Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.202/2022
Sankar Chandra Natta, Son of Late Nishi Kanta Natta, resident of Sukanta
Colony, Gakulnagar, P.O.-Gakulnagar, P.S.-Bishalgarh, District-Sepahijala,
Tripura.
……… Petitioner(s).
VERSUS
1. The State of Tripura, represented by the Secretary, Government of
Tripura, Department of Home, Civil Secretariat, New Capital Complex,
P.O.-Kunjaban, District:-West Tripura, Pin:-799006.
2. The Secretary, Government of Tripura, Department of Home, Civil
Secretariat, New Capital Complex, P.O.-Kunjaban, P.S.-West Agartala,
District-West Tripura.
3. The Director General of Police, Government of Tripura, Police Head
Quarter, Akhaura Road, PO-Agartala, District:-West Tripura.
4. Inspector General, Government of Tripura, Police Head Quarter, Akhaura
Road, PO-Agartala, District:-West Tripura.
5. Deputy Inspector General, AP (Adm and Trg), Government of Tripura,
Police Head Quarter, Akhaura Road, PO-Agartala, District:-West Tripura.
6. The Commandant, 1st Battalion Tripura State Rifles, Veer Bandhu Gram,
Gakulnagar, P.O.-Gakulnagar, Bishalgarh, District-Sepahijala Tripura.
………Respondent(s).
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Raju Datta, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Mangal Debbarma, Addl. G.A.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
Date of hearing and judgment: 27th June, 2023.
Whether fit for reporting
: YES.
JUDGMENT & ORDER(ORAL)
Heard Mr. Raju Datta, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner and Mr. Mangal Debbarma, learned Addl. Government Advocate
appearing for the respondents-State.
2.
Petitioner has joined service on 01.02.1987 on the post of
Riflemen (Band) under Tripura State Rifles. But he has not got single
promotion since joining in his service. He faced criminal proceedings under
Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC, for short) for intentionally
causing death of his wife. He was sentenced to undergo rigorous
imprisonment for 10(ten) years with a fine of Rs.10,000/- (rupees ten
thousand) by the trial Court under Section 304 Part-II of the IPC vide
judgment dated 14.02.2006 (Annexure-1). However, the appellate Court
acquitted him of the charges vide judgment dated 03.07.2013 passed in
Crl.A. No.31 of 2006 rendered by this Court (Annexure-2). The
departmental proceedings initiated against him for the same charges were
dropped on 11.09.2013. His suspension period was also regularized and
treated as having spent on duty. Thereafter, petitioner urged the department
to grant him promotion which he had in the meantime lost. He approached
this Court in WP(C) No.584 of 2017. The said writ petition was disposed of
vide judgment dated 08.04.2021. It transpires from a reading of the
judgment passed in WP(C) No.584 of 2017 (Annexure-13) that in the DPC
held on 27.08.2012 it was found that for the five years under consideration
for the period between the year 2007-08 to 2011-12 he had got overall
"good" remarks only in three years whereas for the years 2009-10 and 201011 his overall performance was graded as "average". The learned Writ Court
taking into account that the "average" ACRs were not communicated to him
disposed of the writ petition with the following directions:
"7.
In the result, the petition is disposed of with following
directions:
The competent authority shall communicate the
grading of “average” to the petitioner for the said years 200910 and 2010-11 and the remarks on which these overall
gradings are based. This shall be done within a period of four
weeks from today upon which the petitioner would have four
weeks to make a representation to the competent authority
against such remarks if he wishes to. If there is any change in
his overall gradings for both those years and the petitioner
does achieve the remarks of “good” or above, he would be
granted promotion from the date when on the basis of
recommendations of the DPC dated 27.08.2012 the colleagues
and juniors of the petitioner were promoted. This would be
retrospective for all purposes except for pay and allowances.
8.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of."
3.
Petitioner was communicated the grading of "average" for the
period 2009-10 and 2010-11 and he also made a representation for its
upgradation. That has been declined by the respondent No.6 vide orders
dated 30.06.2021 and 07.11.2021 impugned herein. The Reviewing/
Accepting Authority declined to upgrade his ACR after careful appraisal of
his performance and examination of all files and related documents for the
years 2009-10 and 2010-11.
