Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
CRLMP No.1743 of 2025
An application under Article 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India.
….
Saraswati Mistry
Petitioner
-versus1. State of Odisha, represented through its
Principal Secretary, Home Department,
BBSR
2. Director General of Police, Odisha
3. Superintendent of Police, Kendrapara
4. Inspector-in-charge (IIC), Rajnagar
Police Station, Kendrapara
…. Opposite Parties
Advocates appeared in this case through Hybrid Mode :
For Petitioner
: Mr.Gyanendra Kumar Tripathy,
Advocate
For Opposite Parties
: Mr. A.K. Apat, AGA
CORAM:
HON’BLE MISS JUSTICE SAVITRI RATHO
.……………………………………………………………………………….
Date of Hearing: 02.02.2026
Date of Judgment: 02.02.2026
………………………………………………………………………………..
.
Savitri Ratho, J.
This CRLMP has been filed by the Petitioner being
aggrieved by the inaction of the Opposite Parties to register her
CRLMP No. 1743 of 2025
//2//
complaint dated 25.11.2025 despite the repeated representation dated
02.12.2025 before Superintendent of Police.
FACT OF THE CASE IN BRIEF
2.
The brief facts of the present case is that on 09.11.2025 at
about 9:30 A.M., while the deceased (daughter of the petitioner) was
standing by the roadside near Baghua Chhak, the motorcycle bearing
registration number OD04T4876 dashed against her from behind as a
result she fell down on the road sustaining grievous injuries. She was
immediately taken to CHC Rajnagar, with the help of local people for
treatment, but due to her critical condition the medical officer referred
her to SCB Medical Cuttack. Thereafter, she was taken to a hospital
in Bhubaneswar, where she was declared dead. Capital PS UD Case
No.300 of 2025 was registered. On the report of Susen Bain, uncle-inlaw of the deceased, Rajnagar P.S. Case No. 397 dated 09.11.2025
was registered under Sections 281 and 106(1) of the BNS against the
rider of the said motorcycle. The record of Capital PS U.D. Case
No.300 dated 09.11.2025 has however, not been produced before the
Court.
3.
In the inquest report dated 10.11.2025, cause of death of the
deceased has been mentioned to be “due to vehicular accident as
CRLMP No. 1743 of 2025
//3//
reported her family members” and the petitioner, Saraswati Mistry
along with others had signed on this inquest report and the details
regarding the accident has been stated under the column “Opinion of
witnesses as to cause of death”. Thereafter, the petitioner sent a
complaint by speed post to the Rajnagar Police Station on 25.11.2025
alleging subject to continuous mental cruelty and harassment on
account of dowry demands by her in-laws for the last two years and
had suddenly died under mysterious and highly suspicious
circumstances.
SUBMISSIONS
4.
Mr. G. K. Tripathy, learned counsel for the petitioner
submits that the daughter of petitioner, who was nine months
pregnant had died under suspicion circumstances, which cannot be
treated as a road accident. The petitioner being the mother of
deceased on account of stress and sorrow has signed on the inquest
report without being aware of its contents. Subsequently, she came to
realise that the death of deceased was being given the colour of an
accident, when in reality she had been killed by her in-laws. She had
approached the Rajnagar Police Station(date not given) and thereafter
submitted a written complaint by speed post on 25.11.2025 alleging
CRLMP No. 1743 of 2025
//4//
that she(deceased) had died on a mysterious and suspicious
circumstances, but her in-laws, namely, Maku Baina (Husband),
Sukumar Baina (Father-in-Law), Nilu Baina (Mother-in Law), Mohan
Baina (Brother-in-Law), Mahadeb Charan Baina (Brother-in-Law)
and Soshen Baina (Uncle-in-Law) had conspired together to give it to
a road accident and they cremated her without informing the
petitioner, for which she became suspicious about her death. He
submits that though the complaint made out a cognizable offence, but
the police did not register a case, for which she had sent a
representation on 02.12.2025 to the S.P., Kendrapara that the IIC,
Rajnagar Police Station be directed to register her written complaint
as an FIR and supply a free copy of the same to her. As this is not
produced any result, she has approached this Court.
