The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. As such, for all these above reasons, this Court does not find any infirmity in the impugned order. The writ petition is accordingly dismissed. Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of. (APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ Pulak +05'30'
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.674/2023
Sanjib Karmakar
……… Petitioner(s).
VERSUS
The State of Tripura & others
………Respondent(s).
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate,
Ms. A. Debbarma, Advocate,
Mr. Dipjyoti Paul, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Dipankar Sarma, Addl. G.A.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
Order
04/07/2024
Heard Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr.
Dipjyoti Paul, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner and Mr. Dipankar
Sarma, learned Addl. Government Advocate appearing for the respondentsState.
2.
The present writ petition is the second round of litigation in
relation to the grievance of the petitioner for promotion to the post of Junior
Operator (Control Room) under the Directorate of Fire & Emergency Services,
Government of Tripura.
3.
The first writ petition being WP(C) No.562 of 2023 was disposed
of vide order dated 12.09.2023 without entering into the merits of the matter by
directing the competent authority/respondent No.3-Additional Secretary, Home
(Fire & Emergency Services) Department, Government of Tripura and
respondent No.6-Director, Fire & Emergency Services, Government of Tripura
for taking a decision since the petitioner had already approached the competent
authority.
4.
In the first round of litigation also petitioner had raised a
grievance that 12 of his juniors have been promoted to the post of Junior
Operator (Control Room) vide notification dated 30.09.2021 issued by the
Additional Secretary & Director, Home (Fire & Emergency Services),
Government of Tripura, Agartala and even after representation made by the
petitioner dated 30.12.2022, 11 more persons have been promoted to the post
of Junior Operator (Control Room) (Group-C) vide order dated 13.01.2023
though they were not junior to the petitioner. Fireman is the feeder cadre of
Junior Operator under the Directorate of Fire & Emergency Services. Petitioner
was in service since 2000 and claimed himself to be eligible having completed
10 years of continuous service as Fireman with a minimum qualification of
Class-X. On that occasion petitioner had also stated that as per the radio
message dated 29.12.2022 inviting options from the Fireman possessing
eligibility criteria for ad hoc promotion to the post of Junior Operator (Control
Room), he submitted a willingness vide representation dated 30.12.2022 stating
that he had completed 22 years of service and his academic qualification was
B.Com. Though 11 Firemen were promoted vide notification dated 13.01.2023,
the case of the petitioner was not considered. Thereafter, again he had made
representations on 18.07.2023, 01.08.2023 and 11.08.2023.
5.
Pursuant to the directions passed by this Court, his representation
has been considered and rejected by the impugned order dated 29.09.2023
passed by the Director, Fire & Emergency Services, Tripura, Agartala on the
following grounds:
(i)
Petitioner's willingness submitted in July, 2013 was not
relevant as no promotion had taken place thereafter till 2021;
(ii)
Petitioner did not submit his willingness as per wireless
message dated 17.09.2021. No exemption was offered to those who had
communicated their willingness earlier;
(iii)
Promotions made in the year 2021 are ad hoc in nature;
(iv)
In his letter dated 30.12.2022, petitioner had declared that
after the last promotion (ad hoc) of Leading Fireman, his name appeared at Sl.
No.02 in the Final Seniority List of Fireman. Therefore, he was eligible for
promotion to the next promotional post of Leading Fireman and Junior
Operator (Control Room) which was the second option. In the meantime, the
Recruitment Rules for the post of Sub Officer had already been notified vide
Gazette Notification dated 28.11.2022 paving way for promotion from the post
of Junior Operator (Control Room) to Sub Officer for the first time as it was
impermissible under the preceding Recruitment Rules (unamended) for the post
notified on 28.10.1971;
(v)
His
unresponsiveness
to
the
radio
message
dated
17.09.2021 appeared to be a studied, deliberate and conscious step as his
subsequent letter dated 30.12.2022 made it clear that the post of Junior
Operator (Control Room) was not his first preference for getting promoted
from the post of Fireman and it was so even after the post of Junior Operator
(Control Room) had been included in the feeder post of Sub Officer by dint of
the amended Recruitment Rules dated 28.11.2022;
(vi)
The Director, Fire & Emergency Services, Tripura also
recorded that legality of seeking willingness for promotion to the post of Junior
Operator (Control Room) was under consideration in WP(C) No.222 of 2023
whereby this Court held that there was no infirmity in calling for option by the
eligible persons for promotion to the post of Junior Operator (Control Room) in
view of the detailed justification given by the respondents in their additional
counter affidavit.
