Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:24975
O.P (C) No.1503 of 2022
'C.R'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K. BABU
MONDAY, THE 24TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 3RD CHAITHRA, 1947
OP(C) NO. 1503 OF 2022
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 03.08.2022 IN EP NO.38 OF 2017 OF
ADDITIONAL MUNSIFF'S COURT,CHERTHALA
PETITIONERS/ADDITINOAL JUDGMENT DEBTORS 2,4 AND 5:
SARASWATHIAMMA,
AGED 69 YEARS,
W/O LATE GOPINATHAN,
DHARMAVILASOM,
KONATTUSSERY,
KADAKKARAPALLI P.O.,
CHERTHALA,
ALAPPUZHA DISTRICT,
PIN - 688529
LALITHADEVI,
AGED 44 YEARS,
D/O LATE GOPINATHAN,
DHARMAVILASOM,
KONATTUSSERY,
KADAKKARAPALLI P.O.,
CHERTHALA,
ALAPPUZHA DISTRICT,
PIN – 688529
2025:KER:24975
O.P (C) No.1503 of 2022
INDIRADEVI,
AGED 42 YEARS,
D/O LATTE GOPINATHAN, DHARMAVILASOM,
KONATTUSSERY, KADAKKARAPALLI P.O.,
CHERTHALA, ALAPPUZHA DISTRICT., PIN - 688529
BY ADV K.S.HARIHARAPUTHRAN
RESPONDENTS/DECREE HOLDER 3RD JUDGMENT DEBTOR:
MANUEL,
S/O JOSEPH, THAIVELIKKAKATHU, NAROTH ROAD,
THAMMANAM, PALARIVATTORM,
EDAPPALLY SOUTH VILLAGE,
ERNAKULAM, PIN - 682025
JAYATHILAKAN,
S/O LATE GOPINATHAN, AGED 46 YEARS,
DHARMAVILASOM, KONATTUSSERY,
KADAKKARAPALLI P.O., CHERTHALA,
ALAPPUZHA, DISTRICT, PIN - 688529
BY ADVS.
C.G.BINDU
AJITHA C.G.(K/000536/1994)
K.J.SARANYA RAJ(K/000465/2018)
THIS OP (CIVIL) HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 24.03.2025,
THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:24975
O.P (C) No.1503 of 2022
'C.R'
K.BABU, J.
-------------------------------------O.P (C) No.1503 of 2022
--------------------------------------Dated this the 24th day of March, 2025
JUDGMENT
The judgment debtors in an Execution Petition challenge the
order of the Execution Court directing restoration of the property to
its original position in this proceedings. Petitioner Nos.1 to 3 are
additional judgment debtor Nos. 2, 4 and 5. Respondent No.1 is the
decree-holder.
Additional judgment debtor No.3 is respondent
No.2.
2.
The decree holder/plaintiff instituted O.S No.512/1990
before the Munsiff's Court, seeking a permanent prohibitory
injunction and mandatory injunction against the defendants. The
Trial Court dismissed the suit.
The decree holder/plaintiff
challenged the decree of the Trial Court filing A.S No.91/2003 before
the Subordinate Judge's Court, Cherthala. The First Appellate Court
2025:KER:24975
O.P (C) No.1503 of 2022
reversed the judgment and decree passed by the Trial Court and
decreed the suit granting a permanent prohibitory injunction and
mandatory injunction in favour of the decree-holder/plaintiff. The
defendants challenged the decree of the First Appellate Court in
RSA No.839/2013, which ended in dismissal. The decree became
final. The decree-holder executed the decree granting a mandatory
injunction in E.P No.68/2012.
2.1.
The decree-holder on 21.03.2017 filed E.P No.38/2017
alleging that on 25.02.2017, defendant No.2 trespassed upon the
plaint schedule property and erected a shed, and dumped waste in
the property. It is also alleged that the fencing on the boundary
was also destroyed. The original judgment debtor (defendant No.2)
filed a petition under Section 47 of the CPC challenging the
executability of the decree. He contended that the decree is not
executable as it is time-barred. He further contends that the relief
of fixation of boundary prayed for in the Execution Petition is not
maintainable.
2025:KER:24975
O.P (C) No.1503 of 2022
2.2.
