Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
31.07.2026.
Item No. 14.
Court No. 652
ap
W.P.A. 28647 of 2023
Salil Kumar Kundu & Ors.
Versus
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
Mr. Anirban Mitra.
..For the petitioners.
Mr. Rajen Dutta,
Mrs. Sutapa Upadhyay,
…For the State.
1.
The petitioners are permanent employees of
West Bengal Valuation Board. All of them have retired
in terms of Rule 75(a) of the WBSR Part-I on attaining
the age of 60 years.
2.
The writ petitioners are aggrieved by the fact
that in spite of being at par with the employees of
other Government Departments, who duly receives
pension after retirement, they have been derived
thereof till now, in spite of discharging diligent duty
and maintaining unblemished service record, during
their service tenure.
3.
Thus, the petitioners have raised grievance
about violation of their constitutional rights of life and
equality.
4.
Mr. Mitra, learned Advocate appears for the
petitioners and Mr. Dutta, learned Advocate for the
State.
5.
Learned Advocate for the State respondents has
relied on a
communication made by the Joint
Secretary to the Government of West Bengal to the
Member Secretary, West Bengal Valuation Board dated
October 17, 2019 which states, inter alia, as follows:
“Earlier, Pension Branch, Finance Department
agreed in principle to introduce pension scheme for
the employees of West Bengal Valuation Board
subject to the condition that the Board should
explore the possibility to earn of its own by way of
imposing levy on the increased rates and taxes
and create pension fund for this purpose initially
with the support of Employer’s share of
contribution together with interest accrued thereon.
It was also stipulated therein that Govt. will
not make any sort of financial assistance for
this purpose. In response it has been clearly
stated by Member Secretary, West Bengal
Valuation Board vide No. 552/WBVB/1R-2/2014
dated 31.10.2018 that it is not possible to explore
any possibility to earn for creation of Pension
Fund.
We may, therefore, regret that we are unable to
agree to the proposal for introduction of Pensioncum-GPF Scheme in lieu of C.P.F. Scheme for the
employees of West Bengal Valuation Board.”
6.
It is informed that the contention of the letter
dated
October
17,
is
the
the
rival
stand
of
the
Government.
7.
Having
considered
submissions
advanced on behalf of the respective parties and upon
examination of the materials placed before this Court,
it appears that the State itself has, as a matter of
policy, extended pensionary benefits to employees
similarly situated in other Government Departments.
The petitioners, who had rendered long years of service
under the West Bengal Valuation Board, have not been
shown to constitute a separate class founded upon
any intelligible differentia having a rational nexus with
the object sought to be achieved. Mere financial
considerations or the inability of the Board to generate
its
own
pension
fund,
as
reflected
in
the
communication dated 17th October, 2019, cannot
furnish a constitutionally sustainable basis to deny
pensionary benefits to one class of retired public
servants,
while
extending
the
same
to
another
similarly circumstanced class. Such differentiation, in
the absence of any valid statutory foundation or
rational classification, is prima facie arbitrary and
offends the mandate of Article 14 of the Constitution of
India.
8.
The communication dated 17th October, 2019
further discloses that the claim of the petitioners has
been declined principally on the ground that the State
would
not
extend
any
financial
assistance
for
introduction of a pension scheme and that the Board
was unable to create a pension fund from its own
resources.
Such
an
approach
reduces
the
constitutional obligation of the State towards its
retired employees to a matter of financial convenience.
Pension is not a gratuitous payment dependent solely
upon executive discretion but is a measure of socioeconomic security intended to ensure a life of dignity
after retirement. Once an employee has rendered
faithful service under an instrumentality of the State,
the denial of pension solely on the basis of financial
incapacity of the employer, without examining the
constitutional implications of such deprivation, cannot
withstand
scrutiny
under
Article
of
the
Constitution, which guarantees the right to live with
dignity and financial security in the evening of life.
Executive expediency cannot override constitutional
guarantees.
9.
The
impugned
communication
dated
17th
October, 2019, therefore, cannot be sustained as it
fails
to
balance
considerations
with
the
State's
administrative
its
constitutional
obligations
flowing from Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution of
India.
