Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:MHC:413
A.S.NO.980 OF 2020
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
JUDGMENT RESERVED ON : 08 / 01 / 2026
JUDGMENT PRONOUNCED ON : 3 / 02 / 2026
CORAM:
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE N.SATHISH KUMAR
AND
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE R.SAKTHIVEL
APPEAL SUIT NO.980 OF 2020
1.Sarasu,
W/o.Late Palaniappan,
Marukkalampatty Village,
Velagoundampatty Post,
Tiruchengode Taluk,
Namakkal District.
2.Manimegalai,
W/o.Ponnusamy,
Thondipattipudhur,
Akkalampatty Post,
Tiruchengode Taluk,
Namakkal District.
...Appellants / Plaintiffs
-Versus-
1.Mani @ Venkatachalam,
S/o.Ramagoundanur @ Ramasamy Gounder
Sallery Thottam (West),
Naikadipudhur,
Kuppagoundampudhur,
Akkalampatty Post,
Tiruchengode Taluk,
Namakkal District.
Page No.1 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.NO.980 OF 2020
2.Thirupathi,
S/o.Ramagoundanur @ Ramasamy Gounder
Naikadipudhur, Kuppagoundampudhur,
Akkalampatty Post, Tiruchengode Taluk,
Namakkal District.
3.Geetha,
W/o.Subramaniam,
Kattupalayam, Elanagar Village & Post,
Tiruchengode Taluk, Namakkal District.
4.Panneerselvam,
S/o.Late Palaniappan,
Marukkalampatty Village,
Velagoundampatty Post, Tiruchengode Taluk,
Namakkal District.
5.Sankar,
S/o.Ponnusamy,
Thondipattipudhur, Akkalampatty Post,
Tiruchengode Taluk,
Namakkal District.
6.Dhanalakshmi,
S/o.Karuppannagounder,
Singilipatty Village, Thaligai Post,
Velagoundampatty Via,
Namakkal District.
7.Pappathi,
W/o.Subramani,
Near Kaliamman Kovil, Thalakkarai Village,
Kolaram Post, Paramathy Velur Taluk,
Namakkal District.
8.Santhamani,
W/o.Raja,
Ayyanthottam, Kottampatty,
Akkalampatty Village, Velagoundampatty via,
Tiruchengode Taluk, Namakkal District.
…Respondents / Defendants
Page No.2 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.NO.980 OF 2020
PRAYER: First Appeal filed under Section 96 read with Order XLI Rules
1 and 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, praying to set aside the
Judgment and Decree dated June 05, 2018 made in O.S. No.204 of 2012 on
the file of the Sessions (Fast Track Mahila) Judge at Namakkal.
For Appellants
:
Mr.N.Krishna Kumar
for M/s.Sarvabhauman
Associates
For Respondent-R1
:
Mr.S.V.Pravin Rathinam
For Respondent-R6
:
Mr.C.Prabakaran
For Respondents2 to 5, 7 & 8
:
No appearance
*****
JUDGMENT
R.SAKTHIVEL, J.
Feeling aggrieved by the Judgment and Decree dated June 05, 2018
passed in O.S. No.204 of 2012 by 'the Sessions (Fast Track Mahila) Court,
Namakkal' ['Trial Court' for brevity], the Plaintiffs therein have preferred
this Appeal Suit under Section 96 read with Order XLI Rules 1 and 2 of
'the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908' ['CPC' for short].
2. For the sake of convenience, hereinafter, the parties will be
referred to as per their array in the Original Suit.
Page No.3 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.NO.980 OF 2020
PLAINTIFFS' CASE:
3. Case of the Plaintiffs is that the suit properties consist of two
items.
3.1. The 1st item of the suit properties comprises of Survey No.464
situate at Akkalampattu Village and the 2nd item of the Suit properties
comprises of Survey Nos.114, 120, 127 and 131 situate at PutthurKeelmugam Village. Both the Suit villages fall under Tiruchengode Taluk
of Namakkal District.
3.2. As regards Suit Item No.1, the entire extent of Suit Survey
No.464 i.e., 10 Acre 75 Cents was originally owned by Rama Gounder.
Post his demise, the entire extent of Survey No.464 fell into the hands of
his three sons, namely Sellappa Gounder, Sengoda Gounder and 'Rama
Gounder alias Ramasamy Gounder' [hereinafter 'Ramasamy Gounder' for
brevity]. One of his sons, namely Sellappa Gounder sold his 1/3 common
share in the entire extent of Survey No.464 to his two brothers - Sengoda
Gounder and Ramasamy Gounder, on February 12, 1947. Thereafter,
Sengoda Gounder and Ramasamy Gounder entered into a registered
Partition Deed dated July 06, 1954, whereby they divided the entire extent
of Survey No.464 equally. In other words, 'A' Schedule Property described
therein consisting of an extent of 5 Acre 37 ½ Cents in Survey No.464 was
Page No.4 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.NO.980 OF 2020
allotted to Sengoda Gounder, and 'B' Schedule Property described therein,
which consists of the remaining extent of 5 Acre 37 ½ Cents in Survey
No.464, was allotted to Ramasamy Gounder. The said property allotted to
Ramasamy Gounder is Suit Item No.1.
3.3. Suit Item No.2 is Ramasamy Gounder's ancestral entitlement.
3.4. Ramasamy Gounder passed away on May 02, 1990. He had two
wives, namely Kaliammal (1st wife) and Sellammal (2nd wife). Through his
1st wife - Kaliammal, he had two daughters namely Pavaayee and
Muthayee. Pavaayee died without any issues prior to 1989. Muthayee
passed away on October 25, 2003, whose legal heirs are Defendants 6 and
7. The Plaintiffs and the Defendants 1 and 2 are daughters and sons of 2 nd
wife - Sellammal respectively.