On 07.03.2021, the original judgment debtor/defendant
No.2 died.
On the application of the decree-holder, additional
judgment debtor Nos.2 to 5 were impleaded as per order in E.A
No.69/2021 dated 23.05.2022. They entered appearance. Additional
judgment debtor No.5 filed a separate objection to the decree. She
also contended that the relief of mandatory injunction is barred by
limitation, and there is no decree for fixation of boundary and
therefore, the decree is not executable.
2.3. The Execution Court on 03.08.2022 allowed the Execution
Petition repelling the contentions raised by the judgment debtors
and appointed an Advocate Commissioner and Surveyor to
supervise the act of restoration of the plaint schedule property to
its original position by the Amin.
3. The learned counsel for the petitioners made the following
submissions:
(i)
The relief granting the decree-holder to construct
the boundary on ABC and AG lines with the
2025:KER:24975
O.P (C) No.1503 of 2022
assistance of the Amin and the Commissioner
amounts to executing a decree for fixation of
boundary, which the First Appellate Court had not
granted.
(ii)
The order in Execution Application No.298/2019 is
an order against a dead person; therefore, it has
no validity in the eye of law.
(iii)
The objections filed by the additional judgment
debtor No.5 were not considered by the Execution
Court.
4.
The learned counsel for respondent No.1 made the
following submissions:
(a)
The Execution Court is empowered to pass
orders for enforcing a decree in a manner
that would give effect to it.
(b)
The Execution Court has considered the
objections raised by the additional judgment
2025:KER:24975
O.P (C) No.1503 of 2022
debtor No.5.
The relief granted in the
Execution Petition is not a relief consequent
to the dismissal of E.A No.298/2019.
5. The decree granted in favour of the decree-holder/plaintiff
is as follows:
“The second defendant, his men and agents are
restrained by a permanent prohibitory injunction from
trespassing into the plaint schedule property or to do
any acts detrimental to the interest of the plaintiff. The
second defendant is directed to dismantle and remove
the latrine and other structures put up by him in the
plaint schedule property within one month from the
date of this judgment at his expense failing which the
plaintiff is permitted to get those things removed with
the assistance of the court and to realise the costs so
incurred from the second defendant and his assets.”
6. In the Execution Petition, the decree-holder contended that
on 25.02.2017, defendant No.2 trespassed upon the plaint property
and constructed a hut, encroaching upon the property and
destroying the boundaries. He also dumped waste on the property.
7. The decree-holder under Order XXI Rule 32 of the CPC
prayed for the following reliefs:
(a)
The construction done encroaching upon the
2025:KER:24975
O.P (C) No.1503 of 2022
plaint property and the waste dumped therein
are to be removed.
(b)
The boundary lines identified as ABC and AG in
the plan prepared in E.P No.68/2012 are to be
restored to their original position by permitting
the decree-holder to construct a permanent
boundary on the said lines.
8. The learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that the
relief praying for erecting a permanent boundary on the lines
specified in the plan submitted amounts to the execution of a
decree for fixation of the boundary, which relief was not granted by
the decree.
9. The learned counsel for the decree-holder countered and
submitted that the relief prayed for is restoration of the property to
its original position as far as practicable and incur the costs of the
same from the judgment debtor, which is within the mandate of
Order XXI Rule 32 CPC. It is admitted that in E.P No.68/2012, the
2025:KER:24975
O.P (C) No.1503 of 2022
boundaries were determined, and a fence was installed.
In the
previous Execution Petition, a plan drawn to the scale was
prepared, and the alleged encroachment that occurred on the lines
was noted as ABC and AG.
10. It is profitable to extract Order XXI Rule 32 (5) of the CPC:
“32. Decree for specific performance for restitution of
conjugal rights, or for an injunction.
xxx
xxx
xxx
(5) Where a decree for the specific performance of a
contract or for an injunction has not been obeyed, the
court may, in lieu of or in addition to all or any of the
processes aforesaid, direct that the act required to be
done may be done so far as practicable by the decreeholder or some other person appointed by the court, at
the cost of the judgment-debtor, and upon the act
being done the expenses incurred may be ascertained
in such manner as the court may direct and may be
recovered as if they were included in the decree.”