4.
Mr. Raju Datta, learned counsel for the petitioner, submits that
the Reporting Officer is in a better position to consider the performance of
the employee concerned. It is contended that the Reporting Officer
(Company Commandant) had granted him "good" grading for the relevant
years as per statement made at paragraph-12 which was downgraded to
"average" by the Commandant without giving any reasons.
5.
Learned counsel for the petitioner has relied upon the decision
of the Apex Court in the case of Union of India and others vrs. G.R.
Meghwal reported in 2022 SCC OnLine SC 1291 (paragraphs-16 and 17)
and submitted that the opinion of the Reporting Authority ought to have
been accepted. On account of the downgrading of the ACRs for the relevant
years, petitioner has not got any promotion till date. As such, the impugned
orders dated 30.06.2021 and 07.11.2021 call for interference in exercise of
powers of judicial review by this Court.
6.
Mr. Mangal Debbarma, learned Addl. Government Advocate
appearing for the respondents-State, has referred to the counter affidavit. He
submits that the representation of the petitioner was duly considered taking
into account the relevant files and records concerning the relevant years
2009-10 and 2010-11 by the Reviewing Authority and regretted as the
performance of the petitioner was not up to the mark. The list of his
allegations/misdemeanors during that period have been enumerated under
paragraph-12 of the counter affidavit which if read together completely
justifies the downgrading of the ACRs. It is submitted that it is not a case of
lack of any instance of absent from duty or misdemeanor on the part of the
petitioner during the said period calling for interference by the Writ Court in
exercise of judicial review. The recording of ACR depends upon the
satisfaction of the Reporting Authority and the Reviewing Authority which
ordinarily should not be interfered in writ jurisdiction unless it suffers from
malice in law or malice on facts or is totally perverse. Since petitioner was
facing a criminal case, only after his acquittal, the disciplinary proceedings
on similar charges were dropped in September, 2013. During the period of
2009-10 and 2010-11 since several instances of absence from duty and other
misdemeanors were found and charges were also framed for absenting from
duty without permission which led to confinement to the quarter guard and
fine on two occasions, the satisfaction recorded by the Reviewing Authority
after consideration of the representation of the petitioner does not suffer
from any legal infirmity for interference by this Court.
7.
Having considered the submissions of learned counsel for the
parties and having taken into account the relevant pleadings placed from the
record and being conscious of the limited grounds of interference in such
matters relating to recording of ACRs by the Reporting/Reviewing/
Accepting Officers, this Court is of the considered view that the impugned
orders rejecting the representation of the petitioner for review of the ACRs
for the relevant years 2009-10 and 2010-11 do not call for any interference
in exercise of writ jurisdiction as they do not suffer from any perversity or
malice in law. The enumeration of the entries made in his Service Book
relating to absence or other misdemeanors and minor punishments imposed
upon him as well do not leave any room of doubt that the satisfaction
recorded by the Reviewing Authority regarding the grading of the ACR as
"average" does not suffer from any illegality or arbitrariness or perversity
which can be interfered with or substituted by this Court in writ jurisdiction.
The instances of absence and misdemeanors and punishments have been
enumerated at paragraph-12 of the counter affidavit which deserves to be
extracted hereunder in support of the observations recorded by this Court:
"12. That, in reply to para 12 to 14 of the writ petition, I say that
on the following irregularities in discharging duties relating to regular activities of
Battalion and committing offences U/S 10 & 11 of TSR Act, 1983 the ACR
grading for the year 2009-10 and for the year 2010-11 in respect of the petitioner
were considered as "Average". Details are as under:During the period of 2009-2010
(i)
On 03.06.2009 the petitioner was absent from Physical
Training held on 0500 hrs and voluntarily joined duty on 04.06.2009 at 0600
hours submitting written mercy petition on 04.06.2009.
(ii)
On 09.06.2009 the petitioner was absent from morning
PT/Parade and other Battalion duties w.e.f. 09/0515 hrs to 09/1900 hours without
obtaining any permission. Later on the petitioner has submitted Joining report
requesting for mercy for his unauthorized absence from active duties.