3.5. The Plaintiffs are entitled to share in the suit properties in view of
'the Hindu Succession Act, 1956' [henceforth 'H.S. Act'] as amended by
'the Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005 (Act No.39 of 2005)'
[henceforth '2005 H.S. Amendment Act']. After the demise of Kaliammal
and Muthayee (1st wife and one of the two daughters of Ramasamy
Gounder born through 1st wife), the Plaintiffs and the Defendants 1 and 2
(being sons and daughters of Ramasamy Gounder born through 2 nd wife)
are each entitled to 1/5 share in the suit properties, while the Defendants 6
Page No.5 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.NO.980 OF 2020
and 7 (being the children of said daughter - Muthayee) are jointly entitled
to 1/5 share in the suit properties. The Plaintiffs and the Defendants are in
joint possession and enjoyment of the suit properties.
3.6. Sellammal, the 2nd wife of Ramasamy Gounder during her
lifetime executed a Settlement Deed in favour of the Defendants 3 to 5 in
respect of suit properties. Hence, the Defendants 3 to 5 were added as
necessary parties. Further, the 2nd Defendant filed O.S. No.824 of 2004 in
his capacity as a co-owner of suit properties, seeking permanent injunction
against the 8th Defendant in respect of Suit Item No.2 and hence, 8th
Defendant was added as a necessary party. Patta has been issued wrongly
in favour of 8th Defendant in respect of Suit Item No.2. Despite the
Plaintiffs' requests, the Defendants 1, 2, 6 and 7 refused partition. The last
refusal was on October 29, 2012. Hence, the Plaintiffs filed the Original
Suit seeking partition of the suit properties into 5 shares and allot one such
share to each of the Plaintiffs and a permanent injunction against
Defendants.
DEFENDANTS' CASE
4. The 1st Defendant filed a written statement. Defendants 2 to 8
remained ex-parte. Sum and substance of the written statement filed by
first defendant is as follows:
Page No.6 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.NO.980 OF 2020
4.1. The relationship between the parties as well as the nature and
character of the suit properties as stated in the plaint is admitted. The plaint
averments, which are captured in Paragraph Nos.3.1 and 3.2 hereinabove
are all admitted.
4.2. According to the first defendant, in the year 1982, the Defendants
1 and 2 and their father - Ramasamy Gounder entered into a Partition
Agreement in respect of suit properties, wherein and whereby an earlier
oral partition was recorded. In the said earlier oral partition, 'A' Schedule
Property described in the Partition Agreement was allotted to the share of
Ramasamy Gounder as life estate and after his death, it shall devolve to the
share of the 1st Defendant on the condition that the 1 st Defendant bears the
marriage expenses of the Plaintiffs and does seer. Further in the earlier oral
partition, the 2nd Defendant acquired 'B' Schedule Property described in the
Partition Agreement and further, the 1st Defendant acquired 'C' Schedule
Property therein. 'A' Schedule Property described in the Partition
Agreement consists of an extent of 1 Acre 60 Cents in Survey No.128/1
(not a suit property) and 15 Cents in Suit Survey No.464. 'B' Schedule
Property therein consists of an extent of 5 Acre 60 Cents within specific
four boundaries in Suit Survey No.464. 'C' Schedule Property therein
consists of an extent of 2 Acre 18 Cents in Suit Survey No.114/4 and 3
Page No.7 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.NO.980 OF 2020
Acre 42 Cents in Suit Survey No.120/2B. As per the Partition Agreement,
pursuant thereto, the parties shall enter into a Partition Deed [Karar] on or
before June 1, 1982.
4.3. However, the 1st wife of Ramasamy Gounder, namely Kaliammal,
had filed a Suit before the District Munsif Court and got a maintenance
decree and pursuantly filed an execution petition bringing major portion of
'A' and 'C' Schedule Properties described in the said Partition Agreement,
which includes major portion of Suit Item No.2 herein, for sale through
process of Court. One Sengottaiyan purchased the same through Court
auction sale and thereafter, it was sold by him to one Selvarani, who is the
daughter of 2nd Defendant. Further, Ramasamy Gounder had borrowed loan
by executing a Promissory Note by mortgaging Suit Item No.2. The
creditor filed a Suit and obtained a money decree in his favour and
executed the same. In such a manner, Suit Item No.2 was sold once again
through Court auction sale in favour of one Duraisamy, who in turn sold
the property to Santhamani, the 8th Defendant.
4.4. Hence, there arose some difficulty in the 1 st Defendant enjoying
'A' and 'C' Schedule Properties described in the said Partition Agreement
including a major portion of Suit Item No.2 as per the earlier oral partition.
Therefore, an oral family arrangement was made between Ramasamy
Page No.8 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.NO.980 OF 2020
Gounder, Defendants 1 and 2, wherein it was agreed that Suit Item No.1
shall be enjoyed equally by the parties thereto. In other words, in the oral
family arrangement, it was agreed that the Ramasamy Gounder,
Defendants 1 and 2 shall each be entitled to 1/3 share in Suit Item No.1.
Thereafter, the 2nd Defendant came forward to execute Sale Deed in favour
of the 1st Defendant in respect of his 1/3 share in Suit Item No.1 and
accordingly, a Sale Agreement dated May 30, 1989 was executed by the 2 nd
Defendant in favour of the 1st Defendant.
4.5. Thereafter, as Ramasamy Gounder passed away on May 02, 1990,
the 2nd Defendant executed Sale Deed dated May 29, 1990 in favour of the
1st Defendant in respect of ½ share (instead of 1/3 share) in Suit Item No.1.
