Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page - 1 of 19
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.718/2020
Sri Shambhu Debnath,
S/o Sri Mantu Debnath of Hatipara,
P.O - Salbagan, P.S. Airport, Agartala, West Tripura.
…………… Petitioner(s).
Vs.
1. The Union of India, represented by the Ministry of Home Affairs,
Government of India.
2. The Under Secretary,
Staff Selection Commission, Block No. 12, CGO Complex, Lodhi
Road, Near JLN Stadium, New Delhi, Delhi - 110091.
3. Staff Selection Commission
Represented by Chairman, Block No.12, CGO Complex, Lodhi
Road, Near JLN Stadium, New Delhi, Delhi -110091.
4. North Eastern Regional Office,
Staff Selection Commission, Gauhati, represented by Regional
Director, Housefed Complex, West End Block, Last Gate Basistha Road, P.O. Assam Sachivalaya, Dispur, Gauhati -781006.
5. Director General,
CRPF (Central Reserve Police Force) (Recruitment Branch) East
Block - 07, Level - 4, Sector - 01, R.K. Puram, New Delhi -110066
(Ministry of Home Affairs).
6. Review Medical Examination Board,
represented by the Presiding Officer/LMO, AR, West Tripura
Centre, Conduct of RME of Combined Rect Rally for Constable
GD In CAPFs and Rfn.(GD) in AR 2018, Kunjaban, Assam Rifles,
Agartala, West Tripura, Pin - 799006
…………… Respondent(s).
_B_E_ F_O_R_E_
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. INDRAJIT MAHANTY
For Petitioner(s)
For Respondent(s)
: Ms. R Purkayastha, Advocate.
: Mr. Bidyut Majumder, Asstt. S. G.
Date of hearing & judgment : 2nd February 2022.
Page - 2 of 19
Whether fit for reporting
: Yes.
J U D G M E N T (O R A L)
Heard learned counsel for the respective parties.
[2]
This writ petition has come to be filed by the petitioner, namely
Sri Shambhu Debnath who appeared in the selection process pursuant to
one advertisement dated 21st July 2018 issued by the Staff Selection
Commission for recruitment to the post of Constable (GD) in the Central
Armed Police Forces (CAPFs), NIA, SSF and Rifleman (GD) in Assam
Rifles (AR). The recruitment process adopted consists of a Computer
Based Examination, Physical Efficiency Test, Physical Standard Test and
Medical Examination. The petitioner, admittedly, was declared qualified in
the Computer Based Examination, Physical Efficiency Test and Physical
Standard Test. It is further stated that on 24th January 2020, the petitioner
appeared for Detailed Medical Examination (DME) and after going
through the test, he has been declared unfit/unqualified inter alia on the
ground that the petitioner had a huge “naevus” on right side of his
abdomen. Although the petitioner claimed that the said nevus was a
birthmark and it is also alleged that the guidelines do not anywhere
prescribe rejection in the event a candidate is found with nevus. Yet since
Page - 3 of 19
the petitioner was declared unfit/unqualified he filed the present writ
petition.
[3]
A counter-affidavit came to be filed by the respondents and it
may be pertinent to note herein that this Court vide order dated 20th
October 2020 directed the respondents to include the petitioner in the final
select list provisionally subject to further orders that may be passed in this
petition and through affidavit dated 12th April 2021, it is admitted by the
respondents that pursuant to said direction one post has been kept reserved
awaiting outcome of the present writ petition.
[4]
Further, in course of hearing of the matter, this Court passed the
following order on 18th November 2021 :
“18/11/2021
Heard learned counsel for the respective parties. The main
issue that arises for consideration at the present juncture in the case
is relating to Annexure-I which is a report submitted by the Review
Medical Board in respect of examination of the petitioner Shambhu
Debnath. The said report appears to have been prepared by a Board
of doctors of the Conduct of RME of Combined Rect Rally for
Constable GD in CAPFs and Rfn (GD) in AR 2018 which is
extracted hereinbelow :
“FORM NO.4 OF CONSTABLE (GD) EXAM-2018
REVIEW MEDICAL EXAMINATION REPORT
Roll No.
