Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.317 of 2022
Debasish Sarkar, S/o Late Samir Chandra Sarkar, resident of Shantipalli,
Charipara, P.O- Charipara, Agartala, P.S. Amtali, District – West Tripura,
Pin-799003.
………Petitioner(s)
VERSUS
1. The State of Tripura, represented to be represented by the Secretary,
GA(Printing & Stationery) Department, Govt. of Tripura, New Secretariat
Building, New Capital Complex, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799010.
2. The Director, G.A (Printing & Stationery) Department, Government of
Tripura, Bardowali, Agartala, West Tripura.
……… Respondent(s).
Along with
WP(C) No.318 of 2022
Sandip Roy, S/o Late Haripada Roy, resident of Hairmara, A.D. Nagar, P.OS.D. Mission, P.S.-A.D. Nagar, District – West Tripura, Pin-799003.
………Petitioner(s)
VERSUS
1. The State of Tripura, represented to be represented by the Secretary,
GA(Printing & Stationery) Department, Govt. of Tripura, New Secretariat
Building, New Capital Complex, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799010.
2. The Director, G.A (Printing & Stationery) Department, Government of
Tripura, Bardowali, Agartala, West Tripura.
……… Respondent(s).
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. Kawsik Nath, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. D. Bhattacharya, G.A.,
Ms. N.C. Saha, Advocate.
Date of Judgment & Order: 05.07.2023
Whether Fit for Reporting: YES
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
Both WP(C) No.317 of 2022 and WP(C) No.318 of 2022 are
being heard together and decided by the common judgment as both the writ
petitions raise common grievances.
2.
Heard Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel assisted by
Mr. Kawsik Nath, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. D.
Bhattacharya, Government Advocate assisted by Ms. N.C. Saha learned
counsel for the respondents.
3.
Sri Debasish Sarkar, petitioner, was appointed as Computor,
Tripura Government Press of the GA(Printing and Stationery), Department,
on 12.06.2001 while Sri Sandip Roy, petitioner, was appointed as Computor,
Tripura Government Press of the GA(Printing and Stationery), Department
on 09.02.2007. Pursuant thereto their joining was accepted vide order dated
19.06.2001 and 27.02.2007 respectively. Both the petitioners were having
granted ad hoc promotion to the post of Senior Computor vide orders dated
16th February, 2022 [Annexure- 8 in WP(C) No.317 of 2022 and Annexure-5
in WP(C) No.318 of 2022]. One of the orders of promotion is extracted
herein below:
“No.F.1(19)-GA(P&S)-PTG/2021/451-57
GOVERNMENT OF TRIPURA
GA(PRINTING AND STATIONERY) DEPARTMENT
Dated, Agartala, the 16th February, 2022.
ORDER
On the recommendation of the Departmental Promotion
Committee held on 13-01-2022 Shri Debasish Sarkar, Computor,
Tripura Government Press of the GA (Printing and Stationery)
Department, Government of Tripura is hereby appointed on
promotion to the post of Senior Computor, Group-C (Technical)
purely on ad-hoc basis as one time measure in the scale Pay Band
Rs.5700-24000/- level-9 of Tripura State Pay Matrix, 2018
(Tripura State Civil Services (Revised pay)(First amendment)
Rules-2018 by creation of 1(one)no. supernumerary post of Senior
Computer as per point no.7 of the Notification No.F.2(24)GA(P&T)/2021 dated 22-06-2021.
2.
The said ad-hoc promotion is subject to the following
conditions.
a). Appointment on promotion purely on ad-hoc basis
subject to final outcome of the SLP pending before the Hon’ble
Supreme Court of India.
b). The ad-hoc appointment on promotion shall not be
treated as regular appointment on promotion.
c). No inter-se seniority list shall be determined/published
in respect of this ad-hoc promotion.
d). When the directions become available, a review DPC
may be held and the necessary adjustments be made in the
promotion based upon the revised seniority list. In Case Shri
Sarkar, appointed on ad-hoc promotion does not figure in the list
approved by the review DPC he may be reverted to the post held
by him earlier.
e). The pay etc shall be fixed as per normal rules. Shri
Sarkar shall submit option for fixation of pay within 1(one) month
from the date of joining to the post.