The
action
of
the
respondents,
being
instrumentalities of the State within the meaning of
Article
12,
must
conform
to
the
constitutional
principles of fairness, non-arbitrariness and protection
of the dignity of retired employees. A decision which
perpetuates discrimination amongst similarly situated
retirees and deprives them of a reasonable source of
post-retiral livelihood without any constitutionally
permissible justification is manifestly arbitrary and
inconsistent with the constitutional vision of a welfare
State. Consequently, the communication dated 17th
October,
cannot
be
treated
as
a
legally
sustainable basis for denying consideration of the
petitioners' claim for pensionary benefits.
10.
The aforesaid conclusion also receives support
from the settled constitutional jurisprudence evolved
by the Supreme Court. In D. S. Nakara versus UOI
[1983
SCC
305],
the
Constitution
Bench
authoritatively held that pension is neither a bounty
nor an act of grace depending upon the sweet will of
the employer, but a valuable socio-economic right
intended to secure dignity and economic security in
the
post-retiral
years,
and
that
an
arbitrary
classification amongst pensioners is violative of Article
14 of the Constitution. Subsequently, in Olga Tellis
VERSUS Bombay Municipal Corporation [1985 3
SCC 545], the Supreme Court expanded the sweep of
Article 21 by recognising that the right to life
necessarily
includes
the
right
to
livelihood,
for
deprivation of livelihood inevitably denudes life of its
meaningful content. The constitutional philosophy was
further deepened in K. S. Puttaswamy versus UOI
[2019 1 SCC 1], wherein the Constitution Bench
reaffirmed that human dignity constitutes the core of
Article 21 and that every action of the State must
conform to constitutional values that preserve the
autonomy and dignity of the individual. Tested on the
anvil of these binding constitutional principles, the
Government
communication
dated
17th
October,
2019, which declines pensionary benefits solely on the
premise of financial inability of the Board and the
State's unwillingness to extend financial assistance,
cannot be regarded as constitutionally sustainable.
Financial
constraints,
however
genuine,
legitimise
an
action
which
executive
cannot
results
in
arbitrary discrimination amongst similarly situated
retirees and deprives them of post-retiral social
security essential for a life of dignity guaranteed under
Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution of India.
11.
The respondents being an authority under
Article 12 of the Constitution of India is bound to act
towards upholding the constitutional rights of its
employees of life and equality.
12.
In such circumstances, the stand taken by the
respondent authorities, expressed vide letter dated
October 17, 2019 appears to be not in consonance
with the constitutional guarantee of right to life and
equality of the present petitioners.
13.
Having found so, this Court is inclined to look
into another communication, inter se Departments i.e.
dated September 4, 2012, in which the Chairman,
West Bengal Valuation Board has proposed and
requested the Chief Secretary, Government of West
Bengal, for extension of Pensionary Benefits Scheme to
the employees of West Bengal Valuation Board. The
same has never been considered or answered by the
addressee as yet.
14.
It is found proper to direct the appropriate
authority dated September 4, 2012, to immediately
consider the said letter of the Chairman, West Bengal
Valuation Board and take a decision thereof afresh,
independent of the constitutionally unsustainable
views and opinion expressed in the letter dated
October 17, 2019, in accordance with law.
15.
Hence, this writ petition is disposed of directing
the respondent no.2, the Additional Chief Secretary,
Government of West Bengal, Finance Department, to
consider and dispose of the representation of the
Chairman,
West
Bengal
Valuation
Board
dated
September 4, 2012, as expeditiously as possible and
not beyond a period of eight weeks from the date of
communication of a copy of this order. In doing so, the
respondent no.2 shall consider the documents from
the respective Departments, if necessary and pass a
reasoned order within a period stipulated as above, if
not the said respondent finds the proposal of the
Chairman, West Bengal Valuation Board in the letter
dated September 4, 2012 worth immediate acceptance
and execution.
16.
Needless is to say that in case he accepts the
proposal of the Chairman, West Bengal Valuation
Board made in the letter dated September 4, 2012, all
subsequent
appropriate
steps
should
be
taken
immediately thereafter to accord pensionary benefits to
the present petitioners being the erstwhile employees
of West Bengal Valuation Board including the arrears.
17.
With the observations and directions as above,
the present writ petition is disposed of.
18.
There will be no order as to costs.
19.
Urgent photostat certified copy of this order, if
applied for, shall be supplied to the parties, on
compliance of all necessary formalities.
(Rai Chattopadhyay, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review