:
5601003543
Name of Candidate
:
SHAMBHU
DEBNATH
Page - 4 of 19
Gender
:
Male
Father’s/Husband Name
:
MANTU DEBNATH
Identification Marks:
(i)
A BLACK MOLE ON BACK OF NECK
(ii)
A BLACK MOLE ON GLABELLA
Candidate’s Signature (in presence of the Medical
Board)
Sd/- (Shambhu Debnath)
(1)
Reason for Medical Unfitness : Huge Nevus on Rt.
Side of abdomen.
(2)
Brief of Review Medical Examination & Finding
thereof :
Huge Becker’s Nevus on Rt. Lower trunk (both
front & back)
(3)
Final Opinion:
(a) FIT
: ……………….
(b) UNFIT on account of: Huge Nevus which may
have underlying Congenital anomalies & may further turn into
tumor.”
The report speaks for itself. The learned Asstt. Solicitor
General on behalf of the Union of India drew the attention of this
Court to Office Memorandum dated 20.05.2015 issued by the
Ministry of Home Affairs and in particular, Chapter-XII under the
heading “Examination for Skin Diseases and Leprosy” and (B)
stipulates other conditions which are to be considered for rejection.
Sl. No.8 thereof reads as follows:
“8.
Congenital or acquired anomalies of the skin such
as nevi or vascular tumors that interfere with function, or
are exposed to constant irritation are disqualifying.
History of Dysplastic Nevus Syndrome is disqualifying.”
Apart from that learned Asstt. S.G. also draws the
Court‟s attention to Clause-C of the terms and conditions of the
Computer Based Examination held by the Central Armed Police
Forces for recruitment of Constables (GD) and Rifleman (GD) dated
Page - 5 of 19
21.07.2018 and in particular to Clause-C under the heading “General
Grounds for Rejection during Medical Examination”, the relevant
portion of which is extracted hereinbelow :
“(xxvii) Any congenital abnormality, so as to impede
efficient discharge of training/duties.
(xlvii)
xxx
xxx
xxx
(n) Any other abnormality if so considered by
the specialist.”
This Court also takes note of the dictionary definition of
the term “Nevus” from the Concise Oxford English Dictionary,
Twelfth Edition which states as follows :
“A birthmark or a mole on the skin, especially a birthmark
in the form of a raised red patch.”
On a reading of the aforesaid as pointed out by the learned
Asstt. S.G. not every congenital abnormality can amount to a
disqualification or rejection. It is only such congenital abnormality
which may impede the efficient discharge of training and/or duties
which may be a ground for rejection. Apart from the above, even in
the 2015 notification under Annexure-R/2 as quoted hereinabove in
para-B(8) thereof it is only all congenital or acquired abnormalities
of the skin such as nevi or vascular tumors that interfere with
function or exposed to constant irritation are disqualifying. In other
words, even if a person is suffering from the skin disease such as
nevi, such a candidate cannot be disqualified unless and until the
Medical Board come to a conclusion that the nevi which is
determined to be a birthmark and/or a mole in the Oxford Dictionary
as quoted hereinabove should be such which may interfere with the
function or is exposed to constant irritation which may amount to a
disqualification.
It is stated by the learned counsel for the petitioner that
the petitioner has no irritation and the marks pointed out in the
Page - 6 of 19
Medical Review opinion was merely non-definitive. It is stated by
the petitioner‟s counsel that he has no irritation and is a birthmark
from birth and the petitioner is not suffering from any irritation of
that area as well nor does the said birthmark nevi in any manner will
interfere with either his training or in due discharge of his duties.
Learned counsel for the petitioner further brings to the
notice of the Court the declaration contained in Form-3 of the
petitioner and signed by the Medical Officer of the AGMC that the
huge nevus on the right side of the abdomen of the petitioner and has
stated that the said nevus is a benign condition and no treatment was
required for the same.
