Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C)No.780 of 2024
Saral Bahadur Molsom,
son of Late Rana Manik Molsom
of Village-Shankhala & P.O. & P.S. Taidu,
Amarpur, Gomati District, Tripura, Aged-51 years
---- Petitioner (s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura,
to be represented by the Secretary,
Rural Development Department,
Government of Tripura,
New Secretariat Building,
New Capital Complex, Kunjaban,
P.S. New Capital Complex, Agartala,
West Tripura, PIN-799010
2. The Joint Secretary,
Rural Development Department,
Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Building,
New Capital Complex, Kunjaban,
P.S. New Capital Complex, Agartala,
West Tripura, PIN-799010
3. The Deputy Secretary,
Rural Development Department,
Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Building,
New Capital Complex, Kunjaban,
P.S. New Capital Complex, Agartala,
West Tripura, PIN-799010
4. The District Magistrate & Collector,
Gomati District Tripura, Government of Tripura,
O/o the District Magistrate & Collector,
Gomati Tripura, Udaipur, PIN-799120
5. The Block Development Officer,
Ompi R.D. Block, O/o the Block Development Officer,
Ompi R.D. Block, Gomati Tripura, PIN-799101
----Respondent(s)
_____________________________________________________
For Petitioner (s)
:
Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Karnajit De, Addl. G.A.
Date of Hearing of
Judgment & Order
:
17.02.2025
[---
Whether fit for reporting :
YES
_________________________________________________________
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order(Oral)
Heard
Mr.
Samarjit
Bhattacharjee,
Learned
counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner and Mr. Karnajit
(2)
De, Learned Addl. G.A. appearing on behalf of the Staterespondents.
[02]
By means of this filing this writ petition, the
petitioner has sought for the following reliefs :
i. Pass an ad interim Order the operation of the
Memorandum, dated 19.05.2023, issued by the Block
Development Officer, Ompi R.D. Block, till disposal of
the instant Writ Petition.
ii. Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as
to why Writ in the nature of mandamus and/or
Order/direction shall not be issued whereby quashing
and cancelling the impugned Memorandum, dated,
19.05.2023, issued by the Block Development Officer,
Ompi R.D. Block.
iii. Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as
to why Writ in the nature of mandamus and/or
Order/direction shall not be issued whereby directing
the Respondents not to cause any recovery from the
Petitioner
in
connection
with
his
ACP-I
financial
benefits.
iv. Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as
to why Writ in the nature of mandamus and/or
Order/direction shall not be issued whereby directing
the Respondents to reimburse the Petitioner with the
money already deducted from his salary in the guise of
recovery
consequent
to
the
issuance
of
the
Memorandum, dated 19.05.2023.
v. Make the rules absolute.
vi. Call for records.
vii. Pass any further order/orders as this Hon’ble High
Court considered fit and proper.”
(3)
[03]
The brief facts mentioned in the writ petition are in
short is that vide Memo No.F./122-A/DM/S/ESTT/151 dated
19.02.2004 issued by the District Magistrate & Collector, Gomati
District the petitioner was appointed to the post of Computer
Operator in Community Information Centre (CIC), under the
Directorate of Information Technology (Department of Industries
and Commerce) on contract basis for two years on the terms and
conditions mentioned therein and accordingly, the petitioner
joined under the Respondents on 21.02.2004.
[04]
After that vide notification dated 27.06.2009,
issued by the Joint Secretary, Rural Development Department,
Government of Tripura, the Governor had been pleased to grant
regular
scale
Operators
of pay of Rs.4200-8650/- to
(CIC)
(Group-C,
Non-Gazetted),
Computer
including
the
Petitioner after continuous service without break on fixed pay
basis. It was also mentioned that the past services of those 52
numbers of Computer Operators under CIC rendered in the IT
Department would be counted towards future service benefit,
and the benefit of regular scale had been extended to those 52
incumbents w.e.f. 01.12.2008.
[05]
The petitioner further asserted that thereafter vide
order dated 08.08.2012 issued by the District Magistrate &
Collector, Gomati District, the petitioner along with three others
were re-designated as Senior Computer Assistant with fixed
emoluments of Rs.7,060/- only per month (being 75% of the
entry level pay in the pay Band-2 of Rs.5,310 – 24,000/- and
grade pay of Rs.2,100/-) w.e.f. the date mentioned in the said
order. In the list mentioned in the aforesaid order, name of the
petitioner appeared at Sl. No.01 and his date of joining in service
(4)
has been reflected on 21.02.2004. It was also further mentioned
in the said order that the date of effect of re-designation of the
petitioner
as
Senior
Computer
Assistant
would
be
w.e.f.