(iii) On 24.07.2009 morning the petitioner left Bn HQR and
remained absent from all regimental duties/activities and voluntarily joined duties
on 25.07.2009 at 1815 hours after unauthorized absence for 2(two) days.
(iv) On 20.08.2009 at 1830 hrs the petitioner was found absent
during evening roll call parade and he had been remaining absent from duty till on
21.08.2009 at 1920 hrs. After joining he had submitted representation seeking
mercy for un-authorized absent from duty.
(v)
On 09.09.2009 at 0530 hrs the petitioner was found absent
from morning PT/Parade till 11.09.2009 at 1730 hrs without any permission from
the competent authority. After joining he had submitted an application begging
pardon for absence.
(vi) On 17.11.2009 at 0600 hrs the petitioner was found absent
without obtaining any permission from his superior till 18.11.2009 at 1730 hrs and
voluntarily joined duty by submitting a written representation begging mercy for
his un-authorized absence.
(vii) On 12.01.2010 from 1730 hrs the petitioner had failed to
attend evening roll call which is unbecoming being a member of the Rifles.
(viii) On 28.01.2010 at 1730 hrs the petitioner was found absent
during evening roll call parade and was remaining absent from duty till
29.01.2010 up to 1730 hrs. which is unbecoming being a member of the Rifles.
(ix) On 03.02.2010 at 1730 hrs the petitioner was found absent
from evening roll call till 08.02.2010 at 1030 hrs. without any permission from the
competent authority. At the time of joining he had submitted an application
begging pardon for his absence.
(x)
On 15.03.2010 from 0530 hrs the petitioner had failed to
attend morning PT/Parade and submitted a writ petition with begged mercy.
(xi) On 18.03,.2010 at 1800 hrs the petitioner was detailed for
G.B. Hospital duty but he left BN HQr and remained absent from duties and
voluntarily reported at Battalion head quarters on 20.03.2010 at 1830 hours after
unauthorized absent for 2(two) days.
(xii) On 27.03.2010 at 2200 hrs the petitioner was detailed for 2nd
duty of night area patrolling at Bn HQr but he had failed to perform duty and
remained absent from static duties and voluntarily reported at Bn/HQr on
29.03.2010 at 1000 hours from unauthorized absence.
During the period of 2010-2011
(i)
On 25.04.2010 the petitioner remained absent from scheduled
working fall-in at 1500 hrs and voluntarily joined duties on 29.04.2010 at 1900
hours after 04 (four) days un-authorized absence.
(ii)
On 03.05.2010 at 1500 hrs the petitioner remained unauthorized absent from scheduled working fall-in till on 09.05.2010 at 1800 hours
and voluntarily joined duties after 06(six) days absence.
In addition to the above indiscipline activities, the petitioner was
dealt in Commandant's Orderly Room on 4 (four) occasions and the Commandant
being the Disciplinary Authority awarded following minor punishments
considering guilty of disobedience, neglect of duty and other misconduct during
the period 2009-2010 and 2010-2011. Details of offence and punishment
awarded is furnished below:Sl.
Date of
Gist of Allegation
Punishment
No.
Orderly
awarded
Room
01.
27.03.2010 In that, while Rfn(GD) Sasnkar Ch "Severe Censure"
Natta detailed for Law & Order under
sectionduties at GBP Hospital on 12(1)(f) of TSR Act
26.03.2010 at 1800 hours under 1983.
command of Hav(GD) Ramjan Ali.
During his active duty period he
was drunken and was hue & cry
using filthy words with civil
security which is prejudicial to
good order and discipline of the
Rifles. He has committed an
offence Under section-11(a) of TSR
Act, 1983.
02.
31.03.2010
In that Rfn (Band) Sankar Chandra
Natta was absenting from Bn HQr.