11. The act required to be done contained in Order XXI Rule 32
(5)
of the CPC was interpreted in a series
of judicial
pronouncements to extend it to prohibitory injunctions.
By Act 22
of 2002, with effect from 01.07.2002 an explanation was added to
cover specifically prohibitory as well as mandatory injunctions
2025:KER:24975
O.P (C) No.1503 of 2022
within the fold of the act that required to be done.
12.
While considering the powers of the Execution Court
contained in Section 51 of the CPC in State of Haryana v. State of
Punjab [(2004) 12 SCC 673], the Supreme Court held thus:
“96. The residuary power under Section 51( e) allows a
court to pass orders for enforcing a decree in a
manner which would give effect to it. The period
specified in the decree for completion of the canal by
Punjab is long since over. The Union of India has said
that it had worked out a contingent action plan during
this period. The contingency in the form of expiry of
the one-year period in January 2003 has occurred. We
have not been told whether the contingency plan has
been put into operation. Although it appears that the
Cabinet Committee on Project Appraisals had
approved the proposal for completion of the SYL
Canal by BRO and at a meeting convened as early as
on 20-2-1991, the then Prime Minister directed that
BRO take over the work for completion of the SYL
Canal in the minimum time possible, BRO is not now
available for the purpose. After the decree the Central
Water Commission officials have inspected the canal
on 9-10-2002. The report has assessed a minimum
period of about two years for removing silt deposits,
clearing of trees and bushes, completing the damaged
and balance works and making the canal functional
and has estimated an amount of about Rs 250 crores
for this purpose excluding the liabilities of Punjab. In
the circumstances we direct the Union of India to
carry out its proposed action plan within the following
time frame:
2025:KER:24975
O.P (C) No.1503 of 2022
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
The Union of India is to mobilise a Central
agency to take control of the canal works from
Punjab within a month from today.
Punjab must hand over the works to the Central
agency within 2 (two) weeks thereafter.
An Empowered Committee should be set up to
coordinate
and
facilitate
the
early
implementation of the decree within 4 (four)
weeks from today. Representatives of the States
of Haryana and Punjab should be included in
such Committee.
The construction of the remaining portion of the
canal including the survey, preparation of
detailed estimates and other preparatory works
such as repair, desilting, clearance of vegetation,
etc. are to be executed and completed by the
Central agency within such time as the HighPowered Committee will determine.
The Central and the Punjab Governments should
provide adequate security for the staff of the
Central agency.”
13. Order XXI Rule 32 CPC applies to prohibitory as well as
mandatory injunctions. In other words, it applies to cases where
the party is directed to do some act and also to cases where he is
abstained from doing an act. Still to put it differently, a person
disobeys an order of injunction not only when he fails to perform an
act which he is directed to do but also when he does an act which
he is prohibited from doing. Execution of an injunction decree is to
2025:KER:24975
O.P (C) No.1503 of 2022
be made in pursuance of Order XXI Rule 32 CPC as the CPC
provides a particular manner and mode of execution and therefore,
no other mode is permissible {Vide: Kanwar Singh Saini v. High
Court of Delhi [(2012) 4 SCC 307]}.
14. In Gopinathan Pillai V. v. Rajappan and Others [2011 (2)
KHC 508], this Court, while dealing with the powers of the
Execution Court under Order XXI Rule 32 (5) CPC, observed thus:
“13. A decree for prohibitory injunction could be of
different types. The nature of injunction may be different.
…......................... Even a prohibitory injunction can be
specifically enforced and the judgment - debtors could be
compelled to obey the decree.
xxx
xxx
xxx
15. An argument is possible that in cases where
the decree cannot be enforced, whether the nature of the
decree is mandatory or prohibitory, the act required to be
done cannot be specifically enforced. In other words, it
can be argued that an act which cannot be undone cannot
be enforced or executed by recourse to R.32 of O.21. I am
not inclined to take such a view as it would defeat the
very purpose of R.32. I am of the view that even such
cases could be effectively dealt with by recourse to subrule (3) and (5) of R.32 as compensation could be
awarded under sub-rule (3) though the decree does not
make such a provision. The costs can be ascertained and
recovered as provided in sub-rule (5) though the decree
is silent about the same. Such wide powers are given to
the executing Court for the purpose of enforcing and
executing the decree and to meet any contingency where
2025:KER:24975
O.P (C) No.1503 of 2022
the decree is violated. If we were to hold that a judgment
- debtor who has cut and removed trees in violation of
the decree cannot be proceeded with under R.32 (except
for detention in civil prison) but he can be proceeded with
only in cases where the act required to be done could be
done positively, we would be conceding that the
executing Court is powerless to deal with a case where
something is done by the judgment - debtor which cannot
be corrected and status quo ante restored. I am of the
view that such an interpretation is not plausible going by
the scheme of the various provisions of the Code of Civil
Procedure including S.51, O.21 R.32 and S.47.”