01.01.2006 and financial benefit would be given effect from
01.01.2009.
[06]
Further, the petitioner was allowed the benefit of ACP-I
on completion of his 10 years of regular and satisfactory service
from the date of his entry into Government service i.e. on
21.02.2004 and the effective date from which such ACP shall be
admissible was determined as 21.02.2014 and accordingly, the
petitioner was allowed one increment on the pay of existing pay
Band and Grade Pay plus next available Grade Pay as benefit of
financial up-gradation under the ACP Scheme.
[07]
Thereafter, vide Memorandum dated 31.12.2016,
issued by the Block Development Officer, Ompi RD Block, Gomati
Tripura the petitioner was granted the benefit of financial upgradation under ACP as per TSCS (Revised Pay) Rules, 2009
(12th Amendment Rules, 2015). It has been mentioned in the
said Memorandum that as per Tripura State Civil Service
(Revised Pay) Rules, 2009 (12th Amendment Rules, 2015) vide
notification No.F.6(1)-FIN(PC)/2012 dated 31.03.2015, the pay
of Sri Saral Bahadur Molsom, Senior Computer Operator, i.e., the
petitioner herein had been re-fixed under ACP-I in the scale of
pay of Rs.5700-24000/- with Grade Pay of Rs.4200/- under PB2. It was further mentioned herein that consequently pay of the
petitioner was fixed at Rs.13,360/- (Rs.11960-2800+4200) on
21.02.2014 with DNI on 01.07.2014 (by allowing only higher
grade pay of Rs.4200/-). From the said memorandum, it is also
reflected that as per option exercised by the petitioner, his pay
(5)
had been once again re-fixed at Rs.14,090/- on 01.07.2014 by
allowing two increments at a time one annual increment and
second under ACP-I provided under Note-1 and 2 of Rule 12 of
TSCS (Revised Pay) Rules, 2009 and his DNI was fixed on
01.07.2015.
[08]
Thereafter,
Development
the
Department,
Deputy
Government
Secretary,
Rural
of
vide
Tripura
communication dated 20.09.2014 to various District Magistrate
and Collectors, Government of Tripura inter alia notified that the
Finance Department, Government of Tripura had opined that the
contractual period of service rendered by a Government servant
would not be taken into account for computing the required
period of service for the grant of ACP benefit. Accordingly, the
Finance Department, Government of Tripura directed that those
Computer Operators (CIC), who had been allowed the benefit of
ACP, taking the contractual period of service into consideration,
should be immediately cancelled and the excess amount paid to
them, should be recovered from them at the earliest.
[09]
Thereafter,
the
Additional
Secretary,
Rural
Development, Government of Tripura made a communication
dated 05.05.2018 to all the District Magistrate and Collectors,
Government of Tripura requesting them to send the status
regarding the grant of ACP-I benefit to the Senior Computer
Assistant,
Rural
Development
Department,
Government
of
Tripura posted under their respective controls and further
directing them that in the event that any Senior Computer
Assistant, RD Department, Government of Tripura had already
been granted the benefit of ACP-I, such benefit should be
immediately withdrawn. In pursuance of that, the District
(6)
Magistrate and Collector, Gomati, Tripura issued Memorandum
dated 11.05.2018 thereby withdrawing the benefit of ACP-I
earlier granted in favour of the petitioner and similarly situated
other Senior Computer Assistant, RD Department, Government
of Tripura.
[10]
Being aggrieved by the aforesaid Memorandum
dated 11.05.2018, the petitioner along with similarly situated
others, approached the Hon’ble High Court of Tripura challenging
the said memorandum which was numbered as WP(C)No.537 of
2018 and the Hon’ble High Court vide order dated 30.05.2018
stayed the operation of the impugned memo dated 11.05.2018,
whereby the benefit of ACP-I had already been withdrawn by the
DM and Collector, Gomati District.
