutive
years from the date of vesting, for a gainful or productive purpose, the land
or the part thereof may be resumed by the State Government subject to
payment of compensation determined in accordance with the principles laid
down in sections 23 and 24 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (I of 1894);
(d) agricultural land in his khas possession, not exceeding twenty-five acres in
area, as may be chosen by him:
Provided that in such portions of the district of Darjeeling as may be
declared by notification by the State Government to be hilly portions, an
intermediary shall be entitled to retain all agricultural land in his khas
possession, or any part thereof as may be chosen by him;]
(e) tank-fisheries;
Explanation.--'Tank fishery' means a reservoir or place for the storage
of water, whether formed naturally or by excavation or by construction of
embankments, which is being used for pisciculture or for fishing, together
with the sub-soil and the banks of such reservoir or place, except such
portion of the banks as are included in a homestead or in a garden or
orchard and includes any right of pisciculture or fishing in such reservoir or
place;
(f) subject to the provisions of sub-section (3), land comprised in tea gardens or
orchards or land used for the purpose of livestock breeding, poultry farming
or dairy;
(g) subject to the provisions of sub-section (3), land comprised in mills, factories,
or workshops;
(h) where the intermediary is a local authority,-land held by such authority,
notwithstanding such land or any part thereof may have been let out by
such authority:
Provided that where any land which has been let out by any local
authority is retained by such authority under this clause. no person holding
such land shall have any right of occupancy therein, and every such person
shall be bound to deliver possession of the land to the local authority when
required by it for its purposes;
(i) where the intermediary is a corporation or an institution established
exclusively for a religious or a charitable purpose or both, or is a person
holding under a trust or an endowment or other legal obligation exclusively
for a purpose which is charitable or religious or both land held in khas by
such corporation or institution, or person, for such purpose including land
held by any person, not being a tenant, by leave or license of such
Corporation or institution or person;
(j) where the intermediary is a co-operative society registered or deemed to
have been registered under the Bengal Co-operative Societies Act, 1940
(Ben. Act XXI of 1940), or a company incorporated under the Indian
Companies Act, 1913 (VII of 1913), engaged exclusively in farming and in
business, if any. connected directly with such farming, agricultural land in
the khas possession of the society or the company on the 1st day of
January, 1952, and chosen by the society or the company. Not exceeding in
area the number of acres which persons, who were the members of the
society or the company on such date, would have been entitled to retain in
the aggregate under clause (d), if every such person were an intermediary:
Provided that where any such person retains any land under clause (d),
such person shall not be taken into account in calculating the aggregate
area of the land which the society or the company may retain.
(k) so much of requisitioned land as the intermediary would be entitled to retain
after taking into consideration any other land which he may have retained
under the other clauses;
Explanation.-- Requisitioned land' means any land which was in the
khas possession of the intermediary and which was requisitioned by
Government under the provisions of any law for the time being in force or
was occupied by Government in pursuance of rule 49 of the Defence of
India Rules and continued to be subject to requisition or occupation on the
date mentioned in the notification issued under section 4;
(l) so much of land in the unauthorised occupation of refugees from East Bengal
immediately before the date of vesting as an intermediary would be entitled
to retain after taking into consideration any other land which he may have
retained under the other clauses;
Explanation.-- Refugees from East Bengal' includes those who are
displaced persons within the meaning of the Rehabilitation of Displaced
Persons and Eviction of Persons in Unauthorised Occupation of Land Act,
1951 (West Ben. Act XVI of 1951).
Exception.--Subject to the provisions contained in sub-section (3),
nothing in this sub-section] shall entitle an intermediary for any other
person] to retain any land comprised in a forest [or any land comprised in
any embankment as defined in the Bengal Embankment Act, 1882 (Ben.
Act II of 1882), the proper maintenance of which should, in the opinion of
the State Government, be taken over by the State Government in the public
interest.
(2) An intermediary who is entitled to retain possession of any land under subsection (1) shall be deemed to hold such land directly under the State from
the date of vesting as a tenant, subject to such terms and conditions as
may be prescribed and subject to payment of such rent as may be
determined under the provisions of this Act and as entered in the record-ofrights finally published under Chapter V except that no rent shall be
payable for land referred to in clause (h) or (i):
Provided that if any tank fishery or any land comprised in a teagarden, orchard, mill, factory or workshop was held immediately before the
date of vesting under a lease, such lease shall be deemed to have been
given by the State Government on the same terms and conditions as
immediately before such date subject to such modification therein as the
State Government may think fit to make.