15. In Krishnan Namboodiri and Others v. A. P. Unnikrishnan
Namboodiri (2005 KHC 681), this Court held that it is only just and
proper to invoke the inherent power of the Court under Section 151
CPC when a specific provision is lacking to meet a particular
contingency to enforce a decree or order of the Court.
16. While dealing with a question of whether in the execution
of a decree for declaration of title, followed by a prohibitory
injunction, a commission can be issued to construct a compound
wall, which relief was not, in terms, granted by the decree, this
Court in Paulose V. U. v. V. P. Molly (2024 KHC OnLine 115) after
surveying all the precedents on the subject observed thus:
2025:KER:24975
O.P (C) No.1503 of 2022
“24. On the strength of the legal position as regards
O.21, R.32(5) as noted above, as also, on the basis of
the dictum laid down in the various judicial
pronouncements, this Court will straight away arrive
at the conclusion that the learned Munsiff clearly erred
in not invoking the powers under Sub Rule (5) of O.21,
R.32 and negating the decree holder's request to
appoint a Commissioner, aided with a Surveyor, to
supervise the construction of the compound wall. In
arriving at such conclusion, this Court should also
address the sweep, as also, the scope of a prohibitory
injunction restraining the defendants from doing
anything interfering with the peaceful possession and
enjoyment of the plaint schedule property by the
plaintiff. Let me employ the precise words in the
decree in question, which is extracted here below:
"Defendants and men under them are restrained by
decree of permanent prohibitory injunction from
trespassing
upon
the
plaint
schedule
property ......... ........ ....... and from doing any act
interfering with the peaceful possession and
enjoyment of the plaintiff over the plaint schedule
property."
(underlined by me for emphasis)”
17. In Suhara Beevi v. Sainudheen (2024 KHC OnLine 481), this
Court observed thus:
“5. R.32 of O.21 of CPC provides modes of
enforcement of decree for specific performance of
contract, decree for injunction, and decree for
restitution of conjugal rights. The rule provides for
attachment of property of the judgment debtor and
payment of sale proceeds to the decree holder as
also detention of judgment debtor (except in case
of decree for restitution of conjugal rights), or by
both. Apart from the arrest of the judgment debtor
or attachment of his property, Sub-rule (5) of R.32
2025:KER:24975
O.P (C) No.1503 of 2022
empowers the executing court to take appropriate
action for enforcing the decree at the cost of the
judgment debtor who willfully disobeys such
decree. It says that, where a decree for the specific
performance of a contract or for an injunction has
not been obeyed, the Court may, in lieu of or in
addition to all or any of the processes stated in
Sub-rules (1) to (4) of R.32, direct that the act
required to be done may be done so far as
practicable by the decree - holder or some other
person appointed by the Court, at the cost of the
judgment - debtor. The Explanation clarifies that
the expression 'the act required to be done' covers
prohibitory as well as mandatory injunctions. A
judgment debtor disobeys a decree of injunction not
only when he fails to perform an act that he is
directed to do but also when he does an act that he
is prohibited from doing. Thus, where a decree for
permanent prohibitory injunction was passed
restraining the judgment debtor from trespassing
into the decree schedule property, and the
judgment debtor subsequently trespassed into the
property and remained in possession therein, the
decree could be enforced by evicting the judgment
debtor from the property. Sub-rule (5) of R.32 of
O.21 of CPC gives such a power to the execution
court. The petitioner has claimed in the objection
statement filed to the Execution Petition that she is
still in occupation of the decree schedule building.
The claim itself is a proof of wilful disobedience of
the decree. Hence, I find no illegality or impropriety
in the impugned order deputing Amin for delivery of
the property by evicting the petitioner.”
