Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:54160
wp13684.26 Judgment.odt
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
WRIT PETITION NO. 13684 OF 2026
Sanjivani Industries
A Proprietorship firm, having
its registered office at A-676,
TTC Industrial Area, Khairane MIDC
Navi Mumbai – 400 709.
...PETITIONER
VERSUS
1. AC Shaikh Contractor
A partnership firm and having
its registered office at ACS Towers,
Opp Jilha Parishad Office,
Near ST Stand, Maliwada,
Ahmednagar, Maharashtra – 414001.
2. Mr. Asir Channubhai Shaikh, Partner
ACS Tower, Opp. Jilha Parishad Office,
Near ST Stand, Maliwada, Ahmednagar,
Maharashtra – 414001.
Also at : Gulshan Bungalow, Burudgaon
Road, Ahmednagar – 414006.
3. Mr. Altaf Asir Shaikh, Partner
ACS Tower, Opp Jilha Parishad Office,
Near ST Stand, Maliwada, Ahmendagar,
Maharashtra – 414001.
Also at : Gulshan Bungalow, Burudgaon
Road, Ahmednagar – 414006.
...RESPONDENTS
…
Advocate for the Petitioner : Mr. Sahil Memmon (Link Legal) a/w Rohit R.
Dhongde
Advocate for the Respondent No. 1 : Mr. Sanket N. Nuryawanshi
...
wp13684.26 Judgment.odt
CORAM : MANJUSHA DESHPANDE, J.
Reserved on
: 28.10.2026
Pronounced on : 03.11.2026
JUDGMENT : -
1.
Rule. Rule returnable forthwith. With the consent of the
parties, heard finally at the admission stage.
2.
The petitioner in this Writ Petition assails the order passed
by the 8th District Judge, and Additional Sessions Judge, Ahmednagar,
(hereinafter referred to as the “trial Court”) in Commercial Suit No. 1 of
2026, dated 03.08.2026.
3.
The learned Advocate Mr. Memmon, appearing for the
petitioner submits that, the petitioner has instituted a Commercial Suit
No. 1 of 2026 (for short “the suit”), which is pending before the trial
Court The summons in the suit were issued on 13.01.2026, which were
served on the respondents on 03.02.2026. On receiving summons, it was
incumbent upon the respondents to cause their appearance and file the
Written Statement within a period of 30 days from receiving the
summons. It is submitted that, as per Order VIII Rule 1 of the Code of
Civil Procedure, which is applicable to the Commercial disputes, the
outer limit for filing the Written Statement is 120 days. Since the
respondents have been served with suit summons, as per the Bailiff
wp13684.26 Judgment.odt
report on 03.02.2026, the limitation for filing the Written Statement
would begin from 03.02.2026. The outer limit of 120 days from
03.02.2026 would end on 03.06.2026.
In the present case, the
respondents have failed to file their Written Statement within the
statutory limit, as prescribed in Order VIII Rule 1 of the CPC. Since the
outer limit for filing the Written Statement was over, the petitioner has
filed an application for passing No WS order against the respondents on
24.04.2026. On filing of such application, it is submitted that, the
respondents have submitted an application seeking adjournment for
filing the Written Statement. It is further submitted that, thereafter, the
matter was listed on 16.06.2026. It is submitted that only on 02.07.2026
the Written Statement has been filed by the respondents, after which the
next date for hearing was 03.08.2026. When the matter was listed on
03.08.2026, the order impugned has been passed, by holding that since
the Written Statement is filed, the application for passing of No WS is
rejected. It is submitted that, the Written Statement is filed beyond the
prescribed period of limitation, as contemplated under Order VIII Rule 1
of the CPC. He submits that, so far as, the commercial disputes are
concerned, the provisions for filing the Written Statement are applied
rigorously and no relaxation is contemplated for granting time for filing
the Written Statement. The outer limit is of 120 days for filing of the
Written Statement, which is required to be followed scrupulously. In
support of his submission the learned Advocate for the petitioner relied
upon the decisions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in M/S SCG Contracts
India Pvt. Ltd. vs Ks Chamankar Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. - AIR 2019
wp13684.26 Judgment.odt
SUPREME COURT 2691, wherein, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has
considered the scope of the order VIII Rule 1 of CPC and its applicability
to the Commercial Suits. The Hon’ble Supreme Court has taken a view
that, there cannot be any extension of further time for filing of the
Written Statement beyond 120 days and failure to file such Written
Statement would result in forfeiting the right to file Written Statement for
the respondents.