(3) In the case of land comprised in a tea-garden, mill, factory or workshop the
intermediary, or where the land is held under a lease, the lessee, shall be
entitled to retain only so much of such land as in the opinion of the State
Government, is required for the tea-garden, mill, factory or workshop, as the
case may be, and a person holding under a lease shall, for the purpose of
assessment of compensation, be deemed to be an intermediary:
Provided that the State Government may, if it thinks fit so to do after
reviewing the circumstances of a case and after giving the intermediary or
the lessee, as the case may be, an opportunity of being heard, revise any
order made by it under this sub-section specifying the land which the
intermediary or the lessee shall be entitled to retain as being required by
him for the tea-garden, mill, factory or workshop, as the case may be.
Explanation I.--The expression "land held under a lease" includes any
land held directly under the State under a lease.
Explanation II.--For the removal of doubts, it is hereby declared that the
expression "revise any order" mentioned in the proviso to this sub-section,
shall, notwithstanding anything contained in any law for the time being in
force or in any agreement or in any decree, judgement, decision, award of
any court, tribunal or other authority, include revision of an order of
retention made under this sub-section, at any time after such order of
retention so made, if the intermediary or the lessee, as the case may be,
fails to use or ceases to use the whole or any part of the land for the
purpose for which it has been retained i.e. for tea-garden, mill, factory or
workshop, as the case may be, by him, so as to resume such land as being
surplus to his requirement, by the State Government in the manner laid
down in this proviso.
Exception.--In the case of land allowed to be retained by an
intermediary or lessee in respect of a tea-garden, such land may include
any land comprised in a forest if, in the opinion of the State Government,
the land comprised in a forest is required for the tea-garden.
(3A) Land which may be retained under clause (k) or clause (1) of subsection (1) shall, if necessary, be demarcated in such manner as may be
prescribed and shall be specified in an order made in this behalf by a
Revenue Officer specially empowered for the purpose by the State
Government.
(3B) In executing any order for eviction of persons in unauthorised
occupation of land in pursuance of proceedings under the Rehabilitation of
Displaced Persons and Eviction of Persons in Unauthorised Occupation of
Land Act, 1951 (West Ben. Act XVI of 1951), possession shall be given to
the intermediary of only so much of such land as he is entitled to retain
under clause (1) of sub-section (1) and possession of any land in excess
thereof shall be given to the Revenue Officer having jurisdiction over the
area in which the land is situated.
(3C) For the purpose of sub-section (3B) the officer or authority
executing the order for eviction shall ascertain from the Revenue Officer
referred to in sub-section (3A) particulars of the land possession of which
may be given to the intermediary.
(3D) Except as otherwise specifically provided in this Act or in the rules
made thereunder, the provisions of the Bengal Tenancy Act, 1885 (VIII of
1885) or the Cooch Behar Tenancy Act, 1910 (Cooch Behar Act V of 1910)
shall not apply in the case of any land referred to in sub-section (2).
(4) In the case of lands comprised in a forest [or in any embankment, referred in
the Exception to sub-section (1)] and held by a person other than an
intermediary which vest in the State, such person shall, for the purpose of
assessment of compensation, be deemed to be an intermediary.
(5) An intermediary shall exercise his choice for retention of land under subsection (1) within such time and in such manner as may be prescribed. If no
choice is exercised by him during the prescribed period, the Revenue Officer
shall, after giving him an opportunity of being heard, allow him to retain so
much of the lands as do not exceed the limits specified in clauses (c), (d)
and (j) of that sub-section:
Provided that nothing in this sub-section shall require an intermediary
to exercise the choice if he has already done so before the date of coming
into force of the West Bengal Estates Acquisition (Second Amendment) Act,
1957.”
31. If we carefully consider the specific language of Section 6(1), it will be
evident that the retention of land as contemplated in Clauses (b) and (c)
thereof, which are relevant for the present purpose, is automatic. The
specific expression used in the Section is: “notwithstanding anything
contained in Sections 4 and 5, an intermediary shall … be entitled to
retain with effect from the date of vesting …”.
32. It is relevant to note that the said provision speaks about the
entitlement, as a matter of right, of the intermediary to retain the land
covered by the clauses contemplated thereunder, with effect from the
date of vesting, without there being any further requirement of any
order to be passed conferring such entitlement.
33. Thus, the right to retain automatically arises simultaneously with the
vesting of the other properties, to which an exception is carved out by
the Clauses (b) and (c) of Section 6(1), without there being any
necessity of subsequent permission by any authority or the State
Government or from any other quarter. Hence, the genesis of the right
of retention is simultaneous with the vesting of the other properties,
which do not come within the exception clause of Section 6(1).
