Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:26108
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE EASWARAN S.
FRIDAY, THE 7TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 16TH PHALGUNA, 1946
CO NO. 76 OF 2023
AGAINST THE AWARD DATED 29.07.2020 IN MACA NO.1456 OF
2021 OF HIGH COURT OF KERALA
CROSS OBJECTOR/1ST RESPONDENT:
SANTHOSH
AGED 43 YEARS
S/O JOSEPH, LIJO BHAVAN, MEKKAD, PANMANA,
CHAVARA, KOLLAM-, PIN – 691583.
BY ADVS.
PRATHEESH.P
ANJANA KANNATH
RESPONDENT/APPELLANT & RESPONDENT 2 & 3:
THE DIVISIONAL MANAGER,
NEW INDIA ASSURANCE COMPANY LTD
BEACH ROAD, KOLLAM
REPRESENTED BY ITS ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICER,
REGIONAL OFFICE, ERNAKULAM, PIN – 682011.
THE MANAGING DIRECTOR
K.S.R.T.C, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN – 695023.
SANIL KUMAR
S/O SUDHAKARAN, PANDAKASSALAYIL, CHAVARA,
KOLLAM-, PIN – 691583.
BY ADV LAL K.JOSEPH
THIS
CROSS
ADMISSION
OBJECTION/CROSS
ON
07.03.2025,
DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
APPEAL
THE
HAVING
COURT
ON
COME
THE
UP
FOR
SAME
DAY
CO No.76/2023
in MACA No.1456/2021
2025:KER:26108
JUDGMENT
The cross-objection is preferred by the claimant against the
award passed in OP(MV)No.371/2016 by the Motor Accidents
Claims
Tribunal,
Kollam.
The
Insurance
Company
had
questioned the award in MACA No.1456/2021 and by judgment
dated
06.03.2025
this
Court
dismissed
the
said
appeal.
However, while dismissing the appeal preferred by the Insurance
Company, the pendency of the cross-objection was not noted
and
therefore
the
cross-objection
was
later
listed
for
consideration.
2.
The brief facts necessary for the disposal of the cross-
objection are as follows:
On 03.07.2013, while the cross-objector/claimant, claiming
to be a fisherman, was travelling on a motorcycle bearing
registration No.KL-7/BB-5640 through Kollam- Alappuzha NH 47
in the north-south direction in front of Titanium Sponge Factory
at Chavara, the offending KSRTC bus bearing registration No.KL15-6459 driven in a rash and negligent manner from south to
CO No.76/2023
in MACA No.1456/2021
2025:KER:26108
north direction i.e. in the opposite direction, hit against the
motor cycle, causing injuries to the claimant. The insurance
company appeared and filed a written statement contending that
the negligence alleged against the 2nd respondent in the claim
petition is not correct. The claim for compensation under various
heads
were
also
cross-objector/claimant,
questioned.
On
behalf
of
the
Exts.A1
A15
documents
were
to
produced before the Tribunal. On behalf of the Insurance
Company, Ext.B1, the case records relating to the Crime was
produced. The cross-objector/claimant examined the eyewitness
who saw the accident as PW1, while the insurance company
examined RW1, the Investigating Officer through whom the CD
File, Ext.X1 was marked. The Tribunal, on appreciation of the
evidence, found that the report filed by the investigating officer
runs contrary to the evidence of PW1, the eyewitness, and
therefore discarded the Final Report and proceeded with the
testimony of PW1 and fastened the liability on the shoulders of
the Insurance Company.
3.
The cross-objector/claimant contended that he was
CO No.76/2023
in MACA No.1456/2021
2025:KER:26108
earning an amount of Rs.20,000/- per mensum. The Tribunal, on
analyzing the evidence, found that the claim of the crossobjector that he was earning Rs.20,000/- per mensum was not
proved. Therefore, the Tribunal proceeded to fix the notional
income at Rs.8,000/- and granted the following compensation:
Sl.No.
Heads
Amount claimed
Loss of earnings
2,00,000/-
Transport to hospital
10,000/-
10,000/-
Extra nourishment
5,000/-
15,000/-
Damages to clothing and
articles
Medicine
Bystander expenses
1,000/3,00,000/10,000/-
1,500/2,45,000/60,000/-
Amount awarded
Compensation for pain and
suffering
1,00,000/compensation for continuing
or permanent disability if any 6,74,000/compensation for loss of
amenities
30,000/compensation for loss of
earning power
6,70,000/-
1,00,000/20,16,000/1,00,000/-
Compensation for future
treatment
Total
4.
Heard,
2,00,000/20,00,000/-
Smt.Anjana
Kannath
27,47,500/-
–
learned
counsel
appearing for the cross-objector and Sri.Lal K.Joseph – learned
counsel appearing for the Insurance Company.
5.
The learned counsel for the cross-objector submitted
CO No.76/2023
in MACA No.1456/2021
2025:KER:26108
that though the claim has been restricted by the cross objector
to Rs.50,000/-, if this Court is of the view that the cross-objector
is entitled for compensation more than what is claimed, then the
claimant is prepared to remit the deficit court fee.
6.
It is under the above premises, that this Court is
proceeding to consider the cross-objection on merits.
7.
On a reading of the award passed by the Tribunal, it is
seen that the Tribunal as per Ext.A11 has noticed the fact that,
during the course of treatment, the claimant had to undergo
amputation of right below knee with stump closer. Even though,
in the absence of any disability certificate the Tribunal assessed
the permanent disability at 100%, since this Court has already
dismissed the appeal preferred by the Insurance Company, the
inevitable conclusion is that the claimant is entitled to get just
and fair compensation in tune with the law governing grant of
compensation towards permanent disability.
