Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE VIJAY KUMAR SHUKLA
ON THE 19th OF JANUARY, 2024
CRIMINAL REVISION No. 4976 of 2023
BETWEEN:SAPAN GOYAL S/O MOHANLAL AGARWAL, AGED
ABOUT 30 YEARS, OCCUPATION: BUSINESS R/O 302,
INDIRA ANDHI WARD HARDA (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI ABHIJEET DUBE - ADVOCATE)
AND
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH STATION HOUSE
OFFICER THROUGH POLICE STATION KHUDEL,
DISTRICT INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENT
(BY SHRI AJAY RAJ GUPTA - P.L.)
T h is revision coming on for orders this day, t h e cou rt passed the
following:
ORDER
The present Revision is filed under Section 397 & Section 401 of Cr.P.C
being aggrieved by the order dated 28.8.2023 passed by IX Additional Sessions
Judge, Indore, District Indore in S.T No.375/2022 whereby the charges has
been framed against the appellant under Section 467, 468, 471, 477A, 408 &
381 of IPC.
2. According to the prosecution case, the complainant is the director of
the M / S carryon food Pvt. Ltd. and the other directors are the son and
daughter-in- law, Smt. Deepaii, of the complainant. The company of the
Signed by: PRAMOD
KUSHWAHA
Signing time: 19-01-2024
18:43:44
complainant deals with the manufacturing and sale of the snacks and namkeen.
The complainant appointed his relative i.e. the applicant/accused as a Manager
in the company. The applicant/accused was responsible to handle and manage
all the work in the company, in which the applicant/accused used to transport
the manufacturing items to the known shops and after that he used to deposit
the amount in the account of the company of the complainant. The
Applicant/accused was involved in the income & expenditure work of the
company of the complainant and also took care of the manufacturing and sale
of the product of the company. Furthermore, all the entries of the income &
expenditure are maintained in tally by the applicant/accused. Tally was
purchased in the name of complainant's son Navneet Goyal, but the
applicant/accused looked after all the work of the company that's why
complainant has provided the ID and Password of the Tally to the
applicant/accused. The complainant used to sale materials with the help of
applicant/ accused, still the company was under loss from last 2 years, so the
complainant asked the applicant/accused why the company is still going under
loss and in reply the applicant/accused said that the turnover of the company is
less that is why the profit is less, the complainant trusted the applicant/accused.
3. During the course of the argument, counsel for the petitioner confined
his challenge to the charge under Section 467, 468, 471, 477A of IPC and
stated that he does not want to challenge the charges under Section 408 & 381
of IPC.
4. It is argued that upon perusal of the impugned FIR and charge-sheet,
no offence is made out under Section 467, 468, 471 and 477A of IPC. As per
the prosecution case, the petitioner used to collect the amount in case and
keeps the remaining money with him. In that way he has made loss to the
Signed by: PRAMOD
KUSHWAHA
Signing time: 19-01-2024
18:43:44
company this at the most the charges under Section 408 shall be made out and
there is no allegation of committing any forgery by making any false documents.
It is argued that the ingredients of Section 467 and Section 471 of IPC of
forgery are not existing. In support of his allegation he places reliance on the
judgment passed by the Apex Court in the case of Md. Ibrahim and Ors. Vs.
State of Bihar and Ors. passed in Criminal Appeal No.1695/2009 decided
on 4/9/2009. In the said case the term forgery has been considered. Para 9 & 10
of the said judgment are reproduced as under:9.The term "forgery" used in these two sections is defined in
Section 463. Whoever makes any false documents with intent
to cause damage or injury to the public or to any person, or
to support any claim or title, or to cause any person to part
with property, or to enter into express or implied contract, or
with intent to commit fraud or that the fraud may be
committed, commits forgery. Section 464 defining "making a
false document is extracted below:
464. Making a false document.--A person is said to
make a false document or false electronic record--First.--Who dishonestly or fraudulently (a)makes, signs, seals or executes a document or part
of a document;
(b) makes or transmits any electronic record or part of
any electronic record;
(c) affixes any digital signature on any electronic
record;
(d) makes any mark denoting the execution of a
document or the authenticity of the digital signature,
with the intention of causing it to be believed that such
document or a part of document, electronic record or
digital signature was made, signed, sealed, executed,
transmitted or affixed by or by the authority of a person
by whom or by whose authority he knows that it was not
made, signed, sealed, executed or affixed; or
Secondly.--Who, without lawful authority, dishonestly or
Signed by: PRAMOD
KUSHWAHA
Signing time: 19-01-2024
18:43:44
fraudulently, by cancellation or otherwise, alters a
document or an electronic record in any material part
thereof, after it has been made, executed or affixed with
digital signature either by himself or by any other person,
whether such person be living or dead at the time of such
alternation; or
Thirdly.--Who dishonestly or fraudulently causes any
person to sign, seal, execute or alter a document or an
electronic record or to affix his digital signature on any
electronic record knowing that such person by reason of
unsoundness of mind or intoxication cannot, or that by
reason of deception practised upon him, he does not know
the contents of the document or electronic record or the
nature of the alteration.