34. Sub-section (5) of Section 6 provides that an intermediary shall exercise
his choice for retention of land under sub-section (1) within such time
and in such manner as may be prescribed. If no choice is exercised by
him during the prescribed period, the Revenue Officer shall, after giving
him an opportunity of being heard, allow him to retain so much of the
lands as do not exceed the limit specified in Clauses (c), (d) and (j) of
the said sub-section.
35. Two important features are inbuilt the said sub-section.
36. First, the need for an intermediary to exercise his choice for retention
can arise only if the land held by the intermediary exceeds the ceiling
limit.
The expression “choice”, by definition, implies that there are
properties beyond the ceiling limit, due to which the intermediary has
to choose, in the first place, as to which portion of the excess land to
retain and which to be permitted to be vested. In the event the total
area of the land held by the intermediary comes within the ceiling limit,
the expression “excess” does not operate at all, thus leaving no scope of
any option being given or choice being made by the intermediary at all.
37. The second feature is that even if an intermediary does not exercise his
choice for retention of his own, it is the incumbent duty of the Revenue
Officer under sub-section (5) of Section 6 to allow the intermediary to
retain so much of the lands as does not exceed the limits specified in
the respective clauses, that too after giving the intermediary an
opportunity of being heard.
38. Thus, even when there is excess land held by the intermediary, before
the vesting is complete, the Revenue Officer is to give an opportunity of
hearing to the intermediary and to pass an order allowing the
intermediary to retain the land which is in excess.
39. It is nobody’s case that in the present instance, such an exercise was
undertaken, either by the intermediary or by the Revenue Officer.
40. Even otherwise, it is an admitted position that the total subject-plot-indispute at present is comprised of 14.33 acres of land with structure.
The said land, thus, even if taken in its entirety, comes within the
ceiling limit of 15 acres as applicable by virtue of Clause (c) of Section
6(1) of the 1953 Act. In respect of the portion of the land where there
was an existing structure, there is no ceiling limit and the same could,
in any event, be retained by the intermediary in its entirety. The landin-question, admittedly, is not used for agriculture. A factory is run on
a portion of the same, whereas the rest is non-agricultural land in the
khas possession of the petitioner-company.
41. Even going by Clause (b) of Section 6(1) of the 1953 Act, the land
surrounding the factory building and structures owned by the
intermediary comes within the purview of “land comprised in or
appertaining to” such buildings and structures, hence, attracting the
definition under Clause (b) of Section 6(1).
42. If either of the said Clauses are applicable, there does not arise any
question of the petitioner exercising any choice of retention. If the land
is construed to be covered by Clause (b), the petitioner would be
entitled to retain the entire land automatically by operation of Section
6(1) of the 1953 Act, co-genetic with the date of vesting as contemplated
under the 1953 Act.
43. Alternatively, even if the land comes within Clause (c) of Section 6(1),
the same being comprised of 14.33 acres, comes under the ceiling limit
of 15 acres and, as such, in such case as well, there was no necessity
for the petitioner/intermediary to exercise any choice of retention under
Section 6(5), as in the first place, there was no excess land at all.
44. Section 6(5) of the 1953 Act, if read in conjunction with the proviso to
Rule 4A(1) of the 1954 Rules, framed under the said Act, the
petitioner/intermediary was not required to exercise such choice at all
in the first place.
45. Hence, the retention being automatic, whatever order was passed under
Section 6(3), read with Section 6(1)(g) of the 1953 Act, the same was
obviously a surplusage and entirely irrelevant, since what the petitioner
was already entitled to retain could not be further conferred on the
petitioner by any order or by any authority.
46. The entitlement to retain, arising out of the statutory right under
Section 6(1), Clauses (b) and (c) of the 1953 Act, was automatic and
Section 6(5) of the 1953 Act and/or Rule 4A of the 1954 Rules is not
attracted at all.
47. As such, the right of the petitioner/intermediary to retain the subjectplot of 14.33 acres, a portion of which contained structures, was a right
vested in the petitioner co-extensive with the commencement of the
1953 Act and could not be curtailed or conferred further.
48. By operation of the 1955 Act, in particular Section 3 of the same, which
provides that the provisions of the said Act shall override other laws
and have effect notwithstanding anything inconsistent therewith in any
other law for the time being in force, the investiture of status vis-à-vis
lands came to be governed by the 1955 Act.