2.
Shri Debasish Sarkar, Computor should join his duties on
promotion immediately.”
Both the petitioners thereafter made representations vide
Annexure –9 dated 21.02.2022 in WP(C) No.317 of 2022 and Annexure-6
dated 21.02.2022 in WP(C) No.318 of 2022 for reviewing their ad hoc
promotion to the post of Senior Computor and promoting them as Head
Computor.
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioners has submitted that both the
petitioners were senior in the year 2017 itself, as per Annexure-2 for being
considered for promotion to the post of Head Computor as they had
completed more than 16/12 years of service as is the requirement under the
Recruitment Rules for promotion to the post of Head Computor in the
Tripura Government Press under the GA (Printing and Stationery)
Department, Government of Tripura vide Annexure-3. The serial No.11 of
the Schedule of Recruitment Rules provides as under:
11.
5.
In case of recruitment by
promotion/deputation/transfer,
grades
from
which
promotion/deputation/transfer
is to be made.
Promotion:- From the post of Sr.
Computor having 5(five) years
experience in the grade failing
which from the post of Computor
having 10(ten) years experience in
the grade.
Since petitioners had remain on the post of Computor for more
than 10(ten) years, they were eligible for being promoted to the post of Head
Computor. It is also their case that since 2017 the post of Head Computor
was also vacant. Since their representations were not considered, they have
approached this Court.
6.
Mr. D. Bhattacharya, learned Government Advocate assisted by
Ms. N.C. Saha, learned counsel have appeared for the State and filed
counter-affidavit in which a common stand has been taken. Respondents
have also relied upon the notification dated 22.06.2021 of GA(P&T)
Department, Government of Tripura which is also known as the Promotion
Policy of 2021. The relevant part of the said notification is extracted
hereunder.
“8. It has also been decided by the Government to allow such appointment
on ad hoc promotion as one time measure, following the below mentioned
conditions:(i)
Appointment on Promotion may be allowed purely on adhoc basis subject to final outcome of the SLP pending
before the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India.
(ii)
Ad-hoc appointment on promotion shall be considered
keeping in view of the latest available seniority list of the
feeder post/ grade subject to condition that he/she is
otherwise suitable & eligible for promotion.
(iii)
No inter-se seniority list shall be determined/ published in
respect of these ad-hoc promotions.
(iv)
Benefit of the ad-hoc appointment on promotion shall be
available to accommodate a candidate to the immediate next
higher promotion post/ grade only and such benefit shall not
be considered to accommodate the said candidate to
multiple higher posts/ grade with prospective effect.
(v)
To create supernumerary posts, administrative Department
shall assess the number of posts to be created to materialize
the promotion as per above procedure and inform the total
number of posts so determined to Finance Department. No,
further concurrence of Finance Department is required.
(vi)
This ad-hoc appointment on promotion shall not be treated
as regular appointment on promotion.
(vii)
The ad-hoc appointment on promotion as per guidelines
illustrated above shall be started in the highest grade of a
cadre/ service first. Due to such promotion, the resultant
vacancies shall be added with the vacancies in the lower
grade, and to be filled up subsequently.
(viii) Regular DPC may be held based on the existing seniority
list. However, while issuing the orders it should be
stipulated that these promotions are provisional and subject
to the final outcome of the S.L.P pending before the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India. Subsequently, when the
directions become available, a review DPC may be held and
the necessary adjustments be made in the promotions of
officers based upon the revised seniority list. In case any of
the officers/ candidate appointed on ad-hoc promotion do
not figure in the list approved by the review DPC they may
be reverted to the posts held by them earlier.
9. As the persons to be appointed on ad-hoc basis subject to final verdict if
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in SLP(C) No.19765-19767 of 2015 are likely
to hold such ad-hoc promotion posts for a period of more than 1(one) year,
consultation with the TPSC is required, wherever the same is necessary,
following the provisions of the TPSC (Exemption form Consultation)
Regulations, 1973.
10. Relevant portion of the conditions as mentioned in Para-8 above shall
invariably be incorporated while issuing the promotion order/ notification
for appointment on ad-hoc promotion.”