Gokulnagar which detail are as
under:(1) AWL w.e.f. 04.06.2008 to
07.06.2008=04 days
(2) AWL w.e.f. 03.09.2008 to
04.09.2008=01 day
(3) AWL w.e.f. 12.09.2008 to
13.09.2008=01 day
(4) AWL w.e.f. 21.09.2008 to
22.09.2008=01 day
(5) AWL w.e.f. 04.10.2008 to
13.10.2008=08 days
(6) AWL w.e.f. 01.11.2008 to
02.11.2008=02 days
(7) AWL w.e.f. 03.06.2009 to
04.06.2009=01 day
(8) AWL w.e.f. 09.06.2009 to
09.06.2009=01 day
(9) AWL w.e.f. 24.07.2009 to
25.07.2009=02 days
(10) AWL w.e.f. 20.08.2009 to
21.08.2009=01 day
(11) AWL w.e.f. 09.09.2009 to
11.09.2009=03 days
(12) AWL w.e.f. 17.11.2009 to
18.11.2009=02 days
(13) AWL w.e.f. 12.01.2010 to
13.01.2010=01 day
(14) AWL w.e.f. 28.01.2010 to
"Confinement in
quarter guard" for
days
under
section 12(1)(d) of
TSR Act 1983.
29.01.2010=01 day
(15) AWL w.e.f. 03.02.2010 to
08.02.2010=04 days
(16) AWL w.e.f. 15.03.2010 to
15.03.2010=01 day
(17) AWL w.e.f. 18.03.2010 to
20.03.2010=02 days
(18) AWL w.e.f. 27.03.2010 to
29.03.2010=01 day
Total period of absence is 37(thirty
seven) days.
03.
10.05.2010
Charge No.01. Rfn (Band) Sankar
Chandra Natta absenting from
Bn/HQr
Gakulnagar
w.e.f.
25.04.2010 at 1500 hrs without any
permission and voluntarily reported
back after AWL for 04 (four) days
on 29.04.2010 at 1900 hrs, which is
gross misconduct against the
disciplined of the Rifles.
"Confinement in
quarter guard" for
days
under
section 12(1)(d) of
TSR Act 1983.
Charge No.02. Further he absented
from Bn HQr. Gokulnagar w.e.f.
03.05.2010 at 1500 hrs without any
permission from the authority and
voluntarily reported back after
AWL for 06 (six) days on
09.05.2010 at 1800 hrs, which is
gross misconduct against the
disciplined of the Rifles.
Total period of AWL (04 +
06)=10(ten) days.
04.
04.06.2010
Rfn(GD) Sankar Ch Natta and "Fine of 7(seven)
Hav(band) Samir Chandra Natta days
pay
and
both are involved in a physical allowances" under
brawl on 03.06.2010 at 0645 hours section-12(1)(b) of
in Sukanta Market near battalion TSR Act, 1983.
complex, which brings bad image
and reputation and prejudicial to
good order and discipline of the
Rifles.
On the assessment of the performance in respect of the petitioner
during the year of 2009-2010 and for the year of 2010-2011, the Commandant 1st
Bn TSR, respondent No.6 being the ACR Reviewing/ Accepting Authority has
considered and graded ACR of the petitioner for the year of 2009-2010 and for the
year of 2010-2011 as "AVERAGE"."
8.
The instances of absence without leave and misdemeanors
entailing minor punishments upon the petitioner during this period do
substantiate the opinion of the Reviewing Officer in refusing to upgrade the
"average" ACRs of the petitioner for the period in question.
9.
On perusal of the judgment rendered by the Apex Court in the
case of G.R. Meghwal (supra), it appears that the same is not applicable to
the facts of the present case in the light of the discussions made hereinabove
and the numerous instances of absence or misdemeanors and minor
punishments imposed upon the petitioner which the Reporting Officer
seems to have overlooked but was rightly recorded by the Reviewing
Officer.
10.
As such, this Court is not inclined to interfere in the matter.
The writ petition is accordingly dismissed.
Needless to say, this Court has not made any comments upon
the eligibility and claim of the petitioner for promotion for subsequent years
which is open for the petitioner to claim and the respondent to consider in
accordance with law.
Pending application(s), if any, stands disposed of.
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
Date: 2023.06.28
PULAK BANIK 15:30:54 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review