4.
Thus, according to him, the law in this regard is settled by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court, in view of the decision in M/S SCG
Contracts India Pvt. Ltd. (supra). He also relied on the decision of this
Court in
Chief Officer, Shrigonda Municipal Council v. The State of
Maharashtra and Ors. – Writ Petition No. 7677 of 2020, dated
10.12.2020, wherein, this Court referring to the decision of M/S SCG
Contracts India Pvt. Ltd. (supra) held that, in context with the
mandatory provisions under Order VIII Rule 1 of CPC, and its application
to the Commercial Suits has taken a view that, there is no discretion is
left with the Court to allow the application for extension of time to file the
Written Statement, if such Written Statement is not filed within the
statutory period. The learned Advocate for the petitioner, therefore,
submits that the case of the petitioner is fairly straight forward, which
needs to be allowed by setting aside un-reasoned order passed by the
trial Court.
5.
The learned Advocate Mr. Sanket Surwanshi, appearing for
wp13684.26 Judgment.odt
the respondents has opposed the Writ Petition, contending that the time
limit as prescribed under Order VIII Rule 1 of CPC would only begin from
the date on which a complete copy of the plaint is served on him. It is
submitted that, admittedly, the respondents were served with suit
summons on 03.02.2026, but summons were not accompanied with the
copy of the plaint and related documents, therefore, the respondents
were not in a position to file their Written Statement. According to him,
in fact, it was titled as ‘notice to show cause’, under the Appendex – H.
This notice was served by respondent No. 1 -Firm calling upon to appear
on 13.03.2026. He submits that no separate summons were ever issued
against the answering respondent Nos. 2 and 3.
He submits that,
although he was not served with a copy of plaint/suit, he has still
diligently appeared through his Advocate, on the first day after issuing
summons on 13.03.2026. Since the presiding Officer was on leave, the
next date was granted 24.04.2026. An application has filed by the
respondents seeking extension of time, for filing of the Written Statement
and that application has remained pending, owing to the transfer of the
matter between the Courts and the intervening Summer Vacation, for
which the respondents cannot be held responsible. It is submitted that
on 16.06.2026, on the very first date after the Summer Vacation, the
Judge of the trial Court has granted time to file written statement by
way of last chance. On 23.06.2026, the respondents were ready with the
Written Statement, as well as the Counter Claim, but due to the leave of
the Presiding Officer, the matter was adjourned and the Written
Statement as well as the Counter Claim were taken on record on
wp13684.26 Judgment.odt
02.07.2026. It is thus, submitted that although the respondents have
timely taken steps to ensure compliance under Order VIII Rule 1 of CPC,
but due to unavoidable circumstances as set out here-in-above, the
Written Statement was filed on 02.07.2026, which is well within the
outer limit of 120 days counting it from the date of obtaining a copy of
plaint from the petitioner. He submitted that in fact, the Counter Claim,
as well as the Written Statement were taken on record by order dated
02.07.2026, which has not been challenged by the petitioner at any point
of time. The petitioner is merely challenging the order dated 03.08.2026,
by which the petitioner’s application at Exhibit-14 for passing of ‘No WS’
order has been rejected, holding it to be infructuous.
6.
In fact, according to him, the day on which the Written
Statement and Counter Claim were taken on record, a copy was also
furnished to the learned Advocate for the petitioner on the same day. He
submitted that on 16.06.2026, the trial Court has allowed the
respondent’s application seeking time to file say as a last chance.