In short, the 1st Defendant is absolutely entitled to Suit Item No.1 vide the
oral family arrangement and the Sale Deed executed by 2nd Defendant. The
Plaintiffs have suppressed the aforesaid material fact. 1st Defendant alone is
in exclusive possession and enjoyment of Suit Item No.1. The Court
Auction purchasers qua Suit Item No.2 are necessary parties to the Suit.
Since they were not added as parties, the Suit is bad for non-joinder of
necessary parties. Accordingly, the 1st Defendant prayed to dismiss the
Suit with costs.
Page No.9 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.NO.980 OF 2020
5. The Plaintiff filed a reply statement on September 01, 2016
denying the averments made in the written statement.
TRIAL COURT
6. Based on the above pleadings, the Trial Court framed the
following issues:
'1.
Whether it is true that the suit properties was already
partitioned between 2nd defendant and the first
defendant and binding on the plaintiff ?
2.
Whether the suit is bad for non joinder of necessary
parties ?
3.
Whether the plaintiff is entitled into 1/5 share in the
suit property ?
4.
Whether the plaintiff is entitled for permanent
injunction ?
5.
To what relief the plaintiff is entitled to ?'
7. At trial, 2nd Plaintiff - Manimegalai was examined as P.W.1 and
one Subramani was examined as P.W.2 and Ex-A.1 to Ex-A.6 were marked
on the side of the Plaintiffs. On the side of the Defendants, 1 st Defendant
was examined as D.W.1, one Thirupathi was examined as D.W.2 and ExB.1 to Ex-B.14 were marked.
Page No.10 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.NO.980 OF 2020
8. After full-fledged trial, the Trial Court concluded that the suit
properties were partitioned between Ramasamy Gounder and his two sons
vide Ex-B.2 - Partition Agreement dated January 06, 1982.
Post the
demise of Ramasamy Gounder, the 2nd Defendant executed Ex-B.4 Sale
Deed dated May 29, 1990 in favour of the 1 st Defendant in respect of his
share in suit properties. Thus, Suit Item No.1 has already been partitioned
and now solely belongs to 1st Defendant. Hence, the Plaintiffs are not
entitled to partition the same. As regards Suit Item No.2, it was sold to
third parties through Court auction sale and those auction purchasers are
necessary parties to the Suit. Hence, the Suit is bad for non-joinder of
necessary parties. The Trial Court further concluded that the Plaintiffs are
not entitled to the relief of partition as they suppressed material facts.
Accordingly, the Trial Court dismissed the Suit.
9. Feeling aggrieved, the Plaintiffs have preferred this First Appeal
under Section 96 read with Order XLI Rules 1 and 2 of the CPC.
ARGUMENTS:
10. Mr.N.Krishna Kumar, learned Counsel appearing for the
Appellants/Plaintiffs would submit that the Trial Court failed to appreciate
the evidence in proper perspective. He would submit that the burden of
Page No.11 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.NO.980 OF 2020
proof lies upon the 1st Defendant to prove that the alleged oral partition /
family arrangement that allegedly took place between Ramasamy Gounder
and the defendants 1 and 2. No evidence was adduced to prove the alleged
oral partition / family arrangement. The Trial Court erroneously relied on
Ex-B.2 - Partition Agreement, which is an unregistered and inadmissible
document. Consequent to Ex-B.2, no Partition Deed was entered into by
the parties. No revenue records were produced to prove the alleged
exclusive / independent possession of Suit Item No.1 in the hands of 1 st
Defendant. No proof was adduced to show that, the 1st Defendant bore the
marriage expenses of the Plaintiffs and thereby, fulfilled the conditions
stated in Ex-B.2.
10.1. He would further submit that the Trial Court was not correct in
recording the finding that the Plaintiff suppressed the oral partition
pursuant to which Ex-B.2 was entered into. Further, the Plaintiffs had no
knowledge about the Execution Proceedings in E.P. No.134 of 1991 and
E.P. No.254 of 1979 and the Court auction sale made through those
execution petitions qua Suit Item No.2. In these circumstances, the Trial
Court's finding that the Plaintiff suppressed the said facts is erroneous.
Page No.12 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.NO.980 OF 2020
10.2. He would further submit that the 8 th Defendant and one
Selvarani are purchasers from the Court auction sale of Suit Item No.2.
While 8th Defendant has been brought on record, the other purchaser
namely Selvarani is represented by her father / 2nd Defendant in the Suit.
Under such circumstances, the Trial Court's finding that the Suit is bad for
non-joinder of necessary parties is incorrect. Accordingly, he would pray
to allow the Appeal, set aside the Decree and Judgment of the Trial Court
and grant a preliminary decree to the Plaintiffs.
11. Per contra, Mr.S.V.Pravin Rathinam, learned Counsel appearing
for the 1st Respondent / 1st Defendant would submit that the suit properties
were ancestral and joint family properties in which Ramasamy Gounder,
Defendants 1 and 2 alone were entitled to equal rights as co-parceners. The
Plaintiffs' marriages took place before March 25, 1989 and hence, they are
not entitled to the benefit under Tamil Nadu Act No.1 of 1990. In view of
Ex-B.2 - Partition Agreement and the subsequent oral family arrangement
between Ramasamy Gounder, Defendants 1 and 2, post the demise of
Ramasamy Gounder, the Defendants 1 and 2 were entitled to ½ share each
in Suit Item No.1. The 2nd Defendant executed a Sale Deed in respect of his
½ share in favour of 1st Defendant vide Ex-B.4 - Sale Deed dated May 29,
1990. Pursuant to the Sale Deed, the 1 st Defendant is in exclusive
Page No.13 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.NO.980 OF 2020
possession and enjoyment of Suit Item No.1 in an open, continuous and
uninterrupted manner, by excluding all and dealing individually. Ex-B.11
to Ex-B.14 would prove the same.
