Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/14
GAHC010259552024
undefined
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : Crl.Pet./1526/2024
SANJEEV GAUR AND ANR
R/O PV 60, THE PALM SPRINGS, GOLF COURSE ROAD, OPPOSITE HOTEL
IBIS, IN FRONT OF SOUTH POINT MALL, SECTOR-54, GURUGRAM-122001,
HARYANA.
2: SRI RANJIT KUMAR YADAV
S/O SHATRUDHAN YADAV
VILL- GOPALPUR
SIRE
GOPALPUR SIRI SUPAUL
BIHAR85213
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND ANR
REPRESENTED BY THE PP, ASSAM
2:M/S ANONDITA HEALTHCARE PVT. LTD.
OFFICE-D-0001
SECTOR-80
P.O. NOIDA-201 305 THROUGH ITS MANAGER VIJAY PRATAP YADAV SON
OF GANGA PRASAD YADAV
R/O PLOT NO. 9/10/11 NEW DELHI
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR J C GAUR, MR D SAIKIA
Advocate for the Respondent : PP, ASSAM,
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE PRANJAL DAS
JUDGMENT
Page No.# 2/14
Advocate for the petitioners
: Mr. J. C. Gaur, Ld Adv
Advocate for the respondents
: Mr. P. Borthakur, Addl. PP
Date on which judgment is reserved
: 08.04.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment
: 23.04.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the
operative part of the judgment ?
: N/A
Whether the full judgment has been
: Yes
pronounced?
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
Heard Mr. J. C. Gaur, learned counsel for the petitioners. Also
heard Mr. P. Borthakur, learned Additional Public Prosecutor for the State.
None appears on behalf of the Respondent No. 2/ informant despite
service of notice.
2. The two petitioners herein are invoking the jurisdiction of this Court
under Section 528/529 BNSS, 2023 seeking quashing of criminal
proceedings pertaining to CR case No. 40 of 2024 and more especially,
the Order dated 21.08.2024 passed by the Learned JMFC, Boko, Kamrup,
taking cognizance against the petitioners under Section 408/420/120(B)
IPC, read with Section 63 of the Copyright Act, read with Section
103/104 of the Trade Marks Act, and issued summoning order.
3. Before proceeding further, the facts may be noted. The respondent
No. 2, represented by its Manager, Vijay Pratap Yadav, submitted a
Page No.# 3/14
complaint before the Superintendent of Police, Kamrup, Assam on
25.09.2021, with allegations that while they were involved in the
manufacture of surgical gloves with the help of their indigenously
designed machine, which was conceptualized in 2013 and started
working in October 2013 - the petitioner Nos. 1 and 2 conspired and
stole their design and started manufacturing identical machines in their
factory at Dholpur, Rajasthan, and caused wrongful loss to them and
wrongful gain to the petitioners. It is stated in the FIR that the design
made by the informant’s company was registered under the Design Act
2002 on 18.04.2016 and certificate to that was also issued.
4. It is stated that one such machine was assembled at Noida, Uttar
Pradesh, and then shifted the same to their Guwahati factory in Assam,
which is situated at village Kurshala, P.O. Paneri, in the district of Kamrup
in 2015. It is stated that petitioner No. 2 was a former employee of the
informant’s company and he was fully abreast of the designs of the
machine of the informant’s company. He stole and cheated the
informant’s company by giving the design to the petitioner No. 1, who
started making similar products as mentioned earlier. It is alleged that
apart from theft, cheating and forgery, the acts of the petitioners also
constituted violation of Copyright Act and Designs Act.
5. It is alleged that subsequently the petitioner No. 2 left the company
represented by the informant, and started working with petitioner No. 1
in his company in Rajasthan. On the basis of the FIR, Boko P.S. Case No.
826 of 2021 was registered under Section 120(B)/408/420 IPC read with
Section 63 of the Copyright Act and Section 103/104 of the Trademark
Act. The corresponding G.R. was G.R. No.938 of 2021. However, upon
Page No.# 4/14
completion of investigation, the Investigating Officer submitted a final
report in the case on the ground of inadequate evidence vide FR No.168
of 2023. It was stated that if the machines of the company of the
accused was the same as that of the company of the informant, then the
company of the accused would not have obtained patent certificate of
their machines. However, it is stated that they tried to get an expert from
the patent office of Government of India but could not be successful as
they were informed that no expert can visit the factory to inspect
machines and that there is no provision regarding the same under the
Designs Act, 2000 and Designs Rules, 2001. It is stated that though the
machines could not be inspected through a patent expert, but due to
lack of evidence, the final report was submitted.