7.
Thus, the Court has permitted the respondents to file the
Written Statement after outer limit for filing the Written Statement,
which has expired on 03.06.2026. He submitted that, considering the
peculiar circumstances, the time has been extended by the District
Judge, Ahmednagar, to file Written Statement, which is very much
permissible, since the respondents were not served with the copy of the
plaint, therefore, they were not in a position to file their Written
wp13684.26 Judgment.odt
Statement within the outer limit as provided under Order VIII Rule 1 of
the CPC. In support of his submission, he would rely upon the decision
of this Court in IK Marine Agencies Pvt Ltd v.
Tata Steel Ltd (Writ
Petition No. 3514 of 2026), decided vide order dated 28 April, 2026,
wherein this Court has taken a view that, since the postal receipt
indicates that the Article contained therein weighed only 110 gms., and
the defendant No. 2 claimed that it had not received the copy of the
plaint and its accompaniment till 29.08.2024. In the application filed
seeking extension of time on 26.09.2024, the defendant No. 2 contended
that it had received all the annexures alongwith the plaint only on the
last date i.e. on 29.08.2024, in such circumstances, when the issue is
about strict time limit for filing the Written Statement, it is imperative
that the summons should be served on the defendants, along with copy
of plaint and its accompaniment, so as to facilitate the defendants to file
their Written Statement, within time frame.
8.
In
view
of
aforementioned
judicial
pronouncements,
according to the learned Advocate for the respondents, in his case also
the summons were not accompanied with the plaint hence, they were
unable to file their Written Statement by adhering to the time limit
prescribed under law and taking into consideration the aforesaid fact,
the District Judge thought fit to extend the time to file Written
Statement. The defendants have filed the Written Statement within the
extended period, hence, there is no merit in the challenge raised by the
petitioner and the Writ Petition deserves to be dismissed.
9.
wp13684.26 Judgment.odt
I have heard the learned Advocates for respective parties and
perused the documents that are placed on record along with the
supporting judgments.
10.
The petitioner is raising challenge to the order dated
03.08.2026, passed by the trial Court, thereby, rejecting his application
with a prayer to pass ‘No WS’ order, against the respondents, since the
respondents had failed to file their Written Statement within 120 days,
from the date of service of summons/notice. An application was filed by
the petitioner on 24.04.2026 and the order thereon has been passed on
03.08.2026. The impugned order has been challenged by the petitioner
on the ground that, it is a cryptic order and not supported by any
reasons.
The other grounds of challenge raised by the petitioner are
that, according to Order VIII Rule 1 of the CPC, the defendants are
required to file the Written Statement within a period of 30 days from the
service of summons. This period of 30 days can be extended further for a
period of 90 days, from the date of service of summons, by recording
reasons by the concerned Court.
So far as a Commercial Dispute is
concerned, this provision has undergone the amendment and the
amended proviso to the Order VIII Rule 1 reads thus :
“(i) in Rule 1 the existing proviso shall be substituted by the
following proviso:
"Provided that where the defendant fails to file the written
statement within the said period of thirty days, he shall be
allowed to file the written statement on such other day, as may
wp13684.26 Judgment.odt
be specified by the Court, for reasons to be recorded in writing
and on payment of such costs as the Court deems fit, but which
shall not be later than one hundred twenty days from the date of
service of summons. On expiry of one hundred twenty days from
the date of service of summons, the defendant shall forfeit the
right to file the written statement and the Court shall not allow
the written statement to be taken on record."
11.
This proviso clearly mandates that the Written Statement
shall not be allowed later than 120 days from the date of service of
summons, and on expiry of 120 days from the date of service of
summons, the defendants forfeit their right to file the Written Statement
and the Court shall not allow the Written Statement to be taken on
record.
12.
In M/S SCG Contracts India Pvt. Ltd. vs Ks Chamankar
Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court while
pronouncing upon the enforceability of the aforementioned provision,
has made following observations in paragraph No. 8, which reads thus :
“8.