Mr. G. K. Tripathy, learned counsel for the petitioner relies
on the decisions of the Supreme Court in the case of Sakiri Basu vs.
State of UP and others reported in (2008) 2 SCC 409 and the case of
Lalita Kumari vs. Govt. of UP reported in (2014) 2 SCC 1, to submit
that where a complaint makes out a cognizable offence, the police has
no option but to register a case and carry out investigation.
CRLMP No. 1743 of 2025
//5//
5.
Mr. A.K. Apat, learned Additional Government Advocate
for the State relying on the instructions received by him, submits that
the materials on record clearly disclose that the death of the deceased
was accidental in nature and the FIR in Rajnagar PS Case No. 397 of
2025 on 09.11.2025 also discloses this. FIR was registered against the
offending vehicle and the inquest report dated 10.11.2025 mentioned
the cause of death to be due to a vehicular accident as reported by the
family members of the deceased. The petitioner herself, along with
others had signed the inquest report and the opinion regarding the
cause of death was duly recorded in the presence of witnesses. He
further submits that no material has been produced earlier to
substantiate the allegation of dowry demand and the subsequent
allegations raised by the petitioner appear to be an after thought and
made without any basis and due to dispute about sharing of the
compensation amount.
JUDICIAL PRONOUNCEMENT
6.
In the case of Sakiri Basu vs. State of UP and others
reported in (2008) 2 SCC 409, this Court has held as follows;
“24. In view of the abovementioned legal position, we are of
the view that although Section 156(3) is very briefly worded,
CRLMP No. 1743 of 2025
//6//
there is an implied power in the Magistrate under Section
156(3) Cr.P.C. to order registration of a criminal offence and
/or to direct the officer in charge of the concerned police
station to hold a proper investigation and take all such
necessary steps that may be necessary for ensuring a proper
investigation including monitoring the same. Even though
these powers have not been expressly mentioned in Section
156(3) Cr.P.C., we are of the opinion that they are implied in
the above provision.
25. We have elaborated on the above matter because we often
find that when someone has a grievance that his FIR has not
been registered at the police station and/or a proper
investigation is not being done by the police, he rushes to the
High Court to file a writ petition or a petition under Section
482 Cr.P.C. We are of the opinion that the High Court should
not encourage this practice and should ordinarily refuse to
interfere in such matters, and relegate the petitioner to his
alternating remedy, firstly under Section 154(3) and Section
36 Cr.P.C. before the concerned police officers, and if that is
of no avail, by approaching the concerned Magistrate
under Section 156(3).
xxx
xxx
xxx
27. As we have already observed above, the Magistrate has
very wide powers to direct registration of an FIR and to
ensure a proper investigation, and for this purpose he can
monitor the investigation to ensure that the investigation is
done properly (though he cannot investigate himself). The
High Court should discourage the practice of filing a writ
CRLMP No. 1743 of 2025
//7//
petition or petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C. simply because
a person has a grievance that his FIR has not been registered
by the police, or after being registered, proper investigation
has not been done by the police. For this grievance, the
remedy lies under Sections 36 and 154(3) before the
concerned police officers, and if that is of no avail, under
Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. before the Magistrate or by filing a
criminal complaint under Section 200 Cr.P.C. and not by
filing a writ petition or a petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C.
28. It is true that alternative remedy is not an absolute bar to a
writ petition, but it is equally well settled that if there is an
alternative remedy the High Court should not ordinarily
interfere.
29. In Union of India vs. Prakash P. Hinduja and
another 2003 (6) SCC 195 (vide para 13), it has been
observed by this Court that a Magistrate cannot interfere with
the investigation by the police. However, in our opinion, the
ratio of this decision would only apply when a proper
investigation is being done by the police. If the Magistrate on
an application under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. is satisfied that
proper investigation has not been done, or is not being done
by the officer-in-charge of the concerned police station, he can
certainly direct the officer in charge of the police station to
make a proper investigation and can further monitor the same
(though he should not himself investigate).