[11]
This High Court after hearing vide judgment dated
03.10.2019 allowed the writ petition bearing No. WP(C) 537 of
2018 along with other connected writ petitions. Challenging that
judgment, the State-respondents filed writ appeal before the
Hon’ble Division Bench, High Court of Tripura which was
numbered as W.A. 139 of 2020. But the Hon’ble Division Bench,
High Court of Tripura vide common judgment and order dated
02.03.2021 allowed the said writ appeal and other connected
writ appeals. However, the Hon’ble Division Bench, according to
the petitioner, did not direct the state-respondents to cause
recovery of the benefits already given to the incumbents. But the
Senior Deputy Magistrate, O/o the District Magistrate and
Collector,
Gomati
District,
Udaipur
issued
letter
dated
19.11.2021 to the Block Development Officer, Ompi RD Block
and others whereby requesting him to confirm about recovery of
the excess amount paid to the Senior Computer Assistant and
(7)
submit a due drawn statement by 25th November, 2021 and
consequently, the BDO, Ompi RD Block issued one Memorandum
on 13.01.2022. But all on a sudden, the BDO, Ompi RD Block
issued another Memorandum dated 19.05.2023 whereby it was
notified that as Audit observation raised by the Audit Officer of
Directorate of Audit, Finance Department, Government of Tripura
vide
No.F.8(1)/AUD-DIR/IA/RDD/10080/GA/2022-23/364-65
dated 20.04.2023 regarding overdrawn salary to the tune of
Rs.6,44,748/- in connection with allowing of unnatural ACP
benefit in the form of personal pay from 21.04.2014 to
01.07.2021 in favour of Sri Saral Bahadur Molsom, Senior
Computer Assistant (SCA) under Ompi RD Block and it was also
mentioned that the whole amount would be recovered as
installments from pay bills of the petitioner from May, 2023
payable in the month of June, 2023 in 128 installments @
Rs.5,000/- per month and one installment for Rs.4,478/- from
May, 2023 to January, 2034. It was further mentioned by the
petitioner that the monthly deductions from the petitioners
salary has already started since June, 2023 and as a result of
such deduction, the petitioner suffered severe pecuniary loss.
Hence, the petitioner has filed the present writ petition with the
grounds as stated above.
[12]
In course of hearing of argument, Mr. Samarjit
Bhattacharjee, Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
petitioner fairly submitted that in similarly situated cases this
High Court granted benefits to the different petitioners cancelling
the recovery order and Learned counsel in course of hearing
relied upon another order passed by this Court in WP(C)No.416
(8)
of 2024 dated 10.01.2025 and submitted that the same order
may also be passed in this case.
[13]
The state-respondents in this case did not file any
counter-affidavit, however, in course of hearing of argument, Mr.
Karjanit De, Learned Addl. G.A. fairly submitted that this case is
squarely covered by a judgment of this Court in WP(C)No.416 of
2024 and WP(C)No.430 of 2024 and urged before the Court to
pass appropriate order.
[14]
I have heard submission of both the parties and
perused the writ petition filed by the writ petitioner. There is no
dispute on record that the petitioner was appointed as Computer
Operator, Group-C in the establishment of Department of R.D.
Department in the year 2004 and after completion of ten years
service he was given the given benefit of ACP-I w.e.f.21.02.2004
by the Department after taking into account of his period of
contractual service and regular service. But the dispute started
after issuing Memorandum of D.M. & Collector, Gomati District,
Udaipur dated 11.05.2018 withdrawing of ACP-I benefit provided
to the present petitioner along with others and accordingly, the
other petitioners challenged the same before the High Court as
discussed earlier.
[15]
In this regard, Hon’ble the Supreme Court of India
in State of Punjab and Others vs. Rafiq Masih (White
Washer) and Others reported in (2015) 4 SCC 334 in para
No.18 observed as under:
“18. It is not possible to postulate all situations of
hardship, which would govern employees on the issue
of recovery, where payments have mistakenly been
made by the employer, in excess of their entitlement.
Be that as it may, based on the decisions referred to
herein above, we may, as a ready reference,
summarise the following few situations, wherein
(9)
recoveries by the employers, would be impermissible
in law:
(i) Recovery from employees belonging to Class-III
and Class-IV service (or Group 'C' and Group 'D'
service).
(ii) Recovery from retired employees, or employees
who are due to retire within one year, of the order of
recovery.
(iii) Recovery from employees, when the excess
payment has been made for a period in excess of five
years, before the order of recovery is issued.
(iv) Recovery in cases where an employee has
wrongfully been required to discharge duties of a
higher post, and has been paid accordingly, even
though he should have rightfully been required to
work against an inferior post.