The
Commercial
Courts,
Commercial
Division
and
Commercial Appellate Division of High Courts Act, 2015 came into
force on 3.10.2015 bringing in their wake certain amendments to
the ode of Civil Procedure. In Order V, Rule 1, sub-rule (1) or the
second proviso, the following proviso was substituted:
"Provided further that where the defendant fails to file the
written statement within the said period of thirty days, he
shall be allowed to file the written statement on such
other days, as may to be be specified by the Court, for
wp13684.26 Judgment.odt
reasons recorded in writing and on payment of such costs
as the court deems fit, but which shall not be later than
one hundred twenty days from the date of service of
summons and on expiry of one hundred and twenty days
from the date of service of summons, the defendant shall
forfeit the right to file the written statement and the court
shall not allow the written statement to be taken on
record.”
Equally, in order VIII Rule 1, a new proviso was substituted as
follows :
"Provided that where the defendant fails to file the
written statement within the said period of thirty days,
he shall be allowed to file the written statement on such
other day, as may be specified by the court, for reasons
to be recorded in writing and on payment of such costs
as the Court deems fit, but which shall not be later
than one hundred and twenty days from the date of
service of summons and on expiry of one hundred and
twenty days from the date of service of summons, the
defendant shall forfeit the right to file the written
statement and the court shall not allow the written
statement to be taken on record."
This was re-emphasized by re-inserting yet another proviso in
Order VIII Rule 10 CPC, which reads as under: "Procedure
when
party
fails
to
present
written
statement called for by Court. - where any party from
whom a written statement is required under Rule 1 or
Rule 9 fails to present the same within the time
permitted or fixed by the Court, as the case may be, the
Court shall pronounce judgment against him, or make
wp13684.26 Judgment.odt
such order in relation to the suit as it thinks fit and on
pronouncement of such judgment a decree shall be
drawn up.
Provided further that no Court shall make an order to
extend the time provided under Rule 1 of this order for
filing of the Written Statement.”
A perusal of these provisions would show that ordinarily a written
statement is to be filed within a period of 30 days. However, grace
period of a further 90 days is granted which the Court may employ
for reasons to be recorded in writing and payment of such costs as
it deems fit to allow such written statement to come on record.
What is of great importance is the fact that beyond 120 days from
the date of service of summons, the defendant shall forfeit the
right to file the written statement and the Court shall not allow
the written statement to be taken on record.
This is further
buttressed by the proviso in Order VIII Rule 10 also adding that
the Court has no further power to extend the time beyond this
period of 120 days.”
13.
Now it is settled position that there can be no relaxation of
the outer limit prescribed in filing of the Written Statement. In the
subsequent order passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court, the Apex Court
has taken a view in case of National Insurance Company Ltd. v. M/s
National Building Construction India Ltd. & Ors. (Special Leave to Appeal
(Civil) No. 5383 of 2020, dated 12.09.2023), (2023 LiveLaw (SC) 800,
that the service contemplated in terms of Order V Rule 2 of the Code
would imply service summons along with a copy of plaint.
14.
wp13684.26 Judgment.odt
The issue in aforementioned decision was about the
computation of starting point of limitation for filing of the Written
Statement in a suit instituted in Original Side of the Bombay High Court
in Commercial Division.
15.
In the present case, although, it is claimed by the petitioner
that, the suit summons has been served on respondents on 03.02.2026
itself. It is the case of the respondents that the single page which was
titled as writ of summons was served on the respondents on 03.02.2026,
which was not accompanied by the plaint or its accompaniments. It was
titled as ‘notice to show cause (General Form)’, under (Appendix – H), No.