In view of the aforesaid facts, this Court is of the
considered view that a fresh Review Medical Examination Board be
constituted by the respondent No.6 making sure that the doctors who
were there in the earlier Medical Board are not members of the fresh
Review
Medical
Examination
Board
who
shall
take
into
consideration all the above as noted hereinabove including the
conditions imposed in the examination stipulations, the notification
of the Government of India as well as the certification granted by the
Medical Officer of the AGMC and shall review the case of the
petitioner. This is so because this Court is of the prima facie view
that the report and the language used in the report is merely nondefinitive to the extent that the huge nevus “may” have underlying
congenital anomalies and “may” further turn into tumors. Such a
finding on the part of the earlier Review Medical Examination Board
appears to this Court to be clearly non-definitive and, therefore,
requiring a detailed scientific evaluation of the petitioner by a fresh
Review Medical Examination Board who shall not be influenced by
the report submitted under Annexure-I to the writ petition, i.e. the
earlier Review Board‟s opinion.
The learned Asstt. S.G. is requested to communicate this
order to the concerned respondent No.6 for necessary compliance.
Page - 7 of 19
For such purpose the petitioner shall appear before respondent No.6
next Wednesday (24.11.2021) and the Head of the Review Medical
Examination Board who shall be a skin specialist may direct the
petitioner to appear on any particular date suitable to the
reconstituted Board and the Review Medical Examination Board
shall complete the exercise of reevaluation of the petitioner after
carrying out medical tests as may be required and submit its report in
a sealed cover to this Court through the office of the learned Asstt.
S.G. within a period of a fortnight from the date of his appearance.
List this matter on 23.12.2021.
A copy of this order be handed over to learned Asstt. S.G.
for necessary communication to respondent No.6.”
[5]
Pursuant to the aforesaid directions, examination of the petitioner
was conducted by the Review Medical Examination Board and the Review
Medical Examination Board submitted its report in a sealed cover to the
Court under its covering letter dated 17th December 2021which is quoted
herein below :
Appendix -“A”
RESULT OF REVIEW MEDICAL EXAMINATION TO RRC
FOR RECRUITMENT OF CONSTABLE (GD) EXAM 2018
OBC
WEST
TRIPURA
WEST
TRIPURA
30/11/21
to
10/12/21
Remarks, if any.
MALE
Final result
FIT/UNFIT
State/UT code
04/03/1996
Date of RME
Category
MANTU
DEBNATH
Name of Naxal/
Militancy Dist.
Gender
(male/Female)
SHAMBHU
DEBNATH
Name of BG Distt.
Date of Birth
(DD/MM/YYYY)
5601003543
Father‟s/
Husband‟s Name
Roll No.
Name of candidate
Ser No.
RME CENTRE : ASSAM RIFLES MULTISPECIALITY HOSPITAL, LAITKOR.
FIT
-
Page - 8 of 19
Hence the Review Medical Examination Board has come to a
conclusion that the petitioner is otherwise physically fit.
[6]
It appears that a further ground was raised by the respondents
under communication of a letter dated 14th December 2021 addressed to
the Assistant Solicitor General of India to the following effect :
“1. Pl refer to the Court Order dated 18.11.2021 passed in the
subject matter.
2.
It is intimated that the copy of Board Proceedings on conduct of
fresh Review Medical Examination in r/o of the petitioner (Shri
Shambhu Debnath) and Directorate General CRPF letter No.A-VI285/2018-RECTT(SSB)-CT/GD-2018
dated
25th
Nov
2021,
wherein, it has been stated that “CBE marks of petitioner is less than
the marks of last selected candidate as already informed to your
office, hence the petitioner will not find place in merit list of
provisionally selected even he will be declared FIT in RME”, are
fwd herewith. You are requested to take the needful action as per the
direction of the ibid Court Order.
3. Expedite action, pl.”
In other words, a fresh ground was raised by the respondents in
the present matter. Accordingly, the petitioner filed an additional affidavit
dated 28th July 2021 stating therein that the averment made by the
respondents that the petitioner had obtained less marks than the last
candidate of his category/State/area inter alia means that the petitioner has
been treated against OBC vacancy. It is also alleged by the petitioner that
Page - 9 of 19
the stand of the respondents that since the marks (45.33123) as obtained by
the petitioner is lower than the marks of the last selected OBC candidate
the petitioner had incurred an additional disqualification apart from his
original
physical
disqualification,
is
completely
misleading
and
unacceptable in the eyes of law. It is further asserted that though the
petitioner belongs to OBC category he had secured total 45.33123 marks
whereas the cut-off mark to unreserved category was 39.98149 for Post
Code A, 41.29914 for Code B, 41.82010 for Code C, 39.66236 for Code
D, 39.32135 for Code E and 50.79069 for Code F.