(v) In any other case, where the Court arrives at the
conclusion, that recovery if made from the employee,
would be iniquitous or harsh or arbitrary to such an
extent, as would far outweigh the equitable balance of
the employer's right to recover.”
Referring the same, Learned counsel submitted
that in view of the principle of law laid down by the Hon’ble Apex
court in the said case there is no scope to recover the excess
amount already paid by the respondents to the petitioner. It was
also submitted that the aforesaid clause-i and clause-ii of the
said judgment would be applied in this case.
[16]
The petitioner also relied upon another judgment
of this High Court in WP(C) No.1342 of 2016 dated 13.07.2017
in para Nos.5, 6, 7, 8 and 9, wherein this High Court observed as
under:
“5. The grievance of the petitioners is thus confined to
the recovery as directed by the order dated
15.11.2016. Mr. Pal, learned counsel has fairly
submitted that in terms of the said memorandum
dated 21.06.2013 if the pay of the petitioners is
refixed, the said arrears as calculated by the Head of
Office, can be shown as the excess drawn by the
petitioners, but after five years when the petitioners
have consumed that sum whether the recovery should
be permitted. This is the sole question that has fallen
for consideration of this court. Mr. Pal, learned counsel
has asserted that in view of Rafiq Masih (supra) such
recovery cannot be permitted as the Apex Court has
clearly laid the guideline that recovery from the
employees belonging to the class III and class IV
services or Group „C‟ and Group „D‟ services whose
excess payment has been made for a period in excess
of five years before the order of recovery was issued
cannot be made.
6. In the present case, the petitioners have enjoyed
the said excess amount for five years when the order
of recovery was issued and hence following the
(10)
guidelines as laid down by the Apex Court in Rafiq
Masih (supra), the respondents be prohibited from
recovering any amount from the petitioners. For
purpose of reference, the relevant paragraph where
the guidelines are laid down has been extracted
hereunder:
“It is not possible to postulate all situations of
hardship, which would govern employees on
the issue of recovery, where payments have
mistakenly been made by the employer, in
excess of their entitlement. Be that as it may,
based on the decisions referred to herein
above, we may, as a ready reference,
summarise the following few situations,
wherein recoveries by the employers, would be
impermissible in law: (i) Recovery from
employees belonging to ClassIII and Class-IV
service (or Group 'C' and Group 'D' service). (ii)
Recovery
from
retired
employees,
or
employees who are due to retire within one
year, of the order of recovery. (iii) Recovery
from employees, when the excess payment has
been made for a period in excess of five years,
before the order of recovery is issued. (iv)
Recovery in cases where an employee has
wrongfully been required to discharge duties of
a higher post, and has been paid accordingly,
even though he should have rightfully been
required to work against an inferior post. (v)
In any other case, where the Court arrives at
the conclusion, that recovery if made from the
employee, would be iniquitous or harsh or
arbitrary to such an extent, as would far
outweigh the equitable balance of the
employer's right to recover.”
7. Mr. Chakraborty, learned Additional Government
Advocate has fairly admitted that on the day of issuing
the impugned order dated 15.11.2016 (Annexure P-7
to the writ petition) the time frame of five years had
expired, but the notice was issued to the petitioner
much before that, i.e. on 22.09.2016. That apart, Mr.
Chakraborty, learned Additional Government Advocate
has submitted that an undertaking was taken from the
petitioner at the time of making payment on refixation of pay in the promotional post that had they
received any amount in excess they would refund the
said amount. Mr. Chakraborty, learned Additional
Government Advocate did not dispute the fact that
after issuance of the memorandum dated 21.06.2013
the clarification generated a new circumstances when
the fact of the drawal of the excess amount was
located as the petitioners‟ pay in the promotional post
was again refixed. Mr. Chakraborty, learned Additional
Government Advocate has submitted having referred
para 11 of the reply that the Head of Office for reason
best known to him had taken the action after 3 years
and 4 months from the date of issuance of the said
memorandum dated 21.06.2013.
8. Having appreciated the submissions made by the
learned counsel appearing for the parties, this court is
of the view that if the recovery is permitted, it would
be inequitous and harsh and it would out-weigh the
equitable balance.
9. In view of this, the impugned order of recovery
dated 15.11.2016 (Annexure 7 to the writ petition) is
set aside and quashed. The respondents are directed
not to recover any amount from the petitioner which
has been determined to have drawn by the petitioner
in excess of the pay till their refixation in terms of the
memorandum dated 21.06.2013 (Annexure R-1 to the
writ petition).”