6. The informant was aggrieved by the submission of final report and he
lodged a protest petition and eventually, he filed a complaint case by
virtue of a complaint dated 28.06.2024, which was registered into
Complaint case No. 40 of 2024. In the complaint, reiterating some of the
allegations of the FIR, he stated that the company is in the business of
manufacturing surgical gloves and they developed an indigenous
machine for the same which became operational by October 2013 and
that the design of the machine was registered under the Design Act,
2002 on 18.04.2016.
7. It is further stated in the complaint that the machine was initially
assembled at the factory at Noida and shifted the same to the Guwahati
factory which was located in village Kurshala under the jurisdiction of
Boko Police Station in the district of Kamrup and that this was done so in
2015. It is stated that petitioner No. 2 was employed as an Assistant
Page No.# 5/14
Production Manager till July 2019 at the factory in Assam at the same
village under the jurisdiction of Boko Police Station and he had access to
the machine, its design and other confidential information.
8. It is stated that petitioner No. 1 wanted to enter the same business
and then he persuaded petitioner No. 2 and offered him a job with better
pay and also bribe for sharing vital information, it is stated that both the
petitioners talked in that direction, and petitioner No. 2 shared all the
intellectual property and confidential information regarding the machine
with the petitioner No. 1. It is stated that this was also revealed by the
petitioner No.2 before some of the employees of the informant company.
Subsequently, the informant came to know that the petitioner No. 2
joined the petitioner No.1 in his separate company by the name M/s
Swear Healthcare Private Limited having factory at Dholpur, Rajasthan. It
is alleged in the complaint that the petitioner No. 2 who was the
employer of the firm represented by the informant stole the design of the
machine which was indigenously developed by them and gave the same
designs to the petitioner No. 1, who started making surgical gloves with
an identical kind of machine. It is also contended that subsequently the
petitioner No. 2 left the company of the informant and joined the
petitioner No.1.
9. The complainant was examined under section 200 CrPC in which he
stated that the petitioner No. 2, Ranjit Kumar Yadav used to work with
his company from 2017 till 2020, and he had stolen the design patterns
and sold it to petitioner No. 1 who is the proprietor of Swear Healthcare.
After receiving the stolen pattern of the machine and design, the same
firm started producing surgical gloves like the company of the
Page No.# 6/14
complainant. He further stated that petitioner No. 2 at the time of
leaving their company spoke to their employees that he is leaving and
joining Swear Healthcare and he will take their employees also.
10. It is stated by the complainant that one of his employees namely
Manoj had visited Swear Healthcare in Rajasthan and found an identical
machine to the one they had manufactured. The complainant stated that
the petitioner violated the provisions of the Designs Act. In support of his
complaint, the complainant side examined three witnesses.
11. CW1, Gauranga Charan Mansi was examined under Section 202
CrPC. He is the Marketing Manager of the informant's company and he
stated that the petitioner No. 2 used to work for their company at
Mathura. Thereafter, he was posted in the Guwahati branch which is
situated three kilometers from Chaygaon and he was posted as
Production Supervisor and he had every knowledge about the machine.
CW1 further stated that Ranjeet Yadav told him that he is manufacturing
machine for Swear Healthcare and that he will leave the informant's
company as soon as the machine is ready and thereafter, he left in 2019,
without issuing any notice.
12. CW1 stated that the design and pattern of machine which he has
manufactured at Swear Healthcare is same as their machine. It is alleged
that the accused person, Ranjeet Yadav, stole their designs and sold it to
petitioner No. 1.
13. CW2 is Manoj Singh who was Marketing Manager of the informant's
company and he stated that the petitioner No. 2 used to work with them
for 8-9 years and he was posted at Guwahati branch situated three
Page No.# 7/14
kilometers from Chaygaon where he was Production Supervisor and he
had every knowledge about the machine which was involved in
production of surgical gloves. CW2 has also stated about the petitioner
No. 2 telling him that he will soon leave the company after the machine
designed by him for Swear Healthcare is ready. He has also stated about
the said accused leaving the company in 2019 without any notice and
about the design and pattern of the machine manufactured by the
informant's company being the same as the one in Rajasthan, where
petitioner No.1 is the owner. He has also stated about some employees
seeing pictures on WhatsApp about identical nature of the two machines.
14. CW3 has also stated on similar lines about the petitioner No.2 being
the Head Supervisor for 7-8 years and that he used to talk to petitioner
No. 1 and tell him about the machine to produce surgical gloves. CW3
has even stated about hearing telephone conversations between
petitioner No.2 and petitioner No. 1 about machine parts to be used at
the Rajasthan factory. CW3 stated that the machine that was set up at
the other place is the exact replica of the machine of their company.
15. On the basis of the complaint and after the initial deposition of the
complainant and examination of the complainant witnesses being CW1,
CW2 and CW3, the learned JMFC, Boko took cognizance vide the
impugned order dated 21.08.2024.