4 bears only the name of the answering respondent No. 1 – Firm, calling
upon it to appear on 13.03.2026. No summons has been issued on the
answering respondents to appear and answer the claim and file the
Written Statement within 30 days. On the aforementioned background
of the facts, according to respondents, the period for filing the Written
Statement under Order VIII Rule 1 of the CPC, did not commence from
03.02.2026. The submission of the respondents that, the copy of the
plaint was received only on 13.03.2026, has not been controverted by the
petitioner. It is stated that, on 13.03.2026, the respondents have caused
their appearance through Advocate, as per the returnable date stated in
the summons. Though the respondents have marked their appearance in
the Roznama, due to unavailability of the Presiding Officer, the
proceedings were not taken up on 13.03.2026. The next date assigned
was 24.04.2026, which was again before a different Court, after the
transfer of the matter.
wp13684.26 Judgment.odt
On 24.04.2026, the respondents have filed an
application seeking time to file their say. On the very day, the petitioner
has also filed an application at Exhibit – 14, seeking a ‘No Written
Statement’ order. Both the applications were kept pending and the
matter was adjourned on 16.06.2026, for filing of the Written Statement
and Say. It is submitted by the learned Advocate for the respondents
that, the 120th day is computed by the petitioner, which fall during the
Summer Vacation on 03.06.2026, when the Court was closed and the
application filed by the respondents seeking time to file Written
Statement was still pending.
16.
It is submitted that, meanwhile again the matter was
transferred to the Principal District Judge, Ahmednagar on 05.06.2026
and thereafter, the matter was listed on 16.06.2026. An application has
been filed by the respondents seeking time to file their say at Exhibit –
15, the time was granted by the learned District Judge by way of a last
chance. This order granting extension of time by way of a last chance
was never challenged by the petitioner. The Written Statement and the
Counter Claim of the petitioner both were filed on 23.06.2026, however,
since the Presiding Officer was on leave, the matter was adjourned on
02.07.2026. After filing of the Written Statement on 23.06.2026, the
petitioner has not raised any objection for taking the Written Statement
of the respondents on record. It is only when the application for ‘No WS’
was rejected by the learned District Judge, the petitioner has challenged
the said order. On the aforementioned background, in view of the
chronology of the dates
wp13684.26 Judgment.odt
& events that have occurred till filing of the
Written Statement, it is evident that, the period of limitation for filing of
the Written Statement cannot be counted from the day on which the
summons were served on 03.02.2026 but it will have to be counted from
the day on which the respondents claimed to have received the copy of
plaint along with the accompanying documents on 13.03.2026.
Since
the respondents were not in possession of the copy of plaint, as well as
the accompanying documents to oppose the prayer and averments made
in the plaint, therefore, there cannot be any compliance of the Order VIII
Rule 1 of the CPC. Since the summons received by the respondents was
not accompanied with the plaint and necessary documents, so as to take
further steps within the period of limitation, as provided in Order VIII
Rule 1 of CPC. In this regard, a profitable reference can be made to the
observations made by this Court, in interim application No. 425 of 2019,
in a Commercial Suit No. 765 of 2019, in Atlanta Limited vs Metso (India)
Private Limited, decided on 3rd and 4th August, 2021, the relevant portion
of the order is reproduced hereunder, which reads thus:
“24.
In this Interim Application, both sides seem to
have proceeded on the basis that the writ of
summons was in fact properly issued as required by
law. If it was not, then there is a very serious issue
under the CCA. The reason is that there is an
absolute bar of 120 days that runs against any
defendant; and it runs from the date of service of the
writ of summons. This is what creates an anomaly.
What is to happen, for instance, if the plaintiff does
wp13684.26 Judgment.odt
not supply a copy of the plaint within a reasonable
period of time? In a given situation, the plaintiff may
be left with no time at all to file a written statement.
Let us take an extreme example at the outer limit of
limitation under the CCA, the period of 120 days from
the date of service of the writ of summons. Let us
next assume that the defendant seeks a copy of the
plaint within two days of being served with this writ
of summons (unaccompanied by the copy of the
plaint). But the plaintiff does not furnish a copy of
the plaint till the 119th day from the date of service of
the writ of summons, or, even worse, furnishes it on
the 125th day after date of service of the writ of
summons.