[6]
The essential contention raised by the learned Assistant Solicitor
General is that the petitioner had been given a “relaxation” of height as
prescribed in the notice dated 21st July 2018 under Annexure-A and in
Column III Physical Standard Test (PST) it was specifically prescribed that
the height of the General, SC & OBC candidates (except those mentioned
below) for male should be 170 cm. and under the heading of Relaxation it
was stipulated that the minimum height for the candidates hailing from
North Eastern States of Arunachal Pradesh, Manipur, Meghalaya,
Mizoram, Nagaland, Sikkim and Tripura should be 162.5 cm.
Clause 11(xiv) of the notice on which Learned Assistant
Solicitor General placed reliance may read as follows :
Page - 10 of 19
“(xiv) SC, ST, OBC and ExS candidate who qualifies on the basis of
relaxed standards viz age limit, height and chest measurement,
experience or qualifications, permitted number of chances, extended
zone of consideration larger than what is provided for general
category candidate etc., irrespective of his/her merit position, such
SC, ST, OBC and ExS candidates is to be counted against reserved
vacancies. In so far as cases of ex-serviceman are concerned,
deduction of the military service rendered from the age of exservicemen is permissible against the reserved or unreserved posts
and such exemption cannot be termed as relaxed standards in regard
to age.”
The contention raised on behalf of the respondents by the learned
Assistant Solicitor General was that since the petitioner, admittedly, had a
height of 167 cm. which was below 170 cm. the original prescribed height
and he had been given such relaxation in terms of Clause 11(xiv), the
petitioner was not selected on his own merit and was given relaxed
standards for his consideration. Consequently, such a candidate could not
be accommodated against the unreserved vacancies as per the position in
the overall merit list and he could only be considered under the OBC
category (reserved vacancies) only.
[7]
Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner, on the other hand,
placed reliance on the same heading i.e. Clause 11 Mode of Selection but
sub-clause (xiii) which may read follows :
Page - 11 of 19
“(xiii) SC, ST, OBC and ExS candidates who are selected on their
own merit without relaxed standards, along with candidates
belonging to other communities, will not be accommodated against
the unreserved vacancies as per their position in the overall Merit
List. The reserved vacancies will be filled up separately from
amongst the eligible SC, ST, OBC and ExS candidates.”
Learned counsel submitted that though the petitioner did not
qualify according to the prescribed height standards but met the height
standards since he was a candidate from Tripura and the minimum height
prescribed for such candidate was held to be 162.5 cm. This aspect could
not be treated as a relaxed standard in any manner. Consequently, if Clause
11(xiii) applies to the circumstances of the present case and not Clause
11(xiv) as claimed by the respondents then in such an event, the petitioner
should have first been considered on merits in the open category and
thereafter, if he did not qualify then he could have been considered under
the reserved category. Learned counsel for the petitioner reasserts that
prescribing a lesser height requirement for people living in different parts
of the country is not a relaxation per se but a standard fixed by the
Government of India for considering candidates from various parts of the
country due to the obvious physical and/or genetic differences that exists in
the population of the nation. Stipulation of standards by itself cannot be
deemed to be a relaxation and even Column III which prescribed Physical
Standard Test (PST) stipulates the height in centimetres to be 170 for
Page - 12 of 19
General, SC and OBC candidates but most importantly also in bracket
stipulates (except those mentioned below). In other words, for the persons
belonging to categories which are mentioned in the said notice who have a
separate height stipulation does not make them to come to get any extra
benefit except to be considered at par with all other candidates from all
parts of the nation.