18.
In the present case, as I stated above, a plan was
prepared in the Execution Petition filed seeking execution of the
2025:KER:24975
O.P (C) No.1503 of 2022
decree for mandatory injunction, wherein the boundaries destroyed
were shown as ABC and AG lines.
The decree-holder placed
sufficient materials to establish that the original judgment debtor
encroached upon the property, violating the order of prohibitory
injunction and thereby destroying the boundaries. The Execution
Court granted the relief of permitting the decree-holder to fix a
permanent boundary on the destroyed lines with the assistance of
the Amin, the Commissioner and the Surveyor. This Court finds no
reason to interfere with that order. The contention of the learned
counsel for the petitioners that the powers of the Court granting
such relief are beyond the scope of Order XXI Rule 32 (5) CPC
cannot be sustained.
19. Yet another objection raised by the learned counsel for the
petitioners is that the order in E.A No.298/2019 is an order against a
dead person as the original judgment debtor (defendant No.2) died
during the proceedings in the E.A.
During the course of the
proceedings in the Execution Petition the decree holder had taken
2025:KER:24975
O.P (C) No.1503 of 2022
steps to implead the Legal Representatives of the original judgment
debtor and they were impleaded as additional judgment debtor
Nos.2 to 5 as per order dated 23.05.2022.
Additional judgment
debtor No.4 filed objection to the Execution Petition. The judgment
debtors, in fact, abandoned E.A No.298/2019 as they did not take any
steps to get them impleaded as parties in the capacity of the legal
representatives of the judgment debtor. Therefore, E.A No.298/2019
stood
abated
due
to
the
non-impleadment
of
the
legal
representatives of the judgment debtor. It is to be noted that the
result of E.A No.298/2019 has no consequence in the proceedings of
the Execution Petition. The Execution Court erroneously referred to
E.A No.298/2019 also in the cause title though the petition stood
abated long back.
20. It is also important to note that the same contentions
were separately raised by additional judgment debtor No.5 by filing
objection.
Those objections were considered by the Execution
Court in paragraph Nos.6 and 7 of the impugned order. Therefore,
2025:KER:24975
O.P (C) No.1503 of 2022
the contention of the learned counsel for the petitioners that the
objections raised by the additional judgment debtors were not
considered has no substance. It was after considering all those
objections the Court allowed the Execution Petition in favour of the
decree-holder.
21.
The learned counsel brought to my notice the
endorsement of the Execution Court in Ext.P4 that 'E.A No.298/2019
stands dismissed'. In fact, the Execution Application stood abated
due to the non-impleadment of the legal representatives in the
application. Since it was a petition filed by the original judgment
debtor himself, the decree-holder had no responsibility to bring the
legal representatives of the judgment debtor into the party array.
22. The resultant consequence is that E.A No.298/2019 stood
abated.
The judgment debtors, without getting themselves
impleaded in the Execution Petition, preferred to file separate
objections, which were considered by the Execution Court while
allowing the Execution Petition. Therefore, the abatement of E.A
2025:KER:24975
O.P (C) No.1503 of 2022
No.298/2019 has absolutely no consequence in the order allowing
the Execution Petition.
The Original Petition (Civil) stands dismissed.
Sd/-
K.BABU,
JUDGE
KAS
2025:KER:24975
O.P (C) No.1503 of 2022
APPENDIX OF OP(C) 1503/2022
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
ExhibitP1
TRUE COPY OF EXECUTION PETITION DATED
21 -03-2017 IN EP. NO. 38/2017 IN O.S.
NO. 512/1990, ON THE FILES OF THE
MUNSIFF’S COURT, CHERTHALA
Exhibit2
TRUE COPY OF THE OBJECTIONS DATED 01–
01–2022 FILED BY THE 3RD PETITIONER/4TH
JUDGEMENT DEBTOR IN EP. NO. 38/2017 IN
O.S. NO. 512/1990, ON THE FILES OF THE
MUNSIFF’S COURT, CHERTHALA
ExhibitP3
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 03–08–2022
IN EA. NO. 298/2019 IN EP. 38/2017 IN
OS. NO. 512/1990 OF THE ADDL.MUNSIFF
COURT, CHERTHALA
ExhibitP4
TRUE COPY OF ORDER DATED 03–08–2022 IN
EP. 38/2017 IN O.S. 512/1990, ON THE
FILES OF THE MUNSIFF’S COURT, CHERTHALA
RESPONDENT EXHIBITS
Exhibit-R1(a)
TRUE COPY OF THE ADDRESS FURNISHED BY
THE COUNSEL OF THE 2ND
RESPONDENT/ADDITIONAL 3RD JUDGMENT
DEBTOR IN E.P. NO.38/17 IN O.S.