Explanation 1 - A man's signature of his own name may
amount to forgery.
Explanation 2 The making of a false document in the name
of a fictitious person, intending it to be believed that the
document was made by a real person, or in the name of a
deceased person, intending it to be believed that the
document was made by the person in his lifetime, may
amount to forgery.
[Note: The words 'digital signature' wherever it occurs were
substituted by the words 'electronic signature' by
Amendment Act 10 of 2009].
The condition precedent for an offence under Sections 467
and 471 is forgery. The condition precedent for forgery is
making a false document (or false electronic record or part
thereof). This case does not relate to any false electronic
record. Therefore, the question is whether the first accused,
in executing and registering the two sale deeds purporting to
sell a property (even if it is assumed that it did not belong to
him), can be said to have made and executed false
documents, in collusion with the other accused.
10. An analysis of Section 464 of Penal Code shows that it
divides false documents into three categories:
10.1)The first is where a person dishonestly or
fraudulently makes or executes a document with the
intention of causing it to be believed that such document
was made or executed by some other person, or by the
Signed by: PRAMOD
KUSHWAHA
Signing time: 19-01-2024
18:43:44
authority of some other person, by whom or by whose
authority he knows it was not made or executed.
10.2) The second is where a person dishonestly or
fraudulently, by cancellation or otherwise, alters a
document in any material part, without lawful authority,
after it has been made or executed by either himself or
any other person.
10.3) The third is where a person dishonestly or
fraudulently causes any person to sign, execute or alter a
document knowing that such person could not by
reason of (a) unsoundness of mind; or (b) intoxication;
or (c) deception practised upon him, know the contents
of the document or the nature of the alteration.
5. Per contra counsel for the State supported the impugned order and
submitted that there are allegations and prima facie material available against the
petitioner who was admittedly working on the post of Manager that he had
committed forgery with the account and receipts. As per the statement of
Navneet Goyal(son of the complainant), it is clear that the petitioner was
provided I.D and password for maintaining the aforesaid record of the
company. He manipulated the documents and had shown the entries of quantity
of the articles less than the quantity of the articles which were actually sold. He
also referred that there is a receipt issued by the petitioner showing the payment
of Rs.52,000/- which has admittedly been found to be forged.
6. I have heard learned counsel for the parties.
7. In so far as the revisional jurisdiction in examining the orders as to the
framing of charges is concerned, it is condign to quote the following extract of
the judgment passed by Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of State of Rajasthan
v. Fatehkaran Mehdu, (2017) 3 SCC 198, herein below:
“ 2 6 . The scope of interference and exercise of
jurisdiction under Section 397 CrPC has been time
and again explained by this Court. Further, the
Signed by: PRAMOD
KUSHWAHA
Signing time: 19-01-2024
18:43:44
scope of interference under Section 397 CrPC at a
stage, when charge had been framed, is also well
settled. At the stage of framing of a charge, the court
is concerned not with the proof of the allegation
rather it has to focus on the material and form an
opinion whether there is strong suspicion that the
accused has committed an offence, which if put to
trial, could prove his guilt. The framing of charge is
not a stage, at which stage final test of guilt is to be
applied.
Thus, to hold that at the stage of framing the
charge, the court should form an opinion that the
accused is certainly guilty of committing an offence,
is to hold something which is neither permissible nor
is in consonance with the scheme of the Code of
Criminal Procedure.”
8. In terms of the revisional jurisdiction in examining the orders passed
by trial Court, the following excerpt of the judgment of Hon’ble Apex Court in
the recent case of Amit Kapoor vs. Ramesh Chandra reported as (2022) 9
SCC 460 is propitious to reproduce here under:“12. Section 397 of the Code vests the court with the
power to call for and examine the records of an
inferior court for the purposes of satisfying itself as to
the legality and regularity of any proceedings or order
made in a case. The object of this provision is to set
right a patent defect or an error of jurisdiction or law.