30. It may be further mentioned that in view of Section
36 Cr.P.C. if a person is aggrieved that a proper investigation
has not been made by the officer-in-charge of the concerned
CRLMP No. 1743 of 2025
//8//
police station, such aggrieved person can approach the
Superintendent of Police or other police officer superior in
rank to the officer-in-charge of the police station and such
superior officer can, if he so wishes, do the investigation
vide CBI vs. State of Rajasthan and another 2001 (3) SCC
333 (vide para 11), R.P. Kapur vs. S.P. Singh AIR 1961 SC
1117 etc. Also, the State Government is competent to direct the
Inspector General, Vigilance to take over the investigation of a
cognizable offence registered at a police station vide State of
Bihar vs. A.C. Saldanna (supra).”
In the case of Lalita Kumari vs. Govt. of UP reported in
(2014) 2 SCC 1, this Court has held as follows;
“111) In view of the aforesaid discussion, we hold:
i) Registration of FIR is mandatory under Section 154 of the
Code, if the information discloses commission of a cognizable
offence and no preliminary inquiry is permissible in such a
situation.
ii) If the information received does not disclose a
cognizable offence but indicates the necessity for an inquiry, a
preliminary inquiry may be conducted only to ascertain
whether cognizable offence is disclosed or not.
iii) If the inquiry discloses the commission of a cognizable
offence, the FIR must be registered. In cases where preliminary
inquiry ends in closing the complaint, a copy of the entry of
such closure must be supplied to the first informant forthwith
and not later than one week. It must disclose reasons in brief
for closing the complaint and not proceeding further.
CRLMP No. 1743 of 2025
//9//
iv) The police officer cannot avoid his duty of registering
offence if cognizable offence is disclosed. Action must be taken
against erring officers who do not register the FIR if
information received by him discloses a cognizable offence.
v) The scope of preliminary inquiry is not to verify the
veracity or otherwise of the information received but only to
ascertain whether the information reveals any cognizable
offence.
vi) As to what type and in which cases preliminary inquiry
is to be conducted will depend on the facts and circumstances
of each case.
The category of cases in which preliminary inquiry may be
made are as under:
a) Matrimonial disputes/ family disputes
b) Commercial offences
c) Medical negligence cases
d) Corruption cases
e) Cases where there is abnormal delay/laches in initiating
criminal prosecution, for example, over 3 months delay in
reporting the matter without satisfactorily explaining the
reasons for delay.
The aforesaid are only illustrations and not exhaustive of
all conditions which may warrant preliminary inquiry.
vii) While ensuring and protecting the rights of the accused
and the complainant, a preliminary inquiry should be made
time bound and in any case it should not exceed 7 days. The
CRLMP No. 1743 of 2025
//10//
fact of such delay and the causes of it must be reflected in the
General Diary entry.
viii) Since the General Diary/Station Diary/Daily Diary is
the record of all information received in a police station, we
direct that all information relating to cognizable offences,
whether resulting in registration of FIR or leading to an
inquiry, must be mandatorily and meticulously reflected in the
said Diary and the decision to conduct a preliminary inquiry
must also be reflected, as mentioned above.”
In the case of Sudhir Bhaskarrao Tambe vs. Hemant
Yashwant Dhage and Others; 2016 (6) SCC 277, the Supreme
Court has held as follows:
“3. We are of the opinion that if the High Courts entertain such
writ petitions, then they will be flooded with such writ petitions
and will not be able to do any other work except dealing with such
writ petitions. Hence, we have held that the complainant must
avail of his alternate remedy to approach the Magistrate
concerned under Section 156(3) CrPC and if he does so, the
Magistrate will d ensure, if prima facie he is satisfied, registration
of the first information report and also ensure a proper
investigation in the matter, and he can also monitor the
investigation.