NO.512/1990 ON THE FILE OF MUNSIFF
COURT, CHERTHALA
Exhibit-R1(b)
TRUE COPY OF THE DELIVERY KYCHIT IN
E.P. NO.68/2012 IN O.S. NO.512/1990 ON
THE FILE OF MUNSIFF COURT, CHERTHALA
2025:KER:24975
O.P (C) No.1503 of 2022
Exhibit-R1(c)
TRUE COPY OF VAKKALATH OF THE
PETITIONERS IN O.S. NO.512/1990 DATED
21.1.2022
Exhibit-R1(d)
TRUE COPY OF THE VAKKALATH OF 2ND
RESPONDENT IN O.S. NO.512/1990 DATED
26.4.2022
Exhibit-R1(e)
TRUE COPY OF E.A. NO.298/2019 IN E.P.
NO.38/2017 IN O.S. NO.512/1990 ON THE
FILE OF MUNSIFF COURT, CHERTHALA DATED
29.8.2019
Exhibit-R1(f)
TRUE COPY OF OBJECTION TO EXHIBIT
-R1(E) DATED NIL FILED BY 1ST
RESPONDENT HEREIN
Exhibit-R1(g)
TRUE COPY OF THE COMPLAINT LODGED BY
ORIGINAL JUDGMENT DEBTOR BEFORE THE
DY.S.P., CHERTHALA DATED 1.10.2012
Exhibit-R1(h)
TRUE COPY OF THE COMPLAINT BEFORE THE
DISTRICT COLLECTOR, ALAPPUZHA SUBMITTED
BY ORIGINAL JUDGMENT DEBTOR DATED
11.10.2012
Exhibit-R1(i)
TRUE COPY OF THE NOTICE OBTAINED BY THE
1ST RESPONDENT HEREIN FROM THE
COLLECTORATE, ALAPPUZHA BEARING NO.C445465/17 DATED 9.5.2018
Exhibit-R1(j)
TRUE COPY OF PROCEEDINGS OF THE SUB
COLLECTOR, ALAPPUZHA DATED 4.4.2016
NO.J-5981/15/K.DIS
Exhibit-R1(k)
TRUE COPY OF THE PROCEEDINGS OF THE
DISTRICT COLLECTOR, ALAPPUZHA DATED
25.10.2017 NO.C4-33147/10.K.DIS
2025:KER:24975
O.P (C) No.1503 of 2022
Exhibit-R1(l)
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT OF THIS
HON’BLE COURT DATED 29.11.2021 IN O.P.
(C) NO.231/2021
Exhibit-R1(m)
TRUE COPY OF THE COMPLAINT SUBMITTED
BEFORE THE DY.S.P. OF POLICE, CHERTHALA
DATED 5.9.2022 AND ITS RECEIPT
Exhibit-R1(n)
THE PHOTOGRAPH SHOWING TIPPER LORRY
BEARING REGISTRATION NO.KL-07 BS 5111
Exhibit-R1(o)
THE PHOTOGRAPH SHOWING UNLOADING RED
SAND
Exhibit-R1(p)
PHOTOGRAPH OF PRESENCE OF 2ND
RESPONDENT
Exhibit-R1(q)
TRUE COPY OF THE WRITTEN STATEMENT IN
O.S. NO.512/90 ON THE FILE OF MUNSIFF
COURT, CHERTHALA DATED 10.7.1995
Exhibit R1(r)
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT DATED
29.10.2011 IN A.S. NO.91/2003 OF THE
SUB COURT, CHERTHALA
Exhibit R1(s)
TRUE COPY OF THE DECREE DATED
29.10.2011 IN A.S. NO.91/2003 OF THE
SUB COURT, CHERTHALA
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review