11.1. He would further submit that while marking Ex-B.2, the
Plaintiffs did not raise any specific objection qua stamp duty and
registration. Hence, the Plaintiffs are precluded from raising an objection
qua stamp duty at a later stage. He would further submit that Ex-B.2 only
recorded past events. Ex-B.2 does not create or extinguish any rights or
interest in praesenti. In fact, an oral partition took place and the properties
were divided in the presence of Panchayatdhars and well-wishers, and only
pursuant to said oral partition, Ex-B.2 - Partition Agreement was executed.
11.2. Further, he would submit that Ex-B.3 - Sale Agreement and ExB.4 - Sale Deed executed between Defendants 1 and 2 in the years 1989
and 1990 respectively, probablize the defense that the oral partition took
place prior to 1990. Pursuant to Ex-B.4 - Sale Deed, the 1 st Defendant is
dealing with the property till date and he mortgaged the property with the
Cooperative Society Bank and also redeemed the same. Further, he got
Ex.B-13 - Release Deed from his daughter in the year 2005. A cumulative
consideration of the evidence shows that the Plaintiffs have been in open
and exclusive possession and enjoyment of Suit Item No.1 after the
Page No.14 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.NO.980 OF 2020
execution of Ex-B.4, to the knowledge of both the Defendants and the
Plaintiffs. The Plaintiffs were never in joint possession and enjoyment of
the suit properties. They are not coparceners as on the date of Ex-B.3 and
Ex-B.4. Therefore, the Plaintiffs cannot claim right over Suit Item No.1.
11.3. Further he would submit that, Suit Item No.2 was sold by Court
auction sale. The 8th Defendant and one Sengottaiyan were in possession
and enjoyment of Suit Item No.2. Hence, the Court auction purchasers as
well as subsequent purchasers from the Court auction sale purchasers, are
necessary parties to decide the Suit. Since they were not added as parties
to the Suit, the Suit is bad for non-joinder of necessary parties. Further, the
Plaintiffs suppressed the said fact in their pleadings. The Trial Court, after
considering the evidence available on record, rightly concluded that the
Plaintiffs have not approached the Court with clean hands and they have
no right over the Suit Property. There is no need to interfere with the
Judgment of the Trial Court. Accordingly, he would pray to dismiss the
Appeal and sustain the Decree and Judgment of the Trial Court.
12. Mr.C.Prabakaran, learned Counsel for the 6th Respondent / 6th
Defendant would submit that the 6th Defendant's mother namely Muthayee
was a Class-I legal heir of Ramasamy Gounder and post her lifetime, 6 th
and 7th Defendants are entitled to her lawful share.
Page No.15 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.NO.980 OF 2020
DISCUSSION:
13. Heard either side. Perused the entire evidence available on
record. The points that arise for consideration in this Appeal Suit are as
follows:(i)
Whether the suit properties were ancestral and joint family
properties in the hands of Ramasamy Gounder ?
(ii)
If Point No.(i) is answered in affirmative, whether the
Plaintiffs qua daughters are coparceners each entitled to equal
share in the suit properties on the same footing as the sons viz.,
the Defendants 1 and 2 ?
(iii) Whether Suit Item No.2 is available for partition and whether
the Suit is bad for non-joinder of necessary parties ?
(iv) Whether any oral family partition or oral family arrangement
took place between Ramasamy Gounder, Defendants 1 and 2
in the time period between the execution of Ex-B.2 - Partition
Agreement dated January 06, 1982 and the execution of ExB.3 - Sale Agreement dated May 30,1989, as alleged by the 1 st
Defendant ?
(v)
Whether the Plaintiffs are entitled to shares in the suit
properties ? If so, to what extent ?
Page No.16 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.NO.980 OF 2020
(vi)
Whether the Judgment and Decree of the Trial Court is
to be interfered with?
14. For ease of exposition, the admitted relationship between the
parties is shown in the below genealogical tree:
Point No.(i) - Whether the suit properties were ancestral and joint family
properties in the hands of Ramasamy Gounder ?
Page No.17 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.NO.980 OF 2020
15. Case of the Plaintiffs is that the suit properties were ancestral
and joint family properties in the hands of Ramasamy Gounder, who is the
father of Plaintiffs, Defendants 1 and 2 and Muthayee whose legal heirs are
Defendants 6 and 7. According to the Plaintiffs, they both are coparceners
in view of 2005 H.S. Amendment Act. Suit properties in this case contains
two items. The 1st Defendant admitted that Suit Item No.1 was ancestral in
nature in the hands of Ramasamy Gounder. As regards Suit Item No.2, the
1st Defendant did not concern him with it. His case is that Suit Item No.2
was sold off twice in Court auction sales and thus, it is currently not
available for partition.
16. As stated supra, 1st Defendant admitted that Suit Item No.1 was
ancestral in nature in the hands of Ramasamy Gounder. Further, in Ex-B.2
- Partition Agreement entered between Ramasamy Gounder, Defendants 1
and 2 recorded an earlier oral partition in respect of suit properties, there
exists a reference that Suit Item No.1 is ancestral property. Coming to the
admissibility of Ex-B.2, a close reading of Ex-B.2 would show that its
recitals are written in past tense, and that it records a past transaction and
does not create any rights or interest in praesenti. A oral partition occurred
between Ramasamy Gounder, Defendants 1 and 2 prior to Ex-B.2. The
parties subsequently recorded the same vide Ex-B.2. They also agreed to
Page No.18 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.NO.980 OF 2020
execute a proper Partition Deed [Karar] pursuant to Ex-B.2 on or before
June 1, 1982. Hence, this Court is of the view that Ex-B.2 - Partition
Agreement being more of a memorandum of earlier oral partition does not
require stamp duty and is an admissible document in evidence. That apart,
such a reference i.e., reference to the effect that Suit Item No.1 is ancestral
property, can also be found in Ex-B.3 - Sale Agreement whereby 2nd
Defendant agreed to sell his 1/3 share in Suit Item No.1 as well as in ExB.4 - Sale Deed whereby after demise of father - Ramasamy Gounder, 2 nd
Defendant sold his ½ share in Suit Item No.1. Hence, this Court concludes
that Suit Item No.1 was ancestral and joint family in nature in the hands of
Ramasamy Gounder, who is the father of Plaintiffs and Defendants 1 & 2
and the grandfather of Defendants 3, 4, 6 and 7.