16. In support of his contentions, the learned counsel, Mr. Gaur, submits
that the instant proceeding has been maliciously lodged by the
complainant after submission of final report at the police, which was
done so upon not finding any evidence regarding any wrongdoing on the
part of the petitioners. It is further submitted that the company of
Page No.# 8/14
petitioner No. 1 has been manufacturing surgical gloves since 2016.
17. It is submitted that a case of business rivalry has been dragged into
the domain of criminal complaint and therefore, it should be quashed
and set aside. Further, it is submitted by the learned counsel for the
petitioners that the Court at Boko did not have any jurisdiction as the
machine which was purportedly copied is working in Dholpur, Rajasthan
and therefore, course of action, if any, does not arise within the
jurisdiction of the Trial court in Assam.
18.
It is also submitted that apart from the infirmity regarding
territorial jurisdiction, on merits also, the complaint does not have merit
and that the Investigating Officer upon not finding evidence submitted
FIR and the complaint was lodged again reviving the same issue. It is
also submitted that the informant had lodged an FIR before the Gautam
Buddha Nagar Police Station in Noida, Uttar Pradesh with allegations of
cheating, conspiracy and siphoning of goods worth crores of rupees and
giving false information to Government of India. The said case was
registered as Gautam Budha Nagar PS case No. 20 of 2016, and it is
submitted that the petitioners side had preferred a quashing proceeding
before the Allahabad High Court, and the Allahabad High Court was
pleased to grant an order of stay.
19. In support of his contentions, the learned counsel for the petitioners
relies upon the following decisions:-
(i) Y. Abraham Ajith & Ors Vs. Inspector of Police, Chennai and
Anr reported in (2004) 8 SCC 100;
(ii) Bhura Ram & ors Vs. State of Rajasthan & Anr reported in
Page No.# 9/14
(2008) 11 SCC 103;
(iii) Sujoy Ghosh Vs. The State of Jharkhand & Anr in SLP (Crl)
No. 9452 of 2025.
20. On the other hand, the learned Additional PP representing the State
submits that the learned Trial court took cognizance after examining the
complainant and as many as three witnesses on his behalf, and at this
stage there may not be sufficient justification to quash the criminal
proceedings. The learned Additional PP further submits that the
machinery had operated within the jurisdiction of Boko Police Station
and, therefore, it cannot be said that the Court at Boko did not have any
territorial jurisdiction. As already mentioned at the outset, none
appeared on behalf of the informant despite being serviced by the
informant.
21. As reflected in Order dated 04.11.2025, as per Office note dated
01.11.2025, service upon respondent No. 2 was completed, indicated by
the consignment tracking report and that the consignment was delivered
on 12.03.2025 and vide order dated 04.11.2025, service upon
respondent No. 2 was deemed to be complete.
22. I have perused the relevant materials, the impugned order and
considered the submissions on both the sides. I have perused the
decisions cited at the bar.
23.
Before
proceeding
further,
the
provisions
of
Section
CrPC (corresponding to Section 197 BNSS) may be reproduced herein
below:-
Page No.# 10/14
“177. Ordinary place of inquiry or trial.- Every offence shall ordinarily be
inquired into and tried by a Court within whose local jurisdiction it was
committed.”
24. Thus, the ordinary territorial jurisdiction of investigation and trying
an offence is the place where the offence took place. However, if an
offence
has
multiple
limbs spreading
across
different
territorial
jurisdictions, then any Court within the jurisdiction of which, any part of
the course of action has taken place would also have the territorial
jurisdiction to try the offence.
25.
This
has
been
specifically
provided
in
Section
CrPC (corresponding to section 198 BNSS) and the said provision may
also be reproduced herein below:“178. Place of inquiry or trial-
(a) When it is uncertain in which of several local areas an offence was
committed, or
(b) where an offence is committed partly in one local area and partly in
another, or
(c) where an offence is a continuing one, and continues to be committed in
more local areas than one, or
(d) where it consists of several acts done in different local areas, it may be
inquired into or tried by a court having jurisdiction over any of such local
areas.”
26. The contentions of the petitioners’ side primarily has two limbs -
firstly, that, as the machine in question which was allegedly made by
copying the machine of the informant ’s company is functioning at
Dholpur, Rajasthan - therefore, the Court in Assam does not have
territorial jurisdiction in terms of the aforesaid procedural provisions. The
second limb of the submission is that the police investigation resulted in
Page No.# 11/14
a final/closure report due to lack of evidence and the informant again
filed a complaint over the same thing. It is submitted that the dispute
between the parties is essentially a business rivalry and therefore, the
criminal prosecution should not lie.