(11)
Referring the same Learned counsel appearing for
the petitioner submitted that in view of the aforesaid citation
there is no scope on the part of the State respondents to recover
the amount from the petitioner which is already been paid.
[17]
Learned
counsel
finally
relied
upon
another
citation of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Jagdish Prasad Singh
vs. State of Bihar and Others reported in 2024 SCC OnLine
SC 1909 wherein para Nos. 23, 24, 27 and 28 Hon’ble the Apex
Court observed as under:
“23. In the case of State of Punjab and Others v. Rafiq
Masih (White Washer) and Others3, this Court held as
under: “18. It is not possible to postulate all situations
of hardship which would govern employees on
the issue of recovery, where payments have
mistakenly been made by the employer, in
excess of their entitlement. Be that as it may,
based on the decisions referred to hereinabove,
we may, as a ready reference, summarise the
following few situations, wherein recoveries by
the employers, would be impermissible in law:
(i) Recovery from the employees belonging to
Class III and Class IV service (or Group C and
Group D service). (ii) Recovery from the retired
employees, or the employees who are due to
retire within one year, of the order of recovery.
(iii) Recovery from the employees, when the
excess payment has been made for a period in
excess of five years, before the order of
recovery is issued. (iv) Recovery in cases
where an employee has wrongfully been
required to discharge duties of a higher post,
and has been paid accordingly, even though he
should have rightfully been required to work
against an inferior post. (v) In any other case,
where the court arrives at the conclusion, that
recovery if made from the employee, would be
iniquitous or harsh or arbitrary to such an
extent, as would far outweigh the equitable
balance of the employer's right to recover.”
(emphasis supplied)
24. Recently, this Court in Thomas Daniel v. State of
Kerala and Others: 2022 SCC OnLine SC 536, held that
the State cannot recover excess amount paid to the
exemployee after the delay of 10 years.
27. The order dated 8th October, 2009 passed by the
State Government directing reduction in the pay scale
of the appellant from Rs.6500-10500 to Rs.5500-9000
w.e.f. 1st January, 1996 and directing recovery of the
excess amount from him is grossly illegal and arbitrary
and is hereby quashed and set aside. The impugned
order dated 27th August, 2012 passed by the Division
Bench of the High Court does not stand to scrutiny and
is hereby quashed. Therefore, the appellant shall
continue to receive the pension in accordance with the
pay scale of Rs.6500-10500.
(12)
28. In case, if any reduction in pension and
consequential recovery was effected on account of the
impugned orders, the appellant shall be entitled to the
restoration/reimbursement thereof with interest as
applicable.”
Referring the same Learned counsel further drawn
the attention of this court that by this time some amount is
already been deducted from the salary bill of the petitioner so a
direction may accordingly be given to the State-respondents to
refund/restore the said amount to the petitioner if deducted from
the salary bill.
[18]
So, after hearing submission of both the sides it
appears to this Court that this case is also squarely covered by
the judgment of this High Court in WP(C)No.416 of 2024 and
WP(C)No.430 of 2024. Accordingly, in view of the principles laid
down by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the aforenoted cases and also
on perusal of the judgment passed by this Court and a
coordinate Bench of this High Court this Court is of the view that
if at this stage, the recovery is permitted, in that case it would
be unjustified and harsh to the petitioner and it would also cause
serious hardships to the petitioner.
So, in view of the above, the impugned order of
recovery dated 19.05.2023 issued by BDO, Ompi, R.D. Block,
Gomati District i.e. Annexure-9 to the writ petition is accordingly
stands set aside and quashed. The respondents are directed not
to recover any amount from the petitioner which has been
determined to have been withdrawn by the petitioner, in excess
of the pay.
[19]
In the result, the writ petition is allowed to the
extent as indicated above. However, if any amount by this time
is deducted from the salary bill of the petitioner that shall be
(13)
refunded/restored to the petitioner by the respondent authority
within a period of 4(four) months from the date of passing of this
order. The interim order dated 16.12.2024 passed by this Court
in connection with I.A. No.01 of 2024 arising out of WP(C)No.780
of 2024 is thus hereby made absolute.
There shall be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
signed by
SABYASACHI Digitally
SABYASACHI
BHATTACHARJ BHATTACHARJEE
Date: 2025.02.20 05:04:09
EE
+05'30'
Sabyasachi B
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review