17. As regards the nature of Suit Item No.2, the burden to prove its
nature lies with the Plaintiffs. The Plaintiffs failed to satisfactorily prove
the same. Under Ex-A.1 - Partition Deed dated July 6, 1954, Sengoda
Gounder and his then minor son on one hand, and Ramasamy Gounder and
his then minor son - Thirupathi (2 nd Defendant) on other hand, entered into
a partition of their ancestral and joint family properties. In Ex-A.1, the Suit
Item No.1 alone, which is described as 'B' schedule property therein, was
allotted to the share of Ramasamy Gounder and his then minor son. There
Page No.19 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.NO.980 OF 2020
is no reference with respect to Suit Item No.2 in Ex-A.1. If really Suit Item
No.2 was an ancestral and joint family property as alleged by the Plaintiffs,
the parties would have at least mentioned about it in Ex-A.1. On the other
hand, Ex-A.1 recites that there is no other property for partition between
the parties thereto. Further, Ex-B.5 is the petition filed seeking delivery by
Sengottaiyan being a Court Auction purchaser of a portion of Suit Item
No.2. Ex-B.6 is an objection petition filed under Order XXI Rule 95 of
CPC by 8th Defendant - Santhamani not to record delivery in Ex-B.5 Petition. Ex-B.7 is the petition filed by 8 th Defendant - Santhamani seeking
to set aside the Court auction sale confirmed on April 20, 1991 in favour of
Sengottaiyan. It could be seen from a cumulative reading of Ex-B.5 to ExB.7 that the first wife of Ramasamy Gounder, namely Kaliammal, filed a
Suit in O.S. No.388 of 1943 for maintenance in 1943 and brought some
properties for Court auction sale in which one Sengottaiyan purchased Suit
Survey No.114/4 forming a portion of Suit Item No.2 and later sold it to
Selvarani, the daughter of 2nd Defendant. It could be further seen that, Suit
Item No.2 faced yet another Court auction sale, in which one C.P.
Duraisamy purchased the entire or major extent of Suit Item No.2 and later
sold to 8th Defendant herein. From the limited evidence available on
record, it could be inferred that Suit Item No.2 is a separate property of
Ramasamy Gounder. Otherwise, Defendants 1 and 2 would have filed an
Page No.20 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.NO.980 OF 2020
intervening petition in the Court auction sales. Under such circumstances,
this Court is of the view that Suit Item No.2 is not an ancestral and joint
family property but a separate property of Ramasamy Gounder. Point No.
(i) is answered accordingly.
Point No.(ii) - If Point No.(i) is answered in affirmative, whether the
Plaintiffs qua daughters are coparceners each entitled to equal share in
the suit properties on the same footing as the sons viz., the Defendants 1
and 2 ?
18. Point No.(i) was answered affirmatively qua Suit Item No.1
alone. Under Point No.(ii), not only the Plaintiffs, but it must also be seen
whether the Defendants are coparceners. Admittedly, the Plaintiffs and
Defendants 1 and 2 are born through the second wife of Ramasamy
Gounder namely Sellammal. The factum of second marriage is not in
dispute. In order to decide whether the Plaintiffs and the Defendants 1 and
2 are coparceners, the question whether the marriage between Sellammal
and Ramasamy Gounder, being a marriage in the presence of first wife is
valid, is to be considered first.
19. Ex.B.5 is the petition filed by Sengottaiyan, being one of the
Court auction purchaser, seeking delivery of possession of a portion of Suit
Page No.21 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.NO.980 OF 2020
Item No.2. Ex.B.6 is the objection petition filed by the 8 th Defendant Santhamani under Order XXI Rule 95 of CPC, opposing the petition in
Ex.B.5 and Ex.B.7 is another petition filed by her seeking to set aside the
Court auction sale that was confirmed on April 20, 1991 in favour of
Sengottaiyan. It could be seen from Ex-B.5 to Ex-B.7, that the first wife Kaliammal filed a Suit in O.S. No.388 of 1943 seeking maintenance. This
leads to an inference that as early as in 1943 there was a strained
relationship between Ramasamy Gounder and his first wife - Kaliammal.