Based on these grounds, his representation was rejected.
6.
In the fresh round of challenge, petitioner has, inter alia, more or
less raised the same grounds. It has been averred that calling of option is not a
statutory requirement. Promotion of juniors as per the tentative seniority list by
the office order dated 30.09.2021 was discriminatory and violative of Articles
14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. Conferment of willingness in the year
2013 should have been treated as exercise of option by the petitioner for
promotion as nobody intends to forego his promotion in the impugned exercise
in September, 2021. As such, the grounds for rejection recorded in the reasoned
order are not proper and tenable in the eye of law.
7.
Mr. Dipankar Sarma, learned Addl. Government Advocate
appearing for the State, has controverted the grounds of challenge. He has
placed reliance upon the averments made in the counter affidavit. According to
the learned counsel for the State, promotion to the post of Junior Operator
(Control Room) is done on the basis of option from the eligible Firemen of the
department as per convention followed from the very beginning. Petitioner's
contention that radio message dated 17.09.2021 required submission of option
only within one day by 18.09.2021 is not correct since by the second wireless
message of the same date the sending of option by eligible Firemen was
modified up to 22.09.2021 instead of 18.09.2021. All those who exercised
options by 22.09.2021 were taken into consideration for promotion. In the
subsequent exercise though petitioner exercised his option but the only
candidate promoted from UR category was senior to the present petitioner at
Sl. No.1 as per Final Seniority List of Fireman dated 01.08.2023.
Learned counsel for the State further reiterates that expression of
willingness made in July, 2013 is meaningless since 8 years had elapsed before
the fresh exercise of promotion was undertaken in September, 2021. All those
who exercised their options were duly considered and promoted as per the
vacancy and seniority position. He further reiterates the other grounds referred
to in the rejection order and submits that the writ petition is without merit and
may be dismissed.
8.
I have considered the submissions of learned counsel for the
parties and taken note of the relevant materials placed on record.
9.
This Court finds that calling of options/willingness from eligible
candidates on the post of Fireman for being considered for promotion to the
post of Junior Operator (Control Room) has been a consistent practice in the
department. As pointed out by the learned counsel for the State, options are
called as not all such eligible candidates are willing to go out of their
headquarters after being promoted and prefer to remain in the feeder post of
Fireman. Rationale for calling of options is at the discretion of the appointing
authority but if such a criteria has been uniformly applied to all eligible
candidates, petitioner cannot complain only on the ground that he had not been
able to offer his option or willingness as per the radio message dated
17.09.2021 by the cut-off date i.e. 22.09.2021. It is petitioner's own case that he
had given his option/willingness earlier in July, 2013. Petitioner had thus
acquiesced to the condition of submission of option/willingness for being
considered for promotion to the post of Junior Operator (Control Room). In the
absence of proper option exercised by the cut-off date, petitioner was left out of
the zone of consideration in the first exercise undertaken in September, 2021.
In the second exercise undertaken in December, 2021/January, 2022 though
petitioner had expressed his option/willingness, but the person at Sl. No.1
above him in the UR category was only promoted, a fact which the petitioner
had also accepted in the earlier round of litigation. Though much emphasis has
been laid upon the tentative seniority list published on 25.06.2021 but the Final
Seniority List was published on 01.08.2023. Petitioner's position in the
tentative seniority list and his challenge on the basis of discrimination vis-à-vis
junior persons would not hold good as the pre-condition of exercise of option/
willingness by all eligible candidates in the cadre of Fireman was not exercised
by the petitioner as per radio message dated 17.09.2021 up to the cut-off date
i.e. 22.09.2021. If a uniform yardstick has been followed in matters of
consideration of eligible candidates in the zone of consideration, petitioner
cannot complain to be treated differently from rest of the candidates who did
opt for being considered for promotion and they were accordingly included in
the zone of consideration.
10.
As such, for all these above reasons, this Court does not find any
infirmity in the impugned order. The writ petition is accordingly dismissed.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
Pulak
PULAK BANIK
Date: 2024.07.06 18:37:03
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review