[8]
In this respect, reliance was placed by the petitioner on a
judgment rendered by Division Bench of the Delhi High Court in WP(C)
4982/2021 & CM 15269/2021 in the case of Hemant Pokhriyal Vs. Staff
Selection Commission and Ors. In the said case, a similar stand on behalf
of respondent-Union of India through its Additional Solicitor General has
been taken insofar as the candidates from the Garhwal Region were
concerned. The contentions were noted by the Hon‟ble Division Bench of
the Delhi High Court in Para -13 and its views on the said subject were
noted at Para - 14. It was categorically held therein that though the
petitioner was an OBC candidate and has availed relaxation in
measurement in the standards of height and chest which was made
available to Garhwali Candidates, the contention made by the respondents
that he could not be considered in unreserved category by virtue of para
11(xiv) is untenable in law as the instructions and the clarifications clearly
Page - 13 of 19
state when a reserved category candidate is selected on the same standard
as applicable to the General candidate then he shall not be adjusted against
reserved vacancies. It is only when a candidate avails relaxations that are
not otherwise available to candidates of the unreserved category then he is
to be considered in his category. Reference has also been made by the
Hon‟ble Delhi High Court to an Office Memorandum dated 1 st July 1998
issued by the Ministry of Personnel, PG & Pensions, Department of
Personnel & Training clarifying the position.
[9]
While the judgment of the Delhi High Court was cited by the
learned counsel for the petitioner, the matter was adjourned and both
learned counsel for the petitioner as well as learned Assistant Solicitor
General were requested to ascertain as to whether the judgment of the
Division Bench of the Delhi High Court in the case of Hemant Pokhrial
(supra) has been challenged before the Hon‟ble Apex Court or not. Today,
at the time of hearing, the learned counsel for the petitioner submitted on
verification that no such challenge appears to have been made and the
learned Assistant Solicitor General submits that the matter remains
pending before the administrative department for implementation of the
judgment.
Page - 14 of 19
[10]
Insofar as the present case is concerned, the relaxation of height
has been availed by the petitioner which is also available to all other
candidates belonging to the North-east States. In fact, there is no specific
height or chest relaxation provided for candidates of the North-east
belonging to OBC category. The Hon‟ble Delhi High Court has also
referred to an earlier order dated 2nd August 2021 where the Division
Bench had opined that insofar as Clause 11(xiv) of the Examination Notice
(supra) refers to Scheduled Castes (SC), Scheduled Tribes(ST), OBC and
Ex-Servicemen candidates who have qualified on the basis of relaxed
standards, the same refers to the relaxation by virtue of being SC, ST, OBC
or Ex-Servicemen and not relaxation given to candidates from particular
States/region inasmuch as the said relaxations are available to all
candidates from that region/State, even those belonging to the unreserved
category. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the Hon‟ble Delhi
High Court, Division Bench, having held that relaxation of height given to
applicants from the North-east is not a relaxation only for the petitioner
who belongs to the OBC category but to all candidates who are residents of
the North-eastern States and accordingly, the writ petition should be
allowed.
Page - 15 of 19
[11]
Learned counsel for the petitioner also placed reliance on a
judgment of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in the case of Sourav Yadav and
Ors. Vs. State of Uttar Pradesh and Ors. reported in (2021) 4 SCC 542
and in particular, paragraphs 43 and 44 which may read as follows :
“43. Finally, we must say that the steps indicated by the High Court
of Gujarat in para 56 of its judgment in Tamannaben Ashokbhai
Desai V. Shital Amrutlal Nishar, 2020 SCC On Line Guj 2592
contemplate the correct and appropriate procedure for considering
and giving effect to both vertical and horizontal reservations. The
illustration given by us deals with only one possible dimension.
There could be multiple such possibilities. Even going by the present
illustration, the first female candidate allocated in the vertical
column for Scheduled Tribes may have secured higher position than
the candidate at Serial No.64. In that event said candidate must be
shifted from the category of Scheduled Tribes to Open / General
category causing a resultant vacancy in the vertical column of
Scheduled Tribes. Such vacancy must then enure to the benefit of the
candidate in the Waiting List for Scheduled Tribes – Female. The
steps indicated by Gujarat High Court will take care of every such
possibility. It is true that the exercise of laying down a procedure
must necessarily be left to the concerned authorities but we may
observe that one set out in said judgment will certainly satisfy all
claims and will not lead to any incongruity as highlighted by us in
the preceding paragraphs.
44.
Having come to the conclusion that the Appellant No.1 and
similarly situated candidates had secured more marks than the last
candidates selected in „Open/General Category‟, the logical
consequence must be to annul said selection and direct the
authorities to do the exercise de novo in the light of conclusions
Page - 16 of 19
arrived at by us. However, considering the facts that those selected
candidates have actually undergone training and are presently in
employment and that there are adequate number of vacancies
available, we mould the relief and direct as under :44.1. All candidates coming from „OBC Female Category‟
who had secured more marks than 274.8928, i.e. the marks
secured by the last candidate appointed in „General Category–
Female‟ must be offered employment as Constables in Uttar
Pradesh Police.