20. Further, the Plaintiffs herein filed an earlier Suit in O.S. No.61 of
2010 against the Defendants 1 and 2 herein seeking partition in respect of
Suit Item No.1 herein. The plaint in the earlier Suit was filed on April 14,
2010 and has been marked as Ex-B.9. In the cause title of that plaint, the
age of the 2nd Defendant herein has been mentioned as 60 years, which
implies that the 2nd Defendant was born in or around 1950. In the present
plaint filed on December 21, 2012, the Plaintiffs have stated the age of the
2nd Defendant herein to be 63 years, which implies that the 2 nd Defendant
herein would have been born in or around 1949. These are with respect to
the year of birth of 2nd Defendant. As regards the year of birth of 1 st
Defendant, in the earlier Suit, the 1st Defendant's age has been mentioned
as 53 Years implying he was born in or around 1957 and in the present
Page No.22 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.NO.980 OF 2020
plaint, his age has been mentioned as 57 Years which implies that he was
born in or around 1955. This also shows that there was an age gap of about
4 years between them. For ease of understanding, the above information is
tabulated as follows:
Particulars
Date of plaint
Mentioned Age of 2nd Defendant
Implied year of birth of 2nd Defendant
Mentioned Age of 1st Defendant
Implied year of birth of 1st Defendant
Age difference between 1st and 2nd
Defendants
Earlier Suit
(O.S. No. 61 of 2010)
Present Suit
April 14, 2010
December 21, 2012
60 years
63 years
Around 1950
Around 1949
53 years
55 years
Around 1957
Around 1955
About 4 years
21. Further, on a lighter note, the 2 nd Defendant was a party to ExA.1 - Partition Deed, which was executed in 1954. This shows that he was
born before 1954. As stated supra, it could be inferred that the 2 nd
Defendant was born in or around the 1949-1950 period, which leads to a
further inference that his parents got married about a year prior to that. To
be noted, the standard of proof in a civil case is preponderance of
probabilities and not proof beyond reasonable doubt. On a comprehensive
reading of all the above information, it could be inferred that the marriage
between Ramasamy Gounder and his second wife - Sellammal, happened
before 1949. As per the Madras Hindu (Bigamy Prevention and Divorce)
Act, 1949 (w.e.f. March 29, 1949) bigamous marriage is invalid only after
Page No.23 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.NO.980 OF 2020
1949. Until then, a Hindu could legally marry for the second time, in the
presence of his first wife. There was no bar against it. Hence, the marriage
between Ramasamy Gounder and his second wife - Sellammal is a legally
valid one. The Plaintiffs and Defendants 1 and 2 are born in a legal
marriage and are legitimate children. Thus, during the lifetime of
Ramasamy Gounder, he along with Defendants 1 and 2 formed a
coparcenary, which consisted of the ancestral and joint family property in
Suit Item No.1.
22. Now this Court shall consider whether the Plaintiffs are
coparceners. Tamil Nadu Act No.1 of 1990 came into force on March 25,
1989. If the marriages of the Plaintiffs had taken place on or after March
25, 1989, then they will be deemed to be coparceners under the said Act.
23. In the present plaint, which was filed in 2012, age of Plaintiffs
are stated to be 47 and 45 Years respectively. Further, the age of 1st
Plaintiff's children viz., Defendants 3 and 4, are stated to be aged 37 and 34
Years respectively, which indicates that they were born in or around 1973
and 1976 respectively. This means the marriage of the 1 st Plaintiff
happened before 1973. Further, in Ex-B.9 - Plaint in the earlier Suit filed in
2010, age of 2nd Plaintiff's child namely 5th Defendant herein is said to be
20 Years, which implies that her child was born in 1990. The 2nd Plaintiff in
Page No.24 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.NO.980 OF 2020
her evidence as P.W.1 has deposed that she was blessed with her child four
years after her marriage, which points out that her marriage must have
been in or around 1986. For better understanding of the above, reference
may be made to the following table:
Particulars
1st Plaintiff
2nd Plaintiff
Children and their
ages
Defendants 3 & 4 - 37 and
34 years
(as stated in present
plaint, 2012)
Defendant 5 - 20 years
(as stated in Ex-B.9 - earlier plaint,
2010)
Implied year of
birth of children
Around 1973 and 1976
Around 1990
Implied year of
marriage
Before 1973
Around 1986
(child born four years after marriage,
as per evidence of P.W.1)
24. Though the present plaint is cleverly silent on the marriage dates
of the Plaintiffs, it could be inferred from the materials on record that both
the Plaintiffs got married before 1989. Therefore, they both are not entitled
to the benefit of Tamil Nadu Act No.1 of 1990.
25. Be that as it may, the Plaintiffs' case is that they are coparceners
in view of in view of Section 6 of the H.S. Act as amended by the 2005
H.S. Amendment Act. It is settled legal position that irrespective of the
date of demise of father, daughters are coparceners by birth and are at
equal footing with the sons. Thus, irrespective of date of demise of
Ramasamy Gounder, Plaintiffs are coparceners in view of the amended
Page No.25 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.NO.980 OF 2020
Section 6. Point No.(ii) is answered accordingly.
Point No.(iii) - Whether Suit Item No.2 is available for partition and
whether the Suit is bad for non-joinder of necessary parties ?
and
Point No.(iv) - Whether any oral family partition or oral family
arrangement took place between Ramasamy Gounder, Defendants 1 and 2
in the time period between the execution of Ex-B.2 - Partition Agreement
dated January 06, 1982 and the execution of Ex-B.3 - Sale Agreement
dated May 30,1989, as alleged by the 1st Defendant ?
26. According to 1st Defendant, vide Ex-B.2- Partition Agreement,
which is an un-registered document, father - Ramasamy Gounder and his
sons - Defendants 1 and 2 recorded an earlier oral partition in respect of
the suit properties. Ex-B.2 is admissible in evidence for the reasons
adduced supra. Further case of 1st Defendant is that in the said earlier oral
partition, major portion of Suit Item No.2 was allotted to him, however he
could not enjoy the same peacefully as it was sold off in Court auction
twice and therefore, Ramasamy Gounder, Defendants 1 and 2 entered into
an oral family arrangement whereby the parties agreed to split Suit Item
No.1 equally. His further case is that after the oral family arrangement and
after the demise of Ramasamy Gounder, 2nd Defendant sold his ½ share in
Suit Item No.1 in favour of 1st Defendant, making 1st Defendant the
absolute owner of Suit Item No.1.