7.
Mr. D. Bhattacharya, learned Government Advocate for the
State submits that as per Clause 8(iv) of the notification dated 22.06.2021
benefit of the ad-hoc appointment on promotion shall be available to
accommodate a candidate to the immediate next higher promotion post/
grade only and such benefit shall not be considered to accommodate the said
candidate to multiple higher posts/ grade with prospective effect. Petitioners
were promoted to the post of Senior Computor on having served for 5(five)
years in the grade of Computor as per the Recruitment Rules quoted above.
After having accepted joining they cannot claim promotion to the next higher
post of Head Computer relying upon Clause 8(vii) of the notification dated
22.06.2021. It is also submitted that the next higher promotion to the post of
Head Computor would only be available after they have completed necessary
experience in the grade of Senior Computor. Since the petitioners have
already accepted joining on the post of Senior Computor, they are stopped
from raising a claim for review of the promotion order to the next higher post
of Head Computor. The hierarchy of the post of computor is also provided
under para 9 of the counter affidavit which is as under:
“According to hierarchy the post of Computer is arranged as under
Manager
Deputy Manager
Superintendent of Press
Head Computor
Senior Computor
Computor”
8.
It is crystal clear there from the above that the post of Head
Computor is not the highest post of Computer. The highest post of Manager
is now physically occupied. For filling up the next highest post of Deputy
Manager
some
administrative
procedures
are
necessary
to
be
completed/followed which is also under process. The averment of the
petitioners that if they declined to join in the post of Senior Computer for any
reason then in that case they will not be considered for the benefit under
MACPs as per ROP-2017 has also been denied at para 13 of the counteraffidavit in WP(C) No.317 of 2022. Therefore, it is submitted that petitioners
do not have a legitimate expectation to be promoted to the next higher post
of Head Computor immediately within one year of their joining.
9.
I have considered the submission of the learned counsel for the
parties and have taken note of the relevant material facts placed from the
records. The guidelines which are framed by the Government of Tripura GA
(P&T) Department dated 22.06.2021 for granting ad hoc promotion, in
particular para-8(iv) thereof make it clear that benefit of the ad hoc
appointment on promotion shall be available to accommodate a candidate to
the immediate next higher promotion post/ grade only and such benefit shall
not be considered to accommodate the said candidate to multiple higher
posts/ grade with prospective effect. As regards the contention of the
petitioner that clause 8(vi) of the notification dated 22.06.2021 thereof
provides for promotion in the highest grade of a cadre/service first it would
not apply to the case of the petitioners since the highest grade is Manager
and not Head Computer. Moreover, the petitioners have accepted joining on
the post of Senior Computor upon issuance of the order of promotion dated
16.02.2022. As per the Recruitment Rules extracted hereinabove 5(five)
years experience on the post of Sr. Computor is required for promotion to the
post of Head Computor and failing which it would be filled up from the post
of Computer having 10(ten) years experience in the grade. The petitioners
though contend that the post of Head Computor was vacant since 2017 and
they were eligible in terms of requisites seniority and experience, they have
approached this Court only after acceptance of the promotion to the next
higher post of Senior Computer. Under the Promotion Policy, 2021 multiple
promotions in such manner is not permissible and more so when the
petitioners have to complete the minimum number of years in the next higher
grade of Senior Computer for being eligible to be promoted to the post of
Head Computer. As such this Court does not find any merit in the instant
writ petitions.
10.
Learned counsel for the petitioner-Sri Debasish Sarkar refers to
the prayer made at para 20(iv) and submits that the respondents may be
directed to give honorarium to the petitioners for holding full charge duty of
the higher post i.e. Head Computer for more than three months.
11.
The competent authority under the respondent department is
required to address the claim of the petitioner as regards the instant prayer in
accordance with law.
12.
However, for the reasons recorded hereinabove and the facts
and circumstances noted above this Court does not find any merit in the
instant writ petitions. Accordingly, the writ petitions are dismissed. Pending
application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
MUNNA SAHA
Munna S
Date: 2023.07.13 17:29:42 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review