Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:26149
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE A. BADHARUDEEN
WEDNESDAY, THE 26TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 5TH CHAITHRA, 1947
RFA NO. 127 OF 2010
AGAINST THE DECREE AND JUDGMENT DATED 28.10.2009 IN O.S. NO.156 OF 2003 OF
THE SUB COURT, NEYYATTINKARA
APPELLANT/PLAINTIFF:
ADDL A2
T.C.BALAKRISHNAN NAIR (DIED)
S/O.CHELLAPPAN PILLAI, LAKSHMIVILASOM BUNGLOW, THANNIVILA,
PALLICHAL VILLAGE, NEYYATTINKARA TALUK.
MRIDULAKUMARI
D/O BALAKRISHNAN NAIR, AGED 45 YEARS, RESIDING AT LAKSHMI
VILASOM BUNGLOW, THANNIVILA, PALLICHAL VILLAGE, NEYYATTINKARA
TALUK
(IMPLEADED AS ADDL. APPELLANT IN RFA AS THE LEGAL HEIR OF THE
DECEASED APPELLANT AND RESPONDENTS 4 TO 6 ARE RECORDED AS LEGAL
HEIRS OF DECEASED APPELLANT VIDE ORDER DATED 04/04/14 IN I.A.
NO.856/2014)
BY ADVS.
SRI.R.S.KALKURA
SRI.M.AJAY IRUMPANAM
SRI.HARISH GOPINATH
SMT.KVP.JAYALEKSHMY
SRI.M.S.KALESH
SRI.V.VINAY MENON
RESPONDENTS/DEFENDANTS:
BIJU RAMESH
S/O RAMESAN G, RESIDING AT SAMTHRUPTHI, INSIDE EAST FORT,
VANCHIYOOR VILLAGE, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
K.K.MAHESH, S/O.N.KRISHNA PILLAI
KRISHNA SADANAM, T.C.50/723, KALADI, KARAMANA, MANACAUD
VILLAGE, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
S.RADHAKRISHNAN
S/O.SADASIVAN, PULIMOODU VEEDU,, VENGANOOR, MUTTACAUD POST,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM TALUK, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
2025:KER:26149
R.F.A. Nos. 127 & 172 of 2010
SANDHYAKUMARI LEKSHMIVILASAM
NARUVAMMOODU, PALLICHAL DESOM AND VILLAGE, NEYYATTINKARA
TALUK.
B.L.JYOTHY, LEKSHMIVILASAM
NARUVAMMOODU, PALLICHAL DESOM AND VILLAGE, NEYYATTINKARA
TALUK.
MEERAKUMARI LEKSHMIVILASAM
NARUVAMMOODU, PALLICHAL DESOM AND VILLAGE, NEYYATTINKARA
TALUK.
PADMAKUMAR G.P.NIVAS
VEMPALAVATTAM, ANAYARA P.O., KADAKAMPALLI VILLAGE,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM-29.
ADDL R8
OLIVER J.,
S/O.JOHNKUTTY , AGED 37, HOUSE NO.TC 45,65 VALIYATHURA,
VALLAKKADAVU, MUTTATHARA, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM DISTRICT.
ADDL R9
SELVARAJ,
S/O.MONLPUS, AGED 59, RESIDING AT HOUSE NO.TC 44/886,
VALIYATHURA, VALLAKKADAVU, MUTTATHARA, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM
DISTRICT.
ADDL R10
SIJU,
S/O.PAPPACHAN,AGED 36, RESIDING AT HOUSE NO.TC 45/838,
VALIYATHURA, VALLAKKADAVU, MUTTATHARA, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM
DISTRICT.
(ADDITIONAL RESPONDENTS 8 TO 10 ARE IMPLEADED VIDE ORDER
DATED 5/9/2018 IN I.A.NO. 1185/2018)
BY ADVS.