It is in the above
backdrop that this Court will discuss the entitlement of the crossobjector for the compensation under the head permanent
disability.
CO No.76/2023
in MACA No.1456/2021
2025:KER:26108
8.
Before dwelling into the said issue, this Court need to
address the question of the notional income liable to be fixed in
respect of the claimant.
In the claim statement, the claimant
had contended that he was having an income to the tune of
Rs.20,000/-.
However, it must be noted that no evidence was
adduced by the claimant to prove that he was earning an
amount of Rs.20,000/-.
However, it must be noted that while
fixing the notional income at Rs.8,000/- per mensum, the
Tribunal failed to consider the principle laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Ramachandrappa v. Manager, Royal
Sundaram Alliance Insurance Company Ltd. [(2011) 13 SCC
236]. Therefore, this Court finds that the claimant is entitled for
an amount of Rs.9,000/- as notional income.
9.
A perusal of the award passed by the Tribunal shows
that under various non conventional heads like pain and
suffering,
attendant
charges
etc,
the
Tribunal
has
erred
egregiously in not granting adequate compensation.
10.
Future attendant charges – on a reading of the
award, it appears that the Tribunal had granted bystander
CO No.76/2023
in MACA No.1456/2021
2025:KER:26108
expenses at Rs.200/- per day for ten months.
The aforesaid
grant is only for the period which the claimant underwent
treatment in the hospital.
However, the Tribunal did not grant
any future attendant charges by applying the multiplier system
as expounded by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Kajal v.
Jagdish
Chand
&
Ors.
[(2020)
SCC
413]
[MANU/SC/0126/2020]. On applying the aforesaid principle, this
Court finds that the claimant is entitled for attendant charges as
follows: 9,000x12x15 = Rs.16,20,000/-.
11.
Permanent disability - Once the notional income is
fixed, then it is imperative for this Court to proceed to consider
the quantum of compensation under the head permanent
disability in accordance with the various principles laid down by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court. In Kajal (supra), the Supreme Court
considered the parameters for grant of compensation in respect
of the claimant who is suffering from 100% permanent disability.
Since this Court has fixed the income of the claimant at
Rs.9,000/-, the compensation towards permanent disability is
reworked as follows: Rs.12,600/-(40% future prospects added)
CO No.76/2023
in MACA No.1456/2021
2025:KER:26108
x12x15=Rs.22,68,000/-.
12.
Pain and sufferings - In the light of the principles
laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Kajal (supra), this
Court finds that the claimant is entitled for a compensation of
Rs.3,00,000/- towards pain and sufferings.
Since the Tribunal
has already awarded Rs.1,00,000/-, the claimant is entitled to
get a further amount of Rs.2,00,000/- as compensation towards
pain and suffering.
13.
Loss of earning – It has come out in evidence that
the claimant was undergoing hospitalization for ten months. The
Tribunal did not thought fit to grant any amount towards loss of
earning.
While it is true that the Tribunal has granted
compensation towards permanent disability by taking into
consideration the functional disability at 100%, nothing prevents
the Tribunal or this Court from granting the compensation under
the heads loss of earning for the period for which the claimant
was undergoing treatment. Hence, the claimant is entitled to get
compensation for the loss of earning for ten months which is
calculated as follows: Rs.9,000/- x 10 = Rs.90,000/-
CO No.76/2023
in MACA No.1456/2021
2025:KER:26108
14.
Loss of amenities – Considering the nature of
disability and also injuries suffered by the claimant, this Court
finds that the claimant is entitled for a compensation of
Rs.2,00,000/- under the head loss of amenities.
Since the
Tribunal has already granted Rs.1,00,000/-, the claimant will be
entitled to get an enhancement of Rs.1,00,000/- under the head
loss of amenities.
Thus in view of the above, the cross objector/claimant is
entitled for enhanced compensation as follows:
Heads
Amount awarded
by the Tribunal
Total
compensation
awarded in
appeal
Enhanced amount
of compensation
Notional income of the claimant is fixed at Rs.9,000/-. Adding 40% future
prospects, the income would come to Rs.12,600/-
Future attendant
charges
Nil
20,16,000/Compensation for
continuing or
permanent disability
16,20,000/[9000x12x15]
16,20,000/-
22,68,000/[12600x12x15]
2,52,000/[22680002016000]
Compensation for
pain and suffering
1,00,000/-
3,00,000/-
2,00,000/[300000-100000]
Loss of earning
Nil
90,000/[9000x10]
90,000/-
Compensation for
loss of amenities
1,00,000/-
2,00,000/-
1,00,000/[200000-100000]
Total enhanced amount of compensation
Accordingly,
the
cross-objector/claimant
22,62,000/-
is
awarded
an
CO No.76/2023
in MACA No.1456/2021
2025:KER:26108
additional compensation of Rs.22,62,000/- (Rupees twenty two
lakhs sixty two thousand only) over and above the compensation
awarded by the Tribunal with interest @8% per annum from the
date of petition till realization together with proportionate costs.
Since the claimant had restricted the amount to Rs.50,000/-, the
claimant is liable to pay additional court fees on the enhanced
amount. The Insurance Company is directed to deposit the
aforesaid amount within a period of two months from the date of
receipt of a copy of this judgment. The Tribunal shall deduct the
deficit court fees from the deposit before releasing the same.
While, calculating interest, it is ordered that the claimant will not be
entitled for interest for a period of 45 days, which represents the
period of delay in filing the cross-objection.
The appeal is ordered accordingly.
Sd/-
EASWARAN S.
JUDGE
ACR
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review