4. In view of the settled position in Sakiri Vasu case, the
impugned judgment¹ of the High Court cannot be sustained and is
hereby set aside. The Magistrate concerned is directed to ensure
CRLMP No. 1743 of 2025
//11//
proper investigation into the alleged offence under Section 156(3)
CrPC and if he deems it necessary, he can also recommend to the
SSP/SP concerned a change of the investigating officer, so that a
proper investigation is done. The Magistrate can also monitor the
investigation,
though
he
cannot
himself
investigate
(as
investigation is the job of the police). Parties may produce any
material they wish before the Magistrate concerned. The learned
Magistrate shall be uninfluenced by any observation in the
impugned order of the High Court.”
ANALYSIS AND CONCLUSION
7.
In view of the decisions of the Supreme Court in the case of
Sakiri Basu (supra) and Lalita Kumari (supra) it is not in dispute that
where a cognizable offence is made out, the police is duty bound to
register a case. In view of the decision in the case of Sudhir
Bhaskarrao Tambe (supra), it is not in dispute that the petitioner has
alternative remedy of approaching the jurisdictional Magistrate in
case of inaction by the police and in all cases where there is
allegations of inaction by the police or improper investigation, the
High Court is not required to interfere.
8.
There is no quarrel over this proposition of law that where a
report/complaint discloses commission of a cognizable offence, the
police should register a case and carry out investigation. It is not
CRLMP No. 1743 of 2025
//12//
permissible to the police to first conduct an enquiry before registering
the case when the allegation relates to a serious / heinous offence.
9.
Perused the instructions dated 21.01.2026 and 28.01.2026 of
the IIC, Rajnagar Police Station produced by Mr. A.K. Apat, learned
Additional Government Advocate where it is stated that after return
from the Capital Hospital, the petitioner had not attended the funeral
ceremony and dispute had arisen between the petitioner and in-laws
of his daughter regarding benefit of insurance claim. Though, the
matter was discussed amicably in presence of village gentries of the
two Panchayats, namely, Ramesh Mistry, Basu Mandal, Sudarshan
Rout, Ramesh Mandal and Keshab Baidya, who stated that the
petitioner demanded cash of Rs. 5 lakhs accidental benefit as advance
from the in-laws of her daughter. As they were not in a condition to
pay the same, the matter could not been solved, for which the
petitioner has filed the complaint.
10.
In the present case, investigation regarding death of the
daughter of the petitioner is already pending in Rajnagar P.S. Case
No. 397 of 2025 where it has been alleged that death was due to a
motor vehicle accident.
CRLMP No. 1743 of 2025
//13//
11.
The petitioner has subsequently made allegations that the
deceased - her daughter, died under suspicious circumstances, and the
cause of death of the deceased was given the colour of an accident,
when in reality she had been killed by her in-laws.
12.
As Rajnagar PS Case No. 397 of 2025 is still under
investigation, I am therefore of the view that direction is not required
to be issued for registering a separate case on the complaint of the
petitioner. As the complaint of the petitioner relates to suspicious
death of daughter of the petitioner who was in an advanced stage of
pregnancy and the petitioner has complained about dowry torture, the
I.O, while investigating into the case should also enquire into the
allegations made by the petitioner.
13.
As the allegations of the petitioner relate dowry torture and
murder of her daughter, the Superintendent of Police, Kendrapara , is
directed to assign a senior officer to supervise investigation of the
case . A separate FIR need not be registered.
14.
Needless to say, if the petitioner is aggrieved by the result of
the investigation, it is open to her to challenge the same in the
appropriate forum.
15.
With the above observation, the CRLMP is disposed of.
CRLMP No. 1743 of 2025
//14//
16.
Urgent certified copy of this order be granted on proper
application.
17.
Copy of this order be communicated to the S.P., Kendrapara
and IIC Rajnagar Police Station by the Registry.
………………….
(Savitri Ratho)
Judge
Orissa High Court, Cuttack
Dated the 2nd February, 2026 / Subhalaxmi
Digitally Signed
Signed by: SUBHALAXMI PRIYADARSHANI
SAHOO
Reason: Authentication
Location: Orissa High Court, Cuttack
Date: 20-Apr-2026 20:43:00
CRLMP No. 1743 of 2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review