SMT.INDULEKHA JOSEPH – R2, R3
SRI.L.MOHANAN – R5, R6
SRI.M.R.ANANDAKUTTAN -R1
SMT.LIGEY ANTONY -R5, R6
SRI.NEERAJ NARAYAN – R2, R3
SRI.V.G.ARUN – R2,R3
SRI.R.S.MADHU -R1
SMT.M.A.ZOHRA -R1
V.JAYA RAGI – R8 TO R10
R.HARIKRISHNAN (KAMBISSERIL) – R8 TO R10
MAHESH ANANDAKUTTAN - R1
THIS REGULAR FIRST APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 26.03.2025,
ALONG WITH RFA NO.172/2010, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE
FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:26149
R.F.A. Nos. 127 & 172 of 2010
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE A. BADHARUDEEN
WEDNESDAY, THE 26TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 5TH CHAITHRA, 1947
RFA NO. 172 OF 2010
AGAINST THE DECREE AND JUDGMENT DATED 28.10.2009 IN O.S. NO.156 OF 2003 OF
THE SUB COURT, NEYYATTINKARA
APPELLANTS/DEFENDANTS 4, 6 & 7:
SANDHYAKUMARI
LEKSHMIVILASAM, NARUVAMMOODU, PALLICHAL DESOM AND VILLAGE,
NEYYATTINKARA TALUK.
MEERAKUMARI
LEKSHMIVILASAM, NARUVAMMOODU, PALLICHAL DESOM AND VILLAGE,
NEYYATTINKARA TALUK.
PADMAKUMAR
G.P.NIVAS, VEMPALAVATTAM, ANAYARA P.O., KADAKAMPALLI VILLAGE,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM-29,
(REPRESENTED BY THE P.A.HOLDER SRI.PRABHAKARAN NAIR,
G.P.NIVAS, ANAYARA, KADAKAMPALLY, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM)
BY ADVS.
SRI.L.MOHANAN
SMT.LIGEY ANTONY
RESPONDENTS/PLAINTIFF AND DEFENDANTS 1 TO 3 & 5:
T.C.BALAKRISHNAN NAIR
S/O CHELLAPPAN PILLAI, LAKSHMIVILASOM BUNGLOW, THANNIVILA,
PALLICHAL VILLAGE, NEYYATTINKARA TALUK.
BIJU RAMESH, S/O. RAMESAN G.
RESIDING AT SAMTHRUPTHI, INSIDE EAST FORT, VANCHIYOOR
VILLAGE, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
K.K.MAHESH, S/O. N.KRISHNA PILLAI
KRISHNA SADANAM, TC 50/723, KALADI, KARAMANA, MANACAUD
VILLAGE, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
S.RADHAKRISHNAN, S/O. SADASIVAN
PULIMOODU VEEDU, VENGANOOR, MUTTACAUD POST,
2025:KER:26149
R.F.A. Nos. 127 & 172 of 2010
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM TALUK, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
B.L.JYOTHY
LEKSHMIVILASAM, NARUVAMMOODU, PALLICHAL DESOM AND, VILLAGE,
NEYYATTINKARA TALUK.
R3 & R4 BY ADVS.
SRI.K.T.SHYAMKUMAR
SHRI.HARISH R. MENON
THIS REGULAR FIRST APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 26.03.2025,
ALONG WITH RFA NO.127/2010, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE
FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:26149
R.F.A. Nos. 127 & 172 of 2010
“C.R”
COMMON JUDGMENT
Dated this the 26th day of March, 2025
R.F.A. No.127 of 2010 has been filed by the plaintiff
in
O.S.
No.156/2003
on
the
files
of
the
Sub
Court,
Neyyattinkara, under Section 96 read with Order XLI Rule 1 of
the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, challenging the decree
and judgment in the above case dated 28.10.2009,
whereby the suit filed by the plaintiff to declare Ext.A1 sale
deed No.2634/1997 executed by the plaintiff in favour of
the 1st defendant, as a sham document, was dismissed. The
respondents herein are defendants in the above suit.
2.
R.F.A. No.172 of 2010 is also filed challenging the
decree and judgment in O.S. No.156/2003, at the instance
of defendants 4, 6 and 7, arraying the plaintiff and other
defendants as the respondents.