44.2. Appropriate letters in that behalf shall be sent to the
concerned candidates within four weeks.
44.3. If the concerned candidates exercise their option and
accept the offer of employment, communications in that behalf
shall be sent by the concerned candidates within two weeks.
44.4. On receipt of such acceptance, the codal and other
formalities shall be completed within three weeks.
44.5. Letters of appointment shall thereafter be issued within a
week and the concerned candidates shall be given appropriate
postings.
44.6. For all purposes, including seniority, pay fixation and
other issues, the employment of such candidates shall be
reckoned from the date the appointment orders are issued.
44.7. The employment of General Category Females with cut
off at 274.8928 as indicated by the State Government in
its affidavits referred to in paragraphs 5 and 8 hereinabove are
not to be affected in any manner merely because of this
judgment.”
Reliance on the same was placed to highlight the issue that even
a person who may be belonging to reserved category is entitled to be
Page - 17 of 19
considered under the open category or unreserved category if the marks
obtained by such a candidate is higher than the marks obtained by the
candidate of unreserved category.
[12]
The learned Assistant Solicitor General, on the other hand,
placed reliance on a judgment of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in the case of
Niravkumar Dilipbhai Makwana Vs. Gujarat Public Service Commission
and Ors. reported in (2019) 7 SCC 383 and in particular, the findings of
the Court arrived at in paragraphs 17, 22 and 23 thereof in order to canvas
the fact that where a candidate has availed the age relaxation in the
selection process as a result of belonging to a reserved category cannot
thereafter seek to be accommodated in or migrated to the general category
seats. There can be no two opinions on the observations and directions of
the Hon‟ble Apex Court in the said judgment. Unfortunately, this judgment
has no relevance vis-a-vis the issue that is raised in the present case. In the
present case, the petitioner though an OBC candidate was originally
disqualified and found unfit due to nevus on his right abdomen. The
opinion of the doctors of the Review Medical Board who conducted the
examination is exactly to the contrary and they found that nevus not to be
in any manner interfered with the work which the petitioner may be
assigned and consequently, held the petitioner to be physically fit.
Page - 18 of 19
[13]
Insofar as the present case is concerned, the only issue that arises
for our consideration is that when the respondents have stipulated the
minimum height of a candidate hailing from the north-east to be 162.5 cm
whereas the original stipulation was 170 cm whether that itself amounts to
a relaxation or a benefit. As seen from the judgment of the Delhi High
Court as in the case of Hemant Pokhrial (supra), the same cannot be
treated as a relaxation to debar the petitioner from being considered under
the open category simply because this relaxation is not meant only for
OBC candidates and extends to all candidates who may apply under any
category or all categories who are residents of the north-east. As noted
hereinabove, the object of stipulating varied standards of height, is clearly
on account of the variances that exist in our nation on account of physical
and or genetic differences amongst various communities which constitutes
our nation. In other words, providing different height criteria for people
from different areas of the nation and/or background essentially is an
affirmative action by the Union of India to put all candidates from all parts
of the country at par for their consideration on merit. So, there is absolutely
no relaxation per se granted to the petitioner and therefore, sub-clause
(xiv) of Clause 11 of the Annexure-A has no applicability in the present
case and the case of the petitioner is to be considered under sub-clause
(xiii).
Page - 19 of 19
[14]
Accordingly, the writ petition is allowed. The petitioner has been
found physically fit for being considered for appointment by the Review
Medical Board and this Court finds that the “purported relaxation” granted
to candidates from the north-east amongst others is not a relaxation of such
a nature which would deprive them from being considered under the open
category as stipulated under Clause 11(xiii) and since this Court had earlier
directed non filling of one post for consideration of the petitioner, the said
post shall be given to the petitioner forthwith preferably within a period of
4(four) weeks from today.
Petition is allowed. Pending application(s), if any, also stands
disposed of.
( INDRAJIT MAHANTY, CJ )
Sukhendu
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review