Page No.26 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.NO.980 OF 2020
27. As stated supra, Ex.B.5 is the petition filed by Sengottaiyan,
being one of the Court auction purchaser, seeking delivery of possession of
a portion of Suit Item No.2. Ex.B.6 is the objection petition filed by the 8 th
Defendant - Santhamani under Order XXI Rule 95 of CPC, opposing the
petition in Ex.B.5 and Ex.B.7 is another petition filed by her seeking to set
aside the Court auction sale that was confirmed on April 20, 1991 in favour
of Sengottaiyan. A conjoint reading of Exs.B.5 to B.7 would reveal that
Kaliammal, the first wife of Ramasamy Gounder had instituted a suit for
maintenance in O.S. No.388 of 1943 which was decreed in her favour.
Then she initiated execution proceedings and brought certain properties to
Court auction sale. In the said auction, Sengottaiyan purchased Survey
No.114, forming part of Suit Item No.2, and subsequently conveyed the
same to Selvarani, the daughter of the 2 nd Defendant. It further emerges
that Suit Item No.2 was subjected to yet another Court auction sale, in
which one C.P. Duraisamy became the purchaser, who thereafter sold the
property to the 8th Defendant. There is no prima facie evidence available
on record to show that the plaintiffs are in joint possession and enjoyment
of the Suit Item No.2. With the limited evidence available on record, this
Court concludes that Suit Item No.2 has been completely sold off in Court
auction sale and that it is not available for partition. Further, Sengottaiyan
and C.P. Duraisamy, being the Court auction purchasers, and Selvarani
Page No.27 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.NO.980 OF 2020
(daughter of 2nd Defendant) and the 8th Defendant being the subsequent
purchasers from the Court auction purchasers are necessary parties to the
Suit. Sengottaiyan, C.P. Duraisamy and Selvarani have not been added as
parties to the Suit. Hence, the Suit is bad for non-joinder of necessary
parties. Point No.(iii) is answered accordingly.
28. From Ex-B.2 - Partition Agreement, it could be seen that in the
earlier oral partition recorded in Ex-B.2, a small portion of Suit Item No.1
was allotted to Ramasamy Gounder as life estate and after his lifetime, it
was to fall into the hands of 1st Defendant. It could further be seen that, the
remaining major portion of Suit Item No.1 was allotted to 2 nd Defendant
and a major portion of Suit Item No.2 was allotted to 1 st Defendant. As per
the Partition Agreement, the parties shall enter into a Partition Deed
[Karar] pursuant to the Partition Agreement on or before June 1, 1982.
However, from a cogent and conjoint reading of the documents in Ex-B.2
and Ex-B.5 to Ex-B.7, it could be inferred that before a Partition Deed
could be executed between them, the property allotted to 1 st Defendant
being major portion of Suit Item No.2, was sold off through process of
Court, that too twice and eventually, Suit Item No.2 fell into the hands of
the daughter of 2nd Defendant and the 8th Defendant. Hence, no Partition
Deed could be executed. It is probable and natural that in these
Page No.28 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.NO.980 OF 2020
circumstances, the parties viz., father - Ramasamy Gounder and his two
sons - Defendants 1 and 2, entered into a fresh oral family partition or oral
family arrangement whereby the remaining property viz., Suit Item No.1
was split equally between the parties. In other words, the earlier oral
partition recorded in Ex-B.2 as a memorandum did not fructify and could
not be sustained as 1st Defendant was deprived of the property thereby
allotted to his share in view of the two Court auction sales. The
documentary evidence in Ex-B.2, Ex-B.5 to Ex-B.7, makes probable the
case of the 1st Defendant that a family arrangement was entered into as Suit
Item No.2 allotted to him was sold off in Court auction sales.
29. The alleged oral family arrangement is further supported by the
documentary evidence in Ex-B.3 and Ex-B.4. Ex-B.3 is the Sale
Agreement dated May 30, 1989 executed by 2 nd Defendant agreeing to sell
his 1/3rd share in Suit Item No.1 in favour of 1 st Defendant. Pursuant to ExB.3 - Sale Agreement, 2nd Defendant executed Ex-B.4 - Sale Deed in
favour of 1st Defendant in respect of ½ share in Suit Item No.1 instead of
1/3 share. This is because the father - Ramasamy Gounder passed away in
the interregnum and according to the 1st Defendant, father's 1/3 share in
Suit Item No.1 devolved upon Defendants 1 and 2, making them each
entitled to ½ share. While the latter part regarding the Ramasamy
Page No.29 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.NO.980 OF 2020
Gounder's share devolving upon Defendants 1 and 2 is not acceptable for
reasons to be stated infra, it could be gathered from a conjoint reading of
Ex-B.3 and Ex-B.4 that an oral family arrangement took place in which the
parties split Suit Item No.1 equally among them. If not, there is no
probable reason for 2nd Defendant to execute Sale Agreement in respect of
his 1/3 share in Suit Item No.1 and following the demise of Ramasamy
Gounder, execute Sale Deed in respect of ½ share in Suit Item No.1. There
is no pleadings and proof to suggest the contrary. In these circumstances,
in view of the pleadings and the documentary evidence in Ex-B.2 to ExB.7, this Court concludes that the 1st Defendant has established the alleged
oral family arrangement held after Ex-B.2 - Partition Agreement and
before Ex-B.3 - Sale Agreement. Point No.(iv) is answered accordingly.
Point No.(v) - Whether the Plaintiffs are entitled to shares in the suit
properties ? If so, to what extent ?