27. On the aspect of territorial jurisdiction, I find from the initial
deposition of the complainant and the initial depositions of the three
complainant witnesses that - all of them have stated about functioning of
the machine in the village near Chaygaon, within the jurisdiction of Boko
police station. The crux of the dispute is that the said machine was
indigenously designed at the informant’s company and the petitioner No.
2 in collusion with petitioner No. 1 stole the design and made identical
machine for their company in Rajasthan. From the statements of the
complainant witnesses, I find that they have stated about functioning of
the machine in the area pertaining to the jurisdiction of the learned Trial
Court at Boko and about the stealing of the design of the machine.
28.
Therefore,
in
terms
of
the
stipulations
in
Section
CrPC (corresponding to 198 BNSS), it cannot be said that no part of the
alleged offence has taken place within the jurisdiction of the learned
JMFC, Boko. Hence, on the aspect of territorial jurisdiction, there is no
error, in my considered view in the order of the learned JMFC, Boko.
29. The decision in Y. Abraham Ajith (supra) relied upon by the
petitioners side discusses the law of territorial jurisdiction for trial of
offences. But the said decision would not be of assistance to the
petitioners as in that case, it was found that no part of the cause of
action had arisen in Chennai and therefore, the concerned Magistrate
there was held to have no jurisdiction to deal with the matter.
Page No.# 12/14
30. Similarly, in Bhura Ram (supra) also, the Hon’ble Apex Court
referred to the aforesaid decision of Y. Abraham Ajith (supra) and it
was found that no part of the offence was committed in Rajasthan and,
therefore,
the
concerned
Magistrate did
not
have
territorial
jurisdiction. Therefore, this decision would also not come to the aid of
the petitioners side on the aspect of territorial jurisdiction.
31. With regard to the aspects of merit of the impugned order of taking
cognizance and summoning the accused petitioners, I again go back to
the statements of the complainant and his witnesses examined by the
learned JMFC, Boko prior to issuing of the summoning order, upon taking
cognizance. The complainant and his witnesses have stated about finding
that the machine in Rajasthan operated by the company of petitioner No.
1, is identical to the machine developed by the company of the
informant. The witnesses have also stated about how the petitioner No. 2
was working with the informant's company and he was crucially involved
in designing of the machine for manufacture of surgical gloves.
32. The witnesses have also stated about the petitioner No. 2, indicating
about making a similar/identical machine for the company of petitioner
No. 1 and one of the witnesses have also stated about telephone
conversations
between
the
petitioners regarding
the
same.
The
complainant and his witnesses have consistently stated about the
petitioner No. 2 stealing the design of the machine of the informant's
company and selling it to petitioner No. 1. The witnesses have also
stated that subsequently, the petitioner No. 2 joined the company of
petitioner No. 1.
33. On the law regarding cognizance, the learned counsel for the
Page No.# 13/14
petitioners’ has referred to the decision of Sujoy Ghosh (supra),
wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court has explained the settled position of
law on the subject. The relevant paragraph 13 may be reproduced herein
below:“13. The principles governing summoning of an accused in a criminal case as
well as parameters for quashing criminal proceedings are well-settled.
Summoning of an accused in a criminal case is a serious matter and criminal
law cannot be set into motion as a matter of course. It is not that the
complainant has to bring only two witnesses to support his allegations in the
complaint to have the criminal law set into motion. The order of the Magistrate
summoning the accused must reflect application of mind to the facts of the
case and the law applicable thereto. The Magistrate must carefully scrutinise
the evidence brought on record and determine whether any offence is prima
facie made out. The Magistrate may even himself put questions to the
complainant and his witnesses to elicit answers to find out the truthfulness of
the allegations or otherwise, and then examine if any offence is prima facie
committed by all or any of the accused.”
34. On the touchstone of these principles, I again peruse the impugned
order passed by the learned JMFC, Boko vis-a-vis the statements of the
witnesses of the complainant side.
35. Upon doing so, and in the backdrop of the nature of the statements
made by the complainant witnesses - I am of the considered view that
the learned JMFC, Boko was justified on these materials to take
cognizance and issue summoning order to the accused petitioners. In the
context of the materials which were presented before the learned Trial
Court, the impugned order passed by the learned JMFC, Boko has not
deviated from the principles summarized by the Hon’ble Supreme Court
Page No.# 14/14
in Sujoy Ghosh (supra).
36. Accordingly, in the facts and circumstances and in the backdrop of
the above discussion, the impugned order dated 21.08.2024 passed by
the learned JMFC, Boko in CR No. 40/2024 is hereby upheld and
confirmed.
37. Consequently, the criminal petition is found to be devoid of merit and
is dismissed.
38. The stay order on the proceedings granted by the order dated
16.12.2024, stand vacated. A copy of this judgment and order shall be
sent to the learned Court below.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review