49. In the above backdrop, the provision of Section 4B (2) of the 1955 Act is
to be considered. The same is set forth below:
“4B(2) Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act or in any other
law for the time being in force or in any agreement, custom or
usage or in any decree, judgment, decision or award of any
court, tribunal or authority, where an intermediary has been
allowed to retain land irrespective of area and classification and
with or without any order under clause (g) of sub-section (1),
read with sub-section (3), of section 6 of the West Bengal Estate
Acquisition Act, 1953 (West Bengal Act 1 of 1954) (hereinafter
referred to as the retainer), or where such retainer has already
transferred such land or any part thereof to any person or
institution or company who is in possession of such land or part
thereof by an instrument mentioned in sub-section (1) of section
5 of this Act, such retainer or transferee, as the case may be,
shall be deemed to hold such land or p[art thereof as lessee
directly under the State Government with effect from the date of
vesting under the West Bengal Estate Acquisition Act, 1953, or
from the date of such transfer as the case may be, for any of the
purposes as referred to in the first proviso to section 14Y
excluding tea garden, in accordance with such terms and
conditions as may be prescribed.”
50. As evident from the language of the above provision, in the event the
retention by an intermediary is by virtue of Section 6(3), read with
Section 6(1)(g), of the 1953 Act, the concerned intermediary shall be
deemed to hold such land or part thereof as a lessee, and not as a
raiyat.
51. In such case, obviously, Section 4C of the said Act would not apply,
since the same envisages only a raiyat to be entitled to apply for
conversion of the character of the land for user for any purpose other
than that for which it was being used.
52. It is also to be noted that Section 2(10) of the 1955 Act defines “raiyat”
to mean a person or institution holding land for any purpose
whatsoever.
53. Thus, on a conjoint reading of the provisions of Section 6(1)(b) and (c) of
the 1953 Act as well as Section 2(10) of the 1955 Act, the moment an
intermediary became entitled to retain a land within Clauses (b) and (c)
of Section 6(1) of the 1953 Act, his status partook of the character of a
raiyat and continued to be so with the promulgation of the 1955 Act.
54. Section 4(1) of the 1953 Act contemplates notifications declaring
estates in Districts or parts of Districts as mentioned therein to vest in
the State free from encumbrances. Section 5(1) of the said Act
stipulates the effect of the notification and provides that upon the due
publication of the notification under Section 4, on and from the date of
vesting, subject to the provisions of sub-section (3) of Section 6, every
non-agricultural tenant holding any land under an intermediary and,
until the provisions of Chapter-VI are given effect to, every raiyat
holding any land under an intermediary, shall hold the same directly
under the State, as if the State had been the intermediary, and on the
same terms and conditions as immediately before the date of vesting.
55. Again, Chapter-VI of the 1953 Act deals with acquisition of interests of
raiyats and under-raiyats, and was substituted by the Amendment Act
of 1955 to the 1953 Act. Section 49 under Chapter-VI provides that the
provisions of the said Chapter shall come into force on such date and in
such District or part of the District as the State Government may by
notification in the Official Gazette appoint and for such purpose
different dates may be appointed for different Districts or part of
Districts.
56. Again, Section 52, also under Chapter-VI, provides that on issuance of
a Section 49 Notification of a particular area, the provisions of ChapterII, etc., shall apply to raiyats and under-raiyats as if they were
intermediaries and the land held by them were estates and the person
holding under a raiyat or an under-raiyat were a raiyat for the
purposes of Clauses (c) and (d) of Section 5.
Thus, on a composite
reading of Section 5(1)(c), read with Sections 49 and 52, the nett effect
is that upon a notification under Section 4(1) for a particular District or
part of a District being published, the lands comprised in such District
or part thereof vests in the State and a non-agricultural tenant or
raiyat becomes a raiyat under the State.
57. Seen in such context, Section 6(1) automatically conferred co-extensive
entitlement of retention, simultaneously with the investiture on the
State of the rest of the lands, with effect from the date of vesting of the
concerned lands, lands which are comprised inter alia under Clauses
(b) and (c) of Section 6(1) of the 1953 Act.
58. Hence, on the date of enactment of the 1955 Act, the same overrode the
provisions of the 1953 Act insofar as there was a conflict between the
two and by operation of Section 2(10) of the 1955 Act, a raiyat who had
retained a land under Section 6(1), Clauses (b) and (c) of the 1953 Act
continued to be a raiyat under the 1955 Act.
59. As per our previous observations regarding the interplay between the
relevant provisions, once the petitioner automatically became entitled
to retain the subject-plot of land of 14.33 acres by operation of Clauses
(b) and (c) of Section 6(1) of the 1953 Act, any subsequent
permission/order passed under Section 6(3), read with Section 6(1)(g) of
the 1953 Act, would be rendered superfluous and be considered to be a
surplusage.