30. As stated supra, the Plaintiffs are coparceners in view of the
amended Section 6 of the H.S. Act. But their coparcenary rights are
enforceable only with effect from September 9, 2005. As held under Point
No.(i), Suit Item No.1 is an ancestral and joint family property. Further, as
held under Point No.(iv), the 1st Defendant has established the oral family
partition / oral family arrangement held before 1989, when the Plaintiffs
Page No.30 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.NO.980 OF 2020
were not coparceners. As the oral family partition / oral family
arrangement took place before December 20, 2005, it is saved under subsection 5 of amended Section 6 of the H.S. Act [See Vineeta Sharma -vsRakesh Sharma, reported in (2020) 9 SCC 1]. Therefore, the same is
binding on the Plaintiffs.
31. However, as per the oral family partition / oral family
arrangement, Suit Item No.1 was divided equally among Ramasamy
Gounder, Defendants 1 and 2, which means Defendants 1 and 2 are each
entitled to only 1/3 share and the father - Ramasamy Gounder was entitled
to 1/3 share in it. It is settled position of law that in oral family partition /
oral family arrangement, that is to say oral partition or oral arrangement
between father and children, where ancestral and/or joint family properties
are partitioned, the property allotted to the share of the father takes up the
character of separate property in his hands qua his legal heirs / branch
[vide Commissioner of Income Tax, Madras -vs- P.L.Karuppan Chettiar,
reported in 1993 Supp (1) SCC 580; Commissioner of Wealth Tax -vsChandra Sen, reported in AIR 1986 SC 1753; Yudhishter -vs- Ashok
Kumar, reported in AIR 1987 SC 558; and Sneha -vs- K.Sakthivel,
reported in 2024 SCC OnLine Mad 1792. In other words, Ramasamy
Gounder was allotted 1/3 share in Suit Item No.1, which was an ancestral
Page No.31 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.NO.980 OF 2020
and joint family property as held under Point No.(i), in the oral family
partition / oral family arrangement and hence, the same was separate
property in his hands qua his legal heirs. He passed away on May 2, 1990
leaving behind his two wives, daughter - Muthayee, Plaintiffs and
Defendants 1 and 2. Upon his demise, succession opened under Section 8
of the H.S. Act [See Karuppan Chettiar's Case (cited supra)] and his 1/3
share in Suit Item No.1 shall devolve upon his legal heirs. Accordingly, his
wives together became entitled to 1/6 share [as per Rule (1) of Section 10
of the H.S. Act], Muthayee was entitled to 1/6 share, and Plaintiffs and
Defendants 1 and 2 were also each entitled to 1/6 share, all in his 1/3 share
Suit Item No.1. They all are thus co-heirs / co-owners and thus deemed to
be in joint possession and enjoyment of the Suit Item No.1. It is to be
noted here that though the first defendant mortgaged and redeemed Suit
Item No.1, and also has revenue records in his favour, he did not take the
plea of ouster and adverse possession. Plea of ouster and adverse
possession cannot be inferred. On the other hand, it has to be specifically
pleaded and proved. In this case, there is no sufficient evidence available
on record to prove that the co-heirs / co-owners including Plaintiffs were
ousted from Suit Item No.1. For the same reason, Ex-B.4 - Sale Deed
executed by 2nd Defendant in favour of 1st Defendant is valid only in
respect of his 1/3 share and the 1/6 share devolved upon him under Section
Page No.32 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.NO.980 OF 2020
8, and not his alleged ½ share. Point No.(v) is answered accordingly.
Point No.(vi) - Whether the Judgment and Decree of the Trial Court is to
be interfered with?
32. The Trial Court erred in dismissing the Suit. It failed to
appreciate the fact that property allotted to father in oral family partition or
oral family arrangement between him and his sons is separate property in
his hands qua his legal heirs and upon his demise, it would devolve under
Section 8 of the H.S. Act. In the said manner, each of the Plaintiffs would
be entitled to 9/144 share in Suit Item No.1, Defendants 1 and 2 would be
each entitled to 57/144 share in it and Defendants 6 and 7, being the legal
heir of Muthayee, will together be entitled to 12/144 share in it. The 2 nd
Defendant cannot lay a claim over the 1/6 share devolved upon him as he
had sold his interest in Suit Item No.3 and in view of Section 43 of the
Transfer of Property Act, 1882, 'feeding grant by estoppel' would apply.
Moreover, he did not file written statement and did not contest the Suit.
Hence, the 2nd Defendant's 57/144 share would fall into the hands of 1st
Defendant. In other words, 1st Defendant would be entitled to 114/144
share in Suit Item No.1. For ease of understanding, the above information
is tabulated as hereunder:
Page No.33 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.NO.980 OF 2020
Party
Share in Suit Item No.1
Plaintiff 1
9/144
Plaintiff 2
9/144
1st Defendant
114/144
Defendants 6 & 7 (together)
12/144
33. To the above extent, the Judgment and Decree of the Trial Court
is liable to be interfered with. Point No.(vi) is answered accordingly.
CONCLUSION:
34. Resultantly, the Appeal Suit is allowed in part. The Trial Court's
Judgment and Decree are set aside qua Suit Item No.1 and the Suit is
partly decreed. The Plaintiffs are each entitled to 9/144 share in Suit Item
No.1 and to that extent, a Preliminary Decree is passed. The Trial Court's
Judgment and Decree qua Suit Item No.2 is sustained. In view of the facts
and circumstances of this case, there shall be no order as to costs in this
Appeal Suit.
[N.S.K., J.]
[R.S.V., J.]
3 / 02 / 2026
Index
Speaking Order
pam/TK
: Yes / No
: Yes
: Yes
Page No.34 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.NO.980 OF 2020
To
The Sessions (Fast Track Mahila) Judge,
Namakkal.
Page No.35 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.NO.980 OF 2020
N.SATHISH KUMAR, J.
AND
R. SAKTHIVEL, J.
pam/TK
PRE-DELIVERY JUDGMENT MADE IN
A.S.NO.980 OF 2020
3 / 02 / 2026
Page No.36 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review