3.
Heard the learned counsel for the appellant, the
learned counsel appearing for respondents 5 and 6 and the
learned
counsel
counsel
appearing
for
additional
respondents 8 to 10 in R.F.A. No.127 of 2010. Perused the
2025:KER:26149
R.F.A. Nos. 127 & 172 of 2010
verdict under challenge and the records of the trial court.
4.
Even though, service is not complete in R.F.A.
No.172/2010, parties to the lis are substantially served or
represented in R.F.A. No.127/2010. Hence, R.F.A. No.172/2010
can also be heard along with R.F.A. No.127/2010.
5.
Parties in these appeals shall be referred with
reference to their status before the trial court.
6.
Short facts:- The case put up by the plaintiff
before the trial court is that, the plaintiff is the owner of the
plaint schedule property. When he borrowed Rs.4,00,000/from the 1st defendant, though initially no document was
executed as security, later when the 1 st defendant insisted
to execute documents to evidence the said transaction,
Ext.A1 sale deed dated 04.08.1997 was executed by the
plaintiff in favour of the 1 st defendant, on understanding
that, as and when the amount would be repaid with
interest, the 1st defendant would execute conveyance at
the cost of the plaintiff. The plaintiff’s case further is that,
he repaid the amount on 05.01.1999. Inspite of receipt of
money, the 1st defendant did not reconvey the plaint
schedule
properties
to
the
plaintiff.
Thereafter,
on
2025:KER:26149
R.F.A. Nos. 127 & 172 of 2010
07.10.1997, the plaintiff executed Ext.A8 settlement deed
in favour of his daughter Sandhya Kumari, who is the
additional 4th defendant herein and now the plaint schedule
property is in possession and enjoyment of the additional
4th defendant. Therefore, the suit has been filed to declare
Ext.A1 document as a sham document.
7.
The 1st defendant filed written statement and
resisted the suit asserting title and possession over the
plaint schedule property on the strength of Ext.A1 and also
on the submission that the suit is barred by limitation.
8.
Defendants 2 and 3 filed written statement
supporting the contentions raised by the 1 st defendant. The
4th
defendant
also
filed written
statement,
asserting
execution of Ext.A18 Rectification deed by the plaintiff as
on 05.08.2002. The 5th defendant was set ex-parte. The 6 th
defendant filed written statement, asserting that, at
present, the plaint schedule property is in the custody of
the 6th defendant. The 7th defendant filed written statement
supporting the contentions raised by the plaintiff.
9.
The trial court ventured the matter, after raising
2025:KER:26149
R.F.A. Nos. 127 & 172 of 2010
necessary issues. PWs 1 to 9 were examined and Exts.A1 to
A21 were marked on the side of the plaintiff. DWs 1 to 10
were examined and Exts.B1 to B31 were marked on the
side the the defendants. Exts.X1 to X4 were also marked as
third party exhibits.
10. Finally,
the
trial
court
after
evaluating
the
evidence, dismissed the suit holding that the suit is
hopelessly barred by limitation.
11. While assailing the verdict of the trial court, the
learned counsel for the plaintiff submitted that, Ext.A1 sale
deed was executed by the plaintiff in favour of the 1 st
defendant to evidence the transaction between the plaintiff
and 1st defendant, on the condition that, when the amount
would be repaid, the 1st defendant would reconvey the
property to the plaintiff. Though the amount was repaid by
the plaintiff, the 1st defendant did not reconvey the plaint
schedule properties to the plaintiff. The learned counsel for
the plaintiff submitted further that, even now tax pertaining
to the plaint schedule property is being remitted by the
plaintiff. Hence, the decree and judgment of the trial court
2025:KER:26149
R.F.A. Nos. 127 & 172 of 2010
would require interference.
12. Whereas, the learned counsel appearing for
contesting respondents would submit that, the suit has
been filed after a period of three years, though the plaintiff
was having knowledge regarding execution of Ext.A1 sale
deed, from the date of its execution itself. Therefore, the
decree and judgment of the trial court finding that the suit is
hopelessly barred by limitation does not require any
interference.