60. The above ratio is strengthened by the proposition laid down in
Calcutta Mineral Supply Company Private Limited (supra)2, where the
Hon’ble Supreme Court categorically affirmed the findings of the High
Court to the effect that retention of the land under Section 6(1) could
not be subjected to Section 6(3) of the 1953 Act, which applies in
respect of the land held in excess of the ceiling.
State of West Bengal and others v. Calcutta Mineral Supply Company Private
Limited and another, reported at (2015) 8 SCC 655
61. In BRC Construction Company Private Limited (supra)3, a co-ordinate
Bench of this Court observed, inter alia, that as the land of the
petitioner was well within the ceiling limit with existing structures, even
assuming that Section 6(3) applied to the land, still the State could not
resume the land-in-question.
62. In Ratnagiri Engineering Private Limited (supra)4, it was observed in
Paragraph No.10 that there is a difference between Clauses (a) to (e) of
Section 6(1) of the 1953 Act on the one hand and Clauses (f) and (g) of
Section 6(1) on the other. It was further held that while in the case of
lands which can be retained under Clauses (a) to (e) of Section 6(1), the
retention is automatic from the date of vesting and no order of any
authority need be passed for that purpose, in the case of Clauses (f)
and (g) of Section 6(1), the retention after the date of vesting is not
automatic but it occurs only when the State Government passes an
order under Section 6(3) of the 1953 Act. Although the context of the
judgment was otherwise, where it was reiterated that once an order was
passed under the main part of Section 6(3) of the 1953 Act, the power
under the proviso thereto cannot be exercised by taking into
consideration subsequent events, the interplay between the provisions
of Clauses (f) and (g) on the one hand and Clauses (a) to (e) of Section
6(1) on the other was also highlighted in the said decision.
BRC Construction Company Private Limited and Another v. State of West Bengal
and Others, reported at 2015 SCC OnLine Cal 5146
State of West Bengal and Others v. Ratnagiri Engineering Private Limited and
Others, reported at (2009) 4 SCC 453
63. The proposition laid down in Ratnagiri Engineering Private Limited
(supra)5 was also followed in Juhi Finalease (P) Ltd. (supra)6.
64. In the present case as well, in view of our observation that the retention
of the land under Section 6(1), Clauses (b) and (c) was automatic, there
remained no scope of further conferment or curtailment of such right
under Section 6(3) of the said Act.
65. In view of the above discussions, this Court is of the firm opinion that
the learned Tribunal as well as the DL & LRO and the Commissioner,
Presidency Division erred in law in refusing to grant permission to the
petitioner-company to convert the nature of user of the subject-land
under Section 4C of the 1955 Act on the premise that the petitionercompany is a lessee and not a raiyat in respect of the said land.
66. Accordingly, WPLRT No.126 of 2023 is allowed on contest, thereby
setting aside the impugned judgment of the Tribunal dated January 3,
2023 passed by the First Bench of the West Bengal Land Reforms
Tribunal in OA No.1635 of 2015 (LRTT) as well as the orders of the
Commissioner of the Presidency Division and the order of the DL &
LRO which were affirmed by the Tribunal.
67. The petitioner-company is hereby declared to be a raiyat within the
contemplation of Section 2(10) of the West Bengal Land Reforms Act,
1955, and not a lessee under Section 4B (2) of the said Act, and
State of West Bengal and Others v. Ratnagiri Engineering Private Limited and
Others, reported at (2009) 4 SCC 453
Juhi Finalease (P) Ltd. & Anr. v. State of West Bengal & Ors., reported at 2017 SCC
OnLine Cal 5043
accordingly entitled in the capacity of a raiyat to apply for conversion of
the subject-plot of land of 14.33 acres under Section 4C of the1955 Act,
subject to otherwise fulfilling the necessary prerequisites and criteria to
obtain such permission to convert.
68. Consequentially, respondent no. 2, that is, the District Land and Land
Reforms Officer, North 24-Parganas, is directed to reconsider the
conversion application of the petitioner under Section 4C of the 1955
Act, by treating the petitioner to be a raiyat competent to maintain the
same, and to process and dispose of the same as expeditiously as
possible, positively within two (02) months from date.
69. There will be no order as to costs.
70. Urgent certified copies of this order, if applied for, be supplied to the
parties upon compliance of all due formalities.
(Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya, J.)
I agree.
(Supratim Bhattacharya, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review