The
defendant
is
deprived
of
any
reasonable opportunity to enter a written statement
for no fault of his own.
25.
This is indeed not the purport or ambit of the
CCA at all. That Act seeks to fast-track the disposal of
commercial suits. But that cannot come at the cost of
equity and justice, including procedural fairness. No
statute can be read like this. It is, therefore,
impossible to accept the argument that time against
the defendant for filing the written statement runs
from the date of a bare-bones writ of summons
without a copy of the plaint; and that it makes no
difference when the plaintiff sends him a copy for no
law or rule fixes any time within which the plaintiff
must furnish a copy. The other side result in an equal
absurdity, for no time is fixed either within which the
defendant must seek a copy of the plaint from the
plaintiff or his advocate. No statute can be read to lead
to a self-annihilating or self-destructive or self-
wp13684.26 Judgment.odt
contradictory manner.8 It is plainly the duty of a court
to construe a statute not literally but to give effect to
its
meaning
and
intent,
and
to
avoid
any
interpretation that yields an absurdity. A construction
that defeats the statute’s objective must be rejected.9
26.
The consequence is inevitable. The writ of
summons was wrongly issued. There is no valid service
of the writ of summons at all. All that Metso can be
said to have received is notice of institution of the suit.
It was never served with the writ of summons properly
so called. A non-conforming writ of summons is no writ
of summons at all and service of a non-conforming writ
of summons is no service at all. Technically speaking,
therefore, no question of limitation in this case runs
against the Defendant. And there is also no question of
assessing any delay or the grounds for delay.”
17.
This Court has taken a view that when there is no valid
service to Writ of summons, it is not good service at all, therefore, there
will be no question of limitation in such circumstances.
18.
In one more decision of this Court in IK Marine Agencies Pvt
Ltd Vs. Tata Steel Ltd - in Writ Petition No. 3514 of 2026 vide order dated
28.04.2026, this Court has made following observations in paragraph
No. 30, which reads as thus :
“30. When the Defendant is sought to be bound by the
strict timeline to file the written statement, it is imperative
that the writ of summons be served on the Defendant
along with the plaint and its accompaniments so as to
wp13684.26 Judgment.odt
facilitate the Defendant to file the written statement within
the time frame. If the Defendant is not equipped to
ascertain the case he is to meet, mere service of summons
sans the plaint and its accompaniments would not
constitute compliance of the statutory mandate so as to
make the time to file written statement run qua the
defendant. Service of summons, without a copy of the
plaint and its accompaniments, would not constitute a
valid service in the eye of law, especially in a case where
the failure to file the written statement within the outer
limit of 120 days entails the grave consequence of forfeiture
of right to defend the suit.”
19.
In the aforementioned decision it is observed by this Court
that the service of summons without a copy of the plaint would not
constitute a valid service in the eyes of law, especially in case where the
failure to file the Written Statement results in grave consequences. Thus,
in the aforementioned decision of this Court, as well the Hon’ble
Supreme Court, it is evident that, if all the procedural requirements
while issuing summons are complied with, only in such case the time
line of outer limit of 120 days, can be adhered for filing of the Written
Statement. The defendants cannot be put to disadvantage when the
plaintiff himself has not taken appropriate steps for effecting the valid
service.
20.
In the present case, a copy of the plaint was received by the
respondents on 13.03.2026, therefore, the period of limitation for filing
the Written Statement would commence from 13.03.2026.
The
wp13684.26 Judgment.odt
respondents have filed Written Statement on 23.06.2026, which is within
the period of 120 days, if counted from the date of receiving the copy of
the plaint by the respondents. In view thereof, no case is made out by
the petitioner for causing interference in the order passed by the 8 th
District Judge, Ahmednagar.
21.
In the result the Writ petition is dismissed.
22.
The rule is discharged.
( MANJUSHA DESHPANDE, J. )
Mahajansb/
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review