13. On hearing the learned counsel for the plaintiff
and the respective counsel appearing for contesting
respondents, the points arise for consideration are:
1. Whether the finding of the trial court that
the suit is barred by limitation is justified?
2. How limitation period to file suit to set
aside or cancel a document is to be arrived at?
3. Whether the trial court went wrong in
refusing the relief of declaration in respect of
Ext.A1 sale deed?
4. Whether the decree and judgment of the
trial court would require interference?
5. Reliefs and costs.
14. In this matter, Ext.A1 sale deed was admittedly
2025:KER:26149
R.F.A. Nos. 127 & 172 of 2010
executed by the plaintiff himself on 04.08.1997 and the suit
has been filed only on 17.12.2003. The trial court after
elaborately
discussing
the
evidence,
addressed
the
question of limitation with reference of Article 59 of the
Limitation Act, 1963 and found that the suit is barred by
limitation. As per Article 59 of the Limitation Act, a suit has
to be instituted within a period of three years to cancel or
set aside an instrument or decree, or for the rescission of a
contract, and the time for which period begins to run is
‘when the facts entitling the plaintiff to have the instrument
or decree cancelled or set aside or the contract rescinded
first become known to him’. When the executant wants to
cancel or set aside a document, the executant could not
contend that he has no knowledge regarding the document
and he came to know about the document at a later stage
from the date of execution of the document, since the
executant is the best person who has knowledge of
execution of the document. In such a case, the date of
knowledge shall be reckoned and counted from the date of
the document and not otherwise. If a non-executant of a
document seeks the relief of cancellation or setting aside a
2025:KER:26149
R.F.A. Nos. 127 & 172 of 2010
document, the date of knowledge regarding the document to
be found from the facts of the case to count the period of
limitation.
15. In the instant case, the executant himself is
seeking the relief of declaration of Ext.A1 sale deed as a
sham document and the same is akin to setting aside an
instrument dealt under Article 59 of the Limitation Act. Even
though, Section 17 of the Limitation Act has been pointed
out to bring the suit within the period of limitation, as rightly
found by the trial court, Section 17 of the Limitation Act has
no application in the facts of this case, since the same deals
with the effect of fraud or mistake.
16. In this matter, evidently the suit has been filed
after a period of three years, though the plaintiff was having
knowledge regarding execution of Ext.A1 sale deed, from the
date of its execution itself. Thus, the finding of the trial court
that the suit is hopelessly barred by limitation is only to be
confirmed and the learned counsel for the plaintiff also could
not justify that the finding of the trial court that the suit is
barred by limitation is wrong.
17. Now, the 1st defendant has assigned the plaint
2025:KER:26149
R.F.A. Nos. 127 & 172 of 2010
schedule property to the 5 th defendant, who is also one of
the
daughters
of
the
plaintiff.
Thereafter,
additional
respondents 8 to 10 in R.F.A. No. 127/2010 purchased the
plaint schedule property from the 5th defendant.
18. However, the trial court found that the suit is
barred by limitation and held that the plaintiff is not entitled
to get the relief of declaration of Ext.A1 sale deed as sham
document. On re-appreciation of the evidence, t he said
decree and judgment are only to be justified. Therefore, there
is no reason to interfere with the verdict of the trial court.
Holding so, the trial court verdict does not require any
interference.
19. In the result, R.F.A. No.127/2010 stands dismissed
and the verdict under challenge stands confirmed. Though
service is not complete in R.F.A. No.172/2010, the parties to
the lis are substantially served or represented in R.F.A.
No.127/2010. Therefore, R.F.A. No.172/2010 can also be
dismissed along with R.F.A. No.127/2010, for the reasons
stated herein above. Thus, R.F.A. No.172/2010 also stands
dismissed. Having considered the facts of these cases, parties
shall suffer their respective costs.
2025:KER:26149
R.F.A. Nos. 127 & 172 of 2010
All interlocutory applications pending in these regular
first appeals stand dismissed.
Sd/-
A. BADHARUDEEN
SK
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review