There has to be a well-founded error and it may not
be appropriate for the court to scrutinise the orders,
which upon the face of it bears a token of careful
consideration and appear to be in accordance with
law. If one looks into the various judgments of this
Court, it emerges that the revisional jurisdiction can be
invoked where the decisions under challenge are
grossly erroneous, there is no compliance with the
provisions of law, the finding recorded is based on no
evidence, material evidence is ignored or judicial
discretion is exercised arbitrarily or perversely. These
are not exhaustive classes, but are merely indicative.
Each case would have to be determined on its own
Signed by: PRAMOD
KUSHWAHA
Signing time: 19-01-2024
18:43:44
merits.
13. Another well-accepted norm is that the revisional
jurisdiction of the higher court is a very limited one
and cannot be exercised in a routine manner. One of
the inbuilt restrictions is that it should not be against
an interim or interlocutory order. The Court has to
keep in mind that the exercise of revisional jurisdiction
itself should not lead to injustice ex facie. Where the
Court is dealing with the question as to whether the
charge has been framed properly and in accordance
with law in a given case, it may be reluctant to
interfere in exercise of its revisional jurisdiction unless
the case substantially falls within the categories
aforestated. Even framing of charge is a much
advanced stage in the proceedings under the CrPC.”
9 . In view of the aforesaid prepositions, the learned trial Court, while
framing of charges, must apply its judicial mind on the material placed on
record and must be satisfied that there is strong possibility subsist that the
accused has committed the offence. At the juncture of framing of charges, the
Court has to prima facie examine whether there is sufficient ground for
proceeding against the accused. Nevertheless, the Court is not expected to
evaluate or analyse the findings in order to arrive at the conclusion that the
material furnished by the prosecution are sufficient to convict the accused or
not? In the case at hand, the findings of learned trial Court regarding prima facie
case against the accused persons appear to be infallible.
10. With regard to the revisional power of this Court, it is well settled that
the jurisdiction of the revisional Court is not as that of an appellate Court, which
is free to reach its own conclusion on evidence untrammeled by any finding
entered by the trial Court. Actually the jurisdiction of revisional Court has a
limited scope. The revisional Court can interfere with the impugned order of the
learned trial Court only when it is unjust and unfair. In case where the order of
Signed by: PRAMOD
KUSHWAHA
Signing time: 19-01-2024
18:43:44
subordinate Court does not suffer from any illegality, merely because of
equitable considerations, the revisional Court has no jurisdiction to re-consider
the matter and pass a different order in a routine manner.
11. Before considering the facts of the present case, it is apposite to refer
the scope of interference against a charge in revisional jurisdiction in the cases
o f State of Rajasthan (supra) and Amit Kapoor (supra). On the anvil of the
aforesaid judgments, if the facts of the present case are examined, the
prosecution has filed certain documents which clearly shows that the false
entries were made by the petitioner in the record of the company showing
wrong entries of sale and payment than the actual sale and payment. One of the
copy of the receipt is also enclosed alongwith the record which has been found
to be forged after investigation. Thus, the contention of the petitioner cannot be
accepted that there is no material at all to establish the ingredients of forgery.
The judgment relied by the counsel for the petitioner passed in the case of Md.
Ibrahim (supra) would not apply to the present case. In the said case the sale
deed was executed by the accused who has not been found to be owner of the
property. The Court held that since the execution of the sale deed is not alleged
to be forged, therefore, if the property is not owned by the executor, the
allegations of forgery under Section 467 & Section 471 of IPC are not made
out. In the present case, the material has been produced which clearly shows
that the petitioner was working as Manager of the company and he was
provided password and I.D and he has forged the records of the company
showing wrong entries in relation to the sale of the articles and transactions
which caused loss to the company.
12. In view of the aforesaid, I do not find any illegality or jurisdictional
error in framing of the charge.
Signed by: PRAMOD
KUSHWAHA
Signing time: 19-01-2024
18:43:44
13. Accordingly, the Revision is dismissed.
CC as per rules.
(VIJAY KUMAR SHUKLA)
JUDGE
Pramod
Signed by: PRAMOD
KUSHWAHA
Signing time: 19-01-2024
18:43:44
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review